S/PV.3842Resumption Security Council
▶ This meeting at a glance
23
Speeches
0
Countries
0
Resolutions
Topics
Security Council deliberations
Peace processes and negotiations
Peacekeeping support and operations
Balkans and Caucasus conflicts
Global economic relations
Diplomatic expressions and remarks
Europe
The President (interpretation from Spanish): The next
speaker inscribed on my list is the representative of
Malaysia. I invite him to take a seat at the Council table
and to make his statement.
Mr. Marzuki (Malaysia): Mr. President, my
delegation is pleased to participate under your able
chairmanship in this formal meeting of the Council to
consider extending the mandate of the United Nations
Mission in Bosnia and Herzegovina, including the
International Police Task Force (IPTF). Malaysia recognizes
the important role played by the IPTF in promoting civil
security by working closely with the parties to achieve the
fundamental reforms in law enforcement institutions in
Bosnia and Herzegovina. We therefore welcome the
extension of its mandate by this Council. Malaysia is
privileged and honoured to be part of the IPTF in
implementing its important tasks as outlined in annex II of
the Dayton Peace Agreement. We call on the international
community to provide the IPTF with the necessary financial
and material assistance so as to enable it to carry out the
additional tasks assigned to it by the London and Bonn
Conferences of the Peace Implementation Council.
My delegation wishes to take this opportunity to
express our sincere appreciation to the men and women
from various countries serving under the Stabilization Force
(SFOR) and the IPTF and other international organizations
who have contributed so significantly to the current peace
in Bosnia and Herzegovina, and to offer our condolences to
the families of the 12 dedicated officers who lost their lives
in a tragic helicopter crash last September.
Thanks to the presence of the multinational force, a
relatively safe and secure environment has now prevailed.
Important efforts towards building a unified Bosnia and
Herzegovina have begun to take root. The common State
institutions have been formed and are functioning, albeit
inefficiently. Increasing numbers of the displaced Bosnians
are beginning to feel confident enough to return to their
homes. At the same time, the international community has
made a significant contribution in the reconstruction efforts,
helping to put Bosnia and Herzegovina back on its feet
economically.
However, we are concerned that serious obstacles
continue to impede the full implementation of the Dayton
Peace Agreement. Mutual mistrust and animosity among the
different ethnic groups continue to obstruct efforts towards
realizing the ultimate objective of making peace in Bosnia
and Herzegovina an irreversible process. We wish to
remind the parties concerned that there is no viable
alterative to the Peace Agreement as the foundation for
building lasting peace and prosperity in a multi-ethnic,
multicultural and multireligious Bosnia and Herzegovina.
The attainment of this goal requires the full commitment
of the Bosnian leaders themselves. They all must be
willing to take bold steps towards establishing a
multiethnic State within its internationally recognized
boundaries, with fully functioning common State
institutions that command the support and confidence of
the people.
When the parties accepted the Dayton Peace
Agreement two years ago, they made a contract and a
commitment to, inter alia, respect the sovereignty,
territorial integrity and political independence of Bosnia
and Herzegovina. It is therefore imperative that they keep
their commitments, including ensuring that all the joint
State institutions are duly constituted and functioning
efficiently and effectively, and that all the attributes of a
sovereign State are fully bestowed on Bosnia and
Herzegovina to enable it to take its rightful place within
the family of nations. In this regard, the Bosnian entities
must work strenuously towards resolving the problems
now confronting the State, from the issue of appropriate
State symbols to the question of the currency and to
various laws that need to be passed by the parliamentary
Assembly.
My delegation believes that a durable peace can be
guaranteed in Bosnia and Herzegovina only through
reconciliation among its people on the basis of the
principles of justice and the rule of law. It is therefore
imperative that the perpetrators of the horrendous crimes
against humanity in Bosnia and Herzegovina be made to
face the consequences of their past actions. In this regard,
we are seriously concerned that many of the indicted war
criminals, including the most-wanted indictees, Radovan
Karadzic and Ratko Mladic, are still at large and continue
to exercise political influence and leadership in the Serb
entity. Their continued freedom constitutes a major
obstacle to the efforts to create a lasting peace in a
unified Bosnia and Herzegovina. If the long-term
prospects for peace are not to be undermined, they must
be immediately apprehended and brought to trial before
the Tribunal established for this purpose in The Hague.
The trial and appropriate punishment of those guilty of
the heinous crimes against humanity are indispensable in
bringing about national reconciliation, on which so much
of the future of Bosnia and Herzegovina depends. My
delegation believes that SFOR has a critical role to play
in apprehending these indicted war criminals. In this regard,
we commend the courageous action of SFOR in arresting
the two indicted war criminals.
To his great credit, the President of the Tribunal,
Judge Antonio Cassese, in presenting the Tribunal's fourth
annual report to the General Assembly last month, was
forthright in singling out the Serb entity and the Federal
Republic of Yugoslavia as the parties that have repeatedly
refused to cooperate with the Tribunal. We view their
refusal to recognize the authority of the Tribunal established
by this Council as a direct affront to the Council and the
United Nations as a whole and one which should not be
allowed to continue with impunity.
My delegation is concerned at the continued violations
of freedom of movement and at the harassment, destruction
of property and discrimination on the basis of ethnicity and
political affiliation that occur in many areas, especially in
the Serb entity. This has hampered the safe return of
refugees and displaced persons, and only a quarter of the
estimated 2 million refugees and displaced persons have
been able to return, most to the areas in which they belong
to the ethnic majority. It is essential that all the relevant
agencies, including SFOR and the IPTF, provide the
necessary support to the High Representative and the Office
of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees
(UNHCR) in the successful implementation of the return
programme, particularly with regard to minority returnees,
who have thus far encountered political, security and
administrative impediments. Clearly, the success of the
return programme is critical to the realization of a viable
Bosnia and Herzegovina.
As the peace implementation process in Bosnia and
Herzegovina enters its most critical stage, it is imperative
that the relatively safe and secure environment created by
the presence of the multinational force be maintained and
further consolidated to ensure that all the efforts and
resources invested so far will bear the desired results. The
international community cannot take the risk of
withdrawing the multinational forces from Bosnia and
Herzegovina at a time when State institutions are still weak,
suspicions and mistrust are still very much in evidence and
indicted war criminals are still free and exercising influence
and authority in the background.
In this regard, Malaysia welcomes the ongoing
discussions on the future role of the international
peacekeepers after the expiration of the SFOR mandate in
June 1998. We hope for a final consensus on this vitally
important issue and are encouraged by some positive
developments in that direction. We welcome in particular
the decision of the United States to extend the role of its
forces in SFOR. We consider a continuing military role
by the United States as pivotal to the viability of the
international peacekeeping force in Bosnia and
Herzegovina. We believe that the further presence of an
international force is necessary, and, as a troop-
contributing country, Malaysia will be prepared to engage
in consultations on that subject.
Clearly, there is a need to build confidence,
understanding and friendship among the ethnic groups in
Bosnia and Herzegovina so that it may be able to sustain
the process of national reconciliation. For this purpose,
Malaysia is prepared to make a modest contribution by
organizing a series of informal forums or workshops with
the participation of Bosnian groups and individuals and
international experts and facilitators. With the support of
Bosnia and Herzegovina, Malaysia proposes to convene
this forum in Malaysia soon. We believe that, given its
unique multi-ethnic, multilingual and multireligious
background and experience at nation-building, Malaysia
can make a positive contribution in this area. While the
international community will continue to assist, the main
responsibility for carrying out the tasks of nation building
ultimately lies with the Bosnian people themselves. Only
when they earnestly and sincerely carry out their
commitments under the Peace Agreement will the peace
settlement be truly achieved and the peace process
irreversible.
The President (interpretation from Spanish): The
next speaker inscribed on my list is the representative of
Slovenia. I invite him to take a place at the Council table
and to make his statement.
Mr. Tiirk (Slovenia): Mr. President, I wish to begin
by expressing our sincere appreciation of the fact that this
meeting of the Security Council is taking place under the
presidency of Costa Rica. The role of your country in
international peace is exemplary, and we believe that it is
most fitting and symbolic that the discussion and the
search for durable peace in Bosnia and Herzegovina is
taking place under your presidency. We are sure that this
month of December will be successful for the Security
Council.
