S/PV.5834Resumption1 Security Council
▶ This meeting at a glance
78
Speeches
0
Countries
0
Resolutions
Topics
Conflict-related sexual violence
Peacekeeping support and operations
Women, peace, and security
Security Council deliberations
Syrian conflict and attacks
Counterterrorism and crime
Thematic
The President (spoke in Spanish): I should like
to inform the Council that I have received a letter from
the representative of Rwanda, in which he requests to
be invited to participate in the consideration of the item
on the Council's agenda. In conformity with the usual
practice, I propose, with the consent of the Council, to
invite that representative to participate in the
consideration of the item, without the right to vote, in
accordance with the relevant provisions of the Charter
and rule 37 of the Council's provisional rules of
procedure.
There being no objection, it is so decided.
At the invitation of the President,
Mr. Nsengimana (Rwanda), took the seat reserved
for him at the side ofthe Council Chamber
The President (spoke in Spanish): I should like
to remind all speakers, as I indicated during this
morning's meeting, to limit their statements to no more
than five minutes, in order to enable the Council to
carry out its work expeditiously. Delegations with
lengthy statements are kindly requested to circulate the
texts in writing and to deliver a condensed version
when speaking in the Chamber.
The next speaker inscribed on my list is the
representative of Kazakhstan, on whom I now call.
Mrs. Aitimova (Kazakhstan): At the outset, I
would like to express our gratitude to you,
Mr. President, for convening this important debate on
the agenda item entitled "Children and armed conflict".
Today's consideration of this issue is not especially
new, but it confirms the readiness of all Member States
to continue work in that direction in accordance with
resolution 1612 (2005) and the Secretary-General's
report (S/2007/757).
We would also like to commend Ms. Radhika
Coomaraswamy, Special Representative of the
Secretary-General for Children and Armed Conflict,
and her Office, as well as UNICEF, for their efforts to
overcome this modern challenge to humankind. Our
delegation fully shares the view that the protection of
children in armed conflict should be considered as a
significant aspect of the strategy to prevent and resolve
armed conflict.
The report of the Secretary-General highlights the
progress made in the implementation of resolution
2
1612 (2005) and its monitoring and reporting
mechanism, including compliance with regard to
ending the recruitment and use of children by armed
groups in a number of countries. In that context, it
seems encouraging to note that since the last report the
number of child soldiers has decreased from 300,000 to
250,000. However, as duly mentioned in the Secretary-
General's report, much work remains to be done by the
international community. In particular, the recruitment
and use of children in armed conflicts is still
continuing in 13 countries. Children are forced to take
part in combat operations and in killing people. Often,
they are themselves also sexually abused, kidnapped or
killed.
It is appalling to realize that for decades in
conflict zones children have been involved in
confrontations between different militant groups,
lacking access to all the elements of normal life that
most children around the world enjoy. Whole
generations of such children have faced nothing but
violence, hostility, abuse, poverty and illiteracy.
In order to put an end to the suffering and the
abuse of children, we have to focus our attention on
minimizing the negative consequences of being a child
in a zone of conflict, including by countering the six
grave violations identified by the Security Council. We
believe that the crucial task for all Member States
should be to take effective measures to bring to
account those who perpetrate grave violations against
children. To achieve those goals, there is a real legal
basis for further action in the form of criminal
prosecution and punishment. An effective mechanism
should be established to ensure compliance with the
main provisions of the conventions and protocols
pertaining to the child.
I would like to emphasize that Kazakhstan
ratified the relevant Optional Protocol to the
Convention on the Rights of the Child five years ago.
In doing so, we reaffirmed our strong commitment to
international efforts to protect the rights of children
affected by armed conflict worldwide.
We entirely support the proposal to adopt targeted
measures against groups and persons who involve
children in armed conflicts. We also support the
Security Council's referral of such cases to the
International Criminal Court for investigation and
prosecution. In that connection, we believe that further
toughening punishment measures and increasing
08-23756
awareness about particular cases at the local, regional
and global levels would have a significant effect.
Due to the vulnerability of children and the
possibility that they will be re-recruited in the
aftermath of conflicts, more support is also needed as
regards the reintegration and rehabilitation of children
who have been associated with armed groups and
involved in war zones.
We also believe that a great deal must be done to
avoid setting the precedent of prosecuting children for
crimes committed as soldiers, as they must be
considered to be victims of the actions of adults and
must be provided with social protection in the
framework of juvenile justice.
The future of our children who are involved in
armed conflicts against their will cannot be ignored; it
mostly depends on how we react and address these
challenges today. The issue of protecting children in
armed conflicts should be one of the main priorities on
the agenda of the Security Council, and we are
confident that the current discussions will greatly
contribute to that process. Let us truly move from
words to effective actions.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Australia.
Mr. Hill (Australia): I thank you, Mr. President,
for the opportunity to participate in this debate.
Australia places the highest priority on protecting
children, and we remain extremely concerned about the
plight of those affected by armed conflicts.
We welcome the significant steps that have been
taken to address this issue and commend the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for Children
and Armed Conflict for her leadership and her
dedication to the issue at hand.
The United Nations system must continue to draw
upon its full range of expertise and coordinate its
efforts to address the issue of children and armed
conflict. We recognize the important role of UNICEF
in child protection. We also commend Mr. Paulo Sergio
Pinheiro, independent expert for the Secretary-
General's study on violence against children, for his
work on that crucial child protection issue.
We are particularly pleased that significant
progress has been made to operationalize the
monitoring and reporting mechanism mandated in
08-23756
resolution 1612 (2005) on children and armed conflict
and that the Security Council Working Group on
Children and Armed Conflict has continued its
consideration of country reports in this regard.
We commend the real progress made in Cote
d'Ivoire in halting the recruitment of child soldiers and
in making progress on the Ouagadougou Agreement.
However, we need to maintain attention and seek
further progress in all situations of children affected by
armed conflicts, including those in Sudan, the
Democratic Republic of the Congo and Somalia.
Children in situations of armed conflict,
including those displaced by conflict, are vulnerable
not only to recruitment as child soldiers, but also to
other grave violations, including killing and maiming,
rape and other grave sexual violence, abductions,
attacks on schools and hospitals and the denial of
humanitarian access. All those violations are egregious,
and no hierarchy can be ascribed to the abuses suffered
by children in times of conflict. We would, however,
encourage the triggering of the monitoring and
reporting mechanism when any of those violations
occur, especially for situations of rape and other acts of
sexual violence.
We encourage the Council to continue to call on
parties listed in the annexes of the reports of the
Secretary-General to prepare time-bound action plans
to stop the recruitment of children into armed forces
and other violations against children. Many of those
who commit violations against children in situations of
armed conflict do so persistently, and have been cited
repeatedly in the reports of the Secretary-General. We
therefore encourage the Council to continue to consider
targeted measures that may be taken against those
persistent violators of children's rights.
The efforts of all key stakeholders remain
essential in combating violations against children in
times of conflict and ensuring adherence to relevant
international law. In addition to ensuring that measures
are taken at the international, regional and national
levels to combat such crimes, Governments must also
ensure that the perpetrators of those crimes are brought
to justice. We echo the Secretary-General in
highlighting the important role of the International
Criminal Court in investigating and prosecuting
violations against children in armed conflict that fall
within its jurisdiction.
3
We encourage those Member States that have not
done so to ratify the Optional Protocol to the
Convention on the Rights of the Child on the
Involvement of Children in Armed Conflict and the
Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court
without delay.
If we, as an international community, are to
create an environment in which children not only
survive, but thrive - a goal of a world fit for children,
which was reaffirmed at the Commemorative High-
Level Plenary Meeting of the General Assembly in
December 2007 - then we must reaffirm our
commitment to protecting all children, particularly
those affected by armed conflict, from harm and
exploitation and to ensure that those who would abuse
them are brought to account. Australia remains firmly
dedicated to that end.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of the Netherlands.
Mr. Majoor (Netherlands): The Netherlands fully
aligns itself with the statement made by the
representative of Slovenia on behalf of the European
Union. I would like to thank the Security Council
presidency, Panama, for organizing this open debate on
the important subject of children and armed conflict.
With the integrity of our children, the integrity of
this Organization and everything it stands for is at
stake. In children we see our future, and in their
suffering during armed conflict we see the dark side of
mankind. To our shame, children continue to be the
primary victims of grave human rights violations in
dozens of conflicts around the world. The latest report
of the Secretary-General (S/2007/757) is a sad
testimony to that reality. The Netherlands strongly
supports the valuable work of the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for Children
and Armed Conflict, Ms. Coomaraswamy, and that of
the Security Council Working Group on Children and
Armed Conflict.
We need concerted efforts at all levels. That
requires political will. The Netherlands funds a number
of projects targeting children in armed conflicts. We
are supporting a multi-year UNICEF project in Uganda
that aims to provide vocational training in camps for
children caught up in the conflict. The Netherlands
contributes a total of €1.3 million to that project. We
are also a major bilateral donor of the World Bank
Multi-country Demobilization and Reintegration
Programme in the Great Lakes region, through which
many child soldiers have been demobilized and
reintegrated.
Abuse truly stops only when perpetrators have
been brought to justice. Anything short of that means a
continuation of the violation of the victims' integrity.
