S/PV.5629Resumption1 Security Council
▶ This meeting at a glance
31
Speeches
0
Countries
0
Resolutions
Topics
Israeli–Palestinian conflict
Peace processes and negotiations
Security Council deliberations
Middle East regional relations
Sustainable development and climate
War and military aggression
Middle East
The President: I wish to remind all speakers to
limit their statements to no more than five minutes in
order to enable the Council to carry out its work
expeditiously.
I now give the floor to the representative of Cuba.
Mrs. Nl'ifiez Mordoche (Cuba) (spoke in Spanish): It is my honour to speak on behalf of the
Non-Aligned Movement. The Non-Aligned Movement
has reaffirmed on many occasions its clear position on
the situation in the Middle East. The Movement is
deeply concerned at the increasing deterioration in the
situation on the ground and the impasse facing the
peace process in the region. The Non-Aligned
Movement has reiterated its deep concern at the
situation in the occupied Palestinian territory during
the most recent period, particularly as the result of the
disproportionate, indiscriminate and excessive use of
force by Israel, which has caused has caused a large
death toll and injuries to Palestinian civilians as well as
huge material destruction.
It is clear that the question of Palestine is at the
core of the problem in the Middle East. As long as this
situation remains unsolved, pockets of tension in the
region will continue to proliferate.
There can be no just and lasting solution to the
question of Palestine that is not based on the principle
of land for peace, which includes the establishment of
an independent Palestinian State in all the Palestinian
territory occupied since 1967, with East Jerusalem as
its capital, living in peace and security with Israel and
its other neighbours. Israel must immediately stop its
aggression against the Palestinian civilian population
and withdraw its troops from the Gaza Strip to the
positions it occupied before June 2006.
Israel must put an end to its occupation of and
illegal practices in the occupied Palestinian territory,
including the illegal construction of the separation
wall, which is aimed at seizing and annexing
Palestinian land and property and modifying the
demographic and geographic character of the
Palestinian territory.
The Non-Aligned Movement reaffirms its support
for Mahmoud Abbas, President of the Palestinian
National Authority and Chairman of the Executive
Committee of the Palestine Liberation Organization, in
2
his rejection of a so-called Palestinian State with
provisional borders. Such a so-called provisional State
would, in essence, be no more than an entity under the
domain and control of Israel as the occupying Power,
rather than a sovereign and independent State.
The Movement rejects any attempt to alter the
terms of reference of the peace process and further
rejects the imposition of unilateral measures aimed at
the imposition by Israel of an unlawful and unilateral
solution. The Non-Aligned Movement stresses the need
for the resumption of direct and substantive
negotiations between the parties so as to achieve a
comprehensive, just, lasting and peaceful settlement to
the question of Palestine, on the basis of the relevant
United Nations resolutions and in accordance with the
norms and principles of international law enshrined
therein.
The Non-Aligned Movement expresses its strong
condemnation of Israel's heinous act of aggression
against the blessed Al-Aqsa mosque and the holy city
of Al-Quds al-Sharif - the demolishing of a historical
road connecting Bab Al-Maghriba with the holy
Al-Aqsa mosque compound, in addition to two rooms
adjacent to Al-Buraq wall. The Non-Aligned
Movement also condemns Israel's continued
excavation work beneath the holy Al-Aqsa mosque
compound, undermining its foundations and
threatening it with collapse. The Non-Aligned
Movement considers those acts and measures taken by
Israel, the occupying Power, as a provocation to the
feelings and sentiments of the more than one billion
Muslims in the world. The Movement denounces
Israel's continued policy of denying Palestinian
worshippers access to their religious sites.
In the context of the grave situation that the
Middle East faces at present, the Non-Aligned
Movement reaffirms the permanent responsibility of
the United Nations, including the Security Council,
with regard to the situation in the region.
It is no secret that Israel's unpunished acts are to
a large extent the result of the protection provided it by
the United States Government in the Security Council
and in other international forums. The United States
has shackled the Security Council through the use of
31 vetoes relating to draft resolutions on the question
of Palestine and through countless threats to resort to
this undemocratic and obsolete privilege.
07-23762
The impasse facing the peace process does not
benefit anyone, not even the Israeli people, who also
suffer the consequences of their Government's policies.
Actions such as the brutal military aggression against
Lebanon and Israel's presence in the occupied Syrian
Golan are likewise unacceptable.
The Government of Lebanon has continuously
endeavoured to stabilize the situation in its territory
following Israel's relentless aggression and serious
violations of the sovereignty and territorial integrity of
Lebanon. The Non-Aligned Movement welcomes the
steps taken by the Lebanese Government to implement
resolution 1701 (2006), particularly through the
deployment of the armed forces in the region south of
the Litani River and along the Blue Line. The
Non-Aligned Movement also welcomes the
deployment of Lebanese armed forces along the
northern and eastern borders of Lebanon with a view to
ensuring the security and stability of the borders.
The Movement remains deeply concerned at the
ongoing air and land violations by Israel of the Blue
Line, in breach of resolution 1701 (2006), and strongly
calls on Israel to end its occupation of the northern part
of Al-Ghajar, a town on the northern side of the Blue
Line, and to refrain, starting immediately, from any
violation of Lebanese sovereignty and of resolution
1701 (2006), as well as from any act of provocation
vis-a-vis the Lebanese armed forces or the United
Nations Interim Force in Lebanon.
The Non-Aligned Movement calls for a prompt
settlement of the Sheba'a farms issue, with full respect
for Lebanese sovereignty and territorial integrity, as
stipulated in resolution 1701 (2006). In that regard, the
Movement takes note of the important proposal made
by the Lebanese Government in its seven-point plan
regarding the Sheba'a farms and calls on all parties to
cooperate to protect Lebanon's sovereign rights in that
area, and notes the important endeavours of the
Secretary-General in that regard.
The Movement is acutely aware of the enormous
challenges facing Lebanon as a result of the 1.2 million
cluster bomblets launched by Israel during its
aggression against Lebanon last summer. While
condemning the use of such weaponry by Israel and
deploring the death toll resulting from them, the
Movement strongly urges Israel to provide the exact
locations of use of those deadly weapons, as well as
07-23762
maps of the mines planted by Israel during its
occupation of southern Lebanon.
The Non-Aligned Movement urges the Security
Council to decide on the entry into force, with no
further delay, of a comprehensive and lasting ceasefire
in Lebanon. The Non-Aligned Movement welcomes
the generous contributions and pledges made during
the Rafik Hariri Paris 111 conference, held in Paris on
25 January 2007.
The Non-Aligned Movement reaffirms that all
measures and actions already taken, or that will taken
in future, by Israel, the occupying Power, such as its
illegal decision of 14 December 1981, which purports
to modify the legal, physical and demographic
conditions and institutional structure of the occupied
Syrian Golan, as well as the measures taken by Israel
to implement its jurisdiction and administration there,
are null and void and have no legal effect.
We reaffirm also that all those measures and
actions, including the illegal construction and
expansion of Israeli settlements in the Syrian Golan
since 1967, are a clear violation of international law,
international agreements, the Charter of the United
Nations and the relevant decisions of the Organization,
including resolution 497 (1981) and the Fourth Geneva
Convention relative to the Protection of Civilian
Persons in Time of War of 12 August 1949, as well as a
challenge to the international community.
The Movement demands that Israel abide by
resolution 497 (1981) and Withdraw completely from
the occupied Syrian Golan to the borders of 4 June
1967.
The Non-Aligned Movement will continue to
support and contribute in every way possible to efforts
to achieve a just, comprehensive and lasting peace in
the Middle East, based on all relevant United Nations
resolutions, including resolutions 242 (1967), 338
(1973), 425 (1978), 1397 (2002) and 1515 (2003), the
terms of reference of the Madrid Conference, the
principle of land for peace, the Arab Peace Initiative
adopted by the summit meeting of the League of Arab
States held in March 2002 at Beirut, and the Road
Map.
