S/PV.5509Resumption1 Security Council
▶ This meeting at a glance
34
Speeches
0
Countries
0
Resolutions
Topics
African Union peace and security
Sustainable development and climate
Peacekeeping support and operations
Security Council deliberations
Peace processes and negotiations
UN procedural rules
Africa
The President: I should like to inform the
Council that I have received letters from the
representatives of Liberia, Niger and Pakistan in which
they request to be invited to participate in the
consideration of the item on the Council's agenda. In
conformity with the usual practice, I propose, with the
consent of the Council, to invite those representatives
to participate in the discussion, without the right to
vote, in accordance with the relevant provisions of the
Charter and rule 37 of the Council's provisional rules
of procedure.
There being no objection it is so decided.
At the invitation of the President, the
representatives of the aforementioned countries
took the seats reserved for them at the side of the
Council Chamber.
I wish to remind all speakers, as I indicated at the
morning session, to limit their statements to no more
than four minutes in order to enable the Council to
carry out its work expeditiously. Delegations with
lengthy statements are kindly requested to circulate the
text in writing and to deliver a condensed version when
speaking in the Chamber.
The next speaker inscribed on my list is the
representative of Guatemala, to whom I give the floor.
Mr. Skinner-Klee (Guatemala) (spoke in Spanish): I would like to begin by congratulating the
Republic of Ghana on its presidency of the Security
Council this month. It is an honour to see the Minister
for Foreign Affairs of your country, Mr. Nana Addo
Dankwa Akufo-Addo, chairing the meeting. We
welcome the initiative to discuss peace consolidation in
West Africa, because it enables us, in the Council and
in general, to review the situation prevailing in the
countries of that important subregion of Africa, in
order to contribute to finding comprehensive solutions
to the various challenges facing the region. In that
context, we welcome the presence and support of the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
West Africa, Mr. Ould-Abdallah, as well as the
Executive Secretary of the Economic Community of
West African States (ECOWAS), Mr. Ibn Chambas.
Guatemala has closely observed the violent
conflicts involving various countries of that region of
Africa. Guatemala itself experienced an internal
2
conflict that lasted four decades, and we understand the
urgent need to strive for peace, stability and
development. We also understand the importance of
regional cooperation and the benefits of strengthening
integration mechanisms.
At no other time in the past have we been as close
to establishing a favourable environment for the
creation and strengthening of international capacities
and for articulating strategies that will help to achieve
sustainable development in the region. The
revitalization of ECOWAS and its links with the
African Union, the way in which it works with the help
of the United Nations and the support of other
international actors are steps in the right direction for
these efforts and thus, bode well for a better future for
the people of the region.
We are glad that the document circulated for this
meeting (5/2006/610) has acknowledged the need to
strengthen and bolster that kind of concerted action.
Guatemala strongly supports the high-level meetings of
the United Nations Secretariat and regional
organizations, as well as the creation of the Standing
Committee. We believe those will help keep us focused
in the correct strategic direction and offer general
guidance on the practical level. We must now take care
of those mechanisms to ensure that they are effective,
binding and flexible and that they always act in
keeping with the principles and purposes of the United
Nations Charter.
We must remember that security matters are of a
priority nature, and cooperation in military and
political areas should be sustained and coordinated.
However, we believe that cooperation should go further
and should try to address the precarious humanitarian
situation of refugees and internally displaced persons
in the regions. The synergy between ECOWAS and the
Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for
Refugees (UNHCR) in that area seems to be a sound
approach.
We also attach similar importance to another joint
effort that we believe will contribute to peace
consolidation in the region, namely, the cooperation
among United Nations entities that are designed to
harmonize disarmament, demobilization and
reintegration programmes, while taking into account
the special needs of women and children as the most
vulnerable individuals, as well as the disabled.
06-46124
Good governance, the strengthening of justice
systems and the formulation and pursuit of human
rights policies will not be possible without
strengthening national capacities and keeping those
capacities up-to-date. Here too, we see a special role
for actors in the region, who should supplement United
Nations actions aimed at continued identification of the
priorities and actions needed for the elaboration of
effective strategies and programmes to overcome
challenges and contribute to the region's development.
In that connection, we welcome what appears to be a
Council practice: the incorporation of elements
anticipating that need within the framework of
peacekeeping operations.
I should like to refer briefly to the role of
development of the Peacebuilding Commission, which,
following its initial organizational and informational
meetings, must provide concrete follow-up to actions
needed to stimulate peace consolidation and attain the
wider objective of sustainable development in the
region.
Given the experience acquired through the
Economic and Social Council's Ad Hoc Advisory
Groups on African countries emerging from conflict,
we believe it is important that the Peacebuilding
Commission cooperate proactively not only in the
important work of mobilizing international
cooperation, but also in helping national authorities
establish priorities and devise realistic strategies and
coherent policies adapted to the circumstances and
environment of each country.
We must bear in mind that peace consolidation is
not achieved only by preventing outbreaks of violence
or physically rebuilding a country or its legal
framework. The Peacebuilding Commission must go
further and support comprehensive changes that
eliminate practices leading to social, economic and
political exclusion and transform State institutions so
that citizens can regain confidence in them and
participate in them.
Therefore, the cooperation that the Peacebuilding
Commission can provide to the Security Council
should be to offer a mechanism to follow up on the
initial work of maintaining peace and security, in
which all actors involved in a particular transition and
recovery process can interact openly and transparently,
addressing the broader areas involved in peace
consolidation - areas in which the Economic and
06-46124
Social Council, in its particular area of responsibility,
has tasks to accomplish. That would ultimately
contribute to better interaction, coordination and
coherence not only between the two Councils but also
throughout the United Nations system.
Finally, Guatemala notes with satisfaction the
recent creation of the United Nations Integrated Office
in Sierra Leone, established by the Security Council in
order to consolidate peace in that country, help the
Government to strengthen human rights and achieve
the Millennium Goals, improve transparency and
cooperate with the country so that it can hold
democratic elections in 2007. We have the same
expectations for Cote d'Ivoire in October 2006.
Guatemala welcomes the developments in
Guinea-Bissau and the activities of the United Nations
Peacebuilding Support Office in Guinea-Bissau.
Likewise, the positive changes that have occurred in
Liberia are true examples of stability and strengthening
in the region. These examples make us optimistic about
the achievement of a promising future for all our
brothers and sisters in the region.
The President: I now call on the representative
of Finland.
Ms. Lintonen (Finland): I have the honour to
speak on behalf of the European Union (EU). The
following countries also align themselves with this
statement: Albania, Bulgaria, Croatia, Montenegro,
Romania, Serbia, the former Yugoslav Republic of
Macedonia and Turkey, as well as the Republic of
Moldova and Ukraine.
The European Union welcomes this opportunity
to exchange views and contribute to the process of
consolidating peace in West Africa. The EU commends
the considerable progress made in recent years in
establishing peace and security in West Africa,
especially in Liberia and Sierra Leone.
Liberia has held its first free and fair elections
and has chosen Africa's first woman President to lead
the country into reconstruction and recovery. Liberia's
democratic Government has taken bold measures to
improve the transparency of its budget. We welcome
the Governance and Economic Management Assistance
Programme, which has already assisted in the partial
lifting of sanctions. The arrest and trial of former
President Taylor demonstrate that those responsible for
war crimes, crimes against humanity or violations of
3
international humanitarian law cannot escape justice.
The EU appreciates the essential work of the Special
Court for Sierra Leone and its vital contributions to the
establishment of the rule of law in the region.
The European Union welcomes the request of
Sierra Leone to be included on the agenda of the newly
established Peacebuilding Commission, as well as the
Commission's positive response to that request. Sierra
Leone will now benefit from the Commission's support
for post-conflict peacebuilding and recovery during the
crucial time of the preparation of the June 2007
elections.
Notwithstanding those positive developments,
many West African countries remain in precarious
situations. The European Union remains concerned
about the fragile political and socio-economic situation
in Guinea-Bissau.
In neighbouring Guinea, the reform process has
stalled. The EU strongly reiterates its call for the new
Government to engage in a dialogue with all parties
concerned in order to improve political stability and
pave the way for democratic reform. The volatile
situation in Cote d'Ivoire continues to hamper peace
and stability in the region. The EU is concerned about
the serious delays in the peace process, in particular in
the implementation of the road map aimed at the
scheduling of elections by the end of October this year.
The stability of the entire West African region depends
to a great extent on developments in Cote d'Ivoire.
The European Union adopted a comprehensive
Strategy for Africa in December 2005. Within the
framework of the Strategy, the EU is committed to
strengthening the dialogue on peace and security in
Africa and to supporting the efforts of its African
partners to build stability on the continent. In line with
the Strategy, the EU maintains an open dialogue with
the African Union and with subregional organizations
on a wide range of issues related to peace and security
on the continent. Notably through its African Peace
Facility, the EU actively supports institutional
capacity-building in these areas.
A year earlier, in 2004, the European Union
adopted its Strategy for West Africa on conflict
prevention, management and resolution. The objective
of the Strategy is to promote regional approaches to
West African transnational problems and to improve
coordination in close cooperation with the main
partners active in the region.
The European Union is well aware that national
solutions alone are not sufficient to address the security
threats in West Africa, owing to the cross-border nature
of problems such as small arms and light weapons,
child solders, refugees, the illegal exploitation of
natural resources, human trafficking and immigration.
In addition to providing its support to each country of
the region through national programmes, the EU is
committed to a regional approach and to improved
coordination with the key partners active in the region,
namely, the Economic Community of West African
States (ECOWAS) and the United Nations Office for
West Africa.
The European Union, as Co-Chair of the
International Contact Group on the Mano River Basin,
is also closely involved in a number of political
dialogues in the region within the framework of the
International Working Group on Cote d'Ivoire and
looks forward to the first meeting of the International
Working Group on Guinea-Bissau. The Special
Representative of the European Union Presidency for
the Mano River Union will ensure the continued
promotion of peace and stability with political
interlocutors in the region.
The European Union also engages in internal
cooperation and coordination among its member States,
relying on the coherent and harmonized use of various
instruments at its disposal, such as political dialogue
and development cooperation.
The European Union attaches special importance
to the development of crisis prevention, management
and resolution capabilities in Africa.
An EU Action Plan for support for peace and
security in Africa under the European Security and
Defence Policy was adopted in 2004. Using the full
mix at its disposal, the EU combines European
Commission development programmes and European
Security and Defence Policy actions to support African
capacity-building in the field of peace and security.
Efforts are under way to further strengthen EU support
to African capabilities for the prevention, management
and resolution of conflicts.
Against that background, the EU continues to be
fully engaged in conflict prevention and management
in West Africa in support of regional organizations and
the countries of West Africa in their efforts to enhance
peace and stability.