That is why ending impunity is a critical element in
ending violations and abuses against children. Member
States concerned should take effective action to bring
to justice individuals responsible for violations of
children's rights. Those who recruit or use child
soldiers; those who rape or commit other grave sexual
violence against children - they all should all be held
to account.
We therefore stress the role of the International
Criminal Court (ICC) and other tribunals in the
investigation and prosecution of such crimes that fall
within their jurisdiction. When national systems of
justice fail, either because of unwillingness or inability
to genuinely prosecute such violations against children
in armed conflict, the situation should be referred to
the ICC. The recent arrest by the ICC of Mathieu
Ngudjolo Chui, former commander of the Fronts des
Nationalistes et Integrationnistes of the Democratic
Republic of the Congo is a notable example. It shows
how the ICC and the Congolese national authorities
indeed cooperate in the fight against impunity for such
crimes.
Progress has been made. The issue of children
and armed conflict is higher on the agenda than it has
been in the past. We commend the progress achieved
by the Security Council, but there is a need for further
commitment and action. For example, the current scope
of the monitoring and reporting mechanism should be
reviewed. Child soldiers are the focus of much
international concern, and rightly so, but they
constitute a relatively small share of affected children.
The Security Council should give equal consideration
to all categories of grave violations against children in
armed conflict and should include in the annexes to the
Secretary-General's reports a comprehensive listing of
parties to armed conflict responsible for any of these
grave violations. An initial expansion of the trigger
mechanisms could include the crime of rape and other
grave sexual violence against children. There are
several reasons for this. Like the recruitment and use of
child soldiers, rape and other sexual violence are
intentional acts committed by individual perpetrators.
Parties to armed conflict can take action to hold such
perpetrators accountable for their actions. Progress in
ending such violations can be measured, allowing for
de-listing: an incentive for change. But more
important, we cannot remain silent in the face of such
hideous acts. What more reason do we need?
We may be encouraged by our efforts so far, but
we should remain outraged at the continuing violence
against children in armed conflict. There is no room for
complacency or even a business-as-usual approach. We
urge the Security Council to continue to address this
issue and to fill existing protection gaps. If the political
will to do so is to be found anywhere, it should be here
at the core of the United Nations, in the Security
Council.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of the Philippines.
Mr. Gatan (Philippines): My delegation
welcomes today's debate on the issue of children and
armed conflict and joins the rest of the international
community in seeking ways to prevent and eliminate
the exploitation and devastation of the lives of children
when they are involved in armed conflict.
My delegation also welcomes the Secretary-
General's report on children and armed conflict
(S/2007/757), which attempts to provide information
on various situations where children's lives are
adversely affected because of conflict and strife. We
condemn violations against the rights of children and
express our readiness to contribute to solutions that
will appropriately and effectively address the problem.
The Philippines would like to reiterate that it is
our Government's policy to consider children as zones
of peace, as stated in section 22, article X, of Republic
Act No. 7610, otherwise known as "An Act Providing
for Stronger Deterrence and Special Protection Against
Child Abuse, Exploitation and Discrimination", and
also intended to protect children against dangers
arising from armed conflict. For this reason, measures
have been adopted to protect children from harm and to
ensure their safety and well-being. Children rescued
from conflict are accorded special treatment by
Government forces.
A memorandum of agreement on the handling
and treatment of children involved in armed conflict
was signed in 2000 to further ensure that the rights of
children are protected, and, in 2001, the President
issued Executive Order No. 56, entitled "Adopting the
08-23756
Comprehensive Program Framework for Children
Involved in Armed Conflict". This directs national
Government agencies and local government units to
implement its provisions. Also, by virtue of that
executive order, an Inter-agency Committee on
Children in Armed Conflict was created; it is
functioning today as the key body that coordinates the
efforts of the Philippine Government in making sure
that children are not affected by or involved in armed
conflict and that, if they are so involved because of
their use by non-State actors, they are properly
rehabilitated and reintegrated into society.
The Inter-agency Committee has focused on three
areas, namely improved monitoring and reporting of
cases of children in armed conflict, improved
institutional coordination, and the effective
rehabilitation of children affected by armed conflict
and their reintegration into the community. Following
recent consultations among the relevant government
agencies and non-governmental partners during a
strategic planning exercise conducted in June 2007, the
Committee has been able to identify the current
challenges faced in addressing the issue of children in
armed conflict as well as the necessary next steps
towards resolving it.
The Philippines recognizes the need for enhanced
monitoring and reporting. It is envisioned that an
operational database monitoring system on children in
armed conflict, shared among the front-line agencies -
namely the Department of Social Welfare and
Development, the Human Rights Commission, the
Office of the Presidential Adviser for the Peace
Process, the Commission for Indigenous Peoples, the
Department of Education and the military - should be
made functional and should be primarily maintained by
the Department of Social Welfare and Development. In
support of the provisions of Security Council
resolution 1612 (2005), the Government is now
developing a procedure for data collection which will
include information pertaining to the six violations
against children enumerated in that resolution.
The Philippines recognizes that institutional
coordination among the front-line agencies, as well as
with the community when it encounters incidences of
children in armed conflict, is essential in order to
effectively address the issue of children in armed
conflict and to ensure that the rights of such children
are upheld. We are already implementing a
comprehensive communications plan on the protection
of children, designed for concerned sectors, namely the
Government, the private sector, civil society and even
non-State armed groups, and intended to draw support
and synchronize efforts to protect the children.
On the matter of rehabilitation and reintegration,
the Department of Social Welfare and Development
continues to provide victims with residential care
services and other social services such as financial
assistance, legal assistance, counselling, skills training,
values formation and spiritual enrichment, livelihood
services, home life services and educational services.
The Government is creating an even more
comprehensive and holistic rehabilitation and
reintegration programme in conflict areas with
provision for the constant monitoring and evaluation
that are necessary for perfecting the programme.
My delegation takes note of the specific reference
in the report of the Secretary-General to the Philippines
and acknowledges that there is indeed room for
improvement in the documentation of violations of
children's rights. This has already been recognized as a
concern, and efforts are under way to strengthen
coordination among the agencies that come into direct
contact with children in armed conflict.
My Government looks forward to the visit of the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict. It looks forward also to a
positive outcome of her visit. We will extend our full
cooperation to her so that her findings and
recommendations can contribute to the achievement of
the aim of the Philippine Government to address gaps,
if any, in providing protection on a nationwide scale to
children affected by armed conflict. It is also our
fervent wish that the visit will lead to a recognition that
my country's adequate policy measures could lead to
the early deletion of the Philippines from the list of
annex II countries.
The Philippines has been more than willing to
cooperate on the issue before us today. We would like
to call upon the Working Group of the Security Council
to be more transparent in its working methods. An open
work environment would surely lead to enhanced
cooperation and a speedier resolution of this issue,
which harms our world's most valuable asset - our
children.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Georgia.
Mr. Alasania (Georgia): At the outset,
Mr. President, allow me to express my appreciation to
the members of the Security Council for providing us
with the opportunity to address this high forum.
The delegation of Georgia fully associates itself
with the statement made by the Slovenian presidency
of the European Union.
Protection of children affected by armed conflicts
has been one of the main priorities of the United
Nations community. During the past decade, the
international community has tried to place the issue
firmly on its agenda. Since 1998, when the first Special
Representative for Children and Armed Conflict began
his work and the Security Council held its first meeting
on this issue, the matter has gained greater visibility.
Over the past several years, the Security Council
has made good efforts in order to assist children
affected by armed conflict and thereby to protect the
most vulnerable, particularly through the adoption of
resolution 1612 (2005), which provided the basis for
the establishment of the Working Group of the Security
Council on Children and Armed Conflict.
We welcome the latest report of the Secretary-
General on the issue of children and armed conflict
(S/2007/757), and we fully share his observation that,
despite some progress with respect to the protection of
children in several areas, new areas of concern require
immediate attention by the international community.
Georgia welcomes the Secretary-General's
recommendation that the mandates of all future
peacekeeping and relevant political missions should
include child protection advisers. Such a change will
increase the effectiveness of monitoring and provide
timely and accurate information with respect to the
protection of children affected by conflicts.
We agree with Council members who have
previously spoken that the Council must move forward
and start responding to the challenges upon us. We
firmly believe that every form or category of the grave
violations against children must be given equal
priority.
For 15 years, my country has been dealing with
the consequences of ethnic conflicts, which have
yielded tragic results. Besides causing a generation of
youth to lose their lives during the civil war, those
conflicts have produced a generation that was forced
by ethnic cleansing into exile. The Government of
Georgia is making its best efforts to support refugee
and internally displaced children, who have been
deprived of their most fundamental right to return to
their places of origin. Among other support, those
children need special care to cope with their post-war
psychological traumas. Although central authorities, in
cooperation with international donor organizations, are
able to provide special rehabilitation, education and
leisure programmes to some of these children, the vast
majority are still beyond the reach of such
programmes.
We would like to draw the Council's attention to
the intolerable situation of children living in the areas
of protracted conflicts within the territory of Georgia.
It is heartbreaking to see how children of all ethnic
origins are becoming victims of physical and
psychological violence on a daily basis. Lack of a
secure environment in these areas prevents children
from having a chance to become integrated members of
civil society.