The President: The next speaker is the
representative of Azerbaijan, to Whom I give the floor.
Mr. Mehdiyev (Azerbaijan): In my capacity as
Chairman of the Organization of the Islamic
3
Conference (OIC) Group at the United Nations, I have
been authorized to read out a statement issued by the
OIC Group on 8 February 2007.
"The OIC Group at the United Nations in
New York met on 8 February 2007, at the
ambassadorial level, to consider the grave
situation in occupied East Jerusalem as a result of
Israeli aggression against the holy city and the
blessed Al-Aqsa mosque, and issued the
following statement.
"The OIC Group at the United Nations in New
York expresses its strong condemnation of
Israel's heinous aggression against the blessed
Al-Aqsa mosque and the holy city of Al-Quds
Al-Sharif, committed by demolishing a historic
road connecting Bab Al-Maghariba with the holy
Al-Aqsa mosque compound, in addition to two
rooms adjacent to Al-Buraq wall. The OIC Group
also condemns Israel's continued excavation
works beneath the holy Al-Aqsa mosque
compound, undermining its foundations and
threatening it with collapse. The OIC Group
considers these acts and measures taken by Israel,
the occupying Power, a provocation to the
feelings and sentiments of more than one billion
Muslims in the world. The OIC Group denounces
Israel's continued policy in denying Palestinian
worshippers access to their religious sites.
"The OIC Group stresses that these provocative
Israeli actions are not the first of their kind. Since
1968, the Security Council has adopted 16
resolutions, particularly resolution 465 (1980),
and has repeatedly declared that measures and
arrangements taken by Israel, the occupying
Power, which aim at changing the legal status,
demographic composition and character of the
city of Al-Quds al-Sharif are null and void and
without any legal validity whatsoever.
Furthermore, the Security Council has repeatedly
reaffirmed the applicability of the Fourth Geneva
Convention of 1949 to all the territories occupied
by Israel in 1967, including East Jerusalem.
"The OIC Group stresses that Israel, the
occupying Power, by escalating its aggression
against Al-Quds Al-Sharif and creating new facts
on the ground, raises doubts about its seriousness
to resume the peace process which aims at
achieving a just settlement of the Palestinian
question - seriously threatens all efforts exerted
to revive the political process and aborts any
possibility for negotiations on the final status
issues, particularly the issue of Al-Quds
Al-Sharif.
"The OIC Group, reaffirming the centrality of the
cause of Al-Quds Al-Sharif for the whole Islamic
umma, affirms the firm position of the
Organization of the Islamic Conference, for
which the cause of Palestine and Al-Quds
Al-Sharif was the raison d'etre, on the
preservation of the Arab and holy characters of
the city of Al-Quds Al-Sharif.
"The OIC Group, emphasizing the need to
prevent a further escalation in the situation in the
region, calls upon the Security Council, as the
body responsible for maintaining international
peace and security, to take immediate and urgent
action in order to bring an end to Israeli
intransigence and violations against the blessed
Al-Aqsa mosque and Al-Quds Al-Sharif, and to
guarantee Israel's respect for the Council's
resolutions and for international law, particularly
international humanitarian law."
The President: I give the floor to the
representative of Turkey.
Mr. Ilkin (Turkey): As Turkey has aligned itself
with the statement delivered by the representative of
Germany on behalf of the European Union, I will
underline just a few points which we deem to be of
critical importance at this juncture in the Middle East.
The events in the region once again depict a grim
reality for the international community. The complex
webs of issues in the region are certainly more
interconnected and entangled than ever. The Middle
East peace process continues to be stalled. The recent
internal strife in Palestine and Lebanon has further
complicated the situation and caused it to deteriorate.
With respect to the Palestinian-Israeli conflict,
there is an absolute need for the realization of the
vision of two States Without further delay. We welcome
the recent agreement to form a Palestinian national
unity government. This is a must. We hope that the new
Palestinian government will be established on a
political platform that embraces the Quartet principles
and meets the expectations of not only the Palestinians,
but the international community as well.
In the Middle East peace process, we believe that
a constructive approach with a view to initiating the
final status negotiations can be within our reach.
However, as the two parties consider the steps
necessary to build mutual confidence, they should also
refrain from actions that might lead to new tensions
and crises. In this respect, we reaffirm our stance
against terrorism and condemn all acts of terrorism and
violence targeting innocent people. At the same time,
we urge all parties to consider and implement
constructive, rather than divisive, policies. In the case
of the most recent incident, it was right that Israel
finally halted its construction work around Al-Haram
Al-Sharif. Yet we understand that the excavation is
unfortunately still continuing. We urge Israel to act
with the utmost caution and consideration, and to
assume policies which reflect high regard for the
religious sensitivities of the Muslims.
The Quartet statement of 2 February, announcing
a re-energized approach and a commitment to engage
with the parties, has been a step in the right direction.
In line with this approach, we believe that regional
efforts which support and complement the work of the
Quartet would be of great value and importance as
well. Turkey is also of the opinion that the Syrian and
Lebanese tracks should not be overlooked. In this
regard, any comprehensive settlement must take into
consideration the relevant United Nations resolutions
and the principle of land for peace, as well as the Arab
peace plan.
Unfortunately, the Israel-Lebanon war of last
summer has set back the efforts of Lebanon to heal and
rebuild itself. On the other hand, we think that Lebanon
could make a strong leap forward and achieve stability
if resolution 1701 (2006) were to be fully
implemented. Certainly, in this framework, the
normalization of relations between Lebanon and its
neighbours would also be vitally important.
We condemn very strongly the two explosions
near Beirut today, which led to the loss of lives. We are
of the view that the collective energy of the Lebanese
should be channelled for the rebuilding of their
country. We wish to see the reconciliation of
differences through a political dialogue in which
common interests in Lebanon become the top priority
for each and every Lebanese. Given today's regional
and global trends, Turkey believes that the preservation
of the unique and exemplary socio-political structure of
Lebanon is of paramount importance. Let me underline
once again that Turkey supports the sovereignty,
political unity and stability of Lebanon; that support is
amply displayed by its contributions to the enhanced
United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL), as
well as to the Maritime Task Force of that Mission.
Furthermore, Turkey has opened its seaports and
airfields for the use of friendly and ally countries to
ease access to Lebanon through UNIFIL. We have also
responded to international calls for the recovery and
reconstruction of Lebanon, and have pledged a total of
$50 million in the form of donations.
Given its historical and cultural bonds with the
brotherly countries of the Middle East, Turkey is
determined to continue to contribute to and facilitate
the regional and international efforts for the realization
of the long-desired peace, security, stability and
prosperity in the region.
The President: I give the floor to the
representative of Japan.
Mr. Oshima (Japan): I would like to thank you,
Mr. President, for having convened this public debate
on the Middle East. I also thank Mr. Alvaro de Soto for
his comprehensive and - I must add - unfailingly
lucid briefing on the often opaque and always complex
situation in the Middle East region. The picture of the
situation in the Middle East that Mr. De Soto has
presented reflects, indeed, a mixture of anxiety and
expectation.
First, on Palestine, the international community
harbours deep concerns over the unremitting
deterioration in the political, security, economic and
humanitarian spheres in Palestine, and in particular
about the political conflict between Palestinian factions
over the past few weeks, which has resulted in many
deaths and casualties. While the international
community can and should help, it is the Palestinians
who bear the primary responsibility to bring unity to
their effort to address those problems. We therefore
commend the fact that President Abbas and Hamas
Political Bureau head Mr. Meshaal agreed, in their
recent talks in Saudi Arabia, to form a unity
Government in order to end the political difficulties in
the Palestinian territories.
That positive step should contribute to the
resumption of the peace process. Japan strongly
expects that, based on the agreement, the violence will
cease and the new unity Government that is to be
established will make serious efforts to advance the
peace process with Israel. Japan gives every
encouragement to the Palestinians and Israelis in their
common effort to find normalcy and peace, and will
follow developments closely.
