S/PV.2853 Security Council
▶ This meeting at a glance
3
Speeches
0
Countries
0
Resolutions
Topics
Security Council deliberations
Global economic relations
Humanitarian aid in Afghanistan
Peace processes and negotiations
War and military aggression
General debate rhetoric
I thank the representative
of the Syrian Arab Republic for the kind words he addressed to me and to my
country, the Soviet Union.
The next speaker is the representative of the German Democratic Republic. I
invite him to take a place at the Council table and to make his statement.
Mr. .ZACHMANN (German Democratic Republic): Allw me first of all to
congratulate you, Sir, on your assumption of the presidency for the month of
April. We are particularly glad to see in that high office the representative of a
country with which the German Democratic Republic maintains close fraternal
relations. We are certain that under your presidency the questions the
Security Council has to deal with will be solved in a satisfactory way.
At the same time my delegation wishes to express its appreciation to the
Ambassador of Senegal, Her Excellency Mrs. Absa Claude Diallo, who presided over . the work of the Security Council in the month of March.
The delegation of the German Democratic Republic is speaking before the
L’
Security Council on this agenda item out of concern at the situation existing in
and around Afghanistan. As a member of the international community, it feels it
has a responsibility to contribute to an end to the bloodshed in Afghanistan and to
the restoration of peace and stability in that country and in the entire region.
We state our views out of solidarity with the sorely tried Afghan people and out of
(Mr. Zachmann, German Uexocra tic Republic)
in bringing about the Geneva accords , can play an even weightier part in their
implementation.
As was the case the world over, the German Democratic Republic welcomed the
Geneva accords on a political settlement of the situation around Afghanistan. The
signing of those accords created rhe conditions under international law for the .
elimination of one of the most canplex regional conflicts of our time. Upon the it
Signing, the overwhelming majority of States emphatically demanded that all sides
involved in the conflict fully implement and respect the provisions if the
accords. That demand was also expressed in resolution 43/20, which was adopted by
consensus at the forty-third session of the General Assembly. The German
Democratic Republic wishes here to commend the strict implementation of the accords
by the USSR and Afghanistan , which is reflected above all in the withdrawal of the
limited Soviet military contingent that began on 15 May 1988 and ended, as planned,
on 15 February last.
(Mr. Zachmann, German Derrpcratic Republic)
There is a chance to remove the conflict, to restore peace in the country on
the basis of national reconciliation and to stabilize security in the region, if
the other sides to the Agreements also fulfil tneir duties flowing from those
Agreements. However, we cannot but note that - as is confirmed by the remarks of
the Foreign Minister of Afghanistan - this has not yet happened.
But one thing should have become obvious since Geneva from the ‘developments in
and around Afghanistan: interference, the use of force, military assistance to the
opposition, the establishment of a so<alled interim Government - which does not
represent all the opposition forces, let alone the majority of the Afghan people,
and even operates from foreign territory - are not at all in the interests of the
Afghan people and of peace in and around Afghanistan. Those forces that openly Set
themselves the goal of removing the legitimate Government of Afghanistan are
responsible for what is happening today. We therefore wish to stress again:
non-compliance with the Geneva Agreements and resolution 43/20 means undermining
the sovereignty of the Republic of Afghanistan and increasing the dangers to peace
and security in the region.
The delegation of the German Democratic Republic believes that there is no
reasonable alternative to a comprehensive solution of the situation in and around
Afghanistan. It considers the cessation of the armed confrontation, stirred up
from outside, & the achievement of a cease-fire to be important prerequisites for
ending the bloodshed.
At the session of the Foreign Ministers of the States parties to the Warsaw
Treaty held in the capital of my country on 11 and 12 April 1989, the Ministers
reaffirmed the determination of their States to participate actively in the search
for political.solutions to the regional conflicts in the Middle East, in Asia, in
(Mr. Zachmann, German Denoctatic Republic)
Africa and in Central America, with due regard for the legitimate interests of the
sides and respect for the right of all peoples to determine their own destinies.
In respect to Afghanistan the communique' of the Berlin session sayst
"The Ministers pronounced themselves in favour of an independent, non-aligned
and democratic Afghanistan , of guaranteeing its free development on the basis
of the policy of national reconciliation without any kind of external
interference. They stressed that further efforts are needed to bring about a
settlement of the Afghanistan problem".
