S/PV.2856 Security Council
In accordance with
decisions taken at the previous meetings on this item, 'I invite the Minister for
Foreign Affairs of Afghanistan and the representative of Pakistan to take places at
the Council table; I invite the representatives of Cuba, Democratic Yemen, the
German Democratic Republic, India, Japan, the Lao People's Democratic Republic,
Madagascar, Mongolia, Nicaragua, Saudi Arabia, the Syrian Arab Republic, Turkey,
the United Republic of Tanzania and Viet Nam to take the places reserved for them
at the side of the Council Chamber.
At the invitation of the President, Mr. Wakil (Afghanistan) and Mr. Inner.
(Pakistan) took places at the Council table; Mr. Oramas Oliva (Cuba), Mr. Al-Ashtal
(Democratic Yemen), Mr. Zachmann (German Democratic Republic), Mr. Gharekhan
(India), Mr. Kagami (Japan), Mr. Kittikhoun (Lao People's Democratic -Republic),
'Mr. Rabetafika (Madagascar), Mr. Dugersuren (Mongolia), Mr. Serrano Caldera
(Nigaragua), Mr. Shihabi (Saudi Arabia), Mr. Al-Masri (Syrian Arab Republic),
The PRESIDmT (interpretation from Russian): I should like to inform the
Council that I have received letters from the representatives of Angola, Bulgaria,
the Comoros and Iraq, in which they request to be invited to participate in the
discussion of the item on the Council's agenda. In conformity with 'the usual
practice, I propose, with the consent of the Council, to invite those
representatives to participate in the discussion without the right to vote , in
accordance with the relevant provisions of the Charter and rule 37 of the Council's
provisional rules of procedure.
There being no objection, it is so decided.
At the invitation of the President, Mr. Diakenga Serao (Angola), Mr. Stresov
(Bulgaria), Mr. Moumin (Comoros) and Mr. Sumaida (Iraq) took the places reserved
for them at the side of the Council,Chamber.
The Security COUnCil will
now resume its consideration of the item on its agenda.
I should like to draw the attention of members of the Council to document
S/20585, which contains the text of a letter dated 12 April 1989 from the Charge'
d'affaires ad interim of the Permanent Mission of Afghanistan to the United Nations
addressed to the President of the Security Council.
The first speaker is the representative of the Lao People's Democratic
Republic. I invite him to take a place at the Council table and to make his
statement.
Mr. KITTIKI33I.N (Lao People's Democratic Republic)(interpretation from
French): The delegation of the Lao People's Democratic Republic is delighted to
see presiding over the Security Council's work this month a son of the Soviet
Union, a country with which we have excellent relations of friendship, fraternity
and multifaceted co-operation. Aware as we are, Sir, of your outstanding qualities
as a diplormt, your wisdom and your profound knowledge of international affairs, we
are sure that the Council's present deliberations will be successful. My
delegation would also like to congratulate Ambassador Absa Claude Diallo, the
Permanent Representative of Senegal, for the competent manner in which she guided
the Council's work during the month of March. We also want to take this
opportunity to extend our sincere thanks to the members of the Council for having
kindly agreed to our request to speak here on this important issue involving
international peace and security that is nw before the Council.
The diplomatic process begun by the United Nations Secretary-General and the
continuing efforts made by all parties concerned to resolve the Afghan problem led
last year to the signing of the Geneva Agreements , which was warmly welccmed by a
gratified international oommunity. Those accords, which were the result of a long
and arduous endeavour, were siqned by the Republic of Afghanistan and the Islamic
Republic of Pakistan, with the two great Pwers, the Soviet Union and the United
States of America, as guarantors, and under the auspices of the United Nations
Secretary-General. They are an edifying achievement of the United Nations
machinery for the peaceful settlement of disputes; they have thus opened the way to
a comprehensive settlement of the situation in Afghanistan and in the region.
After the signing of the accords, the Soviet Union and the Republic of
Afghanistan dedicated themselves to their strict implementation. In accordance
with the accords, on 15 February of this year the withdrawal of Soviet troops from
Afghanistan was completed. Such.strict respect for the time-table set forth in the.
Geneva accords, which was welcomed by the international community and valued by the
United Nations, attests to the Soviet Union's sincerity and to its clear resolve to
settle the problem by peaceful means. However, it is most regrettable that, for
well-known political motives, the other signatory countries of the accords have
seen fit not to discharge their international obligations. Military bases for the
training of armed extremist Afghan groups on foreign territory have been enlarged;
the participation of foreign advisers and experts specializing in terrorist
activities has become much more active - in short, foreign interference in the
internal affairs of Afghanistan has not come to an end but has, on the contrary,
been seriously stepped up. The tense situation in Afghanistan has not only failed
to diminish, it has become increasingly dangerous for both the Afghan people and
for peoples in other countries of the region.
