S/PV.5110Resumption1 Security Council
▶ This meeting at a glance
39
Speeches
0
Countries
0
Resolutions
Topics
Peacekeeping support and operations
Peace processes and negotiations
Haiti elections and governance
Security Council deliberations
Economic development programmes
Sustainable development and climate
Americas
The President (spoke in Spanish): I should like
to inform the Council that I have received a letter from
the representative of El Salvador, in which she requests
to be invited to participate in the discussion of the item
on the Council's agenda. In conformity with the usual
practice, I propose, with the consent of the Council, to
invite that representative to participate in the
discussion without the right to vote, in accordance with
the relevant provisions of the Charter and rule 37 of the
Council's provisional rules of procedure.
There being no objection, it is so decided.
At the invitation of the President, Ms. Gallardo
(El Salvador), took the seat reserved for her at
the side of the Council Chamber
The President (spoke in Spanish): In accordance
with the usual practice, and in the absence of objection,
I shall take it that the Security Council agrees to extend
an invitation under rule 39 of its provisional rules of
procedure to Ms. Carol Bellamy, Executive Director of
the United Nations Children's Fund.
It is so decided.
I invite Ms. Bellamy to take a seat at the Council
table and to make her statement.
Ms. Bellamy: Let me begin by thanking the
Argentinean presidency for giving us the opportunity
to address the Security Council in its open debate on
Haiti.
The United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF) is
pleased to note the continued interest of the United
Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH) in
the human development dimensions of building peace
and security in Haiti. We have, through our team on the
ground, seen many examples of personal engagement
by the contributing troops to the well-being of
children, whether in Gonai'ves or elsewhere in the
country.
I would also take this opportunity to acknowledge
the important leadership of Special Representative of
the Secretary-General Juan Gabriel Valdes.
Today, I have been invited to contribute our
perspective on the situation of Haitian children, who,
as this Council may be aware, represent close to one
out of every two Haitians. In Haiti, one child under
five dies each hour. Every day, a mother dies giving
birth. Four children out of 10 do not go to school. One
child out of four suffers from chronic malnutrition, his
or her growth stunted forever. How can we guarantee
Haitian children their childhood? How can we build
peace and security and the future of that country
without ensuring the survival of its children?
The present peace process in Haiti is the third in a
period of 15 years. Imagine if we had invested much
more in Haitian children 15 years ago. Let us get it
right this time around and recognize that investment in
children is the best foundation to build a strong and
peaceful nation.
Haiti has never had universal and free education,
a fundamental factor for peacebuilding, for
reconciliation and for long-term sustainable
development. Education not only protects children, it
builds and gives them a sense of purpose and of a more
positive future. It helps them to become responsible
citizens who can contribute to the development of
Haiti. Simply, it takes them out of the negative vicious
circle of poverty and violence. It gives them hope.
I do, however, have good news. Under the
auspices of the Transitional Government, education is
becoming a more dynamic sector in Haiti, actively
supported by the donor community. Equally
encouraging, the private education sector, which
represents about 85 per cent of the total, is now more
integrated into the national education system.
A truly global, integrated approach also requires
essentials such as immunization, access to clean water
and decent sanitation, good nutrition, care and
protection from abuse. Children who have lived
through what no child should ever have to live through
need psychosocial affective support. Together with
many partners in the United Nations and externally, we
are strongly supporting actions in those areas.
Traditional donors, international financial
institutions, as well as countries in the region are
responding to the commitments they made about six
months ago in Washington, DC. In our view, after the
difficult year 2004, Haiti is now at a turning point.
There are good signs of progress, but children still face
major challenges. For example, we are increasingly
concerned by the thousands of children in Haiti living
today on the streets, often serving as domestic helpers
in slavery-like conditions, being trafficked or
experiencing other forms of exploitation. Many have
been drawn into gangs, their childhood literally stolen.
It is incumbent on all of us - adults, decision-
makers and leaders - to help break the cycle of
violence in Haiti and better to prevent and protect
children from abuse. So I would like to make a special
appeal to the Council and to MINUSTAH. In slum
areas like Cite Soleil and very poor urban areas - for
example, around Gonai'ves - children are held hostage
under the brutal and criminal rule of local gangs.
Today, the children in those places are denied their
very basic human rights. My plea to the Council is to
help them. I urge the Mission to keep on securing
urban areas such as Cite Soleil to guarantee a degree of
normal life and to allow the Haitian institutions, United
Nations agencies and non-governmental organizations
to work unhindered.
Finally, UNICEF appeals to every actor to
redouble its support for Haitian children. All of us
share in the responsibility for relieving their suffering.
Investing now in the survival, education and protection
of children is indeed investing in the future of Haiti.
Mr. Dolgov (Russian Federation) (spoke in Russian): We are pleased to welcome you, Sir, as you
preside over the Council. We thank Special
Representative of the Secretary-General Valdes for his
very substantive briefing on developments in the
settlement of the situation in Haiti and the activities of
the United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti
(MINUSTAH). We welcome the efforts and overall
work of the Mission he heads in the implementation of
its important mandate.
Russia has consistently supported the efforts of
the Transitional Government of Haiti to end the
violence perpetrated by illegal armed gangs. We
believe that a comprehensive and effective solution to
that problem will be promoted by the prompt
establishment of the national commission on
disarmament, demobilization and reintegration.
We welcome MINUSTAH'S efforts to assist the
Transitional Government in restoring law and order
and in launching a comprehensive national dialogue
and a process of national reconciliation open to all
political forces in Haiti. It is important further to
pursue work in those areas.
The Haitian authorities, working with
MINUSTAH and the Organization of American States,
must immediately undertake all necessary measures to
prepare for the holding in 2005 of free and fair
elections. We welcome the fact that work in that area is
under way, and it must be continued.
The restoration of legality must be pursued in that
country with due respect for the rule of law. We call on
all Haitian parties strictly to respect human rights and
to refrain from violence as a means of achieving their
political ends. We note the steps taken by the
Transitional Government to release unjustifiably
detained persons. We anticipate the prompt release of
all who have not been charged and expect that those
who are genuinely guilty of breaking the law will be
brought to justice.
It is important to develop long-term and
coordinated economic, financial and technical
assistance for Haiti, to be provided by the specialized
agencies of the United Nations system, international
financial institutions, regional organizations and donor
countries. A clear priority in that regard is the speedy
disbursement to Haiti of funds pledged at the
international donors' conference held in July 2004.
We anticipate that the deployment of
MINUSTAH's military and police contingents will be
sped up, so as to bring their numbers up to the strength
authorized by the Security Council. I would like to take
this opportunity to inform the Council of Russia's
decision to provide MINUSTAH with a team of
civilian police officers.
The challenge for both the people of Haiti and the
international community is to take into account the
lessons of the past and prevent a resurgence of
instability in Haiti that would negate the many years of
what, frankly, has been a costly joint effort to
normalize life in that country.
Ms. Lflj (Denmark): Allow me to formally
congratulate Argentina on becoming a member of the
Security Council and on assuming the presidency of
the Council. We are honoured to have you, Sir, the
Minister for Foreign Affairs of Argentina, chairing the
meeting today, which is a clear sign of the importance
your country attaches to finding a peaceful and durable
solution to the situation in Haiti. I also wish to thank
Ambassador Valdes for his comprehensive briefing.
Denmark fully supports his work as Special
Representative of the Secretary-General and Head of
the United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti
(MINUSTAH). My Government urges all parties
involved - at the national, regional and international
levels - to support the work of the United Nations in
Haiti.
Denmark also fully associates itself with the
statement that the Ambassador of Luxembourg will
deliver shortly on behalf of the European Union (EU).
Mr. President, a secure environment is a
precondition for a viable political process and for long-
term development in Haiti. Recurring incidents of
violence remind us of the urgent need to stabilize the
still-volatile security situation. In that context, we urge
all Haitians to refrain from using any kind of violence
to achieve their political goals.
Denmark welcomes the recent deployment of
additional military and civilian police units to
MINUSTAH. We would like to take this opportunity to
express our appreciation to the many troop
contributors. We are encouraged by the reported
improvement of the security situation at the end of
2004, and would like to see further action by
MINUSTAH and the Haitian National Police to
stabilize the situation in all parts of the country. In that
connection, my Government would like to underscore
the importance of demonstrating respect for all human
rights.
The ongoing high level of violence underlines the
urgent need for the effective removal of all illegal
weapons from the streets of Haiti. With the assistance
of MINUSTAH, the Transitional Government should
initiate a comprehensive and community-based
disarmament, demobilization and reintegration (DDR)
process. In that respect, Denmark urges the
Government to establish without delay a national
commission on DDR.
A national reconciliation process is very much
needed. Although the United Nations and regional
partners can play an important supportive role in such a
process, the initiative must come from within Haitian
society itself, and it must be based on the broadest
possible national political dialogue.
The Transitional Government should take the lead
in the national reconciliation process. We therefore call
on the Transitional Government to continue to explore
avenues for the creation of an all-inclusive political
process that encourages all segments of Haitian society
to participate. That process should be initiated before
the upcoming elections later this year.
Only 10 months from now, local, parliamentary
and presidential elections will take place in Haiti. We
welcome the agreement signed recently between
MINUSTAH, the Transitional Government, the United
Nations Development Programme and the Provisional
Electoral Council on the organization of the elections.
Denmark urges all parties involved to continue to make
all the necessary preparations to ensure truly free and
fair elections that will ultimately lead to the handing
over of power to an elected Government.
Poverty, extreme inequality and public corruption
have fuelled authoritarian rule and violence for
decades. The Haitian people longs for sustained and
equitable economic and social development. There is a
clear need for both long-term development
programmes and quick-impact projects. Substantial
funds were pledged at the international donors'
conference on Haiti last summer, where the EU
emerged as the largest donor. Regrettably, only little of
the aid pledged at the conference has been disbursed so
far. My Government urges financial institutions,
international organizations and donor countries to
accelerate the disbursement of pledged funds. In that
regard, we welcome the recent release of resources by
the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund.
Part of the problem stems from administrative
bottlenecks in Haiti itself. The lack of administrative
capacity and resources within the Transitional
Government and State institutions is hindering the
proper preparation and implementation of development
projects. Donors should therefore pay special attention
to the urgent need for capacity building within the
Transitional Government, as a prerequisite for effective
development cooperation.