If the problem of Afghanistan cannot be solved in a peaceful way, that hotbed
of conflict may remain a danger to peace and stability in the region for an
undetermined period. We are therefore in favour of a resolute commitment by the
United Nations to ensure the implementation of the Geneva Agreements. We believe
that the more effective carrying out of the mandate entrusted to the United Nations I
Good Offices Mission in Afghanistan and Pakistan (UNGXAP) under the Geneva
Agreements will be an important contribution to increasing the peace-making role of
the Organisation. A first appropriate step in that direction would be the setting
uP of UNCXAP observer posts at the Afghan border , as proposed by the Foreign
Minister of Afghanistan in his letter of 3 April 1989 to the President of the
Security Council. The German Democratic Republic also supports the proposal by the
Government of Afghanistan that an international conference be convened under the
Lauspices of the United Nations to discuss questions related to the neutrality and
demilitarisation of Afghanistan.
My delegatian welcomes the statement of 14 April 1989 by the Secretary-General
in which he reiterated his
(Mr. Zachmann, German Denccra tic Republic)
“commitment to continue to provide all assistance required by the Afghan
people for the early realization of a comprehensive, political solution in
Afghanistan, as called for by General Assembly resolution 43/20”.
Just as the Geneva Agreements are another confirmation of the fact that even
complex international issues can be solved by political means if the legitimate
interests of all sides involved are taken due account of and if there is a
reasonable measure of readiness for compromise, the German DerrPcratic Republic
expects political will to prevail when it comes to the implementation of those
Agreements.
My Government and the people of the German Democratic Republic support all
measures capable of ensuring for the Afghan people ii life of peace and harmony in
an independent, neutral and non-aligned Afghan is tan. The proposals submitted by
the .Foreign Minister of Afghanistan in his statement of 11 April 1989 are suited to
serving the attainment of that goal.
The PRESIDENT (interpretation from Russian) t
I thank the representative
of the German Demcratic Republic for the kind words he addressed to the Soviet
Union -and to me personally.
invite him to take a place
The next speaker is the representative of Cuba. I
at the Council table and to make his statement.
Mr. CRAMAS OLIm {Cuba) (interpretation from !Zpanish)t I should like
f frst of all to congratulate you, sir, on your assumption of the presidency of the
Security Council for the month of April. We are convinced that under your wise and
able leadership this body will continue to contribute to the preservation of
international peace and security , in accordance with the mandate conferred upon it .
by the Charter. We pledge our modest co-operation for the attainment of that
(?4r. Otamas Oliva, Cuba)
I take this opportunity to express our appreciation for the efficient way in
which Ambassador Absa Claude Diallo conducted the Council's proceedings in March.
In Cuba's opinion, this series of Security Council meetings is not Only
pertinent but necessary, for the present situation in Afghanistan endangers peace
and security in a large portion of the Asian continent as well as the
implementation of the Geneva Pqreements, by which it seemed that an end would be
put to a conflict that had already lasted for 10 years.
(Mr. OramaS OliVa, Cuba)
We welcome the decision by the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics to withdraw
its military contingent from Afghanistan in Compliance with it.5 commitments, and we
salute the willingness of the Government of Afghanistan to adopt the. measures
necessary to achieve a negotiated peace. Cuba believes that the peaceful
settlement of disputes is one of the most basic purposes of the United Nations.
This is one case where it is indispensable that full use be made of al,1 the
Organisation’s moral reserves and energy to ensure not only peace in Afghanistan,
but also that country’s independence , sovereignty and territorial integrity. We
must restore the peace and security longed for by the countries of the region.
But to achieve that goal it is vital that all parties to the Geneva accords
comply with their commitments and cease all foreign interference in Afghanistan so
the Afghan people can solve its own problems and decide freely on its own future,
with a broad-based Government of national reconciliation, as repeatedly proposed by
President Na jibullah.
There is no doubt that a so-called military solution is not valid for
Afghanistan. It had been said that the Kabul Government would be quickly
overthrown; yet events have clearly shown that the country’s second largest city, .
Jalalabad, has not been taken.
Consequently, and in view of the escalation of recent months, it is urgent
that .vigorbus measures be adopted to end the conflict. me such measure could be
the convening of an international conference on Afghanistan, where outstanding
differences could be resolved and arrangements for a just and lastinq peace adopted.