06-46124
The President: The next speaker is the
representative of Namibia, to whom I give the floor.
Mr. Shiweva (Namibia): Allow me at the outset
to congratulate you, Sir, on your assumption of the
presidency of the Security Council for the month of
August. We appreciate the opportunity to participate in
this open debate on peace consolidation in West Africa
and commend you and your delegation for this
important initiative. We also thank you for the
thoughtful concept paper (S/2006/610, annex) that
forms the basis of the Council's deliberations today.
Namibia believes that peace and stability in West
Africa are fundamental to achieving sustainable
development, not only in that subregion but also in
Africa as a whole. It is in that context that Namibia
continues to participate in United Nations
peacekeeping missions in that subregion, by
contributing troops as well as military and civilian
police observers.
We note with satisfaction the steady progress that
has been made in Sierra Leone, Guinea-Bissau and
Liberia, and we commend the role played by the
United Nations, the African Union (AU), the Economic
Community of West African States (ECOWAS) and the
international community in ensuring peace and security
and laying the foundations for democracy and the rule
of law. Functional Governments and democratic
institutions have been established; improved health and
education systems in these countries have also been put
in place.
However, serious attention should be paid to the
disarmament and demobilization of ex-combatants and
the reintegration of displaced persons and refugees.
Cooperation within and among the countries of the
region is required for a successful disarmament,
demobilization and reintegration (DDR) process. This
should be done in a balanced, comprehensive and
transparent manner. Peacebuilding efforts must focus
on security, the rule of law and the provision of basic
services and social and economic infrastructure.
We are happy to note that the newly created
Peacebuilding Commission has agreed to focus its
work on the situations in Sierra Leone and in Burundi.
Its performance will be tested and judged upon the
results of the consideration of those situations. It
should, therefore, prove its ability and effectiveness in
that daunting challenge before it.
06-46124
With regard to Cote d'Ivoire, we are pleased to
note that the Pretoria Agreement on the peace process
in that country continues to be respected and adhered
to by the parties in their implementation of their
agreements. We are encouraged by the efforts of the
United Nations, ECOWAS and the African Union in
bringing about a lasting solution to the problems in
Cote d'Ivoire. We applaud the mediation role of
President Mbeki of South Africa on behalf of the
African Union and encourage continuous consultations
with the Secretary-General and the Security Council.
However, we have doubts about the peacekeeping
efforts in that country, particularly the command
relations of the United Nations peacekeeping force on
one hand and the international force on the other, to
which the Government of Cote d'Ivoire has referred on
several occasions. Furthermore, we are concerned
about the fact that the elections in Cote d'Ivoire
continue to be postponed. We are, however, hopeful
that pre-election tasks such as disarmament,
demobilization and reintegration, voter identification
and registration, the designation of polling stations and
polling officers and other related assignments will be
completed in good time for peaceful and democratic
elections to take place.
It must be emphasized that reconciliation is the
key to sustainable peace. Reconciliation is a two-way
process that should aim at forging a spirit of
forgiveness rather than vengeance or retaliation.
However, a distinct line has to be drawn between
reconciliation and the search for justice. While we
recognize that crimes committed during a conflict
should be accounted for, we are also cognizant of the
need for an independent, competent judicial system and
an open trial process to be put in place, not to punish
those who committed crimes, but to rehabilitate them
and to correct the mistakes that were made. In this
connection, my delegation fully supports the role and
authority of the International Criminal Court, the
International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda and the
Special Court for Sierra Leone. We further support
their full utilization and funding.
As in any other conflict, the majority of those in
West Africa who have suffered due to armed conflict
are women and children. In that connection, we
strongly believe that a post-conflict peacebuilding
strategy and programmes should be designed for
women, children and girls, especially in the areas of
education and employment creation.
While we fully agree that Africa should take the
lead in finding solutions to Africa's problems, we wish
to reiterate that the United Nations, in particular the
Security Council, should not abdicate its responsibility
for maintaining international peace and security. In that
regard, we call for the strengthening of the relationship
between the United Nations and regional and
subregional organizations in promoting durable peace
and sustainable development in Africa.
Democratically elected Governments should be
supported and strengthened. Furthermore, the DDR of
former combatants should be completed within
established time frames and all former combatants
should be placed in the socio-economic mainstream of
society. We are hopeful, in this regard, that the
Peacebuilding Commission will fill the gap by exerting
and coordinating peacebuilding efforts in countries
emerging from conflict.
We urge the United Nations agencies dealing with
Africa to assist the AU and subregional organizations
in promoting good governance, democracy, respect for
human rights and the rule of law. Enhancing the
capacity of the AU in conflict prevention, management
and resolution is of paramount importance.
Finally, my delegation would like to underscore
that greater investment should be made in conflict
prevention, as we believe that conflict prevention is
cost-effective, in terms of both saving lives and
financial resources. Let us, therefore, strive to establish
an early warning system that will enable us to detect
the signs of conflict and address them head-on before
the real conflict occurs.
The President: The next speaker is the
representative of Egypt, to whom I give the floor.
Mr. Abdelaziz (Egypt) (spoke in Arabic): It gives
me great personal pleasure, Sir, to see you presiding
over the Security Council today as head of Ghanaian
diplomacy and to read out to the Security Council a
statement by His Excellency Ahmed Aboul Gheit,
Minister for Foreign Affairs of the Arab Republic of
Egypt, who, due to the situation in the Middle East, is
unfortunately unable to participate in this important
meeting in person, in response to your kind invitation.
His statement reads as follows.
"Mr. President, I wish to express to you
personally and to the Government of sisterly
Ghana my gratitude and appreciation for your
initiative in calling for this important meeting of
the Security Council at the ministerial level to
debate peace consolidation in West Africa, which
is a significant component of our efforts to
achieve peace and stability in the African
continent and of the maintenance of international
peace and security. This initiative, taken together
with that of the United Republic of Tanzania last
January on peace, security and development in
the Great Lakes region, testifies to the importance
that African countries attach to assuming a
leading role in the settlement of their regional and
subregional problems and to contributing
effectively to meeting the aspirations of both
Africa and the international community.
"Egypt is strongly committed to working
with its brothers and sisters in Africa to achieve
peace, stability and development. As a current
member of the African Union's Peace and
Security Council and the Organizational
Committee of the United Nations Peacebuilding
Commission, Egypt attaches great importance to
reinforcing the regional approach in addressing
peace consolidation. To that end, Egypt believes
in the need to develop and strengthen the
institutional partnership between the African
Union and the African subregional organizations
on the one hand, and the United Nations on the
other.
"However, in order to ensure the success of
such institutional relationships and to increase its
potential to achieve its objectives, the requisite
partnership must be based on a comprehensive
vision for peace consolidation that addresses the
concept of peace in an integrated manner,
including the security, political, development,
cultural, social, and human dimensions and
ensuring the coordination of the efforts and roles
of all influential actors. All that should be
founded on the principles and purposes enshrined
in the United Nations Charter and the principles
of international law. Such a comprehensive
approach to peace is the only sure way to prevent
conflict and relapse into conflict, as well as to
ensure security, stability and development in
Africa.
"Despite the important role of the Security
Council in the maintenance of international peace
and security, experience has shown that there are
limits to the capacity and role of the Council in
addressing the requirements of the transition from
conflict to comprehensive development,
particularly as it has repeatedly hesitated to open
channels of genuine and effective coordination
with the General Assembly, the Economic and
Social Council and the relevant regional and
subregional organizations.
"Consequently, the establishment of the
Peacebuilding Commission as an advisory
intergovernmental forum for coordinating the
efforts and roles of the organs and actors capable
of contributing to peace consolidation was an
important achievement for the United Nations
and for Africa. Egypt, as the coordinator for the
African Group in New York on that issue,
supported the initiative and contributed to all
stages of its realization. I am confident that the
substance and conclusions of our discussions
today will enrich the prospective discussions of
the Peacebuilding Commission on Sierra Leone
in particular, as well as its future thematic
discussions relevant to peace consolidation in
Africa in general.
"Allow me now to lay out Egypt's views on
the elements proposed by you, Sir, as the focus of
our discussions today, as contained in the
valuable concept paper that was distributed
earlier and on which I congratulate you.
"West Africa has undoubtedly entered a new
phase in the settlement of the conflicts that
hampered its potential over the past decade. The
achievement in Sierra Leone in the past few years
is a model for the convergence of the will of its
people, together with their neighbours in other
West African States, the African Union and the
international community, as represented by the
United Nations, the European Union and other
partners. Equally encouraging are the confident
steps taken by Liberia on the same path to peace
and national reconciliation, which will enable it
to achieve the required peace and stability.
"Moreover, we believe that with more
international economic and technical support,
Guinea-Bissau should witness increasing political
stability and sustainable development. We are
also confident that the wisdom and the will of the
united people of Cote d'Ivoire will enable it to
transcend its temporary plight with the help and
support of the African Union. All those
developments prove that West Africa is set to take
a major political, security and economic leap,
supported primarily by the firm resolve and
resilience of its peoples and their aspirations to
own their future and to espouse a spirit of
tolerance and reconciliation, together with their
efforts to reinforce the rule of law and the
foundations of democracy and to expand their
political and economic participation.
"Equally important is the need to address
cross-border issues with implications for regional
stability, such as the illicit trade in small arms
and light weapons and its links to the illegal
exploitation of natural resources; the recruitment
of mercenaries; improved settlement of the status
and future of refuges; the settlement of land
ownership disputes; and other issues that could
fuel conflicts and wars in the subregion.
"To that end, we need to adopt a two-tiered
integrated strategy for peacebuilding and peace
consolidation. The first tier should focus on the
direct and individual needs of the countries under
consideration, while the second tier should
address the needs of West Africa from a
subregional perspective aimed at enhancing
cooperation among the West African States in the
areas of security and economic development and
at supporting the pioneering role of the Economic
Community of West African States (ECOWAS) in
those areas.
"As for the direct needs of individual
countries, the proposed peacebuilding strategy
must emanate from a national vision presented by
the country under consideration, depicting its
own priorities in a manner that would allow for
the most efficient coordination among the various
contributing actors, with the aim of capitalizing
on the existing political momentum and available
resources. We expect the Peacebuilding
Commission to play a lead role in ensuring such
coordination. Moreover, past experience has
shown that the point of departure for achieving
sustainable peace is the institutional, human and
legislative capacity-building of the country
emerging from conflict, in parallel with the
rehabilitation of public services, such as
education, health and security. We need to ensure
parallel progress on both tracks of peacebuilding.
