S/PV.3188 Security Council
I should like to inform the Council that I have
received a letter from the representative of Somalia in which she requests to
be invited to participate in the discussion of the item on the Council's
agenda. In conformity with the usual practice, I proPose, with the consent of
the Council, to invite that representative to participate in the discussion
without the right to vote, in accordance with the relevant provisions of the
Charter and rule 37 of the Council's provisional rules of procedure.
There being no objection, it is so decided.
At the invitationsf the President, Ms. Hassan (Somalia) took a place at
the Council table.
Vote:
S/RES/814(1993)
Recorded Vote
✓ 15
✗ 0
0 abs.
The Security Council will now begin its
consideration of the item on its agenda.
The Security Council is meeting in accordance with the understanding
reached in its prior consultations.
Members of the Council have before them the further report of the
Secretary-General submitted in pursuance of paragraphs 18 and 19 of resolution
794 (1992), contained in document S/25354 and addenda 1 and 2.
Members of the Council also have before them document S/25472, which
contains the text of a draft resolution prepared in the course of the
Council's prior consultations. I should like to draw attention to the
following revision to the draft resolution in its provisional form: at the
end of paragraph 2 insert "representative" between "other" and "groups".
I should also like to draw the attention of members of the Council to the
following documents: S/24976 and S/25126, letters dated 17 December 1992 and
19 January 1993, respectively, from the Permanent Representative of the United
States of America to the United Nations addressed to the President of the
Security Council: S/24992 and S/25168, report of the Secretary-General
submitted in pursuance of paragraphs 18 and 19 of resolution 794 (1992) and
progress report of the Secretary-General, respectively: S/25072, letter dated
7 January 1993 from the Permanent Representative of Canada to the United
Nations addressed to the President of the Security Council; S/25163, letter
dated 25 January 1993 from the Permanent Representative of the United Arab
Emirates to the United Nations addressed to the President of the Security
Council; and S/25312, letter dated 18 February 1993 from the Permanent
Representative of Kuwait to the United Nations addressed to the President Of
the Security Council.
It is my understanding that the Security Council is ready to proceed to
the vote on the draft resolution, as orally revised in its provisional form,
which is before it. If I hear no objection, I shall take it that that is the
case.
There being no objection, it is so decided.
Before putting the draft resolution to the vote, I shall call on those
members of the Council who wish to make statements before the voting.
Mr. OLHAYE (Djibouti): f wish warmly to congratulate you, Sir, on
assuming the presidency of the Council for this month. You have demonstrated
effectiveness and rare personal skills in conducting our work. May I also pay
my sincere tribute to your predecessor, Ambassador Ahmed Snoussi of Morocco,
for the exemplary manner in which he executed his responsibilities last month,
We wish to record our sincere appreciation for the vision and
determination demonstrated by the Secretary-General in elaborating bold and
far-reaching measures, as contained in his report (S/25354) of 3 March, to
return Somalia to being a safe and functioning entity. Equally, we wish to
express our deep gratitude to the more than 20 countries that, through a
United States initiative, mounted the decisive humanitarian intervention to
confront widespread insecurity, lawlessness and extortion, and to enable the
humanitarian agencies to reach and care for the dying, starving and
malnourished.
This unprecedented humanitarian intervention underscored the
international community's response to Somalia's long agony, when inadequate
and protracted multinational measures failed to make any significant impact on
the ever-deepening anarchy and ignominious deprivation, Thanks to the
impressive coordination of military and civilian efforts, remarkable results
have been achieved within a short period.
As indicated earlier, my delegation found the Secretary-General's report
most informative and clarifying. We believe the draft resolution we are about
to adopt sufficiently reflects the mandate, as well as the resources, desired
by the Secretary-General to fulfil his responsibilities. Particularly
noteworthy is the attention given to matters of transition and coordination
between the Unified Task Force (UNITAF) and the expanded United Nations
Operation in Somalia (UNOSOM II), the continuing need to realize full and
effective disarmament and pacification, to refocus our priorities from purely
humanitarian aid to rebuilding and reconstruction, and to help the Somali
people achieve political governance. The emphasis devoted to questions of
de-mining, the return of refugees and the integration of Somali civil society
in nation-building highlights a complex picture of what has to be done to
bring Somalia to being a'country.
Somalia is in many ways a modern anomaly, a land with no effective
mechanism for governance. Wo operational institutions of any kind exist -
financial institutions, government offices, schools, hospitals, Police,
military or political organs of government. It is in key respects a
non-State. The civil strife dealt a deadly blow to the long history and
tradition of a single race sharing the same land, customs, foods, language and
religion. However, Somalia does offer positive encouragement. There are few
long-standing irreconcilable ideological differences, or obvious widespread
discrepancies in living staadards. Clearly, in Somalia we have witnessed a
political and social collapse manifested in human and material destruction.
But the underlying perception remains, the sense of "nationhood". Perhaps our
role in Somalia is at bottom to provide a secure basis for its re-emergence
institutionally.
Undoubtedly, the Somalis who have been spared the ravages of war, of
death,and starvation are profoundly thankful for the efforts of the
international community. They anxiously anticipate a return to normality, to
peace and personal safety, which will lead to a genuine re-emergence of
political expression and participation. Perhaps Ambassador Oakley summed up
well the yearnings of the ordinary Somali: "From now on the people of Somalia
will have the power, and that power will not come from the barrel of the
gun". We believe this can be achieved.
In the final analysis, reconstructing Somalia will entail many critical
choices which will determine its political, economic and social destiny. This
has to be done by the Somalis themselves - every one of them. The vital
question we face is the manner in which this can best,be achieved. It is a
matter of concern, not only to the Somalis themselves, but to the world
community, given the sensitivity of the issue.