In that regard, we welcome as a positive step the
fact that the Government of Israel has taken some
measures for the partial transfer of tax and customs
revenues to the Palestinian Authority and the easing of
restrictions on the movement and access of the
Palestinian people following the summit meeting held
last December between the Israeli and Palestinian
leaders. That being said, we expect Israel to take steps
to reduce the number of checkpoints and to transfer
further tax and customs revenues. Japan also expects
that both the Israeli and Palestinian sides will continue
their peace efforts with strong determination,
especially regarding the remaining issues, such as the
improvement of the dire humanitarian situation of the
Palestinian people, the extension of the ceasefire
agreement to the West Bank, and the safe return of the
abducted Israeli soldier, as well as the release of the
Palestinian prisoners.
At the same time, the international community,
on its part, particularly countries in the region and the
major donors, must undertake and strengthen proactive
engagement to support the Palestinians' efforts to
advance the peace process. Japan welcomes the recent
diplomatic initiatives of the international community to
revitalize the peace process, including Saudi Arabia's
mediation efforts towards the agreement on the unity
Government, the initiative by United States Secretary
of State Rice to hold a tripartite meeting among Israel,
Palestine and the United States, and the convening of
the Quartet meetings. It is hoped that those efforts will
lead, through further direct talks between the parties,
Palestine and Israel, to a two-State solution reflecting
previous international references, including the
relevant Security Council resolutions, the road map
and the Arab peace initiative.
Of particular importance in that regard, in our
view, is the need to give strong, tangible and visible
support to President Abbas, who has been exerting the
most serious efforts to ensure the interests of all of the
Palestinian people. If a new Palestinian unity
Government, once established, lives up to the intention
to achieve peace and peaceful coexistence with Israel,
the international community will undoubtedly respond
positively to such a new direction.
For its part, Japan will continue its assistance to
the Palestinian people as a major and long-time
participant in the international donor community for
Palestinians. We will implement projects for
strengthening the Office of the President, for
humanitarian assistance, including medical care and
public health, and for job creation, as part of our
support for President Abbas in his endeavours for
peace. Japan will also continue working on the concept
of a corridor of peace and prosperity, which is a
development plan for the Jordan Valley, through
regional cooperation involving Israel, Palestine and
Jordan. Further action on that initiative will follow.
Let me briefly touch upon the situation in
Lebanon. Japan supports the efforts of the Lebanese
Government, under the leadership of Prime Minister
Siniora, to achieve stability in Lebanon. Japan hopes
that the concerned parties and factions in Lebanon will
engage proactively in the efforts for stability and
reconstruction in the country through dialogue and
without resorting to violence.
In that regard, we appreciate the International
Conference for Support to Lebanon convened in France
last month, which sent a strong message reconfirming
the resolve of the international community to continue
providing support to Lebanon. At the same time, we
strongly condemn the terrorist attack on innocent
civilians that took place in Lebanon today, the day
before the second anniversary of the attack against
former Prime Minister Rafik Hariri and 22 others.
There remain many challenges to be addressed,
foremost among them the issue between Lebanon and
Israel, to ensure the full implementation of resolution
1701 (2006) and the stabilization of the situation in
Lebanon. The disarming and disbanding of all
remaining militias, as well as the delineation of the
border, are among the key issues that must be tackled
with vigour. A comprehensive peace that includes both
the Lebanese and the Syrian tracks is the only way to
achieve permanent peace in the region. From that point
of view, Japan expects Syria to play a proactive role
for the realization of regional peace and stability.
In conclusion, the Middle East region is fraught
with risks and dangers, but at the same time there are
encouraging initiatives that require strong support from
the international community if we are to avert the
further escalation of tension and conflict. Not least
among the issues to be tackled are the situation in Iraq,
the Iranian nuclear issue and the situation in Lebanon.
Those issues are all affected by and interrelated with
one another.
That is why it is so important to ensure that
progress is made on the core, central issue in the region -
the Middle East peace process, including the
Palestinian problems - leading to a positive outcome.
We take this opportunity to reaffirm Japan's readiness
and determination to continue its proactive,
constructive engagement in the region and to extend
the maximum assistance possible in order to contribute
to the efforts to achieve a just, comprehensive and
permanent peace, while working for stability and
development in the region as a whole.
The President: I give the floor to the
representative of Malaysia.
Mr. Zainuddin (Malaysia): Let me first of all
extend my delegation's congratulations to you, Sir, on
your accession to the presidency of the Security
Council for the month of February. We look forward to
an energized Security Council under your presidency
as the Council carries out its responsibility for the
maintenance of international peace and security.
We commend the delegation of the Russian
Federation on its presidency for the month of January.
My delegation wishes to express its appreciation
to you, Sir, for organizing this open debate on an issue
which is of the utmost importance. It is our earnest
hope that this open debate will be followed up with
timely and concrete action by the Security Council on
the situation in the Middle East, in particular the
Palestinian issue. It is our earnest hope also that the
Security Council, under your able presidency, will take
the necessary just decision to protect the Palestinians,
including their inalienable rights, and to act
accordingly on the Israeli occupying Power.
My delegation associates itself with the
statements made by the representatives of Azerbaijan
on behalf of the Organization of the Islamic
Conference and Cuba on behalf of the Non-Aligned
Movement.
There is no denying that the Palestinian question,
including the Palestine-Israel conflict, remains the
most important issue in the Middle East. Not only does
it remain the single most important reason for and
catalyst for conflict, strife and terrorism in that region;
it is also becoming the justification for the violence
related to international terrorism that we continue to
see throughout the world. We strongly believe that a
solution to that problem would be a major step for the
international community in our shared desire for
international peace and security.
Sadly, while we all share that concern and hope
for a peaceful world, we failed miserably for years on
end to find durable and lasting peace in the region. The
situation in the Middle East continues to remain
volatile. The lack of political commitment and will,
particularly on the part of the major players, is telling
and well manifested through the incapability of the
Security Council to come up with relevant resolutions.
In the meantime, Israel continues with its belligerent
acts against the Palestinians, disregarding international
law, conventions and United Nations resolutions and
ignoring calls by the international community to stop
its atrocities against the Palestinians. Israel continues
to use violence against the Palestinian civilian
population, destroy civilian infrastructure and strangle
the economic livelihood of Palestinians. Israel also
continues to build the illegal separation wall on
occupied Palestinian territory, despite the advisory
opinion of the International Court of Justice and
international condemnation. Illegal Israeli settlement
activities in the occupied Palestinian territory continue
to be supported and encouraged by the Israeli
Government, in total disregard of international laws
and norms and its obligations as the occupying Power.
Most recently, Israel came up with yet another
belligerent action that smacked of sheer arrogance and
insensitivity towards the feelings not only of the people
in the region but also of others around the world, in
particular those of Muslims. Israel's excavation work
around and beneath the holy Al-Aqsa mosque and its
wilful destruction of religious, cultural and heritage
sites in Al-Quds constitute direct aggression upon the
holy Al-Aqsa mosque. Malaysia condemns Israel for its
action in that regard. We denounce that blatant act of
provocation and the complete disregard shown for the
sanctity of the holy mosque. That act will ignite the
feelings of Muslims all over the world, and is in fact a
step backward in the efforts to achieve peace in the
region.
Those acts by Israel against religious, cultural
and heritage sites in the occupied territories are direct
violations of international law. Malaysia demands an
immediate stop to the excavation work being carried
out by Israel that has had direct impact on the Al-Aqsa
mosque. We urge the Security Council to demand that
Israel immediately seize those illegal activities. We call
upon the international community to intervene
immediately in order to stop those illegal actions by
Israelis.
Israel, as a Member of the United Nations, must
respect international laws, conventions and United
Nations resolutions, which gave birth to Israel itself.