The situation in Bosnia and Herzegovina continues
to be a matter of international concern. While some
progress has been made in the implementation of
Dayton/Paris Peace Agreement, as noted in the Secretary-
General's report on the United Nations Mission in Bosnia
and Herzegovina, it is obvious that further sustained efforts
of the international community are indispensable to stabilize
the situation and to make the peace process irreversible.
There have been some developments that should
encourage our common effort for peace. The Peace
Agreement concluded two years ago has been an important
achievement in itself. It stopped the war and opened the
path towards preservation of the independence, sovereignty,
legal continuity and territorial integrity of Bosnia and
Herzegovina. The implementation of the Peace Agreement
has established the lasting cessation of hostilities and
represents important progress in the domain of arms
reduction. The efforts of the High Representative have
gained wide international recognition and support. A
plethora of international organizations, financial institutions
and non-governmental organizations have contributed to
various aspects of the efforts to achieve economic
reconstruction and a durable peace.
Slovenia has actively joined these efforts. Recently, it
assumed further responsibility by becoming member of the
Stabilization Force (SFOR), and we are cooperating closely
with the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) in
contributing to various options for the post-SFOR operation.
In addition, Slovenia is in the process of establishing an
international fund for demining and for assistance to mine
victims.
The international concern for the peace in Bosnia and
Herzegovina has been most clearly expressed at the meeting
of the Peace Implementation Council held in Bonn on 9 and
10 December 1997. The Peace Implementation Council
reaffirmed that there is no alternative to the Peace
Agreement as the foundation for political and economic
reconstruction in Bosnia. The vital contribution of the
multinational Stabilization Force in providing a secure
environment for the implementation of the Peace
Agreement has been widely recognized. The Peace
Implementation Council confirmed an emerging consensus
on the need for an international military presence to
continue beyond June 1998. This remains indispensable for
any progress in the peace process in the future, and we
welcome the recent decisions in that connection.
The message of the Peace implementation Council is
clear: The responsibility for consolidating the peace rests
primarily with the authorities of Bosnia and Herzegovina.
The immediate neighbours of Bosnia and Herzegovina are
expected to take a constructive approach to achieving this
end and must assist in the endeavours for peace. Finally,
the international community has to take a robust stance
towards all the major problems impeding the peace
process.
These messages were echoed and strengthened in
resolution 52/150 on the situation in Bosnia and
Herzegovina, adopted by the General Assembly earlier
this week on 15 December. Slovenia is gratified that the
resolution was adopted by consensus, which clearly
reflects the unity and resolve of the entire international
community to work together for a just and durable peace
in Bosnia and Herzegovina and for the removal of all
obstacles that still impede that process.
Among the impediments to peace, some are obvious,
as are the measures to expedite their removal. Stricter
measures are needed to remove the war criminals from
their positions of influence over decision-making and to
transfer them for trial to the international war crimes
Tribunal. The efforts to secure compliance with the orders
of the Tribunal have to be supported and the courage of
those involved in such efforts, including the most recent,
have to be commended. The Security Council should
encourage further efforts to bring the criminals to justice
and enhance the effectiveness of the Tribunal, which the
Security Council established in 1993. This would not only
strengthen justice as a value in itself and safeguard the
credibility of the Security Council, but would also create
important conditions for the success of the peace efforts
in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
The Security Council should also render its political
support for the voluntary repatriation of refugees and for
the removal of obstacles which hinder the process of
repatriation. Harassment of the returnees, intimidation and
killings designed to discourage the voluntary return of
refugees must be stopped and, if that becomes necessary,
the Security Council should consider specific measures
against those responsible for such acts.
The return of refugees is also vital for the proper
functioning of the elected institutions in Bosnia and
Herzegovina and for the restoration of the ethnic diversity
that has always represented the essence of the identity of
the country. Therefore, it is essential for the very
existence of Bosnia and Herzegovina as an independent
and united country. The need to prevent attempts to
undermine the sovereignty of Bosnia and Herzegovina or
to achieve domination by a single group over the common
institutions will be best met by ensuring the restoration,
to the largest extent possible, of the ethnic balance in the
country. The basic guarantee to achieving this is to ensure
the necessary level of security of the population in Bosnia
and Herzegovina. This is a requirement which could
gradually lose its centrality in the peace process, in
accordance with the overall progress. However, it is of
central importance now and every effort must be made to
strengthen it. A continued international military presence
and the strengthening of the police component are the main
pillars of a secure environment in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
We support the suggestions of the Secretary-General
concerning the strengthening of the International Police
Task Force (IPTF) monitoring of police activities with a
view to effectively dealing with problems like corruption,
smuggling and financial crime. One important area of these
activities is also the functioning of the border-control police
units.
In addition to providing a secure environment, the
multinational Force should also take an even more active
role in supporting the Peace Agreement and those who
implement it. On the other hand, the Force should take
active steps against those who oppose the Peace Agreement
or refuse to comply with its provisions. The multinational
military and police forces need to play a role in
apprehending the indicted war criminals and in clearing the
obstacles to the safe and voluntary return of refugees and
displaced persons.
The success of other aspects of the peace process will,
to a large extent, depend on the completion of these tasks.
In this area, we see the primary challenge for the High
Representative. We therefore welcome and support the
strengthening of his mandate, in accordance with the
conclusions of the Bonn Peace Implementation Conference.
Let me conclude by saying the following: The efforts
of the international community so far have brought some
important progress in the peace process in Bosnia and
Herzegovina. We should renew and reinforce our
commitment to pursuing this process further and rendering
it irreversible.
The President (interpretation from Spanish): I thank
the representative of Slovenia for his kind words addressed
to me.
The next speaker is the representative of Turkey. I
invite him to take a seat at the Council table and to make
his statement.
Mr. Celem (Turkey): At the outset, my delegation
would like to commend the Costa Rican presidency and the
Security Council for scheduling an open debate on this very
important subject at this crucial stage. We expressed our
views in depth on the situation in Bosnia and
Herzegovina in the General Assembly in the debate under
agenda item 47 three days ago. Therefore, I will be brief.
It is noteworthy that considerable progress has been
made in implementing peace and stability in Bosnia and
Herzegovina since the signing of the Dayton/Paris Peace
Agreement. The fact is that, since the signing of the
Peace Agreement, considerable progress has been
achieved in the military field. Nonetheless. lack of
compliance on some crucial civilian aspects of the
Agreement indicates that the task undertaken by the
international community is far from complete. As
accurately reflected, most recently in the conclusions of
the Bonn Peace Implementation Conference of 9 and 10
December 1997, the fragility of the situation in the
country compels us to maintain a stable security
environment. The Secretary-General's reports of 8
September and 10 December 1997 and the latest report of
the High Representative for the implementation of the
Peace Agreement on Bosnia and Herzegovina all point to
the fact that the peace process has not yet become
irreversible.
In this respect, I would like to reaffirm Turkey's full
support for the General Framework Agreement for Peace
in Bosnia and Herzegovina and the annexes thereto. They
constitute the basis for the establishment of a durable and
just peace in Bosnia and Herzegovina. In order to heal the
wounds of the war and to attain lasting peace, it is
incumbent upon the international community to exert
every effort to help Bosnia and Herzegovina in its
arduous endeavour for reconciliation and reintegration.
Turkey, along with other States, is actively participating
in the implementation of both the military and civilian
aspects of the Dayton/Paris Peace Agreement and is
ready, on its part, to continue doing so.
With its resolution 52/150, the General Assembly
recently reiterated its full commitment to the stabilization
and consolidation of peace in Bosnia and Herzegovina
and reconciliation among its constituent peoples. We
welcome this unanimous decision reaffirming its concern
about non-compliance with the peace agreement and
demonstrating its willingness to take the necessary
measures in its power to obtain full implementation. For
this purpose, it is essential that all the conditions
envisaged by the Dayton/Paris Peace Agreement - inter
alia, cooperation with the International Tribunal, the
return of refugees and displaced persons to their homes
and the establishment of common institutions - materialize
without delay.