My delegation remains optimistic that available skilled and trained
Somali manpower could be lured to participate in the reconstruction of their
shattered country. Thousands of such professionally qualified people, who had
been forced to flee the country, are everywhere waiting for an opportunity to
return. An atmosphere of welcome, a concerted effort to employ their skills,
must pervade the operations of the United Nations and international agencies.
We hope a mechanism can be created for the utilisation of such diverse talents
towards better attainment of the inseparable national and international goals.
I thank the representative of Djibouti for his kind
words addressed to me.
Mr. BARBOSA (Cape Verde) (interpretation from French): By agreeing
to the important proposals of His Excellency Mr. Boutos Boutros Ghali,
Secretary-General of our Organisation, the Security Council, acting under
Chapter VII of the Charter, has authorized the Secretary-General and certain
States Members to establish as soon as possible the necessary secure
environmment for humanitarian relief operations in Somalia. This decision, in
our view, is a turning-point and without a doubt a new point of departure as
regards involvement of the international community in that country.
Cape Verde, which in the Council has always advocated a vigorous
involvement of the international community in Somalia, supported without
hestitation the proposals of the Secretary-General contained in the letters he
addressed to the Security Council in November of 1992, and that at a time when
many sectors of international public opinion still harboured considerable
doubts as to the legitimacy of the step the United Nations had decided to take.
Indeed, the members of the Council will recall that in the statement I
made on behalf of my delegation when the historic resolution 794 (1992) was
adopted, I said the following:
What is occurring in Somalia is a threat to the very existence of
Somali society; but at the same time it represents one of the most
serious challenges to the full establishment of a new international order
on Earth within which the United Nations has a role of capital importance
to play.
"Moreover, we have no doubt that the national conflict has a second
dimension - an international dimension - in view of the fact that,
because of its repercussions on neighbouring States, it is imperilling
the stability and security of the whole region.
Wy country therefore fully concurs with the assessment of the
Secretary-General - whose efforts we greatly value - that the situation
in Somalia has become intolerable, for existing circumstances do not
permit the effective execution of the peace-keeping operation,
necessitating forceful action on the part of the international community
to restore order, disarm the warmongers and ensure the delivery of
humanitarian assistance to the population. Such an operation will be a
very important and urgently needed step towards solving the Somali
problem, if we wish to assist in creating a favourable climate in which
the Somali people will be able to begin to resolve its political problems
and repair the country's economy." (3145th meetins, P. 19-20)
The events that have taken place since the adoption of resolution
794 (1992), and especially since the arrival in Somalia of forces of the
United States of America, are well known to all, and the important
developments that have taken place have not only proven the wisdom of our
decison but also put us on the road that will no doubt lead us, with
perseverance and greater determination, to the achievement of the United
Nations objectives in Somalia, especially the establishment of peace,
security, national reconciliation democracy, respect for human rights and
national reconstruction.
In this context, we should welcome the fact that the Unified Task Force
(UNITAF), despite certain persistent difficulties, has succeeded in
establishing, in the areas of Somalia where it has been deployed, propitious
conditions for the provision of humanitarian assistance, even in most
destitute areas: and this has not only allowed us to reduce considerably the
number of deaths but also had quite positive effects on the health,and
nutritional situation of the population.
The process of national reconstruction, thanks to the efforts of the
Secretary-General and of his Special Representative, has made giant strides,
and we are on the verge of witnessing - perhaps even today - the approval by
the Conference on National Reconciliation of all the documents governing the
process of national reconciliation,
We also feel it important to emphasiae that the role of civilian society,
both in rebuilding the life of the country and in the political arena, has
continued to grow, thanks to the new climate. This can be seen in the
important role played in the above-mentioned process by religious and women's
groups, representatives of civilian organizations and non-govenmental
organizations, elders, traditional leaders and the country's outstanding
personalities.
We also feel it important to note that an important conference on
humanitarian assistance has been held and that the key ideas on clearing
hundreds of thousands of mines scattered indiscriminately throughout Somali
territory have already been identified by the Secretary-General.
In brief, we can state that, in spite of the great damage done to Somali
society because of a long period of anarchy, confrontation and chaos, the
country is now determined to rise from the tragic situation into which it was
plunged.
We thus believe it is timely to pay tribute once again to the
Secretary-General for his decisive contribution to the redefinition of the
United Nations strategy for approaching the Somali conflict.
We also value most highly the actions of the countries participating in
UNITAP, in particular the United States of America, for their contribution,
withoutwhich this operation would have been impossible to carry out.
The new stage we are now entering, despite the successful actions of
UNITAF, presents even more complex challenges, and the work yet to be done is
of a more delicate nature. In fact, we have reached a critical point in the
process of putting an end to the Somali conflict, a point at which greater
perseverance, determination and creativity will be required of all members of
the international community and in particular Members of the United Nations.
In this light, we welcome and support most earnestly the comprehensive
and excellent report submitted to us by the Secretary-General, which, in our
view, deals in exemplary fashion with the main questions relating to the
process of peace, reconciliation and reconstruction in Somalia, particularly
those of disarmament, humanitarian assistance, the restoration of national
institutions, the unity of the country, the resolution of problems of refugees
and displaced persons and mine-clearing.
The draft resolution was well debated in the Security Council and
obviously deserves the strong support of the Cape Verde delegation, which will
therefore vote in favour of it.
Now, when we are in the process of establishing the expanded United
Nations Operation in Somalia (UNOSOM II), we think it fitting to highlight the
important contribution of UNOSOM I in the peace process in Somalia at a time
full of uncertainty and difficulties - and this was in spite of the
limitations of its mandate and the reduced means available to it.