At the same time it is increasingly necessary to stren+hen the good offices.
the United Netions has been employing in the country. lb that end, we must
(Mr. Oramas Oliva, Cuba)
strengthen the United Nations Good Offides Mission in Afghanistan and Pakistan
(UNC3XlAP) and adopt all the measures that would enable it fully to fulfil its
mandate.
Cuba has been and remains a fervent champion of the use of peaceful means fOt
the settlement of disputes, and the issue before the Council today is no
exception. Therefore, we would not wish to end without making a fresh appeal to
all parties to cease all interference in the internal affairs of Afghanistan, to
respect the principles that should govern peaceful coexistence among States and to
take the path of negotiation -and dialogue to put an end once and for all to a
conflict that defies universal common sense.
We are grateful to the Secretary-General, Mr. Javier Perez de Cuellar, for
recalling in his 14 April statement on this subject a paragraph of General Assembly
resolution 43/20, unanimously adopted on 3 November 1988, which
"Reaffirms the right of the Afghan people to determine their wn form of
government and to choose their economic, political and social system free from
outside intervention, subversion , coercion or constraint of any kind
whatsoever". (General Assembly resolution 43/20, para. 6)
The PRESIDRJT (interpretation from Russian)% I thank the representative
of Cuba for the kind words he addressed to me.
The next speaker is the representative of Mongolia. I invite him to take a
place at the Council table and to make his statement.
Mr. DUCERSUREN (Mongolia) (interpretation from Russian) : I wish first to
congratulate you, Sir, on your assumption of the presidency of the Security Council
for this month. We are certain that you will be successful in carrying out the
difficult tasks that will face you when disturbing and critical events demand close
attention and appropriate action by the Security Council.
I should like to join previous speakers in thanking your predecessor, the
Ambassador of Senegal, Mrs. Abda Claude Diallo, for the capable way in,‘which she
guided the Council’s work in March.
My thanks go also to you, Sir, and the other members of the Council< for giving
us this opportunity to state briefly my Government’s position on the item before
the Counci 1. The Government of the Mongolian People’s Republic attaches particular
importance to this item. It crucially affects the vital interests of a State
Member of the United Nations, the Republic of Afghanistan, and the cause of peace
and security in Asia.
A year ago the international oxamunity welcomed with considerable hope the
signing of the Geneva accords which laid down the international legal basis for a
comprehensive political settlement of the situation that had arisen around
Afghan is tan. Hembets will recall that the accords provided for the withdrawal of
the limited contingent of Soviet troops that had been deployed in Afghanistan at
the request of the-Afghan Government, Rut the central goal of the Geneva accords
was to bring an end to foreign interference , which had.been widening and
exacerbating internecine strife in Afghanistan , and to ensure that Afghan refugees
could freely return to their country.
Through joint active efforts, the Governments of the Republic of Afghanistan
and the Soviet Union have, within the timaframe set out in the accords, effected
the withdrawal of Soviet troops from Afghanistan and ensured the conditions
(Mr. Dugersuren, Mongolia)
policy of national reconciliation. They are now taking constructive steps to
ensure complete compliance with the Geneva accords.
i But the actions of other parties to the Geneva accords, particularly Pakistan,
run directly counter to the spirit and letter of those historic documents.
SpeoificallY, among all the various articles and paragraphs, we find there to have
been violations of a particularly important element of the Geneva aocordst the
Bilateral Agreement Between the Republic of Afghanistan and the Islamic Republic Of
Pakistan oxi the Principles of Mutual Relations, in particular on Non-Interference
-and Non-Intervention.
There is much cogent evidence of the constant escalation of those violations,
as set out in the statements before the Council by the Minister for Foreign Affairs
of Afghanistan, Mr. Wakil, and other speakers. I shall therefore refrain from
going through the facts yet again.
(Mr. Duger suren, Mongol ia)
In that regard, I should just like to stress that, pursuant to the agreement,
the parties undertook .to refrain from the promotion, encouragement or support,
direct or indirect, of rebellious or secessionist activities against the other High
Contracting Party” (S/19835, .Annex’ I; .Article. XI; paragraph 7). However, external
forces continue to finance and. arm extremist anti-Government groups and are
encouraging and organising bloody armed actions. Those forces make no effort to
conceal their attempts to overthrow the legitimate Government of the Republic of
Afghanistan, an equal party to the Geneva accords. In light of that, we find
particularly illuminating the piecing-together of a so-called “transitional
Government” in the territory of Pakistan and the fierce attacks organised from
there on Jalalabad and other Afghan towns.