It is not possible to overstate the importance of the
work of the International Tribunal for the process of
reconciliation in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Turkey supports
fully the efforts of the International Tribunal aimed at the
prosecution of persons responsible for serious violations of
international humanitarian law committed in the territory of
the former Yugoslavia since 1991 and believes that States
and parties to the Peace Agreement must meet their
obligations to cooperate with the Tribunal.
The conclusions of the Peace Implementation
Conference on Bosnia and Herzegovina held in Bonn drew
particular attention to the failure of the authorities of the
Republika Srpska entity of Bosnia and Herzegovina and the
Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (Serbia and Montenegro) to
carry out their obligations. It is the duty of the international
community to exert the necessary pressure on the parties
which do not live up to their legal obligations of
cooperating with the Tribunal. At this juncture, it is
important to recall that, under the Dayton Accord, the
Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (Serbia and Montenegro) is
responsible for the Serbian entity's cooperation and
compliance, as well as its own.
Security Council resolution 1088 (1996), the Sintra
Political Declaration of the Ministerial Meeting of the
Steering Board of the Peace Implementation Council and,
just recently, the Bonn Peace Implementation Conference
all confirmed that international economic aid is conditional
upon compliance with and implementation of the Peace
Agreement. In this regard, we would like to stress the need
for timely information about the level of cooperation and
compliance so that necessary assessments can be made.
Turkey welcomes the positive steps taken towards a
normalization of relations between the Federal Republic of
Yugoslavia (Serbia and Montenegro) and Bosnia and
Herzegovina. However, there is ample room for progress in
this respect. Therefore, we call upon the Federal Republic
of Yugoslavia (Serbia and Montenegro) to fulfil
immediately the requirement of establishing full and
unconditional diplomatic relations with Bosnia and
Herzegovina. We believe that such a development will
provide the necessary tool to remove some of the existing
hurdles on the road to normalization.
Turkey also welcomes the successful conclusion of the
local elections of 13 and 14 September 1997. We expect
full and unconditional implementation of the election
results. Any attempt not to implement them will hamper
the delicate process underway.
Economic revitalization is essential for the process
of reconciliation, the improvement of living conditions
and the maintenance of durable peace, both in Bosnia and
Herzegovina and in the region. However, we are
dismayed that the package of essential legislation
establishing the common institutions of economic
management has not been implemented in full; nor has
the State-level legislation specified in the Sintra
Declaration been adopted. We hope that necessary steps
will be taken immediately, so that Bosnia and
Herzegovina can have an economic policy framework
which would allow it to start taking advantage of the
multilateral economic assistance already available. As
urged by the Organization of the Islamic Conference
Contact Group on 7 December 1997, the international
community must disburse expeditiously the funds pledged
for the rehabilitation and reconstruction programme of
Bosnia and Herzegovina.
The Implementation Force (IFOR) has played a
crucial role in preserving peace and order and in ensuring
progress on the peace process in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Turkey believes that the Stabilization Force (SFOR), as
the successor to IFOR, has been indispensable for the
maintenance of a stable security environment essential for
deterring or, if necessary, halting a resumption of
hostilities. We welcome the emerging consensus on the
need for a military presence in Bosnia and Herzegovina
to continue beyond June 1998. As pointed out by the
Secretary-General in his last report,
"Much has been achieved, but much also remains to
be done." [S/1997/966, para. 45]
At this volatile stage of the peace process, it is
essential that the international community continue to
exert itself persistently in order to achieve a lasting peace
in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
The President (interpretation from Spanish): I thank
the representative of Turkey for his kind words addressed
to me.
The next speaker is the representative of Hungary.
I invite him to take a seat at the Council table and to
make his statement.
Mr. Erdos (Hungary) (interpretation from French):
Hungary welcomes this discussion in the Security Council
of the activities undertaken by the international community
in Bosnia and Herzegovina and of the tasks that remain to
be completed in order to implement the decisions made in
the framework of the Dayton Agreement. We note in
particular the importance of the conclusions of the Peace
Implementation Conference held recently in Bonn, which
emphasized building on the achievements of the peace
process, continuing international assistance and
strengthening the role of the High Representative.
Hungary, which neighbours the Balkan region, is
profoundly attached to a political settlement of the issues of
conflict on the territory of the former Yugoslavia. It is also
attached to the preservation of the sovereignty and
territorial integrity of Bosnia and Herzegovina and of all the
other successor States of the former Yugoslavia. We reject
vigorously the proposals that have been made here and
there suggesting the dismemberment of Bosnia and
Herzegovina as a solution. It is not necessary to dwell at
length on the possible negative repercussions of such
destructive ideas.
We welcome the determination of the international
community to proceed on the track of carrying out the
civilian aspects of the Dayton Agreement. We also
welcome the intention of the Security Council to extend the
mandate of the United Nations Mission in Bosnia and
Herzegovina for an additional period. Hungary joined the
peacekeeping operations in 1996 by opening a base for the
Stabilization Force at Taszar, in the south of our country,
and by sending a logistical contingent of 500 people, which
last year was able to rebuild 20 bridges used for railway
and surface transportation. That contingent also began
demining operations in the immediate vicinity of those
bridges. This year the contingent is continuing its
reconstruction activities without interruption, in order to
facilitate the resumption of normal economic and
commercial life in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Likewise, my country has participated in the
operations of the International Police Task Force since it
was created and at the beginning of this year again
increased the number of its personnel serving in the Force.
Nevertheless, we note that the efforts made to improve
the economic situation in Bosnia and Herzegovina could be
accelerated further if the necessary economic legislation
were implemented and if the functioning of the central
bodies were made more effective. It is harmful for Bosnia
and Herzegovina that the laws which are absolutely
necessary for the recovery of the country's economic life
have not yet been approved by the competent bodies
because of differences in views, a lack of confidence or
the absence of political will.
Nor can we fail to underscore the importance of
reconciliation in Bosnia and Herzegovina, for if peace and
political and economic stability are not accompanied by
the corresponding psychological changes in the citizenry,
the situation in the country will remain fragile and the
results of the peace process may be reversed.
Administering justice, monitoring respect for human
rights - including the rights of minorities - education,
spreading the values of democracy and a free press could
contribute greatly to this process.
We note with satisfaction the arrest in Bosnia and
Herzegovina of two more individuals accused of war
crimes. We encourage the International Tribunal for the
Former Yugoslavia and the Stabilization Force to continue
their activities in this sphere, while emphasizing the need
to secure the full cooperation of all three communities in
Bosnia and Herzegovina, and of neighbouring countries
as well, so that the number of those brought to justice
will accurately reflect the true dimensions of the atrocities
committed there. It is time we remembered the bitter
lessons of this bloody century of ours, recalling the words
spoken at Nuremberg in November 1945 by the United
States judge Robert Jackson:
(spoke in English)
"The wrongs which we seek to condemn and
punish have been so calculated, so malignant and so
devastating that civilization cannot tolerate their
being ignored, because it cannot survive their being
repeated".
(spoke in French)
One might well wonder how many times the horrors
of the past will have to be repeated. The parties in Bosnia
and Herzegovina and the immediate neighbours of that
country must also shoulder their share of the
responsibility in efforts to reject vigorously aggressive
nationalist, racist and ethnocentric theories - theories
that in fact contributed greatly to kindling the inferno in
the former Yugoslavia.
We are convinced that in spite of the difficulties and
the passage of time, the international community must not
turn away from the developments in Bosnia and
Herzegovina, and must maintain its civilian and military
presence in that country. Here, Hungary welcomes
yesterday's announcement on this matter by the President
of the United States, and is prepared to continue to
contribute to reaching the objectives of the Dayton
Agreement. The Security Council can play an enormous
role in the uniquely complex endeavour aimed at restoring
normalcy to this sorely tried country.
The President (interpretation from Spanish): The next
speaker is the representative of Ukraine. I invite him to take
a seat at the Council table and to make his statement.
