S/PV.4067Resumption1 Security Council
▶ This meeting at a glance
15
Speeches
0
Countries
0
Resolutions
Topics
Peace processes and negotiations
African conflict situations
Security Council deliberations
Peacekeeping support and operations
Humanitarian aid in Afghanistan
General debate rhetoric
Africa
Mr. Jagne (Gambia): My delegation would like to
thank you, Mr. President, for the initiative that you have
taken to organize this meeting. We are also grateful to Mr.
Fall for his very useful briefing.
The situation in Burundi is a source of concern for my
delegation. Notwithstanding the enormous time and energy
invested by the international community to find a peaceful
solution to the conflict, there is yet to be a breakthrough.
My delegation would like to take this opportunity to
pay tribute to the late Mwalimu Julius Nyerere for his
preponderant role and invaluable contribution in the Arusha
process. With the demise of Mwalimu Nyerere and the
resumption of hostilities, it would appear that the Burundian
factions are even further away from peace. There is
therefore an urgent need to redouble efforts with a View to
salvaging the flagging peace process.
As a first step, a facilitator should be identified as
soon as possible to continue the important work started by
Mwalimu Nyerere. The new facilitator should be someone
of high calibre, morally and politically. A former African
head of State, if possible, agreeable to the Burundian
parties, would be the ideal choice.
We note with keen interest that the parties concerned
are already considering some personalities and that they
will be discussed at the upcoming summit of the countries
of the Great Lakes region. We encourage them, in
consultation with the United Nations and all the parties
concerned, to reach an agreement on a facilitator as quickly
as possible.
The Arusha process, through its committees, has made
progress in many areas. The work of these committees
should be continued. We cannot afford to start the process
all over again. It is our View that we should build on what
has been achieved already rather than going back to square
one, especially at this time, when more and more civilians
are being targeted.
The situation is exacerbated by the fact that not even
humanitarian and United Nations personnel are spared. This
state of affairs is unacceptable to the international
community. We are outraged by these barbaric and
despicable acts committed against civilians, both local and
international. We therefore condemn the attack in Rutana
and all attacks against unarmed non-combatants. We call on
the authorities in Burundi to investigate these incidents and
to prosecute those responsible with the full vigour of the
law.
We must emphasize that it is the responsibility of
every Government to ensure the protection of its citizens.
We understand the concerns of the Government of
Burundi, but we fear that putting people in camps, away
from their farms, may not be the best solution. We
understand the constraints of the Government, but there
might be better alternatives. Having heard from the
Permanent Representative of Burundi this morning that
this is only a temporary measure, our fears have now
been allayed, and we look forward to the early return of
the families concerned to their respective homes.
The humanitarian situation in the country is
deteriorating very rapidly. The belligerents are not helping
the situation, either. With the recent trend of calculated
attacks against humanitarian personnel, the corridors for
the delivery of humanitarian assistance are shrinking
significantly. We urge all sides to ensure the safety,
security and freedom of movement of all humanitarian
personnel.
The presence of combatants in refugee camps is also
a source of grave concern to us. This unfortunate state of
affairs has been largely responsible for the numerous
reports of executions. The civilian character of refugee
camps must be respected by all concerned.
The latest report on the food situation in Burundi is
very bleak, and it is feared that next season will not be
any better. Relief assistance is therefore badly needed to
avert an imminent humanitarian crisis.
In the same vein, it is worrisome for my delegation
to note that, notwithstanding the lifting of the sanctions
against Burundi, the economic situation continues to
deteriorate. My delegation wholeheartedly supports the
expansion of aid to the Government of Burundi. We
therefore appeal to the donor community to resume
assistance to Burundi as soon as possible.
It cannot be gainsaid that the present civil war in
Burundi is hampering economic development. The
belligerents must understand this fact and stop their
people from suffering any further. They must get their
acts together, lay down their arms and negotiate genuinely
and in good faith for a final settlement. This would be a
welcome tribute to the memory of Mwalimu Nyerere. In
this way, his efforts will not have gone in vain. We hope
that the Burundian parties will see reason and heed the call
of the rest of the international community.
Mr. Fonseca (Brazil): I thank you, Mr. President, for
convening this meeting and this open debate. I also wish to
thank the Ambassador of Burundi for the comprehensive
information he provided for us this morning.
We commend the Secretary-General's efforts in
coordination with countries in the region to revive the
Arusha peace process. The situation in Burundi remains a
matter of great concern, as it poses a major threat to peace
and stability in the Great Lakes region.
The report presented a few days ago by the Under-
Secretary-General for Humanitarian Affairs, Mr. Sergio
Vieira de Mello, provides a clear picture of a tragic
humanitarian situation. A lasting solution to the crisis in
Burundi can be found only through political and diplomatic
means. We reaffirm our support for the efforts of African
leaders to achieve a negotiated solution to this conflict.
The Arusha peace process has been a relevant tool to
promote political dialogue in Burundi and should continue
to receive strong support from the United Nations and the
international community. We regret that the late Mediator
of the Arusha process, Mwalimu Julius Nyerere, can no
longer make his valuable contribution to the peace talks,
and we look forward to the timely appointment of his
successor. Peace in the Great Lakes region will be the best
tribute to his inspiring struggle for justice and development
in Africa.