Those actions have aroused the severe condemnation of all peace-loving forces
that uphold the interests of the Afghan and Pakistani peoples and respect the
principles of justice, including faithful compliance with international
obligations. Those actions further contravene the principles of the united Nations
Charter, the spirit of our times, when there is growing recognition of the need to
ensure the primacy of law in international relations.
YI delegation was particularly concerned by the danger of a possible military
intervention in Afghanistan, and warning to that effect was issued .by the Foreign
Minister of Afghanistan here in the Security Council. Once again, this
demonstrates that the continuation and, particularly, the further exacerbation of
the current situation in Afghanistan threaten the cause of peace and security in
the region. We are also alarmed by reports in the media that the implacable rebels
are establishing contacts with extremist elements in certain countries in the
region and are making attempts to recruit “volunteers”.
(Mt. Uugersuren, Mongolia)
The escalation of the current intervention in Afghanistan’s affairs after the
withdrawal of Soviet troops makes it absolutely clear that that presence was not
the reason for the crisis which has arisen in that country. The causes were
altogether different.
On the other hand, the course of events has shown that the Government, army
and people of Afghanistan are fully determined and capable of &fending their
freedom, independence and territorial integrity. We are all familiar with the
heroic traditions of the Afghan people in its struggle against the colonialists for
its freedom, independence and self-determination.
The Mongolian People’s Republic whole-heartedly supports the efforts of the
Government of the Republic of Afghanistan, led by President Najibullah, to bring
about national reconciliation and to ensure the Afghan people’s right to choose its
wn economic, political and social system without any outside interference
whatsoever. Our Government very much appreciates the diplomatic and other actions
undertaken by the Soviet Union as the guarantor State in support of a political
settlement of the problem. The constructive and realis tic compromises undertaken
by the Afghan and Soviet sides are a concrete demnstration of their goodwill.
y! delegation appeals to the Security Council to take urgent measures to
ensure full compliance with the Geneva accords.
The Security Council has called upon all parties and guarantor States of the
Geneva accords to do everything in their power to call an immediate halt to outside
intervention in Afghanistan’s affairs, to bring about a cease-fire and to cti%te
the conditions for an intra-Afghan dialogue aimed at forming a broad-based
Government.
In the present circumstances , the swift deployment of the necessary number of
United Nations observer posts along the Afghan-Pakistan border is extremely urgent-
(WK. Uugecsuren, Mongolia)
My delegation supports the proposal to convene an international conference on
the notmalization of the situation in Afghanistan , under the aegis of the United
Nations and on the basis of the Geneva accords.
In conclusion, we express the hope that the Security Council, aware of its
great responsibility for the maintenance of international peace and security, will,
in the true interests of the Afghan people and of peace and security in the area,
take concrete decisions that will contribute to an effective end to intervention in
Afghanistan’s internal affairs.
The PRESIDR4T (interpretation from Russian) t I thank the representative
of Mongolia for his kind words addressed to me.
The next speaker inscribed on my list is the representative of tit key. I
invite him to take a place at the Council table and to make his statement.
Mr. AKSW (Turkey): At the outset, Sir, 1 wish to extend to you my
congratulations on your assumption of the presidency. of the Council for the month
of April and my best wishes for success. We are pleased to see as President of the
Security Council the representative of the Soviet Union , a neigbouring country with
which Turkey has very good relations. We are confident that the Security Council
will benefit from your diplomatic skill and experience in dealing witn sensitive
international questions.
I wish equally to pay a tribute to Ambassador Absa Claude Diallo of Senegal
for having led the Council in March with ability and distinction.
This debate takes place exactly one year after the Geneva Agreements were
Concluded. There is no doubt that the conclusion of those accords constituted an
important step towards the political situation of the Afghanistan problem. Through
them the international community has witnessed the withdrawal of foreign troops and
welcomed the opportunity given to the Afghan people freely to determine its own r
Afghan people , stands out as anessential element for a lasting solution of this
problem. We consider the interim Government established by the Consultative Shura
last February as a positive step in the tight direction. In that respect, I should
also like to recall that the Islamic Conference expressed its support of this
development during its recent meeting in Riyadh.