Mr. Yel'chenko (Ukraine): It gives me special
pleasure, Mr. President, to take part in this meeting under
your leadership. It is by coincidence that I had the honour
today to transmit to the Permanent Mission of Costa Rica
to the United Nations my foreign ministry's agreement to
the appointment of the first Ambassador of Costa Rica to
Ukraine.
Looking at the situation in Bosnia and Herzegovina
after more than six years of United Nations involvement
and two years after the General Framework Agreement for
Peace in Bosnia and Herzegovina was signed, the
international community can feel some sort of relief and
cautious optimism concerning the future of that country.
Despite the problems and the persistent difficulties on the
road towards the establishment of a democratic, multiethnic
State of Bosnia and Herzegovina, we cannot deny the
remarkable progress that has been made.
There is no doubt that it has been achieved thanks in
the first place to the efforts of the parties to the Peace
Agreement. However, the process could have been much
more difficult had it not been facilitated by the continuous
assistance of the international community. It is also true
that, despite signs of overall improvement, the present
situation in Bosnia and Herzegovina, as well as that in the
whole region, will continue to require agile efforts.
The Peace Implementation Conference held at Bonn
earlier this month demonstrated once again the existence of
a strong international commitment to the process of
reconciliation and nation-building in Bosnia and
Herzegovina.
The international community must concentrate on
preventing the political development of the country from
moving in a direction contrary to the Peace Agreement. In
this regard we should remove the temptation to use military
force and the fear that the latter will be used. Ukraine
shares the view that the Stabilization Force (SFOR)
authorized by Security Council resolution 1088 (1996)
continues to be an important element in securing the first
outcomes of the ongoing process of reconciliation and
State-building in Bosnia and Herzegovina, as well as in
contributing to the stabilization of the situation in the
Balkans.
We believe that the continued military presence in
Bosnia and Herzegovina should not be limited by specific
time limits, but should be measured by the progress in the
implementation of the Peace Agreement. This presence
can only ensure the concentration on the political,
economic and social issues and challenges that is so
desperately required.
Therefore, my delegation fully supports the
recommendation of the Secretary-General to extend the
mandate of the United Nations Mission in Bosnia and
Herzegovina (UNMIBH), which includes the International
Police Task Force (IPTF), to pursue the work entrusted to
it in accordance with annex 11 of the Peace Agreement.
With this in mind, my country stands ready to extend its
participation in a feasible post-SFOR operation to be
mandated by the Security Council beyond June 1998.
The delegation of Ukraine is convinced that the role
of the United Nations in the process of reconciliation and
civilian consolidation in Bosnia remains indispensable. At
the same time, inasmuch as further success in
implementing the Peace Agreement depends largely on
the fulfilment of its civilian aspects, the United Nations
role in the solution of the humanitarian problems should
be increased. In our view, the issues of demining,
economic reconstruction, human rights, the return of
refugees and law enforcement are of special importance.
The proper coordination of humanitarian efforts between
the United Nations bodies in the field and all other
international structures involved, including the Office of
the High Representative, the Organization for Security
and Cooperation in Europe, non-governmental
organizations and others, as well as between SFOR and
the IPTF, will be extremely helpful to that end. As no
agency has the lead in the field of human rights, further
coordination among the various organizations dealing with
different aspects of this problem is also necessary.
Demining still represents one of the serious obstacles
hampering the effective implementation of the civilian
aspects of the Agreement. There is no doubt that the
solution of this problem would substantially contribute to
the return of refugees, increased freedom of movement
and the economic reconstruction of the whole country.
As one of the contributors of personnel to the IPTF,
Ukraine notes with satisfaction that the Force has become
more assertive in focusing on enhancing freedom of
movement, police training and protection of human rights.
A high level of cooperation between the IPTF and SFOR
on the ground has proved to be very effective and should
thus be further developed.
The progress reached under IPTF guidance in police
reform in Bosnia and Herzegovina is also remarkable and
commendable. At the same time, we are of the view that
the multifaceted process of implementation of the civilian
aspects of the Dayton accords, in particular police reform
in the Federation and the Republika Srpska, should acquire
a more integrated character. Future progress cannot be
achieved in one sphere without being complemented by
relevant measures in another. We therefore share the view
that police reform in Bosnia necessitates adequate changes
in the country's whole judicial and penal systems.
It will be difficult to achieve final success in the peace
process in Bosnia unless the process is supported by
effective economic reconstruction in the country with the
continued assistance of the international donor community.
Top priority should be given to projects aimed at promoting
economic cooperation between the Federation and the
Republika Srpska, as well as within the Federation itself.
Both multiethnic entities and the three constituent peoples
of Bosnia and Herzegovina, along with all other peoples
residing in the country, should equally enjoy the advantages
of economic recovery, including international financial aid.
In this context, I should like to stress that all these
practical measures aimed at improving everyday life should
be guided by the need to build confidence and mutual trust
among the multi-ethnic entities in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
However, the primary responsibility for building a
viable democratic society as well as lasting peace and
reconciliation lies with the authorities of Bosnia and
Herzegovina. This will become a reality only with the full
implementation of the Peace Agreement by the parties
themselves, since it is up to them alone to define the
destiny of the country.
Finally, my delegation would like to join previous
speakers in paying special tribute to those who have
tragically lost their lives in the name of peace and a better
life for the Bosnian people. I should like also to take this
opportunity to confirm Ukraine's steadfast commitment to
the cause of peace in Bosnia in the pursuit of a secure and
prosperous future for that country and in the Balkans as a
whole, which, hopefully, has come closer during the past
year.
The President (interpretation from Spanish): I thank
the representative of Ukraine for the kind words he
addressed to me.
The next speaker inscribed on my list is the
representative of Canada. I invite him to take a seat at the
Council table and to make his statement.
Mr. Fowler (Canada) (interpretation from French):
Canada is pleased to participate in this meeting of the
Security Council in its consideration of the mandate of
the United Nations Mission in Bosnia and Herzegovina,
including the International Police Task Force (IPTF).
Canada is pleased to continue its support for and
contribution to the IPTF in Bosnia. The IPTF is the
largest international police mission ever fielded. Its
existence is an indication of the increasing importance of
the role of civilian police in peacekeeping operations.
Civilian police provide the transition from military to
civilian authority, from peacekeeping to peace-building.
In democratic societies, there is a security covenant
between the government and the people. This covenant is
still fragile in Bosnia, hence the role for the international
military and civilian police forces. The military provides
space between factions, and the police mission provides
monitoring and training for local forces, so that
democratic institutions can take root.
Democracy and national reconciliation depend on the
rule of law. The establishment of a capable, professional
and motivated multi-ethnic Bosnian police force is key to
achieving that goal.
Canada supported the call for a strengthened IPTF
for Bosnia at meetings held in October and December
1996 in Paris and London. That support was reinforced at
meetings of the Steering Board of the Peace
Implementation Council in Istanbul, Sintra, and, last
week, in Bonn. The IPTF has begun to show results.
Throughout Bosnia, it is carrying out rigorous weapons
inspections, reducing the number of illegal checkpoints
and applying pressure to ensure that joint police uniforms
and vehicles are used. It has also started a restructuring
and training programme with the Republika Srpska police.
However, it will take some time for training in the rule of
law and in democratic, community-based policing to have
some effect on ingrained attitudes.
(spoke in English)
Canada is pleased that the training component of the
IPTF's role is now expanding. This is all the more reason
for careful coordination between training agencies, the
United Nations Civilian Police (UNCIVPOL) and IPTF
contributors. We would welcome an update on the training
programme which discusses its effectiveness and future
plans.
The IPTF faces structural challenges inherent to any
large United Nations mission. It could be more effective if
there were better screening and training of international
police before deployment. Improved administration and a
clearer chain of command would also enhance the IPTF's
capabilities. In addition, it must work with small groups of
civilian police who arrive in Bosnia with different training
backgrounds and capabilities, and who are then placed in
mixed units in isolated police stations throughout the
country. Despite the evident difficulties, this approach
offers, of course, the opportunity for civilian police to
exchange training methods, and demonstrates to the local
population that multi-ethnic policing can be effective.