The contribution of the Organisation of African Unity, the Organization
of the Islamic Conference, the League of Arab States and the Non-Aligned
Movement, especially in the area of national reconciliation, has also been
invaluable.
(Mr. Barbosa. Caoe Verde)
Finally, we hail all the praiseworthy and courageous efforts of United
Nations bodies, non-governmental organizations and individuals taking part in
the comprehensive process of promoting a lasting peace in Somalia.
Mr, SNOUSSI (Morocco) (interpretation from French): My delegation
would like, first of all, to congratulate the Secretary-General, His
Excellency Mr. Boutros Boutros-Ghali, for his wise and effective handling of
the tragic question of Somalia since assuming his post. We appreciate his
rational analysis of the development of the Somali tragedy and the lucidity
and clarity of the recommendations contained in his latest report (S/25354),
dated 3 March 1993.
(Mr Barbosa,)
Over the past year, the international community has followed with
frustration and anguish the torment of the Somali people, exposed to the
rigours of hunger and gradually being decimated while political factions waged
merciless war and marauding bands sowed terror, pillaged and prevented
humanitarian aid from reaching the starving population. The impact of the
horrifying images has mobilized international solidarity to put an end to the
chaos and anarchy.
The Security Council's adoption under Chapter VII of the historic
resolution 794 (1992) on 3 December 1992 was a firm and appropriate response
to a situation unprecedented in the annals of the United Nations. In this
connection, we wish to express our gratitude to the United States of America
for its role in helping this resolution to materialize and making possible its
immediate implementation.
We were in full agreement with the Secretary-General when he deemed it
wise and vital to review the underlying basis for United Nations action in
Somalia with a view to adapting that basis to this exceptional situation, in
which an unbreakable link has been established between humanitarian assistance
and security. There can be no doubt today that the Unified Task Force,
despite its relatively limited deployment in the field, has had a positive and
* decisive influence with respect to peacemaking in the country and the
establishment of conditions that have returned hope to thousands of suffering
Somalis. In addition to its mission of peace, this police operation has
contributed to a great extent to charting the course for a political solution
to the Somali crisis and has helped the Secretary-General and his Special
Representatives in their efforts to achieve a political normalization of the
situation.
The Secretary-General's actions towards reconciliation and national unity
in Somalia have indeed had positive effects. Thus, last January in Addis
Ababa, for the first time the parties to the conflict sat around the same
table and signed three important agreements, despite the often difficult and
laborious nature of their negotiations. The progress achieved at this meeting
made it possible to prepare the Conference on National Reconciliation that
began on 15 March and took a great step forward in its turn towards national
conciliation on substantive questions affecting the future and very existence
of the country. We ardently hope that the agreements will be signed as soon
as possible and that the signatories will scrupulously respect their
commitments.
Despite all these positive developments, the improvement noted in the
field remains relative and is not irreversible, as mentioned by the
Secretary-General in his report. The problem of security has not been fully
resolved and disarmament is far from being complete. In other words, the
mission which falls to the expanded United Nations Operation in Somalia
(UNOSOM II) will have to face the present and future requirements of the
Situation.
Indeed, in addition to the tasks entrusted to the Unified Task Force,
UNOSOM II will be called upon to undertake the enormous task of rebuilding the
country, restoring its political institutions and renewing its economy. This
operation, the first of its kind ever undertaken by the United Nations,
clearly illustrated the important role which this Organization, henceforth the
very embodiment of international solidarity, can play in crises of this kind.
It is a source of pride for my country that we have participated in a
concrete way in all the operations launched to date in Somalia, because we
have wished fully to shoulder our moral commitments to the United Nations and
because we feel that it is our duty, as Arabs, Af!-icans and Muslims, to
participate in the international effort to find a:1 effective solution to the
crisis of our brother country Somalia. We are certain that, in adopting this
draft resolution, the Security Council will carry out its obligations under
the United Nations Charter in an appropriate, timely and effective way.
We sincerely hope that all the factional chiefs in Somalia will give
priority to their people and to peace and security, and that they will fully
cooperate with the United Nations and with the political and humanitarian
organisations operating in the country in order to find a lasting solution to
this tragedy, because prime responsibility devolves upon the Somalis
themselves to achieve their own future well-being.
Ms. ALBRIGHT (United States of America): By adopting this draft
resolution, the members of the Security Council will signify that it is time
for the United Nations to resume its rightful leadership role in restoring
peace to Somalia and in creating conditions for Somalis to choose their own
future. We appreciate the vital role of the Secretary-General thus far and
look forward to his continued vision and leadership now and in the future.
Since the adoption of Security Council resolution 794 (1992) on
3 December last year, the United States has been pleased to join with more
than 30 other United Nations Members in a military mission of mercy
unprecedented in size or purpose. Those countries are too numerous to name
here, but they came from every region and they gave assistance of every type:
infantry, doctors and nurses, engineers, humanitarian workers, police
specialists, trucks, aircraft, logistics support 02 all kinds, use of naval
and air bases, and of course generous financial assistance.
The United States does not want to understate the tasks ahead; as great
as the challenges in Somalia have been, those before us are even greater. But
it can be fairly said to all the members and supporters of Operation Restore
Hope that they have met their calling. Today, hope has returned to Somalia.
It is now time for the United Nations to complete the work begun by the
Unified Task Force. By adopting this draft resolution, we will embark on an
unprecedented enterprise aimed at nothing less than the restoration of an
entire country as a proud, functioning and viable member of the community of
nations. This is an historic undertaking. We are excited to join it and we
will vigourously support it.
