S/PV.3060 Security Council
▶ This meeting at a glance
11
Speeches
0
Countries
1
Resolution
Resolution:
S/RES/746(1992)
Topics
Peace processes and negotiations
Security Council deliberations
War and military aggression
African conflict situations
UN procedural rules
Peacekeeping support and operations
I should like to
inform the Council that I have received letters from the representatives of
Italy, Kenya, Nigeria and Somalia, in which they request to be invited to
participate in the discussion of the item on the Council's agenda. In
conformity with the usual practice, I propose, with the consent of the
Council, to invite those representatives to participate in the discussion
without the right to vote, in accordance with the relevant provisions of the
Charter and rule 37 of the Council's provisional rules of procedure.
There being no objection, it is so decided.
At the invitation of the President, Ms. Hassan (Somalia) took a place at
the Council table: Mr. Traxler (Italy), Mr. Adala (Kenya) and Mr. Nwachukwu
(Nigeria) took the places reserved for them at the side of the Council Chamber.
Vote:
S/RES/746(1992)
Recorded Vote
✓ 15
✗ 0
0 abs.
I should like to
inform the Council that I have received a letter dated 17 March 1992 from the
Permanent Representative of Morocco to the United Nations, which reads as
follows:
(The President)
"I have the honour to request that the Security Council extend an
invitation to His Excellency Mr. Ahmet Engin Ansay, Permanent Observer of
the Organization of the Islamic Conference to the United Nations, to
address the Council under rule 39 of its provisional rules of procedure
in the course of the Council's consideration of the item entitled 'The
situation in Somalia’."
That letter will be published as a document of the Security Council under the
symbol S/23723. -
If I hear no objection, I shall take it that the Council agrees to extend
an invitation under rule 39 to Ambassador Ahmet Engin Ansay.
There being no objection, it is so decided.
I should like to inform the Council that I have received a letter dated
17 March 1992 from the Permanent Representative of Morocco to the United
Nations, which reads as follows:
"I have the honour to request that the Security Councii, in
accordance with rule 39 of its provisional rules of procedure, extend an
invitation te His Excellency Mr. Aboul Nasr, Permanent Observer of the
League of Arab States to the United Nations, in the course of the
Council’s consideration of the item entitled, ‘The situation in Somalia'."
That letter will be published as a document of the Security Council under the
symbol S/23724. a, aos
If I hear no objection, I shall take it that the Council agrees to extend
an invitation under rule 39 to Ambassador Aboul Nasr.
There being no objection, it is so decided.
The Security Council will now begin its consideration of the item on its
agenda. The Council is meeting in accordance with the understanding reached
in its prior consultations. Members of the Council have before them the
report of the Secretary-General on the situation in Somalia, contained in
document 8/23693 and Corr.1. Members of the Council also have before them
document S/23722, which contains the text of a draft resolution prepared in
the course of the Council's consulations. I should like to draw attention to
the following revisions to the provisional version of the draft resolution
contained in document §/23722. I shall read these texts in English.
(The President)
The new preamblular paragraph 7 would read as follows:
(spoke in English)
“Bearing in mind that the factors described in paragraph 76 of the
Secretary-General's report (S/23693) must be taken into account,", (spoke in Spanish)
The last preambular paragraph would read as follows:
(spoke _in English)
"Expressing its appreciation to the regional organizations,
including the Organization of African Unity, the League of Arab States
and the Organization of the Islamic Conference, for their cooperation
with the United Nations in the effort to resolve the Somali problem,". (spoke in Spanish)
Operative paragraph 2 would read as follows:
(spoke in English)
“Urges the Somali factions to honour their commitment under the
cease-fire agreements of 3 March 19923". (spoke in Spanish)
There would be a new operative paragraph 6, which would read as follows:
(spoke in English)
"Strongly supports the Secretary-General's decision urgently to
dispatch a technical team to Somalia, accompanied by the coordinator, in
order to work within the framework and objectives outlined in
paragraphs 73 and 74 of his report (S/23693) and to submit expeditiously
a report to the Security Council on this matter:".
(spoke in Spanish
There would be a new operative paragraph 7, which would read as follows:
(spoke in English)
"Requests that the technical team also develop a high priority plan
to establish mechanisms to ensure the unimpeded delivery of humanitarian
assistance;".
(spoke in Spanish)
The paragraph that would now be operative paragraph 10 would read as
follows:
(spoke in English)
"Calls upon all Somali parties, movements and factions to cooperate
fully with the Secretary-General in the implementation of the
resolution;:". (spoke _in Spanish)
Those are all the revisions to the text.
I should like to draw the attention of members of the Council to document
§/23718, which contains the text of a letter dated 13 March 1992 from the
Permanent Representative of Egypt to the United Nations addressed to the
Secretary-General.
The first speaker inscribed on my list is the Minister for External
Affairs of Nigeria, Major-General Ike 0. S. Nwachukwu, who wishes to make a
statement on behalf of the Current Chairman of the Organization of African
Unity. I welcome Major-General Nwachukwu and invite him to take a place at
the Council table.
I now call on the Minister for External Affairs of Nigeria.
Mr. NWACHUKWU (Nigeria): It is a distinct privilege for me to
convey to you, Mr. President, and to the esteemed members of the Security
Council the warmest greetings of the President of the Federal Republic of
Nigeria and Chairman of the Organization of African Unity (0AU),
(Mr. Nwachukwu, Nigeria)
General Ibrahim Babangida and to thank you for granting me the opportunity to
address the Council on his behalf on a subject that Africa and the
international community at large are at present grappling with. I should also
like to take the opportunity to congratulate Mr. Boutros Boutros-Ghali on his
appointment to the office of Secretary-General of the United Nations.
Somalia, a member of the OAU, is currently embroiled in an internecine
civil war that has destablilized the political and socio-economic set-up of
that country and brought untold hardship to its population. The carnage has
been mindless, and it has also brought in its wake loss of property, hunger,
poverty and forced migration of Somalis across their national frontiers. Men,
women and children have been turned into refugees with consequential
implications for the neighbouring States.
(Mr. Nwachukwu, Nigeria)
In the life of every nation there are periods of growth and development
just as there are periods of pain and difficulties. What we are witnessing in
Somalia is a disintegrative force of change along clannist lines and power
play among its political and military élites.
Africa has watched with extreme concern the volumetric increase in
frustration incident on the reluctance of the warring factions in Somalia to
end this fratricidal war, in the interest of their national unity. There is
abundant evidence that the fighting soldiers are themselves getting tired of
the war and would rather lay down their arms. This notwithstanding, Africa
would be pleased to see a better demonstration of a political disposition on
the part of the wider international community to deal seriously with the
Somali situation and in a manner which sends a clear message to the warring
factions that the continuing carnage is not only senseless but unacceptable.
It is against this backdrop that at the recent meeting of the Council of
Ministers in Addis Ababa, from 24 to 28 February this year, the Council called
upon the belligerent factions in Mogadiscio to honour fully the pledges they
had made here in New York on 14 February this year to cease hostilities
immediately and to maintain a cease-fire. The Council urged them to cooperate
with the joint mission to Somalia comprising the Organization of African Unity
(OAU), the United Nations, the Organization of the Islamic Conference and the
League of Arab States in its efforts to conclude a cease~fire agreement aimed
at the restoration of peace and stability in Somalia in line with Security
Council resolution 733 (1992) of 23 January this year.
I am greatly heartened that the Security Council, which has the primary
responsibility for the maintenance of international peace and security, is
sufficiently seized of this question and has undertaken some efforts in this
regard. Africa places a premium on the capacity of the Security Council to be
(Mr. Nwachukwu, Nigeria)
responsive to situations which are likely to constitute a threat to
international peace and security.