"I wish to emphasize, in that context, that
the success of any regional or international effort
is linked to the degree to which such efforts
correspond to the nature and specificities of the
country under consideration and to which they
avoid the imposition of uniform models,
concepts, approaches and ideas that do not take
those specificities into account and that could be
interpreted as an attempt to impose trusteeship on
those countries, thus rendering all such efforts
counterproductive to the objective of sustainable
peace. Egypt insists that any approach to
addressing the needs and requirements of
countries emerging from conflict must reinforce
national ownership of all peacebuilding activities
and related concepts.
"Moving to the second tier of the integrated
strategy, aimed at meeting subregional
requirements for peace consolidation, we believe
in the importance of further enhancing the roles
played by the African Union and ECOWAS in the
establishment of a system of security and
integration based on respect for the sovereignty
of States over their own territory, including
measures to secure borders against the illicit
trafficking of arms and other illegal commercial
activities. In that respect, in cooperation with the
Special Adviser to the Secretary-General on
Africa, from 17 to 19 June 2006, Egypt hosted a
meeting of an international working group on
combating the illicit exploitation of the
non-natural resources in Africa. We believe that
such measures must also include the initiation of
an early warning system capable of containing
conflicts by capitalizing on regional good offices,
the completion of ongoing efforts to establish a
stand-by force for the purposes of peacekeeping
and rapid deployment, and enhancing cooperation
in the area of exchange of information and
experience on lessons learned from the
management of disarmament, demobilization and
reintegration programmes. Other measures aimed
at encouraging trade and facilitating movement
across borders for the purpose of social and
commercial exchange are also of immense
significance.
"All such measures would also require
strong support from the United Nations, the
international financial institutions and the donor
countries through the provision of technical and
financial assistance, as well as other necessary
expertise and support, to the African Union and
ECOWAS in order to enable both organizations to
discharge their roles in that sphere.
"Egypt maintains high-profile relations with
all West African States and is committed to
enhancing their capacity to achieve their national
priorities and interests through existing bilateral
mechanisms. The Egyptian Fund for Technical
Cooperation with Africa is one important
mechanism in that area and is currently preparing
to support the reintegration programme in Liberia
through small projects aimed at providing
employment opportunities to demobilized
elements and to contribute to security sector
reform and capacity-building for the Liberian
national police. Egypt remains prepared to
support the efforts of its sisters and brothers in
West Africa in their quest to build and
consolidate comprehensive and sustainable peace
that would fulfil their aspirations."
The President: The next speaker on my list is the
representative of Senegal, to whom I give the floor.
Mr. Badji (Senegal) (spoke in French): I am
pleased, Mr. President, along with offering you my
sincere congratulations, to tell you how proud my
delegation is to see you bringing the mark of African
leadership to the Security Council during this month of
August 2006, a month replete with threats, particularly
due to the current upheavals in the Middle East.
In reiterating to you the unswerving support of
your friend and brother, Cheikh Tidiane Gadio,
Minister of State, who, because of urgent duties was
unable to be with us today, as he would have wished, I
should like on behalf of my delegation to congratulate
you and, through you, your country, Ghana, so dear to
my country, on the very timely choice of the theme of
the discussion which brings us together today. I should
like to convey respectful greetings to the Ministers for
Foreign Affairs of Qatar and of Cote d'Ivoire, to the
Secretary-General in the Ministry of State in charge of
Foreign Affairs of Guinea, to the Executive Secretary
of the Economic Community of West African States
(ECOWAS) and to the Special Representative of the
Secretary-General for West Africa, and to pay tribute to
them for their outstanding contributions to this
discussion. I am grateful to you, Sir, and to the other
members of the Council for having authorized me to
address you on behalf of my country, Senegal.
After decades of deadly upheavals that have beset
a number of countries in West Africa, the subregion
seems recently to be experiencing a return to social
peace. Today, this normalization is to be seen in
Liberia, in Sierra Leone and in Guinea-Bissau, which
once seemed to be caught in an endless spiral of
violence. In Cote d'Ivoire, a country which was known
as a friendly, hospitable and stable country, the process
of national reconciliation is now taking shape. Thus,
the subregion is now enjoying favourable conditions
where the diligent support of the international
community would help to finally ground West Africa in
a positive process of peace and common prosperity.
In order to achieve this noble objective, we must
take the steps required by this favourable situation. I
will now merely refer to four of these steps. The first
step relates to consolidating confidence-building
measures. In countries of the subregion that are
emerging from conflict, where peace remains
precarious and fragile, special attention needs to be
given to the effectiveness of disarmament,
demobilization and reintegration (DDR) programmes.
This exercise should include, to the extent possible, the
integration into State institutions, including the army,
of elements coming from various factions. That is
particularly crucial because peace cannot be reduced
merely to a cessation of hostilities and the conclusion
of an agreement. Peace, above all, means cultivating
mutual trust and undoing attempts to take recourse in
violence. Clearly, the implementation of this strategy
can work only with the substantial support of
international donors and the full involvement of the
new Peacebuilding Commission, the United Nations
Office for West Africa (UNOWA), and the specialized
agencies, funds and programmes of the United Nations.
The second step involves speeding up the process
of integration. The efforts of ECOWAS to integrate
member States must be strengthened. Achievements
already made in this area are many and encouraging
and are reflected at the ECOWAS level by an abundant
juridical and institutional framework. Among other
achievements, I would refer to the treaty that
established the Community and its various protocols,
in particular, the one relating to the Mechanism for
06-46 124
Conflict Prevention, Management, Resolution,
Peacekeeping and Security, established in Lome in
1999, and the one relating to Democracy and Good
Governance, adopted in Dakar in 2001.
The work of consolidating the achievements of
the Community must take place through a proactive
campaign so that peoples of the subregion internalize
the ideals of ECOWAS and so that all States conform
without delay to the spirit and the letter of the
Community's rules. In this campaign, civil society and
non-governmental organizations have a decisive role to
play.
The third step is to promote the security-
development tandem. More robust struggle is required
to deal with the proliferation of small arms and light
weapons. The illicit circulation of these weapons
encourages the appearance of criminal gangs, either
domestic or foreign, whose evil deeds undermine the
very foundation of States and render fragile young
nations under construction.
On this subject, I would recall the danger posed
by mercenaries, a phenomenon that was strongly
denounced a little less than three years ago in this very
Chamber by Minister of State Gadio during an open
debate on that question (see S/PV.4720). In order to
ward off the danger of small arms and illicit light
weapons and by their users, in 1998, ECOWAS
adopted the Moratorium on the Importation,
Exportation and Manufacture of Light Weapons in
West Africa, which has now become the Convention on
Small Arms and Light Weapons, their Ammunition and
Other Related Materials, supported by the Programme
for Coordination and Assistance for Security and
Development, which benefits from support from the
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP). The
support of the international community for this
programme is still needed to improve this vital sector
of Community security.
But, make no mistake, poverty causes Violence,
as reflected in the shocking, unbearable image of
young West Africans, overwhelmed by despair and
forced to take set sail on the waters of the Atlantic
aboard makeshift boats seeking some hypothetical
better life. For many of them, the odyssey ends in
tragedy. This distressing phenomenon is a reminder to
our partners of the need to establish with West Africa
more effective cooperation to convince young people
that life is also worth living in their own countries,
which are so rich in economic possibilities.
Finally, the fourth step involves consolidating
democracy and the rule of law. Efforts at the State level
must be continued to further develop a democratic
culture and the rule of law. All sectors of national life
must participate in this sacred endeavour, primarily
schools, civil society, non-governmental organizations,
opinion-makers and the media.
With regard to the media, journalists need to be
better trained and ethics committees must be
established to avoid a situation where, because of
irresponsibility or negligence, tension or conflicts are
created, with devastating effects. Another participant in
the consolidation of democracy and the rule of law
should be the justice system which must be free and
independent in a society where citizens who believe
that their rights have been violated are able to have
recourse to an ombudsman or to a State mediator in an
environment where executive, legislative and judicial
branches coexist and are strictly independent.
The normalization of the political situation in
ECOWAS countries should not be considered to be
irreversible - far from it. If we consider the classic
case of Guinea-Bissau, we can see that lack of support
from the international community at a crucial time,
when the country needed to consolidate the
achievements of peace quickly, led to the return of the
demons of Violence. That is a constant that applies to
all countries emerging from conflict or crisis, whether
they are in the West African subregion, elsewhere in
Africa or in other parts of the world.
I reiterate my heartfelt congratulations to you,
Mr. President, for having organized this important
debate. I venture to hope that your initiative will help
to raise awareness with regard to the consolidation of
peace and stability in West Africa.
The President: The next speaker on my list is the
representative of Brazil, to whom I give the floor.
Mr. Tarragfi (Brazil): I would like to thank the
Ghanaian presidency for having convened this timely
open debate on peace consolidation in West Africa, a
subject of the utmost importance for my country. I
would like to extend our warmest greetings to you, Sir,
Minister Nana Akufo-Addo, as you preside over the
meeting.
I am also grateful to the Special Representative of
the Secretary-General for West Africa, Ahmedou Ould-
Abdallah, and to the Executive Secretary of the
Economic Community of West African States
(ECOWAS), Mohamed Ibn Chambas, for their
informative statements.
This Council meeting addresses two topics of
particular interest to all of us: peacebuilding and
Africa. Brazil has long held that lasting peace can be
achieved in post-conflict situations only by means of
the early implementation of concrete measures aimed
at attaining social, economic and institutional
development.
It is in the interests of the international
community to contribute to the consolidation of peace
in West Africa. Peace, security and development not
only are crucial for the people in the region, but also
help spread progress to a wider area in the continent. In
that sense, Brazil considers the Zone of Peace and
Cooperation in the South Atlantic, which comprises
countries from West Africa and South America, to be a
valuable instrument in fostering peace and
development and in promoting closer cooperation
among countries on both sides of the ocean.
In recent years, countries in West Africa have
been involved in a number of conflicts. But today,
thanks to the return of peace, Liberia, Sierra Leone and
Guinea-Bissau can aspire to enjoying economic growth
and political stability; C6te d'Ivoire is making every
effort to return to constitutional rule.
The stability of those countries, however, is
fragile and requires continuous support. For this
reason, the various United Nations missions in the
region should be maintained and reinforced, and
cooperation among them should open a new and
dynamic process to tackle cross-border issues. Without
neglecting the immediate humanitarian and security
needs, the main task of the United Nations is to support
long-term initiatives in West Africa that can produce a
"virtuous cycle" of socio-political inclusion,
sustainable development and peace, thereby preventing
a relapse into violence and political instability.
That long-term effort must be predicated on the
understanding that no peace is sustainable if the root
causes of the conflict are not addressed, as rightly
elaborated in the concept paper prepared for this debate
(S/2006/610).