The IPTF's mandate, role and, indeed, its very
existence in training and monitoring are linked for the
foreseeable future to the continued presence of a military
stabilizing factor - currently the Stabilization Force
(SFOR), led by the North Atlantic Treaty Organization
(NATO) and authorized by the United Nations Security
Council. In order to gain the confidence of all parties, the
IPTF must be unarmed. However, the ability of the IPTF to
call on SFOR is equally important in carrying out its
operations. Recent successes with regard to investigations,
removal of roadblocks, weapons inspections and prison
monitoring would not have been possible without backing
from SFOR to enforce IPTF requirements.
Recently, some have suggested that there may be a
gap between the mandates of SFOR and the IPTF which
should be filled by armed police. This might be better
characterized as an attitude gap. SFOR and the IPTF have
unique and mutually supporting responsibilities for
establishing sustainable security and the transition to peace-
building in Bosnia. However, and this I emphasize, we
should not lose sight of our goal: reinforcement of the
capacity and willingness of the local police and
Government to fully assume their responsibilities within a
context of peace. These are their responsibilities, which we
urge them to assume and exercise. We, the international
community, must avoid the temptation of displacing these
authorities. This would send the wrong message, and the
underlying local conditions would remain unchanged.
In a related effort to empower Bosnian authorities,
the United Nations will shortly begin transferring the
authority of the Mine Action Centre to the local
government. This is a significant responsibility which
Bosnian leaders will need to address seriously. The
scourge of land mines is very real in Bosnia and will
require new leadership on the part of Bosnian politicians
from all sides. For its part, Canada provided the largest
in-kind contribution of demining experts of any
participating nation to the Mine Action Centre from April
to September 1997, and continued to provide personnel
until just recently. We expect we will also provide
personnel to the Bosnia and Herzegovina Mine Action
Centre next year.
In another related effort, as part of the international
community's drive for justice and peace in Bosnia and
Herzegovina, Canada announced the day before yesterday
an additional financial contribution of $600,000 and five
additional crime analysts to the International War Crimes
Tribunal to support its work of exhuming mass graves in
Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Close cooperation between the IPTF and SFOR in
recent months has been effective in implementing the
Dayton peace agreements and in ensuring that local police
function effectively. SFOR and the IPTF must continue to
combine their efforts, taking action in a coordinated and
creative fashion, using their respective strengths as part of
a long-term commitment by the international community.
The President (interpretation from Spanish): The
next speaker inscribed on my list is the representative of
Luxembourg. I invite him to take a seat at the Council
table and to make his statement.
Mr. Wolzfeld (Luxembourg) (interpretation from French): I have the honour to speak on behalf of the
European Union. The Central and Eastern European
countries associated with the European Union -
Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania,
Poland, Romania and Slovakia - and the associated
country Cyprus, as well as Iceland, align themselves with
this statement.
The European Union wishes first of all to thank the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General and
Coordinator of United Nations Operations in Bosnia and
Herzegovina, Mr. Kai Eide, for the tireless efforts that he,
his deputy and the other members of the United Nations
Mission in Bosnia and Herzegovina, in particular the
members of the International Police Task Force (IPTF),
have made to assist in the establishment of a lasting peace
in Bosnia and Herzegovina. We would also like to take this
opportunity to congratulate the new Special Representative,
Ms. Elizabeth Rehn, and to assure her of our full
cooperation and assistance in the discharge of her important
responsibilities.
The adoption without a vote by the General Assembly
on Monday, 15 December 1997, of the resolution on the
situation in Bosnia and Herzegovina was a clear message of
support for the peace process in Bosnia and Herzegovina on
the part of the international community.
The European Union wishes to recall that there is no
alternative to the Peace Agreement, which is the foundation
for the political and economic development of Bosnia and
Herzegovina and its two multi-ethnic entities. The process
initiated two years ago has been characterized by the fact
that it has been possible to implement efficiently the
military aspects of the agreements. Furthermore, the
international community has launched a substantial effort to
rebuild infrastructure in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Full respect for human rights and the rights of
minorities is closely linked to the restoration of a multi-
ethnic Bosnia and Herzegovina, with institutions operating
in full respect for the rule of law and in conformity with
universally recognized principles of justice.
One of the most delicate areas, which remains a
determining factor for the return to normality in Bosnia and
Herzegovina, is the training of police forces. Indeed, a great
many refugees and displaced persons, including those from
regions in which they were members of minority groups,
have still not returned home for fear of acts of intimidation
and violence. Administrative and legal measures must be
taken immediately to put an end to such acts. If these
measures are to be implemented promptly and without
discrimination, action by a police force imbued with
democratic principles is essential.
The European Union welcomes the progress made in
the two entities in restructuring the police thanks to the
tireless activities of the International Police Task Force. In
particular, we wish to welcome the disbandment of the
special units, the re-entry into the regular civilian police of
some qualified members of those units and the creation of
mixed police patrols. Furthermore, we wish to underline the
importance of organizing in the territory of both entities
courses on respect for human dignity and on the role of
the police in a democratic society, as well as the
importance of reopening and developing police academies
to ensure the training of police in accordance with
democratic principles.
Improved cooperation between the IPTF and the
local police, in the context of promoting freedom of
movement between and within the entities, and with the
assistance of the Stabilization Force, has enabled many
illegal checkpoints to be dismantled. The number of
checkpoints has been considerably reduced, and we wish
to welcome this positive development.
The close cooperation between the International
Police Task Force and the Organization for Security and
Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) made it possible to hold
orderly local elections on 13 and 14 September 1997 and
for the Assembly of Republika Srpska on 22 and 23
November 1997. This cooperation bodes well for the
general elections scheduled to take place in 1998 in
Bosnia and Herzegovina. To this end, the reform of the
media must be successfully completed so that they can
operate in a democratic and pluralist manner. The multi-
ethnicity of the parties needs to be developed.
The European Union wishes to pay tribute to the
work carried out by other divisions of the United Nations
Mission in Bosnia and Herzegovina, in particular the Civil
Affairs division, the Human Rights Office and the Office
of Press and Information. Furthermore, the European
Union wishes to underline the importance of the Mine
Action Centre, which will be called upon to continue to
play an essential role in Bosnia and Herzegovina after 1
January 1998, with the implementation of the Agreed
Principles for Demining, which have been agreed upon by
the Council of Ministers of Bosnia and Herzegovina.
While 1997 has seen real progress, further efforts
will have to be made in such diverse areas as the
re-establishment of security, the bringing to justice of
those responsible for war crimes, the establishment of a
free press, the return of refugees and displaced persons,
economic rehabilitation and the holding of local elections.
It is true that the results achieved will remain fragile if
further progress is not made soon. It is obvious that much
more could have been achieved had the authorities in
Bosnia and Herzegovina contributed fully to the
construction of a civic and democratic society in the
country. As we enter the third year of implementation of
the Peace Agreement and the last phase of the
consolidation period, major efforts are still needed to
ensure the functioning of viable structures in Bosnia and
Herzegovina and its two entities. The European Union is
concerned about the fact that the central Government in
Bosnia and Herzegovina operates without any organic law,
secretariat or fixed headquarters. The Assembly has met
only five times since its election last year. The central
budget is not funded by the entities, which withhold
customs revenues or do not collect them. Large sums are
being managed without the necessary transparency and
outside the legal process. Bosnia and Herzegovina still has
neither a flag nor a common currency.
The Peace Implementation Council met in Bonn on 9
and 10 December 1997 to examine progress made since the
London Conference on 4 and 5 December 1996 and the
Sintra Ministerial Meeting. The European Union welcomes
the convening of the Bonn Conference and fully supports
its conclusions. We hope that the decisive impetus given to
the peace process during that Conference will be
complemented by the full cooperation of all the parties
concerned.
We fully support the High Representative in the
difficult discharge of his duties. This action, as well as that
of the international community, remains indispensable in
the foreseeable future. Our ultimate aim is a Bosnia and
Herzegovina with an impartial administration that is finally
capable of governing itself and living within borders
respected by its neighbours.
The European Union reaffirms that it will not tolerate
attempts within the entities to undermine the sovereignty of
Bosnia and Herzegovina, nor will it tolerate attempts by
any group to dominate the political institutions of that
country.