At the same time, we are soberly conscious of the fact that this draft
resolution engages the world community to provide the most comprehensive
assistance ever given to any country, but to do so with few lessons and no
models to guide our path,
Yet we are certain of this: Each element of the programme for Somalia is
necessary to its overall success and that country's recuperation. Through his
Special Representative, the Secretary-General must oversee the continued
cease-fire, disarmament, the maintenance of security, further relief and
humanitarian assistance, reconstruction and economic renewal, refugee
repatriation, the creation of civilian administratFon, and especially
political reconciliation,
Indeed, by today's action the Security Council will commit the United
Nations to what is probably the toughest coordination challenge of its
history. It is difficult to overstate the importance of its success'or the
Costs Of its failure. Let us commit ourselves tc its success.
I shall now put to the vote the draft resolution in
document S/25472, as orally revised in its provisional form.
A vote was taken bv show of hands.
In favour: Brazil, Cape Verde, China, Djibouti, France, Hungary, Japan,
Morocco, New Zealand, Pakistan, Russian Federation, Spain,
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, United
States of America, Venezuela
There were 15 votes in favour. The draft
resolution, as orally revised in its provisional form, has therefore been
adopted unanimously as resolution 814 (1993).
I shall now call on those members of the Courxil who wish to make
statements following the voting.
Mr. CHEN Jian (China) (interpretation from Chinese): The question
of Somalia has been at the centre of attention for the international community
since the end of 1991. In order to stop the war in Somalia, bring to an end
the untold sufferings of the Somali people, achieve national reconciliation
and restore peace and stability there, the United Nations, the Organization of
African Unity and the entire international community have made tireless
efforts. At present, though the situation in Somalia has witnessed a degree
of relaxation it remains unstable and complicated. We have noted with concern
that sporadic armed conflicts are still occurring in Somalia; that a secure
environment for humanitarian assistance has yet to be completely established:
and that conditions remain miserable for the many disaster-stricken victims.
How to put a genuine and effective end to the crisis in Somalia is an
issue that faces the entire international community. China has always held
that a political solution to the Somali question should be sought through
peaceful means within the framework of the Conference on National
Reconciliation under the auspices of the United Nations. At the same time, we
also take note of the opinion of the Secretary-General to the effect that
while the unique situation of the absence of any effective, functioning
government in Somalia has' increased the difficulty and complexity of the task
of settling the Somali question, delaying such a settlement will undoubtedly
affect the peace and stability of the entire region. We are therefore in
favour of the United Nations taking strong, exceptional, measures in Somalia,
in accordance with the Secretary-General's recommendations and at the request
of most of the African countries, so as to establish a secure environment for
humanitarian assistance and to create conditions for the final settlement of
the Somali question.
Authorizing UNOSOM II to take enforcement action under Chapter VII of the
Charter in order to implement its mandate has made it the first operation of
its kind in the history of United Nations peace-keeping. It is our
understanding that this authorization is based on the needs of the unique
situation in Somalia and should not constitute a precedent for United Nations
peace-keeping operations. At the same time we believe that UNOSOM II should
act prudently in carrying out such enforcement action. Once the situation in
Somalia improves, UNOSOM II should promptly resume its normal peace-keeping
operations.
A genuine settlement of the Somali question relies, in the final
analysis, on the Somali people. Only when disputes are resolved through
dialogue and consultation and there is national reconciliation can lasting
peace and stability in Somalia be achieved. In this respect, we are glad to
note that with the efforts of the Secretary-General, the Conference on
National Reconciliation in Somalia held in Addis Ababa has made some positive
progress despite many difficulties. We sincerely hope that the Somali
factions concerned will put the fundamental interests of the Somali people and
of regional peace and security first, maintain the momentum of national
reconciliation and achieve a political solution to the Somali question at an
early date.
Mr. MERIMEE (France) (interpretation from French): Since the
Security Council adopted resolution 794 (1992) and deployed the Unified Task
Force on the ground, the situation in Somalia has developed in an encouraging
manner. There has been a tangible improvement in the humanitarian situation
because of a substantial increase in the assistance provided to those affected
and because distribution has improved, and dialogue between Somalis with
national reconciliation in view has been begun,
France welcomes these instances of progress, which have been made
possible thanks to an unprecedented mobilization on the part of the
international community. France for its part has spared no effort to
contribute to the operation, both by providing hm‘lanitarian assistance and by
sending a contingent of about 1,500 men to Somalia.
Despite the encouraging results I have just mentioned, there is still
much to be done. The events of the last few weeks have confirmed, in
particular, that satisfactory security conditions have not yet been restored:
this has also been noted by the Secretary-General in his report to the
Council. The factions still have large quantities of arms at their disposal,
and serious incidents are still occurring, such as, for example, the recent
resumption of confrontations between factions at Kismayo. We are also
concerned about the risk of a deterioration in the situation in the north of
the country arising particularly from the Task Force's absence from the area.
In such circumstances, it is essential that UNOSOM II should have the
necessary mandate and resources, in the first place in order for it to carry
out its mission in a situation that remains unstable, and in the second to
take the necessary steps to improve security. This presupposes that disarming
the factions is carried out in a resolute manner and that the Task Force is
deployed over more and more territory until the whole of Somalia is covered.
It is also essential, if the gains already achieved by the Task Force are to
be held on to, that the transition from the Task Force to UNOSOM II is carried
out cautiously, stage by stage, and taking the situation in each area into as
complete account as possible.
The French Government is happy that the resolution the Security Council
has just adopted is along the lines of these concerns, and in particular that
(Mr, M&rim6e, France)
a substantial part of the provisions of the resolution, in accordance with the
Secretary-General's recommendations, fall under Chapter VII of the United
Nations Charter. As it has done up till now, France will continue to
contribute actively to United Nations activities for Somalia by continuing to
provide humanitarian assistance and by making available to UNOSOM II a
military contingent of 1,100 men.