For the Haitian people, last year was supposed to
be a year of celebration marking the bicentenary of its
victory over slavery and colonization. Unfortunately,
that did not happen. Instead Haitians found themselves
in the midst of the kind of violent political unrest that
has dominated Haiti for too long. It is vital that, this
time, the international community delivers on its
promises and helps the Haitian people to establish the
foundation for a secure environment and economic and
social development based on democratic principles, the
rule of law, good governance and respect for all human
rights. The Haitian people needs, deserves and expects
that to happen.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I thank the
representative of Denmark for her kind words
addressed to my country.
Mr. Adechi (Benin) (spoke in French): We would
like to thank you, Mr. President, and to congratulate
you for your timely initiative to hold a debate on the
situation in Haiti. I am also pleased to welcome the
presence of Ambassador Valdes, to whom I am
particularly grateful for having briefed us on the
situation in Haiti. I also wish to take this opportunity to
tell Ambassador Valdes how much we appreciate his
work on the ground.
The briefing made by Ambassador Valdes clearly
illustrated that Haiti is facing several major challenges:
achieving success in the political transition process that
has been taking place for a year now, improving the
security situation, re-launching the Haitian economy in
the short- and medium-term and promoting sustainable
development.
The political crisis that has rocked Haiti has deep
roots in Haitian society. It is important that Haitians
and the international community face the obvious,
namely, that peace in Haiti will only be sustainable if it
is based on a national consensus forged through the
participation of all of the country's inhabitants.
From this perspective, it is important that, as they
adopt positions and take action, the Transitional
Government and the various institutions that are in
place work, on a daily basis to promote the creation of
an environment that inspires unity and restores the
confidence of all those who fear for their future
because of their political sympathies or affiliations.
They will need to work tirelessly to bring about
national reconciliation and inclusiveness wherever
possible.
In several months' time, the country will hold
legislative and presidential elections - the final
milestone on its journey towards a definitive return to
the great family of the world's democracies. Given the
recent history of the country, we again urge the Haitian
political class to make the political concessions
necessary to facilitate the establishment of institutions
that will promote the return of peace and stability in
the country after the elections. The Transitional
Government should spare no effort to integrate within
the political arena all Haitian parties, as long as they
reject violence.
The second major challenge is to improve the
security situation, which continues to be of great
concern because of the abuses being carried out by the
armed groups that hold sway in poor areas and
markets. The international community must work to
ensure the better protection of human rights and
citizens' rights in Haiti.
Now that MINUSTAH has sufficient strength to
be fully operational, it needs to address the problem of
the lack of security with due resolve. We welcome its
recent success in this area. We believe that, in
accordance with its mandate, MINUSTAH can play an
active role in assisting the Transitional Government to
pursue the necessary major reforms being undertaken
in the area of security. From this perspective, the
rebuilding of the Haitian police and the army of the
republic are of paramount importance.
MINUSTAH now needs to increase its efforts,
working in an energetic and vigorous fashion with the
Haitian National Police, with a view to discouraging,
once and for all, the illegal armed gangs that continue
to prefer the language of arms to that of dialogue in
pursuing their demands.
In analysing sources of violence in Haiti, it is
clear to us that political violence and criminal violence
fuel each other. In order to eliminate such violence, we
must urgently establish an integrated, comprehensive
programme of disarmament, demobilization and social
reintegration, which must take into account the
problems of the country.
In this context, we must link paid disarmament
and the rejection of violence with the integration of the
people involved in a programme that brings together
vocational reintegration with rehabilitation, through
activities to promote a culture of non-violence and
peace, as advocated by United Nations Educational,
Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO).
However, such an approach can provide specific results
only if Haitians themselves believe in peace and work
to establish it within the culture, focusing on the goals
of economic recovery and social development.
The Transitional Government of Haiti must
urgently step up the process of establishing a national
disarmament commission and work to mobilize the
resources pledged to the country during the donors
conference held in Washington in July 2004, so as to
fund the implementation of the programme to create
30,000 jobs in the public sector and in the area of
environmental protection. In this context, the key to
success lies in support for small and medium-sized
companies.
A strategic approach that is well thought out
could help to ensure an effective interface between
assistance for stabilization and peacekeeping on the
one hand, and peacebuilding and the promotion of
sustainable development on the other, by permitting
immediate social change and necessary reform. That is
the second major challenge facing Haiti.
In this regard, we believe that MINUSTAH must
fully carry out its complex mandate so as to achieve
tangible results that are consonant with the many
human, financial and material investments that have
been agreed to in recent months by the Transitional
Government and the international community with a
view to ensuring collective responsibility for the future
of the country.
Prospects for the future of the country must be
restored by making use of the unprecedented wave of
solidarity that has been demonstrated by all the
countries in the region to help in Haiti's recovery. It is
also essential for Haiti to regain its place within its
natural family - the Caribbean Community. We urge
the States members of that body to overcome their
internal differences, which are hindering unity of
action with respect to that brotherly country, whose
people have, for decades, been suffering as a result of
poverty and political violence.
In conclusion, we welcome the establishment and
the beginning of the work of the Ad Hoc Advisory
Group on Haiti of the Economic and Social Council.
The establishment of the Advisory Group is further
proof of the international community's mobilization in
favour of Haiti. We also welcome initiatives to
promote a better contribution by the Haitian diaspora
to the rebuilding of the country.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I will now
make a statement in my capacity as Minister for
Foreign Affairs, International Trade and Worship of the
Argentine Republic - that sounds as though I am
announcing to everyone that it is my birthday so as to
receive gifts. But that is how the system works.
In my capacity as Minister for Foreign Affairs of
the Argentine Republic, it is a privilege to address the
Security Council. My country feels respect and
friendship towards the Haitian people. We are also
grateful to Haiti. On 9 June 1956, Argentina suffered a
coup d'etat. Seven rebels struggling to re-establish the
constitutional order, were granted asylum at the Haitian
embassy in Buenos Aires. The Ambassador of Haiti at
the time, Jean Brierre, saved his guests from being
abducted and shot, with words that we in Argentina
still remember today. He said,
"Just because Haiti is a small country does not
mean that it will allow such an abuse. Quite the
contrary, small countries must be scrupulously
respected because they are small - so that the
rule of law remains a moral imperative, not
something based on force".
My country also feels compassion for Haiti -
compassion in its true meaning, which is to understand
the suffering of others and to wish to share it.
More than a decade ago, the international
community realized that it was necessary to help Haiti
to break out of the vicious circle of poverty,
authoritarianism, violence and desolation. As
Argentina is presiding over the Security Council this
month of January 2005, we proposed to convene an
open debate on Haiti in the hope of finding realistic
and lasting solutions. The Organization has established
the United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti
(MINUSTAH), headed by a talented friend of my
country, Ambassador Juan Gabriel Valdes of Chile,
whom we congratulate on his outstanding performance.
MINUSTAH includes civilian and military personnel
from all over the world. It is an operation in which, for
the first time, many American States have decided to
act together: we feel that MINUSTAH is our mission.
The regional presence in Haiti has made us a part
of a search for a multifaceted solution that has a real
chance of enduring. In this context, my country would
like to see the creation of a number of mechanisms for
cooperation. Furthermore, working within our
capacities, Argentina is undertaking an analysis to
determine the potential for Haiti to export its products
to Argentina with a view to facilitating access to our
markets.
In the area of human rights - which is one of the
pillars of our foreign policy - my country supports the
efforts of the Transitional Government and urges it to
be extremely careful so that there are no violations of
the Haitians' basic rights.
In the humanitarian field, our country has also
wished to have a presence in Haiti. President Kirchner
mandated the participation of White Helmets for
humanitarian assistance. Solidarity is an excellent
therapy for many mental states: arrogance, desperation,
indifference, egomania.
In the context of rebuilding institutions,
Argentina has offered technical assistance to support
the Transitional Government in the tasks of organizing,
supervising and holding free and fair elections as soon
as possible. For the electoral process to succeed, a
broad-based dialogue among all the local political
forces is essential, the only condition being that they
explicitly reject the use of violence. That includes
leaders of the Fanmi Lavalas who have accepted the
democratic process and have rejected violence.
If being in Haiti today is a moral obligation, the
international community must provide the assistance
needed to cooperate in the functioning of a Haitian
State apparatus that can provide essential needs to the
country's inhabitants. The reconstruction of the Haitian
economy, together with the restoration of democratic
institutions and the maintenance of a secure
environment based on respect for the law, is essential.
The donor conference held in Washington
represents a new source of opportunities and hope for
Haiti, and we urge that it be translated into concrete
action. It will be necessary to identify infrastructure
projects and innovative cooperation mechanisms that
will generate economic reconstruction. Donors must
strive to honour their commitments.
We also hope that the programme of work
formulated by the United Nations, the United Nations
Development Programme, the World Bank and the
Inter-American Development Bank will be an action
framework through which we, together with the
authorities of Haiti, can begin to turn the situation
around. For projects that still lack essential technical
expertise, the region offers its most competent
technicians, who can join their efforts with those
already under way.
Sometimes, speaking with excessive candour can
leave the audience with the feeling that the speaker has
not been sincere enough. However, I have tried to
express myself with candour and also with sincerity.
My country renews its commitment to work for
development, peaceful understanding and social justice
in Haiti. I hope that this joint effort, which is the
purpose of this debate, will lighten the path towards
overcoming the difficulties and the injustice in Haiti,
that beloved Caribbean country.
I now resume my functions as President of the
Security Council.
I give the floor to the representative of Peru.
Mr. Balarezo (Peru) (spoke in Spanish): At the
outset, I want to congratulate Argentina on the
leadership it has demonstrated in the presidency of the
Security Council this month and also to congratulate it
on this initiative, which enables us to specifically
address a most important issue, which is one of the
complex crises faced by the region. I should also like
to welcome the presence of Juan Gabriel Valdes,
Special Representative of the Secretary-General and
Head of the United Nations Stabilization Mission in
Haiti (MINUSTAH), and to thank him for his report,
which has informed us in greater detail about the
progress made.
As our heads of State reiterated at the Rio Group
Summit last November, the stabilization,
reconstruction and development of Haiti are regional
priorities. That is why we welcome the strong response
from countries of the region in support of Haiti, which,
in the specific case of Peru, is expressed in the
contribution of a military contingent to MINUSTAH.
But complex crises like the case of Haiti also
highlight the new challenges to international security
that confront the United Nations. Therefore, our
commitment to international peace and security is
regional, but it is also universal. That is why Peru
participates in five peacekeeping operations in Africa
and Cyprus.
For Peru, restoring the Transitional Government's
control over civil order throughout the country is a
basic element of stability in Haiti; nothing is more
important than that aspect. However, in the case of
Haiti, the insecurity arising from the persistence of
illegal armed groups requires a special political and
inclusive effort. We see that the consolidation of a
sustainable security environment requires simultaneous
action on various fronts, especially in the political,
institutional and social development of the country.