We deplore the acts of violence committed against
humanitarian personnel in Burundi and the murder of two
United Nations aid personnel last October. In the light of
the recent upsurge of violence, the United Nations must
stand ready to react to a further deterioration of the
humanitarian situation. All parties concerned must refrain
from all acts of violence and commit themselves without
delay to a broad-based political dialogue with a View to
establishing conditions conducive to national reconciliation,
democracy and the rule of law. For its part, the
international community should be prepared to provide
support to the peace process and assistance to the
subsequent rehabilitation of the country.
I wish to recall that in March 1996, by adopting
resolution 1049 (1996), the Security Council requested the
Secretary-General to intensify the preparations for
convening a regional conference for peace, security and
development in the Great Lakes region in order to address
the issues of political and economic stability, as well as
peace and security in that region. Unfortunately, as the
security situation in the region deteriorated the necessary
consultations for convening such a conference could not
be undertaken.
We continue to support this proposal, on the
understanding that such a conference, convened under the
auspices of the United Nations and the Organization of
Africa Unity, would contribute to the search for
comprehensive solutions to problems affecting the entire
region - such as poverty, economic stagnation, arms
trafficking, the flow of refugees and the persistence of
violence.
We look forward to the report of the visit by Under-
Secretary-General Prendergast to the countries in the
region. We hope that his report will provide the basis for
a greater involvement of the United Nations in Burundi.
The President: I thank the representative of Brazil
for his kind words addressed to me.
Mr. Andjaba (Namibia): My delegation would like
to thank you, Sir, for organizing this open meeting to
address the situation in Burundi. Not only has this
situation destabilized the whole country, but its impact
has gone beyond its borders. It is in this context that we
extend our appreciation to Assistant Secretary-General
Ibrahima Fall for the informative briefing provided to us.
The Great Lakes region is besieged by many
problems that require the collective will, efforts and
support of the international community. We are deeply
concerned at the increasing violence and instability in
Burundi. We are also concerned at the plight of the
refugees who are fleeing continuing fighting between the
rebels and Government forces.
It is disheartening to know that innocent civilians are
the main victims of this conflict. They are forced to flee
their homes in search of safety or have been forced into
regroupement camps where humanitarian conditions are
appalling and where there is no adequate shelter or water
supply. Worse still, some of these camps are inaccessible
to humanitarian organizations.
We pay tribute to the late Mwalimu Julius Nyerere
for the leadership he provided and the tireless efforts he
made in bringing the parties to the negotiating table. We
cannot fail to recognize the role played by the United
Republic of Tanzania in the Burundi peace process.
Indeed, Tanzania has extended its hospitality to many
Burundian refugees, just as it did to many Namibians
during the days when we were fighting for the
independence of our country. Today, Tanzania, a least
developed country, continues to play host to about 300,000
refugees from Burundi. Tanzania continues to bear this
burden despite meagre resources. We hope that it will
continue to play a positive role in the negotiations.
We encourage the parties in Burundi to continue in
earnest with the negotiations in a bid to find a peaceful
solution to the country's civil strife. We call upon those
who have not been participating to join the process so that
peace can be found for all the people of Burundi. In the
same vein, it is important that the fighting stop, so that all
efforts are concentrated on a negotiated settlement. We very
much regret that it might not be possible for such a
settlement to be reached by the end of the year, but we are
hopeful that this will take place early during the new
millennium. We encourage the parties to resolve the
question of a successor to former President Nyerere, so as
to fill the vacuum caused by his untimely death, allow the
process to move forward and bring an end to the suffering
of the people of Burundi.
Let me emphasize that only inclusion of all the people
of Burundi - irrespective of ethnicity - in the political,
economic and social development process of the country
can bring peace to Burundi. It is up to the people of
Burundi to muster the courage and will to foster mutual
accommodation and acceptance. The international
community can only assist.
We call on the donor community to continue to
support the Arusha negotiations and to provide resources
and assistance for addressing the humanitarian needs of the
population in need of such assistance.
Namibia condemns the killing of two expatriate United
Nations workers in the Rutana province on 12 October this
year, deaths that led to the suspension of United Nations
humanitarian activities. We hope that these activities will
resume as soon as security conditions permit. Furthermore,
it is important that investigations into the killings are
carried out and that the perpetrators are brought to justice.
We are grateful to the Secretary-General for having
sent the Under-Secretary-General for Political Affairs to
Burundi and other countries in and outside the region to
consult with their leaders on the situation in the country and
the United Nations role in helping with the peace process.
We look forward to the outcome of his visit.
The President: I thank the representative of
Namibia for his kind words addressed to me.
Mr. Dangue Rewaka (Gabon) (spoke in French):
My delegation is grateful to you, Sir, for having been so
kind as to organize this debate on the situation in
Burundi.