The situation in Somalia should qualify for direct action by the Security
Council in line with the provisions of the United Nations Charter. In short,
the Security Council should take a definitive step to establish a United
Nations presence in Somalia through the deployment of a military observer
mission te moniter the cease-fire. This, in the view of the OAU and in our
view as Africans, is the minimum action expected from the Security Council;
otherwise Africa will be left with no other impression than that its problems
are of limited concern to the international community, and particularly the
United Nations. The Security Council not only must conduct preventive
diplomacy in line with its new orientation and thrust, but must be seen to do
so effectively in the case of Somalia, which is the most recent test case, the
most recent disaster, on our continent,
We welcome the cooperation between the United Nations and the regional
organizations in addressing issues of concern to the international community.
We believe that such cooperation in the case of the OAU and the United Nations
shovld result in the peaceful resolution of the Somali conflict, as, indeed,
of other conflicts in Africa. The United Nations, as the conscience of the
international community, should perforce encourage a political process that
ensures the unity and the viability of the Somali State as it pursues national
reconciliation and reconstruction.
Africa notes with considerable interest the efforts of the United Nations
in crisis management, in peacemaking and peace-keeping. We suggest that
Africa deserves the same qualitative and quantitative attention which has been
paid to other regions - and perhaps much more because of its weak economic
(Mr. Nwachukwu, Nigeria)
base. There is need to have a strong and visible United Nations presence in
the conflict areas in Africa.
We commend the efforts of the Secretary-General in collaboration with the
regional organizations in the quest for a durable peace in Somalia. We should
also like to place on record our appreciation to the special envoy of the
Secretary-General to Somalia for his efforts during his recent visit. Our
appreciation goes also to the staff of the United Nations Development
Programme (UNDP) and the International Committee of the Red Cross inside
Somalia for their special courage and dedication in helping to provide
“assistance to the population and, most recently, in facilitating my own visit
to that country. We urge the Security Council to maintain the momentum for
the peace process by sending immediately United Nations observers to maintain
the cease-fire and enable the process of national reconciliation in Semalia to
proceed.
To this end, Nigeria, in line with its obligations under the Charter and
as a further contribution to the peace process in Somalia, is prepared to host
the Somali national reconciliation conference in Abuja, our new capital, under
the joint auspices of the United Nations, the Organization of African Unity,
the Organization of the Islamic Conference and'the League of Arab States. We
hope and expect that all the leaders of the warring factions will attend the
conference and reach agreement on the political future of Somalia.
Africa calls on all the parties to the Somali conflict to cease
hostilities immediately and observe the jointly negotiated cease-fire. They
must do so to promote the process of reconciliation and of political
settlement in Somalia.
(Mr. Nwachukwu, Nigeria)
Finally, Africa urges the Security Council to send a clear and definitive
message to ali the Somali factions by dispatching a military observer mission
to monitor the cease-fire and encourage a quick return to democracy in the
country.
I thank the Minister
of Foreign Affairs of Nigeria for the kind words addressed to the members of
the Security Council,
Sete (The President)
The next speaker. inscribed on my list is the representative of Kenya, who
wishes to make a’ statement in his capacity as, Chairman of the Group of African
States for the month of March. I invite him to take a place at the Council
table and to make his statement.
Mr, ADALA (Kenya): On behalf of the African Group, I congratulate
you, Mr. President, on your assumption of the presidency of the Security
Council for the month of March. We assure you of our unfailing support and
cooperation as you exercise the functions of this high office. We also thank
your predecessor, Ambassador Thomas Pickering of the United States, for the
efficient manner in which he guided the deliberations of the Council for the
month of February.
The situation in Somalia, which is the agenda item before the Council,
has caused great anxiety and concern.to many, especially those countries
immediately neighbouring Somalia and, indeed, all peoples committed to the
process of peaceful and democratic political changes in Africa. Over one
million Somalis are adversely affected in one way or another by the current
wave of violence. Women, children and the aged are subjected to subhuman
conditions in refugee camps, where the basic life-supporting necessities are
grossly inadequate or totally lacking.
My attention was recently called to an Africa Watch report on Somalia
entitled "A Fight to the Death - Leaving Civilians at the Mercy of Terror and
Starvation". I normally do not find much common ground with Africa Watch, but
I think a point was made which graphically illustrates the vicious coexistence
of war and famine in Somalia. I quote the following paragraph:
“War and famine in Mogadiscio feed on each other in a vicious cycle of
deprivation and destruction. The scarcity of food and its high price
causes many young men to turn to banditry and looting in order to
(Mr. Adala, Kenya)
survive, and*is one motivation for the two armies’ to fight ...--The:
. fighting in turn disrupts commerce, drives people from their homes,‘ and
prevents relief supplies from coming in. Hunger and Fighting: are
inextricably intertwined: beneath the fight for political. control there ‘18 a Light. for survival. It.follows that a solution to. the political
conflict cannot succeed without a solution to the food problem."
Given the above scenario, the African Group strongly.supports the:
recommendations in the Secretary-General's report of 11 March 1992: first, to
send to Mogadiscio, as soon as possible, a technical team, together with the
representatives of the Organization of African Unity, the League of Arab
States and the Organization of the Islamic Conference, to prepare an
operational plan for a United Nations monitoring mechanism, in accordance with
the agreement on the implementation of the cease-fire signed in Mogadiscio on
3 March 1992 by the leaders of the two factions; secondly, to request the
technical team to look into possible mechanisms to ensure the unimpeded
delivery of humanitarian assistance to the displaced persons; and, thirdly,
that the Security Council underline the individual and collective
responsibilities of the leaders of the factions to save lives and to assist in
the distribution of humanitarian assistance,
The Security Council, as was stated by the Secretary-General, needs to
make absolutely clear to the leaders of the two factions the consequences of
obstructing in any way the work of international monitors or the operations of
any United Nations observer mission that the Security Council might decide to
set up. The lives of millions of Somalis as well as the lives of those who
will be mandated by this Council to assist in finding a humane solution cannot
be left entirely in the hands of a few warring factions. A resolution coming
from this Council must convey that unmistakable message. Nor should this
eee a . - ; _... (Mr. Adala, Kenya) bee ee - carer ans _—
-Council,be seen to waver in the exercise of its responsibilities under the
Charter. .The situation in Somalia calls for the active involvement and strong
presence.of the United Nations.
Finally, the African Group would like to express its profound thanks to
the Secretary-General for his initiative on Somalia: to the
Under-Secretary-General for Political Affairs, Mr. James Jonah, who has
undertaken those delicate missions to Somalia; to the Secretaries—General of
the three regional Organizations for their collaborative efforts; and to this
Council for its untiring search for global peace. To you, Mr. President, we
reiterate our thanks for your diplomatic skills, which have enabled the
Council to conduct its deliberations with transparency, objectivity and
foresight.
I thank the
representative of Kenya for the kind words he addressed to me.
Mr, SNOUSST (Morocco) (interpretation from French): This is the
second time in a few months that the Security Council is reacting to the
tragic consequences of the civil war that has been ravaging Somalia. Such
interest in the Somali situation shows once again the growing concern of the
international community and its determination to alleviate the sufferings of
that people, which has been scourged by famine, sickness and fear.
In that regard, I should like to extend my warmest congratulations to the
Secretary-General for the excellent oral and written reports he has submitted
to the Council on this question. My delegation firmly supports the
recommendations and measures contemplated to alleviate the sufferings of the
Somalian people and to normalize the situation in that country.
(Mr. Snoussi, Morocco)
My congratulations also go to Under-Secretary-General James Jonah and to
the team he led in such difficult conditions in Somalia in order to find terms
for a peaceful settlement of this conflict and the means to solve: the
catastrophic. humanitarian situation.
My country, as it belongs both to the Arab nation and to Africa, is
especially interested in the Somali problem and in the dangers which threaten
peace, security and stability in the region. Somalia, which has heretofore
been independent, united and sovereign, is now likely to suffer dislocation,
not because of racial or religious differences, but primarily because of
personal and tribal hatreds between rival factions.