We must resolutely support the reconstruction of
national capacities to strengthen the rule of law and the
exercise of civil rights and to help the people overcome
poverty. Peru is paying particular attention to the
development and implementation of the electoral
timetable planned for this year in Haiti. We also need a
transparent, robust and independent judiciary. That will
permit full respect for human rights and a resolute fight
against impunity and corruption. Strengthening the
judiciary is paramount.
The political and institutional development of
Haiti is closely linked to economic and social
development. Therefore, it is essential to adopt a
comprehensive, long-term strategy that will take into
account the many challenges facing the country. Peru
believes there must be a firm commitment on the part
of the international community to the reconstruction
and development of Haiti.
Certainly, the Haitian Government has a basic
responsibility to carry out the domestic efforts
necessary to lay the foundations for sustained growth
and poverty reduction. But the fact is that Haiti does
not have the resources to address the great challenge of
development on its own. Haiti requires international
cooperation in terms of financial and technical
assistance. Therefore, it is very important that
MINUSTAH devote special attention not only to the
humanitarian aspect, but also, and above all, to the
dimension of long-term development. Haiti requires
resolute support from the United Nations, the donor
community and the international financial institutions.
In its short period of existence, MINUSTAH -
thanks to the troop contributors, the Mission authorities
and the Security Council - has made progress in
implementing its mandate, including the civil
component, security and the preparation of the
forthcoming elections. But additional efforts are
needed in terms of contributing military and police
staff, disarmament, stabilizing the political system and
rebuilding Haiti.
Therefore, we must continue to provide to
MINUSTAH all the necessary means so that, at the end
of its mission, we will have a successful experience. A
good sign for the future would be to establish a longer
mandate period when MINUSTAH's mandate is
renewed. In addition - and this is a fundamental
aspect - we need to ensure that the funds pledged to
Haiti are disbursed.
In conclusion, we have the opportunity to create
the conditions for a promising future in Haiti. And, as
the Minister for Foreign Relations of Chile said, we
must not fail in that effort.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Luxembourg.
Mr. Hoscheit (Luxembourg) (spoke in French): It
is an honour for my country, Sir, that I am speaking in
this forum for the first time during this semester under
your presidency and on behalf of the European Union
(EU). The candidate countries Bulgaria, Croatia,
Romania and Turkey, the countries of the Stabilization
and Association Process and potential candidates
Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina and the former
Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, and the European
Free Trade Association countries Iceland and
Liechtenstein align themselves with this statement.
The European Union welcomes this opportunity
to address the situation in Haiti and notes that the
presence here of several high-ranking political
personalities underlines the importance of today's
debate. The European Union welcomes also the report
by the Special Representative of the Secretary-General,
Mr. Juan Gabriel Valdes, as well as the unanimous
decision taken by the Security Council on
29 November 2004 to extend the mandate of the United
Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH)
until June 2005, with the intention of extending it for
further periods.
The European Union notes that the United
Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti is nearly up to
its full authorized strength and that this has increased
its ability to use a more robust approach in
implementing its mandate, in particular when it comes
to conducting joint operations with the Haitian
National Police against illegal armed groups.
The European Union welcomes the recent
positive developments on the ground but notes that
further action is required to improve the overall
security situation in the country, which remains of
concern. In some areas, the lack of security is still an
impediment to effective humanitarian assistance and
project implementation.
The European Union urges all parties without
exception to refrain from any kind of violent behaviour
that would further imperil the welfare of the Haitian
people, to abide by the rule of law and to respect
human rights. We call on the Transitional Government
to take the necessary measures to put an end to
impunity.
We strongly believe that the ongoing crisis in
Haiti can be resolved only by peaceful means, through
a constitutional and inclusive political process of
national dialogue, compromise and reconciliation,
leading to free and fair elections by the end of this year
and to the transfer of power to elected authorities. We
strongly encourage the Transitional Government to
pursue its efforts in this regard, with the assistance of
the United Nations Stabilization Mission. In that
context, it is important that all political forces publicly
renounce violence and join the democratic and
electoral process.
The European Union strongly supports the
adjustments proposed by the Secretary-General in
November 2004 with regard to the structure of
MINUSTAH, in particular adding a formed police unit
to provide enhanced operational support to the Haitian
National Police; implementing quick-impact projects
that will directly improve the lives of the Haitian
people; and increasing MINUSTAH's capacity to
implement projects in the area of disarmament,
demobilization and reintegration into the community.
In that context, the European Union encourages
the Transitional Government of Haiti, assisted by
MINUSTAH, to redouble, as a matter of highest
priority, its current efforts aimed at removing all illegal
weapons from the streets and fully to disarm all armed
groups, in order not to jeopardize the democratic
transition process under way.
With 271 million euros' worth of pledges, the
European Union has emerged as the largest single
donor from the pledging conference on Haiti held in
Washington in July 2004. Those pledges do not include
contributions from individual EU member States. The
European Union will make every effort to reduce
bottlenecks and to disburse those funds promptly, with
a view to creating employment and achieving quick
and visible changes. A total of 45 million euros has
recently been approved for infrastructure projects, and
27 million euros for rehabilitation projects. To promote
the rule of law, the European Union, together with
Canada, has furthermore launched an important project
aimed at reforming the judiciary system.
The European Union is also providing substantial
financial support for the organization of elections.
Haiti is also on the European Union's priority list for
electoral observation for the local, parliamentarian and
presidential elections, scheduled to take place in
November and December 2005. An exploratory
mission is scheduled to be dispatched in June to assess
the feasibility of a European Union election
observation mission to Haiti.
The European Union fully supports the efforts by
the countries of the region, as well as those undertaken
by regional groups such as the Organization of
American States. We believe that the United Nations
should be present in Haiti for as long as necessary,
with a view to encouraging international support for
the sustainable political, social, economic and
ecological development of the country. In that context,
we support the activities of the Economic and Social
Council's Ad Hoc Advisory Group on Haiti.
The European Union, for its part, remains
committed to supporting the ongoing political process
and to playing its role in providing further help to
alleviate the Haitian people's suffering by means of
prompt humanitarian aid and continued long-term
assistance, with a view to contributing to lasting peace
and stability in Haiti.
The President (spoke in Spanish): The next
speaker is the representative of Guatemala, to whom I
give the floor.
Mr. Briz Gutierrez (Guatemala) (spoke in Spanish): Allow me at the outset, Sir, to welcome your
presence and to congratulate your country for having
begun its term of office as a non-permanent member of
the Security Council in the exercise of the presidency,
and for having taken, in this first month of the new
year, the initiative of convening an open meeting to
discuss the situation in Haiti. Guatemala wishes you
every success.
We would like also to express our appreciation to
the Special Representative of the Secretary-General,
Mr. Juan Gabriel Valdes, for his comprehensive
presentation on recent developments, and for the work
he has been doing as head of the United Nations
Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH).
Since the very beginning of the Haitian crisis, my
country has expressed its solidarity with the people and
the authorities of that country. Our Government has
also publicly expressed its sincere wish that all
political sectors in Haiti find a way of preserving
democracy and of creating a favourable environment
that will help ensure the sustainable development of
the country. We know that this objective can be
accomplished only if the international community
promotes a cooperative long-term effort that is not only
generous in nature and well coordinated but also goes
beyond merely putting an end to violence and
confrontation.
The security situation in the country, the
weakness of the judiciary and the ongoing problem of
impunity are but a few of the major obstacles that the
Haitian people face. That is why Guatemala deems it
important that the international community and
relevant regional organizations continue to support
Haiti in the promotion and protection of fundamental
rights, particularly of women and children, assisting in
the investigation of abuses and seeking to end impunity
through the reform and strengthening of institutions
charged with the administration of justice. As we know
from firsthand experience, that is not an easy task.
We also appeal to the Transitional Government to
take concrete measures to prevent such abuses through
the effective investigation of reported cases and the
prosecution of those responsible. We reiterate the need to
follow procedures that have proved to be fair and
effective and that are consistent with international norms
and the corresponding right of all to due process - in
particular the right to be heard by a competent,
independent and impartial court without discrimination of
any kind.
The delegation of Guatemala believes that
another fundamental problem is the extreme poverty
prevailing in the country as well as the high rate of
illiteracy and malnutrition that continue to deprive the
Haitian people of their basic economic, social and
cultural rights. That in turn aggravates the
consequences of the lack of observance of their basic
civil and political rights.
We are aware of the fact that this represents a
tremendous challenge to the Transitional Government.
We urge it, in collaboration with all sectors of society
and the support of the international community, to
design and implement the development plan that will
enable it to meet the fundamental economic and social
needs of every Haitian citizen.
It is also important to take into account at all
times the country's vulnerability to natural disasters, as
we saw with tropical storm Jeanne, which struck the
country a few months ago.
Accordingly, we believe that the Ad Hoc
Advisory Group on Haiti set up by the Economic and
Social Council and reactivated by a decision adopted
on 15 November 2004 is a mechanism that has
contributed to revitalizing the link between the
Economic and Social Council and the Security
Council. It has also provided a tangible framework
within which the United Nations and the Bretton
Woods institutions have deepened their cooperation in
support of Haiti.
In keeping with its policy of promoting
multilateral solutions to conflicts, the Government of
Guatemala has reaffirmed its commitment and its
willingness to participate in MINUSTAH, established
by the Council pursuant to resolution 1542 (2004). In
that framework, a contingent of Guatemalan military
police officers constitutes our current contribution to
MINUSTAH.
Guatemala reaffirms its support for the
Stabilization Mission, which is working tirelessly to
carry out its mandate to consolidate stability in the
country, support the constitutional and political
process, help the Transitional Government to hold
elections and assist Haitian institutions in ensuring
respect for human rights, among other tasks.
Thus, it is important to recognize that a military
presence alone cannot ensure the political stabilization
of Haiti. It is worrisome that prevailing conditions
make it difficult to bring about solid and lasting
national reconciliation. Coordination among the
regional organizations, agencies, programmes and non-
governmental organizations in support of the
Transitional Government's establishment of a secure
and stable environment is a crucial element for fully
taking the most efficient advantage of all the work
being carried out on the ground.
Guatemala stresses the importance of the
elections scheduled to take place in Haiti at the end of
2005. We believe that they will provide an opportunity
to create greater stability for the country's future.
Finally, in connection with that challenge and all
the other challenges that Haiti and its people face, my
delegation renews its appeal to the international
community to provide Haiti with the support and
assistance needed to overcome the difficulties of the
past and enable the country to advance towards a future
that will witness the full realization of the rule of law,
democracy and respect for human rights.