It is regrettable that some of the parties in Burundi,
taking advantage of the vacuum created by the tragic
death of Mwalimu Julius Nyerere, the Facilitator of the
inter-Burundi talks, deemed it necessary to break the
ceasefire and relaunch the civil war. The delegation of
Gabon condemns this attitude and urges all those who,
overcome by despair, have resorted to the use of force to
return immediately to the way of negotiation and
dialogue. In our View only these means can lead to a
lasting settlement of the crises now shaking not only
Burundi but all of the Great Lakes region. This is why
my delegation remains convinced that the full
implementation of the Lusaka Agreement would also
promote the resolution of the situation in Burundi.
We ask all of those who are involved in the peace
process in Burundi to reach agreement as quickly as
possible on the choice of a new Facilitator, and that all
the Burundian parties be closely involved in the search
for peace.
Experience, indeed, has shown that those who are
considered small factions and have no authority to
influence the course of events have most frequently been
at the root of problems of insecurity and instability that
are delaying the normal conduct of the peace process.
In this regard the delegation of Gabon reiterates its
condemnation of the murder of staff members of the
United Nations and humanitarian organizations, which
took place on 12 October 1999 in the province of Rutana.
We welcome the Government of Burundi's investigation
aimed at finding the perpetrators of this act and bringing
them to justice.
The cycle of Violence resuming in Burundi is a
source of serious concern because it is increasing the
number of victims, in particular children and women, and
unleashing a large flow of refugees into the neighbouring
countries. We urge our brothers in Burundi to make a
reality of the solemn commitment they undertook in
Arusha on 21 June 1998 by signing the declaration
following the first round of negotiations, in which they
said:
"Aware of our historic responsibility, we share
the same conviction that we owe it to the Burundian
people, both present and future generations, to create
a climate of lasting peace in our country and to put an
end to the constant cycle of violence and fratricide
that has long afflicted Burundi,
"Aware of the suffering of our people, we are
determined to exercise, individually and collectively,
responsible leadership with the aim of putting an end
to this suffering and creating the conditions for
peaceful coexistence on the basis of democratic values
and security for all". (S/1998/562, annex I, p. 3)
To act in any other way would provide excuses to
those who remain reluctant to join the efforts at
reconstruction and economic and social development
undertaken by the Government and the people of Burundi.
The Secretary-General's report of April 1998 on the
causes of conflict and the promotion of durable peace and
sustainable development in Africa stressed the need to
provide aid and significant assistance to countries in
conflict. The state of poverty and the lack of development
which they must often endure can damage the efforts
undertaken to restore peace and stability in the countries
involved.
The President: I thank the representative of Gabon
for the kind words he addressed to me.
Mr. Hasmy (Malaysia): My delegation commends
you, Sir, for convening this open meeting of the Council to
consider the situation in Burundi. We believe that the
participation of the larger membership of the Organization
will contribute positively to the process of Council
consideration of the subject.
We appreciate the briefing given this morning by
Assistant Secretary-General Ibrahima Fall on the current
situation in Burundi. We were dismayed to learn from Mr.
Fall and from other sources that the situation on the
political, economic and humanitarian fronts remains very
bad and very disturbing. It is therefore imperative that the
international community and this Council redouble their
efforts to nudge the peace process forward and to
encourage the Burundian parties to work together for an
enduring political settlement. We hope that today's open
meeting of the Council will provide the necessary impetus
for these efforts.
My delegation does not believe that a lasting
solution of the Burundian conflict can be attained through
military means. In this regard, we note with concern the
current impasse in the political dialogue. We urge the
international community, particularly the regional States,
to continue to galvanize efforts to bring the parties
together to end the fighting and to commit themselves to
the political process. We urge the Burundians to search
for a lasting solution to their tragic conflict at the
negotiating table rather than on the battlefront.
Like other members of the Council, Malaysia fully
supports the initiatives of the regional leaders and the
Organization of African Unity (OAU) to assist Burundi in
finding a negotiated settlement to the conflict. We
welcome the African lead, while believing that the
Security Council and the international community also
have equally Vital roles to play. In this context, we wish
to pay tribute to the memory of the late former President
of Tanzania, Mwalimu Julius Nyerere, whose untimely
death has left a vacuum which must be filled as soon as
possible so as not to lose the momentum that he
generated with his tireless efforts. It is imperative,
therefore, that the current consultations among leaders in
the region to find a new Facilitator result in an early
decision. Time is of the essence. But it is equally
important to find someone with the energy, dedication and
stature of the late Mwalimu - one who can command
the respect and confidence of the parties.
We believe that the Arusha peace process remains
the most viable avenue towards achieving lasting peace.
We were dismayed to hear of the polarization that has
emerged among the Burundian parties and would urge
them not to lose faith in the Arusha process. We believe
that, while the hurdles are significant, they are not
insurmountable. The mediation efforts of the new
Facilitator must be given every chance to succeed,
representing as they do the most realistic opportunity for
pursuing dialogue among the key players. The momentum
towards peace generated during the early stages of the
Arusha peace process must not be allowed to grind to a
halt.