Here, let me note in particular the situation of
Georgian-speaking children in Abkhazia, Georgia.
They are deprived of one of their most fundamental
rights, namely to study in their mother tongue, since
the de facto regime has prohibited Georgian as a
language of instruction in schools in the Gali district,
which is populated mostly by Georgians.
The Secretary-General's latest report on the
situation in Abkhazia, Georgia (S/2007/588) suggests
that the language of instruction in Gali district schools
remains a concern. It is highly unlikely that anyone
opposing education of children in their mother tongue
is thinking of reconciliation. The prohibition of
education in the Georgian language in breakaway
regions is intended to increasingly separate the
generations brought up apart. Unfortunately, all this is
a continuation of the policy of systematic cleansing of
Georgians from Abkhazia, Georgia. It is ironic that
oppression on the basis of language continues to take
place in 2008 - the year the United Nations declared
to be the International Year of Languages.
Another matter of concern to us is the problem of
mines left after past military operations. Just recently,
in one village in Abkhazia, Georgia a boy was killed by
an anti-personnel mine that he had found on the bank
of a river.
The international community must make better
efforts to assist those children who have been deprived
of normal life conditions. The need for action is
obvious because the impact of conflict and violence on
children will have consequences for the formation of
their values, identity and beliefs.
The circle of violence and hatred can only be
stopped through joint international efforts. In this
regard, the Government of Georgia has provided
channels for international organizations to be involved
in the most critical confidence-building measure -
bringing children from both sides of a war-torn society
together, helping them to restore their faith in peaceful
coexistence with each other.
Mr. President, I want to thank you again for
giving me this opportunity to address you today on this
matter that is very important for all of us.
The President (spoke in Spanish): The next
speaker is the representative of Chile, on whom I call.
Mr. Munoz (Chile) (spoke in Spanish): I would
like to thank Panama and you, Sir, for inviting us to
debate this topic that involves acts of utmost gravity
against unprotected children in flagrant violation of
human rights and international humanitarian law.
As a State party to the Convention on the Rights
of the Child and to its Optional Protocol on the
Involvement of Children in Armed Conflict and to
Convention No. 182 of the International Labour
Organization, on the prohibition of the worst forms of
child labour, Chile wishes to reiterate its commitment
to the initiatives designed to eliminate all forms of
violence against children. We therefore strongly
support multilateral actions to reduce and eradicate this
scourge, and we urge the Council to use its authority to
identify and punish those responsible for the atrocities
documented in the recent report of the Secretary-
General on children and armed conflict (S/2007/757)
and its respective recommendations.
In this context, we acknowledge the work done
by the Special Representative of the Secretary-General,
Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy, and note with special
interest the recommendations contained in her report
on the subject (A/62/228), particularly those relating to
the application of the 2007 Paris Principles, which
represent significant progress regarding prevention and
reinsertion and the special needs of the girl child in
armed conflicts.
Although the international community recognizes
that children are precious subjects of law, their rights
are contrarily ignored, daily, in situations of armed
conflict between or within States, conflicts of low
intensity or armed violence in the civilian sphere. We
therefore support the work done by, among others, the
Working Group of the Security Council established
pursuant to resolution 1612 (2005), as well as the work
of UNICEF and civil society, which contribute to the
implementation of the monitoring and reporting
mechanism in the framework of this resolution.
However, the persistence of these grave acts and
the impunity noted by this Council impel us to make
greater efforts with respect to the implementation of
this mechanism. Chile therefore believes that the
Council should enhance the protection of children by
allowing the expansion of the monitoring mechanism
contemplated in resolution 1612 (2005), so that it can
be triggered in cases of rape and other grave sexual
violations, which do not constitute collateral damage
and which should be urgently eradicated, as has been
widely recognized by the international community.
Likewise, we call for the adoption of the
recommendations made to the Council and to Member
States in the Secretary-General's recent report,
particularly the recommendation that the mandates of
all future peacekeeping missions and relevant political
missions should, where appropriate, include the
presence of child protection advisers.
A decade after the publication of Graca Machel's
historic report on the impact of armed conflict on
children, Chile reaffirms its commitment to contribute
actively to the elimination of all forms of violence
affecting the world's children, from armed conflicts to
urban violence. Inspired by the aphorism coined by our
Nobel Prize winner Gabriela Mistral, "The future of
children is always today; tomorrow will be too late",
we strongly support all initiatives aimed at fulfilling
international commitments in this area.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now call on
the representative of Brazil.
Mrs. Viotti (Brazil) (spoke in Spanish): It is a
pleasure for the delegation of Brazil to participate in
this very important debate under the Panamanian
presidency. The presence of the Vice-President and
Minister for Foreign Affairs at this morning's part of
our meeting reflects Panama's commitment to the
United Nations and also highlights the importance of
the issue of children for the countries of Latin America
and the Caribbean.
(spoke in English)
I wish to thank Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy for
her excellent work as Special Representative of the
Secretary-General for Children and Armed Conflict.
I would like to refer to the latest report of the
Secretary-General (S/2007/757), which presents a
comprehensive picture of the situation of children
affected by armed conflict around the world. The report
confirms that, although some progress has been made,
the situation of children in armed conflicts remains a
source of grave concern for the international
community.
Creating a world fit for children is tantamount to
guaranteeing the future of all humankind. In recent
years, United Nations efforts to focus international
attention on child-specific issues in the context of
armed conflicts have been expanding in order to
respond to the demand for action, given the seriousness
of the issue and the growing number of conflicts
affecting children in various parts of the world.
We expect the Security Council to perform its
work in close coordination with the General Assembly
and the Economic and Social Council. An effective
response to the issue of children affected by armed
conflict only stands to benefit from being placed
squarely within the context of the more general
problem of children in need.
Ending all forms of violations against the rights
of the child affected by armed conflict is our common
goal. It is unacceptable that armed conflicts continue to
subject children to all forms of violence, including not
only the recruitment and use of children, but also
killing and maiming, rape and other forms of sexual
violence, abductions, and attacks against schools and
hospitals. A strong commitment by Governments and
the full cooperation of all relevant United Nations
entities are essential elements in order to reverse that
situation.
The work of the United Nations on children and
armed conflict should be guided by the existing
international framework, in particular the Convention
on the Rights of the Child and all relevant resolutions
of the General Assembly and the Security Council. The
Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights of
the Child on the Involvement of Children in Armed
Conflict is of particular importance in guiding the work
of the United Nations.
My delegation agrees with the recommendation,
contained in the Secretary-General's report, that
Member States should take effective action to bring to
justice perpetrators of violence against children
through national justice systems. While we are
encouraged by efforts of Governments in that regard,
we also strongly support the strengthening of the
International Criminal Court and the full
implementation of its decisions in cases of violations
against children in armed conflict falling within its
jurisdiction.
Brazil is particularly concerned about the
continuation of gender-based violence affecting girls,
in particular sexual violence, which leaves a long-term,
devastating impact on children and their families.
Another aspect to be considered is the efforts to
reintegrate former child soldiers in countries emerging
from conflict and to protect such children in specific
situations in which they are vulnerable, such as
exposure to cluster munitions and landmines. My
delegation considers that the Peacebuilding
Commission has an important role to play in this area
and that it should include the discussion of concrete
measures for the disarmament, demobilization and
reintegration of children as part of its long-term
recovery and development programmes.
The complexity of the question of children
affected by armed conflict demands that all relevant
entities of the United Nations, in close cooperation
with Member States and non-governmental
organizations, adequately address its many
components, including the social and economic
components, particularly with regard to demobilization
and reintegration. Such broad and comprehensive
coordination is essential to maximize the effect of the
Council's actions in its efforts to make the best
possible use of the monitoring and reporting
mechanism established under resolution 1612 (2005).
In addition to the involvement of UNICEF and
other relevant agencies, funds and programmes, I
would like to mention the need to fully integrate into
this process the newly established post of Special
Representative of the Secretary-General on Violence
against Children. As mandated in General Assembly
resolution 62/141, the new Special Representative and
the Special Representative for Children and Armed
Conflict will cooperate and coordinate their activities,
taking into account the complementarity of their
respective mandates.
Brazil is fully committed to the promotion and
protection of the rights of the child in general and is
determined to contribute to maximizing the
effectiveness of the United Nations system in
responding to the issue of children affected by armed
conflict. If we are to secure a better world for future
generations, we cannot fail to protect the rights of
children affected by armed conflict. By doing so, we
will be helping to ensure that today's victim does not
become tomorrow's aggressor. We believe that the
United Nations plays an essential role in preventing
childhood from being victimized amid warfare and in
guaranteeing a future in which children can be bearers
of hope and confidence as they emerge from conflict
situations.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now call on
the representative of the Republic of Korea.
Mr. Kim Hyun Chong (Republic of Korea):
First, allow me to commend the work of the Security
Council and its Working Group on Children and Armed
Conflict to end violations against children and to
guarantee the exercise of their rights. My delegation
would also like to commend Secretary-General Ban
Ki-moon and his Special Representative, Ms. Radhika
Coomaraswamy, for their dedication in addressing the
plight of children in armed conflict.