In adopting this resolution, the United Nations is undertaking an
operation that is unprecedented both in its scope and in terms of the
situation in which it is intervening, which is characterized by the absence of
governmental authority and institutions in Somalia. On the subject of the
scale of the operation - which is justified by the diversity and difficulty of
the tasks to be accomplished - we hope that every possible effort will be made
to limit the cost of the Force without harming its effectiveness.
Concerning the second factor that I have just mentioned, the absence of
government and institutions, it is up to the international community, and in
particular the United Nations to continue to lend all its support to the
process of national reconciliation, which alone affords hope for a political
reconstruction of the country and a lasting return of peace. In this regard,
we welcome the recent meeting of the factions at Addis Ababa and hope that, on
the basis of the results that have already been achieved, the dialogue will
continue. France reiterates its full support for the efforts the
Secretary-General and his Special Representative are making towards this end.
In conclusion, allow me to express the hope that the Somalis will put the
interests of their country first by cooperating fully with the actions of the
international community, which are aimed at helping them, and by continuing
the efforts that have been begun towards national ;econciliation. The success
of the actions taken by the Security Council depends on their doing so.
(Mr. M&rim&e, France)
Mr. PEDAUYE (Spain) {interpretation from Spanish): As this is the
first time my delegation has spoken in a formal meeting of the Security
Council during your term as President, allow me, Sir, to express to you our
great appreciation for the efficiency, professionaiism and skill with which
you are carrying out your duties. I should also like to express my
delegation's gratitude to Ambassador Ahmed Snoussi of Morocco for the very
competent manner in which he guided the work of the Council during the month
of February.
The report submitted by the Secretary-General on 3 March highlighted the
important achievements that have come about thanks to the activities of the
Unified Task Force in Somalia. Nevertheless, the deployment of the Force has
been limited to the centre and south of the country, it has not been possible
to complete the disarmament and the progress that has been made, although
significant, is not irreversible, as the Secretary-General himself points out
in his report.
The exceptional nature of the situation in Somalia, Carefully described
in the report cited earlier, has made necessary the adoption of equally
exceptional measures. As a result, the historic resolution we have just
adopted, while undertaking to advocate the recommendations of the
Secretary-General and their implementation, establishes the first operation of
this nature authorized by the international community and constitutes a
decisive step towards trying to put an end to the sufferings of the Somali
people and towards facing a crisis which, despite the fact that it is
basically of an internal nature, could affect the peace and stability of the
entire region. My delegation is very much aware that this operation is
without precedent and that its proposed objectives are as laudable as they are
ambitious.
The magnitude of the tasks entrusted to the expanded United Nations
Operation in Somalia (UNOSOM II) has the objective of breaking the vicious
circle that has prevented the effective distribution of humanitarian
assistance. The United Nations recognizes that it is impossible to limit
itself to ensuring the distribution of humanitarian assistance and that it is
also necessary to support the process of reconciliation and national
reconstruction in Somalia. Both tasks can only be undertaken feasibly if
security is guaranteed throughout the entire territory of Somalia. This is
the main mission of UNOSOM II and the reason why United Nations forces will
continue t0 act in accordance with Chapter VII of the Charter and will, among
other important functions, proceed to disarm the factions and other groups of
Somali society.
It is basic for the success of the operation that the transition between
the Unified Task Force (UNITAF) and UNOSOM II occur without problems. This
transition should be gradual and take place without obstacles or disruptions
(Mr. Pedauve, Spain)
to avoid the possibility that the heads of the different factions or armed
groups might take advantage of the advent of a vacuum in an area over which
UNITAF has already established its control. My delegation must therefore
highlight the warnings of the Secretary-General concerning the need to respect
the flexible nature of this transition process and of the four phases into
which it is divided. I also feel it appropriate to recall here the importance
of having the Unified Task Force constantly maintain its logistical support to
the United Nations operation.
This ambitious project should enjoy - and this is a basic element - the
full cooperation of the Somali people, and hence the need, as the resolution
points out, to include in the process of national reconciliation the greatest
possible number of representatives of the society of that country, including
leading figures, professionals, intellectuals, women and so on, and to be
careful to work to restore institutions such as a Somali police force around
which the national administration can be rebuilt. I should like to express my
hope that the Conference on National Reconciliation, which is curently being
held in Addis Ababa, can make substantial progress in this direction.
On the other hand, tha active participation of specialized bodies, United
Nations programmes, regional organisations and non-governmental organizations
will be required as well. In any event, perseverance should be a basic
element throughout this process, since the state of anarchy described by the
Secretary-General in his last report of 3 March makes it quite apparent that
the operation will be of long duration and that all sorts of challenges will
have to be faced.
As I pointed out at the beginning of this statement, Spain has carefully
followed the evolution of the Somali crisis. In so doing, it has contributed
(Mr. Pedauve, Spain)
as much assistance as it has been able, both through national contributions
and through international organisations to which it belongs. In this rgard., I
feel it is important to,point out that between 1991 and 1992, the European
Community and its member States have contributed more than $350 million in
assistance to Somalia, and that the bodies of European political cooperation
have issued statements supporting the efforts made by the international
community and the United Nations to contribute to the solution of the Somalia
conflict.
Spain believes that the resolution we have just approved and the
implementation of UNOSOM II will make possible the restoration of peace and
security in Somalia and put an end to the humanitarian disaster afflicting
this country. I should like for all these reasons to express my Government's
gratitude to the Secretary-General and his Special Representative for the
vision and the courage which they have demonstrated and to assure them that
they have our support in working to carry out the arduous tasks they still
must face.