The European Union would remind the neighbouring
countries of their obligations under the Peace Agreement.
These obligations must be fulfilled in their entirety,
voluntarily and immediately.
Furthermore, we would recall that in the framework of
its regional aid, the continuation of the European Union's
international assistance is linked to full compliance by the
authorities in Bosnia and Herzegovina and by the
neighbouring States with the Peace Agreement as well as
all subsequent obligations.
The President (interpretation from Spanish): The next
speaker inscribed on my list is the representative of Italy.
I invite him to take a seat at the Council table and to make
his statement.
Mr. Fulci (Italy): Italy associates itself with the
statement made on behalf of the European Union by the
Permanent Representative of Luxembourg.
We strongly support the conclusions of the Peace
Implementation Conference held in Bonn from 9 to 10
December 1997, which sets the stage for further progress
in the peace process in Bosnia. Since the last Peace
Implementation Conference in London, and thanks also to
the tireless efforts of the High Representative and his
office, it is fair to say that progress has been made.
To consolidate these achievements and make the
peace process irreversible, the international community
should take a careful look at the future. It is now up to
the parties to show renewed determination to respect the
conunitments they have freely entered into, and work
toward the full stabilization of the country and the region.
In this respect, we note that, thanks also to the action of
the High Representative, earlier this week the Bosnian
parliament adopted two of the three laws agreed upon in
Bonn. We also welcome the provisional entering into
effect of the law on citizenship.
In our view, improvements are needed in the
following areas.
First, the common institutions must function
properly. The elections held in Bosnia since 1996 have
favoured a trend toward a more pluralistic political
scenario. Consequently, the enhancement of political, civil
and media freedom, and the establishment of pluralism in
opinions and political parties must become priority
objectives. The ultimate goal should be political
stabilization through a continuing series of democratic
elections supervised by the international community.
In this context, respect for human rights and the rule
of law are the basis for all societies that intend to grow
towards prosperity and development. We trust that the
parties will commit themselves to protecting and
promoting these basic rights and be firmly committed to
ensuring respect for them in every sector of society.
Secondly, fostering good relations with and between
neighbouring countries is crucial to the implementation of
the Peace Agreement. But special relationships between
the entities and other countries should be in full
compliance with the Dayton Agreement. In this context,
I would like to recall Italy's assistance to the Bosnian
Presidency of the Central European Initiative in 1997,
which only a few weeks ago successfully organized this
year's summit in Sarajevo.
The maintenance of an international military presence
in Bosnia after the Stabilization Force (SFOR) mandate
expires in June 1998 is essential to ensuring security and
stability in Bosnia and the region. Italy therefore welcomes
the consensus that is emerging on this need. We are ready
to work with our partners on identifying the best possible
options. We believe that a presence led by the North
Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) continues to be
necessary and must have as broad a participation of
countries as possible. In this regard, we warmly welcome
the announcement made yesterday by President Clinton that
the United States will keep its troops in Bosnia. Let me
also stress that nobody, nobody can deny the extent of
Europe's current commitment, both in military and
economic terms. Italy, which is contributing many troops to
SFOR, will certainly continue to play its part, also in the
eventual multinational follow-up force.
My country is one of the major contributors of
emergency assistance and reconstruction aid to Bosnia and
Herzegovina.
We believe that an effective use of reconstruction
funds may prove crucial to fostering and consolidating
peace. Aid must be used as a catalyst to ensure genuine
reconciliation. Economic assistance should also be seen as
a way to encourage democratization in the whole region.
Conditionality does not mean penalizing or discriminating
against one or another party: it means encouraging everyone
to take a positive attitude towards the peace process. These
criteria should be applied to every aspect of the peace
process, such as respect for human rights - how
fundamental is respect for human rights, especially there -
the return of refugees, media restructuring, and the fight
against corruption.
Another essential aspect of the peace process is full
cooperation with the International Criminal Tribunal for the
Former Yugoslavia. It is our strong hope that the parties
will translate their commitments into effective and concrete
collaboration.
The Council is in the process of renewing the mandate
of the United Nations Mission in Bosnia and Herzegovina,
which is playing a crucial role in stabilizing the country,
especially the restructuring of law enforcement institutions,
through the International Police Task Force (IPTF), to
which Italy already contributes personnel and to which it
intends to allocate additional funding. In the context of the
peacekeeping operation in Bosnia, the IPTF has the
essential function of reassuring the civilian population and
paving the way toward national reconciliation and
peaceful coexistence. We welcome the Secretary-
General's intention to expand the Force's areas of
operation to key public security issues, such as financial
crime, smuggling and corruption, and judicial reform. The
IPTF's activities are of a long-term nature. We share the
Secretary-General's assessment that this progress is still
fragile, and therefore the Mission's engagement in Bosnia
will be needed for a long period to come. In this regard,
we agree that future security arrangements should be
carefully considered since they impact on the IPTF's
ability to function effectively.
Italy fully supports the draft resolution before the
Council, which it co-sponsored.
To conclude, allow me to assure the Council that my
country will continue its commitment to contribute to
international efforts aimed at restoring peace, security and
stability in Bosnia and Herzegovina and the region as a
whole.
The President (interpretation from Spanish): The
next speaker is the representative of Croatia. I invite him
to take a seat at the Council table and to make his
statement.
Mr. Simonovie (Croatia): Since I have already
elucidated Croatia's general views on the situation in
Bosnia and Herzegovina, in the General Assembly debate
on Monday, it is my intention to limit my comments
today to the role and the results of the International
Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia as they
relate to Bosnia and Herzegovina.
I wish to emphasize that Croatia assigns special
significance to the International Criminal Tribunal and its
work. Indeed, my country was instrumental in the
Tribunal's establishment. When it was ultimately
established in May 1993, one of its primary aims was to
contribute to peace by dispensing justice. This laudable
aim is not adequately reflected in the results to date.
Croatia does not condition its cooperation with the
Tribunal upon the reciprocal cooperation of any other
country or entity. Croatia has always considered
cooperation to be its legal, political and moral duty. We
believe that all other countries should have the same
attitude towards the Tribunal.
Due to its limited capabilities in comparison to the
magnitude of the crimes committed, it is apparent that the
Tribunal can only carry out its work in a selective manner.
Therefore, discretion in deciding which crimes and
perpetrators to pursue carries significant weight. Croatia
cannot be wholly satisfied with the exercise of this
discretion to date.
International sources have estimated that Bosnian
Croats and Muslims are responsible for about 10 per cent
of all the crimes committed in Bosnia and Herzegovina
during the conflict, while Bosnian Serbs are responsible for
about 90 per cent. Yet, at this moment, Bosnian Croats
represent 73 per cent of those in the custody of the
Tribunal. Furthermore, in spite of ample evidence, no
indictments are forthcoming for the crimes committed
against Bosnian Croats. The Croatian Government
maintains its insistence that the Tribunal must take action
in respect of these crimes.
The Tribunal's objective of dispensing justice, in
which my country and Bosnia and Herzegovina have placed
much hope, cannot be achieved if the present pattern is
maintained.
Concerning the recent arrest of two Bosnian Croats,
we wish to affirm that it is partly in order to avoid the risk
associated with the use of force that the Republic of Croatia
has encouraged the voluntary surrender of indictees,
Moreover, while the arrests are based on international law
and are within the scope of the mandate of the Stabilization
Force (SFOR), they have brought to an even higher level
the already existing disproportion of detainees, in terms of
the involvement of their ethnic group in war crimes.
While this debate proceeds, the architects of ethnic
cleansing walk freely in the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia
and Republika Srpska. General Mladic attends sporting
events in Belgrade, fraternizing with other former and
present senior Yugoslav army officers, some of whom are
responsible for the atrocities committed in Vukovar.
Radovan Karadzic gives interviews for foreign television
from Pale, where he pulls the strings in Republika Srpska.
Milan Martic, who ordered the shelling of Zagreb and is
indicted by the Tribunal for that crime, lives in a villa in
the immediate vicinity of SFOR headquarters in Banja
Luka. We should ask ourselves, what kind of message does
this send?