The Republic of Korea appreciates the report of
the Secretary-General (S/2007/757) as well as the
presentation by Ms. Coomaraswamy on recent
developments. We appreciate the achievements
accomplished so far, yet continue to have grave
concerns about the challenges that we still face.
Achievements have been accomplished in areas such as
the establishment of the monitoring and reporting
mechanism in 11 countries since the adoption of
Security Council resolution 1612 (2005).
We are particularly pleased to note a number of
significant developments related to ending impunity
for crimes against children, particularly the recruitment
of children in armed conflicts. These include, inter alia,
the confirmation of charges by the International
Criminal Court against the leader of an armed group in
the Democratic Republic of the Congo and the arrest
warrants issued by the Court for senior members of the
Lord's Resistance Army.
Despite this progress, we remain greatly
concerned about the continuing plight of children
affected by armed conflict. Child recruitment is still an
issue of grave concern. As the Security Council
continues to call upon parties engaged in armed
conflict to take firm and timely action to stop the
enlistment of children, it must also address the lack of
security in camps for refugees and internally displaced
persons, which are known hotbeds for recruitment.
My delegation contends that dealing with
persistent violators is an urgent issue that must be
addressed. Through the Secretary-General's reports, 16
persistent perpetrators have been identified. What will
the Security Council do with these offenders? The
Security Council should take effective targeted
measures against such perpetrators, including a ban on
the export or supply of arms, a ban on military
assistance, travel restrictions, freezing of assets and a
restriction on the flow of financial resources.
Otherwise, they will continue to violate and undermine
the credibility of the Security Council.
The delegation of the Republic of Korea, like
those of many other Member States, is disturbed by the
deplorable situation of sexual violence and abuse
against children in armed conflict. As the Secretary-
General's report highlighted, children are targeted with
various forms of sexual and gender-based violence
during armed conflict, including rape. As many as
60 per cent of the victims of sexual violence in areas of
conflict are children. Furthermore, in some trouble
spots, sexual violence and rape have been deliberately
employed for political and military purposes. Unless
the Security Council and the international community
respond strongly to these violations, such disturbing
cases will continue.
In this context, we urge the Security Council to
consider widening the scope of the monitoring and
reporting mechanism. We agree with the
recommendation in the Secretary-General's report that
equal weight be given to all categories of grave
violations. These include not only the recruitment and
use of children but also the other five grave violations:
the killing and maiming of children, rape and sexual
violence, abductions, attacks against schools or
hospitals and the denial of humanitarian access to
children.
The Republic of Korea supports an incremental
approach, extending the mechanism to include sexual
violence as a trigger for listing a party in the annexes
to the reports of the Secretary-General and establishing
a monitoring and reporting mechanism in the country
concerned. We urge the Security Council to take this
issue seriously and to work on a draft resolution in that
direction.
Ending impunity is a critical element for halting
violations of all kinds. Impunity for parties engaged in
armed conflict, as well as for individual perpetrators,
should cease. In order for this to come about, the
Security Council should refer those accused of
systematic and persistent violations against children to
the International Criminal Court.
Lastly, the delegation of the Republic of Korea
would like to emphasize the need to strengthen the role
of major actors and the coordination among them. The
Special Representative should be given all the
necessary support, assistance and cooperation in
implementing her mandate. The role of the Council's
Working Group on Children and Armed Conflict
should be further bolstered to address measures such as
recommending targeted action to the Security Council
and monitoring its implementation.
The additional actors involved in addressing the
issue of children in armed conflict are the
peacekeeping operations and the political missions,
specifically their child protection advisers. My
delegation believes that their role is crucial not only for
the effective implementation of the monitoring and
reporting mechanism, but also for the effective
prevention of violations and for more comprehensive
protection of children. In this regard, the Security
Council and the Secretary-General should send a stern
message to the head of each mission to assume strong
leadership.
Overall, national Governments should, in the end,
take responsibility in protecting their children. In this
regard, technical and financial assistance should be
provided for capacity-building, and Governments
should fully cooperate with the Security Council in
preparing and implementing these actions, including
the establishment of a justice mechanism.
Coordination and coherence are another important
element. In order to effectively address the complex
issue of children in armed conflict, both ending
violations and the recovery and reintegration process
need full coordination by all relevant bodies, including
the Security Council, the Office of the Secretary-
General, the peacekeeping operations, political
missions, humanitarian agencies such as UNICEF and
the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner
for Refugees and various non-governmental
organizations (NGOs). At the field level, the
participation and contribution of NGOs are especially
critical. Therefore, more closely coordinated
involvement of NGOs in implementing the monitoring
and reporting mechanism is needed.
We hope that today's open discussion on children
in armed conflict will pave the way for meaningful
deliberation in the Security Council. We look forward
to a strong presidential statement which will lead to a
new resolution in the near future.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Uruguay.
Mr. Rosselli (Uruguay) (spoke in Spanish): My
delegation is pleased to address the Council today
under your presidency, the presidency of a very able
representative of our brother country, Panama. We also
welcome the presence here today of the Vice-President
and Minister for Foreign Affairs of Panama,
Mr. Samuel Lewis-Navarro. This demonstrates
Panama's commitment to the activities of the United
Nations and in particular, those of the Security
Council.
My delegation has high regard for the open
debates of the Security Council. We feel this is a way
for those of us who are not members to draw closer to
this very important central organ of the United Nations.
My delegation has stated previously that,
unfortunately, meetings of this kind often coincide with
very important activities requiring the presence my
colleagues, the Permanent Representatives of Council
members.
Looking around the Chamber now, see that,
except for the Permanent Representative of Indonesia
and you, Mr. President, there are no other Permanent
Representatives of Council members here. Nor are
there any Deputy Permanent Representatives. It is a
shame that the Security Council should hold such
meetings when members are so busy that they cannot
be here to hear their peers. I, too, have a number of
other activities on my agenda and so I will be asking
my colleague, Uruguay's expert on the Third
Committee, to present my country's statement. I bid
you good afternoon, Sir.
Mrs. Pi (Uruguay) (spoke in Spanish): The
delegation of Uruguay welcomes this open debate on
children in armed conflict and welcomes all the efforts
of the international community in this regard. My
delegation particularly appreciates the work of the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children in Armed Conflict, a mandate that Uruguay
fully supports.
We take this opportunity again to thank
Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy for her work and her
commitment to broad-based and effective protection of
children in a situation of particular vulnerability. Her
substantive reports, undertaken in the context of broad
consultation, not only allow us to appreciate the
achievements, but also clearly show how much work
remains to be done.
The figures cited in recent reports on the impact
of armed conflict are particularly worrisome, and no
region in the world is immune. We are stunned by the
number of children killed in war zones; injured or
suffer permanently disabling injuries; recruited as
soldiers, in blatant violation of international human
rights instruments and humanitarian law; and the
thousands of children, girls in particular, who are
subject to sexual exploitation. We are concerned by the
ongoing illegal recruitment of children in conflict
zones, many of whom are kidnapped from refugee
camps; by the various forms of sexual violence
suffered by children, with devastating and permanent
repercussions for the victims; by the cases of children
who are detained in contravention of international
norms; by systematic and deliberate attacks on
educational institutions; and by the impunity still
enjoyed by the perpetrators of crimes against children.
Uruguay welcomes the fact that the issue of
children affected by armed conflict is receiving
increasing attention on the international agenda, as
reflected in the many international instruments to
which my country is a party. Much remains to be done,
however. The subject is on the General Assembly's
agenda, and every year my country plays a very active
role in that regard with a view to strengthening and
increasing the involvement and responsibility of a body
of universal composition in a subject that falls within
its purview and is of concern to us all.
Uruguay nonetheless recognizes the role that has
been played by the Security Council, where progress
has moved from talk to implementation through the
adoption of numerous resolutions, the most recent of
which created the monitoring and reporting mechanism
with a view to ensuring that sound information is
available and concrete action taken to end the illegal
recruitment and exploitation of children in conflict
zones.
Some two years after the adoption of resolution
1612 (2005), establishing the monitoring and reporting
mechanism, it is now time to assess not only its
implementation, but also its format. We are thus
concerned that, despite the reports received identifying
six types of serious violations against children, the
mechanism is applicable only to the recruitment and
illegal use of child soldiers. We feel that that approach
should be broadened, since no violation is more serious
than another and all should be considered on an equal
footing.
We appreciate the inclusive and broad-based
nature of the mechanism, which works with the
involvement of all parties to a conflict -
Governments, non-governmental armed forces, the
United Nations system and civil society, including non-
governmental organizations. We believe that only
through joint and coordinated endeavours, the
strengthening of the rules of international law and the
utilization of available judicial mechanisms - the
International Criminal Court in particular - will it be
possible to develop and implement plans of action
allowing us to put an end to the serious violations that
children continue to endure in armed conflict.
We welcome the joint work done by civil society
with the United Nations system as a whole, including
the peacekeeping missions, in building lasting child
protection mechanisms. We believe that the work of the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict in peacekeeping
missions, as well as the inclusion by UNICEF of child
protection advisers in such missions - in which
Uruguay has been deeply involved - should be
stepped up and receive sufficient human, financial and
technical support.