The magnitude of the human suffering experienced by the Afghan people is well
known. The loss of life and the material destruction have been stagqerillg- There
has also been an enormous displacement of population. In his comprehensive
statement in the Security Council last Tuesday the representative of Pakistan gave
a dramatic account of the situation prevailing in the country. Unfortunately, it
has thus far not been possible to carry out effective international action to
alleviate‘ the economic hardships and the human suffering described in the various
reports of the United Nations Co-ordinator for Humanitarian and Economic Assistance
Programmes, .
(Mr. Aksin, Turkey)
a At present Pakistan and Iran continue to bear the heavy burden of providing
shelter for about five million Afghan refugees who have been driven from their
homes. We are keenly aware of the tremendous sacrifices undertaken by Pakistan in
accorunodating millions of destitute victims of a Cruel war.
Turkey has deep-rooted ties of ftiendship with the Afghan nation. We
fervently hope that the Afghan people will begin to tend their wounds gs soon as
possible. However, it would be unrealistic to expect the resolution of the current
humanitarian and development problems under the conditions prevailing in’
Afghanis tan. It is clear that the repatriation and rehabilitation of the refugees,
as well as the overcoming of the vast economic disruption, are dependent on a
political solution that is in full conformity with the aspirations of all segments
of the Afghan nation.
The Geneva Agreements and General Assembly resolutions constitute a sound
basis on which to build a political settlement of the Afghanistan problem. Turkey
is convinced that after 10 year8 of heavy sacrifices the Afghan people have a right
to live in peace under a Government of their choosing so that they can resume their
normal activities and rebuild their country. The international community has a
duty to assist in making this goal possible.
TWkey has a long tradition of co-operation with Afghanistan going back to the
early part of this century, and, in this spirit, it will be glad to do its part
towards healing the wounds of that proud nation. -* The PRESIDENT (interpretation from Russian) t I thank the representative
e of Turkey for his kind war-Us addressed to me.
The next speaker is the representative of Japan. I invite him to take a place
at the Council table and to’ make his statement.
Mr. RAC%1 (Japan): I wish to congratulate you, Sir, on your assumption
of the presidency of the Security Council for the month of April. I am confident
that with the benefit of your guidance and diplomatic skill the work of the COutlCil
will be fruitful. I would also like to express my appreciation for the exemplary
manner in which your predecessor, Ambassador Absa Claude Diallo of Senegal,
conducted the Council’s work during the month of March.
On 14 April we obsetved the first anniversary of the signing of the Geneva
accords. Japan wishes to take this opportunity to reiterate its high appreciation
for the efforts of the Secretary-General. and the historic importance of the accords
and to commend once again the efforts of the parties concerned that led to the
successful conclusion of difficult negotiations. Recently, the United Nations Good
Offices Mission in Afghanistan and Pakistan (DNG@IAP) witnessed the complete
withdrawal of Soviet troops from Afghanistan in accordance with the Geneva accords,
which is of crucial importance to the just and comprehensive settlement of the
problem.
During the discussions held in the Security Council last Tuesday and again
today we have heard allegations of violations of the Geneva accords. Japan would
be gravely concerned if such violations were actually being committed and urges all
the parties concerned to observe and fulfil their obligations under the accords.
However, if the issue under consideration is, in fact, violations of the Geneva
accords, we cannot but question the appropriateness of discussing it here today l
First, as is clear to everyone, the Geneva accords provide a mechanism for settling
disputes. We understand that, having received complaints from both sides, UNGCMAP
is duly conducting its detailed investigations. It is therefore important that we
carefully refrain from having discussions that could affect the impartiality of
UNQDMAP’s own investigations - and the integrity of the Geneva accords, for that
matter. The Government of Japan 1OOkS forward to a report that UNGCMAP will. submit
(Mr. Kagami, Japan)
in due course to the Secretary-General and the parties concerned so that it may
help bring an early settlement of the problem.