The countries in West Africa require the creation
and reinforcement of capacity-building, which is
essential for a prosperous and stable economy. In
addition, cooperation among neighbouring countries is
to be encouraged. We are of the View that, in the short
run, two interrelated issues deserve special attention:
the reduction of youth unemployment, and programmes
for disarmament, demobilization and reintegration
(DDR) and for security sector reform.
Unemployment deprives young people of a
legitimate source of income and makes them prey to
warlords in their petty but bloody conflicts. Foreign
investment and trade can help put the region back on
the track of development. DDR programmes must have
reliable resources in all of their phases and, when a
peacekeeping operation is deployed, should rely on
assessed resources for funding. To that list, one could
add the use made of the natural resources of the region.
It is important to prevent the illegal exploitation of
natural resources, the proceeds of which are used to
fuel war. The Kimberly Process has shown us the way
ahead.
The newly established Peacebuilding
Commission represents an important instrument for
supporting the consolidation of peace in West Africa.
We are happy that Sierra Leone will be considered in
the country-specific configuration of the Commission.
The Peacebuilding Commission has been created to
garner resources and support in order to address the
problems of countries in the rebuilding process. The
Commission's work on Sierra Leone will certainly lead
us to understand better the regional dynamics and the
needs of other countries in the region.
In West Africa, the Brazilian Government
considers that Guinea-Bissau deserves particular
attention. That country has struggled to achieve
stability, but its situation is fragile. The lack of
economic growth remains a source of unrest, and State
institutions sorely need to be supported and
strengthened. The United Nations and its Member
States should show, with practical deeds - as Brazil
has tried to do - its solidarity with Guinea-Bissau.
The Community of Portuguese-Speaking Countries and
the India-Brazil-South Africa Forum are also assisting
that country with projects that, we hope, will have a
positive and immediate impact on the population.
It is important that the Council continue its
quarterly review of the United Nations Peacebuilding
06-46 124
Support Office in Guinea-Bissau and consider
broadening its mandate. We firmly believe that
investing a little more time and money in Guinea-
Bissau now will spare suffering in the future and
obviate the need to return after a hasty exit.
Brazil would like to pay tribute to the endeavours
of the African Union in West Africa. I would also like
to congratulate ECOWAS for its relentless efforts in
the defence of peace and development in the area. In
particular, I would like to express my Government's
appreciation for the decision to transform the
moratorium on small arms into a convention, which
will represent a credible framework for action. We
equally commend the contribution made by the United
Nations Office for West Africa in drafting the
convention.
My country has a special interest in the
development of Africa, the source of the majority of
the Brazilian population. The current administration of
President Lula attaches high priority to strengthening
relations with the African continent. We are committed
to supporting all initiatives designed to make the West
African countries prosperous and stable.
I believe that this debate provides further
evidence of the relevant and active role of Ghana in
building peace in the region. As President Lula said in
welcoming President John Kufuor on his recent Visit to
Brazil,
"for decades Ghana has been writing a
fundamental page in the African saga. The heroic
struggle of Kwame Nkrumah against colonialism,
for the right of Africa to decide its destiny,
enthused the continent and the world. Many
Brazilians mirrored themselves in that example".
The President: The next speaker on my list is the
representative of India, to whom I give the floor.
Mr. Sen (India): It gives me great pleasure to
participate in this open debate on the theme of peace
consolidation in West Africa. This initiative of the
Ghanaian presidency of the Security Council is timely
and meaningful, and we welcome it. It was to be
expected from a nation that has consistently made
noteworthy contributions to peace, not only in its own
region, but internationally as well. For me personally
and for my country, it is an added pleasure to address
the Foreign Minister of Ghana presiding today, given
our traditionally close bilateral relations and our
experience of the wisdom and insight that Nana Akufo-
Addo has always brought to any international forum he
has graced with his presence. I have also been asked by
our Minister of State, Anand Sharma, to convey to you,
Sir, his personal greetings and warmest good wishes.
To save time, I shall not adhere entirely to my
written text.
The history of conflict in West Africa has shown
that stability can be imposed for a while by force of
arms and the determined involvement of the world. But
history also tells us that such stability is often short-
lived. Peace achieved through force of arms is often, to
quote the Secretary-General, a situation that is stable
but fragile.
Indeed, recent World Bank studies emphasize that
countries that have suffered conflict in the recent past
are also likely to see conflict return: the risk that the
country will fall back into conflict within the first five
years of the end of a conflict is nearly 50 per cent. That
worrisome statistic is made worse by the fact that
armed conflict inevitably increases military
expenditure in the countries involved. Such
expenditure not only crowds out other public spending
but, on a worldwide basis, has come to exceed
spending on international development assistance.
Furthermore, given the current international economic
order, the advantages obtained through employment
generation in parts of Africa have been squandered
through negative resource flows, low commodity
prices, a lack of access to international markets and the
debt trap. In other words, global conditions make it
likely that the vicious circle of conflict-peace-conflict
becomes self-sustaining. Thus, the creation of peace
has rarely ensured that peace will endure.
The overarching question before the world today
is how to find ways to consolidate peace. In other
words, how can regional organizations and the United
Nations prevent States emerging from old conflicts
from lapsing into new conflict situations? We agree
that, in this context, we must promote sustained,
equitable and employment-driven economic growth, as
that is an inextricable part of the process of building
durable peace. The effort to achieve these goals needs
to be managed institutionally and driven
internationally. It is this that gives relevance to the
newly established Peacebuilding Commission.
We believe that conflict prevention must include
operational prevention efforts, which include responses
to immediate and pressing crises through preventive
diplomacy and structural prevention, which implies
long-term structural preventive measures to prevent
crises from arising or prevent them from recurring. The
latter often involves a long-term commitment to help
vulnerable and poor countries develop human and
institutional resources through increased development
assistance. While peacebuilding focuses on preventing
conditions that foster conflict, development focuses on
the structural conditions that prevent growth and equity
and thereby provide breeding grounds for conflict.
Peacekeeping and peacebuilding must be part of the
same continuum, if peacekeeping is to succeed.
Interestingly, studies show that military
interventions in conflict-ridden areas are actually more
expensive than preventive approaches. Estimates show
that the international community spent approximately
$200 billion on seven major interventions in the 1990s,
while it is estimated that a successful preventive
approach would have cost nearly $130 billion less.
Fundamental to a successful and long-term
preventive approach are sound macroeconomic policies
promoting sustained employment-driven growth.
Expenditure on social sector programmes of poverty
eradication, education - in particular the education of
women - immunization and basic health and basic
infrastructure creates conditions for sustained
economic growth.
In that context, I am tempted to note that
developing societies such as ours do not live on bread
alone, but equally on solidarity. India and others have
written off the debt of the seven highly indebted poor
countries. India will continue its economic and
scientific initiatives, such as the Techno-Economic
Approach for Africa-India Movement (TEAM. 9),
which involves a concessional credit of $500 million
along with technology transfers to countries in the
West African region; further cooperation with the New
Partnership for Africa's Development; and the satellite
and fibre-optic connectivity mission for the entire
African continent, announced by our President.
Another essential pillar of the process of
economic transformation involves the development of
effective mechanisms to resolve social tensions arising
from the legacy of conflict. Such mechanisms include
rehabilitation, reconciliation and reconstruction. It also
includes the development of credible institutions of
governance; stable political structures, including
political parties; and credible strategies to effectively
mobilize human and material resources. Hence the
Peacebuilding Commission must not only work with
the Security Council but also, and above all, take into
consideration inputs from other United Nations bodies
and work under the overall guidance of the General
Assembly. Effective coordination and consultation with
regional groups and organizations must be encouraged
as part of that effort.
Another key element for peace consolidation is
the development of an overall country strategy
framework to deal with post-conflict recovery and
reconstruction. What is crucial here is national
ownership, as many speakers before me have pointed
out. It is the only pragmatic answer to a practical
problem. In order to ensure that peacekeeping blends
into peacebuilding, it may occasionally be necessary to
operate without clear-cut national authority. But, in
spite of that, it is essential that embryonic national
ownership be respected through clear guidelines for
ascertaining and respecting the views of civil society
and community representatives.
That brings me to good governance. Strong local,
regional and national institutions are fundamental for
societal transformation. Without legitimate laws,
justice cannot be effective; without minimum standards
of social equality, one cannot guarantee principles of
justice and fairness. Thus, it is essential that good
governance prescribed for recipient countries should
also be practiced by the international institutions doing
the prescribing. The two speakers before me pointed to
success stories in, for example, Liberia, Sierra Leone
and Guinea-Bissau. We are engaged in Guinea-Bissau
and, to some extent, in Sierra Leone. But it is also
important to look at the recent past. There, one finds
that - to cite one example in West Africa - Sierra
Leone, which collapsed in civil war in 1990, was under
an extensive International Monetary Fund (IMF)
programme from 1994 to 1998. When civil war broke
out again, it had spent 83 per cent of the period under
an IMF programme. Therefore, the reform of
international institutions - in particular the Bretton
Woods institutions - to increase the voice and
participation of developing countries is absolutely
essential.
Lastly, it is essential that the process of peace
consolidation be implemented at various levels. At one
level, the Peacebuilding Commission will implement
its mandate of proposing integrated strategies for post-
06-46 124
conflict peacebuilding and recovery, ensuring
predictable financing and developing best practices for
cooperation among relevant actors and stakeholders. At
another level, effective regional initiatives are
essential. In that context, we fully support the efforts of
the Economic Community of West African States
(ECOWAS) and the African Union in cooperating to
address questions related to peace and security in West
Africa. Finally, there is the national level, where it is
essential that international institutions and partners
support the efforts of countries emerging from conflict
through highly concessional aid; debt waivers;
assistance with the disarmament, demobilization and
reintegration of former combatants; employment
generation strategies; and the extension of appropriate
technologies. It is only through integrated action at all
these levels that the consolidation of peace can be
made effective and durable.
The President: I thank the representative of India
for his attempt to respect the four-minute rule.
I now call on the representative of the Libyan
Arab J amahiriya.
Mr. Mubarak (Libyan Arab Jamahiriya) (spoke in Arabic): Permit me at the outset to congratulate you,
Mr. President, on your delegation's presidency of the
Security Council this month. We are convinced that
you, both personally and as a representative of your
country, will play an outstanding role in leading the
work of the Council to success. I should also like to
take this opportunity to thank your predecessor, the
Permanent Representative of France, for his efforts as
President of the Council last month. In addition, I
cannot fail to associate myself with earlier speakers in
thanking the Secretary-General, Mr. Kofi Annan, who
made a very important statement to the Council this
morning; Mr. Ahmedou Ould-Abdallah, Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for West
Africa; and Mr. Mohamed Ibn Chambas, Executive
Secretary of the Economic Community of West African
States (ECOWAS), who have participated effectively in
the debate on this agenda item.