I thank the representative of Spain for his kind
words.
Mr. SARDENBERG (Brazil): By unanimously adopting today's
resolution, the Security Council is taking a furtler important step in
addressing the complex and unique situation that still prevails in Somalia.
The fundamental reason why the United Nations is being called to play a
more robust role in Somalia is the temporary non-existence of a government in
that Member State, as national and regional Somali institutions and civil
administration have virtually collapsed.
(Mr. Pedauve. Soain)
The complex and wide-ranging mandate contained in the resolution we have
adopted is, therefore, a necessary and appropriate step taken by the Security
Council with a view to restoring normalcy in Somalia at an early date.
The delegation of Brazil welcomes the progress achieved at the Conference
on National Reconciliation for Somalia and hopes that the process of political
settlement and national reconciliation will be successfully achieved with the
active and broad participation of all sectors of Somali society.
While recognising that the people of Somalia bear the ultimate
responsibility for national reconciliation and for the reconstruction of their
country, the delegation of Brazil welcomes the willingness expressed by
Governments at the Third United Nations Coordination Meeting for Humanitarian
Assistance for Somalia to contribute to relief and rehabilitation efforts in
that country.
We commend the cooperation of regional and other organizations such as
the Organisation of African Unity, the League of Arab States, the Organisation
of the Islamic Conference and the Non-Aligned Movement with the efforts of the
United Nations, as well as the invaluable assistance that is being provided by
neighbouring countries to promote the process of national reconciliation in
Somalia and to alleviate the plight of the Somali people.
We also express our appreciation for the significant role played by the
Unified Task Force with a view to the establishment of a secure environment
for humanitarian relief operations in Somalia. The convergent and coordinated
efforts of all those organisations with the United Nations in an operation of
unprecedented scale underscores the possibilities for constructive partnership
and task-sharing that may exist when the international community is ready to
display solidarity and political commitment.
(Mr, Sardenberg. Brazil)
The delegation of Brazil once again pays tribute to the selfless
dedication of the personnel of the United Nations and other organizations
endeavouring to provide humanitarian assistance to the Somali population,
It is our hope that all sectors of Somali society will intensify their
efforts towards the successful conclusion of the process of national
reconciliation. We are convinced that the international community will not
fail to continue to give its full support to the achievement of that goal,
Mr. MARKER (Pakistan): Let me begin, Sir, by placing on record my
delegation's profound appreciation of the skill, the supreme efficiency and
the sagacity with which you have been discharging your duties as President for
the current month in innings characterized by a judicious blend of initiative
and patience.
I would also wish to express my delegation's admiration for the
competence and wisdom which my brother, Ambassador Ahmed Snoussi, displayed
during his tenure as President in the previous month. Our only regret is that
last month had only 28 days.
My delegation welcomed, and we deeply appreciate, the Secretary-General's
comprehensive report of 3 March 1993 on Somalia, submitted in pursuance of
Security Council resolution 794 (1992). It is obvious that a great deal of
effort and constructive thinking has gone into the preparation of the report.
We look forward to the Secretary-General's continuing initiative and
leadership in the implementation process.
Despite competing demands on its limited resources, the Government of
Pakistan has actively and materially supported United Nations efforts in
Somalia, as demonstrated by our participation in the initial United Nations
OPeratiOn in Somalia (UNOSOM I). We hope to continue that cooperation and
even to increase our commitment.
The important, indeed crucial, role played by the United States
contingent and the United Task Force (UNITAF) in restoring a semblance of
normality in Somalia deserves the gratitude and approbation of the entire
international community. Without their effort, we would not have reached the
stage where we could have adopted today's resolution.
MY delegation also commends the commitment shown and the efforts
undertaken by the Secretary-General and his team of dedicated officials, by
the various multilateral agencies, by United Nations bodies and by
non-governmental organizations: all of them, despite very daunting odds, have
provided relief and succour to the suffering Somali people and have helped
ameliorate the situation in Somalia.
We also owe a debt of gratitude to the peoples and the Governments of
Djibouti, Ethiopia and Kenya, which have faced with fortitude and courage the
problems created for them and the burdens imposed on them by the internal
strife in Somalia. Indeed, without Ethiopia's active assistance the
reconciliation process under way in Addis Ababa would not have been possible.
The role of the Organization of African Unity (OAU), the League of Arab
States, the Grganization of the Islamic Conference and the Non-Aligned
Movement also deserves recognition.
The main causes of the tragic situation the Somali people have endured
over the last two years are to be found in the internal politics of Somalia.
It is nevertheless true that the introduction of modern weapons from outside
and their wanton use served to give an internal s:ruggle for power the
dimensions of a catastrophe. Thus, besides progress in the reconciliation
process, the measures that need to be pursued with equal determination and
singlemindedness include the securing of weapons, particularly heavy weaponsI
under United Nations control, the de-mining of all regions, the earliest
possible rehabilitation of displaced persons and the rebuilding of the Somali
infrastructure and economy.
It is therefore crucial that UNOSOM II and the Secretary-General be
provided with a wide enough and a flexible enough mandate to achieve what they
are being asked to deliver. In this context, my delegation awaits a positive
outcome of .the Conference on National Reconciliation in Somalia, which began
in Addis Ababa on 15 March. We were concerned at the brief suspension of the
Conference; however, its resumption was reassuring. It is our earnest hope
that the Conference will set in motion an irreversible process towards the
establishment of a democratic order in Somalia. We applaud the wise decision
of the Secretary-General to widen participation in the Conference by inviting
representatives of various sectors of Somali civil society. We wish this
process every success.