The ultimate objective of the Geneva accords was to attain self -determination
by the Afghan people without outside interference so that they may live in lasting
peace under a truly representative government. Therefore, if lasting peace is to
be restored in Afghanistan it is essential that a broad-based government that truly
represents the people of Afghanistan should be established and take over ruling the
country. Japan re.iterates its appeal to States and relevant international
organisations to intensify their efforts in their respective capacities for the
achievement of such a goal.
Until peace and unity are restored in Afghanistan the suffering of the Afghan
refugees will continue. The Government of Japan sincerely hopes that the VOlUntarY
repatriation of refugees will be realised before long. In this respect I would
like to take this opportunity to reaffirm the intention of the Government of Japan
to continue its positive assistance, through the United Nations and other
international organisations, for the voluntary repatriation of refugees, in
consultation with the countries concerned. I also wish to express our sincere
appreciation for the enormous sacrifice and assistance that the Government of
Pakistan has rendered in the cause of self-determination and the welfare of the
Afghan people.
The PRESIDENT (interpretation from Russian) t I thank the representative
of Japan for his kind words addressed to me.
The next speaker is the representative of Democratic Yemen. I invite him to
take a place at the Council table and to make his statement.
Mr. AL-ASBTAL (Democratic Yemen) (interpretation from Arabic) f I wish at
the outset to congratulate you, Sit, on your assumption of the presidency of the < 5eCur fty Council for this month. I am convinced that, with your well-known
experience and courtesy , you will lead the Council’s deliberations to a successful
ooncl us ion. 1 should also like to take this opportunity to express my appreciation
to Her Excellency Ambassador Absa Claude Diallo, Permanent Representative of
Senegal, who skilfully presided over the Council during the month of March.
The international political climate is undoubtedly affected to varying degrees
W regional disputes, by their extent and by how close they come to turning into
regional - or, indeed, international - crises. The crisis in Afghanistan, which
led to the convening of an emergency special session of the United Nations General
Assembly in early 1980, has had direct tepetcussions on the international political
climate, which began to deteriorate very tapidly thereafter. Indeed, the 1980s
were characterized by confrontation and tension on mote than one front and in more
than one region;
(Mr. Al-Ashtalr Democratic Yemen)
The beginning of the Afghan crisis caused
a clouding of the international
climate and a deterioration in international relations. Then ame the signing on
14 April 1988 by all parties Concerned of the Geneva accords for the settlement of
the crisis in Afghanistan , which marked the end of a period of international
confrontation and sharp dispute and the beginning of the settlement of
Afghanistan’s problems. The international mmmunity has giv.en the eneva accords
its blessing. The General Assembly WelCOmed those accords in its resolution of
3 November 1988, the first on Afghanistan to be adopted by consensus. ’
The General Assembly resolution provided the general framework for the
settlement of the situation in and around Afghanistan. In addition to welcoming
the Geneva Agreements and calling for their faithful implementation in letter and
spirit, the resolution set out the most important elements of the settlement. It
stressed the need for a full withdrawal of foreign forces in accordance with the
televant provisions of those accords, reiterated that the preservation of the
sovereignty, territorial integrity, political independence and non-aligned
character Of Afghanistan was essential; reaffirmed the fight of the Afghan people
to determine their own form of government free from outside intervention, and
called for. the creation of the necessary conditions of peace that would enable the
Afghan refugees to return to their homeland. The resolution further emphasized the
need for an intra-Afghan dialogue for the establishment of a broad-based government
to ensure the broadest support and immediate participation of all segments of the
Afghan. people.
What steps were then taken to implement the Geneva accords and the General
Assembly resolution? What are the political and military facts on the ground? How
can the Security Council participate in the creation of the necessary conditions of
peace that would enable the Afghan refugees to return in an atmosphere of national
(Mt. Al-Ashtal, Democratic Yemen)
. No one expected the situation in Afghanistan to be settled by mere agreement
among the parties concerned on the elements of such a settlement. The Geneva
accords were not the ideal result that would not leave any grounds for continuing
military struggle following the withdrawal of foreign forces. The same is true of
the General Assembly resolution. How can an atmosphere of peace be established
without a cease-fire? How can Afghan refugees return to their homeland unless
peace has been established? How can Afghan fadtions participate in a.dialogue, in
accordance with the General Assembly resolution, without a cease-fire? This is
most important. Acceptance of a cease-fire is the only indication of a certain
readiness to accept the status quo as a basis for negotiation among the warring
parties. More: acceptance of a cease-fire is the only indication that the
military option for the solving of the problem has reached's dead end.