I am speaking today on behalf of my Minister for
Foreign Affairs, Mr. Shalghem, who is unable to take
part in this important meeting. He has asked me, Sir, to
express our gratitude to your friendly country, Ghana,
for the initiative to debate the agenda item "Peace
consolidation in West Africa".
My country's participation in this debate reflects
its interest in the subject and its concern for
strengthening international, regional and national
efforts to build peace, security and stability in the West
African countries of C6te d'Ivoire, Guinea-Bissau,
Liberia and Sierra Leone. We consider those countries
to be our sisters, and my country has special bilateral
relationships with them. We are all members of the
same regional integration organization, the African
Union (AU), of which Libya was a founding member.
Indeed, the AU has played a very important role in
addressing many of the continent's problems,
particularly those of West Africa.
This debate is of particularly critical importance
given the destructive internal conflicts that have taken
place in many countries of the region, including in
Cote d'Ivoire, Guinea-Bissau, Liberia and Sierra
Leone. These conflicts have led to a loss of control
over those countries' national institutions and have
resulted in a high death toll among innocent civilians.
Indeed, they have destroyed infrastructure and property
and have caused the displacement of hundreds of
thousands of inhabitants of those countries and has
given rise to the illicit exploitation of their natural
resources. These events have had a negative impact on
economic, political and social life after a decade of
conflict.
At long last, national leaders have been able to
acknowledge that peace is the speediest and best way
to settle these conflicts. My country has worked very
hard at all levels, particularly at the leadership and
ministerial levels, to find settlements to the conflicts in
that region. The Libyan Arab J amahiriya has joined in
many international and regional efforts to that end. As
an example, I would cite the donor conference that
took place in Freetown under United Nations auspices
at the beginning of 2002, as well as our participation in
the joint initiative to rebuild Sierra Leone, which was
launched in Tripoli in February 2002, and which led to
the establishment of a joint fund for the reconstruction
of Sierra Leone in the amount of $24 million. Another
example is the 2002 campaign to destroy small arms
and light weapons in Sierra Leone. These are very
significant examples of our resolve to put an end to
these conflicts.
With the cooperation and coordination of the
African Union and the Economic Community of West
African States (ECOWAS), United Nations efforts have
led to the establishment of peacekeeping and security
operations in a number of West African countries.
We are optimistic about the political future of
these countries, in particular in terms of the gradual
transition from war and conflict to peacebuilding,
reconstruction and stability. In that regard, we thank
the Secretary-General for attaching such importance to
the problems besetting the African continent, West
Africa in particular. We share the concerns expressed
today by the Secretary-General in his statement to the
Council, in particular the weakness of good governance
arrangements, which prevents these countries from
benefiting properly from their natural resources. Yet,
we see efforts being made on a daily basis to promote
peace and security, notwithstanding the problems to
which the Secretary-General has drawn attention. In
our view, we can achieve lasting peace and security by
building and promoting national institutions,
particularly in areas such as security, democracy-
building, the rule of law, human rights, the resettlement
of internally displaced persons and refugees,
transparency in the establishment of better conflict
management and settlement mechanisms and enhanced
early warning systems designed to address conflict
before it erupts. It can also be achieved by dealing with
problems such as poverty and unemployment, which
lead to the recruitment of young people into armed
forces. International efforts should be stepped up to
mobilize resources and financial and technical
assistance that could make it possible to build peace,
stability and sustainable development. This requires
efforts by all States and regional and international
institutions in order to ensure success.
In conclusion, I assure the Council that we are
ready to contribute positively to efforts to establish
lasting peace and security, not just in West Africa but
throughout Africa, because bolstering peace and
security in the continent is at the top of Libya's foreign
policy priorities.
Mr. President, we thank you for convening this
important meeting and wish the Council every success
in the debate.
The President: The next speaker is the
representative of Sierra Leone, to whom I give the
floor.
Mr. Rowe (Sierra Leone): Mr. President, my
delegation would like to join others in welcoming you
to New York to chair this debate on the consolidation
of peace in West Africa, which is still one of the most
volatile regions in the world in terms of peace and
security. We regret that, due to unavoidable
circumstances, my Foreign Minister was unable to
attend and participate in this important meeting.
We note that virtually all the speakers in this
debate have made reference to my country, Sierra
Leone, including, just a few minutes ago, my
colleagues, the Permanent Representative of India and
the representative of the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya. We
thank those who acknowledged the progress that we
have made in becoming, perhaps, a model in post-
conflict recovery.
Due to time constraints, I will try to summarize
my statement.
Peacekeeping is an essential element, but not the
only one in the process of creating the conditions for
lasting peace in West Africa. Peacekeeping, in our
view, must be undertaken in conjunction with
peacebuilding, which has become synonymous with the
consolidation of peace. In our View, the benefits of
peacekeeping will be lost unless peacekeeping is
accompanied by a comprehensive programme of
measures for peace consolidation. The newly
established Peacebuilding Commission, to which
delegations have referred today, marks an
acknowledgement of the necessity to build on the solid
foundation laid by its peacekeepers, particularly those
of the United Nations Mission in Sierra Leone
(UNAMSIL). We are grateful that Sierra Leone is one
of the two post-conflict countries on the agenda of the
Commission, and we hope that our sister republics of
Guinea-Bissau and Liberia, which are also recovering
from devastating armed conflict, will also be
considered by the Commission in the not-too-distant
future.
This morning, we heard several views on what
constitutes the consolidation of peace. In our View,
peace consolidation should not be seen merely as an
effort to ensure that our countries do not slide back into
conflict. The primary objective of the consolidation of
peace, in our view, should be to attain sustainable
development. This involves the mobilization of
resources for economic and social reconstruction,
including, of course, repairing the infrastructural and
institutional damage resulting from conflict. The
consolidation of peace, in our View, is a development
exercise, one which must be seen and addressed in the
06-46 124
context of our poverty alleviation programmes in the
subregion.
We consider ECOWAS to be an important and
effective instrument for the consolidation of peace as
well as for peacekeeping in the subregion. In spite of
its limited logistical and other resources, ECOWAS,
through its Monitoring Group (ECOMOG) has already
demonstrated its capacity to help keep the peace. Who
can forget, for instance, the important role that
ECOMOG played in Sierra Leone before the
deployment of United Nations peacekeeping forces?
We note also that the Security Council itself
commended ECOMOG and ECOWAS for what they
had done. It also took an unprecedented decision under
Chapter VIII of the Charter to authorize ECOWAS to
enforce an arms embargo against the rebel junta in
Sierra Leone in 1997.
ECOWAS needs the support of the United
Nations and the international community to fulfil its
primary objectives of economic cooperation and
integration aimed at ensuring sustainable development
in its member States. We appeal to the United Nations
and the international community to strengthen their
relations with ECOWAS and its specialized agencies
and programmes.
While it is the responsibility of each State in the
subregion, including ours, to devise and implement
policies and programmes aimed at the consolidation of
peace and sustainable development, we strongly
believe that the United Nations and the international
community could make a tremendous contribution to
our efforts by, first, mobilizing resources, as a matter
of urgency, in support of the reconstruction and long-
term development programmes of the countries of the
subregion, most of which, including Sierra Leone, are
among the least developed in the world; recognizing
and responding to the linkage between the eradication
of poverty, sustainable development and the
maintenance and consolidation of peace; and
recognizing the linkage between the consolidation of
peace and the implementation of agreed guidelines and
commitments in international trade and financing for
development, including debt relief.
As we have witnessed, conflicts in the West
African subregion have been exacerbated by cross-
border movements of illegal small arms and light
weapons and their ammunition, as well as of
mercenaries. Many speakers, including my colleague
from Senegal, have referred to this today. Indeed, the
hard-won peace in countries such as Sierra Leone is
threatened by increasing flows of these weapons. The
United Nations and the international community can
contribute effectively to the consolidation of peace in
the ECOWAS subregion also by intensifying efforts to
eradicate the illegal trade in small arms and light
weapons, which have devastated the human and
physical resources of the subregion.
I think it is a shame that the recent United
Nations Conference to Review Progress Made in the
Implementation of the Programme of Action to
Prevent, Combat and Eradicate the Illicit Trade in
Small Arms and Light Weapons in All Its Aspects
collapsed last month. We were also disappointed that
following its recent debate on small arms (see S/PV.5390), the Security Council did not adopt any
resolution on the issue. Those facts do not augur well
for the consolidation of peace in the ECOWAS
subregion, which is awash with those illegal and
deadly weapons. However, we trust that there will be a
change of attitude when the matter is brought before
the Council again.
Meanwhile, we look forward to the adoption of
the draft presidential statement that will be issued at
the close of this meeting.
The President: I thank the representative of
Sierra Leone and the previous speaker for their respect
for the four-minute rule.
The next speaker is the representative of the
Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela, to whom I give the
floor.
Mr. Chaderton Matos (Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela) (spoke in Spanish): We are pleased, Sir, to
see you presiding over the work of the Security
Council. Your country, Ghana, has been a pioneer in
the history of liberation and the consolidation of Africa
as a region of free States.
Our commitment to international social justice
and our sense of solidarity with our brothers and sisters
of West Africa prompt us to support initiatives and
programmes to enhance cooperation within the United
Nations system, not only to eliminate real or potential
causes of war but also to consolidate peace in the
region: peace that will generate freedom, growth and
justice - and Vice versa, in a virtuous circle.
Lasting peace and sustainable development are
complementary and mutually inclusive terms. In its
process of historic democratic institutional and social
change, the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela has
deepened and broadened its relations with Africa based
on a foreign policy that draws upon our African roots
to develop a multi-ethnic and multicultural society. For
us, rhetoric has been outpaced by events. In recent
years, President Hugo Chavez and other high
Venezuelan officials have frequently visited Africa.
Thus far, we have more than doubled the number of
Venezuelan embassies in the continent; we have
created a unit within our Ministry for Foreign Affairs,
headed by a Deputy Minister, dealing exclusively with
that friendly and fraternal continent. This ideological,
political and spiritual commitment was highlighted by
the participation of our head of State in the African
Union (AU) summit held at Bajul.
We have moved forward in applying the
principles of solidarity and complementarity through
tangible, productive actions such as the signing of
cooperation agreements with Benin, the Gambia,
Libya, Mali and the Sudan, as well through measures
in support of specific programmes in Burkina Faso,
Mauritania, Mali and Niger. We have worked with the
secretariat of the United Nations Convention to
Combat Desertification, to support the efforts of Benin,
Burkina Faso, Cape Verde, Cameroon, Mali,
Mozambique, Niger, Senegal and Togo. Further
examples include our support for the programme for
woman and young people in the Sahelian region;
agreements on energy cooperation with Mali and
Senegal; and tripartite education and health projects
among Venezuela, Cuba and Africa, which are to be put
in place by the end of this year. In Venezuela, we have
established institutions such as the following: African
Friendship House, created in an area with a large
population of African descent; a regional study centre
for African historical heritage; and an educational
cooperation programme with Mali, which is open to
grant-holders from that country. That is the practical,
peaceful way in which we contribute to international
peace and security.