My delegation feels that greater attention should
be paid to the rehabilitation of children linked to armed
groups or that have been the victims of other serious
violations of their rights, particularly in cases of sexual
abuse or exploitation. We agree with the Special
Representative that the efforts made in the initial
planning and implementation of peacekeeping
operations should take into account the need to protect
and rehabilitate children, and that such action should
12
be community-based so as to facilitate the sustainable
and successful reintegration of children.
Child protection is a commitment on the part of
us all. We hope in that regard that all States, together
with the United Nations system and organized civil
society, including children themselves, can undertake
joint action that will allow us to achieve a world of
peace for all in which we can truly protect the rights
and well-being of children.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I call on the
representative of Argentina.
Mr. Argiiello (Argentina) (spoke in Spanish):
Argentina would like to start by thanking the
Panamanian presidency of the Security Council for the
month of February for organizing this debate, which
ratifies the political decision of this Council to put an
end to the suffering of children affected by armed
conflict.
We would also like to thank the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for Children
and Armed Conflict, Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy, and
the Executive Director of UNICEF, Ms. Ann Veneman,
for their comprehensive presentations on this complex
issue, as well as Ms. Jo Becker from Watchlist on
Children and Armed Conflict and the Coalition to Stop
the Use of Child Soldiers for the information she has
shared with us.
More than two years since the adoption of
resolution 1612 (2005), we welcome the progress made
in the protection of children affected by armed conflict
through the joint action of States and the mechanisms
created by the United Nations system, with the
invaluable contribution of civil society. We must
commend the actions taken by some national
Governments to put an end to crimes committed
against children in armed conflict and to bring
perpetrators to justice. We must also highlight the
activities of civil society in gathering information on
the situation of children in territories affected by armed
conflict and in denouncing the abuses to which
children are subject. It is indispensable to guarantee
their safety, as well as that of the victims and their
families, when denouncing such acts in order to
guarantee the proper functioning of the justice system
and avoid impunity.
Argentina places the highest importance in the
promotion and protection of the rights of girls and
boys, both in its national plans and strategies centred
on the family as the basic unit of society, as well as
through its ongoing support for and participation in all
international initiatives aimed at ensuring the
opportunity for all children to enjoy a childhood
effectively free from violence.
In that regard, we note that, in spite of the
progress made, it is necessary to strengthen the
measures for the protection of children affected by
armed conflict in the framework of an integral
approach that cannot be limited to the security aspects
and must include political, juridical and
socio-economic measures.
Regarding the implementation of resolution 1612
(2005) of the Security Council and the functioning of
the Working Group on Children and Armed Conflict,
Argentina believes that progress is needed with regard
to the following.
First, the Security Council must reiterate the clear
message to all responsible parties that the international
community will not tolerate any further violation of the
rights of children in conflict. We are persuaded that the
presidential statement to be adopted by the Council at
the end of this debate will serve that purpose.
Secondly, it is necessary to deepen the political
and financial commitment of Member States in support
of the monitoring and reporting mechanism and to keep
it operational in all situations of armed conflict.
Thirdly, it is imperative to achieve the full
implementation of all monitoring and reporting
mechanisms on children affected by armed conflict of
the Working Group, as provided for in resolution 1612
(2005).
Fourthly, the Security Council must incorporate
into the mandate of the Working Group those situations
where may arise any of the six categories of grave
violations: the recruitment and use of child soldiers,
rape and other grave sexual violence, the killing and
maiming of children, abductions, attacks against
schools or hospitals, and denial of humanitarian access
to children.
Fifthly, we have confirmed the valuable
contribution that the presence of child protection
advisers can make in terms of obtaining timely and
precise information that allows for the prompt
undertaking of promotion activities and a rapid
response to diverse situations in order to protect
children affected by armed conflict, as well as
contributing to their prevention. Thus, it is necessary to
consider their incorporation into the mandates of all
relevant future peacekeeping missions and political
missions.
Sixthly, it is necessary to strengthen
disarmament, demobilization and reintegration
programmes so that victims have a real opportunity to
rejoin society with sufficient funding and practical
efficient mechanisms that produce sustainable results
in the long term.
Combating impunity and finding justice are at the
heart of any effective response to prevent and end
violations of human rights in any situation. In that
regard, we believe it is essential to explore all means of
bringing perpetrators to justice. That includes the
jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court in
appropriate cases.
Violations of the rights of children in situations
of conflict not only affect peace and security, they also
have dire consequences for the present and future
development of affected societies. The heightened
vulnerability of those children makes them easy targets
when it comes to increasing the number combatants, as
well as regards forced labour and sexual exploitation.
The exploitation of children, either in an armed
conflict or in any other situation is unspeakable,
inexcusable and an affront that goes to the very heart
of the common values that all our societies share.
Argentina therefore reiterates its ongoing
commitment to the protection of children from all
forms of violence. We also reiterate our readiness to
continue to cooperate with the Working Group chaired
by the delegation of France, as we did from 2005 to
2006 as an elected member of the Council and as we
reiterated recently through the submission of our 2007
national report and our support for the adoption of
concrete steps towards improving the life of children
who are being affected daily by the consequences of
conflict.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Guatemala.
Mr. Briz Gutierrez (Guatemala) (spoke in Spanish): Allow me to thank the Vice-President and
Minister for Foreign Affairs of Panama for his presence
at our meeting this morning, to which we have come to
debate this issue. We also welcome the presence of
several ministers of State, as well as the briefings by
Ms. Coomaraswamy and Ms. Veneman, the valuable
contribution of Ms. Jo Becker of Watchlist on Children
and Armed Conflict and the information provided by
the organization Security Council Report.
A little over 10 years ago, Graga Machel's report
(A/51/306) highlighted to the Organization the horrors
suffered by children affected by armed conflict. That
led to the holding of the Security Council's first open
debate on children and armed conflict. In June 2008,
10 years will have passed since that event. We regret
how many young lives have been lost or tragically and
violently affected, especially as regards girls.
Unfortunately, since then we have also witnessed the
changes that have taken place in war tactics and the
nature of conflicts, wherein civilian populations have
increasingly become the targets of violence and
unspeakable atrocities, leading to a new spiral of
violence and further threats to children.
In spite of so many atrocities, which have all
caused irreversible damage to children, Guatemala
recognizes that some progress was made in that time.
For example, this subject has been regularly discussed
in 11 open debates, and resolutions have been adopted
that refer specifically to the situation of children in
armed conflict - including resolution 1612 (2005),
which set out the conceptual framework to strengthen
the protection of children who are victims of armed
conflict and to combat the recruitment and use of
children as soldiers by armed forces or groups of any
sort. It is clear that of the six grave violations
identified throughout the years, the recruitment and use
of children has garnered the greatest attention. In
addition, more recently, child protection advisers have
been included in peacekeeping and special political
operations. It is now up to us to continue to move
ahead to address the very widespread phenomenon of
gender-based violence, including the systematic rape of
girls, sexual slavery and the brutal violence to which
they are subjected and their ensuing stigmatization by
their communities.
We must also not fail to increasingly address
other forms of violence that also affect children:
mutilation, murder, kidnapping and attacks against
school and hospitals. Such violence forces children to
flee their families and communities, forcing them to
become refugees in neighbouring towns and countries.
Without a doubt, that makes them even more
vulnerable. Worse yet is a phenomenon that has been
documented in several conflicts, namely, the denial of
the very humanitarian assistance that goes some way
towards ameliorating the problems of children affected
by armed conflict.
The responsibility to protect children in armed
conflict is incumbent upon us all. However, there is no
doubt that this is the primary responsibility of States.
Civil society can be a country's best ally - gathering
information on examples or cases of violence against
children and sharing that information with the relevant
Government officials responsible for corroborating it
and taking the appropriate steps. The role of civil
society can also be very important as regards working
with Governments to implement a monitoring and
reporting mechanism, mediation efforts to secure the
release of children in the hands or combatants and
rescuing children from military organizations. Civil
society also has a role to play in the rehabilitation and
social reintegration of children and in designing and
implementing reconciliation processes aimed at
repairing the social fabric.
If they do not receive appropriate assistance, as
adults, children who have grown up in a climate of
violence, have suffered from violence or have been
forced to engage in it are likely to repeat that
behaviour. In that connection, we should also recall the
importance of fully adhering to and implementing
international principles, norms and procedures of
restorative justice and social rehabilitation when it
comes to addressing cases of children accused of
committing crimes in association with armed groups or
forces.
That reference to justice leads me to the annexes
published by the Secretary-General in his reports,
which identify groups that recruit children and on
which, year after year, several groups are listed that we
already know to be habitual violators of the rights of
children. In that connection, there is a need to put an
end to impunity. Guatemala concurs with the
Secretary-General that those groups should be
subjected to much more robust and effective targeted
sanctions. There should also be closer controls over the
sale and availability of weapons and over capital flows
intended for weapons. Eliminating such groups should
be a resolute and urgent priority for the Security
Council.
Given the sensitive nature of the issue before us
today, it is important that any information coming into
the United Nations system, the Office of the Special
Representative, the Security Council and any other
body of the Organization should be objective, reliable
and from responsible interlocutors. From the
community level to national and international
institutions, communication, cooperation, coordination,
information exchange and verification, and
transparency among all parties and actors should be
carried out in line with the relevant mandates and
working methods.