It is no coincidence that the Afghan opposition forces and their allies wefe
the very ones who rejected any mention of a cease-fire in the Geneva accords or in
the resolution adopted by the General Assembly. They believed that the withdrawal
of foreign forces from Afghanistan would provide them with conditions for a quick
military success. However, it has become clear that the Afghan opposition
miscalculated. It miscalculated the balance of.power following the withdrawal of
foreign forces. It is regrettable that those supporting the opposition committed
the same error and that an opportunity has been lost to find an honourable solution
that would guarantee a balancing of internal and external interests.
Let us go back to the recent past. Let us see what happened on the ground
following the General Assembly's adoption of its resolution on the situation in
Afghanistan.
First, the foreign forces did withdraw from Afghanistan. The very last
soldier has left Afghanistan, in accordance with the Geneva accords.
I
(Mr. Al-Ashtal, Democratic Yemen)
e Secondly , despite the withdrawal of foreign forces from all Afghan territory
and the fact that they completely ceased all participation in the fighting, the
military situation in the country has changed only negligibly, without any. real
effect on the balance of power. The Afghan Government forces onntinue to control
most ci ties, including the capital, Kabul, and at the same time the opposition
forces control the countryside. So we see that the predictions of the iopposition
and its allies have not been borne out - they predicted that the Government forces
would not be able to resist their attack following the withdrawal of foreign
forces - even though the opposition massed considerable military Potential and used
it to break through governmental defences around Jelalabad. However they suffered
terrible losses in both lives and property 1 this is most regrettable. At the same
time, the military situation remains unchanged , with neither victor nor vanquished,
and wi th no way to settle the issue other than by peaceful means. The military
option is finished as a solution. It will, however, remain a means for
destruction.
Thirdly, it is regrettable that the Afghan opposition made a second
miscalculation. Following its failure to enter the cities and to control the
capital, and the rest of the country for that matter , the opposition has now fallen
back on a second sterile attempt: to use political means to achieve what military
means have failed to achieve. Instead of resorting to teason and accepting the
principle of dialogue among all Afghan factions without exception in an atmosphere
of peace and with a cease-fire, the opposition has proclaimed the establishment of
a government, claiming it represents the entire Afghan People when in fact it
represents not even the entire opposition. E’utthetmore, it has totally ignored the
legi tfmate Government and other independent factions.
The siege to which some Afghan cities are being laid, inoluding( the capital,
(Mr. Al-Ashtal, Democratic Yemen)
forces-. Similar to the case in Afghanistan, the siege of San's followed the
withdrawal of Egyptian forces that had come to the aid of the Yemeni revolution and
its republican Government. The siege of San'a, which started in January 1968,
continued for more than 70 days, during which the whole population of the city -
men, women and children - put up a heroic opposition that ended with the siege
broken and the enemy routed; even though the closest friend of the republican
Government was thousands of miles away. So what is the situation concerning Kabul
and the other Afghan cities?
We can only appeal to all parties for reason and dialogue. We hope this
Council will be able to reinforce the General Assembly resolution by calling for a
cease-fire.
I thank the representative
of Demcratic Yemen for the kind words he addressed to me.
i . .
Mr. PICKERING (United States of America) t I should like to begin by
congratulating you., sir, on your assumption of the great responsibilities of the
office of President of the Security Council. I am sure that you will discharge
these respons ib ili ties wi th fairness , efficiency and good order.
As the new boy on the block, so to speak, I arrived just as Ambassador
Absa Claude Diallo was relinquishing her duties as President of the Security
Council. On my own behalf and on that of my delegation I should like to thank her
for the superb way in which she carried out her responsibilities as President.
If I may be permitted a few personal words before launching into my statement,
I should like to thank you, Mr. President, and dll the other members of the Council
who have welcomed me so warmly. It is with a great sense of responsibility that I
take up my duties in representing my country here. It is some thing of a
disappointment to me that my first statement in the Council should be in a debate
so little promise of constructive on an issue and on an occasion when there is
activity.
For the last 10 years the Government of
the United States has followed with
great concern the situation in Afghanistan.