This internecine war, with its terrible toll of victims and destruction,
is entailing terrible human suffering of which the international community has
become increasingly aware and to which it has been reacting somewhat slowly
but, one must say, soundly. Unfortunately, the non-observance by the main
belligerents of the commitments to which they have appended their names and
their disregard for the provisions of Security Council resolution 733 (1992),
have prevented the free transport and distribution of the humanitarian
assistance so sorely needed by the Somali people.
Morocco, an Islamic, Arab and African country takes this opportunity to
make a fraternal appeal to all the Somali parties, factions and groupings to
comply with the cease-fire, to allow United Nations monitoring and to
cooperate fully with the Secretary-General with a view to solving this
fratricidal conflict peacefully.
I thank
Ambassador Snoussi of Morocco for his kind words addressed to me.
(The President)
-The next speaker inscribed on my list is Mr. Aboul Nasr, Permanent
Observer of the League of -Arab States to the United Nations, to whom the
Council.has extended an invitation under rule 39 of its provisional rules of
procedure. .
I invite him to take a place at the Council table and to make his
statement.
Mr. NASR (interpretation from Arabic): Allow me at the outset to
express to you, Mr. President, and to the other members of the Security
Council my most sincere thanks for allowing me to participate in the debate
today with a view to finding a solution for the tragic situation in fraternal
Somalia.
Since the inception of the regrettable developments in Somalia, the
members of the League of Arab States have tried to contain the crisis. From
the beginning of the crisis, the Secretary-General of the League set up
contacts with many of the warring factions with a view to stopping the carnage
and finding an acceptable peaceful solution. He also sent, on many occasions,
a special envoy to the area in order to meet directly with the parties
concerned. He also sent the Assistant Secretary-General of the League to the
reconciliation conference held in Djibouti.
Since the beginning of the crisis, the Arab League has frequently called
on the warring factions to stop the civil war and to seek a solution to the
crisis by peaceful rieans. The League of Arab States has also called on all
the specialized agencies and the Arab Funds concerned to give immediate heip
to the Somali people. Moreover, the Council of the Leaque charged the
Commission on Somalia, which was established for that purpose last May, with
directing an active Arab effort aimed at solving the crisis.
(Mr. Nasr}
The Commission, after consideration, recommended that there should be an
item on the deteriorating situation in Somalia on the agenda of the Council of
the Arab League at its regular ninety~sixth session, and resolution 5097 to
that effect was issued last September by the Council. After it became clear
that there were difficulties in implementing the Djibouti resolution, an
extraordinary session was held on 5 January last to consider the deteriorating
Situation in Somalia, and resolution 5157 was adopted and transmitted to the
Security Council as document S/23448.
The League of Arab States appreciates the meritorious efforts of the
United Nations and its bodies in this respect. It has also followed, with
keen interest and appreciation, the great efforts of the Security Council and
of Mr. Boutros-Ghali, and noted the fact that he has on many occasions sent
Mr. Jonah to Somalia with a view to establishing the conditions necessary for
the cease-fire and for the steps leading to national reconciliation.
The Arab League welcomed the adoption of Security Council resolution
733 (1992) and confirmed its willingness to take part in implementing it. It
also welcomed the Secretary-General's initiative of inviting the warring
factions in Mogadiscio to New York in February last, and it also took part,
with the Organization of African Unity (OQAU) and the Organization of the
Islamic Conference (OIC), in the meeting that was held at United Nations
Headquarters which concluded in an agreement for a cease-fire between the
warring factions.
The League of Arab States also participated, with the representative of
those organizations, in Mr. Jonah's mission to Mogadiscio, where a new
cease-fire agreement was issued, This is the mission that is described in
detail in the report of the Secretary-General (S/26693), which is before the
Council today.
(Mr. Nasr)
I wish in this respect, and on behalf of the Secretary-General of the
League of Arab States, to note with appreciation the great efforts made by the
Secretary-General of the United Nations and by the regional organizations that
took part in that mission. I also wish to commend the results and
recommendations of that mission. I believe that what took place was a unique
and new experience of creative cooperation between the United Nations and the
regional organizations, in accordance with Chapter VIII of the Charter of the
United Nations.
There can be no doubt that important steps were taken towards achieving
the goals to which we aspire in respect of Somalia. Regrettably, we still
have a long road before us; many steps have yet to be taken in order to secure
observance of the cease-fire by all the parties concerned and its immediate
implementation in Mogadiscio so that there can be an immediate end to the
plight of the Somali people.
I have received today a directive from the Secretary-General of the
League of Arab States confirming the League's full support for the draft
resolution before the Council and the League's willingness, immediately the
draft resolution is adopted, to coordinate with the United Nations in order to
implement the provisions of the draft resolution; the directive also confirms
the League's willingness to measures necessary for success as a result of the
draft resolution.
On behalf of the League, I wish to join in sending a clear message
calling on all the warring factions in Somalia immediately to observe the
agreements so that the humanitarian assistance can be distributed to the
refugees and to begin taking effective steps, under United Nations auspices,
to find an acceptable solution and put an end to this human tragedy.
I thank Mr. Aboul Nasr
for his kind words addressed to me.
The next speaker is Mr. Ahmet Engin Ansay, Permanent Observer of the
Organization of the Islamic Conference to the United Nations, to whom the
Council has extended an invitation under rule 39 of its provisional rules of
procedure. I invite him to take a place at the Council table and to make his
statement.
Mr. ANSAY: First of all, Sir, may I convey to you my warmest
congratulations on your assumption of the presidency of the Security Council
during this difficult period. We are indeed confident that your experience
and very well known professional skills will serve well in the successful
discharge of the complex task currently facing the Security Council, just as
they did admirably in the course of the previous week during the consideration
by the Council of another formidable issue.
I should also like to take this opportunity to thank another exceptional
diplomatist, the Permanent Representive of the United States of America,
Ambassador Thomas Pickering, for his virtuoso performance in steering the
Council's work during the month of February.
The Organization of the Islamic Conference is deeply concerned over the
situation in Somalia and has made efforts to restore peace and promote
national reconciliation since the very inception of the crisis. Its
Secretary-General, Mr. Hamid Algabid, personally visited certain parts of
Somalia and established contact with all Somali political groups.
We contributed to the launching of the peace process signified by the
Djibouti round-table conferences of Somali political factions. A meeting of
the Somali leaders and representatives was also held in Jeddah last year.
The States members of the Organization of the Islamic Conference have
been seized of the situation in Somalia at the ministerial and summit levels
and have adopted important resolutions which set forth the principles,
parameters and modalities for achieving a comprehensive peaceful settlement of
the Somali crisis.
The Sixth Islamic Summit Conference, held in Dakar in December 1991,
invited its Chairman, His Excellency Abdou Diouf, President of the Republic of
Senegal, to undertake appropriate contacts with the Secretary-General of the
United Nations with a view to examining the possibility of sending
peace-keeping forces to safeguard peace and order in Somalia.
President Abdou Diouf undertook the required consultations and brought the
contents of this resolution of the Sixth Islamic Summit to the attention of
the United Nations.
It is also a matter of deep satisfaction to the Organization of the
Islamic Conference that Mr. Boutros Boutros-Ghali, the Secretary-General,
acted promptly and sagaciously in bringing the issue of Somalia to the
attention of the Security Council.
The Organization of the Islamic Conference welcomed the adoption of
Security Council resolution 733 (1992) on Somalia. In an official statement
the Secretary-General extended the full support of the Organization of the
Islamic Conference to the call of the Security Council to all parties to cease
hostilities, which is an essential prerequisite for addressing seriously all
other aspects of the problem.
Hopes for peace in Somalia raised by the Djibouti round of consultations
were, unfortunately, short lived. Eruption of violence, especially in the
Mogadiscio area, has caused death and destruction on a large scale. It is
important to identify the main impediments to the implementation of the
decisions taken in Djibouti. It is also necessary fully to analyse the root
(Mr. Ansay)
causes of the intra-tribal conflict so as to find a just, durable and
equitable solution.
The principles and parameters which should govern the actions of the
United Nations and other international and regional organizations to achieve a
political solution to the Somali crisis should be clearly enunciated and
translated into a comprehensive and coherent policy framework for the joint .
pursuit of peace in Somalia.