The Afghan people, like all the other peoples of the world, are entitled to
peace so that they can rebuild their war-torn homeland. Those who once invoked the
presence of foreign troops in Afghanistan as a strong pretext for their
interference in Afghan affairs are today continuing to conceal their
interventionist policies by resorting to other pretexts. Instead of promoting
inter-Afghan dialogue to achieve the national reconciliation begun by the'
legitimate Government of the Republic of Afghanistan , as requested by the United
Nations General Asser&ly at its forty-third session, those circles have in fact
encouraged the armed Afghan extremists to opt for military methods and to gain
power by force and violence. It is deeply deplorable that bloodshed and a
fratricidal war that pits Afghans against Afghans shoiild be used to implement a
political policy.
The present situation, as it is emerging, is undoubtedly prejudicial to the
Geneva accords, to the resolutions adopted by the Conference of Ministers of
(Mr. Kittikhoun, Lao People's Democratic Republic)
Foreign Affairs of the Non-Aligned Movement and to the resolutions adopted by the
United Nations General Assembly at its forty-third session. If nothing is done to
remedy it, the situation could degenerate into a widespread regional conflict. The
international community must do all it can to defuse this tense situation and to
find a political solution to the Afghan problem. At a time when de'tente and
dialogue continue to prevail in international relations, it is difficult to
understand the motives of those who continue to advocate the use of force to
resolve the conflict in Afghanistan. Far from contributing to a peaceful
settlement of the problem, the formation of a so-called interim government on
foreign soil, one that has in fact been challenged by other armed opposition
groups, can only aggravate it further. This is a not a time to shed more Afghan
blood but, rather, a time to help the Afghan people towards reconciliation and'to
settle their conflict by peaceful means.
It is clear from the evidence that aggression and acts of foreign interference
in the internal affairs of the Republic of Afghanistan, in particular in the wake
of the complete withdrawal of the Soviet Union's reduced military contingents, have
intensified. In the view of the Lao delegation, it is up to the Security Council,
which is entrusted'with the maintenance of international peace and security, to
take the necessary steps to forestall the dangerous consequences of such acts of
aggression and interference.
(Mr. Kittikhoun, Lao People's Uenocratic Republic)
The long-suffering Afghan people has already endured too much, and everything
must be done to put an end to.this senseless fratricidal war among the Afghans
which is being promoted from outside. The recent deadly battle around the city'bf
Jalalabad, which left thousands of dead and wounded, clearly demonstrated that
there can be no military method in the quest for a solution to the Afghan
conflict. The sooner contacts and dialogue are established.among Afghans within
the country and outside, the sooner there will be a chance to restore peace in that
country, to the greater interests of peace and stability in the region and in the
world.
In this context, the delegation of the Lao People's Democratic Republic
welcomes the policy of national reconciliation proclaimed by the Government of the
Republic of Afghanistan and appeals to the international community to make an
active contribution towards the success of this.inter-Afghan dialogue. In this new
era of de'tente and international co-operation, the Afghan problem, like all other
regional conflicts, requires a political and not a military solution. It is only
this course of action that can allow the Afghan people to restore the peace it-so
needs in order to rebuild their country.
The'PRESIDENT (interpretation from Russian): I thank the representative
of the Lao People's Democratic Republic for his kind words addressed to the Soviet
Union and to me personally.
The next speaker is the representative of Nicaragua. I invite him to take a
place at the Council table and to make his statement. .
Mr. SmRANO CALDERA (Nicaragua) (interpretation from Spanish): MaY 1
congratulate you, Sir, on your assumption of the presidency of the .Security Council
for the month of April. My delegation is gratified that the representative of a
country with which'we have a great friendship and mutual respect is guiding the
(Mt. Kittikhoun, Lao People's Democratic Republic)
At the same time I should like to express our appreciation to the Ambassador
of Senegal, Her Excellency Ambassador Absa Claude Diallo, for having conducted the , work of the Council last month in a way that enhanced the prestige of her country. -$-
Nicaragua is addressing the Council convinced more than ever that strict
compliance with international law, non-interference in the internal affairs of
other States, respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity and the non-use of
force in international relations must always govern relations among countries,
above all at a time as delicate and significant as the present. There can be no
substitute for the principles and purposes of the Charter of the United Nations,
and their defence is the responsibility of the international community.
l'bgether with the international community, Nicaragua warmly welcomed the
Geneva accords, on the understanding that the Afghan people would be free to forge
its own destiny in an atmosphere of freedom on the basis of its own national
interests. We regret the course of events and deplore the fact that two friendly
non-aligned countries are in a state of confrontation and that interference from
outside the region continues in Afghan affairs.
The Geneva accords are a reflection of the letter and spirit of the United
Nations Charter and were signed precisely with the purpose of achieving a
comprehensive settlement of the situation in Afghanistan and guaranteeing that
peace and security in the region would be strengthened. The signing of these
accords was achieved, taking into account the interests of the Afghan people
themselves and of the various parties involved in the conflict. Article II of the
accords is very clear in stipulating that the contracting parties must refrain from
concluding agreements or settlements with other States whose goal might be
interference or intervention in their internal and external affairs. The use of
. .