The President (spoke in Spanish): The next
speaker inscribed on my list is the representative of
Mexico, to whom I give the floor.
Mr. Berruga (Mexico) (spoke in Spanish): At the
outset, allow me to wish all success to Argentina as it
begins its mandate on the Security Council and
assumes the presidency for the month of January.
The question of Haiti has particular relevance in
the foreign policy of Mexico. For that reason, my
Government considers this debate, wisely convened by
the Argentine presidency, to be a good opportunity to
share some of the guiding ideas of our policy on that
Caribbean country.
Mexico supports the efforts of the international
community, in particular those of our continent, to
restore peace and security in Haiti and to reconstruct
its democratic institutions. Moreover, we express our
firmest support for the activities of the United Nations
Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH), whose
principal civil and military component is of Latin
American origin. In particular, Mexico expresses its
support for the work of the Special Representative of
the Secretary-General for Haiti and Head of
MINUSTAH, Ambassador Juan Gabriel Valdes.
Mexico agrees with Secretary-General Kofi
Annan that the international community's
commitments towards Haiti should be of a
comprehensive and long-term nature, with the goal of
resolving the structural problems that that brotherly
country continues to face.
We believe that the priority for 2005 should be to
promote political dialogue among all groups of actors
in Haiti, without exclusion, with a view to preparing
and holding the local and presidential elections, which
should be participatory, representative and legitimate.
At the same time, it is necessary to maintain a
medium- and long-term plan for the reconstruction of
solid institutions for Haitian society, especially in the
areas of justice administration and prosecution, human
rights, the fight against poverty, the creation of
infrastructure and the development of high-quality
health, education and other services.
The participation and support of the Caribbean
Community (CARICOM) in the resolution of the
Haitian crisis are fundamental. For that reason, the
initiatives taken in the framework of the United
Nations, the Organization of American States, other
regional groupings and financial organizations should
be coordinated with the Caribbean countries.
In the various forums and mechanisms concerned
with the Haitian crisis, Mexico will continue to offer
its support, especially in the reconstruction of the
country's civilian institutions. As well, we will
continue to provide timely humanitarian assistance as
we have been doing so far.
Allow me to give a brief account of the actions of
cooperation taken by Mexico at the bilateral and
regional levels. During 2004, the Government of
Mexico sent emergency humanitarian aid to Haiti on
four occasions. In April, Mexico responded to the
appeal of the interim President, Mr. Boniface
Alexandre, and we sent 1,012 tons of aid, in particular
food and medicines. On 5 June, Mexico sent 19 tons of
food and medicine in response to the crisis caused by
the heavy rains that devastated Haitian communities
along the border with the Dominican Republic. On
11 and 12 October, the Government of Mexico sent to
Haiti two Hercules C-130 aeroplanes of the Mexican
air force with 25 tons of aid to alleviate the damage
caused by Tropical Storm Jeanne. That assistance
included a group of 16 experts, medical material,
various kinds of equipment and food. Finally, on
17 November, a Mexican navy ship arrived at Port-au-
Prince transporting specialized medical personnel and
civilian engineers as well as a helicopter and an
ambulance. During its stay, the team of medical
specialists carried out many surgical operations and
gave medical assistance to more than 1,000 persons.
In the regional context, we note Mexico's
cooperation in electoral assistance through the Federal
Electoral Institute of Mexico. In response to the
request of the Organization of American States (OAS),
the Electoral Institute is currently providing technical
support in the organization, administration and
development of the process for the elections to take
place in Haiti this year. To that end, from 22 to
27 November, the members of the Haitian Provisional
Electoral Council participated in an international
workshop in Mexico on electoral administration
organized with the support of the United Nations
Development Programme and the OAS.
Representatives of electoral organizations from the
Dominican Republic, El Salvador, Panama and
Venezuela also participated. As well, the Institute has
named two Mexican officials to participate in the OAS
Special Mission in Haiti. In the second quarter of 2005,
Mexico will make a voluntary contribution of $20,000
to the OAS Special Mission.
In the framework of the last July's donors
conference for Haiti organized by the Inter-American
Development Bank, Mexico pledged $40,000 worth of
cooperation in the technical-scientific and cultural-
educational areas; those resources will be used to
facilitate the movement of experts and technicians
between the two countries. The modalities for
cooperation include capacity-building and assessments
in areas such as agriculture, drinking water, training in
HIV/AIDS prevention and medical attention,
diplomatic training, drainage engineering and the
production and quality-control of seeds.
At the subregional level, Mexico is exploring
various areas of cooperation within the Group of
Three, comprising Mexico, Venezuela and Colombia,
and within the Rio Group.
Finally, at the bilateral level, last October,
Mexican officials, including our Under-Secretary of
Foreign Affairs for Latin America and the Caribbean,
made a working visit to Haiti to evaluate possible areas
of cooperation. The following were identified.
In the area of the reconstruction of highways,
Mexico committed itself to study contributing to
financing the reconstruction of sections of the highway
between Saint-Marc and Gonai'ves.
In the area of reforestation, the Secretariat of the
Environment of Mexico and the Ministry of
Environment of Haiti signed a preliminary agreement
on cooperation on two specific projects: the ongoing
evaluation of natural resources in the arid ecosystem of
north-west Haiti and the administration of La Visite
National Park.
In the educational realm, Mexico has offered a
package of 40 scholarships for high school students
who wish to study in our country beginning in the 2005
school year. Likewise, it has been agreed to create the
Gerard Pierre Charles chair at the State University of
Haiti in recognition of the work of that distinguished
intellectual and politician of Haiti who lived in Mexico
for more than 20 years.
To date, those have been Mexico's most relevant
contributions to the pacification and stabilization of
Haiti.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I thank the
representative of Mexico for his kind words addressed
to me.
The next speaker is the representative of Norway,
on whom I now call.
Mr. Frydenlund (Norway): Norway welcomes
this important opportunity to address the situation in
Haiti and would like to use the occasion to express
solidarity with Haiti and its population. Further, we
would like to express our strong support for the efforts
of the Special Representative of the Secretary-General,
Mr. Juan Gabriel Valdes, and the United Nations
Stabilization Mission in Haiti.
The security situation in Haiti continues to be an
obstacle to sustained democratic and economic
development in the country. Haiti now needs both to
restore security and to implement investment and aid in
order to lay the foundations for the country's
reconstruction and the strengthening of the rule of law.
In those efforts, it is essential that the international
community confirm its long-term commitment to
assisting Haiti. Faced with a difficult situation, we
should intensify our efforts rather than turn our
attention elsewhere.
There is a strong need to promote and facilitate
national reconciliation in an open and inclusive
process. Political training is important for national
opinion leaders and other social and political actors in
order to ensure the continued strengthening of
democracy in Haiti.
Over the past six years, Norway has been
involved in facilitating political dialogue and
consensus-building. It is Norway's view that, by
bringing political groups into a dialogue based on
democratic values and practices, an environment for
democratic development can be established. Norway
intends to continue those efforts, in close coordination
and cooperation with national and international efforts.
Norway also welcomes the joint efforts to prepare for
fair and transparent elections to be held in November.
Norway fully supports and has made financial
contributions to the Organization of American States
and its electoral assistance to Haiti.
Norway maintains its commitment to Haiti. We
will continue to support the processes of dialogue and
reconciliation and will be pleased to coordinate with
others in those efforts.
The President (spoke in Spanish): The next
speaker is the representative of Ecuador, on whom I
now call.
Mr. Gallegos Chiriboga (Ecuador) (spoke in Spanish): I wish at the outset to extend to you, Sir, the
most cordial congratulations of the Government and
people of Ecuador on Argentina's well-deserved
election to the Council. In my capacity as
representative of a former non-permanent member of
the Council, I express my delegation's gratification at
addressing you as President of this United Nations
organ.
I also wish to thank my colleague and friend
Ambassador Juan Gabriel Valdes for his briefing and
his efforts.
I further wish to thank you, Sir, for convening
this very timely open debate so that the international
community can understand the magnitude of the
problems besetting Haiti and get a clear picture of the
crisis affecting that Caribbean nation.
Ecuador fully supports the Haitian democratic
institutions and reiterates the appeal made to them and
to the political leadership and people of Haiti - issued
at the 49l7th meeting of the Council in February 2004,
almost a year ago - to establish channels for dialogue
and democratic understanding that would allow them to
resolve their country's ongoing problems peacefully
and to achieve a national reconciliation that would
strengthen the roots of democracy and bolster the
country's efforts to improve political, economic and
social conditions with a view to ensuring the prosperity
and sustainable development of future generations in a
framework of peace, tolerance and national harmony.
While Ecuador is aware of the efforts being
deployed in Haiti to stabilize the situation, preserve the
legal and political order, protect human rights and
prevent a humanitarian crisis, it believes that, in the
current circumstances, the international community
must make a greater and more decisive contribution to
assisting and strengthening the institutions of that
country.
However, as my delegation has underscored on
other occasions, we fully agree with the statement,
made on behalf of the Rio Group in the Special
Political and Decolonization Committee, that peace
cannot last without development, that we must counter
the underlying causes of conflict, and that the
promotion of development, the rule of law, the
establishment of reliable transitional mechanisms of
justice, attention to the special needs of women and
children in armed conflict, and the success of
disarmament, demobilization and reintegration are,
inter alia, crucial to the consolidation of democratic
institutions in post-conflict countries.
Ecuador, a firm defender of the United Nations
Charter, believes that we must all commit ourselves to
peacebuilding. Aware of its responsibilities as a
Member of this Organization to contribute to the best
of its abilities to the establishment of peace and
security throughout the world, Ecuador has decided to
participate in Haiti. On 29 September 2004, we signed
a memorandum of understanding to contribute to the
United Nations reserve forces in that brotherly
Caribbean country by dispatching a company of 66
military engineers and trucks in a joint operation with
Chile.
In resolution 1576 (2004) of 29 November 2004,
the Security Council underlined that political
reconciliation and economic reconstruction efforts
remain key to the stability and security of Haiti and
urged the Transitional Government to continue to make
progress in the implementation of the Interim
Cooperation Framework, including by developing
concrete projects for economic development, in close
cooperation with, and with the full assistance of, the
international community, in particular the United
Nations and international financial institutions. At the
same time, the Council urged the relevant financial
institutions and donor countries to disburse promptly
the funds pledged at the International Donors
Conference on Haiti held in Washington, DC. on
19 and 20 July 2004.
My delegation therefore stresses the spirit of that
resolution and recalls the Security Council's call on the
international financial institutions and the donors to
disburse without delay the funds pledged in
Washington, DC. We cordially appeal to them
resolutely to cooperate to resolve the situation in Haiti
in all its aspects.