We note with grave concern that, as in many other
conflicts, the unfortunate victims of the conflict in
Burundi are the innocent civilians who are caught in the
middle. The deteriorating security situation, following an
escalation of violence in rural areas, has resulted in large-
scale population displacement and forced a suspension of
humanitarian assistance. While every effort should be
made by the international community to resolve the
conflict at the political-diplomatic level, there is an urgent
need to ensure continued humanitarian assistance to the
affected population so as to avoid further hardship and loss
of lives. The situation on the economic front is also a
matter of serious concern. Earlier expectations of
improvements in the economy following the removal of the
economic embargo by Burundi's neighbours have failed to
materialize, due mainly to the continuing Violence and
insecurity.
Unimpeded provision of and access to humanitarian
assistance are imperative if the situation in Burundi is to be
stabilized. Further human displacements will have serious
ramifications for peace and security throughout the Great
Lakes region. Preventing them should therefore be a high
priority of the international community. Malaysia condemns
the attack on the humanitarian mission in Rutana province
on 12 October resulting in the tragic death of two
representatives of United Nations agencies. We welcome
the decision by the Government of Burundi to institute a
thorough investigation of the incident and the subsequent
prosecution of those responsible.
Narrow sectarian interests must give way to the larger
interests and concerns of the Burundian people at large. The
international community can no longer allow acts of
unbridled violence to continue with impunity. Those who
commit serious violations of international humanitarian law
should be held responsible for crimes against humanity. We
also note that the recent spate of attacks on civilians has
resulted in the Government of Burundi's resettling some
130,000 people in regroupement camps, as confirmed by
Assistant Secretary-General Fall during his briefing.
Although such drastic measures are prompted by safety and
security considerations and may well have resulted in an
improvement in the security situation, we would urge that
the needs and welfare of the people placed in such camps
be fully assured and adequately provided. In any case, they
should be allowed to return to their Villages and homes as
soon as possible.
In conclusion, my delegation wishes to underscore that
the responsibility for ending the conflict lies with the
Burundian people themselves, particularly their leaders. The
genuine political commitment of the leaders is imperative
if a process of political dialogue is to succeed. We call on
all Burundians to end their ethnic and factional differences
in the larger interest of their country. They must seize the
opportunity provided by the Arusha process and begin the
task of rebuilding a united nation under a constitution
which enjoys the widest possible support. The memory of
the many Burundians who have perished and that of
Mwalimu Nyerere and his efforts should inspire them to
succeed.
Mr. van Walsum (Netherlands): A year ago, when
the Netherlands joined this Council, Burundi was often
referred to as a shimmer of light in a region of darkest
conflict. Regional sanctions were subsequently lifted, and
it was expected that by the end of this year the Arusha
peace process would result in an overall settlement.
Today I cannot but express the Netherlands' extreme
concern about the present situation in Burundi. Extremist
forces have gained new ground, and in this atmosphere
two United Nations staff were recently killed, one of
whom was a Dutch national. The perpetrators of these
murders must be brought to justice.
Amidst these deteriorating security conditions, the
humanitarian situation continues to worsen. We call upon
all parties to respect the relevant rules of international
humanitarian law. The neutrality and impartiality of
humanitarian assistance must be respected and everything
possible must be done to guarantee the safety of those
who deliver this assistance.
While we appreciate that a degenerating security
situation may call for exceptional measures, we do not
believe that the forced regrouping of the rural population
is an acceptable response. At any rate, we wish to remind
the authorities concerned that, by virtue of this policy, the
Government of Burundi has assumed full responsibility
for the safety and well-being of those who have been
regrouped against their will.
The untimely death of President Nyerere and the
subsequent interruption of the Arusha peace process could
not have occurred at a more inopportune time. The
Arusha peace process must be resumed as soon as
possible. We hope the parties concerned will soon be able
to identify a successor to Mr. Nyerere so that a dangerous
vacuum may be avoided. All parties must gear their
efforts towards an early resumption of the negotiations.
The Netherlands stands ready to continue its support for
the Arusha peace process.
The situation in Burundi is cause for broader
concern because of its potentially dangerous implications
for the entire region. The Arusha process and the Lusaka
process are intertwined: they are dependent on each
other's success. There is no hope for peace in the
Democratic Republic of the Congo if there is no prospect
of stability based on reconciliation in its neighbouring
countries to the east.
In conclusion, I wish to confirm that the Netherlands
associates itself with the statement the representative of
Finland will deliver on behalf of the European Union.
The President: I shall now make a statement in my
national capacity as the representative of Slovenia.
I would like to begin by expressing my delegation's
appreciation to Assistant Secretary-General Ibrahim Fall for
his briefing today. His briefing and other information that
we are receiving show that this debate is indeed timely.
Burundi is a situation of grave political crisis and one
where a humanitarian drama is evolving. We have learned
about 10,000 refugees since the beginning of October, a
number which has to be added to 300,000 refugees in
Tanzania and about 800,000 internally displaced persons in
Burundi. The reports which we receive from the United
Nations Children's Fund speak about the very rapidly
deteriorating health situation of children. One of the
illustrations is that of 287 health centres, which barely
deliver basic health services, 30 have been closed. If this
trend continues, the situation will become much worse.
Hence, there is a reason for saying that this is a timely
debate and for pointing out that this tragedy has to be
stopped.