(Mr. Serrano Caldera, Nicaragua)
force in any form with a view to disrupting the political, social or economic
order, or to overthrow or change the system of any one of them, is prohibited.
Similarly, the statement signed by the Governments of the United States of
America and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics stipulates, among other things,
respect for the commitments contained in the bilateral agreements between the
Republics of Afghanistan and Pakistan, the principles that must govern mutual
relations, in particular, non-interference and non-intervention. This represents a
commitment on the part of the two super-Powers , which both have the obligation to
fulfil.
,It is well kncwn that, in fulfilment of the agreements, the Union of Soviet
Socialist Republics completely withdrew its troops from Afghanistan - an undeniable
contribution to the negotiation of an agreement between the Cbvernment of the
Republic of Afghanistan and the opposition for the establishment of a government of
national reconciliation.
Unfortunately, these accords have not been completely fulfilled by all the
parties. On the contrary, in violation of the letter and spirit of the .agreements,
military aid is still being promoted and provided to the irregular forces, thus
encouraging the continuation of military action, which has already caused great
suffering to the Afghan people and which hinders efforts to achieve a political and
negotiated solution to the situation.
In fulfilment of the Geneva accords , not only the prestige and interests of
the countries directly involved in the conflict are at stake, but also those of the
international community, because the political will of States to find political and
negotiated solutions to resolve conflicts is being put to the test - and two of
those States are permanent members of the Security Council.
(Mr. Serrano Caldera, Nicaragua)
Throughout this debate we have listened attentively to statements of support
for the right to self-determination and on the need for the Afghan people to
determine its own fate without any coercion or foreign interference. We have also
heard the request made to the international community to play a more active role in
support of the Afghan people both in the repatriation of refugees and in the
reconstruction of the country itself. But deeds must be matched by words in order
to be consistent with the letter of the Geneva accords.
My delegation, which unreservedly supports the role of the United Nations in
the maintenance of international peace, believes that the emplacement of the United
Nations Good Offices Mission in Afghanistan and Pakistan (UNCDMAP) at border areas
of Afghanistan would contribute to easing tensions and to putting an end to this
terrible war. In this way the necessary conditions would also be created for the
Afghan people to choose, without coercion and without interference, their own
leaders within a policy of national reconciliation.
I thank the representative
of Nicaragua for the kind words he addressed to the Soviet Union and to me
personally.
Mr. TAUESSE (Ethiopia): At the outset let me convey to you, Sir, my
delegation’s congratulations on your assumption of the presidency of the Security
Council for the month of April. Your quality of leadership, as demonstrated by
your handling of critical issues in the last three weeks, is ample evidence of the
wisdom and the rich experience you bring to the Council. It is therefore a
pleasure for me to assure you of our confidence in you as President and of our full ‘. co-operation in the discharge of the high responsibilities you have assumed.
(Mr. Serrano Caldera, Nicaraqua)
I also seize this opportunity to express our satisfaction and heartfelt
appreciation to our sister the Permanent Representative of Senegal, Ber Excellency
Ambassador Absa Claude Diallo, for the sagacity with which she conducted the
affairs of the Council during her presidency last month.
It was with a collective sigh of relief that the international Community
learned last year, on 14 April , of the signing of the Agreements on the settlement
of the situation relating to Afghanistan. Indeed it was one of the landmark
achievements aimed at bringing an end to the human suffering caused by the
decade-long fratricidal conflict within that country. As the instruments
comprising the settlement were the product of painstaking negotiations that began
in 1982, there was great hope that, on their entry into force and their scrupulous
observance by all sides, the situation in Afghanistan would change for the better.
It is with this same conviction that the General Assembly at its forty-third
session also welcomed the conclusion of these Agreements as constituting "an
important step towards a comprehensive political solution of the Afghanistan
problem".
This week the international community witnessed the first anniversary of the
signing of the Geneva accords. mday, we all know that if these accords have
brought a change in the Afghan situation it is only in the withdrawal of foreign
forces, whose presence in that country was a matter of serious controversy, with
grave ramifications in super-Power relations. In full compliance with the
provisions of the accords the Soviet Union has withdrawn its forces. But the
situation in Afghanistan still remains critical.
Since the expected intra-Afghan dialogue for the establishment of a
broad-based government has not yet materialized, the mountains and fields of
Afghanistan continue to be a theatre of armed conflict between the forces of the
(Mr. Tadesse, Ethiopia)
Government and the opposition groups. It is unfortunate that neither the
objectives of the Agreements nor the various political and diplomatic initiatives
in various capitals seem to exert any pressure to bear on the armed opposition to
talk peace and not war. Because of this and the opposition's bent on overthrowing
the Afghan Government or attempt at excluding it from any political process aimed
at determining the country's future, the flames of conflict and war are being kept
alive.
In the view of the opposition, dialogue is not being seen as a matchless
alternative to the blood-letting. Only recently, by rejecting the proposed
cease-fire on the occasion of Ramadan, the opposition has, regrettably, once again
demonstrated its choice of a military solution to Afghanistan's problem. We trust
that nobody in his right mind will condone this situation involving massive
destruction and loss of lives as politically expedient and morally justifiable;
The plight of Afghanistan demands urgent measures that would facilitate a
speedy cease-fire and create conditions for a peaceful resolution of the problem.