Israel must be held responsible for all breaches
committed under the norms of international practice
and international law. It cannot continue to do
whatever it pleases with impunity and in total disregard
of the demands of the international community. Israel
must cease its practice of extrajudicial killings,
excessive use of force and other destructive practices,
such as destroying civilian infrastructure, homes and
means of economic livelihood. Such measures violate
its obligation as an occupying Power to protect the
civilian population.
The United Nations, and in particular the Security
Council, must act to ensure that Israel respects and
abides by its responsibilities as an occupying Power
and as a Member of the United Nations. Continued
Security Council inaction and paralysis in the face of
Israeli actions will be interpreted as promoting double
standards in terms of international practice.
Palestinian statehood remains the apex of the
aspirations of the Palestinian people. Israel and its
allies must understand that without resolving the
Palestinian question, lasting peace cannot not be
achieved in the region or beyond it. The Quartet peace
process must be put back on track. Israel must agree to
return to the peace process and to the implementation
of the Quartet Road Map. All parties must have the
resolve and political will to provide justice for the
Palestinian people. The agreement reached among
Palestinians in the holy city of Mecca to form a unity
government in Palestine is a positive development in
the process of comprehensive engagement among all
parties to find long-lasting peace in the Middle East.
We commend the Palestinians in that regard, as well as
Saudi Arabia for facilitating the agreement.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of the Islamic Republic of Iran.
Mr. Danesh-Yazdi (Islamic Republic of Iran): I
wish to begin by congratulating you, Sir, on your
assumption of the presidency of the Council this
month, as well as by thanking you for having convened
this open debate to discuss the situation in the Middle
East, especially the most recent expansionist policies
and practices of the Israeli regime in Al-Quds
Al-Sharif. Nor should I fail to express our appreciation
to the Russian Federation for its able and effective
presidency of the Council in the month of January. Our
thanks also go to Mr. De Soto for his comprehensive
briefing today.
We would like to express our delight and
satisfaction over the recent agreement reached between
our Palestinian brothers to form a national unity
government. We congratulate them on that important
achievement. That is a welcome step towards
strengthening and enhancing solidarity among
Palestinians at this crucial juncture.
My delegation would also like to join other
speakers in strongly condemning today's heinous
terrorist acts in Lebanon. We express our condolences
to the families of the victims and to the people and the
Government of Lebanon.
The recent atrocious acts by the Israeli regime
and its insolent expansionist policy vis-a-vis the holy
Al-Aqsa mosque have once again heightened the
concerns of the international community over Israel's
unlawful activities, and has consequently exacerbated
the already dire situation in the volatile Middle East
region. Israel's recent heinous action against the
blessed Al-Aqsa mosque and the holy city of Al-Quds
Al-Sharif, and its demolition of a historic road
connecting Bab Al-Maghriba with the holy Al-Aqsa
mosque compound, as well as two rooms adjacent to
the Al-Buraq wall, have yet again put on display the
aggressive and racist nature of that regime.
Moreover, Israel's continued excavation work
beneath the holy Al-Aqsa mosque compound is indeed
a provocative and insulting measure that undermines
the sanctity and foundations of the holy Al-Aqsa
mosque compound and threatens it with collapse. We,
along with the other members of the international
community, strongly condemn that shocking act.
Equally provocative and condemnable is Israel's
continued policy of denying Palestinian worshippers
access to their religious sites, and its intention to
construct a tourist site below the holy Al-Aqsa
compound.
As pointed out by the representatives of Cuba and
Azerbaijan, speaking on behalf of the Non-Aligned
Movement and the Organization of the Islamic
Conference, respectively, since 1968 the Security
Council has adopted no fewer than 16 resolutions that
have repeatedly declared the measures and
arrangements taken by Israel aimed at changing the
legal status, demographic composition and character of
the city of Al-Quds Al-Sharif null and void and Without
any legal validity. Nevertheless, the Israeli regime's
defiance of all those calls by the Council and the
international community has continued unabated.
Indeed, this latest illegal Israeli act is a nefarious
attempt to colonize and Judaize Al-Quds Al-Sharif.
Undoubtedly, such deplorable policies and
practices are in line with other Israeli war crimes and
atrocities, such as extrajudicial killings, targeted
assassinations, the wanton destruction of homes,
infrastructure and agricultural lands, the detention and
imprisonment of thousands of Palestinians, the
construction of the expansionist wall and the
imposition of collective punishment on the entire
Palestinian population. There is an absolute need for
the international community to decidedly weigh in and
to prevent Israel from carrying out its dangerous
designs against Palestinians and against the holy
Al-Aqsa mosque compound, which will further
jeopardize peace and security in the whole region. The
Council has an immense responsibility to shoulder in
fulfilling its Charter-based mandate by preventing
Israel from continuing to flout the will of the
international community incorporated in numerous
United Nations resolutions.
It is unfortunate that a single delegation,
exploiting its permanent presence on the Council and
its privilege of the veto, has always prevented the
Council from pronouncing itself, let alone taking any
meaningful action, on numerous Israeli crimes in
Palestine and elsewhere in the region. We hope that all
members of the Council recognize the need to take
decisive action in the face of the new Israeli crimes in
the region, and that they will not choose to allow a
further erosion of the Council's authority as a result of
a failure to address the grave situation created in the
wake of recent Israeli expansionist policies and
actions. There should be no doubt that those who
impede justice and accountability for Israeli war crimes
by repeatedly abusing the power of the veto bear
responsibility for the bloodshed that we witness in the
occupied Palestinian territories time and again.
Throughout the period under review, and while
the Israeli war machine has been relentlessly at work to
shatter the lives and livelihoods of Palestinians, the
Israeli regime has persisted with its aggressive policy
towards Lebanon, as well as towards others in the
region. It has continued to occupy the Syrian Golan
Heights and parts of Lebanese territory. That regime is
adamantly violating Security Council resolution 1701
(2006), including by violating Lebanese airspace.
Israel's violation of Lebanese territory in the area of
Maroun Al-Ras last week was a flagrant breach of
resolution 1701 (2006) and a showcase example of
Israeli contempt for the Council and its decisions.
The tragedy of Palestine, as a major source of
anger and frustration that is felt throughout the Islamic
world, lies at the heart of the Middle East conflict. The
criminal Israeli acts against the Palestinians and other
peoples in the region constitute the gravest threat
currently posed to regional and international peace and
security. It is evident that durable peace in Palestine
and throughout the Middle East will be possible only
with justice, an end to discrimination, an end to the
occupation of Palestinian, Syrian and Lebanese
territory, the return of all Palestinian refugees and a
democratic mechanism through which all the
inhabitants of Palestine, as well as Palestinians driven
from their homeland, will have the opportunity to
determine their future in a democratic and peaceful fashion.
If history is any guide, peace in the Middle East cannot be
achieved through State terrorism, occupation, intimidation
and aggression.
Before concluding, I would like to place it on
record that my delegation rejects the baseless
allegations raised against my country in the Council
today by the representatives of Israel and the United
States. This is yet another tired practice of the Israeli
regime and its advocate, intended to divert the
attention of the international community from Israeli
crimes in Palestine and elsewhere in the region, by
raising unfounded allegations against others.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Norway.
Mrs. Juul (Norway): Norway welcomes the
agreement reached in Mecca on the formation of a
Palestinian unity government. We commend President
Abbas for his tireless efforts to establish a broad
national unity government on a political platform that
reflects the Quartet principles of non-violence,
recognition of Israel and acceptance of previous
agreements and obligations.
Norway would also like to acknowledge the
particularly important role that Saudi Arabia -
together with Egypt, Jordan, Syria and the League of
Arab States - have played in making this possible.
This shows that concerned countries are taking
responsibility for dealing with the major political
challenges in their own region.
The Mecca agreement is an important step
forward. The formation of a unity government will give
President Abbas a broad basis for conducting
negotiations with Israel. It is essential that the
international community continue to build on what has
been achieved. We firmly believe that this positive
development needs international encouragement.