Today's open debate can also be considered timely
because it is an opportunity for the Security Council to
reconfirm its support for the Arusha peace process. Every
speaker this afternoon and this morning has expressed
regret over the unfortunate, untimely passing of Mwalimu
Julius Nyerere, the Facilitator of the Arusha peace process.
Ambassador van Walsum said that many of us had
expectations at the beginning of the year that the peace
process in Arusha would be completed by the end of this
year, and now we know that that goal will not be realized.
Now it is clear that peace efforts for the restoration of
constitutional rule and the promotion of peace and
reconciliation will have to continue next year.
The appointment of a new facilitator is a task of
critical importance, and we share the disappointment over
the fact that the appointment has been postponed again. We
think that this is a priority task which has to be pursued
vigorously. Furthermore, we believe that it is essential that
all parties be given the opportunity and that they
participate. A peace agreement which does not enjoy the
support of all the players in Burundi will be meaningless
and will probably not be accepted by the entire
population.
Another basic problem which needs to be mentioned,
and has been mentioned by everybody in the discussion
today, is that of the safety and security of international
personnel. The sad events of 12 October 1999, when we
learned about the attack on an inter-agency evaluation
mission which was visiting a camp of displaced persons
in the province of Rutana, near the border of Tanzania,
showed how fragile and precarious is the situation in the
country, and how persistent is the violence. We believe
that every effort needs to be made to bring the
perpetrators to justice and to take the experience of this
tragic event as yet further proof of the need to
reinvigorate the peace process in Arusha.
The problems are many and they are frightening, and
the Security Council must be able to react. We hope that
the visit of the Under-Secretary-General, Mr. Kieran
Prendergast, will bring fresh information, new ideas and
proposals as to how the Security Council can contribute
to the overall efforts and how the United Nations can
support the efforts of the regional organizations. We hope
that the Council will be ready not only to follow events,
but also to act when necessary and make proposals or
recommendations as appropriate.
I shall now resume my function as President of the
Council.
The next speaker inscribed on my list is the
representative of Finland. I invite him to take a seat at the
Council table and to make his statement.
Mr. Kaeiriainen (Finland): I have the honour to
speak on behalf of the European Union on Burundi. The
Central and Eastern European countries associated with
the European Union - Bulgaria, the Czech Republic,
Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Romania and
Slovakia - and the associated countries Cyprus and
Malta, as well as the European Free Trade Association
country member of the European Economic Area,
Liechtenstein, align themselves with this statement.
With our message today to the Security Council, we
want to express our serious concern about the slow pace
of progress in the peace process and to deplore the
deterioration in the security, humanitarian and human
rights situation in Burundi and its regional implications.
These developments call for even more active engagement
by the international community and by the leaders in the
region. We should continue to support Burundi and its
people. We look forward to possible recommendations from
Under-Secretary-General Prendergast when he returns from
his mission to the region.
We had hoped that this year would have seen the
conclusion of a general peace agreement in Burundi.
Unfortunately, that is not the case. The current situation is
in stark contrast to that of a year ago, when the
international community regarded Burundi as a good
example of a peace process in the Great Lakes region.
The death of His Excellency Mwalimu Julius Nyerere
was an enormous setback to the Arusha peace process. The
European Union acknowledges his pivotal role as the
Facilitator who tirelessly worked towards peace and
reconciliation. He is greatly missed. Nevertheless, the
European Union considers it to be of the greatest
importance that the talks continue while a new Facilitator
is agreed upon.
The European Union welcomes the news that regional
leaders are due to discuss the future of the Burundi peace
process. The EU urges all parties involved to reach an
agreement rapidly on a new Facilitator and a format for the
deliberations. The European Union is of the View that the
continuing peace process must be based on the progress and
results already achieved in Arusha. We also note with
satisfaction that the Burundian Government has publicly
announced its commitment to the process.
The European Union reaffirms its support for the
internal negotiations and the Arusha peace process, which
are fundamental elements in the search for a sustainable
solution to the Burundian crisis. The European Union
encourages all Burundi rebel movements to join the Arusha
peace process so that the parties will choose the path of
negotiation rather than that of violence and conflict. The
Union is convinced that there can be no military solution
and that lasting peace in Burundi can be achieved only
through a negotiated settlement.
The European Union deeply deplores the renewed
outbreak of indiscriminate violence in Burundi, the main
Victims of which continue to be the people of that country.
We call once again on all the Burundian parties and other
armed groups in the region to immediately end all acts of
violence in Burundi. The EU urges that the neutrality of
refugee camps in the region be assured. It calls upon States
in the region to prevent the use of their territory to stage
attacks against neighbouring States.
The European Union strongly condemns the
targeting of civilian populations, including refugees and
humanitarian organizations. In the struggle between the
armed forces and the rebels, the Victims are mostly
women, children and the elderly. The European Union is
particularly outraged at the attack on the humanitarian
mission in Rutana province in October. It was shocked by
the massacre of several members of that mission,
Burundians and expatriates, including two representatives
of United Nations agencies. We call for the perpetrators
of this massacre to be brought to justice. The
humanitarian community's ability to distribute aid is being
severely hampered by the violence.