Ecuador is ready to confront the challenges of
stabilizing Haiti and endorses a multidimensional
approach to peacekeeping operations. We are prepared
to contribute to such operations and to world security
under United Nations auspices, but we feel that the
international community should demonstrate greater
sensitivity and resolve in facing the threats to
democratic institutions, human rights and economic
development in Haiti. That is all the more important
when we consider that countries with scarce economic
resources, like Ecuador and others in the Latin
American and Caribbean region, have demonstrated
their profound commitment to the success of the
United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti by
offering their assistance and contributing military
personnel in solidarity and cooperation with the
Haitian nation.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now call on
the representative of Paraguay.
Mr. Buffa (Paraguay) (spoke in Spanish): Allow
me at the outset to congratulate Minister Rafael Bielsa
and the Argentine Republic on their timely initiative of
convening an open debate on Haiti during the
Argentine presidency of the Security Council this
month. It is extremely important for Paraguay to see
the willingness of the Security Council to make known
and explain topics of overarching interest to all
Member States, and in particular matters related to
security and institutional stabilization in countries
affected by internal conflict.
The establishment of the United Nations
Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH) in June
2004 provided the endorsement necessary to guarantee
an orderly and transparent transition to institutional
and political recovery in the Republic of Haiti, thereby
averting destabilizing effects in the region. We would
therefore like to congratulate the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General in Haiti,
Mr. Juan Valdes, for his detailed briefing on the current
situation, which pointed to substantive progress
towards the normalization of activities in the country.
We are also pleased to note the active joint
participation of the Organization of American States
(OAS) and the United Nations in the electoral process
this year, which will be of vital importance. We
therefore hope that that process will also have the
resolute support of other institutions and States in order
to ensure free and transparent elections with the
participation of all Haitians.
The human and financial resources mobilized to
date for MINUSTAH confirm the willingness of
Member States to decisively support multilateral
cooperation to overcome the climate of instability and
disorder that prevailed during Haiti's political crisis
and that caused significant damage and irreparable
losses to the Haitian people. Paraguay is taking part in
the Stabilization Mission by contributing staff officers.
However, for logistical reasons beyond our control, and
although our desire remains firm and committed, we
have had to postpone to a later stage the deployment of
troops to the field.
Paraguay welcomes the active mobilization of a
great number of Latin American and Caribbean
Member States, which has provided an effective and
decisive response to a humanitarian emergency
besetting a country of the region. Meanwhile, as we
have heard during this open debate, financial
contributions are still lagging. We urge donor countries
and financial institutions to streamline the process of
fulfilling the pledges they made at the donors
conference in Washington last year.
Finally, we would like to place on record
Paraguay's commitment to continue to support the
cause and ideals of the United Nations as it seeks to
bring about lasting stability and development for its
Member States, in particular for those that have for far
too long seen their aspirations thwarted when it comes
to providing their citizens with the stability and
institutional development necessary to support their
legitimate right to achieve sustainable economic and
social development.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I thank the
representative of Paraguay for his kind words
addressed to my country.
I now call on the representative of Canada.
Mr. Rock (Canada): Let me say at the outset how
much the Government of Canada appreciates the
opportunity to take part in this discussion today. This
initiative on the part of the Government of Argentina
furnishes us with additional evidence of the sincerity of
that Government's commitment to the cause of Haitian
reconstruction. The involvement today of so many
senior Government representatives from this
hemisphere and elsewhere demonstrates the truly
international and interregional nature of this
cooperative work.
Almost one year has passed now since former
President Jean-Bertrand Aristide left Haiti, a country
then in a state of turmoil and on the brink of civil war.
The efforts of the Council - first by authorizing the
deployment of the Multinational Interim Force and,
subsequently, by establishing the United Nations
Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH) - have
provided important support to the Transitional
Government of Haiti and to its efforts to re-establish
stability and security, promote reconciliation and
relaunch the democratic process. We believe that,
under United Nations leadership, a coordinated
approach between national actors and regional and
international partners will ensure a better future for all
Haitians.
We wish to say a word in particular about Juan
Gabriel Valdes, the Special Representative of the
Secretary-General, who has worked so effectively and
who has won the confidence and respect of all actors
with his frankness, his skill and his evident
commitment.
Canada would respectfully suggest that Haiti
currently faces three fundamental and pressing
challenges. The first challenge is to establish and
sustain security and implement comprehensive
disarmament, demobilization and reintegration (DDR).
The second is to ensure economic and social
reconstruction. And the third is to promote national
reconciliation and relaunch the democratic process in
Haiti. While efforts to respond to those three areas
must of course be made in parallel, it seems clear that
without a secure environment economic and social
reconstruction cannot happen, reconciliation will
remain but a hope and the democratic process
eventually leading to fair and free elections cannot
proceed.
Let me first deal briefly with the security
challenge. Canada welcomes the efforts of the
Transitional Government to begin to address the issue
of former members of the Haitian armed forces. That
problem continues to have serious implications for the
security situation, in particular with regard to the
capacity of the Haitian National Police and
MINUSTAH to operate effectively in Haiti. Canada
welcomes the intent and actions of the Transitional
Government of Haiti in tackling that issue, including
through its plan to establish a national commission on
DDR. But we suggest that it must be addressed as a
matter of utmost urgency. We also suggest that the
reinsertion of any members of the former armed forces
into the Haitian National Police or other security
apparatus should involve strict and comprehensive
screening and training procedures, to ensure a
transparent, accountable and effective process.
Canada will continue to do its part, as evidenced
by our current contribution to MINUSTAH, in
particular to its civilian police component. In that
regard, we particularly welcome the recent joint
operations between MINUSTAH and the Haitian
National Police that have successfully supported the
restoration and maintenance of the rule of law, public
safety and public order in Haiti. Those operations are
excellent examples of the type of close coordination
that is essential to our collective efforts to create a
secure and stable environment. We hope they will
continue. However, we would suggest that true security
cannot be attained without an end to impunity and
without the effective promotion and protection of
human rights.
(spoke in French)
Canada condemns all violations of human rights.
We urge the Transitional Government to ensure that
due process is followed and that individuals subject to
imprisonment are formally charged in accordance with
Haitian law. We welcome the investigation recently
launched by MINUSTAH into alleged extrajudicial
executions committed by the Haitian National Police.
We also urge an immediate end to the unauthorized
exercise of law enforcement functions by armed
groups.
(spoke in English)
Let me turn briefly to the challenge posed by
social and economic reconstruction. At the December
meeting of the Contact Group, donors identified the
slow pace of disbursements as perhaps the most
significant problem. We all agreed to look proactively
at reducing bottlenecks and at strengthening support
for capacity-building in ministries that require
assistance. The need to rapidly identify four or five
priority projects that can deliver much-needed quick
results on the ground is a pressing one. We are working
hard with the Transitional Government and our
partners to identify solutions.
Since December, the Canadian International
Development Agency has provided 16 million
Canadian dollars to the Transitional Government of
Haiti to assist it in the clearance of arrears to the World
Bank. In clearing its arrears, the Transitional
Government becomes eligible for new modes of
financial support provided by the Bank. In addition,
part of the contribution will go towards the
construction of the Route de Rail in Port-au-Prince, a
highly visible project, co-funded with the European
Commission and implemented in collaboration with
MINUSTAH, which will open up a southern exit from
Port-au-Prince and create employment in the
surrounding area, a disadvantaged neighbourhood of
the capital.
Clearly, more must be done quickly to rebuild
Haiti, and Canada remains conscious that our
commitment must also be sustained over the longer
term.
We are pleased to chair the Ad Hoc Advisory
Group of the Economic and Social Council that will
examine Haiti's development challenges. That
committed group, which includes Benin, Brazil,
Canada, Chile, Haiti, Spain and Trinidad and Tobago,
is working actively with the Transitional Government,
with MINUSTAH, with international financial
institutions and with the Special Representative to
identify obstacles to development. We have already
identified areas such as capacity-building, sustainable
funding for disarmament, demobilization and
reintegration and the involvement of the Haitian
diaspora as requiring particular attention. The Group
welcomes the opportunity to work with the Security
Council in addressing the situation in Haiti, and to that
end hopes that a joint mission to Haiti can soon be
organized.
Prime Minister Martin, speaking both in Haiti and
at the Montreal Conference on the Haitian Diaspora in
December, encouraged all Haitians to renounce
violence and participate in a genuine and broad-based
national reconciliation process. He also promised
Canadian support for the re-establishment of
democracy through free and fair elections. We are
pleased to note that this week, Canada committed to
providing $17 million in support of Haiti's electoral
processes, to assist the Provisional Electoral Council in
fulfilling its mandate. But successful elections require
not only that technical conditions be met, but also that
an appropriate political context be developed. That
context can be created only through an open and
forthright national dialogue among all sectors of
Haitian society and the main political parties, including
Fanmi Lavalas.
We consider that a national dialogue is of
fundamental importance in mobilizing all Haitians for
the restoration of democratic order and the
reconstruction and sustainable development of the
country. We welcome Prime Minister Latortue's recent
commitments to do what it takes to launch this process.
We urge all political actors to renounce violence and to
take part fully.
Canada has committed more than $180 million
over two years for the reconstruction of Haiti. We
understand that the task is formidable, that it will be
costly. But the international community cannot again
afford to fail the Haitian people. Canada wants to help
build a stable, democratic and prosperous society in
Haiti. We stand ready to continue to work with the
Transitional Government, the United Nations and our
other international partners towards this end.
The President (spoke in Spanish): The next
speaker is the representative of Morocco, on whom I
now call.
Mr. Bennouna (Morocco) (spoke in French): I
should like at the outset to congratulate you, Sir, on
your assumption of the presidency of the Security
Council. You are well known for your great diplomatic
experience and commitment to peace in your continent,
and specifically in the Caribbean region and Haiti. We
are convinced that, under the outstanding leadership of
Ambassador Cesar Mayoral, the Argentine team will
discharge its responsibilities to the fullest. Indeed, it
has already begun to do so, to the satisfaction of all.
I should also like to congratulate all of the new
Council members and to pay tribute to the very
positive and fruitful work of the Algerian presidency
during the month of December.
I welcome your initiative, Mr. President, to
convene this public debate on the situation in Haiti.
This is an issue to which the Kingdom of Morocco
attaches the greatest importance, given our long-
standing relations of cooperation with that friendly
country, to whose security and stability we are firmly
committed, and our desire - which you share, Sir -
for the harmonious development of the Caribbean
region.