Norway welcomes the recent statements by the
Quartet, in which it promises to remain closely
engaged in the renewed political dialogue between
Israeli and Palestinian leaders, and to monitor
developments and actions taken by the parties.
Norway would also like to express its full support
for the upcoming tripartite meeting between President
Abbas, Prime Minister Olmert and Secretary of State
Rice. We hope that it will encourage the resumption of
a peace process leading to a two-State solution, with
Israel and Palestine living side by side in peace, within
secure and recognized borders.
To underpin the political process, the two parties
should make every effort to build confidence. Norway
urges the parties to implement fully what was agreed
upon at the 23 December meeting between the Israeli
and Palestinian leaders and to meet their obligations
under the Agreement on Movement and Access, the
Sharm el-Sheikh understanding of 2005 and the Road
Map.
The Mecca agreement should also be an
important step towards ending internal violence among
the Palestinians and creating stability in the Palestinian
territory. We expect the new government to reinstate
the rule of law in Gaza and to act decisively against
terrorism and rocket attacks on Israel.
Norway also urges the immediate release of the
captured Israeli soldier and the detained members of
the Palestinian Legislative Council.
Norway has for many years actively promoted a
two-State solution by supporting Palestinian
institution-building. This is crucial in building a viable,
democratic and independent Palestinian State that can
live in peace with Israel.
We welcome the Mecca agreement. It is now our
hope that the agreement can make it possible to
normalize relations between a Palestinian unity
government and the international community.
Let me also, on behalf of my Government,
condemn today's terrorist attack in Lebanon and extend
our condolences to the Government and the people of
Lebanon.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela.
Mr. Arias Cz'trdenas (Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela) (spoke in Spanish): The delegation of the
Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela congratulates the
delegation of the Slovak Republic on its assumption of
the presidency of the Security Council for the month of
February and on having convened this important debate
on the situation in the Middle East, including the
Palestinian question. Our congratulations go also to the
delegation of the Russian Federation on the excellent
manner in which it presided over the work of the
Council in January 2007. We thank Mr. Alvaro de Soto,
Special Coordinator for the Middle East Peace Process
and Personal Representative of the Secretary-General,
for his briefing this morning.
My delegation aligns itself with the statement
made by the representative of Cuba on behalf of the
Non-Aligned Movement.
We are convinced that the maintenance of
international peace and security is founded on the
premise that relations between States - regardless of
their ideological, cultural or political differences -
should be guided by strict commitment to the purposes
and principles of the Charter of the United Nations and
by respect for international law, including the principle
of peaceful coexistence between States. Our country
has historically worked to promote a permanent
solution to the Palestinian question in order to achieve
stable and lasting peace in the Middle East. In that
context, we have supported all agreements between the
parties in the search for a peaceful negotiated solution.
Hence, we consider it indispensable that the
fundamental rights of the Palestinian people be fully
realized.
The Government of Israel has continued to move
civilians into settlements that had previously been
vacated, in clear violation of the Road Map. This has
led to a 6-per-cent increase in the number of Israeli
settlers in the West Bank, as Mr. Ibrahim Gambari,
Under-Secretary-General for Political Affairs, told the
Council on 25 January (see S/PV.5624).
Peace in the region will be achieved only with
full implementation of the relevant resolutions of the
Security Council, the Arab Peace Initiative, the
principle of land for peace and the Road Map. My
Government considers it crucial to establish an
independent Palestinian State that will respond to the
Palestinian people's aspirations to freedom,
independence and security.
The Government of the Bolivarian Republic of
Venezuela reaffirms its firm support for the legitimate
and democratically elected Government in Beirut and
for the territorial integrity, unity and political
independence of Lebanon. It fully supports the
reconstruction of Lebanon and reaffirms its
condemnation of actions taken against that country.
Here, we consider that complete implementation of
resolution 1701 (2006) is essential.
The abuse of the veto by the United States with
respect to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has served as
a cloak for major human rights violations which have
been vigorously condemned by the United Nations, and
in particular by the Human Rights Council. The
violence in Iraq clearly shows the consequences of
unilateral action taken in violation of international law,
such as the United States invasion of Iraq.
The situation in the Middle East region
constitutes one of the greatest moral debts owed by the
international community, and especially by the United
Nations and the Security Council. The Organization
was born with a mandate to maintain international
peace and security and to ensure compliance with the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the norms
of coexistence and unwavering respect for international
law. The international community expects the Security
Council and the Organization as a whole to act with
that historical perspective.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Argentina.
Mr. Mayoral (Argentina) (spoke in Spanish):
First of all, Mr. President, we would like to thank you
and your delegation for organizing this open debate
and to congratulate you on the way in which you are
leading the Security Council's debates during the
month of February. We would also like to welcome
Mr. Alvaro de Soto, Special Coordinator for the Middle
East Peace Process and Personal Representative of the
Secretary-General to the Palestine Liberation
Organization and the Palestinian Authority.
As we all know, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is
at the core of the Middle East peace process today.
That is why, now more than ever before, we must
attach priority to this subject before it is too late. Over
the past few years, the Quartet, through the Road Map
has been leading this process, defining what the final
objective of the peace process should be and what road
the parties should take to reach it. In spite of the efforts
made since 2002, the objective of two States living
side by side in peace and security continues to be as
elusive as before.
The process has stalled in its first phase. We
believe that if the Quartet does not involve itself more
actively in the evaluation and the implementation of
the revised Road Map and does not play a more
proactive role in the peace process, it will become a
dispensable mechanism, and the United Nations will
have failed once more in the Middle East peace
process.
However, we would like to stress that the parties
directly involved bear the main responsibility for the
stalemate in the peace process. They cannot blame the
United Nations. It is the responsibility of the
Palestinian Authority to maintain peace and order in
Gaza, to prevent rocket attacks against Israel,
immediately free the Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit,
reform their institutions, eradicate corruption and
combat extremism.
Although we support the recent agreement
between President Mahmoud Abbas and Hamas leader
Khaled Mashal to create a unity government - and we
wish them success in its administration - we believe
that their authorities must recognize the right of Israel
to exist, accept previous agreements signed by the
Palestinian Authority and renounce violence.
As for the Israelis, the practices of expansion of
settlements, the construction of the separation wall on
the West Bank, the policy of closures and restriction of
movement, extrajudicial assassinations, excessive use
of force and arbitrary arrest of Palestinian officials and
legislators do not contribute to generating hope in the
Palestinian population for the future. As a consequence
of such practices, the humanitarian crisis in Gaza has
deepened, worsening the precarious living conditions
of the Palestinian population.
Argentina would like to reiterate that the only
path is that of peace negotiations on the basis of
Security Council resolutions, the Madrid terms of
reference and the principle of land for peace. The
international community, and especially the Quartet
and the Security Council, must assume a more active
role in helping the parties resume negotiations and put
an end to the vicious circle of death and retaliation that
has beset the Middle East. In this regard, we welcome
the next conference, planned for later in February.
With regard to Lebanon, we would like first of all
to condemn today's attacks north of Beirut and to
express our condolences to the families of the victims.
With regard to the implementation of resolution
1701 (2006), we cannot but express our concern at the
recent violence along the Blue Line between Lebanon
and Israel. Both the detonation of explosives along the
Blue Line by the Israel Defense Force at the beginning
of February - explosives suspected to have been
recently placed there by Hizbollah - and the exchange
of fire between the Lebanese Armed Forces and the
Israel Defense Force on 8 February in the vicinity of
Maroun al-Ras demonstrate the fragility of peace in
that country. We repeat that the arms embargo
established in resolution 1701 (2006) must be
respected not only by the parties but also by all States,
be they neighbours or not. We also consider it essential
that the two Israeli soldiers captured by Hizbollah in
July 2006 be freed.
Finally, we believe that another fundamental
ingredient in the search for peace is the end of the
Israeli occupation of the Golan Heights and the return
of that territory to Syria in accordance with resolutions
242 (1967) and 338 (1973), as well as through Syria's
adoption of policies that demonstrate its commitment
to peace and stability in the region.