The European Union is deeply alarmed that, as a
consequence of the latest outbreak of violence, the
number of refugees and displaced persons has risen
dramatically, putting at risk the lives and well-being of a
large part of the population, especially the most
vulnerable groups. More than 1.1 million Burundians have
been displaced since the beginning of the conflict in 1993.
The European Union is particularly concerned about the
recent forced removals by the Burundi army of some
300,000 civilians in the countryside around Bujumbura.
We deplore the violation of human rights, the loss of
human life and the destruction of property which have
been the hallmark of this operation. We regret the anguish
and suffering to which the civilian population were
subjected during their forced transfer to the assembly
areas. The European Union calls upon the Burundi
Government to call a halt to the policy of forced removals
and to allow the people to return to their homes as
quickly as possible. In the meantime, it urges that
Government to provide the people with improved sanitary
and temporary accommodation conditions.
The bleak picture painted by the humanitarian
organizations in Burundi is coupled with a warning that
the situation will deteriorate. The humanitarian
community is warning that levels of malnutrition are on
the rise, particularly among children, and that the risk of
epidemics, aided by the lack of sanitation and safe
drinking water, is threatening the general population.
The European Union reiterates its appeal to all
parties to respect human rights and international
humanitarian law, to cooperate with humanitarian
organizations in the delivery of emergency relief
assistance and the protection of civilians and to guarantee
the safety and freedom of movement of their personnel,
as well as access to affected populations. We note that the
Burundi Government has assured representatives of the
United Nations and international non-governmental
organizations free access to all of the camps concerned to
enable them to provide humanitarian assistance. The EU
looks to the Burundi authorities to provide security
guarantees for personnel of the United Nations and
humanitarian organizations and to continue to afford the
Burundi Office of the United Nations High Commissioner
for Human Rights and its observers the same access.
The European Union also notes with interest a plan for
reform of the judicial and penitentiary system prepared by
the Government of Burundi, and it welcomes the adoption
of the new code of criminal procedure which will enter into
force next year. The EU emphasizes the importance of the
fight against impunity and urges the Government of
Burundi to accelerate investigations relating to human rights
violations, especially those where army units have been
involved, and to bring those responsible to justice.
The international community cannot be passive about
the situation in Burundi. All international actors have to use
the means at their disposal to contribute to the stabilization
of the country. The European Union welcomes the
Secretary-General's decision to extend the United Nations
political presence in Burundi until the end of December
2000. The European Union considers that the United
Nations presence can contribute positively to a peaceful
settlement of the conflict. It remains ready to support the
United Nations Secretary-General and the Secretariat in
their task of facilitating the restoration of constitutional rule
and to promote peace and reconciliation and the rule of
law. The EU calls upon the Government of Burundi to
continue its cooperation with the United Nations human
rights mechanisms, in particular with the Office of the
United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights. The
Security Council has a special role in helping Burundi and
its citizens to find a peaceful solution to this crisis.
In accordance with the "enhanced humanitarian"
strategy decided at the donors' meetings in Ottawa and New
York, the European Union gave 15 million euros in
humanitarian assistance in 1998, and this year it has
dedicated approximately 10 million euros. In addition,
bilateral contributions have been made.
Furthermore, two suspended development projects will
be reactivated, and 48 million euros are allocated for a
rehabilitation programme targeted at the resettlement and
reintegration of displaced persons. The European Union has
supported the Arusha peace process financially, and we call
upon States also to give their financial support for this
process.
We stand ready to provide further support for the
reconciliation, reconstruction and democratization of
Burundi. In this context, the willingness and readiness of
the parties to fully engage themselves in the peace
process play a pivotal role.
Mr. Kolby (Norway): I would like to begin by
expressing our appreciation to your Presidency, Sir, for
the initiative to hold an open debate in the Security
Council on the situation in Burundi.
Norway is deeply concerned by the recent increase
in violence in Burundi, in particular in the south and in
the environs of Bujumbura. We believe that this spiral of
violence must be stopped.
The international community has a special
responsibility to prevent another human tragedy from
happening in this region. Norway therefore believes that
the United Nations should and could play a more active
role in ensuring peace and stability in Burundi.
Norway has for several years actively supported the
peace and reconciliation efforts in Burundi and has also
been one of the major financial contributors to the Arusha
process. So far this year we have channelled $4.5 million
in humanitarian assistance to Burundi. Another $4.7
million has been channelled through the United Nations
system to the Great Lakes region in response to United
Nations regional appeals. Taking into account the present
severe situation and the need for supporting the
humanitarian efforts to restore peace in Burundi, we are
now also considering additional support in the near future.
The demise of Mwalimu Nyerere was met with great
sorrow. His leadership, as the first head of State of the
United Republic of Tanzania and as a peacemaker in the
region, made lasting contributions to a better world. He
will be greatly missed by us all.