The Organization of the Islamic Conference member States at the highest
level have affirmed their commitment to the restoration and preservation of
the unity, sovereignty, territorial integrity and political independence of
Somalia. In view of the dangers inherent in the present situation in Somalia,
it is necessary that the international community as a whole reiterate its
commitment to these principles.
As far as the issue of establishing a durable cease-fire agreement is
concerned, we are of the view that a comprehensive cease-fire agreement
covering all parts of Somalia, and not merely the capital and its adjacent
areas, is of vital importance. This would require obtaining the unequivocal
commitment of all Somali political groups. In the absence of institutions of
State power, which characterizes the current situation in Somalia, it would be
futile to expect that any cease-fire arrangement confined to Mogadiscio would
hold for the other parts of the country. However, we recognize the urgent
need to take steps te stop the fighting in Mogadiscio and would strongly urge
the parties concerned to comply with the resolutions of the Security Council
and the Organization of the Islamic Conference.
For its part, the Organization of the Islamic Conference is ready to
assist in any manner deemed appropriate in arranging a comprehensive and
@urable cease-fire aqreement.
(Mr. Ansay)
In this connection, the Organization of the Islamic Conference is
concerting its efforts with those of the United Nations to help the people of
Somalia overcome their present hardships and difficulties. In this spirit,
the Organization of the Islamic Conference actively participated in the
New York talks from 12 to 14 February 1992 and took part in the joint United
Nations/Organization of the Islamic Conference/Organization of African
Unity/League of Arab States delegation which visited Mogadiscio to consult
with the Somali factions on ways and means to conclude a cease-fire agreement
and pave the way for a peaceful solution to the problem of Somalia. The
successful crowning of that mission was unfortunately shadowed later by the
resurgence of fighting. It is therefore important that enforcement,
monitoring and observance of the cease-fire agreement be ensured by a
peace-keeping force in Somalia.
The search for a just and durable solution to the Somali crisis could
best be pursued by initiating a serious intra-Somali dialogue between all
Somali political groups, taking into account the complex tribal complexion of
the Somali political scene and respecting the Somali traditions. The most
important, and perhaps the only, unifying element which transcends the tribal
and clannish diversity in Somalia is the Islamic faith of the Somali people.
It could provide them with a real and true basis for overcoming their
parochial interests and Living in brotherhood and harmony with each other.
The Organization of the Islamic Conference believes that consideration
must be given to the convening, under the joint sponsorship of the United
Nations, the Organization of the Islamic Conference, the Organization of
African Unity and the Arab League of a conference on national reconciliation
consisting of all Somali political groups.
(Mr. Ansay)
The Organization of the Islamic Conference deeply appreciates the
measures taken by Mr. Boutros Boutros-Ghali, the Secretary-General, to
mobilize humanitarian assistance for the Somali people. The Organization of
the Islamic Conference will be happy to coordinate its efforts with those of
the United Nations in the field of humanitarian assistance.
Effective relief work commensurate with the grave magnitude of the
problem requires that urgent consideration be given to creating appropriate
conditions for the disbursement of humanitarian assistance to ali parts of
Somalia. It is important that the physical safety of those who are engaged in
this noble endeavour be assured. For this purpose, we suggest that serious
consideration be given to establishing zones of peace in various parts of
Somalia.
In the light of those considerations, the Organization of the Islamic
Conference warmly welcomes the excellent report by the Secretary-General which
has just come out, and most sincerely commends Under-Secretary-—General
James Jonah for his brilliant catalytic role and fruitful efforts in the
pursuance of a just and durable peace in Somalia.
Our Organization is ready to explore further any other ideas and
proposals together with the United Nations and other international and
regional organizations so that a well-coordinated and comprehensive approach
to resolve the crisis in Somalia may be evolved. By the same token, the
Organization of the Islamic Conference fully supports the draft resolution.
In conclusion, I should like once again to thank
Mr. Boutros Boutros-Ghali, the Secretary-General, for having provided us with
this opportunity to concert and coordinate our efforts with those of the
United Nations for the cause of peace in Somalia.
I thank
Mr. Ahmet Engin Ansay for the kind words he addressed to me.
Mr. GHAREKHAN (India): We in India have been watching the
deterioration of the situation in Somalia with increasing sadness. The Horn
of Africa lies just across the Arabian Sea from the Indian peninsula, along
the great sea-trade routes that have linked my country with the east coast of
Africa for centuries. To us, therefore, the awful political and humanitarian
consequences of this fratricidal conflict stand out with tragic clarity.
The Secretary-General's report on Somalia, following the extraordinarily
difficult mission undertaken recently by Under-Secretary-General James Jonah
and his team, graphically depicts the complexity of the situation. The
fighting in Mogadiscio between two factions of the same Somali movement is
compounded many-foid by hostility between political factions and movements in
other parts of Somalia, fractures and struggles within these movements
themselves, secessionist movements in the north and uncontrolled armed
elements on the rampage everywhere. The Secretary-General has drawn our
attention to the absence of any civil society and to the breakdown of law and
order in Mogadiscio and elsewhere, which is further exacerbated by the
proliferation and easy availability of arms and ammunition among the
population.
There is no single political authority today in Somalia with which the
world community can interact and to which it can turn for a resolution of this
problem. The people of Somalia, innocent men, women and children caught in a
horrendous web of internecine warfare, cry out for help. The sheer maqnitude
of the problem ana its continuation constitute a threat to the peace and
security of the region, as mentioned in the draft resolution before us.
(Mr. Gharekhan, India)
The Somali situation is thus sui generis and, as the Secretary-General
points out, has eluded conventional solutions. The principles drawn from the
United Nations Charter, which the Security Council must always build upon in
its consideration of the issues before it, have nevertheless to be applied in
this case also. But as the Secretary-General himself concludes, new avenues
and innovative methods commensurate with the humanitarian and political
situation at hand need to be explored to facilitate a peaceful settlement. In
this, the collaborative role being played by the regional organizations along
with the United Nations, in the context of Chapter VIII of the Charter,
assumes importance.
The Secretary-General has proposed to send a technical team to work out,
in consultation with the two main protagonists in Mogadiscio, an operational
pian for a United Nations monitoring mechanism for the stabilization of a
cease-fire in the city. Such a monitoring mechanism has been agreed to by the
two main protagonists as a result of the efforts of the recent joint mission
led by Mr. James Jonah. Unfortunately, they have yet to abide by the
cease-fire agreement signed by them at the same time. The question of
uncontrolled armed elements remains to be dealt with. Without an effective
cease-fire on the ground it will be extremely difficult for any United Nations
monitoring mission to carry out its task, and the primary aspect of the
technical team’s work would be to impress upon the combatants the need to stop
the fighting and observe the agreed cease-fire,
The Secretary-General has proposed an additional aspect to the technicai
team's mandate, which is to look into possible mechanisms to ensure the
unimpeded delivery of humanitarian assistance. Indeed, this has come not a
moment too soon. The terrible humanitarian situation that has resulted from
the conflict, and the lack of food, have only aggravated the reckless warfare,
which in turn has rendered substantial international humanitarian efforts
impossible.
The situation is of crisis proportions, with five times as many
casualties as have taken place in Yugoslavia and with the displacement of
hundreds of thousands of innocent people in and around conflict areas in all
parts of the country. Some international organizations and non-governmental
organizations have worked heroically to provide relief, but the absence of a
' cease-fire and the lack of cooperation by the warring groups have thwarted
effective operations and have even resulted in unfortunate casualties among
relief workers.
The conflict in Somalia can ultimately be resolved only through political
dialogue within the conference of national reconciliation and unity which will
form the second phase of the United Nations action. In this first phase,
however, the urgencies are well defined, and the responsibility lies,
individually and collectively, with the leaders of the various Somali factions
themselves. The United Nations has stepped forward to help them, and they
must offer it every possible support.
The next speaker is
the representative of Italy. If invite him to take a place at the Council
table and to make his statement.