In conclusion, Guatemala recognizes and is
grateful for the valuable contributions made by the
Paris Principles and Guidelines on children associated
with armed forces or armed groups. They provide us
with a comprehensive picture of the experiences and
lessons learned in the course of the past 10 years. We
also appreciate the so-called toolkit developed by the
Council's Working Group. We believe its work should
be decisively utilized.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Israel.
Mr. Gillerman (Israel): At the outset, allow me
to congratulate you, Mr. President, on your very able
stewardship of the Council this month and thank you
for convening this important meeting. My delegation
also wishes to thank the Special Representative of the
Secretary-General for Children and Armed Conflict,
Ms. Coomaraswamy, the UNICEF Executive Director,
Ms. Veneman, and the representative of the Watchlist
on Children and Armed Conflict for their statements
and their important work on behalf of children
everywhere.
In addition, my delegation commends the
Working Group on Children and Armed Conflicts,
under the able stewardship of France, for its work on
the promotion and protection of children affected by
armed conflict.
At the outset, allow me a personal note. When I
presented my credentials to Secretary-General Kofi
Annan just over five years ago, on 6 January 2003, I
said to him that I was doing so on behalf of a nation, a
people and a child. When I said the word "child", I saw
him tense, and then I said that the nation was the State
of Israel, which I love very much, the people are the
Jewish people, who I am very proud to represent, and
the child was my four-year-old grandchild, Ron, who at
the time was attending a kindergarten in Tel Aviv.
Every time I went to pick him up from the
kindergarten, my heart broke at the sight of the armed
guard standing outside those innocent kids'
kindergarten to protect them from terror. I told the
Secretary-General that Israel was the only democracy
in the world where nurseries, kindergartens and schools
are protected by armed guards, and I voiced my hope
and prayer that by the end of my tenure here, no child
in the world would have to be guarded by armed
guards. Unfortunately, today, more than five years
later, my grandson is nine years old and attending a
school in Israel that is still guarded by armed guards.
Over the past two decades, more than 2 million
children have been killed in conflicts, with another
6 million maimed or permanently injured. More than a
quarter of a million youths have been exploited as child
soldiers, and, needless to say, most are recruited at
such a young age that they are robbed of their
schooling and youth. Thousands of girls have been
subject to sexual exploitation, prostitution, rape -
which is even used as a weapon of war - and sexual
and gender-based violence.
Accordingly, Israel assigns great importance to
the protection of children, particularly from violence
and armed conflict. Israel has been a signatory to the
Convention on the Rights of the Child since 1991 and
to its Optional Protocol on the Involvement of Children
in Armed Conflict. Last year, Israel was pleased to
welcome the Special Representative of the Secretary-
General, Ms. Coomaraswamy, for a visit and to
cooperate with and support her as she sought to better
understand the impact of conflict on all the children of
our region.
In that regard, my delegation takes note of the
report of the Secretary-General on children and armed
conflict, (S/2007/757) and wishes to briefly highlight
and expand on some of the issues it references.
Armed conflict levies a heavy toll on all civilian
populations, and no effort must be spared to ensure the
protection of civilians, particularly children, whose
inherent vulnerabilities make them dependent on others
for safety. The spread of terrorism around the globe
means that civilians today are especially and
increasingly placed in danger, from both indiscriminate
and targeted terrorist attacks.
There can be no doubt that terrorism comes at
civilians' expense. Even worse, children have often
become the object of such terrorist interest for
purposes of recruitment, incitement to violence, human
shielding and even targeted attacks. While terrorism is
a global concern, the situation in our region provides a
stark snapshot of some of the most daunting challenges
the international community faces in the protection of
children.
Extremist ideology is the handmaiden of youth
violence. Young people are extremely impressionable,
susceptible to brainwashing and indoctrination by
icons of popularity. Often enough, official textbooks
used in schools teach children hatred and incite them to
violence. Indeed, indoctrination is just as dangerous as
the acts of violence and terrorism themselves, as they
pervert the value and worth of education, poison the
social bloodstream and create an infrastructure for
continued terrorism and extremism.
As one example, a recent episode of the Hamas
television show "Tomorrow's Pioneers" featured a
malevolent rabbit that eats Jews. Numerous other
television programmes, all viewed by thousands upon
thousands of Palestinian children, are known to praise
jihad and violence and indoctrinate that young
viewership.
Palestinian terrorists use similar tactics to
actively recruit children to carry out terrorist
operations. Then there are the cases of parents, mothers
and fathers, who strap suicide belts on their own
children and send them off to carry out terrorist attacks
and those who dance on the rooftops celebrating the
carnage they caused by firing Qassam rockets and
injuring Israeli children. Those grotesque images shake
us all to the very core, but they are also a very real
aspect of the way that children are threatened and
harmed by Palestinian terrorism.
Moreover, the use of civilian areas to carry out
acts of terrorism is being seen with alarming frequency.
On 29 October 2007, Hamas terrorists in the Gaza Strip
fired mortars from the yard of a United Nations Relief
and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near
East (UNRWA) elementary school in Beit Hanoun.
That cynical abuse of the school and violation of a
United Nations installation for terrorist purposes was
rightfully condemned by the Secretary-General.
Regrettably, the incident is absent from the
aforementioned report.
Similarly, while the report provides statistical data
on the number of Israeli children physically injured by
Qassam rockets, the report fails to reflect on the long-
term damage, such as psychological conditions and
stress disorders that are the direct consequence of the
rocket barrages fired by Palestinian terrorists.
That indiscriminate rocket firing poses a
particular danger to children. A case in point is the city
of Sderot, where up to 94 per cent of children suffer
from post-traumatic stress disorder, including sleep and
concentration problems and even bed-wetting. The
psychological effects are no less damaging than
physical wounds and should not be casually dismissed.
Indeed, the frequency of rocket attacks has increased
alarmingly in recent months, where, on average, one
rocket is fired at Israel every three hours.
The rockets, sadly, inflict devastating physical
suffering as well. Over the past weekend, two brothers
were seriously wounded when a Qassam rocket
slammed into their hometown of Sderot, On Sunday
evening, doctors were forced to amputate part of the
left leg of one of the boys, eight-year-old Osher Tuito.
In Hebrew, by the way, "Osher" means joy and
happiness. His 19-year-old brother Rami was also
badly injured from the terrorist attack. Osher, who
dreamed of becoming a soccer player, does not yet
know that he has lost one of his legs.
Israelis were reminded of the never-ending and
inescapable pain of Palestinian terrorism when the
Tuito family received a letter yesterday from the Cohen
family, whose children, Tehila and Yisrael, ages seven
and eight, also had their legs amputated after being
severely injured in a terrorist attack a few years ago. In
their letter, the Cohen children wrote to the Tuitos:
"What can we say to you as Osher lies in
the hospital bed without knowing what the future
holds? It is heartbreaking. Such a small child.
And the biggest question is - will he ever be
able to ride a bike again or kick a soccer ball?
You deserve the security of living in your own
home and your own town, living with the other
citizens who live there".
That is a touching statement of courage and solidarity
in the face of terrorism, but it is also a harrowing
reminder of how Palestinian terrorism continues to
destroy and shatter innocent lives.
Surely, there is no monopoly on suffering. All
children - Palestinian and Israeli - suffer from and
are victims of this Palestinian terror. Terrorism is a
gross threat to the ability of our children to live in
peace and safety in the region. Hence, terrorism, in all
its varieties and forms, is always unacceptable and can
never be justified - because it is the children who
ultimately suffer, each and every one of them. The
child victims of terrorism, both Israeli and Palestinian,
are real. Each one has a name and a family; each one
has his or her own dreams and aspirations. And each
victim has now had those dreams and hopes shattered
by the cruelty and inhumanity of terrorism.
Lastly, my delegation wishes to place on record
its concern regarding some of the methodologies
utilized in compiling the report. Specifically, our
concerns relate to sections where ambiguities in the
report may allow for misinterpretation. Moreover, the
tendency to rely on unsubstantiated reports, third-party
testimony and hearsay harms the report's credibility
and effectiveness. We stress that accurate reporting is
in the interest of regional peace and security and that
all efforts should be made to utilize credible
testimonials and evidence. My delegation is engaged in
active dialogue and cooperation with the Office of the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict, and we hope to see these
concerns reflected in future reports.
As Israel engages with the moderate Palestinian
Authority leadership and works shoulder to shoulder to
achieve peace and security for all citizens of our
region, we are aware of the impact that conflict has had
on our children. It is in this interest, therefore, that
Israel hopes to prepare its children for peace, to
maintain a commitment to dialogue and moderation
and to eradicate extremism, racism and hate. Only
upon those foundations will we truly be able to build a
better world today for our children and grandchildren
of tomorrow.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Canada.
Mr. McNee (Canada): I would like to thank the
delegation of Panama for convening today's important
meeting. We would also like to thank the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General, Ms. Radhika
Coomaraswamy, for her impressive and compelling
statement today and for the excellent work she has
done since taking office two years ago. We would also
like to thank Ms. Ann Veneman, the Executive Director
of UNICEF, whose statement today illustrates the
importance of UNICEF for the issue of children and
armed conflict. We also welcome to this debate Ms. Jo
Becker from Watchlist on Children and Armed
Conflict, an organization whose rigorous and important
work is supported by Canada.