Before dealing with the situation in Haiti, I
should like to thank the Secretary-General, Mr. Kofi
Annan, and his Special Representative and Head of the
United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti
(MINUSTAH), Mr. Juan Gabriel Valdes - a good
friend who was the representative of his country, Chile,
here at the United Nations - for their tireless efforts
and their dedication to the restoration of peace and
security and to strengthening the political process in
Haiti.
We should also like to commend the efforts of the
Multinational Interim Force in Haiti, which was made
up of contingents from Canada, France and the United
States and which carried out its responsibilities with
great professionalism.
Haiti has given French-speaking countries, and
the entire world, many eminent artists and poets. It is a
country with great cultural vitality. But it is also a
country that has, unfortunately, been the victim of
confrontations and cycles of violence that have torn it
apart, depriving it of the means to provide for the basic
needs of its people and to address the challenges of
sustainable development - a situation has been made
worse by natural disasters.
In April, our Organization launched an appeal to
Member countries to support the political transition by
contributing to the United Nations Stabilization
Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH), which was established
pursuant to resolution 1529 (2004). The Kingdom of
Morocco had no hesitation in responding positively to
that appeal. Indeed, in July we decided that, working in
close cooperation with the Kingdom of Spain, a
neighbouring country that is also committed to the
stability and security of the Caribbean region, we
would participate in MINUSTAH by providing an
operational military contingent.
For Morocco, this is a matter of working to
ensure the success of the United Nations Mission with
a view to meeting all conditions for the normal
resumption of the constitutional process in Haiti and
the full functioning of the governmental authorities,
within the framework of the rule of law.
We sincerely hope that security conditions will
quickly be restored so that the Transitional
Government can hold elections this year. The
Moroccan contingent has been operational since
November, and it is fully carrying out its
responsibilities within MINUSTAH. Similarly,
Moroccan and Spanish troops have been cooperating
very successfully since taking over from the Chilean
battalion at Fort Liberte and Terre Rouge in the north-
east of Haiti. They now control the main crossing
points on the border with the Dominican Republic and
are working to stem smuggling and arms trafficking.
We are pleased that the many contributions to
MINUSTAH have enabled it almost to reach full
strength, as authorized by the Security Council, and to
deploy throughout the country, thus ensuring that it has
a permanent presence. Here, we would like to pay
tribute to the effective and well-respected command
that is being exercised by Brazil with great
competence. The latest report of the Secretary-General
on MINUSTAH, dated 18 November 2004, outlines the
key tracks for moving forward in our thinking and in
the efforts undertaken so that the Organization can lead
the transitional process under way in Haiti to a
successful conclusion.
We earnestly hope that the Transitional
Government - with MINUSTAH's help, of course -
will pursue without delay its disarmament,
demobilization and reintegration programmes, which
should lead to the creation of the national commission
on disarmament, demobilization and reintegration
recommended by the Secretary-General. The
disarmament of armed groups is, in our View, the sine
qua non for restoring stability on the island and for the
success of the transitional process. Disarming militias
will not only help to establish an appropriate
environment for the forthcoming elections, but will
also undoubtedly help promote the restoration of the
rule of law on the island.
If re-establishing security is a necessary condition
for the transitional process and for peace-building, we
remain convinced that that process, if it is to have
lasting success, must be accompanied by an in-depth
political reform in which all actors commit to dialogue
and cooperation aimed at organizing transparent and
fair elections. It goes without saying that
accomplishing those objectives is also largely a
function of the degree and level of international
assistance in the military, humanitarian, economic and
political areas.
We welcome the fact that the financial
institutions and donor countries responded to the
Security Council appeal, in accordance with resolution
1576 (2004), which permitted significant disbursement
of the funds pledged at the international donor
conference on Haiti held in Washington on 19 and
20 July 2004. We hope that that financial support will
continue, because the normalization of the situation in
Haiti will largely depend on it. There is a link between
purely military action and economic action aimed at
meeting the people's basic needs.
As this new year begins, we express the hope that
the Transitional Government and all the parties
concerned will move towards peace, with
MINUSTAH's help, within the framework of the
mandate set by the Security Council. We are convinced
that political harmony, once restored, will lead all
Haitians to mobilize for the development and
prosperity of their country.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Cuba.
Mr. Requeijo Gual (Cuba) (spoke in Spanish):
At the outset, I should like to express to you,
Mr. President, the satisfaction of the Cuban delegation
at your presence at today's Security Council meeting
and to join all those who have congratulated the
Argentine Republic on assuming the Council
presidency for this month.
Haiti, cradle of the liberation struggles against
colonialism in America and the first independent black
republic in the Western Hemisphere, is today a country
passed by and forgotten by the international
community. It suffers because of its poverty; it endures
chronic and structural underdevelopment; and it is
submerged in violence and the permanent political
crises not unfamiliar to foreign interests and the
continued interventionism that has characterized its
turbulent republican history. It is crumbling because of
the devastating effects of successive natural disasters
and the ecological damage to its deteriorated
environment. The year 2004 was particularly tragic for
the brotherly Haitian people.
Cuba, which feels united in its history and culture
with the destiny of the Haitian people, continues to
observe the developments in Haiti attentively and with
concern. Our country, which has made supportive and
unconditional cooperation a pillar of its relations with
the Haitian people, believes that a massive contribution
of financial and human resources to the economic and
social rehabilitation and national reconciliation of that
brotherly people is an inescapable duty of the
international community.
Haiti is undoubtedly one of the clearest examples
of the disastrous consequences of the current
international order for underdeveloped countries,
particularly in the case of a country that has had to
endure more than 200 years of the most flagrant
colonialism, exploitation and intervention.
My country supports all the efforts of the Haitian
people to overcome existing tensions and to move
forward a process of dialogue and national
reconciliation, as well as the efforts of the Caribbean
Community to find a peaceful and just solution to the
Haitian situation. Such a solution will be possible only
with the promotion of the economic and social
development of the country and the development of its
human resources and infrastructure. It is essential that
the international community and international
institutions increase their contributions and their
permanent commitment to this Caribbean country. We
hope that the United Nations and the international
community as a whole will unite their efforts to attain
that objective and that the pledges made at the
international donor conference will materialize.
The members of the Council also must work to
guarantee that we attain that objective. To focus
exclusively on the so-called security problems in Haiti,
without considering the fact that only development and
progress will lead to peace and stability in that
suffering Caribbean nation, would be a short-sighted
and unrealistic view that would soon lead to failure. It
is only through solidarity that the international
community's duty and commitment to the sovereignty,
independence, unity and territorial integrity of Haiti
will fully materialize.
The uninterrupted cooperation that Cuba has
maintained with Haiti for years shows how much can
be achieved for that country through cooperation and
development assistance. Cuba is cooperating with Haiti
in various sectors, placing top priority on the health
care sector. In more than five years of medical
cooperation, 1,909 Cuban health care specialists have
worked in Haiti. Their work has made it possible to
hold nearly 6 million consultations. They have
administered 756,000 vaccinations, assisted with
52,000 births and performed 75,000 surgical
interventions. All those actions have enabled us to save
more than 120,000 human lives.
Despite the critical situation in that country,
Cuban volunteers, resolutely adhering to the principle
of non-interference in Haitian internal affairs, have
remained at their posts. Our medical brigade in
particular, composed of 492 health-care workers and
posted throughout the country's 10 departments, has
been an example of disinterested cooperation, saving
lives in the most difficult conditions.
Cuban cooperation with Haiti goes beyond direct
medical assistance. It includes continuous training
aimed at capacity-building in the short and medium
term. More than 3,000 persons have participated in
those programmes, and today there 889 Haitian
students in Cuba, 606 of whom are attending our Latin
American School of Medicine.
We wish to reiterate once again the firm resolve
of the people and the Government of Cuba to continue
to contribute, with all the means at our disposal, to
achieving a peaceful, just and lasting solution to the
situation in Haiti.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I thank the
representative of Cuba for the kind words he addressed
to my country.
The next speaker is the representative of
Uruguay, to whom I give the floor.
Mr. Paolillo (Uruguay) (spoke in Spanish):
Uruguay, which is among the 10 main troop
contributors to United Nations peacekeeping missions,
responded promptly to the appeal for personnel for the
United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti
(MINUSTAH) by dispatching approximately 600
military and police personnel, who were among the
first to be deployed. Uruguay is now the third-largest
troop contributor to the Mission.
Our Government recently decided to increase the
size of its military contingent in Haiti. The
authorization to deploy an additional 200 troops was
given a few days ago by the Uruguayan Parliament,
and the new contingent is expected to arrive in Haiti by
early February.
Uruguay is thus joining in the efforts of the
United Nations in Haiti, not to impose solutions to the
political problems that beset that tormented country,
but, rather, to help its people and their authorities find
their own solutions.
The Transitional Government bears the primary
responsibility for leading the country towards the
establishment and consolidation of a State based on the
rule of law and on the functioning of democratic
institutions. That can be achieved only if such
leadership is exercised in accordance with democratic
principles, ensuring strict respect for human rights. We
would recall here the appeal made by the Security
Council in its resolutions 1542 (2004) and 1576
(2004), particularly as regards the release of
individuals detained for exclusively political reasons
and against whom no charges have been brought, and
the need for all necessary measures to be taken to
prevent impunity for violations of human rights.
The recent agreement signed between the
Stabilization Mission and the Haitian Government for
general elections this year, as well as the pledges made
by Canada, the European Union and the United States
to finance those elections, represent very good news
and are clear evidence that the stabilization process is
under way.
We must also expedite the disarmament,
demobilization and reintegration process, and,
accordingly, we hope that the Transitional Government
will finalize its elaboration of the legal framework
governing that process. Long-term development
programmes must also be elaborated and implemented.
However, we believe that, given the deplorable
economic and social conditions facing the majority of
the Haitian population, priority must be given to short-
term programmes designed immediately to satisfy the
basic needs of Haitians such as food, housing and
essential services.
At this stage, efforts should focus on alleviating
the extreme poverty that affects the Haitian population.
We must recall that Haiti ranks 153rd in the Human
Development Index. Haiti is a country with a per-
capital gross national product of $415, whose
inhabitants lack the basic resources necessary for
survival with a minimum of dignity. Under such
circumstances, the normalization of the political and
security situation appears to be, if not a mission
impossible, at the very least an extremely difficult
undertaking - unless there is a substantial
improvement in the socio-economic framework within
which the international community is providing
assistance.