In our view the Geneva accords , on the basis of which the withdrawal of foreign
forces was effected, coupled with the resolution of the General Assembly adopted by
consensus at the forty-third session , continue to provide conditions for peace
talks among Afghans with a view to enabling them to decide their own future without
any foreign interference or intervention.
A close look at the continuing crisis in Afghanistan compels us to make the
following three observations:
First, the intransigence of the opposition groups to enter into a cease-fire
agreement and initiate dialogue among Afghans themselves, the Government of
Afghanistan included, stands as a major obstacle to national reconciliation and the
restoration of peace and security 'to the people of Afghanistan.
(Mr. Tadesse, Ethiopia)
Secondly, the failure of some of the parties to adhere scrupulously to the
provisions of the Geneva accords is a problem that needs to be appropriately
addressed, so that the momentum created by the implementation of some of the
provisions of the accords will not be lost.
Thirdly, the guarantors to the Geneva accords, as permanent members of the
Security Council and in view of their broad responsibilities in global affairs,
need to re-examine the present failure in the interest of their credibility and
their important role in the international ajmmunity.
We do. not believe recriminations would bring change in the already-polarized
and deteriorating situation in Afghanistan. As we are considering this question,
it should be recognised that human lives and property continue to be destroyed
while many people are still compelled to live in exile. In light of this, the
minimum the people of Afghanistan expect is the restoration of normalcy to the
country.
(Mr4 Tadesse, Ethiopia)
Since we started this debate in the Security Council, despite the divergent
views of the concerned parties , we have been much encouraged that, given the
political will, the problem is not insurmountable. We are also heartened by the
fact that all the parties consider the Geneva Agreements still instrumental in
resolving the Afghan problem. The Security Council has also been informed that the
parties to the accords reject the use of force as a means for the settlement of
disputes in inter-State relations. Those are indeed positive elements.
Afghanistan and Pak'istan need to build on those positive elements in order to
change the present negative situation. In that spirit, we call on all the parties
to the Pqreements to honour their connnitments fully.
Afghanistan and its neighbours stand to gain from peace. In that respect, the
United Nations and the international community must see to it that the Pqreements
are observed by the parties. Towards this end, we support the request for the.
strengthening of the United Nations Good Offices Mission in Afghanistan and
Pakistan, including the manning of additional border posts on both sides, so that
the,Mission is enabled sufficiently to assume its responsibilities and help prevent
the further deterioration of the situation.
I thank the representative
of Ethiopia for his kind words addressed to me.
The next speaker is the representative of Viet Nam. I invite him to take a
place at the Council table and to make his statement.
Mr. NCXJYEN DUC RUNG (Viet Nam): I should like at the outset to convey to
you, Comrade President, and to all the other members of the Security Council my
Fmbassador's apology for not being able to be here today to make his statement,
owing to the poor state of his health. I shall therefore make the statement on his
behalf at these very important Council meetings .
(Mr. Tadesse, Ethiopia)
I have the honour to convey to you, Comrade President, my Ambassador's and my
own congratulations on your assumption of the presidency of the Security Council.
The delegation of Viet Nam would like to express its firm confidence that the
Council, under your skilful and able guidance , will proceed with its work
successfully. .The Soviet Union, which you represent, is highly valued.for its
great contributions to the cause of international peace and security.
My delegation also takes this opportunity to express its appreciation to your
predecessor, I&r Excellency Mrs. Absa Claude Diallo, for the outstanding manner in
which she conducted the Council's business last month.
AYear ago, the Geneva accords on Afghanistan were signed after a long,
arduous and difficult diplomatic process , and we all welcomed the event with
enthusiasm and expectations. Since their signing, we have all hoped that a
comprehensive settlement in and around Afghanistan would be achieved, and that.
peace and good-neighbourliness would be ensured, thus eventually ending a decade of
tension and confrontation and thereby beginning a new chapter in the relations
among the countries of the region. In strict observance of these Pqreements and
with goodwill -the Government of the Republic of Afghanistan has since pursued a
policy of national reconciliation and been making every effort for ensuring the
region's peace and security. Likewise, in accordance with the Geneva accords the
Soviet Union completed the withdrawal of its troops from Afghanistan on
15 February 1989, as scheduled , and it has taken actions to fulfil its
commitments. All other provisions of the Geneva accords would have been fulfilled
had all the other parties concerned pursued the same efforts of goodwill and
responsibility and refrained from doing anything that could hamper the sovereignty,
independence and territorial integrity of Afghanistan and the peace and security of ,
the region. Regrettably, that has not been the case.