My Government is concerned that his passing at this
critical juncture in the peace negotiations on Burundi
could lead to a vacuum in the efforts for peace and
reconciliation, which could further aggravate the security
situation in Burundi and cause a new escalation of
violence. We also fear that the violence in Burundi may
spread to neighbouring States and create increased
instability in the region at large. We therefore strongly
urge all the parties concerned to join in the effort to
appoint, as soon as possible, a new facilitator to replace
the late Mwalimu Nyerere, and also to resume without
any delay the peace talks in Arusha in a constructive
manner in order to overcome the present dangerous
standstill in the peace process.
It is important to see the present situation in Burundi
in the context of political events elsewhere in the Great
Lakes region, in particular in the light of the still volatile
situation in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. It will
be difficult to ensure peace and reconciliation in Burundi if
the Lusaka Agreement is not effectively implemented in the
Democratic Republic of the Congo. We are therefore
concerned by the recent reports of an increasing number of
Violations of the ceasefire in that country. We urge all the
parties to the Lusaka Agreement to respect the
commitments they have made in this respect, and we also
urge the Security Council to follow the situation in that
country with close attention.
The President: I thank the representative of Norway
for the kind words he addressed to me.
The next speaker is the representative of the United
Republic of Tanzania. I invite him to take a seat at the
Council table and to make his statement.
Mr. Bandora (United Republic of Tanzania): My
delegation joins others in commending you, Sir, on your
assumption of the presidency of the Security Council for
the month of November. We similarly wish to commend
the Council for its continued interest in the situation in
Burundi, and we thank Assistant Secretary-General Fall for
the extensive briefing he gave the Council.
For our country, this meeting carries a special
significance coming as it does on the last day of the
national mourning following the demise of our founding
President, the late Mwalimu Julius Kambarage Nyerere
who, in his capacity as Facilitator, tirelessly worked in
pursuit of a peaceful settlement to the problems facing
Burundi. The most fitting tribute the Council can bestow on
his memory is to rededicate itself to the resolute search for
a lasting solution the conflict in that country.
The situation in Burundi remains tense and
challenging. It remains a situation characterized by violence
and human suffering. It remains challenging to Burundi
itself, to the subregion, to Africa, to the international
community and, in this case, to the Security Council.
The Council is convening against the background of
two major developments, namely, the death of the
Facilitator of the Burundi peace negotiations within the
framework of the Arusha talks and the deepening crisis in
that country. It is therefore incumbent upon the Council
to take stock of where the efforts for a negotiated
settlement in Burundi stand and what can be done to
reinforce them in a manner that will reinvigorate and push
the peace process begun at Arusha further.
On 21 June 1998, when the all-party talks began in
Arusha, the participants in the Burundi peace negotiations,
including all the parties to the Burundi conflict, signed a
declaration of principles and intent. In the declaration, the
signatories committed themselves to engaging in serious
negotiations until a just and lasting solution to the crisis
in their country was reached, to resolving the crisis
through peaceful means and to putting an end to all forms
of violence; and they declared a suspension of hostilities.
In the declaration, the parties also identified and agreed
on five bodies of issues which were to be discussed and
decided to establish a committee to deal with each issue.
For the record, the five broad areas of negotiations were,
first, the nature of the conflict in Burundi, the problems
of genocide and exclusion and their solution; secondly,
democracy and good governance, constitutional
arrangements, questions of justice and the fight against
impunity, the judiciary, the system of administration and
transitional institutions; thirdly, peace and security for all,
issues of public security and defence, cessation of
hostilities and permanent ceasefire arrangements; fourthly,
rehabilitation and resettlement of refugees and displaced
persons, economic and social reconstruction and
development; and, fifthly, guarantees on implementation
of the agreement emanating from the Burundi peace
negotiations.
Since the convening of the second and substantive
session of the negotiations in July 1998, and the
beginning of work by the committees, considerable work
has been done. The principle of negotiation is firmly
established, and the parties have managed to sustain the
Arusha mechanism for those negotiations. Armed
hostilities have, unfortunately, not ended but the
negotiations have continued.
The countries of the region have taken note of the
disposition of the Burundi parties - in particular of the
Government - to negotiate, and has supported them. It
is in this regard, and in recognition of the progress made,
that the region collectively decided to suspend the
sanctions against Burundi in January this year.
As a neighbour of Burundi, our overriding interest
is in seeing to it that the Arusha process, which was so
painstakingly put together and which has made
appreciable progress until now, is sustained and steadily
brought to a comprehensive conclusion.
There will be accusations, as there have frequently
been against my country, that we support and harbour
armed elements operating against Burundi. This is an
allegation we reject most vigorously. We have stated time
and again that Tanzania has no interest in supporting armed
attacks against Burundi or in harbouring, training or arming
its opponents. We know we would be the very victims of
such a policy. In addition, my Government has challenged
the Burundi authorities to provide proof of their allegations.
To date, no such evidence has been forthcoming, and it will
not be, because the accusations are false and baseless. This
notwithstanding, Tanzania is determined, as a responsible
neighbour, to continue to honour its international
obligations relating to the hosting of refugees and, together
with the rest of the region, to strive for peace in Burundi.
Their peace is also our peace.