Extreme poverty is the greatest threat to peace.
Half of the world's population survives on less than
two dollars a day, and some 1.2 billion people live on
barely one dollar. That is both a potential and a real
source of political destabilization and social
disintegration. Hunger and the lack of health care and
education trigger violence which the most powerful
have come to meet with the ultimate response of
further violence: war.
We believe that, last year, we lost an important
opportunity to reverse those trends when we failed to
address the economic and social elements of the Goals
adopted at the Millennium Summit. The Bolivarian
Government of Venezuela is looking to the South for
new responses to old questions that we have sought to
resolve, questions imposed from the North. At present,
we are developing projects such as Televisora del Sur
(TeleSUR) to provide free and accurate information
that will show the other side of the coin, as well as
projects such as the Banco del Sur, the Universidad del
Sur and Petrosur: areas in which African nations can
work together with us.
We are focusing priority attention on education,
which is a basic tool for the liberation of peoples.
UNESCO has verified that Venezuela is now free of
illiteracy. Now, we are freer, and we want to share our
experiences.
We must support the countries of West Africa in
their democratic progress towards peace, respect for
human rights and development. That requires
continued commitment on the part of the international
community. We encounter specific problems in West
Africa, including poverty, famine, the spread of
HIV/AIDS, the role of women, the reintegration of
child soldiers and the trafficking of small arms and
light weapons. Those issues need to be addressed
together with the development of political democracy.
We support the initiatives of the New Partnership for
Africa's Development (NEPAD), launched by the
African Union in 2001, which addressed the primary
responsibilities of the peoples and Governments of
Africa in defining their economic growth and their
sustainable development.
My country hopes that the General Assembly will
be able to establish machinery, whereby nations that
make contributions to promoting the development of
African countries can present voluntary reports
concerning their achievements. Venezuela reaffirms its
concern for the well-being of our brothers and sisters,
the peoples of Africa, which will only be possible if
their most pressing needs are met in the framework of
complete freedom and the full enjoyment of human
rights.
06-46 124
At the same time, it is essential for the
international community to give all the support
requested in order to ensure that African nations have
direct control over their political and economic
processes, in keeping with the principle of the self-
determination of peoples.
The United Nations Charter was crafted in order
to ensure respect and enjoyment of such principles and
to pave the way to peace, not to allow war to prevail.
Mr. Choi Young-jin (Republic of Korea): For
years, West Africa has been riven with violent internal
conflicts. Recently, however, the political instability
that has afflicted the region for so long has, for the
most part subsided, and peace processes have been
making steady progress.
In Liberia, under the leadership of President Ellen
Johnson Sirleaf, laudable progress is being made in
rebuilding the country. Sierra Leone and Guinea Bissau
have likewise transitioned from war to constitutional
Government. And in Cote d'Ivoire, the peace roadmap
established by the International Working Group is in
place, and all Ivorian parties reached an agreement in
Yamoussoukro last month on significant commitments
for peace.
Despite those positive political developments, the
region still faces daunting challenges, including
massive cross-border refugee flows, slow economic
growth, low inflows of foreign direct investment,
heavy debt burdens and the proliferation of small arms
and light weapons. Achieving lasting peace and
security in the region will take considerable effort.
I would like to stress three steps that are, in our
view, vital to the consolidation of peace in the region:
first, taking a regional approach; secondly, focusing on
the peacebuilding process and thirdly, addressing the
root causes of conflicts.
First, my delegation believes that peace
consolidation in West Africa needs to be pursued on a
regional basis. The peoples and countries in the region
are closely interlinked, which means that ensuring
peace and security in one country necessitates close
cooperation with its neighbours. This regional
approach can best be carried out through regional
organizations. In that regard, we appreciate and support
the continuing role of the Economic Community of
West African States (ECOWAS) in maintaining peace
and security in the region, both through its own
initiatives and in collaboration with the United
Nations.
Secondly, peace and security in West Africa
requires a focus, not just on peacemaking and
peacekeeping, but also on peacebuilding efforts. As the
Secretary-General aptly put it, security in the region is
stable but fragile. The first post-conflict years are the
most dangerous, as wounded societies walk the
tightrope from chaos and violence to sustainable peace
and stability. If West Africa is to avoid falling into the
abyss of renewed conflict, it will need support for new
institutions, disarmament, demobilization, and
reintegration efforts and economic recovery, among
others. In that regard, we believe that the United
Nations Peacebuilding Commission has an important
role to play in providing guidance and in coordinating
the efforts of the Security Council, ECOWAS and other
regional and United Nations bodies that will be
engaged in the region.
Thirdly, to prevent new crises and the recurrence
of conflict, it is important to address the root causes of
instability in West Africa. Regional, ethnic and
socioeconomic tensions in the region have been
immensely destructive to infrastructure, caused mass
migrations of refugees and have led to the exploitation
of natural resources for the benefit of combatants
rather than societies. To prevent renewed conflict,
long-term economic and social development strategies
need to be formulated and implemented with the
assistance of the international community. Sustained
attention and commitment by the international
community will be crucial.
The Republic of Korea has actively participated
in international efforts to help the development of
African countries. The plan to double our official
development assistance by 2009 is part of our
commitment to assist African development. We hope
that the era of West African conflict will be followed
by an era of peace, prosperity and renewal.
The President: I now call on the representative
of Nigeria.
Mr. Wali (Nigeria): First of all, I want to thank
you, Sir, and members of the Security Council for
giving me the opportunity to address the Council on
peace consolidation in West Africa. This is an issue
that is of critical importance, not only to my country
and the subregion, but also to the entire African
continent.
I also wish to congratulate Ghana, a close and
brotherly country from our subregion, for presiding
over the affairs of the Council during the month of
August, and on a day when the issue of peace
consolidation in West Africa is being discussed. I feel
particularly happy to observe that you, Honourable
Minister, are personally chairing this meeting and wish
you a pleasant visit in New York.
I seize this opportunity, too, to express Nigeria's
gratitude to the Secretary-General, Mr. Kofi Annan, for
his continuing interest and tireless efforts towards the
resolution of conflicts and consolidation of peace in
our subregion.
Until recently, West Africa had the unenviable
record of being an unstable subregion in Africa. It was
threatened by a series of conflicts, the longest being
the conflict in Liberia. I am happy to note that the
record is gradually being reversed with the recent
election of democratic Governments in Sierra Leone,
Liberia and Guinea Bissau. Those gains were possible
through the efforts of our leaders, who had resolved
that the subregion could no longer continue to be the
theatre of unending fratricidal wars. In that connection,
the role of the Economic Community of West African
States (ECOWAS) has been exemplary and highly
commendable. In addition, the understanding and
cooperation of the leaders of the African Union and of
this body contributed in no small measure to the
growing peace in our subregion.
I must also point out that the handing over of
former President Charles Taylor to the Special Court in
Sierra Leone greatly contributed to the easing of
tension and opened a new chapter for the consolidation
of peace and security in our subregion. Mr. Taylor's
arrest and subsequent transfer to the International
Criminal Court in The Hague served as a strong
message to both present and future actors on the West
African scene that it is no longer business as usual. It
further encouraged our partners that hope is not lost for
transforming the subregion into a region of peace,
progress and economic prosperity.
In spite of those gains, however, the challenges of
peace consolidation in our subregion are enormous.
The situation in Cote d'Ivoire remains of serious
concern to us. The possible spillover effects of the
Ivorian conflict cannot be overstated. Furthermore,
peace in Liberia, Sierra Leone and Guinea-Bissau
remains fragile. The Governments of those countries
have to contend daily with the threat of relapsing into
crisis because of the daunting challenges they have to
contend with.
We cannot, therefore, consolidate peace in West
Africa without addressing some urgent issues. First, the
issue of the proliferation of small arms and light
weapons deserves greater and urgent attention. The
unrestrained access to those weapons by individuals
and groups is, without doubt, a major threat to peace.
Those weapons have proved to be a great disincentive
to non-State actors to follow the path of peace through
negotiations. On our own, we are constrained as
members of ECOWAS and the African Union from
effectively countering the consequences of the
proliferation of those weapons.
Secondly, the opportunities for economic growth
and development need to be enhanced. Like most
developing countries, the countries of our subregion
are saddled not only with the visible consequences of
conflicts, human rights abuses and poor governance,
but also with the state of our economies. That has
worsened the level of poverty and unemployment
among our youth. The spectre of youth unemployment
and its potential negative impact on our social fabric,
peace, stability and security are indicative of the scope
of the challenges facing the subregion.
Finally, the question of capacity-building and
institutional support requires no less urgent attention.
The countries of our region, particularly those
emerging from conflict, require urgent support to build
and strengthen their institutions of governance,
dispensation of justice, protection of human rights, and
promotion of health and educational services. It is in
that regard that we consider the establishment of the
Peacebuilding Commission and its ongoing work as a
genuine contribution to peace consolidation in our
subregion and look forward to the early translation of
the Commission's work into concrete action in Sierra
Leone.
It is therefore our hope that this debate will
strengthen the resolve of the international community,
including that of this body, to take concrete steps
towards further assisting the countries of our subregion
and removing the obstacles to a durable and
sustainable peace in West Africa.
The President: The next speaker on my list is the
representative of Norway, to whom I give the floor.
06-46 124
Ms. Enge (Norway): The Norwegian Government
very much appreciates your initiative, Sir, in convening
this open debate in the Security Council on peace
consolidation in West Africa. We are pleased to see that
West Africa has made considerable progress on peace
and security in recent years.
In Liberia, Africa's first female president and her
Government have taken decisive and courageous steps
towards reconstruction and recovery. We commend
Liberia for requesting that former President Charles
Taylor be turned over to the Special Court for Sierra
Leone. A society ravaged by war cannot be healed
unless those responsible for crimes against humanity
and violations of international humanitarian law are
held responsible. Sierra Leone's request to be included
on the agenda of the United Nations Peacebuilding
Commission is also important. It can help speed up the
process of reconstruction and recovery in preparation
for the 2007 elections.
Those achievements are commendable, but
fragile. Many West African countries face enormous
challenges, such as in Cote d'Ivoire, where the
precarious situation continues to threaten the stability
of the region. The international community must
continue its support for consolidating peace in West
Africa. Broad, consistent and long-term assistance to
regional organizations is crucial. It is in our common
interest to provide financial support for Governments
that struggle to enhance security, promote national
reconciliation and build peace in their societies.