It is most alarming that the recent acts of interference and military
intervention in the internal affairs of the Republic of Afghanistan have acquired
an ever increased intensification and ever more dangerous and wider dimensions. In
fact, those acts of interference have changed from the imposed undeclared war of
the past 10 years into a war of aggression against that sovereign country. Aiming
at fanning the flames of the armed conflict, opposition extremists, with
encouragement and arms supplies extended from outside, have pushed forward the
fratricidal war in Afghanistan to an ever more grave and fiercer level, against the
aspirations of the Afghan people as well as the interests of peace and security in
the region. The recent creation of a so-called interim Government of Afghanistan
in a foreign land is of no legality and only serves to prolong the bloodshed and
increase the complexities of the situation and instability in the region.
At the same time, foreign territory continues to be used for the military.
training of the opposition groups, for the stockpiling and transfer of weapons and
ammunitions and as a springboard for interference and aggression against the
Republic of Afghanistan. All those acts run wholly counter to the provisions of
the Geneva accords and must be condemned and put to an end by all possible and
effective measures.
Faced with this situation, the Government of the Republic of Afghanistan has
time and again appealed for a settlement through political means, for national
reconciliation and for strict observance of the Geneva accords. In his letter of
10 March 1989 to the guarantors of the Geneva accords and to the United Nations
Secretary-General the President of the Republic of Afghanistan has urged that every
necessary measure‘be taken in order to prevent a further deterioration of the
situation. The Soviet Government has also called upon the Secretary-General and
(Mr. Nguyen Due Hung, Viet Nam)
the United States to take effective measures, as a matter of urgency, to put an end
to foreign intervention in Afghanistan and thereby implement the Cianeva accords in
their entirety. Only a political settlement to the situation will benefit the
peoples of the region as well as international peace and security. It is
necessary, in this context, to reiterate General Assembly resolution 43/20, which
was adopted by consensus, whereby the General Assembly earnestly called for the
scrupulous respect for and faithful implementation of the Geneva accords by all the
parties concerned, who should fully abide by their letter and spirit.
(Mr. Nguyen Uuc Hung, Viet Nam)
The Vietnamese people, bound to the Afghan people by close relations of
friendship, fully share their grave concern over the recent developments resulting
from those acts of interference and aggression and demand that they be prevented
and stopped forthwith. At this moment the people and Government of Viet Nam, as
always, extend their fraternal solidarity and whole-hearted support to the people
and Government of the Republic of Afghanistan in the heroic defence of their
homeland. We support the appeal made in the 10 March 1989 letter from the
President of the Republic of Afghanistan and the proposals put forward in the
statement before this Council by the Minister for Foreign Affairs,
Mr. Abdul'Wakil. A solution to the domestic issues of Afghanistan can be achieved
only through peaceful negotiations among the Afghan opposing groups aimed at
national reconciliation, the cessation of bloodshed and the establishment of a
broad-based government acceptabie to all concerned - as has been proposed by the
Republic of Afghanistan.
It is our hope that these appeals will be met with a constructive response
from the parties concerned. It is also our hope that the Council ‘6 deliberations,
which the Republic of Afghanistan has called for with high responsibility. and with
a view to achieving a political settlement , will result in tne Council's taking
effective measures to fulfil the task entrusted to it - that is, to maintain peace
and security.
I thank the representative
of Viet Nam for the kind words he addressed to me and my country.
The next speaker is tie representative of Comoros. I invite him to take a
place at the Council table and to make his statement.
Mr. MOT.MIN (Comoros): It gives me great pleasure to express my
delegation's congratulations to you, Sir, on your assumption of the presidency of
the Security Council for the current month. Your diplomatic skills and wisdom, as
well as the deep respect most of us have for your country's role in and
contribution to the solution of many .international problems, including the question
under discussion, will ensure a successful conclusion of the Council's
deliberations.
Let me also take this opportunity of expressing the profound appreciation of
'my delegation for the exemplary manner in which Ambassador Absa Claude Diallo of
Senegal guided.the deliberations of the Security Council last month.
Since this is the first time I have addressed the Security CCUnCil this year!
I should like to convey my delegation's warm congratulations to the new members of
the Council and wish them every success in carrying out the important
responsibilities they have assumed.
This debate coincides with the first anniversary of the signing of the Geneva
Agreements on the question of Afghanistan. My delegation is amazed at the
coincidence. But is it mere coincidence or is there something more to it? That is
a $1 million question to which my delegation has not yet been able to get a
mnvincing answer.
Having said that, my delegation would like.to avail itself of this opportunity
of the first anniversary of the Geneva Agreements 'on Afghanistan to commend the
parties to them. There can be no doubt that the conclusion of the Agreements
constituted an important step towards the very-much-desired political solution of
the Afghanistan problem.
demands by the international community demands by the international community for the for the
After 10
years of persistent
Afghanistan, at long last, on 14 April Afghanistan, at long last, on 14 April 1988, 1988,
withdrawal of
foreign forces from
under the auspices of the United Nations, Agreements
which the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics agreed
Afghanistan. By 15 February 1989 the withdrawal had
It is in order for one to state that with the conclusion of the Geneva
Agreements on 14 April 1988 and the completion of the Soviet troop withdrawal on
15 February 1989, the external aspects of the Afghanistan situation were
successfully addressed.