Mr, TRAXLER (Italy): I am speaking today because on this occasion
Italy would like to express its full support for the draft resolution to be
adopted by the Security Council and for the measures therein aimed at
promoting the achievement of a peaceful solution to the tragic conflict
troubling Somalia, a country which, as members know, is very close to mine in
view of our long-standing ties of friendship and cooperation.
Indeed, it is these very ties of friendship that encourage me, with the
Council's permission, to express my country's sincere appreciation to the
Secretary-General, Mr. Boutros Boutros-Ghali, for his initiative in seeking a
peaceful solution to the Somali crisis, as well as to Under-Secretary-General
James Jonah for his untiring efforts towards that same end.
While hailing with satisfaction the forthcoming dispatch of a United
Nations technical team to Somalia, Italy expresses the wish that this peace
initiative may be complemented - as in fact is provided for in the draft
resolution - by appropriate cooperative efforts on the part of the United
Nations, the Organization of African Unity, the League of Arab States and the
Organization of the Islamic Conference towards the convening of a conference
of national reconciliation and unity which would bring together ail parties,
movements and factions now present in Mogadiscio and in the whole Somali
territory.
Needless to say, Italy stands ready to contribute in every possible
manner to the success of that conference. Furthermore, Italy hopes that the
initiatives provided for by today's draft resolution may establish the
necessary conditions for the orderly and safe distribution of humanitarian aid
to the Somali population, which has been so grievously affected by the tragic
developments.
My country stands ready to contribute to the international aid programmes
set up by specialized organizations. In this connection I wish to announce
that a mission of Italian officials is already in touch with the International
Committee of the Red Cross in Geneva to work out a possible Italian
contribution to the humanitarian effort in Somalia already planned by that
Committee in cooperation with the United Nations and several non-governmental
organizations.
In conclusion, I should like to express to you, Sir, my country's sincere
good wishes and congratulations on your assumption of the presidency of the
Security Council, together with our sincere appreciation for the work of your
predecessor, Ambassador Thomas Pickering.
I thank the
representative of Italy for his kind words addressed to me.
It is my understanding that the Security Council is ready to proceed to
the vote on the draft resolution before it. If I hear no objection, I shall
take it that that is the case.
There being no objection, it is so decided.
Before putting the draft resolution to the vote, I shali call on those
members of the Council who wish to make statements before the voting.
Mr. JESUS (Cape Verde): We have been very much touched by the
tragedy in Somalia. Torn by a horrible internal war that has caused much pain
and suffering to its people and brought about destruction and death, that
sisterly African country has come to the brink of chaos and disarray.
Last January the Council, faced with this horrible situation, attempted
to come to the assistance of the Somali people, and adopted resolution
733 (1992) which called for the cessaticn of hostilities and the conclusion of
a cease-fire agreement, and requested the Secretary-General to assist in the
political normalization of Somalia and to mobilize the humanitarian assistance
to that country. My country willingly and actively joined this decision of
the Council because we believed it to be a timely and necessary measure to
come to the rescue of the Somali people.
The efforts made so far by the Secretary-General in carrying out the
mandate conferred upon him under resolution 733 (1992) are commendable and,
certainly, we strongly urge him to pursue these efforts with a view to helping
bring stability and normalcy of life to Somalia.
We particularily value the Secretary-Generai's assistance in brokering
cease~fire agreements between the two factions. We regret to note, however,
that, as mentioned in the Secretary-General's report, the parties have not
abided by these agreements.
We urge ~ we demand - the parties concerned to respect the cease-fire
agreements in order to bring the carnage of the Somali people to a halt and
create the necessary conditions for a political settlement of the conflict.
The international community cannot and should not wait anymore to stop
one of the most destructive internal wars of modern times, which has plunged
the country into chaos. No faction, party or movement, however
well-intentioned their policies might be or however lofty the goals they
purport to pursue, should have the right to impose, let alone to prolong, such
sacrifice on their people.
For the sake of their country, for the love of their people and for
humanitarian considerations, we appeal to all those involved in the conflict
to cease their hostilities promptly and to cooperate fully with the
Secretary-General in his peace-making efforts.
We are glad to note that the Secretary-General has decided to send to
Somalia, as soon as possible, a technical team to prepare an operational plan
for a United Nations monitoring mechanism. We believe this is an important
step towards stabilizing the cease-fire and facilitating a negotiated solution
to the conflict.
We hope that the Council, when the time comes, will rise to its
responsibilities and adopt any measure that, in accordance with past practices
in similar situations, might prove to be necessary to bring stability and to
restore peace and tranquility to Somalia.
We take this opportunity to praise the role played by the international
humanitarian organizations, particularly the International Committee of the
Red Cross, for their dedicated and courageous efforts to provide humanitarian
assistance to the affected Somali population. The risks they have been taking
make their humanitarian assistance all the more commendable and highly
appreciated.
We have taken note of the efforts made by the United Nations system in
providing humanitarian assistance and relief. We urge the Secretary-General
to pursue these efforts and, in this context, we emphasize the importance of
the coordinator, whose appointment the Council requested in its resolution
733 (1992).
The draft resolution before us is another step to be taken shortly by the
Council in its efforts to assist in the normalization of the situation in
Somalia. It is to be expected that a technical team will soon be able
successfully to discharge its mandate to allow the Council to proceed promptly
with further measures to stabilize the cease-fire as envisaged in the
Secretary-General's report.
We hope the Council will continue to monitor closely the situation in
Somalia and will take all appropriate and prompt measures to assist that
country to gain back its lost tranquility and stability.
Finally, we appreciate the work done by Mr. James Jonah and his team, and
their courageous commitment to carry out their missions in a difficult and
risky situation in Somalia.
Mr. NOTERDAEME (Belgium) (interpretation from French): All the
information emanating from Somalia coincides on one point: the humanitarian
situation there is a traqic one, The number of dead, injured and displaced
persons continues to increase, and famine is taking a firm hold. Moreover,
the extremely complex political and military situation is impeding - indeed it
is making impossible - the provision of the assistance that the Somali people
so sorely needs.
(Mr, Noterdaeme, Belgium)
We should therefore like to pay a tribute to all the members of
international, regional and non-governmental organizations, who, often at a
risk to their lives, continue to lend assistance to the people of Somalia.
My delegation should also like to thank the Secretary-General for his
report and, above all, for the efforts made through his representative,
Mr. James Jonah, which resulted in the signing of cease-fire agreements by
Ali Mahid Mohamed and Farah Aidid on 3 March.
These agreements provide for the establishment of a United Nations
monitoring mechanism with a view to establishing a durable cease-fire that
“would also apply to uncontrolled armed elements. However, the establishment
of such a mechanism implies that the parties to the agreement will take
certain measures that are set forth in paragraph 40 of the Secretary-General's
report.
It is primarily to see to it that these provisions have effectively been
implemented that the dispatch of a technical team, proposed by the
Secretary-General, is particularly useful. This mission should, among other
things, determine whether the security conditions in Somalia are sufficient to
make it possible to dispatch a team to verify the cease-fire.
The second objective of the technical team is to study the ways and means
of ensuring the unhindered distribution of humanitarian assistance to
displaced persons in Mogadiscio. In view of the distress of the Somali
people, my delegation has no difficulty in endorsing what the
Secretary-General has personally called "innovations".
I should nevertheless like to point out that in the eventual
implementation of a United Nations operation in Somalia a clear distinction
should be drawn between the political and military aspects and the
humanitarian aspect, especially because of their specific budgetary
implications.
In conclusion, I would emphasize the importance my delegation attaches to
the role which is being played - and should continue to be played - by the
Organization of African Unity, the Organization of the Islamic Conference and
the League of Arab States. My delegation cannot but approve of paragraph 9 of
the draft resolution, in which the Secretary-General is called upon to
cooperate closely with the regional organizations with a view to convening a
conference for national reconciliation and unity in Somalia. Furthermore,
Belgium welcomes the Secretary-General's intention to involve those
organizations in an eventual United Nations monitoring mechanism in Somalia.