The Norwegian Government will increase its
support for post-conflict peacebuilding and
reconstruction in West Africa. Norway has provided
post-conflict support to Liberia, Sierra Leone and Cote
d'Ivoire. This year, Norway plans to provide
approximately $27.5 million for humanitarian relief,
peacebuilding and reconstruction activities in Cote
d'Ivoire, Sierra Leone and Liberia.
Norway has over the years given priority to
development assistance to African nations. We also
support efforts by African Governments and work
closely with the African Union, the Economic
Community of West African States (ECOWAS) and
other regional organizations in Africa. Their leadership
is crucial in building capacity for stronger engagement
in conflict prevention, conflict resolution, peace
operations and peacebuilding on the African continent.
Allow me to highlight a few of the issues raised
in the comprehensive concept paper put forward by the
Government of Ghana.
It is important to support efforts for more
regional cooperation. It is also crucial to address cross-
border issues that could fuel conflicts and increase
tensions. We would welcome the early ratification and
implementation of the ECOWAS Convention on Small
Arms as a key to progress here. The progress achieved
by ECOWAS in developing a regional standby force
for peace operations is impressive. In particular, the
Norwegian Government would like to commend
ECOWAS for taking the lead in developing the civilian
components of the African Standby Force, including
humanitarian capacity.
As part of our long-standing cooperation with
African partners under the Training for Peace
programme, Norway has worked with the Kofi Annan
International Peacekeeping Training Institute to assist
ECOWAS in developing West African civilian capacity
for peacekeeping operations. The use by ECOWAS of
its Peace Fund for programmes of cooperation in
conflict-prone border areas deserves active
international support. Norway is about to enter into an
agreement with ECOWAS to provide financial
assistance to the ECOWAS Peace Fund and to the
ECOWAS Small Arms Control Programme.
The importance of the transparent and
accountable management of natural resources and the
establishment of oversight bodies needs to be
emphasized. Several countries in West Africa have
endorsed the Extractive Industries Transparency
Initiative (EITI) and are on their way to implement the
EITI principles. That is a key contribution to build
lasting peace and stability. We encourage and support
further EITI implementation efforts in West Africa and
look forward to broad West African participation at the
third plenary EITI conference, which is scheduled to
take place in Oslo, Norway, on 16 and 17 October this
yean
The President: The next speaker is the
representative of Pakistan, to whom I give the floor.
Mr. Akram (Pakistan): We congratulate Ghana
on its assumption of the Council presidency for this
month. We are confident, Sir, that, under your
country's leadership, the Council will find its way to
silencing the guns in the Middle East and elsewhere.
May I also felicitate Ambassador De la Sabliere and
the French delegation on last month's intense and
important presidency of the Council.
We welcome your presence here, Sir, to preside
over this important meeting of the Security Council.
We also welcome the participation of other dignitaries
in this meeting.
Africa, afflicted for years by conflict, disease and
poverty, justifiably occupies a significant segment of
the Security Council's work. Today's discussion is
relevant and timely, especially in the context of
significant strides that have been made in recent years
for peace and stability in West Africa. Sadly, that is not
the case when it comes to some other situations around
the world, such as in the Middle East.
Sierra Leone is a United Nations peacekeeping
success story. It is now engaged in peace consolidation.
We trust that the Peacebuilding Commission will
reinforce this process.
Liberia is on the road to recovery and stability
from the horrors of the cruel conflict and crimes we
witnessed three years ago. Liberia and its leadership
deserve the full support of the Council and the world
community in sustaining stability, reviving its economy
and respecting human rights.
We hope to see similar progress in Cote d'Ivoire.
That would enable this important African country to
serve once again as the economic hub of West Africa.
Pakistan enjoys friendly and fraternal relations
with the countries of West Africa. We have made our
modest contributions to the United Nations
peacekeeping and peacebuilding efforts in West Africa.
Pakistan takes pride in its participation in the United
Nations Mission in Sierra Leone (UNAMSIL). We now
look forward to contributing to Sierra Leone's
reconstruction through our membership in the
Peacebuilding Commission. Our troops are serving in
the United Nations Mission in Liberia (UNMIL) in
support of peace in that country. We are also
participating in the United Nations Operation in Cote
d'Ivoire (UNOCI).
During this meeting, our African brothers have
expressed their perspectives and priorities regarding
the problems of West Africa. The Security Council
should heed their voices. Indeed, the important issues
outlined in the presidency's non-paper for this debate,
have been the subject of frequent discussions in the
work of the Council.
During Pakistan's tenure on the Security Council,
we were able to acquire a greater understanding of the
situation in West Africa. In May 2004, Pakistan, as
Council President, organized a public meeting on
complex crises and the United Nations response. A
summary of the important ideas and suggestions
advanced in that debate was circulated as document
S/2004/723 and may be worth revisiting.
Most of the situations in Africa are complex
crises. They require a combination of actions -
conflict prevention and resolution to begin with, and,
later, peacemaking, peacekeeping, and peacebuilding.
In View of the linkage between security and
development, the newly established Peacebuilding
Commission will, we hope, be able to focus on the
multifaceted aspects of recovery and peacebuilding in
country-specific situations. Pakistan will contribute
actively to its work.
Despite the progress achieved in West Africa,
considerable work remains to be accomplished,
especially in addressing the root causes of conflicts.
What we have often referred to as the "politics of
poverty and scarcity" characterizes most of these
internal conflicts. The politics of scarcity and poverty
must be ended. In this context, greater political will is
required to break the link between the illegal
exploitation of natural resources and the illegal trade of
arms, which so often spark and sustain the conflicts in
Africa. More attention must still be given to
disarmament, demobilization, repatriation and
reintegration (DDRR) and to security sector reform.
And it is clear that laying the foundation for
sustainable development will require, apart from direct
international assistance and debt relief, better terms of
trade, larger trade capacity and greater trade access.
A heartening feature of the West African
developments is the regional approach being adopted
to address its problems, especially cross-cutting
issues - small arms, mercenaries, refugees, migrants,
et cetera. The Economic Community of West African
States (ECOWAS) has proved itself a competent and
reliable partner for peace in this region. Its leadership
merits acclaim. Pakistan fully supports your call, Mr.
President, and that of Executive Secretary Ibn
Chambas, to address the capacity and resource
constraints of ECOWAS.
A comprehensive regional approach could also
open greater possibilities for the resolution of security,
06-46 124
peacebuilding and development challenges in other
parts of the world that are today riven by rampant war,
occupation and destruction.
The President: I thank the representative of
Pakistan for his statement and, again, for his respect of
the four minute rule. The next speaker on my list is the
representative of Niger, to whom I now give the floor.
Mr. Abani (Niger) (spoke in French): I would
like in taking the floor to convey to you the
congratulations of the delegation of Niger on the work
that has been so ably accomplished under the Ghanaian
presidency of this body, work that I am sure will
ultimately lead us to concrete results at a time when
several equally crucial challenges face us, challenges
which it is your daunting but very inspiring task,
Mr. President, to manage throughout this month of
August.
I should also like to say, Mr. President, that the
delegation of Niger is pleased about the theme that you
chose for this open debate and for good reason. Peace
consolidation is indeed a challenge to our subregion
because our capacity to consolidate peace in our
subregion will determine the fate of all of our
initiatives. The regional economic programme, where
we enjoy a partnership with institutions and friendly
countries, can only be successful if we create an
environment where peace, security, good governance,
human rights, combating corruption, protecting the
environment, education and health are solidly
established.
The question of peace and security in West Africa
was soon seen as being one of the major problems
facing the Economic Community of West African
States (ECOWAS), which immediately proceeded to
strengthen its legal arsenal by adopting instruments
that would help to resolve those problems.
Today, just looking at West Africa alone, we note
a significant improvement in the peace and security
situation in the subregion. Liberia has just achieved an
outstanding success with its presidential elections, with
the crucial assumption of power by the first woman at
the head of an African State. Sierra Leone and Guinea-
Bissau are now gradually building a newly refound
peace, and their situation deserves more than ever to
benefit from the support of the international
community, in particular, that of the new Peacebuilding
Commission, in their efforts to build stable nations
with a focus on national rebuilding. Cote d'Ivoire,
likewise, enjoys the support and assistance of the
international community, and it deserves the continued
unwavering support of the international community for
the efforts it is making.
I should also say, Mr. President, that peace is not
merely the absence of conflict, nor is the absence of
conflict synonymous with peace. Indeed, situations
such as food insecurity and endemic poverty in some
of the countries of the West African subregion often
lead to the displacement of persons and to irredentist
movements, and can thus threaten peace, just as the
burden of debt and institutional deficiencies can also
constitute similar dangers to peace and jeopardize the
development of the West African subregion.
As I said before, Mr. President, your choice of
this theme was, for us, a very wise one, because here in
the United Nations these same concerns are still with
us, as shown in the fact that the World Summit
Outcome called upon all of us to establish the
Peacebuilding Commission, a body which, unlike the
plenary summit recommendations, enjoyed the active
support of a rather broad consensus, which meant that
it could be established in a relatively short period of
time.
Now that we have this mechanism, which should
help us to consolidate peace by assisting countries that
are emerging from conflict, it is essential that the new
institution fully play its role. It is also essential that we
think about how to make that body as effective as
possible.
In that regard, it is essential that the countries
concerned first proceed to build up the capacity of their
national institutions. Here, one of the problems facing
West African countries is the absence of - or
insufficient access to - justice, because judges are
overburdened. This results in delays in the
administration of justice. Similarly, when it comes to
controlling and punishing criminal activities,
deficiencies are resulting in breaches of the peace and
a breakdown of security in our countries.
The circulation of small arms and light weapons
has led to the emergence of warlords, who have taken
advantage of institutional weaknesses within States to
establish their rule, which is based on chaos and
desolation.
My delegation once again congratulates the heads
of State of the subregion, who have transformed their
Moratorium into a legally binding Convention on
Small Arms and Light Weapons, Their Ammunition
and Other Related Materials. The national control
commissions responsible for the collection of small
arms and light weapons which have been set up in most
ECOWAS countries should be congratulated, because
they have spearheaded the work that has led to the
major normative progress that has been made in West
African countries aimed at combating the illicit traffic
in small arms.
My delegation also believes that the ECOWAS
Protocol on Democracy and Good Governance is an
irreplaceable instrument that should be welcomed,
since it has facilitated increased mobilization by
countries of the subregion in situations where peace is
threatened, particularly during unconstitutional
changes of power. That ambitious Protocol on Good
Governance provides for concrete actions, not least
against countries that are conspicuously lacking when
it comes to good governance. It is an instrument that
should be kept strong in the interests of peace
consolidation in West Africa. That instrument, which,
when it was adopted, was considered revolutionary, is
today a tool that should be promoted and disseminated,
because it has deterrent potential when it comes to
preserving good governance.