There is no doubt that the responsibility for war
crimes is always individual and that all perpetrators have to
be brought to justice. At the same time, due to its limited
resources, the Tribunal cannot prosecute all perpetrators.
Therefore, it is essential for the peace process that the
Tribunal in its future work better reflect the level of
involvement and degree of responsibility of the different
sides in the conflict. The fact that it has not so far done
so detracts from the achievement of justice and
reconciliation in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
The President (interpretation from Spanish): The
next speaker is the representative of Germany. I invite
him to take a seat at the Council table and to make his
statement.
Mr. Rudolph (Germany): At the outset I would like
to state that Germany fully supports the statement made
by the Permanent Representative of Luxembourg,
Ambassador Wolzfeld, on behalf of the European Union.
The latest report of the Secretary-General on the
United Nations Mission in Bosnia and Herzegovina
(UNMIBH) shares the analysis of the Peace
Implementation Conference hosted by Germany on 9 and
10 December 1997 in Bonn: namely, progress has been
made, but many steps are still to be taken towards a self-
sustaining peace, lasting reconciliation, tolerance and
democracy.
We firmly believe that the importance of the United
Nations Mission in Bosnia and Herzegovina in the
process of civil implementation of the Peace Agreement
can hardly be overestimated. In close cooperation with the
Stabilization Force (SFOR) troops, the Organization for
Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) and the other
international organizations and agencies present in Bosnia
and Herzegovina, the United Nations personnel, and in
particular the police officers of the International Police
Task Force (IPTF), face the unique challenge of serving
both as monitors and partners in dialogue of the local
authorities in order to establish a stable, non-
discriminatory environment of law, order and tolerance.
This engagement by men and women from 40 countries
deserves our respect and our full support.
A lasting, self-sustaining security and police
structure in Bosnia and Herzegovina, based on the
confidence of the citizens of all three constituent peoples,
cannot be established by international decree; it needs the
cooperation of the local authorities. The absence of war
can be imposed by international troops, but reconciliation
has to root in the peoples' hearts and minds.
We share the Secretary-General's observation that
UNMIBH should increase its contribution to the peace-
building process in an even more effective way, within the
limits of the current mandate, as outlined in Annex 11 of
the Dayton Agreement. While the monitoring continues, the
training programme for the local police will be enhanced.
Specialized education and training by international experts,
particularly in fighting economic crime and corruption, will
help not only to expand the capacities of the local police,
but also to limit the illegal profits of those opposing the
peace process.
Our increased input of international experience and
police skills in order to support the police of Bosnia and
Herzegovina in fighting crime and maintaining public
security will remain ineffective without a democratically
legitimized judicial system that guarantees fair
investigations and trials as well as acceptable circumstances
of detention. The international legal assistance should be
welcomed by all the parties as a chance, not as interference.
Last week's request of the High Representative's Supervisor
in Brcko to review the privatization programme of the
Republika Srpska shows the intention to work out adequate
regulations in a joint effort.
Germany therefore welcomes the Secretary-General's
intention also to increase the efforts of IPTF in the area of
judicial reform, as well. Germany is the second largest
police contributor to IPTF, having provided 166 well-
trained and experienced police officers. Germany has also
provided a prosecutor and other experts. We have extended
invitations for training courses in Germany to Bosnian
police officers. My Government is now considering ways
to meet the request contained in both the final document of
the Peace Implementation Conference and the Secretary-
General's report, for more contributions in the form of
training, funds and equipment.
UNMIBH and IPTF cannot operate in Bosnia and
Herzegovina without the necessary security arrangements.
At present, a secure environment for United Nations
personnel can be guaranteed only by the international
military force. In our opinion, the current distribution of
responsibilities between IPTF and SFOR has been effective
and has met the challenges. The civilian and military
international engagement are mutually reinforcing. Only a
successful civilian implementation under the protection of
the military forces can lead to a self-sustaining peace that
may finally make an international military presence
unnecessary.
But while UNMIBH - like SFOR, the High
Representative, the Organization for Security and
Cooperation in Europe, the European Union and many
more - stands ready not only to continue, but to enhance
its efforts, all authorities of the central Government and
the two entities must know that they themselves are
responsible for achieving reconciliation, stability and
democracy. The support offered by the extension of the
mandates of UNMIBH and IPTF must be met by their
full compliance with the Peace Agreement and subsequent
obligations. These commitments include, in particular,
cooperation with the International Criminal Tribunal for
the Former Yugoslavia.
Germany welcomes the arrest of two more persons
indicted for war crimes by members of SFOR on
Thursday night. The operation in Vitez underlines once
more the resolve of the international community to bring
the indicted persons to trial in The Hague. If justice is not
brought to Bosnia and Herzegovina, peace and
reconciliation will remain a distant goal.
At the Bonn Conference, it was clearly pointed out
that the patience of the international community is not
unlimited. Those who ignore or boycott their obligations
to cooperate, in particular in the joint Presidency, should
know that time is not on their side. Therefore, the Peace
Implementation Conference strengthened the position of
the High Representative. Germany welcomes the first use
of his new competences on 16 December, when the High
Representative imposed new legislation on citizenship,
effective 1 January 1998, after the Federal Assembly
failed to come to an agreement.
I want to close by expressing our gratitude and deep
respect for the work of the Secretary-General's Special
Representative, Ambassador Kai Eide, and his staff, who
can claim credit for the successful work of UNMIBH and
IPTF thus far. Ms. Elisabeth Rehn has all our best wishes
and support as she takes over Mr. Eide's task to work
towards establishing a lasting and self-sustaining peace in
Bosnia and Herzegovina.
The President (interpretation from Spanish): The
next speaker is the representative of Argentina. I invite
him to take a seat at the Council table and to make his
statement.
Mr. Petrella (Argentina) (interpretation from Spanish): It is a great honour to take part in this debate
under your presidency, Sir. You fittingly represent a
country that has played a key role in the successful
achievement of peace in Central America and that has for
a long time been an example of good government for the
entire hemisphere.
Argentina participated in the Security Council's
adoption in 1995 of the first resolutions designed to
implement the General Framework Agreement for Peace,
which was initialled in Dayton on 21 November of that
year. In our view, any assessment of the process that began
there must take into account the contrast between the
prevailing scepticism of that time and today's relative
optimism.
It is true that much remains to be done. A fully
functioning central Government, the practice of good
government, the return of refugees and displaced persons to
their places of origin, the exercise of freedom of
expression, cooperation with the International Tribunal and
the holding of municipal elections are some of the matters
that must be addressed as soon as possible. The difficulties
they present should not be cause for discouragement, nor
should they justify delays that jeopardize areas of
agreement or long-term objectives.
We are encouraged by the description in the Secretary-
General's report of the progress made in the
implementation of the Peace Agreement, especially as
regards the functioning of the United Nations Mission in
Bosnia and Herzegovina and, specifically, the fulfilment of
the mandate of the International Police Task Force. The
United Nations and all the agencies mentioned by the
Secretary-General that are involved in implementing the
Peace Agreement deserve our fullest confidence so that
they can successfully continue their difficult task.
We fully support the initiative to extend the mandate
of the United Nations Mission in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
We also hope that the International Police Task Force,
which is part of that Mission, will have the necessary
military support to carry out its functions during the period
of its mandate.
We would like to express our special appreciation for
the work being done by Mr. Kai Eide, Special
Representative of the Secretary-General, and by
Mr. Manfred Seitner, Commissioner of the International
Police Task Force. At the same time, allow me to express
my gratitude to all the countries that, in various ways, are
contributing to this delicate mission. Argentina is honoured
to have been part of the International Police Task Force
since its inception and will continue to participate as long
as is necessary.
Allow me to say, as we approach the conclusion in
this important debate, that what has happened in that
region and its consequences can be only partially rectified
by the tools available to this Council. We therefore
believe that every avenue of solidarity and assistance
must be pursued, in order to return as much hope as
possible to those who have suffered so much.
The President (interpretation from Spanish): I thank
the representative of Argentina for his kind words
addressed to my country.
It is my understanding that the Council is ready to
vote on the draft resolution before it. Unless I hear any
objection, I shall put the draft resolution (S/1997/989) to
the vote now.