Considerable progress had been made by the
conclusion of the fourth session of the peace negotiations
held at Arusha in July of this year. Indeed, we are informed
that two of the committees have finished the bulk of their
work. The follow-up consultations between the
Government, the National Assembly, the Union pour le
progres national (UPRONA), the Parti pour le redressement
national (PARENA), the Front pour la democratie au
Burundi (FRODEBU) and the Conseil national de defense
de la democratie (CNDD) - which were held at Dar es
Salaam from 30 August to 12 September 1999 - were able
to thrash out a number of issues in detail. The follow-up
consultations that were scheduled to convene in mid-
October could not be held due to the passing away of the
Facilitator, Mwalimu N yerere.
This is where we stand today. How, then, does
Tanzania see the way forward? To us, the Arusha process
has been able to give a framework to the Burundi parties to
begin on the difficult but inescapable road to dialogue and
accommodation. Tanzania believes that the search for peace
and stability in Burundi is not a utopian effort. It is within
the reach of the parties, if the progress made so far at
Arusha is consolidated and expanded. We therefore see the
way forward as follows.
First, as the negotiations process has reached a critical
stage, it is important not to lose the momentum. It is quite
possible that in this state of flux attempts could be made to
create an impression that little of substance has been
achieved and that, since a new facilitator is being sought,
the process must be reconstituted anew and, worse still,
restarted. We should not allow this to happen. We should
instead ensure that the process of transition to another
facilitator is managed in a manner that ensures the
consolidation of the gains made in the process and its
continuity.
Secondly, we see no reason why the negotiation
process within the committees should not restart
immediately. For even during the facilitation of Mwalimu
Nyerere, the nitty-gritty of negotiations was done in those
committees, which were established by the parties
themselves. The committees, headed by individuals of
great experience and integrity drawn from around the
world, exist, and each has a specific mandate. The
facilitator comes in as an overseer to the process and as
a convener of the plenary sessions. In addition to the
committees, there exists a structure of experts that has so
far supported the work of the committees and assisted the
facilitator. We see no reason why these too cannot
continue to render services to the process even as the
consultations to designate a new facilitator continue.
Thirdly, in addition to the formal structure of the
committees, the major parties initiated informal
consultations to complement the Arusha process. Again,
there is no reason why that arrangement - which, at any
rate, is not dependent on the facilitator - cannot
continue.
Fourthly, as we aim at re-invigorating the process of
negotiation, we are also concerned at the increasing level
of armed activity in Burundi and the negative
consequences this is having on peace and security in that
country and on the negotiating process itself. It is
therefore important to see how best the armed elements
can rapidly be brought into the negotiating process as it
proceeds. We need to speed up the consultations in these
areas so as to bring an end to the violence in Burundi.
Fifthly, the Facilitator, the late Mwalimu, was
designated by the region. As we speak, consultations are
under way within the region on the designation of a
successor facilitator. A regional summit planned to take
place towards the end of this month will hopefully
finalize this matter. The region is fully aware that in
designating the new facilitator it will have to consult
extensively and to seek the concurrence of the Burundi
parties, as well as of the international community at large,
on the choice. The region is determined to ensure that an
individual of stature who can inspire the full trust and
confidence of the parties and who is capable of exercising
effective and undivided superintendence over the
negotiating process is designated as facilitator.
What, then, do we think the United Nations Security
Council should be doing? My Government believes that an
agreement in Burundi is possible only if the parties can be
further nudged down the path of negotiation. We believe
that the ground covered is considerable, even as we
recognize that fundamental differences still stand in the way
of that agreement. It is therefore important for the Council
to come out unequivocally in support of the Arusha process
and to continue to encourage the parties to persist in
dialogue and to remain committed to the principle of a
negotiated settlement. In this respect, the United Nations
must remain positively implicated in the ongoing
consultations on a way forward in the Great Lakes region.
Secondly, Tanzania believes that the Security Council
must itself maintain and urge sustained support for the
facilitation process and should also provide it with
resources. I wish, in this regard, to express the gratitude of
my Government, on behalf of the facilitation, to the
countries and organizations that have until now extended
financial and other support to the Arusha process. Such
support has enabled many actors to take part in the Arusha
talks, particularly the small parties in Burundi.
Thirdly, and lastly, my Government believes that the
United Nations must make contingency preparations for
the outcome of the Arusha process. We have learned in
other situations how tragic it can be if we are not
prepared. Burundi will need to be supported in the area of
reconstruction and in building the institutions that will
oversee the implementation of the peace process. The
people of Burundi will need assistance as they rebuild,
deal with the internally displaced and welcome and
resettle those who are in exile as refugees. Above all,
they will need the constant encouragement and support of
the international community as they heal, rebuild trust and
reconstruct a united and peaceful Burundi.
The President: I thank the representative of the
United Republic of Tanzania for his kind words addressed
to me.
There are no further speakers inscribed on my list.
The next meeting to continue the consideration of
this item will be held immediately following the
adjournment of the present meeting.
The meeting rose at 4.15 p.m.
▶ Cite this page
UN Project. “S/PV.4067Resumption1.” UN Project, https://un-project.org/meeting/S-PV-4067Resumption1/. Accessed .