Hence the situation in Afghanistan has changed its status. It has ceased to
be a question of foreign aggression and interference and has become a question of
an internal struggle by the Afghan people for the restoration of their national and
human rights - a purely internal matter which does not come within the ambit of
Article 34 and Article 35.(l) of the United Nations Charter. Consequently my
delegation is inclined to support the views of Ambassador Shihabi of Saudi Arabia,
who rightly stated that the Council's deliberation on this issue
"is a case in which both the plaintiff and the substance of the complaint lack
legitimacy and in which competence does not rest with the body to which the
complaint is being made". (S/PV.2853, p. 11)
@ delegation was greatly impressed by the able manner in which the Permanent
Representative of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics presented his arguments
against Pakistan at the Council's last meeting. We noted with keen interest that
all his allegations are based on violations of the Geneva Agreements - allegations
which I must admit, if proven , must constitute a source of grave concern to my
delegation. However, if the issue under consideration is in fact nothing but
allegations of violations of the Geneva Agreements, then my delegation cannot but
agree with the representative of Japan's questioning of the appropriatenessof this
debate.
(Mr. Moumin, Comoros)
were concluded in Geneva by
to withdraw its forces from
been ccmpleted.
Surely the Geneva Agreements must have.provisions that envisage a mechanism
for the settlement of disputes arising from the Agreements. Furthermore it is,our
understanding that the United Nations Good Offices Mission in Afghanistan and
Pakistan (UNaMAP) has been seized of the matter and is duly conducting a detailed
investigation. It would therefore be prudent for the Council to refrain from
engaging in a discussion that might affect the impartiality of UNalMAP's own
investigation.
Manoeuvring to convene the Council for propaganda purposes will not help to
bring the needed peace to war-torn Afghanistan.
The crux of the matter in this tragic continuation of the conflict in
Afghanistan is the consequence of the continuing denial to the Afghan people of
their right to self-determination. We believe that peace and stability can be
restored to Afghanistan only with the establishment of a broad-based government
acceptable to the Afghan people. The establishment of such a government, which is
the exclusive prerogative of the Afghans themselves, was acknowledged in the Geneva
Agreements and in General Assembly consensus resolution 43/20 of 3 November 1988;
that resolution, inter alia, mandated the Secretary-General to facilitate the
establishment of a broad-based government.
The time has come to heal the grievous wounds inflicted on Afghanistan. The
Afghan people, who for nearly 10 years have borne incalculable suffering, cannot be
expected to accept a rdgime that for 10 years have given them nothing but suffering
and destruction. The situation in Afghanistan can be resolved only when a
comprehensive political settlement in accordance with the wishes of the Afghan
nation has been achieved and a broad-based government, fully representative of the
Afghan people, has been established in that country.
(Mr. Moumin, Comoros)
The PRESIDmT (interpretation from Russian): I thank the representative
of the Comoros for the kind words he addressed to me.
The next speaker is the representative of Iraq. I invite him to take a place
at the Council table and to make his statement.
Mr. SIMAlDA (Iraq) (interpretation from Arabic): Allow me at the outset
to convey to you, Sir, my delegation's congratulations on your assumption of the
presidency of the Security Council for April. This month always reminds us of the
great Treaty of friendship concluded 19 years ago, in April, between Iraq and the
Soviet Union. Your rich experience and diplomatic skill guarantee success in the
Council's work this month.
I should also like to express my delegation's appreciation to
Ambassador Absa Claude Diallo of friendly Senegal for the very efficient and
successful anduct of the business of the Council last month.
When the international community is faced with the task of deciding whether a
step is correct or erroneous , or whether a cause is just or otherwise, it must use
the most important yardstick available to it - that is, the rules of international
law, the purposes and principles of the United Nations embodied in its Charter, and
United Nations resolutions, as well as commitments entered into in accordance with
international conventions, foremost among which is the commitment of all to refrain
from the use or threat of force against the sovereignty, territorial integrity or
political independence of any State.
Therefore, in addressing the situation in Afghanistan , my delegation wishes to
reaffirm the need to arrive at a peaceful settlement that ensures the independence,
sovereignty and non-aligned status of that friendly country. Any violation of the
sovereignty or independence of any State is a clear breach of the purposes and
principles of the United Nations Charter.
Since the beginning of the regrettable incidents, the position adopted -by Iraq
has been consonant with the interests of the Afghan people and the other peoples of
the region. It has always been in harmony with the positions taken by the
Non-Aligned t&?ement and United Nations resolutions. Iraq has thus proceeded from
the historic bonds that link the peoples of Iraq and Afghanistan and other
neighbouring peoples. In all forums Iraq has consistently supported the
sovereignty, independence, non-aligned status and territorial integrity of
Afghanistan as the basic conditions for a peaceful settlement of this question and
indispensable to ensuring the Afghan people's right freely to choose'its form of
government and its social , economic and political path free from any foreign
intervention.