Mr. HOHENFELLNER (Austria): For quite some time, the deteriorating
situation in Somalia has been of great concern to my country. The ongoing
violence and its negative impact on the grave situation of the civilian
population constitute a serious threat to peace and security in the Horn of
Africa, a region already gravely afflicted by starvation, civil wars and
massive flows of refugees. Austria therefore welcomed the initiative taken by
the Secretary-General in December 1991 in bringing this issue before the
Security Council.
Austria also strongly supported the adoption of Security Council
resolution 733 (1992), which gave a dual mandate to the Secretary-General: on
the one hand to take the necessary actions to increase humanitarian assistance
to the affected population, and on the other hand to seek the commitment of
all parties involved in the conflict to the cessation of hostilities, in order
(Mr. Hohenfeliner, Austria)
to permit the humanitarian assistance to be distributed. The Security Council
thereby recognized the close link between a durable cessation of hostilities
and the establishment of viable mechanisms for the distribution of
humanitarian assistance.
We welcome the fact that, as a first step towards fulfilling the mandate
given by resolution 733 (1992), the joint mission of the United Nations, the
Organization of African Unity, the League of Arab States.and the Organization
of the Islamic Conference was able on 3 March to achieve the signing in
Mogadiscio of cease-fire agreements by the two major factions. The
' regrettable fact, however, that the cease-fire has not yet been fully
respected, thereby still preventing the distribution of humanitarian
assistance to the population, clearly indicates that further efforts are
necessary. We therefore support the proposal by the Secretary-General
urgently to dispatch a technical team to Mogadiscio and other parts of Somalia
to discuss arrangements to stabilize the cease-fire agreements as well as to
look into possible mechanisms to ensure the unimpeded delivery of humanitarian
assistance.
We are convinced that the draft resolution before us, endorsing these
proposals by the Secretary-General, will gain the unanimous support of the
members of the Security Council. Thereby the Council will send the strongest
possible signal to all parties, movements and factions in Somalia to respect.
the Security Council's demand for full cooperation with the Secretary-—General
and for full respect for the safety and security of the technical team and
humanitarian personnel in all parts of Somalia.
Mr. LI Daoyu (China) (interpretation from Chinese): The
long-drawn-out conflict and war in Somalia have brought enormous losses of
property and life to the Somali people. The Chinese delegation shares the
deep concern expressed by other delegations over this situation.
We are pleased to note that thanks to the mediation of the United Nations
and the relevant regional organizations, the Interim President of Somalia and
the Chairman of the United Somali Congress signed respectively on 3 March this
year the agreement on the implementation of the cease-fire and agreed to take
immediate steps for the implementation of measures aimed at stabilizing the
cease-fire by means of a United Nations monitoring mechanism. This, in our
view, is a good starting-point and a favourable opportunity for achieving a
peaceful solution to the internal disputes of Somalia. We sincerely hope that
the relevant Somali parties involved in the conflict will seize this
opportunity to implement the cease-fire agreements in earnest and strive for
the early restoration of peace and stability in Somalia. We should also like
to take this opportunity to express our appreciation and thanks to the
Secretary-General and his special representative Mr. James Jonah, and to the
League of Arab States, the Organization of African Unity and the Organization
of the Islamic Conference for their tireless efforts to ensure the peaceful
settlement of the Somali question.
The Chinese delegation appreciates the Secretary~General’s report on the
Somali question and supports the adoption by the Security Council of a
resolution on this issue. At the same time, we believe that the Somali
question should be peacefully settled mainly by the Somali people themselves
through consultations and dialogues. Only at the request and with the support
and cooperation of the Somali people can any external endeavours, including
(Mr. Li Daoyu, China)
the Unitea Nations monitoring mechanism and humanitarian relief, be genuinely
effective. It is our hope and belief that United Nations activities in
Somalia will be conducted in accordance with the purposes and principles of
the Charter of the United Nations, with full respect for Somalia's
independence and sovereignty, so as to make due contributions to the early
restoration of a just and lasting peace in Somalia. In this regard, we
believe that any further peace-keeping operations to be carried out by the
United Nations in Somalia must be reported in advance to the Security Council
and approved by it.
Mr. MERIMEE (France) (interpretation from French): The very grave
situation in Somalia resulting from the violent fighting affecting most parts
of that country is a source of profound concern to the French Government. In
addition to the large loss of human life, this fighting is causing massive
displacements of populations as well as an extremely serious deterioration of
the humanitarian situation, particularly with regard to food. It also
endangers the already fragile peace and stability of the entire region.
The Security Council, by adopting its resolution 733 (1992) on 23 January
last, expressed its determination to contribute to efforts to bring about an
end to the hostilities, to facilitate the channelling of assistance to the
affected populations and to promote a political settlement of the conflict.
Since that time, the Secretary~General has endeavoured, on a priority basis,
in the framework of the mission conferred upon him by our Council, to induce
the parties in conflict in Mogadiscio to put an end to the confrontations. My
delegation wishes to express its complete support for the Secretary-General's
action as well as for the efforts made by Under-Secretary-General James Jonah.
We deplore the fact that the cease-fire to which the parties have
committed themselves is not yet respected, and we call upon the parties to put
(Mr. Mérimée, France)
an end to the fighting without delay. We call upon them aiso to do all in,
their power to promote the provision of assistance so badly needed by the
populations, inter alia by ensuring the safety of the personnel of
humanitarian organizations.
‘In that spirit, my delegation supports the initiatives envisaged in the
Secretary-General‘'s report, and especially the plan to send to Mogadiscio a
United Nations technical team. My delegation expresses the hope that these
initiatives will receive the cooperation of the parties, which is
indispensable if they are to succeed. It is also essential that all States,
in accordance with the appeal made to them by our Council, refrain from any
act likely to increase the tension.
In conclusion, my delegation hopes that the Security Council will
unanimously adopt the draft resolution before it, thus demonstrating its
determination to contribute to putting an end to the tragedy afflicting
Somalia and so heavily weighing upon the peoples of that country.
Mr. MUMBENGEGWI (Zimbabwe): My delegation wishes to commend and |
congratulate the Secretary~-General for launching - in close cooperation with
the Organization of African Unity (OAU), the Leaque of Arab States and the
Organization of the Islamic Conference - the peace effort in Somalia that
resulted in the 14 February New York commitment by two of the warring parties
to cease hostilities, and the subsequent signing of the cease-fire agreements
on 3 March 1992 in Mogadiscio.
The report of the Secretary-General before us today (8/23693 and Corr.1)
notes that the complexity of the tragic situation in Somalia required this
concerted effort from the United Nations and the three regional
Organizations. In this regard, my delegation welcomes the participation of
His Excellency General Nwachukwu, the Chairman of the OAU Council of
Ministers, in our deliberations. We thank him for his excellent address.
The Security Council has of late been seized of fratricidal conflicts
that have caused so much destruction and massive loss of life and have
threatened the peace and stability of regions. Effective and appropriate
(Mr. Mumbengeqwi, Zimbabwe)
measures have already been taken by the Council to stabilize the cease-fires
in two areas - Yugoslavia and Cambodia. The tragedy of Somalia has for almost
a year been unravelling before our very:eyes. My delegation believes that the
Somalia conflicts are of an extremely grave nature and showld be addressed
with utmost urgency. That is why we welcome the recommendation of the
Secretary-General to dispatch to Somalia, as soon as possible, a technical
team that will prepare a plan for a United Nations monitoring mechanism. It
is my delegation's expectation that the dispatch of this technical team will
not be delayed by the reference to a coordinator for humanitarian efforts in
operative paragraph 6 of the draft resolution before us.
I must place on record our indignation at some of the parties in Somalia,
which seem not to take seriously their commitment to the recently signed
cease-fire agreements. They should be warned that the international community
will not accept a situation in which innocent people continue to lose their
lives in circumstances where differences can easily be resolved through
peaceful means.