Although this debate has historically focused on
trying to give momentum to the peace process between
Palestinians, Lebanese, Syrians and Israelis, the
gloomy prospects for the Middle East as a whole as
well as for neighbouring and nearby countries such as
Iraq and Iran mean that the Arab-Israeli conflict now
has an additional dimension that facilitates,
unfortunately, international terrorist activity, for
example that of Al-Qaida, and endangers peace in all
countries of the region.
We believe that all these conflicts are interrelated
and reinforce each other. That is why we call for
greater Security Council activity and courage on the
part of all parties involved to sit down at the
negotiating table, bearing in mind that only a just peace
that reflects all the interests of all the parties will be
sustainable in the future. That should be objective of
the Security Council and of our Organization.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Morocco.
Mr. Chabar (Morocco) (spoke in Arabic): Allow
me at the outset, Sir, to extend to you and your friendly
country, Slovakia, our sincere congratulations on your
assumption of the presidency of the Security Council
for this month. We wish you every success in your
work. Nor must I fail to pay tribute to your
predecessor, the representative of the Russian
Federation, for the wisdom with which he conducted
the work of the Council last month.
Permit me also to extend our thanks to Mr. Alvaro
de Soto for his briefing today. The briefing showed that
this meeting of the Security Council to discuss the
situation in the Middle East is taking place in very
delicate and sensitive conditions that raise both hope
and concern: hope in the wake of the Mecca agreement
between the Palestinian parties and the continuation of
international efforts to revitalize the peace process and
direct negotiations between the parties; and concern
because of the explosions in brotherly Lebanon this
morning, in addition to the continued tense situation in
the occupied Palestinian territories, particularly
Al-Quds Al-Sharif, which is due to the continuation by
the occupying Power of its policy of provocation and
daily humiliation of the Palestinians.
In this context, Morocco associates itself with
those that have condemned Israeli intransigence. In
that regard, we particularly support the statements
made on behalf of the Group of Arab States, the
Organization of the Islamic Conference and the Non-
Aligned Movement. Those statements clearly
expressed the Kingdom of Morocco's concerns with
regard to the situation in the occupied Palestinian
territories.
I will address only certain points, in view of the
fact that the Kingdom of Morocco, in the person of His
Majesty King Mohammed V1, is currently presiding
over the Al-Quds Committee of the Organization of the
Islamic Conference and given the gravity and the
consequences of the situation in Al-Quds Al-Sharif.
It is no secret that what the Israeli authorities in
occupied East Jerusalem are calling renovation work in
the vicinity of the Al-Aqsa mosque has led to the
collapse of the Al-Maghariba gate and two rooms
adjacent to the Al-Boraq wall, which are extremely
important religious and historic sites. Nothing can
justify such actions, which constitute further violations
and aggression against the sanctity of the Al-Aqsa
mosque and threaten it with collapse, and they provoke
Muslim sentiments. These actions contravene
international laws and norms and constitute a direct
violation of Security Council resolutions.
His Majesty King Mohammed VI, Chairman of
the Al-Quds Committee, immediately condemned the
work being carried out in the vicinity of the Al-Aqsa
mosque - work aimed at changing the demographic
character of the site, which is a symbol of Islamic
culture. He reiterated that Israel must abide by United
Nations resolutions concerning Jerusalem and
reaffirmed the legal imperative of preserving its
religious, cultural, geographic and demographic
character. The Chairman of the Al-Quds Committee
also called upon Israel to immediately halt these
activities and instead to focus on peace negotiations
and mutual respect.
These illegitimate Israeli practices, which pose a
grave threat to the region, should be addressed by the
Security Council, which bears primary responsibility
for the maintenance of international peace and security.
The Council should urge the Israeli Government to put
an immediate end to these violations and to comply
with all relevant international resolutions.
The Kingdom of Morocco believes that the time
has come for the Security Council to shoulder its
responsibilities, just as Palestinian and Arab efforts
have been made at Mecca to prevent the situation from
deteriorating further. My delegation believes that a just
and equitable peace must be based on the security and
stability of the region and that the path of peaceful
negotiations is the only basis for international
legitimacy. That path will free the Middle East from
the vicious circle of violence and counter-violence.
Accordingly, we believe that every effort should
be made to that end. All the parties must return to the
negotiating table as the only means of establishing a
just and comprehensive peace in the Middle East,
leading to Israeli withdrawal from all occupied Arab
and Palestinian territories and to the establishment of
an independent Palestinian State with East Jerusalem
as its capital. As ever, Morocco stands ready to
contribute to any effort to escape this vicious circle,
which would enable the peoples and the countries of
the region to live in peace and security.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Pakistan.
Mr. Amil (Pakistan): Allow me at the outset to
congratulate you, Sir, on your assumption of the
presidency of the Security Council for this month.
Permit me also to congratulate Ambassador Churkin of
the Russian Federation on a successful Council
presidency during the month of January.
We thank you, Mr. President, for convening this
meeting on this important issue at this crucial and
delicate time. Since the Council last convened a public
meeting on the situation in the Middle East, including
the Palestinian question, notable developments have
taken place in the region, which has long been used to
living in hope and despair, side by side.
While there was hope in the respite from violence
brought about by the ceasefire in Gaza, that proved to
be short-lived when, yet again, the region was thrown
into despair by Israeli actions in and around the Haram
Al-Sharif compound. We fully support the statements
made on behalf of the Non-Aligned Movement and the
Organization of the Islamic Conference.
Although media reports claim that the
controversial construction work near the Al-Aqsa
masjid is to be put off to allow public consultations,
preparatory excavations still continue, much to the
anguish of Muslims the world over. Those actions are
illegal, they play with the emotions of the Muslim
world and they threaten peace and security in the
region.
The Al-Aqsa masjid is the third-holiest place for
Muslims: the site of the ascension of the Prophet
Mohammed. We are distressed that the historic road
connecting the Bab al-Maghariba with the Al-Aqsa
compound has already been demolished, in addition to
two rooms adjacent to the Al-Buraq wall. The
excavation work undermines the foundations of
Al-Aqsa and could threaten it with collapse.
Since 1968, the Security Council has adopted 16
resolutions - in particular resolution 465 (1980) -
which have repeatedly declared that measures and
arrangements undertaken by Israel with the aim of
changing the legal status, demographic composition
and character of the holy city of Jerusalem - Al-Quds
Al-Sharif - are null and void and without any legal
validity whatsoever. These acts undermine the efforts
that the international community is undertaking to
resume the peace process. They also prejudice the
final-status negotiations by creating new realities on
the ground.
We call on the Security Council to fulfil its
responsibilities and to take urgent action to end the
Israeli violations against the Al-Aqsa masjid. We call
on Israel to respect the Council's resolutions and
international law, particularly international
humanitarian law. We strongly urge the Israeli side to
halt all work at the site and to take all precautions
necessary for the preservation of the holy places.
While these Israeli actions pose new obstacles to
peace, the Muslim world has been engaged in sincere
endeavours to promote peace in Palestine and
throughout the Middle East through the active
intercession of King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia. Fatah
and Hamas have reached an agreement in Mecca to
form a national unity government. The Security
Council and the Quartet should welcome that
development. A Palestinian unity government willing
to negotiate peace with Israel is a positive
development. It should lead to an end to the economic
boycott of the Palestinian Government. It should also
lead to concerted efforts to ensure the stability of the
Palestinian Authority and to enhance its capacity to
preserve peace and promote development.
The Israeli-Palestine issue is at the heart of the
multiple challenges confronting the Middle East. A
comprehensive, just and lasting solution based on
Security Council resolutions 242 (1967), 338 (1973),
1397 (2002) and 1515 (2003), the principle of land for
peace, the Arab Peace Initiative and the Quartet's Road
Map is urgently needed.