Today's debate is an opportunity once again to
bring to the attention of the Council the severity of acts
of violence against children in violation of human
rights and international humanitarian law. The Security
Council has a central role to play in protecting children
who suffer from the horrific effects of armed conflict
and in holding accountable those responsible for the
continuing atrocities committed against them. The
Secretary-General's report on children and armed
conflict is an important tool to understand how
violations against children constitute a threat to
international peace and security. The report
(S/2007/757) outlines clear recommendations for
future action.
Canada strongly supports and wishes to speak to
three areas in particular: first, the need for the Security
Council to give equal attention to children affected by
armed conflict, whether in situations on the agenda of
the Council or not; secondly, the necessity to give
equal weight to all categories of grave violations
described in the report, beyond simply the recruitment
and use of children; and finally, the need to implement
the monitoring and reporting mechanism within the
framework of resolution 1612 (2005) in all situations
of concern.
In July 2005, the Council adopted resolution 1612
(2005), which has proven to be an effective tool for
putting pressure on those who commit violations
against children. Canada commends the work of the
Security Council Working Group created by resolution
1612 (2005) and the strong support provided by the
Secretariat to the Working Group. It is also important
to underline the tremendous work in the field that has
been accomplished by UNICEF and by the various
non-governmental organizations and civil society
actors that contribute to the 1612 (2005) monitoring
and reporting mechanism. The work of all United
Nations personnel in the field, whether in peace
missions or in United Nations country teams, is
instrumental in making child protection a reality on the
ground. Without this joint effort, the impact of
resolution 1612 (2005) would fail to reach the children
in need.
Addressing the situation of children and armed
conflict can be difficult. The Secretary-General's report
shows this all too well. The protection framework
created by resolutions 1539 (2004) and 1612 (2005) is
a complex web of instruments that can lead to concrete
actions to end violations, but only with the cooperation
of Member States. Those who criticize the complexity
of these instruments should not forget the important
successes that have been achieved. For example, the
de-listing of parties to the conflict in Cote d'Ivoire is a
significant achievement of the resolution 1612 (2005)
framework and offers lessons for future success. We
also note with satisfaction some progress in various
situations outlined in the report of the Secretary-
General which are clearly linked to the implementation
of resolution 1612 (2005).
While Canada is generally satisfied with the
current state of implementation of resolution 1612
(2005), there remain clear gaps. Several parties that
persistently commit grave violations against children in
conflict situations remain untouched by the resolution.
This cannot continue. In order to end this culture of
impunity, it is essential that the Council apply targeted
measures against these violators and work on their
referral to the relevant tribunals. In this regard, Canada
is pleased by the charges, trials and sentences over the
past year by the International Criminal Court and the
Special Court for Sierra Leone for crimes against
children. We urge the Working Group to continue its
efforts and we urge the Council to use this route while
also pursuing targeted measures through the specific
country mandates.
(spoke in French)
We think the time is right for the Council to
strengthen its protection framework for children,
particularly by allowing the existing resolution 1612
(2005) monitoring and reporting mechanism to be
triggered by all violations against children described
by the Secretary-General in his report. Specifically,
rape and other grave sexual violations must be
addressed. While we welcome the cooperation of the
Government of the Democratic Republic of the Congo
in the implementation of resolution 1612 (2005), the
appalling situation in that country demonstrates why
this type of violation has been deemed a threat to
international peace and security.
Moreover, Canada believes that the Council
should adopt a new resolution to expand monitoring
and reporting, including strengthening the relevant
work of the Security Council Working Group, in order
to eradicate these heinous crimes committed against
children. These measures should be undertaken as soon
as possible.
At the end of the day, what matters is real and
visible protection for children. Furthermore, that
consideration underpins our support for strengthening
the framework of protection provided for in resolution
1612 (2005). In particular, we must eliminate sexual
violence in conflicts and make progress towards the
fulfilment of an ideal: freeing children from the
shackles of war. We all know that, if we are to improve
their living conditions, all efforts count, in all fields
and in all places, from war zones to the halls of
academia to United Nations conference rooms in New
York.
Finally, Canada believes that the Security Council
is on the right track in addressing this issue, thanks in
particular to France's leadership of the Working Group
on Children and Armed Conflicts. We are convinced
that the Council will continue to do its part, including
through its excellent work in this area.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now call on
the representative of Austria.
Mr. Pfanzelter (Austria): Austria fully aligns
itself with the statement made by the representative of
Slovenia on behalf of the European Union. We would
like to make some additional comments.
We highly commend the Panamanian presidency
for holding this open debate on children and armed
conflict. We are also grateful to the Secretary-General
for his report (S/2007/757) and welcome his
recommendations.
As all speakers have stated, children are among
the most vulnerable groups in our societies. They are
the easiest prey for ruthless perpetrators; they are also
the key to the future of our societies. The way in which
children are treated in conflicts has fundamental
implications for society and for our self-conception as
human beings. We must therefore put an end to the acts
of those groups and individuals who systematically and
deliberately target and abuse children in situations of
armed conflict.
We highly appreciate the outstanding work of the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General,
Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy. Her efforts have made a
real difference for children on the ground. We also
support the important UNICEF initiatives to, inter alia,
follow up on the Paris Principles and Commitments.
The crucial role of non-governmental organizations
must also be highlighted. They are on the front lines in
supporting children and make a very special
contribution to the success of the monitoring and
reporting mechanism.
We now have a comprehensive set of instruments,
including Security Council resolutions, prohibiting and
criminalizing the recruitment and use of child soldiers
as well as other abuses of children in armed conflict.
The Security Council has been actively engaged in
addressing violations against children, in particular
through the establishment of the monitoring and
reporting mechanism pursuant to resolution 1612
(2005) and the creation of the Working Group on
Children and Armed Conflicts, which, under France's
leadership, has greatly enhanced the Council's efforts.
However, despite all our efforts, there still is a
long list of perpetrators who for years have continued
to systematically commit serious violations against
children and have gone unpunished. That situation
demands further action by the Security Council.
Unfortunately, some of the existing mechanisms and
tools of the Council and of the Working Group have
been underutilized. We support the Secretary-General's
call for making full use of the available range of
measures in these cases, including the imposition of
targeted measures and the referral of violations against
children in armed conflict to the International Criminal
Court for investigation and prosecution. We also call
on Member States to strengthen the rule of law and to
fully utilize judicial mechanisms to bring to justice
perpetrators of violations against children.
We support the Secretary-General's
recommendation that equal weight be given to all
categories of grave violations against children. A
phased approach could be taken to make that
recommendation a reality. As a first step, the crime of
rape and grave sexual violence against children could
be added as an alternative gateway to trigger the
monitoring and reporting mechanism. Like the
recruitment of child soldiers, these crimes are
intentional acts. Parties to armed conflict can
reasonably be expected to take action against
perpetrators. Progress in the implementation of action
plans can be measured.
We are deeply shocked by the appalling level of
sexual and gender-based violence against children, as
documented in the Secretary-General's report. As has
been pointed out by all previous speakers, these acts
are horrendous crimes, and those responsible for
committing them must be brought to justice. For that
reason, Austria has increased its support for campaigns
against sexual violence and assistance programmes for
victims of such violence, in particular in eastern
Democratic Republic of the Congo.
Children and armed conflict has been an issue of
critical importance and great concern for Austria for
many years. We have made the protection of children
in armed conflict a priority in our foreign and
development policy and will continue to do so in the
future.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now call on
the Permanent Observer of Palestine.
Mr. Mansour (Palestine): I congratulate you, Sir,
and your country, Panama, on your assumption of the
presidency of the Security Council for this month and
express our confidence in your ability to wisely guide
the work of the Council. I also reiterate our thanks to
the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya for its able leadership of
the Council in January. In addition, I thank
Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy, Ms. Ann Veneman and
Ms. Jo Becker for their statements.
Armed conflicts continue to claim the lives of
innocent children around the world. Our world is not
one fit for all children, particularly those in situations
of armed conflict, who are surrounded by dangers that
force them to live in constant fear for their lives and
leave them needy and vulnerable. Their childhoods are
marred by violence, physical and psychological harm;
displacement; imprisonment; exploitation, including
recruitment as soldiers and sexual exploitation; hunger;
poverty; lack of education; and devastation of their
families and communities.
For children in situations of armed conflict,
including foreign occupation, all aspects of life are
detrimentally impacted and the meaning of childhood
is lost. As stated in the important Graca Machel study
"Impact of armed conflict on children",
"War violates every right of a child - the
right to life, the right to be with family and
community, the right to health, the right to
development and the right to be nurtured and
protected".
Moreover, the damage caused to children today has
negative short and long-term consequences for
children, women, families and societies as a whole,
inevitably impacting future prospects for peace and
development in our world. We know that to be true.
Yet, regrettably, children continue to be the victims of
appalling human rights violations and crimes, despite
the international community's Declaration, more than
five years ago, that
"Children must be protected from the horrors of
armed conflict. Children under foreign
occupation must also be protected, in accordance
with the provisions of international humanitarian
law". (General Assembly resolution S-27/2, para. 7 (7), annex)
We must act now, in reaffirmation of this commitment,
to protect children and to ensure their rights under the
Convention on the Rights of the Child, the Universal
Declaration of Human Rights and all other relevant
international legal instruments.