If the MINUSTAH presence is accompanied by
material assistance that brings about even a slight
improvement in living conditions, that will increase the
population's confidence in the Mission and its
willingness to cooperate, which will facilitate the
reconciliation, disarmament and demobilization
processes. That is why we consider it very important to
provide MINUSTAH with the capacity it needs to
rapidly implement short-term projects that have an
immediate and tangible impact on the population, as
proposed by the Secretary-General in his most recent
report on the Stabilization Mission.
I wish to express our satisfaction at the decision
of the Economic and Social Council to reactivate its
Ad Hoc Advisory Group on Haiti, and we hope that its
work will help to promote the country's recovery. The
Advisory Group must coordinate its work with the
Core Group established by the Security Council in
paragraph 5 of its resolution 1542 (2004) in order to
avoid any overlap.
The task of restoring order and security in Haiti
and of creating conditions conducive to its
development is of tremendous scope and will require
considerable human and financial resources as well as
perseverance and dedication on the part of all the
individuals and institutions involved in the effort. We
are certain that, led by Mr. Juan Gabriel Valdes -
whom we thank for his report this morning - this
effort will ultimately be successful.
The President (spoke in Spanish): The next
speaker is the representative of Bolivia, to whom I give
the floor.
Mr. Quiroga (Bolivia) (spoke in Spanish):
Mr. President, allow me to welcome your presence at
this meeting and that of the ministers of Brazil, Chile,
Guyana, Haiti and the Dominican Republic, as well as
the Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Haiti and the Acting Secretary General of the
Organization of American States.
I should like to congratulate the Argentine
Republic and you personally, Sir, for having taken the
initiative of convening this open debate of the Security
Council, which, as has been the case on other
occasions, will without a doubt contribute to a greater
understanding of the situation in Haiti and increase the
international community's awareness of the priority
importance that the Latin American and Caribbean
region attaches to the consolidation of the process of
strengthening Haiti's institutions and the rule of law
there.
We are concerned that this sister Caribbean
republic has not yet been able to overcome the
recurrent crises afflicting it, which are characterized by
complex political, social, humanitarian, economic,
financial and security problems which have kept the
greater part of its population outside the development
process.
Despite the efforts made since 1988 by the OAS
and the United Nations, it has not been possible to
uphold the principle of democratic legitimacy in Haiti
for more than short periods of time.
Given the lessons learned from the United
Nations stabilization Mission in Haiti in 1994, and in
view of the gravity and urgency of the situation, the
Bolivian delegation last year supported resolution 1529
(2004), which, at the request of the Interim
Government of Haiti, authorized the deployment on the
territory of that country of a Multinational Force and
requested the Secretary-General to begin preparations
for a stabilization force - MINUSTAH - which was
concretized by resolution 1542 (2004) under Chapter
VII.
We note with regret the deterioration of the
security situation and the increasingly tense political
climate referred to in last November's report of the
Secretary-General (S/2004/908), and we encourage the
Transitional Government to continue to pursue
measures aimed at restoring the democratic process,
full respect for human rights and the rule of law in the
Republic of Haiti.
The report of the Secretary-General describes the
progress achieved in the deployment of the United
Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti and the activities
of its various contingents, including those of the nine
Latin American countries that contributed officials,
military troops, civil police and formed police units.
We note with satisfaction that the provisions of
Chapter VIII of the Charter of the United Nations have
been implemented in a positive manner, through the
signing of a memorandum of understanding between
the United Nations and the Organization of American
States (OAS) on electoral assistance in Haiti and
through the contacts established with the Caribbean
Community (CARICOM) to assess the electoral
assistance that its members would contribute to support
the reconciliation and recovery efforts of the people of
Haiti.
I wish to express our thanks to the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for Haiti, Mr.
Juan Gabriel Valdes, for his briefing and to Mr. Luigi
Einaudi, Acting Secretary General of the OAS, for his
valuable information and views. I also underline the
highly illuminating information the Executive Director
of the United Nations Children's Fund has shared with
the Council.
With respect to humanitarian action, we agree
with the report that is important that MINUSTAH
demonstrate its effectiveness through actions having
tangible benefits for the population. That is a
particularly sensitive matter for the small island
developing States most vulnerable to natural disasters,
as has been tragically demonstrated.
Moreover, security - the indispensable
requirement for safeguarding the political transition
process leading to a participatory democracy inclusive
of all segments of society - is undoubtedly one of the
most important challenges for MINUSTAH in its work
to support the Transitional Government: it involves not
only restoring the population's confidence but also
implementing disarmament, demobilization and
reintegration programmes.
The United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti
testifies to the commitment of the international
community, in particular of our entire region, to the
people of Haiti. Ensuring MINUSTAH's success is a
challenge and inescapable responsibility for the Latin
American and Caribbean countries in the task of
maintaining a genuine zone of peace and development
in our region.
We reaffirm Bolivia's support for Haiti in its
efforts, and we call upon the entire international
community to continue to extend its decisive and long-
term cooperation, which will enable MINUSTAH to
fully carry out its mandate.
The President (spoke in Spanish): The next
speaker is the representative of Honduras, to whom I
give the floor.
Mr. Suazo (Honduras) (spoke in Spanish): It is an
honour to address the Council under your able
leadership, Mr. Minister. We thank in particular the
delegation of Argentina for its wise decision to
convene this public meeting of the Council on the
situation in Haiti, a brotherly country with which
Honduras maintains excellent relations of friendship
and cooperation. Since the creation of the United
Nations we and Haiti have sat side by side, as we do at
this table.
We welcome the interest - heightened by you,
Sir - which has led to the participation of the Foreign
Ministers of Brazil, Chile, Barbados and the
Dominican Republic; the Special Representative of the
Secretary-General for Haiti, Mr. Juan Gabriel Valdes;
and the Acting Secretary General of the Organization
of American States, Mr. Luigi Einaudi. We welcome
with particular optimism the message delivered to the
Council by the Minister for Foreign Affairs of Haiti.
The participation of the United Nations and the
Organization of American States in Haiti prior to the
establishment of the United Nations Mission in Haiti
(UNMIH), in 1993, and the subsequent missions
leading to today's United Nations Stabilization Mission
in Haiti (MINUSTAH), cause us to recall our
participation in the Council's debates on the need to
restore democratic and constitutional order in that
brotherly country. In those debates, Argentina and
Honduras, which were members of the Council at the
time, were filled with optimism and hope. A decade
later, in January 2005, we understand how difficult it
can be to achieve some objectives, no matter how
simple they may seem.
At that time, Honduras introduced the question of
the humanitarian situation in Haiti in the General
Assembly. It was duly followed up until the item was
biennialized and then practically forgotten. The two
times the General Assembly considered the item, there
was neither a resolution nor a debate on the
humanitarian situation in Haiti. The international
community shares the blame.
The passing of a decade and the repetitious nature
of the situation today would seem discouraging.
However, it is preferable to underline the positive
elements and state that we will not forget the people of
Haiti. We will continue to seek the best formula to
remedy their problems and help them to achieve
political and socio-economic recovery. The Millennium
Development Goals are the same for all, but not all
have the same resources and means to achieve them.
For that reason, the convening of this meeting leads us
to envision a new opportunity and renewed hope for
Haiti.
The report of the Secretary-General on the United
Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti (S/2004/908)
unambiguously states that
"Haitians will vote in local elections on
6November 2005. On 27 November 2005, the
first round of national elections (presidential and legislative) will be held, with the option of a
second round of voting '- if necessary,
7
according to our understanding - on
18 December 2005". (para. 29)
The report adds that
"The memorandum of understanding
between the United Nations and the Organization
of American States (OAS) concerning electoral
assistance to Haiti was signed on 2 and
3 November 2004". (para. 31)
The political landscape seems to be becoming
clearer, and we hope that the timetable can be adhered
to without setbacks.
With respect to humanitarian problems, the
situation is very different. In that regard, we make a
special appeal to the international community in
connection with the fragility of the environment and
the need for international assistance to continue, as The
New York Times recently put it, beyond the period that
the media keeps the crisis situation on the front page.
The international community must not forget its long-
term commitments when the situation is no longer
news or, in particular, when faced with the constraints
that always arise when such commitments are carried
out.
The report of the Secretary-General is clear on
the devastation and the destruction of the environment
caused by the recent floods in Haiti, but today that is
no longer news. Tragically, another, unprecedented
natural disaster has struck brotherly countries of the
Asia Pacific region - and we express our solidarity to
those countries. It has led us quickly to forget the more
than 2,000 dead and the 30,000 others affected in Haiti.
Haiti is also seriously afflicted by pandemics
such as HIV/AIDS. An additional effort could be made
in the area of cooperation to reinforce health-care
programmes in the country. We make an appeal to the
international community in that regard.
Haiti has a special place in the history of the
international community, in particular of Latin
America. It was among the first of the discovered
lands. It achieved independence in 1804, and in 1816 it
gave refuge and unreserved support to the liberator of
America, Simon Bolivar. Thus, we owe a debt to that
brotherly republic. Honduras expresses its solidarity in
these difficult times and raises its voice so that the
Haitian people will not be forgotten again.
The President (spoke in Spanish): The next
speaker is the representative of El Salvador, to whom I
give the floor.
Ms. Gallardo (El Salvador) (spoke in Spanish):
Mr. President, allow me to voice the satisfaction of the
Government of El Salvador at your initiative to
convene an open Security Council debate on the
situation in Haiti. We take this opportunity also to
express our confidence in the diplomatic leadership of
Argentina in guiding the affairs of the Council.
My Government attaches great importance to this
topic, not only because of its implications for regional
peace and security, but also because of the human
tragedy and the pressing needs of Haitian civil society
at present. The social harmony to which it aspires
requires progress towards the creation and subsequent
consolidation of democratic institutions that can
improve living conditions and strengthen the rule of
law.
This debate provides an opportunity to reiterate
El Salvador's political will to continue contributing,
within our limited possibilities, to the stabilization
process that the international community and the
Transitional Government are carrying out in Haiti. This
process is taking place in the context of the
international community's action, in the global,
multilateral context of the United Nations, through the
United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti
(MINUSTAH), as well as in the regional context,
through the Organization of American States (OAS),
the Caribbean Community (CARICOM) and the Rio
Group. It must continue to be consolidated.
We would like to take this opportunity to
commend the Secretary-General on his endeavours and
leadership in this process.
El Salvador shares the concern of the Transitional
Government of Haiti about the deteriorating security
situation, particularly in Port-au-Prince, and the
resulting tense political climate. The existence of
armed groups, and the intention of some of them to
confront the Transitional Government, continues to be
among the main threats to peace and security in Haiti.