We therefore call upon ali the parties in Somalia to cease all
hostilities; to cooperate fully with the technical team in its mandate to
prepare an operational plan for a United Nations monitoring mechanism; and to
cooperate fully with the technical team in putting in place mechanisms for
unimpeded delivery of humanitarian assistance to all persons in need
throughout Somalia.
We are confident that the Secretary-General will vigorously pursue his
humanitarian efforts in Somalia by harnessing all the resources at his
disposal, including those of the relevant United Nations agencies, to address
urgently the critical and tragic situation of the population in Somalia.
(Mr. Mumbengeawi, Zimbabwe )
We look forward to the Secretary-Generai’s report and to the expeditious
approval and implementation of his recommendations so as to stabilize the
situation in Somalia. _ | .
Mr. WATSON (United States of America): ‘The human suffering in
Somalia over the past several months has been a tragedy of heartbreaking
magnitude. “Innocent Somalis, including thousands of women and children, have
faced starvation, disease and death as a result of the brutal struggles for
control over territory that have racked this unfortunate country. The United
States Government sees a cease-fire, the establishment of a process of
national reconciliation and the provision of humanitarian assistance and
relief to these unfortunate victims as the primary goals of the international
community in Somalia.
Not only must the alleviation of human suffering be intensified as soon
as possible, but it is also clear that a cease-fire is unlikely to be
effective without the provision of humanitarian relief. One will not work
without the other. A more concerted, well-articulated and tightly coordinated
humanitarian assistance effort is urgently needed now.
To these ends, it is important to work towards a cessation of all
hostilities and a political settlement. Unfortunately, while two of the
warring factions in the capital of Mogadiscio have signed cease-fire
agreements with representatives of the United Nations and three regional
organizations, the cease-fire does not appear to be holding. This cease-fire
must be strictly and effectively adhered to in good faith before the Security
Council can send in United Nations monitors. Prior experience in
peace-keeping operations throughout the world has shown us that the United
(Mr. Watson, United States)
Nations cannot perform effectively in a situation where the parties to the
conflict are unwilling to create the conditions necessary to enable it to do
so. No United Nations monitoring mechanism to supervise a cease-fire can be
put into a situation where there is no effective cease-fire. The United
Nations cannot deliver humanitarian assistance where an active conflict is
under way. For all these reasons, we call upon all parties to cease
hostilities immediately.
When an effective cease-fire is achieved, all parties to the conflict
must be willing to accept international supervision of it in order for United
Nations monitors to operate with a modicum of safety. Without such agreements
firmly in place, we would be placing the monitors in an excessively dangerous
situation. Upon the return of the technical team from Somalia, and the
Secretary-General’s next report to the Council, we shall have to consider
seriously whether these conditions can be met.
Under your leadership, Mr. President, the Council today is acting
expeditiously so that the United Nations, in cooperation with other
international organizations, can provide intensified assistance to the Somalis
as they seek to overcome their horrendous, multifaceted crisis. We wish them
well and look forward to receiving and acting upon the Secretary-General's
next report as soon as possible.
Mr. AYALA LASSO (Ecuador) (interpretation from Spanish): Almost two
months exactly after adopting its resolution 733 (1992), the Security Council
is once again going to express its determination to respond effectively to the
challenges that the situation in Somalia poses for the international community.
The report the Secretary-General submitted to us on 11 March and the oral
information which recently supplemented it demonstrate the gravity and the
tragedy of the crisis in Somalia. We wish to express our appreciation and our
support for the Secretary-General and Mr. James Jonah in everything they have
done in fulfilling the mandate given them in resolution 733 (1992).
‘All countries the world over - especially those in the developing world
and, obviously, most especially those in Africa - have followed the work of
the Security Council with interest and attention. There is no doubt that the
voice of Africa has been a powerful stimulus to the Security Council, which
has reacted by producing the draft resolution we are now preparing to adopt.
Thus, one more new, important and positive step has been taken along the
road which the Council set out in January thanks, in large measure, to the
outstanding, universal citizen of Africa who is now our Secretary-—General;
this is a road which we all hope will end in the establishment of peace and
national reconciliation in Somalia and in a fitting solution to the
humanitarian problems that are among the components of this crisis. The
Ambassador of Kenya eloquently reminded us of this in saying that war and
hunger are feeding off each other in the crisis in Somalia.
We are sure that the technical team our Secretary-General will soon send
to Somalia and the coordinator for humanitarian assistance will £ulfil their
mandates effectively in monitoring the cease-fire operations and the
distribution of humanitarian assistance. For this to be achieved, the parties
and factions in Somalia will have to live up to their commitments and
cooperate fully with the United Nations team.
It is for the Somali people and their leaders to fulfil their fundamental
responsibility of seeking, through dialogue and peaceful negotiation, an
appropriate and lasting solution to this crisis. For this, and in order to
make possible effective United Nations participation, there is also a need for
all the factions and movements in Somalia to will it to be so.
We consider it extremely important to highlight and promote the
assistance which the regional organizations, such as the Organization of
African Unity, the League of Arab States and the Organization of the Islamic
Conference, can and have been offering and providing in order to contribute to
solving the problem of Somalia.
I wish to express to the noble Somali people Ecuador's total solidarity
in these difficult and tragic moments in its history, along with our
conviction that, through its own action and resolve, this fraternal people
will be able to recover a normal life of peace and democracy in which they can
work effectively to ensure its progress.
Ecuador is sure that the Security Council will be capable of doing its
duty in cooperating in that noble endeavour.
Mr. LOZINSKY (Russian Federation) (interpretation from Russian):
The Russian Federation supports the efforts designed to put an immediate end
to armed conflict in Somalia and to achieve national reconciliation and
agreement in that country as quickly as possible.
(Mr. Lozinsky, Russian Federation)
We rate the activities being carried out by the Secretary-General,
Mr. Boutros-Ghali, and by the Under-Secretary-General for Political Affairs,
Mr. James Jonah, very highly. The Russian Federation supports the draft
resolution we prepared during our consultations, given the critical nature of
the developing situation in Somalia and the loss of life and the suffering
caused by the conflict, which harbours a threat to international peace and
security.
We support the draft resolution's urgent appeal to the Somali parties to
fulfil their obligations under the cease-fire agreement of 3 March, cooperate
with the Secretary-General and ensure that humanitarian assistance by the
United Nations, its specialized agencies and other humanitarian organizations
is provided to all who need it.
We also support the Secretary-General'’s rapid dispatching to Somalia of
the technical team which will carry out the mission set out for it under
paragraphs 73 and 74 of his report (8/23693 and Corr.1). It is important for
there to be a total cease-fire and a complete cessation of military activities
as quickly as possible, and for all possible steps to be taken to ensure the
unimpeded delivery of humanitarian assistance to the country.
Furthermore, we associate ourselves with the views expressed here
concerning the need to draw a clear distinction between United Nations
expenditures on peace-keeping and the parallel expenses incurred in providing
technical, humanitarian and other assistance, which should be funded either
through voluntary contributions or through the active and coordinated
involvement of the United Nations specialized agencies and other organizations
in the United Nations system.
(Mr, Lozinsky, Russian Federation)
We should especially like to emphasize the importance of close
cooperation between the United Nations and the Organization of African Unity,
the League of Arab States and the Organization of the Islamic Conference,
particularly in consulting all the Somali parties, movements and factions with
a view to convening a conference on national reconciliation and unity in
Somalia.
By actively and unanimously responding to the Secretary-General's report
on the situation in Somalia, the Security Council has once again demonstrated
the great peace-making potential of the United Nations.
Mr, BUDAI (Hungary): First of all, I should like te express our
gratitude to the Secretary-General for his report on the situation in Somalia,
which has provided an excellent basis for the Security Council to consider the
issue before us.
The Republic of Hungary is deeply concerned by the continuous
deterioration of the situation in Somalia and by the magnitude of the human
suffering brought about by the conflict. The continuation of this tragic and
alarming situation constitutes a threat to international peace and security
and, consequently, it demands effective action on behalf of the Council. We
are fully aware of the complexity and the extraordinary nature of this crisis,
which indeed requires new and innovative approaches by the international
community.