The stability of the situation in Afghanistan is one of the most important
factors contributing to .the stability of the whole region and thus to the
prosperity and progress of its peoples and their ability to face development and
economic problems - all of which is of benefit to international peace and security
and the promotion of rapprochement and de'tente , which now prevail in international
relations, particularly in the field of the settlement of regional conflicts.
Having supported the Geneva accords signed on 14 April last between the
concerned parties, we call upon all parties to refrain from any act that might
render the problem more complex or intense. We call upon all patties to act in
accordance with the resolutions and principles of the United Nations and the
interests of the people of Afghanistan and the other peoples of the region and the
world. world.
The path of violence and continued conflict cannot lead to a just settlement The path of violence and continued conflict cannot lead to a just settlement
of the situation in Afghanistan. of the situation in Afghanistan. Proceeding from its faith in the positive Proceeding from its faith in the positive
principles of international relations and good-neighbourliness, Iraq calls upon the principles of international relations and good-neighbourliness, Iraq calls upon the
(Mr. Sumaida, Iraq)
international community to encourage all efforts aimed at the achievement of
national reconciliation in Afghanistan in order to save that country and its people
from further killings, destruction and displacement. Undoubtedly, the long years
of war have left a legacy of great tragedy for the people of Afghanistan and
destruction of its economy and in all areas of life. Like the rest of the peoples
of the world, the Afghan people has a right to dignified life in an-independent and
non-aligned State, and enjoyment of its full sovereignty and territorial integrity.
Therefore, recalling General Assembly resolution 43/20, adopted unanimously at
the forty-fifth meeting of this session , on 3 November 1988, my delegation believes
that the principles contained therein provide the necessary basis for all efforts
to end the tragedy afflicting the friendly people of Afghanistan. We reiterate our.
call to all parties to do their utmost to contain the dangers involved in the
situation and to enable the Afghan people to achieve national reconciliation in an
independent and non-aligned Afghanistan.
The PRESIDmT (interpretation from Russian')r I thank the representative
of Iraq for the kind words he addressed to me.
The next speaker is the representative of Bulgaria. I invite him to take a
place at the Council table and to make his statement.
Mr. STREHOV (Bulgaria): Comrade President, allow me first .to
congratulate you on your assumption of the presidency of the Security Council for
the current month and to wish you every success in your important work.
May I also express the deep appreciation of my delegation for the wise and
highly professional way in which Ambassador Absa Claude Dial10 of Senegal led the
work of the Council as President in the month of March.
(Mr. Sumaida, Iraq)
The time that has elapsed since the withdrawal of the Soviet troops from The time that has elapsed since the withdrawal of the Soviet troops from
Afghanistan has clearly shown that the people of Afghanistan and its legitimate Afghanistan has clearly shown that the people of Afghanistan and its legitimate
Government are fully in a position to defend the independence, sovereignty and Government are fully in a position to defend the independence, sovereignty and
territorial integrity of the country against attempts to promote a different course territorial integrity of the country against attempts to promote a different course
of events by means of war and aggression from abroad. of events by means of war and aggression from abroad.
(Mr. Stresov, Bulgaria) (Mr. Stresov, Bulgaria)
than ever it is necessary to utilise all opportunities to overcome
Now more
Afghanistan's
internal differences through peaceful means. In this respect, the
patience, consistency and determination of the Government of the Republic of 1
Afghanistan in steadily pursuing , even in these difficult moments, its policy of
national reconciliation should be welcomed and encouraged. The rejection of the
call for an immediate cease-fire as the basis for further peaceful steps towards a
settlement in the interest of all parties is to be deplored. Ill-advised political
manoeuvres, such as the recent establishment outside Afghanistan of a socalled
interim government - which, not surprisingly, has failed to gather the full support
even of those it claims to represent - and attempts to resolve the conflict by
force can only harm the chances for an early, just Andy viable settlement. The
armed extremists, recruited, based and trained abrOad, supplied from abroad and
encouraged by their supporters in the region and overseas# are carrying out a
further escalation of the military conflict. Continuing reports of direct foreign
involvement in the hostilities cannot but give rise to the most SeriOUS concern.
In his detailed statement on 11 April, His Excellency Mr. Abdul Wakil,
Minister for Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Afghanistan, brought t0 the
attention of the Council the grave situation which is developing as a result of the
increas-ing outside interference in the internal affairs of his country, a
full-fledged Member of the United Nations. The People's Republic of Bulgaria calls
for the immediate cessation of all such interference. These alarming developments
pose a tangible threat to peace and security in the region and the world. They
also run counter to the Geneva Agreements on Afghanistan of 14 April 1988. We
welcome the fact that the Republic of Afghanistan and the Union of Soviet.Socialist
' Republics are strictly honouring their part of the obligations stemming from the
Geneva %reements, and we invite all the other signatories to adopt the same
approach without further delay.
(Mr. Stresov, Bulgaria)
The United Wati'ons too has a vital role to play. The Security Council should
consider the uuestion before it with the utmost care and responsibility, as it is
mandated to do under the Charter of the United Nations with regard to matters
involving threats to international peace and security. All Member States should
endeavour to assist the United Nations in its efforts to ensure the efficient and
successful completion of the mandate of initiatives already under way, in
particular the United Nations Good Offices Mission in Afghanistan and Pakistan
(UNGXAP), with respect to the implementation of all aspects of the Geneva
Agreements.