There has been tragic Suffering as the
Afghan people have fought for their freedom from fqreign coercion and control. The
signing of the Geneva accords one year ago was a major breakthrough, for it led to
the withdrawal of Soviet troops - whose presence the international community
continually and rightly condemned.
t a My Gxernment’s policy towards Afghanistan is simple and straightforward: it
, is designed to uphold, above all, the principle that the Afghan people themselves
must be allowed to determine their own future , without outside interference or
coercion. The condi tions must be created for the Afghan people to be able to carry
out a’ true act of self-determination. The illegitimate Uabul re’gime is ndw intent
on impeding this process as it tries to retain its waning grip on< Afghanistan.
(Mr. Pickering, United States)
. Unfortunately, the present process here in the Council appears to be being used by
that same re'gime as part of such an effort.
l
Throughout their history the Afghan people have successfully fought off
invaders. The fight against the most recent attempt at foreign domination has been
long and hard. By defending their sovereignty the Afghan people have earned the
fight to choose their destiny. The United States strongly supports their desire to
make their own decisions about their future now that Soviet force's have left.
After their long struggle, we do not believe that the Afghan people would be
receptive to unwarranted interference by outside forces.
There is a proper role for the international community to play, of course. It
is to Continue to Support the Afghan people's desire to ChOOSe their own
government, to provide assistance to the refugees to return home in safety and with
honour and to help rebuild the country once stability and peace are achieved.
At this time, there are several United Nation6 mechanisms in place to deal
with the problems this conflict has created. The United States supports them
fully. However, the United States will oppose any attempt to use these mechanisms
to perpetuate the illegitimate re'gime in Kabul or to impose a -political settlement
on the Afghan people. I
The United Nations is playing an important humanitarian role for the Afghan
people. Teaching refugees how to recognize mines, laid in reckless fashion by
i Sov-iet and-Kabul forces, will save many lives. We hope that the Soviet Union and 1
Kabul will see fit to turn over to the United Nation6 maps Showing the location Of
their minefields, particularly in the vast areas which are now free from Kabul's
control, so that the clearance of mines can begin and the refugee6 return to their
homes. 'The appointment of Prince Sadtuddin to lead the involvement of United
Nations specialized agencies in providing assistance to refugees will help'
(Mr. Pickering , United States)
In this debate the Security Council has heard many charges against Pakistan, a
nation that has sacrificed so much to help care for and feed millions of Afghan R refugees, the world’s largest refugee population. There is no need for me to
cxJmme.nt at length on these spurious allegations. They have already been eloquently
refuted by the representative of Pakistan. I will note, however, that the United
States views with great concern theintroduction of Scud missiles, one of which was
fired into Pakistan in recent days. This attack illustrates the desperate measures
Kabul is prepared to use to stave off the inevitable.
With regard to a cease-f ire, my Government believes that this issue can only
be decided by the Afghan people themselves.
The United States does not believe that the Security Council can or should at
this time take a more prominent role in Afghanistan unless the Afghan people
themselves and all of the Afghan parties should actively seek greater Council
involvement. We hope that Afghanistan will soon enjoy true peace, stability and
the opportunity for its people to determine their own future.. The conflict has
been a long and arduous one. It took over nine years before Soviet troops were
withdrawn . Esow they have been gone only two months. The Afghan people should now
decide freely and for themselves how they wish to be governed. They must be
permitted to find the common denominator or understanding that allcws them to
restore a purposeful, cohesive national political life.
. The United Wations has played a useful and supportive role. Now is the time
for the United Nations to support and assist the Afghan people in their efforts to ’
achieve full self*etetmination. It is not the time to impose a specific future
political configuration upon them. They have won the right, through ma jot
sacrifices and suffering, to determine their own future. They should have our
support in doing so. r
I thank the representative
of the United States of America for his kind words to me.
There are no further speakers inscribed on my list for this meeting. The next
meeting of the Security Council to continue the consideration of the item on the
agenda will take place, in all probability, on Wednesday, 19 April 1989, in the
morning - if, of course, we ‘are successful in proceeding with the election of a
member of the International Court of Justice tomorrow.
The meeting rose at 12.50 p.m.
r
▶ Cite this page
UN Project. “S/PV.2853.” UN Project, https://un-project.org/meeting/S-PV-2853/. Accessed .