My delegation hopes that the Transitional
Government's proposed measures will contribute to
reducing levels of violence and will promote a political
climate conducive to tolerance, dialogue and
negotiation. As the Council is aware, the Government
of El Salvador is convinced that those are the required
tools to seek and consolidate the peace. Our own
history has proven that.
The coordination efforts of MINUSTAH and the
National Police in Port-au-Prince, intended to restore
the population's trust in the capabilities of the Haitian
National Police, have proven to be an effective practice
in making progress. In that context, it is important to
make a greater effort to strengthen the national
commission on disarmament, demobilization and
reintegration. We must recall that in the process of
peacebuilding in El Salvador, that was an essential step
to which the international community attached a great
deal of importance.
As to the civilian police component of
MINUSTAH, at the request of the United Nations, the
Government of El Salvador is considering the
possibility of making available more police officers,
particularly women, to be included in the overall
international effort, and in conjunction with other
countries of Latin America and the Caribbean.
The Government of El Salvador is convinced that
stabilization and peacebuilding in Haiti must be based
on promoting dialogue and national reconciliation. In
that regard, we are gratified at the positive assessment
provided by Mr. Juan Gabriel Valdes, the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General, as a result of
his exploratory meetings with political leaders and
representatives of civil society, who have stated their
readiness for a national dialogue.
The Transitional Government's commitment to
organize free, fair and legitimate elections in 2005 and
to hand over power to a president to be elected on
7February 2006 is another key element that can
contribute effectively to the success of dialogue and
national reconciliation. Here, El Salvador's experience
might be useful to Haiti, and we shall place it at their
disposal under any agreed modalities and format. In
this context, my delegation is gratified at the signing
on 3 November 2004 of the memorandum of
understanding between the United Nations and the
Organization of American States on electoral
assistance for Haiti. It sets out respective
responsibilities and establishes a committee for
electoral cooperation to ensure that the assistance
provided will be effective and consistent.
In addition to the gravity of the political
situation, it is important for us to recognize the
negative impact of natural disasters, in particular the
flooding that occurred in southern Haiti in May 2004,
as well as the torrential rains in the wake of Tropical
Storm Jeanne in September of the same year.
Undeniably, the need to respond immediately to the
disaster was a further challenge for MINUSTAH,
which had to temporarily redeploy its military and
police personnel to Gona'i'ves to support the Argentine
troops in providing security at distribution points and
warehouses, and for humanitarian convoys. In my
delegation's opinion, the international community's
response was excellent and effective. However, Haiti's
manifest vulnerability to natural disasters, along with
other pending development tasks, are a double
challenge for the national authorities and the
international community. We must not forget that
political stabilization must go hand in hand with
strengthening national capacity to confront both
challenges simultaneously.
In this respect, the Government of El Salvador
endorses the commitment of the Rio Group to
coordinate with the World Bank, the International
Monetary Fund, the Inter-American Development Bank
and donor countries to ensure prompt disbursement of
the funds and resources pledged for stabilization in
Haiti. We also are pleased with the decision adopted by
the Economic and Social Council to reactivate its Ad
Hoc Advisory Group on Haiti.
In conclusion, I would like to express my
delegation's satisfaction with the actions adopted by
the Security Council with respect to the proposals
made in the report of the Secretary-General contained
in document S/2004/908, and in particular the
extension of MINUSTAH's mandate for an additional
18-month period, until 31 May 2006. El Salvador is
convinced that the engagement of the United Nations at
this stage of the stabilization process in Haiti is
fundamental for successful and lasting national
reconciliation.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to Mr. Juan Gabriel Valdes to respond to
comments and questions offered in the course of the
meeting.
Mr. Valdes (spoke in Spanish): On behalf of the
Secretary-General and the United Nations Stabilization
Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH), I would like to speak
briefly to thank all speakers for their statements; they
have been most helpful in enriching our vision of the
determination of the Security Council and the
international community with respect to our task in
Haiti. I would like especially to thank everyone for the
very generous - and undeserved - words addressed
to me personally. I shall take them as an expression of
trust in the United Nations Mission, in the soldiers and
the police officers who are helping support the
restoration of security in Haiti, and in the United
Nations officials who, on a daily basis, provide support
to Haitian society in so many different areas to bring
about development and reconciliation.
Throughout today's statements, I could note that
delegations spoke of the priority that MINUSTAH
attaches - and must attach - to the disarmament of
all illegal groups within Haitian society that continue
to possess weapons. I noted also that delegations
underscored the need for Haitians to begin a process of
national dialogue and reconciliation, as well as the
need for the United Nations Mission to provide Haitian
society with technical and political support to ensure
that the dialogue yields positive results for the
elections that will take place this year and for the
improved governance that will be required to establish
a democratic, legitimate Government in early 2006.
I have already had an opportunity to tell you, my
dear friend Rafael Bielsa, how much I value this
meeting, as well as Argentina's decision to convene
this open Security Council debate to discuss the
situation in Haiti. This meeting is being held at a time
when the United Nations Mission, with the support of
the Transitional Government of Haiti and the growing
participation of Haitian society, has effectively halted
the disintegration of that society and its spiral towards
the abyss. We now need to climb back up the slope. To
do so we need to promote a process of reconciliation
and dialogue among Haitians, strengthen institutions,
fine tune the work of the police and, as has often been
said at this meeting, maintain the international
community's economic support for projects that will
have a positive impact on the quality of life of the
Haitian people in the coming months and throughout
the year. This meeting once again confirms that the
main contribution of the Organization in support of
developing countries experiencing internal
disintegration depends on ongoing work and support
and on the ability to reassure such countries that they
themselves have the capacity to extricate themselves
from their predicament, given that there is international
support for them.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I thank the
Special Representative for his clear comments and for
his kind words addressed to me.
Following consultations among the members of
the Security Council, I have been authorized to make
the following statement on behalf of the Council.
"The Security Council reaffirms the
comprehensive mandate of the United Nations
Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH) as
set forth in resolutions 1542 (2004) and 1576
(2004), and expresses its support for the United
Nations presence in Haiti as long as necessary.
"The Security Council underlines that
national reconciliation, security and economic
development remain key to stability in Haiti, and,
in that regard, stresses that all Member States and
international organizations, especially those in
the region, should support the Transitional
Government of Haiti in those efforts.
"The Security Council underlines the
important role of MINUSTAH in ensuring a
secure environment and commends the recent
joint operations by MINUSTAH and the Haitian
National Police (HNP), in particular against all
illegal armed groups. It notes however that
further urgent action is needed to continue to
improve the security situation. The Council again
calls on all parties in Haiti to respect human
rights and to renounce the use of violence to
advance their goals.
"The Security Council encourages the
Transitional Government to create without delay
the National Commission on Disarmament,
Demobilization and Reintegration (DDR), to
address all armed groups, particularly former
members of the military, in a comprehensive
manner. It notes that any compensation should be
part of a comprehensive and durable solution.
"The Security Council renews its appeal for
the prompt disbursement of the funds pledged by
international financial institutions and donor
countries at the International Donors Conference
on Haiti held in July 2004. It recognizes the need
for MINUSTAH, other organs of the United
Nations system, international financial
institutions and Member States to assist the
Transitional Government in the preparation and
implementation of development projects in Haiti,
as well as quick-impact projects. The Council
reiterates the need to assist the Transitional
Government in establishing a long-term
development strategy for Haiti, in accordance
with the priorities set forth in the Interim
Cooperation Framework.
"The Security Council welcomes recent
steps taken by the Transitional Government of
Haiti to release some individuals being held
without formal charge or trial, and calls on the
Transitional Government to review all such cases
in order to ensure full respect for due process and
the rule of law. In this regard, the Council calls
on MINUSTAH to continue its support for the
provision of human rights training to Haitian
judicial, police and correctional authorities to
ensure adherence to international norms and
standards.
"The Security Council encourages the
Transitional Government to continue to take steps
towards a comprehensive and inclusive national
dialogue and reconciliation process and calls
upon all political actors in Haiti to renounce
violence and join this dialogue without delay. The
Council fully supports MINUSTAH's continuing
facilitation of this process.
"The Security Council calls upon the
Transitional Government, with the assistance of
MINUSTAH and the Organization of American
States (OAS), to take urgently the necessary
measures to ensure the holding of free and fair
elections in 2005 and the subsequent transfer of
power to elected authorities, and welcomes the
recent decisions of the Provisional Electoral
Council (CEP) in its preparations. It encourages
all political parties that have rejected violence to
participate in the electoral process.
"The Security Council expresses its
intention to organize a mission to Haiti before 1
June 2005, possibly in conjunction with a mission
of the Economic and Social Council Ad Hoc
Advisory Group on Haiti.
"The Security Council expresses its
gratitude to the countries that have contributed
personnel to the Mission. It urges troop - and
police-contributing countries to complete the
authorized strength of MINUSTAH as soon as
possible, stressing that prompt completion of this
step is an essential requirement for the continuing
success of the operation.
"The Security Council expresses its full
support for the Special Representative of the
Secretary-General for Haiti, Juan Gabriel Valdes,
and commends the work done by MINUSTAH
and all of its personnel."
This statement will be issued as a document of
the Security Council under the symbol S/PRST/2005/ 1.
The Minister for Foreign Affairs of Haiti has
asked to speak. If no member of the Council objects, I
propose to give him the floor.
I call on the Minister for Foreign Affairs of Haiti.
Mr. Simeon (Haiti) (spoke in French): As this
meeting of the Council draws to a close, I should like
very briefly to again thank the brotherly country of
Argentina for having organized this special debate, and
to convey to you, Mr. President, my friend Rafael
Bielsa, heartfelt congratulations for the skill with
which you have conducted the proceedings.
I should also like to thank all those who
responded to his appeal today. The level at which they
participated demonstrates the level of solidarity that
they feel with my country. I would like to thank them
for their acts of solidarity and for the understanding
that they have shown of our problems, which has been
apparent from all of their statements. I would also like
to thank them for having sincerely voiced their
concerns and offered their advice. I promise that that I
will report back to my Government and, through the
media, to my people and to the social and professional
organizations in my country. I would also like to say
that, with their support, we will move forward in the
future - I know that their support will always be
friendly and based on feelings of solidarity.
The President (spoke in Spanish): There are no
further speakers inscribed on my list. The Security
Council has thus concluded the present stage of its
consideration of the item on its agenda.
I cannot conclude without thanking the
Secretariat, whose staff members tirelessly provided
water and other essential logistical support, as well as
the interpreters, without whom the Security Council
would be a Tower of Babel.
The meeting rose at 5.35 p.m.
▶ Cite this page
UN Project. “S/PV.5110Resumption1.” UN Project, https://un-project.org/meeting/S-PV-5110Resumption1/. Accessed .