My delegation regards today's resolution on Somalia as a historic
document, because it engages the United Nations in a broad range of
activities. It is a positive response by the United Nations to a series of
challenges which now face the international community. Success in its
implementation is therefore a matter of the utmost importance to all of us.
Pakistan will play a positive role in the process of implementation and
remains deeply committed to the objectives of the resolution in both letter
and spirit.
I thank the representative of Pakistan for the kind
words he addressed to me.
Mr, ERDOS (Hungary) (interpretation from French): when last
December the Council adopted resolution 794 (1992), which defined resolute and
innovative action to put an end to the suffering of the Somali people, my
delegation noted that it was highly important for international action in
(Mr. Marker, Pakistan)
Somalia to go beyond achieving the immediate objective of providing
humanitarian assistance to the civilian population. We stressed that paral lel
action was necessary to create conditions not only for the survival of the
Somali people but also for national reconciliation and the political and
economic renewal and reconstruction of Somalia.
We therefore welcome the adoption of Security Council resolution
814 (1993), which is intended to ensure the prompt, phased transition from the
United Task Force (UNITAF) to the expanded United Nations Operation in Somalia
(UNOSOM II).
We are, of course, aware of the dimensions of the challenges that will
face the United Nations when UNOSOM II begins its operations. To meet that
challenge, we must ensure that UNOSOM II is fully able to carry out its
mandate, which includes taking the steps necessary to create a climate of
security, and to establish stability and public order in Somalia. In line
with present requirements, this also includes assistance from the
international community to Somalia, through UNOSOM II, to get the country back
on its feet and to rebuild its institutional structures.
That grand design should extend to the entire country, both North and
South; it can be achieved only through a process of national reconciliation
among the Somalis combined with large-scale sustained efforts by the
international community.
Since the international community is ready and willing to help the Somali
people, through UNOSOM II, the Somalis themselves must take charge of their
future with a heightened sense of responsibility and must build a civil
society in Somalia, something that is cruelly lacking at present. We
therefore attach the highest importance to the Addis Ababa conferences and
hope they will result in the establishment of an effective democratic system
in Somalia..
We believe that cooperation between the United Nations and the Unified
Task Force countries has been exemplary. We expect that the transfer to
UNOSOM II, though it will be far from simple, will similarly be carried out in
a satisfactory manner and without a loss of momentum. In that connection, I'
note that it was thanks to the praiseworthy initiative of the United States of
America - to which we are grateful - that it now has become possible for
UNOSOM to resume its responsibilities.
(Mr. Erdijs. Hunaarv)
In our opinion, there can be no doubt that the United Nations operation
in Somalia, of which a new chapter is opening with the adoption of resolution
814 (1993), is implemented only on the basis of Chapter VII of the Charter.
It is clear that the success of this endeavour will inspire the United Nations
in charting its course with regard to other conflicts tearing our world apart,
Mr. HATANO (Japan): My Government wishes to pay tribute to the
countries contributing troops to the Unified Task Force (UNITAF) to carry out
its mandate in a difficult environment. UNITAF has achieved great progress in
establishing a secure environment for humanitarian relief operations in
Somalia. While we in the Security Council should continue efforts to maintain
and improve the environment for relief, I believe Somalia’s need will be
shifting to national reconstruction - political, social and economic.
My delegation welcomes the results of the United Nations conference on
humanitarian assistance for Somalia to review the relief and rehabilitation
programme. In our view, the conference was useful in providing an important
framework, not only for relief assistance, but also for putting Somalia back
on the track to economic recovery.
Japan was pleased to contribute $100 million to the Trust Fund for
Somalia to support UNITAF operations. It has also extended $20 million for
humanitarian assistance in Somalia. Japan will continue to explore, in Cl’OSe
coordination with the United Nations, how it might best support the Somali
people in their efforts for national reconstruction. In this connection, it
is my delegation's view that the importance of job-creation efforts, such as
vocational training programmes, as mentioned in the Secretary-General's
report, should be stressed.
(Mr. Erdijs, Hungary)
Lasting peace and security and genuine reconstruction will not be
possible without a broad political settlement. My Government urges the
parties, movements and factions in Somalia to abide by the agreements which
they themselves concluded in Addis Ababa in January. The future of Somalia is
not in the hands of the United Nations or of UNITAF or UNISOM I or UNISOM II,
but is in the hands of the people of Somalia.
Mr. RICHARDSON (United Kingdom): Let me at the outset, Sir,
congratulate you on your splendid job in the presidency, which already seems a
rather longer month than its allotted span of 31 days. I also take this
opportunity to join many others in warmly congratulating Ambassador Snoussi on
the magnificent job he did in the presidency last month.
The hour is fairly late. Others have been very eloquent about the
situation in Somalia, and I have no wish to go over ground that they have
covered so ably. I should simply like to make a few points.
First and foremost, a word of thanks is due to the United States and to
all others that have contributed to the united Force, and without whose
efforts and groundwork I doubt that we should be adopting the resolution on
the United Nations Operation in Somalia (UNISOM II) today.
Secondly, I think the great merit of the resolution we have just adopted
is its mixture of firmness and sensitivity - firmness in the sense that
UNISOM II will be endowed with a robust Chapter VII mandate. We believe that
to be necessary. The process of disarming must continue, as the
Secretary-General has pointed out. It is also important that UNISOM II will
operate throughout the territory of Somalia. As others will know, my
delegation attaches great importance to that point.
(Mr. Hatano, JaDan)
In mentioning sensitivity I have in mind particularly the
Secretary-General's invaluable work in promoting the task of political
reconciliation. Like others, I want to pay him a warm tribute for the
conferences that have been organized in Addis Ababa and for handling them so
carefully and sensitively.