In the context of the increasing and multiple
threats to peace and security in the Middle East,
President Musharraf recently visited several Islamic
countries to consult their leaders on ways and means to
address and overcome the threats arising from the
Palestinian problem, the Israeli-Syrian difficulties over
the Golan and the phenomenon of violent resistance to
the injustices suffered by the Muslim world. A core
group of Muslim countries has been constituted to
develop a comprehensive approach to the multiple
crises besieging the Middle East, including by
providing fresh impetus to resolve the long-standing
Arab-Israeli conflict. The President of Pakistan has
explained that new initiative to the leaders of Egypt,
Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Iran, Malaysia, Indonesia
and the United Arab Emirates, and it has found general
support and understanding. We hope that a group of
leading Muslim countries will soon meet at a high level
to bring their collective weight to bear in favour of a
just and fair solution to the Palestinian question and
other problems afflicting the Middle East. The Security
Council should actively support those efforts.
The President: I now call on the representative
of Bangladesh.
Mr. Sorcar (Bangladesh): Let me begin by
thanking you, Mr. President, for the timely convening
of this meeting against the backdrop of the recent
developments in the Middle East. We fully align
ourselves with the statements made by the Chairs of
the Non-Aligned Movement, the Arab Group and the
Organization of the Islamic Conference.
We would like to reaffirm that the question of
Palestine lies at the heart of the Middle East crisis and
that the occupation must be recognized as central to the
issue of Palestine. Lasting peace cannot be achieved
unless the root causes are addressed. We reiterate our
full support for the legitimate cause of the Palestinian
people and for its inalienable right to a sovereign and
independent State, with East Jerusalem as its capital,
existing alongside Israel in peace and security.
We maintain that for a just and sustainable peace
to take root, Israel must meet all its obligations under
the Fourth Geneva Convention, relevant General
Assembly and Security Council resolutions and other
peace initiatives, including the Road Map.
We are pleased to note the recent conclusion in
Mecca of the agreement between Hamas and Fatah. We
hope that this will resolve the difficulty within the
Palestinian administration, create an enabling
environment for peace through the formation of a
national unity government and lead to the lifting of the
siege currently imposed on the Palestinian
Government. We also look forward to the upcoming
tripartite meeting to be held on 19 February, between
the United States Secretary of State, the Israeli Prime
Minister and the Palestinian President and to a positive
outcome, and we hope that this will revive the stalled
peace process.
The Al-Aqsa mosque in Jerusalem is one of the
holiest places for Muslims. It is the mosque towards
which all Muslims turned for daily prayer before they
turned to Mecca. Due to the extreme political
sensitivity of this area, very little archaeological
excavation has been done until now. We do not see any
reason why this should suddenly change. When there
are major political issues pending, it would be
imprudent to continue with this plan, as it is in no way
helpful to the peace process. Digging under the holy
site gives the feeling that the shrine above is under
threat. This is neither the time nor the place to look for
ancient artefacts.
The building of the bridge that is planned here is
widely suspected to have strategic intent. The
controversial construction and the excavation work
should immediately stop. The Security Council has a
responsibility to halt the ongoing work as it could
affect and further destabilize the already imperilled
peace effort.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Senegal.
Mr. Badji (Senegal) (spoke in French): First of
all, Sir, I should like to congratulate on you on your
assumption of the presidency of the Security Council
and to pay a well-deserved tribute to the Permanent
Representative of the Russian Federation for his
outstanding presidency last month. I should also like to
warmly thank Mr. Alvaro de Soto, Special Coordinator
for the Middle East Peace Process and Personal
Representative of the Secretary-General to the
Palestinian Liberation Organization and the Palestinian
Authority. This important debate on the situation in the
Middle East, including the Palestinian question,
enables us to keep constantly under careful review the
issue of stability in the Middle East, which is a crucial
item on the international peace and security agenda.
My delegation wishes to draw attention to recent
developments in the situation in occupied Palestinian
territory, which are cause for renewed concern
regarding the chances for a resumption of the Israeli-
Palestinian peace talks. It is a matter of regret that
every time we have some hope for the establishment of
conditions for peace in the region, various acts are
committed that once again undermine what has been
achieved as a result of long years of effort and
compromise, as well as the desire of the protagonists
on both sides to commit themselves resolutely to the
path of peaceful coexistence between the Palestinian
and Israeli peoples.
Indeed, the climate of relative calm which
recently reigned between Israelis and Palestinians has
just suffered yet another blow following a decision
taken by the Israeli authorities to begin on Tuesday,
6 February 2007, an archaeological dig at the foot of
the mosque compound in Jerusalem, in addition to the
construction work for a new bridge leading to the
Al-Maghariba gate. The implementation of this project
for a bridge by the Israeli occupation authorities is
paralleled by drastic measures restricting the freedoms
of Palestinians, especially the prohibition against entry
by anyone younger than 45 years of age into the area of
the Al-Aqsa mosque. This is a flagrant violation of the
right of this people to have access to its religious sites.
This Israeli initiative is likely to increase the
climate of tension and violence in the region and could
also revive the anger and bitterness of the Islamic
umma, which would have consequences for the overall
process for a settlement of the Israeli-Arab conflict.
This is especially true since the Al-Aqsa mosque
represents the third holiest place for Islam after Mecca
and Medina in Saudi Arabia. In this regard, Senegal
emphasizes the need to conserve the tri-faith nature of
the holy city of Jerusalem and calls upon Israel to
urgently halt its policy of the systematic destruction of
the symbols of Islam in that city.
In the same vein, my delegation is of the View
that none of the parties can gain from committing acts
which could have the effect of compromising peaceful
coexistence between the Arab and Jewish peoples and
the stability of the Middle East region as a whole.
My delegation welcomes the inter-Palestinian
agreements achieved in Mecca on 9 February 2007
between Fatah and Hamas on the formation of a
government of national unity in Palestine. These
agreements should bring about reconciliation among
Palestinian leaders with a view to resuming
negotiations with the Israeli authorities. With this in
View, we call upon the international community, and
more particularly the Quartet, to help in this process
with a view towards a rapid return to the negotiation
table and the implementation of the relevant peace
plans.
For its part, the United Nations, and more
specifically the Security Council, should continue to
urge all the parties to respect and strictly implement its
resolutions and international law. Senegal places a
great deal of hope in the activities of the new
Secretary-General, who, thanks to his qualities as a
seasoned diplomat, in which he resembles his
predecessor, could play a decisive role to that end.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Jordan.
Mr. Zoubi (Jordan) (spoke in Arabic): Allow me
at the outset, Sir, to congratulate you on your
assumption of the presidency of the Security Council
for this month. I wish also, through you, to express our
thanks to your predecessor, the Permanent
Representative of the Russian Federation, for his
leadership last month. I should also like to express our
appreciation to Mr. Alvaro de Soto, Personal
Representative of the Secretary-General, and to thank
him for his briefing to the Security Council this
morning.
My delegation would also like to align itself with
the statements made by the Permanent Representative
of Kuwait on behalf of the Group of Arab States and by
the Permanent Representative of Azerbaijan on behalf
of the Organization of the Islamic Conference in the
context of the Council's consideration of the item
entitled "The situation in the Middle East, including
the Palestinian question".
The question of Palestine remains the core of the
Arab-Israeli conflict. The situation in the Middle East
is directly affected by any progress or backward
movement on the question of Palestine. Jordan
welcomes the agreement reached in the holy city of
Mecca between Fatah and Hamas as an important step
towards the creation of a government of national unity.
It will bolster practical, serious efforts to reach a just,
peaceful and fair settlement in accordance with the
terms of reference of the peace process, the relevant
international resolutions, the Arab Peace Initiative and
the fundamental principles of the Road Map.
While the Palestinian parties were consulting and
reaching agreement in the holy city of Mecca, Israel
initiated excavation and demolition work on the
historic road leading to the Al-Bab Al-Maghriba,
abutting Al-Haram Al-Sharif. That represents a serious
escalation that jeopardizes Islamic holy sites in the city
of Al-Quds. It is unacceptable under any pretext and is
likely to trigger emotional responses and lead to grave
consequences.