There being no objection, it is so decided.
A vote was taken by show of hands.
In favour:
Chile, China, Costa Rica, Egypt, France, Guinea-
Bissau, Japan, Kenya, Poland, Portugal, Republic of
Korea, Russian Federation, Sweden, United
Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland,
United States of America
The President (interpretation from Spanish): There
were 15 votes in favour. The draft resolution has been
adopted unanimously as resolution 1144 (1997).
I shall now give the floor to those members of the
Council who wish to make statements after the voting.
Mr. Richardson (United States of America)
(interpretation from Spanish): It is an honour to
participate in this meeting under your able guidance as
President and in light of the leadership shown by your
country in this and in many other issues.
(spoke in English)
The action of the Security Council today to approve
the extension of the mandate of the United Nations
Mission in Bosnia and Herzegovina, including the
International Police Task Force (IPTF), demonstrates our
continuing commitment to peace in the region. Since
yesterday, we have assembled to debate in open session
on the situation in Bosnia and Herzegovina, a little more
than two years after the General Framework Agreement
for Peace was signed. We face many challenges ahead,
but our debate has highlighted the impressive level of
accomplishment thus far and should give us a renewed
sense of hope and resolve, however tempered by the
difficulties before us now.
Most importantly, a stable military environment exists.
Stockpiles of armaments are being reduced, and the
Standing Committee on Military Matters is helping to
bridge the gap between former adversaries. Thanks to the
North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) and the
multinational Stabilization Force (SFOR), the threat of war
has receded, affording the parties the opportunity to make
peace and to build a stable and democratic society. The
presence of these international armed forces is the biggest
factor contributing to implementation of the Peace
Agreement at the current time.
Despite lingering memories of war and conflict, the
seeds of reconciliation are growing. With the assistance of
the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe
(OSCE), democratic elections have been successfully held
for all levels of government, and new governmental
institutions are beginning to function. National institutions
have been established, and Federation joint institutions are
formed and operating. Although municipal election results
are being contested in some areas and implementation can
be slow, multi-party democracy is beginning to take hold in
Bosnia. While many of these institutions and structures may
not yet function fully or independently, the fact that they
exist and provide a potential forum for joint decisions and
policy-making was inconceivable to many just last year.
Meanwhile, economic prospects are brightening. In the
Federation, the gross domestic product is rising and
unemployment is falling. International reconstruction
assistance has made great strides in rebuilding
infrastructure, providing electric power, utilities, housing
and schools. Progress is being made on an integrated
telecommunications system, and airports in Sarajevo, Banja
Luka and Mostar are being opened to civil air traffic. We
hope that increased cooperation on implementation of the
Peace Agreement in the Republika Srpska will soon allow
more international assistance to be made available in that
entity as well. Assistance from the international community
must remain conditional on compliance with the Peace
Agreement and subsequent obligations.
Despite the encouraging signs, we cannot deny that the
people of Bosnia and Herzegovina - and the international
effort to assist them - continue to face daunting odds.
While there has been progress on common institutions,
more is needed. The leadership in Bosnia and Herzegovina
must do more to make economic revival self-sustaining.
Return of refugees and displaced persons also has not
been as rapid as we would like, even though it is perhaps
the key element of the reconciliation and rebuilding effort.
On this issue in particular we must make a concentrated
and concerted effort, on an urgent basis. While more than
400,000 refugees and displaced persons have returned
home, four times as many were displaced by the war.
Moreover, the remaining returnees are mainly those from
areas in which they are "the minority" group and where
they face even greater obstacles to their return. If we fail
to support the right of refugees to return home in safety,
we accept and legitimize the results of ethnic cleansing
and brutality on a scale which has no place in the late
twentieth century. Even worse, we create the conditions
for a new cycle of displacement and conflict which will
threaten lasting peace in the region.
Our focus on reconciliation also means political and
material support for the International Criminal Tribunal
for the Former Yugoslavia and continuing the pressure for
the surrender of all persons indicted by the Tribunal.
While gratified by recent improvement in cooperation
with the Tribunal by some parties, and strongly
supporting recent SFOR actions in this regard, we
reiterate that other parties' failure to cooperate can mean
only continued isolation.
The full establishment of independent media
throughout Bosnia and Herzegovina is also a pressing
priority for reconciliation efforts.
Another essential factor in the reconciliation process
and the rebuilding of civic life is the International Police
Task Force, which we have just addressed. The IPTF has
made valuable contributions to the retraining and
restructuring of local police and in helping to achieve
significant improvement in freedom of movement.
Increased and enhanced international contributions to the
IPTF are needed, especially in providing monitors with
specialized qualifications, and we warmly welcome the
pledges that have already been made in this regard. Police
reform is critical for all aspects of Dayton
implementation, including refugee returns, freedom of
movement and good governance. We strongly support the
recommendations made at the Peace Implementation
Conference in Bonn to restructure the IPTF to provide
maximum support to the most pressing civilian
implementation needs, particularly the creation of
specialized units to train Bosnian police to address more
effectively key public security issues.
The meeting of the Peace Implementation Council held
in Bonn last week demonstrated that the international
community remains unified and resolute in its efforts to
help the parties create lasting peace in the region. The
Council reinforced the authority of the High Representative
in the broad range of responsibilities related to civilian
implementation of the Peace Agreement. We strongly
support the important initiatives taken by the Peace
Implementation Council to ensure that the civilian
implementation effort has adequate authority and
sufficiently robust mechanisms to function assertively and
decisively, especially when addressing the serious problem
of corruption.
For our part, we will remain actively engaged with
NATO allies and SFOR partners in considering options for
the multinational follow-on force to SFOR to provide a
secure environment for civilian implementation in Bosnia
beyond June of 1998. It has become clear that continued
progress in Bosnia necessitates a follow-on military force,
led by NATO, after SFOR ends. In that light, President
Clinton yesterday announced that the United States can take
part in a security presence in Bosnia when the multinational
Stabilization Force withdraws this summer, to enable
intensified civilian and economic efforts in the region to
proceed in an atmosphere of confidence.
My Government agrees with the Secretary-General's
view that the future of the IPTF is closely linked to the
continued presence in Bosnia of a NATO-led peacekeeping
force. It therefore makes sense that further extensions of the
IPTF's mandate should be considered only when the details
of what will follow SFOR become clearer. That is why we
have supported a six-month extension of the mandate of the
United Nations Mission in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
As the debate on an SFOR follow-on force moves
ahead, we expect that IPTF will assume as much
responsibility for public security as it can. We should all
be thinking about how IPTF can play a more effective
role in pursuing our shared goals. My Government has
made a number of suggestions to improve IPTF's
performance under its current mandate. We believe these
should be implemented, especially those related to reform
of personnel policies. We do not claim a monopoly on
good ideas, however, and we welcome suggestions from
other IPTF contributors and the Secretary-General.
We have not pressed for changes in IPTF's mandate
in the context of this renewal. However, a prolongation of
the status quo is not acceptable. We have not foreclosed
the option of changing the mandate in the future if that
would help to improve IPTF's effectiveness. In the
meantime, we look forward to a constructive dialogue
with our United Nations partners on how to maximize
IPTF's contribution to peace and stability.
I would also add that my Government believes that
changes, for now, can be kept within existing financial
resources. Our vote in favour of this resolution should not
be interpreted as authorizing any increase in costs for the
United Nations Mission in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Finally, we join in expressing our deep appreciation
to the Secretary-General's Special Representative and all
the international personnel serving the cause of peace in
Bosnia and Herzegovina. We remember, in particular the
victims of the 17 September helicopter crash. Their
sacrifice and those of many, many others in the years
since the war began strengthen our resolve as we continue
our efforts to ensure a just and lasting peace in the
region.
The President (interpretation from Spanish): I thank
the representative of the United States for his kind words
addressed to my country.
There are no further speakers on my list. The
Security Council has thus concluded the present stage of
its consideration of the item on its agenda.
The meeting rose at 12.30 pm.
▶ Cite this page
UN Project. “S/PV.3842Resumption.” UN Project, https://un-project.org/meeting/S-PV-3842Resumption/. Accessed .