I think we all recognize, as indeed the report of the Secretary-General
does, how difficult the task of political reconciliation will be and how much
we shall need to build upwards from the grassroots. I think things are going
in the right direction, and I pay tribute,again to the efforts of all those
involved in the United Nations so far.
The resolution rightly underlines the contributions that must be made by
the humanitarian organisations in Somalia. Like others, I pay tribute to all
the United Nations agencies, intergovernmental and non-governmental
organizations, which are operating in a difficult and still, unfortunately,
dangerous environment. I think it will be important in the future to achieve
an ever closer coordination of the humanitarian effort in Somalia, and I am
pleased that efforts are being made in that direction,
My own Government has been a major contributor to the relief effort, both
nationally, and, as my Spanish colleague mentioned, within the framework of
the European Community.
Finally, the unity of the Security Council in adopting what others have
rightly called a historic resolution is itself an important factor, and I hope
a decisive factor. We shall need to maintain this unity of action in what are
bound to be difficult times ahead as the operations of UNISOM II unfold.
I thank the representative of the United Kingdom for
his kind words addressed to me.
Mr. VORONTSOV (Russian Federation): The Russian delegation joins in
the expression of warm words to you, Mr. President, in connection with your
excellent guidance of our Council's meetings. We also congratulate your
predecessor, Ambassador Snoussi, on his excellent work last month as President.
The Russian Federation supports the efforts of the United Nations to
ensure safe conditions for emergency humanitarian assistance to the Somali
people, to stabilise the situation and to achieve a political settlement and
national reconciliation in Somalia. We voted for the resolution adopted by
the Security Council on transferring functions from the Unified Task Force
(UNITAF) to the United Nations Operation in Somalia (UNISOM II), based on the
fact that the mandate of the United Nations Operation focuses on ensuring safe
conditions for the supply of emergency humanitarian assistance, inter alia, by
disarming the Somali armed formations. We feel that in so doing it is
necessary to ensure a stage-by-stage, fluid transition of the UNITAF operation
to UNISOM II. It is also important that the beginning of the Operation and
its implementation be closely linked to the efforts to achieve a long-term
political settlement in Somalia.
In this connection, we hope that the results of the Conference on
National Reconciliation held in Addis Ababa will have a significant, positive
impact on the swift implementation of the tasks facing the United Nations
Operation.
We attach great importance to strengthening the embargo established by
the Security Council on arms supplies to Somalia, and we consider it important
that all States strictly carry out this decision yf the Security Council.
The Russian delegation attaches great importance to the need for sensible
expenditures of funds. In this regard, we note the Secretary-General's
intention to support the United Nations presence in Somalia at a minimal level.
The financial implications of this Operation should be carefully considered by
experts in the appropriate budgetary bodies of the United Nations to ensure
economically effective use of the significant allocated funds.
Taking into account the unprecedented nature of the Operation, it is
necessary that the Secretary-General, Mr. Boutros Boutros-Ghali, report
regularly to the members of the Council on measures relating to the period of
transition from UNITAF to UNISOM II and the deployment of the Operation itself.
The Russian Federation is ready, together with other members of the
international community, actively to promote the effective implementation of
the tasks facing this important United Nations Operation in Somalia.
I thank the representative of the Russian Federation
for his kind remarks addressed to me.
I should now like to make a brief statement in my capacity as
representative of New Zealand.
New Zealand applauds the efforts of the Unified Task Force and the
contributions which individual countries of the United Nations have made to
the operation in Somalia. -We draw satisfaction, too, from the fact that New
Zealand has participated in this effort. We acknowledge the lead which has
been given to the Unified Task Force operation by the Government of the United
States.
It is clear, however, that the situation in Somalia remains extremely
volatile. Recent tragic events have shown that the progress which has been
made cannot yet be understood as irreversible.
In this context, New Zealand fully supports the resolution that we have
just adopted. It is a significant decision, and it marks a further step by
the United Nations towards defining a new era in international peace-keeping
operations.
We believe the resolution accurately describes the situation in Somalia
and correctly identifies the priority tasks for the new United Nations
operations in that country.
In New Zealand's view, a first priority is to complete the process of
disarming started by the Unified Task Force. This cannot be stressed too
highly, Progress towards political reconciliation and economic recovery in
Somalia depends upon the creation of sustainable peace and security. New
Zealand supports, therefore, the particular emphasis in the resolution on
disarming, and we believe it is important, as an initial step, to define now
the parties that are to be disarmed.
Equally important, of Courser is the continuation of the humanitarian
relief that has been the principal motivation for United Nations i.nVOlVement
in Somalia. The effectiveness of the United Nati.jns efforts in this regard
will be enhanced, in our view, through close cooperation and coordination with
non-governmental organizations, as is called for in the resolution that we
have just adopted.
New Zealand takes this opportunity to acknowledge and give credit to the
role of the many non-governmental organisations that have since the earliest
days of Somalia's crisis shown their willingness to help the people and to
continue to assist through the most difficult times, working often in
precarious circumstances.
Recovery in Somalia depends upon the reconstruction of effective
political institutions at the local, regional and national levels and on the
establishment of democratic processes. It also depends upon ensuring
protection for the human rights of the people in that country. United Nations
efforts to assist in these areas is of the highest priority and will require a
sustained involvement on the part of this Organisation.
The United Nations must be prepared to see through its commitment in
Somalia.
I now resume my functions as President of the Council.
There are no further names inscribed on the list of speakers, The
Security Council has thus concluded the present stage of its consideration of
the item on its agenda. The Security Council will remain seized of the matter.
The meetinff rose at 6.15 n.m.