The Hashemite leadership has given the utmost
attention to the issue of rebuilding and restoring
Islamic holy sites in Al-Quds al-Sharif. The Dome of
the Rock and the Al-Aqsa mosque were restored in
1952 and again following the fire at Al-Aqsa in early
1969.
Earlier this month, Jordan completed the
rebuilding of the Salahaddin shrine and has returned it
to the Al-Aqsa mosque, having thus repaired the
damage done to the shrine by the 1969 fire. The
Jordanian Government has strongly condemned Israel's
violations of the sanctity of the holy Al-Aqsa mosque,
beginning with excavation work and followed by the
use of force against worshippers in the compound.
The desecration of any holy site or symbol is of
the utmost seriousness, and the continued excavation
by Israel of Islamic holy sites can lead only to a further
escalation of violence, which certainly will not help
efforts to reactivate the peace process and return to
direct negotiations.
The Bab Al-Maghriba area, where Israel is
undertaking its excavations, is part and parcel of
Al-Haram al-Sharif, as it is one of the main entryways
to the site. It is an Islamic site and must not be
desecrated. Its maintenance and restoration are the
responsibility of the religious authorities, not of the
Israeli Government.
Furthermore, Al-Haram al-Sharif, including the
Bab Al-Maghriba area, is inside the city of Al-Quds -
Jerusalem - to which the relevant Security Council
resolutions apply. The Israeli Government knows full
well that Israel has no sovereignty over Al-Quds. No
Security Council resolution recognizes Israeli
sovereignty over Al-Quds. These latest Israeli practices
are a clear violation of those resolutions and represent
an attempt to change the legal status of the city of
Al-Quds, an occupied city to which the Fourth Geneva
Conventions of 1949 apply, just as they do to all
territory occupied by Israel since 1967, including the
city of Al-Quds.
All of those Israeli actions are a clear violation of
the legal opinion of the International Court of Justice
on the construction of the wall, which called for Israel
to refrain from any attempt to change the demographic
or geographic status of Al-Quds and the Palestinian
territory.
The Government of the Hashemite Kingdom of
Jordan calls on the Israeli Government immediately to
cease its illegal violations. We call on the Security
Council to move quickly and to make every effort and
use its good offices to put an end to illegal Israeli
practices such as excavation work and its attempts to
destroy Islamic sites in Al-Quds. We warn of the grave
consequences of this escalation, which strikes at the
heart of all the efforts made by the international
community, including the Quartet, to achieve a just,
comprehensive and lasting peace in the Middle East.
Reactions to Israel's excavation and demolition
work were not limited to the Arab world or the Islamic
world. Indeed, the parties that ordered such work have
now realized the widespread condemnation to which it
has led, even inside Israel, and perhaps they now
realize how unwise their decision was.
The President: The next speaker inscribed on my
list is the Chairman of the Committee on the Exercise
of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People, to
whom I give the floor.
Mr. Badji (Senegal) (spoke in French):
Mr. President, may I at the outset congratulate you on
your assumption of the presidency of the Security
Council for the month of February. I am certain that,
under your enlightened guidance, the work of the
Council will be carried out in a constructive spirit and
with all due efficiency. I should like also to avail
myself of this opportunity to commend your
predecessor, the Ambassador and Permanent
Representative of the Russian Federation, for the
exemplary manner in which he led the work of the
Council during the month of January.
I am grateful to you, Sir, as well as to the other
members of the Council, for having given me the
opportunity to participate, in my capacity as Chairman
of the Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable
Rights of the Palestinian People, in this important
debate on the situation in the Middle East, including
the Palestinian question.
We are gathered here today in the Council to
provide a response to the disturbing events that
continue to take place in the occupied Palestinian
territories, including East Jerusalem. The Committee
remains extremely concerned at the situation in the
territory, which is a dangerous one in terms of security
and disastrous in humanitarian terms. That situation is
the direct result of the Israeli occupation. The stringent
restrictions imposed on freedom of movement within
the territory, as well as border closings, seriously
hinder the delivery of humanitarian assistance as well
as economic recovery and development. Frustration is
increasing, which in turn fuels extremism.
At this sensitive juncture, it is truly extraordinary
that the Israeli Government should have authorized
excavation and repair work on a site that includes the
Al-Aqsa mosque. As the Council is aware, there is
great tension between the peoples who live in
Jerusalem because of what the city represents to
various religions. The excavation work done several
years ago in the area of the Al-Aqsa mosque had
already violated the sanctity of the third holiest site in
Islam and given rise to indignation throughout the
Muslim world.
The Security Council has consistently reaffirmed
the fact that the Fourth Geneva Convention of 1949
applies to all territories occupied by Israel since 1967,
including East Jerusalem, and has repeatedly called on
Israel to comply with the provisions of that
Convention. It has stated in several resolutions that all
steps taken by Israel to modify the status of Jerusalem
are null and void, and it has asked Israel to rescind
such measures and to refrain from any actions that
might alter the status of Jerusalem. The excavation and
the work under way today not only undermine the
foundations of the mosque compound; they also alter
the character of the city, thereby triggering a dangerous
resurgence of tension in the Middle East that could
doom to failure any peace talks between Israel and the
Palestinians.
We are encouraged by the agreement recently
concluded in Mecca between the leaders of Fatah and
Hamas. We welcome that initiative and the assistance
given by the regional parties, especially the
Governments of Saudi Arabia, Egypt and Jordan. We
look forward to the formation of a new government of
national unity - one that is determined to shoulder its
responsibility for the maintenance of order and to put
an end to the violence in the territory under its
authority. That will mean putting an end to the firing of
rockets against Israel and to all other attacks targeting
innocent civilians. We hope that the formation of a
government of national unity will enable the
international community to lift the financial
restrictions, which are preventing well-disposed
Governments, organizations and individuals that wish
to release their financial aid.
The Committee welcomed the November
ceasefire in the Gaza Strip. The ceasefire must now be
extended to the West Bank, and it must be reinforced
by specific political measures to enable the parties to
engage in real political dialogue. The international
community should create a credible and effective third-
party monitoring mechanism in order to help to
maintain the truce.
We appeal to Israel, the occupying Power, to
immediately end its military operations and its use of
excessive force so that its actions comply with the
Fourth Geneva Convention. We appeal to both parties
to immediately put an end to all acts of violence, to
show the greatest restraint and to foster a return to
calm. The Committee believes that the Security
Council must live up to its responsibilities and help to
put an end to the violence and the dire poverty in the
occupied Palestinian territories.
For its part, the Committee will continue to work
with the legitimate representatives of the Palestinian
people, first and foremost the President of the
Palestinian Authority. The Committee hopes that a new
18
government of national unity will endeavour to restore
unity among Palestinians and that it will be able to take
the courageous steps necessary to improve their living
conditions.
The Committee furthermore believes that peace
can be achieved only through a negotiated settlement
to the conflict - one that would lead to the birth of
viable Palestinian State on the basis of the pre-l967
borders. The resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian
conflict will be based on the Madrid terms of
reference, the principle of land for peace, resolutions
242 (1967), 338 (1973), 1397 (2002) and 1515 (2003)
and the Arab Peace Initiative, including the acceptance
of Israel as a neighbour, living in peace and security
within the framework of a comprehensive settlement.
The President: I thank Mr. Badji for his
statement.
There are no further speakers inscribed on my
list. The Security Council has thus concluded the
present stage of its consideration of the item on its
agenda.
In accordance with the understanding reached in
prior consultations, I invite Council members to
consultations following the adjournment of this
meeting.
The meeting rose at 4.45 p.m.
07-23762
▶ Cite this page
UN Project. “S/PV.5629Resumption1.” UN Project, https://un-project.org/meeting/S-PV-5629Resumption1/. Accessed .