At this juncture, we are particularly encouraged by the efforts of the
Organization of African Unity, the Leaque of Arab States and the Organization
of the Islamic Conference towards achieving a peaceful settlement. We also
(Mr. Budai, Hungary)
concur with the Secretary-General's observation in his report that the
collaborative efforts of the United Nations and the regional and
intergovernmental organizations undertaken in the context of Chapter VIII of
the Charter have set a useful precedent for future cooperation.
In our view it is essential, for any progress to be made towards the
solution of the crisis, that the signatories of the cease-fire agreements of
3 March 1992 honour their commitments fully and unconditionally. It is
equally important that all Somali parties, movements and factions facilitate
the unimpeded delivery of humanitarian assistance to all those in need and
cooperate with the United Nations, its specialized agencies and other
humanitarian organizations for this purpose. In our opinion, efforts to solve
the political and humanitarian aspects of the crisis should be made
simultaneousiy.
For these reasons, we welcome the idea of dispatching a technical team to
Somalia, to be accompanied by the coordinator of humanitarian assistance in
order to work within the framework and objectives outlined in paragraphs 73
and 74 of the Secretary-General's report. In our view it is of paramount
importance that all parties concerned respect fully the security and safety of
this team and the personnel of the humanitarian organizations and guarantee
their complete freedom of movement in the country.
On the basis of those considerations the Hungarian delegation strongly
supports the adoption of the draft resolution contained in document S$/23722.
Sir David HANNAY (United Kingdom): I shall be very brief, because I
have little to add to the remarks made by others in the Council. We too have
been shocked and horrified by the way in which events have gone in Somalia and
by the terrible suffering of its people.
There is one point I should like to make on the cease-fire. We were very
admiring of the efforts of Under-Secretary-General Jonah when he managed to
broker a cease-fire in extremely difficult circumstances a few weeks ago. But
the fact that that cease-fire has not held has demonstrated something which
(Sir David Hannay, United Kingdom)
the Council is now all too familiar with ~ namely, that the will of the
parties to a cease-fire to honour it is absolutely fundamental to any
effective return to more tranquil and peaceful conditions, and that remains
the case in Somalia. tt is all summed up in the little phrase, “You can't
have peace-keeping if you haven't got a peace to keep". I hope very much that
this renewed effort by a technical mission will lead to there being a peace to
keep.
The second point I should like to make relates to the very welcome
intention of the Secretary-General and his officials to devote their
humanitarian efforts to the whole of Somalia and not just the area around
Mogadiscio. The area around Mogadiscio has of course caught all the
headlines, and there is no doubt at all that the suffering and damage there
are greater than anywhere else, but it is not the only part of the country
where there are real problems. The north, too, where there has been less open
civil strife, but where there have been every bit as many humanitarian
problems, will benefit greatly if the United Nations and its agencies are able
to resume their operations in an effective way.
Thirdly, and finally, I hope the technical team will be able to begin to
nudge people forward towards a process of reconciliation, because otherwise
the risk is that the United Nations and Somalia will remain stuck halfway
between peace and war, and that is a situation which benefits nobody. So I
hope that we shall also hear from the Secretary-General in his next report
whether there are any signs of hope that a process of reconciliation on a
long-term basis can now be set under way.
Mr, HATANO (Japan): If Sir David had little to add, I have still
less to add.
The Government and the people of Japan are seriously concerned about the
tragic situation in Somalia. A large number of human lives have already been
sacrificed, and to cease hostilities and to restore peace and stability in
that country must be a priority concern not only of the people of Somalia but
of the entire international community.
The situation in Somalia is indeed complex, and new and innovative
methods may have te be explored to cope with the political and humanitarian
aifficulties. In this connection, my delegation wishes to express sincere
appreciation of the efforts made so far by the Secretary-General and his
representative, Mr. James Jonah, and especially the production of the
excellent report on the recent situation in Somalia.
My delegation supports the draft resolution before the Council,
especially the important decision to dispatch a technical team to Somalia. We
sincerely hope that the team will be accorded full cooperation by all parties
in that country and that the draft resolution will contribute to ensuring a
cease-fire, as already agreed upon on 3 March, and to ensuring that there will
be no impediment to the delivery of humanitarian assistance to the displaced
persons.
We eagerly await the Secretary-General's next report.
‘I shall now make a
statement in my capacity as. representative of Venezuela.
Somalia was for many years an active part of the theatre of confrontation
of the cold war, and then, paradoxically, it fell victim to the end of that
war, which has left as_a sad and distressing legacy a dangerousiy impoverished
people, dangerously over-armed and also dangerously undernourished.
As representative of Venezuela, I congratulate the Secretary-General,
Mr. Boutros Boutros-Ghali, on the expeditious way in which he has implemented
resolution 733 (1992) of 23 January. The consultatiens held in New York
between the parties to the conflict and the sending to Somalia of the special
envoy, Under-Secretary-General James Jonah, have at last made it possible to
establish a certain cease-fire. The cooperation and assistance of the
regional organizations, such as the Organization of African Unity, the League
of Arab States and the Organization of the Islamic Conference, have
undoubtedly contributed to alleviating tension and facilitating dialoque.
Both those developments are a significant example of the work that the
United Nations must do at this new stage in international relations and the
irreplaceable support that can be provided by those regional organizations.
Thanks to them we are now at a new stage in this painful African situation.
The draft resolution before the Council today underscores the two aspects
of Somalia's immediate problems. The first is reflected in paragraph 6 of the
draft resolution, which is aimed at continuing to explore the possibilities of
consolidating the cease-fire and ensuring the effectiveness of the
humanitarian aid and assistance urgently required by the Somali population.
The second is reflected in paragraph 9, which is aimed at recognizing that the
tragedy of Somalia will be resolved in a stable and definitive way only in so
far as the Somali nation recognizes the need for its own reconciliation,
putting an end to a terrible war that it is waging with itself.
Qn behalf of Venezuela, I should like to make a few comments on that
latter aspect of the Council's mandate, Somalia is at present a devastated
country in economic, social and institutional terms. Twenty years of civil
war have left deep marks on Somali society.
(The President)
Without a political settlement, the country will be unable to resolve its
civil and humanitarian problems. The challenge for the international
community is to reverse this process of alienation and the fratricidal
division of the Somali nation. Despite its recent painful history, that
nation has invaluable strengths, particularly those stemming from its
cultural, ethnic and religious unity.
In our view it is indispensable that to promote those purposes the
Secretary-General should turn to a personality of a very high level, widely
recognized internationally. That person could work with vision towards
achieving the delicate political task of national reconciliation as the
technical team carries out its work in respect of the cease-fire and
humanitarian assistance, Those efforts would be complementary and would give
the parties confidence in a future not limited to the presence of United
Nations monitoring mechanisms.
As the Secretary-General observed in his report, the substantive problem
that Somalia must face is the absence of a civil society. The international
community as a whole, and the Security Council in particular, can, should and
must respond effectively with assistance and advice in this extraordinary
African tragedy to which the international community too long remained
dangerously indifferent.
I now resume my functions as President of the Security Council.
IT now put to the vote the draft resolution contained in document 8/23722,
as orally revised in its provisional form.
A_vote was taken by show of hands.
In favour: Austria, Belgium, Cape Verde, China, Ecuador, France,
Hungary, India, Japan, Morocco, Russian Federation, United
Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, United States
of America, Venezuela, Zimbabwe
There were 15 votes in
favour. The draft resolution, as orally revised in its provisional form, has
been’ adopted unanimously as resolution 746 (1992).
There are no further speakers. The Security Council has thus concluded
the present stage of its consideration of the item on its agenda.
The meeting rose at 8.05 p.m.
▶ Cite this page
UN Project. “S/PV.3060.” UN Project, https://un-project.org/meeting/S-PV-3060/. Accessed .