We particularly welcome the valuable efforts of the Secretary-General and his
renewed
*commitment to continue to provide all assistance required by the Afghan
people for the early realization of a comprehensive , political solution in
Afghanistan as called for in General Assembly resolution 43/20".
(Press Release SG/SM/4286)
We support the proposals formulated in the statements of the Minister for
Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Afghanistan and the representative of tne USSR
concerning possible ways to overcome the present dangerous situation, in particular
the convening of an international conference on Afghanistan and the measures which
could be undertaken as the first steps leading to it.
As recently stated by the President of the State Council of the People's
Republic of Bulgaria, Mr. Tbdor Zhivkov , in a message (S/20588) to His Excellency
Mr. Najibullah, President of the Republic of Afghanistan, my country reiterates its
solidarity with the heroic struggle of the Afghan people and with the consistent
policy of the Government of the Republic of Afghanistan aimed at halting the
bloodshed and achieving the long-awaited peace on Afghan soil in an independent,
non-aligned and neutral Afghanistan.
(Mr. Stresov, Bulgaria)
'The PRESIDENT (interpretation from Russian)x I thank the representative
of Bulgaria for the kind words he addressed to me.
The next speaker is the representative of Angola. I invite him to take a
place at the Council table and to make his statement.
Mr. DIAKENCA SEIZED (Angola) (interpretation from French): Allow me first
of all, Sir, to congratulate you warmly on your assumption of the presidency of the
Security Council for the month of April. Our two countries enjoy excellent
relations, on which I need not dwell at length. Your professional qualities and
wisdom guarantee success in your noble and difficult tasks.
I take this opportunity also to pay a tribute to your predecessor,
Her Excellency Mrs. Absa Claude Diallo, Permanent Representative of Senegal to the
Dnited Nations, for the skill with which she guided the Council's work during the
month of March.
The alarming and worrisome facts of the situation around and within
Afghanistan, which is leading to a new escalation of the conflict in that country,
do not fulfil the hope felt by the international community when the Geneva accords
were signed on 14 April 1988.
We regret those facts, which could raise a new obstacle to settling the Afghan
question. We believe not only that the Geneva accords are a balanced set of
commitments accepted by all the parties, but also that they take into account the
varying interests of the parties. Hence only implementing those accords can ensure
'the beginning of a genuine dialogue among Afghans and the elimination of the
differences which pit Afghanistan against some of its neighbours. Implementation
would undoubtedly be a contribution to the peoples of the whole region. Moreover.,
it is demanded by the entire international community , which wishes the tragedy of
the Afghan people to come to an end.
, -
The Afghan conflict is a human tragedy and the entire international community
must work' to end it. My delegation considers the stubborn disregard of the \ constructive proposals of the Afghan Government displayed by the Afghan opposition
as an attempt to settle the question by warlike means. Such an attempt is in
defiance of the efforts that led to the conclusion of the Geneva Agreements, to
which the United Nations has given its total support. We also believe that the
support being given the Afghan opposition by certain Governments is putting off the
possibilities of establishing a lasting peace in that country.
There is little need to dwell upon the obligations that devolve upon the
parties to the Geneva Agreements, particularly that of respecting commitments
undertaken. Indeed, that is the only way to achieve peace and the only way to
sustain the judgement of posterity. The principle of respect for cormnitments
undertaken represents civilized values in international relations. It is therefore
absolutely necessary to pursue that course. In any event, the primary condition
for making progress in that direction is respect for the sovereignty of States and
non-interference in the internal affairs of other parties.
The Security Council, which embodies the international community's aspirations
with regard to the maintenance of peace and international security, must work to
bring all parties to agree to a peaceful process for settling the Afghan question
in order to spare the region a further escalation of the war. If the Council fails
to take advantage of the opportunity provided by the framework of the Geneva
Agreements on the situation in Afghanistan and if the Council allows the principle
of the primacy of force to prevail in the Afghan conflict, then international legal
principles, and particularly respect for commitments in international relations,
will be jeopardized. Moreover, such a situation will have negative repercussions,
and very serious ones, on the present positive trend that has emerged in the search
for negotiated solutions to other regional conflicts.
(Mr. Diakenga Serao, Angola)
In conclusion, my Government is in full solidarity with the Government and the
people of Afghanistan in their efforts to find a political and peaceful solution to
the Afghan problem, a solution, obviously, that will take fully into account the
sovereignty of that country.
The PRESIDlWT (interpretation from Russian): I thank the representative
of Angola for.his kind words addressed' to me.
There are no further speakers inscribed on my list for this meeting. The next
meeting of the Security Council to continue consideration of the item on its agenda
will take piace on Monday, 24 April 1989, at 10.30 a.m.
The meeting rose at 12.15 p.m.
I /-' ///
(Mr. Diakenga Serao, Angola)