Another important mechanism that West Africa
must make its own in the interests of peace
consolidation is the African Peer Review Mechanism,
which was initiated within the framework of the New
Partnership for Africa's Development. That innovative
mechanism is a kind of reward for good governance
and peace at the regional and international levels, and
its impact can only strengthen African Governments
and their peoples in their nation-building efforts,
which, as we know, can be fruitful only in a climate of
peace and security.
Accordingly, the countries of the West African
subregion are, in the main, participating in economic
reform programmes in the context of bilateral and
multilateral partnerships. While we appreciate the
crucial contribution of those partners, in terms of both
support for the economy and multifaceted efforts to
combat poverty, such partnerships must give top
priority to national ownership of policies and
programmes by the countries concerned. It is also true
that the search for effective partnerships - when these
have a strictly economic orientation - could upset the
fragile balance of peace and security, particularly in the
poorest countries. For example, we know that social
unrest can be caused by a sudden sharp increase in
certain taxes or in the price of essential goods. While
that might seem normal in some situations, in other
cases it could jeopardize peace and security.
My point is that, in countries where everything is
fragile, peace too is inevitably precarious, and that the
particular situation of each area must be taken into
account. Countries emerging from conflict should
therefore be given the special attention that they
deserve within the Peacebuilding Commission.
In this regard, the approach taken by the
Commission - to consider all the aspects of the work
that needs to be done to help countries to consolidate
peace by providing for the participation of financial
institutions - is extremely important. The
Commission must, however, fully implement the
existing cooperation frameworks between West Africa
and the African Union on the one hand, and West
Africa and the United Nations on the other. That global
partnership for peace is already quite prominent in the
fundamental ECOWAS texts, and, as has been rightly
noted by the United Nations, which provides for active
involvement by the regional economic communities in
peace consolidation, that should be emphasized and
further refined.
Those are my delegation's comments on this
extremely important topic that you, Sir, wisely chose
for discussion in this body. I would like to conclude by
reiterating my delegation's support for the draft
presidential statement that you have prepared.
The President: The next speaker is the
representative of Liberia, to whom I give the floor.
Mr. Eesiah (Liberia): I should like at the outset
to join previous speakers in welcoming you, Sir, as you
preside over this meeting, attended by foreign
ministers of the countries of the Economic Community
of West African States (ECOWAS). I bring you
greetings and felicitations from Her Excellency
Mrs. Ellen Johnson-Sirleaf, President of the Republic
of Liberia, and from the Government and the people of
Liberia, and I congratulate you on my own account.
Let me also take this opportunity to thank you for
having convened this Security Council open debate on
peace consolidation in West Africa.
His Excellency Ambassador George W. Wallace,
Foreign Minister of Liberia, would have very much
06-46 124
loved to participate in these deliberations, but, owing
to current developments in Liberia, he was not able to
be here.
Liberia, which has experienced more than 14
years of civil war, welcomes this open debate aimed at
finding equitable solutions to the many problems
affecting the West African subregion. We know too
well the magnitude of these problems and the
devastating effect they have on the youth of our
country. The conflicts have not only killed thousands
of our people, but have also brought about economic
deprivation and political instability in the subregion.
There is no doubt that the Economic Community
of West African States (ECOWAS), the African Union
(AU), the European Union, the United States of
America, the United Nations, the international
community and non-governmental organizations, as
well as peace-loving countries, made tremendous
sacrifices to bring about peace in Liberia, thereby
successfully resolving years of civil war, which left the
country devastated and in total ruins.
It is the View of my delegation that Liberia is
ready to support and implement the draft presidential
statement to be adopted later in this ministerial-level
meeting, aimed at promoting sustainable economic
development and putting in place a viable mechanism
and measures to stop the cross-border recruitment of
child soldiers in the subregion.
The Liberian delegation believes that that cross-
border recruitment is one of the most serious problems
affecting our region, and every effort must be made to
put an end to it immediately.
The Liberian delegation is, therefore, appealing
to you, Mr. President, and to this ministerial meeting to
make it an extreme priority to implement the decision
of this meeting in order to stop the importation of
weapons into the subregion, which has robbed it of its
young people.
My delegation would like to pay special tribute to
the Mano River Union, ECOWAS and the African
Union for their tireless efforts to help bring about the
peace that Liberia is enjoying today. We request those
organizations to consolidate that hard-won peace by
encouraging and promoting economic and employment
opportunities for the people of the subregion.
The President: I thank the representative of
Liberia for respecting our rule.
I now give the floor to Mr. Ahmedou Ould-
Abdallah, Special Representative of the Secretary-
General for West Africa, to respond briefly to
comments made.
Mr. Ould-Abdallah (spoke in French): I should
like to make only four points.
I think it is extremely important to insist once
again that the unemployment among young people in
West Africa poses a great threat to the stability of
countries, as a number of speakers have said. It is also
a threat to the bilateral relations between the region
and its closest neighbours, particularly in Western
Europe. In all of these countries, the immigration of
young people is also an issue.
Secondly, the Security Council should discuss
how to find the best way to support the presidential and
parliamentary elections to be held in 2007 in Benin,
Cote d'Ivoire, Mali, Nigeria, Senegal and Sierra Leone.
It is a period of tension - tension that must be
prevented.
Thirdly, there are democratic countries such as
yours, Mr. President - stable countries such as Mali
and Niger, which at the same time are fragile countries
exposed to drought and other unpredictable events.
They respect the law and the rights of their citizens.
How can we help them to strengthen their capacities?
My last point is that African public opinion is
better informed. Today, I circulated a little radio that
cost $1, bought in Africa - a radio that all Africans
can buy. My generation could not buy one for less than
$50. Therefore, Security Council debates are followed
closely by all African countries in crisis, thanks to
FM. radio, so we must be increasingly mindful of
public opinion in Africa, particularly West Africa. It is
aware of the messages that the Council can send it.
The President: I thank Mr. Ould-Abdallah for his
comments and, once again, for his gift.
After consultations among members of the
Security Council, I have been authorized to make the
following statement on behalf of the Council:
"The Security Council, recalling its relevant
resolutions and the statements of its President,
stresses the importance of addressing the issue of
peace consolidation in West Africa in a
comprehensive and coordinated manner. It
recognizes the need for such an approach for
durable solutions to the conflicts in West Africa
and to explore ways and means to promote
sustainable peace, security and development.
"The Security Council welcomes the
transition from war to democratic rule in Sierra
Leone, Guinea-Bissau and Liberia, as well as
current efforts aimed at implementing measures
leading to free and fair elections in C6te d'Ivoire.
It also notes that the security situation in those
countries remains generally stable but fragile.
"The Security Council stresses the need to
build the capacity of national institutions to
address the root causes of conflict as an essential
part of peace consolidation, especially in the
areas of political and economic governance as
well as the rule of law and the fight against
impunity.
"The Security Council recalls the measures
it has implemented on the illegal exploitation of
natural resources in the region and encourages
member States of the Economic Community of
West African States (ECOWAS) to promote
transparent and sustainable exploitation of such
resources.
"The Security Council stresses the primary
role of each West African Government in peace
consolidation for the benefit of all citizens and
reiterates the importance of all leaders working
together for peace and security in the region.
"The Security Council considers that illicit
trafficking in small arms and light weapons still
poses a threat to peace and security in the region.
In this connection, it welcomes the decision of
ECOWAS member States to transform the
Moratorium on the Import, Export and
Manufacture of Light weapons into a binding
Convention on Small Arms and Light Weapons,
Their Ammunition and Other Related Materials.
It further urges all States, both within and outside
the region, to ensure compliance with its existing
arms embargoes in West Africa and for States
within ECOWAS to ratify the Convention as soon
as possible to enable it to come into effect
promptly.
"The Security Council considers that civil
society, including women's organizations, has a
role to play in supporting peace consolidation
initiatives in the region and that their efforts in
this regard deserve to be supported as
appropriate.
"The Security Council underlines the
crucial importance of the disarmament,
demobilization and reintegration (DDR) of ex-
combatants, taking into account the special needs
of child soldiers and women, and encourages the
international community to work in close
partnership with the countries concerned. It
further affirms the need to find lasting solutions
to the problem of youth unemployment in order
to prevent the recruitment of such youth by
illegal armed groups.
"The Security Council considers reform of
the security sector an essential element for
sustainable peace and stability in West Africa and
urgently calls on the donor community and the
international financial institutions to coordinate
their efforts to support the States concerned.
"The Security Council stresses the
continued need for assisting West African States
and ECOWAS to curb illicit cross-border
activities.
"The Security Council reiterates the
importance of finding effective solutions to the
problem of refugees and internally displaced
persons (IDPs) in the region and urges the States
in the region, in collaboration with relevant
international organizations and donor countries,
to create the necessary conditions for their
voluntary and safe return.
"The Security Council welcomes the
positive role played by the international
community and civil society in addressing the
humanitarian situation in many parts of the region
and urges them to provide adequate resources as
part of a coordinated humanitarian response
strategy to improve the human security of the
people of West Africa in need of such protection.
"The Security Council stresses the need to
ensure improved coordination of donor initiatives
in order to make the best use of available
the
resources, as well as encourages donor partners to
redeem their pledges in a timely manner.
"The Security Council further stresses the
need for continued and enhanced cooperation
between the United Nations, ECOWAS and the
African Union in peace consolidation initiatives,
based on an integrated approach and with the aim
of maximizing the use of available resources.
In this connection, it commends the role of the
United Nations Office in West Africa, as well as
other United Nations offices, missions and
agencies in the region in facilitating, in close
cooperation with the ECOWAS Executive
Secretariat and its member States, the
achievement of peace and security priorities of
the region. It further encourages the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for West
Africa and the United Nations missions in the
region to continue their efforts in coordinating
United Nations activities to ensure their improved
cohesion and maximum efficiency.
"The Security Council underscores the
importance and the role of the Peacebuilding
Commission in assisting countries emerging from
conflict to achieve sustainable peace and stability.
"The Security Council emphasizes the
regional dimension of peace and security in West
Africa and requests the Secretary-General, in
consultation with the ECOWAS secretariat, to
submit to it by the end of the year a report with
recommendations on the cooperation between the
United Nations missions deployed in the region
and on the cross-border issues in West Africa."
This statement will be issued as a document of
Security Council under the symbol
S/PRST/2006/38.
There are no further speakers inscribed on my
list. The Security Council has thus concluded the
present stage of its consideration of the item on its
agenda.
The meeting rose at 5.20 p.m.
▶ Cite this page
UN Project. “S/PV.5509Resumption1.” UN Project, https://un-project.org/meeting/S-PV-5509Resumption1/. Accessed .