The wide gap between such international legal
standards and their actual implementation for
safeguarding children's rights must be closed. Ending
impunity for violations against children is paramount,
and we agree in this regard with the recommendations
in the 10-year strategic review of the Machel report,
including the application of targeted measures such as
sanctions against those persistently committing grave
violations against children in armed conflict.
Decades of human rights violations and hardships
have indelibly marked Palestine's children and
refugees and those under occupation, resulting in what
the Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict, Ms. Coomaraswamy,
described in a report following her visit to the occupied
Palestinian territory in April 2007, as "a palpable sense
of loss and a feeling of hopelessness that places the
children of the West Bank and Gaza apart from all
other situations the SRSG has visited to date".
Palestinian children continue to be killed and
wounded in Israeli military assaults and to be
traumatized by the vicious cycle of violence, with
nearly 1,000 children killed since September 2000 and
more than 3,500 injured, many of them permanently
disabled.
Children continue to be used as human shields by
the occupying forces, and their schools continue to be
targeted by attacks. More than 400 Palestinian
children, some as young as 12 years old, also continue
to be imprisoned by Israel under inhumane conditions
and subject to physical and mental ill-treatment,
including torture and threats of sexual violence.
Palestinian children also continue to suffer
displacement and its many associated consequences,
including induced poverty, as a result of the occupying
Power's wanton destruction of homes and refugee
shelters and unlawful construction of the wall and
settlements.
Palestinian children also continue to suffer
gravely from the deliberate denial of humanitarian
access by the occupying Power. Israel's collective
punishment of the Palestinian people has disastrously
impacted the humanitarian situation of children, with
the situation in the besieged Gaza Strip most severe.
There, Israel's obstruction of access for humanitarian
supplies and personnel is violating children's rights to
food, health care, education and, in some cases, the
right to life itself.
It has been reported that already more than 67
children have died due to blockage of access to proper
medical care, including prevention of treatment outside
the Gaza Strip and a shortage of 150 critical
medications. In conjunction with this, widespread
hunger in Gaza, where mothers and fathers cannot even
feed their children without food aid, and the severe
shortages of fresh drinking water have caused a
dramatic decline in health, with rampant child
malnutrition, anaemia, and stunted growth. Medical
research estimates that at least 70 per cent of children
in Gaza are anaemic and that, consequently, these
children lack immunity even to common childhood
diseases, not to mention other, more virulent diseases.
In such a situation, even a simple outbreak of influenza
could cause severe illness or widespread death among
children. Such a catastrophe must be averted by
immediate humanitarian and political intervention.
While it is our deepest hope that current peace
efforts will lead to a just and lasting settlement that
will bring to Palestinian children the freedom, security
and well-being of peace in their independent State,
living side by side with Israeli children in peace and
security, reiterate that the rights of children living in
such situations of armed conflict, including foreign
occupation, and response to their needs cannot be
postponed or withheld. For all of these children, there
must be collective efforts to ensure their protection and
their rights as well as the necessary assistance and
rehabilitation to give them hope and allow them to
become productive members of their societies,
contributing to the advancement of their nations.
In this regard, we agree with the recommendation
in the report of the Secretary-General that child
protection advisers should be posted in the occupied
Palestinian territory, among other places, to enhance
human rights monitoring and appropriate responses to
children's issues.
Moreover, we stress the central role of the United
Nation in assisting and protecting children, particularly
through the important work of UNICEF and, in the
case of Palestinian children, of the United Nations
Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the
Near East as well, and the many other United Nations
agencies working with other international humanitarian
organizations to help children around the world. Such
efforts, combined with the important advocacy work of
the Special Representative of the Secretary-General,
will keep attention on the plight of children in armed
conflict, a plight that the Security Council must also
address as it endeavours to address armed conflicts in
their entirety for the promotion of peace and security
for all in our world.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Nepal.
Mr. Acharya (Nepal) (spoke in English): First of
all, Mr. President, I wish to thank you very much for
organizing this open debate on the important issue of
children and armed conflict.
On behalf of the delegation of Nepal, I would like
to welcome the report of the Secretary General of
21 December 2007 (S/2007/757), including the
comments on progress in the implementation of various
Council resolutions on the subject. We especially
appreciate the presentations on the subject by the
Special Representative of the Secretary General,
Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy, and the Executive
Director of UNICEF, Ms. Ann Veneman.
My delegation feels that the Council, through its
resolutions, including resolution 1612 (2005), has
contributed immensely to improving the plight of
children in armed conflicts in various parts of the
world. Since the question of children in armed conflict
is undoubtedly one that cuts across a number of
complex social, cultural, economic and legal issues, it
requires simultaneous actions on multiple fronts.
Recruitment of children in armed conflicts
continues to be the issue of overarching concern.
Needless to say, a successful reintegration of children
recruited in armed conflicts is a key to finding a lasting
solution in any situation involving children and armed
conflict.
As mentioned in the report of the Secretary-
General, the sexual abuse and exploitation of children
during armed conflicts is an issue of a serious concern.
Impunity on such heinous crimes should not be
tolerated. We welcome the recommendation that the
Council give the same importance to all categories of
grave violations, including rape and sexual violence as
well as abductions of children in all situations, as it
does to the recruitment of children in armed groups.
Allow me to make a few points with regard to the
section in the report on children affected by armed
conflict in Nepal. Nepal has attached high priority to
protecting and promoting the rights of the children who
have been victims of armed conflict.
In accordance with the provisions of the
Comprehensive Peace Agreement, the process of
verification of the Communist Party of Nepal (Maoist)
combatants now living in cantonments has been
completed and children under the age of 18 have been
identified. At the moment, we are working with the
United Nations Mission in Nepal, UNICEF and
relevant United Nations agencies in developing
modalities with regard to releasing and rehabilitating
the minors from the cantonments, as provided for in
the Comprehensive Peace Agreement. In that regard,
we particularly welcome the recommendation that the
United Nations agencies, donors and partners should
provide adequate support to national Governments in
the rehabilitation and reintegration of children affected
by armed conflicts.
We are confident that the election to the
Constituent Assembly, to be held on 10 April, will pave
the way for a better future for children affected by the
decade-long conflict in Nepal. The Government of
Nepal is committed to preventing children and youth
from being part of any violent activities and is also
determined to end impunity for crimes committed
against them under any pretext. We believe that the
establishment of the truth and reconciliation
commission, which is under active consideration, will
also address that issue. As a party to the Convention on
the Rights of the Child and its Optional Protocol,
Nepal is committed to taking measures to enact and
implement the provisions of those instruments.
I wish to take this opportunity to express my
thanks to the Working Group on Children and Armed
Conflict for the important work it has one under the
chairmanship of the Permanent Representative of
France. The Government of Nepal is committed to
implementing various recommendations of the
Working Group adopted on 12 June last year,
especially in the context of the ongoing peace process.
Let me also take this opportunity to inform the Council
that the Government of Nepal looks forward to
seriously engaging in discussions during the proposed
visit to Nepal later this month of the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General, Ms. Radhika
Coomaraswamy, on various protection measures for
children affected by the conflict.
In closing, let me reiterate that Nepal is steadfast
in fulfilling its responsibilities in providing effective
protection and promoting the rights of children affected
by armed conflict, and in that regard is ready to extend
full cooperation to the monitoring and reporting
mechanism established under Security Council
resolution 1612 (2005).
The President (spoke in Spanish): I call on the
representative of Uganda.
Mr. Lukwiya (Uganda): I would like to thank the
Security Council for allowing my delegation to
participate in this debate on the important issue of
children and armed conflict. My delegation has
carefully studied and noted the seventh report of the
Secretary-General on Children and Armed Conflict,
contained in document S/2007/757.
My delegation wishes to address itself
specifically to paragraphs 133, 134 and 135 of the
report, as well as to annex II of the report, in which,
once again, references are made to the Uganda
People's Defence Forces (UPDF), as well as to the
now-defunct local defence units, as parties that have
also been responsible for committing rape and other
grave sexual violence against children in the reporting
period.
It has been reported that, due to the lack of
effective monitoring at the local level, children have
continued to join the armed forces. We would like to
state that Uganda has evolved a very effective
mechanism to monitor recruitment into the armed
forces. The mechanism starts at the village level, with
the village chairman or head testifying to the character,
education and age of the potential recruit. A medical
examination is undertaken by a fully qualified medical
officer at the recruitment centre to verify both the age
and the medical condition of the applicant. Any recruit
found to be below the age of 18 years and medically
unfit is discharged. He or she is not allowed into the
forces. We are, however, cognizant of the fact that no
mechanism or system can be perfect. Uganda is,
however, determined to ensure that the system works
and does not allow children to join the armed forces,
contrary to the law and constitution of the land.
It has been stated that, during the reporting
period, 16 cases of recruitment and use of children
aged between 14 and 17 were detected. As a percentage
of the total force throughout the country, that is a very
small fraction, considering that some cases do slip
through the system. However, all efforts are made to
avoid that happening at all. Uganda handles such cases
appropriately through immediate demobilization and
sanctions against those individuals that assisted in the
violation. Demobilization and reintegration in such
circumstances are immediate. In that endeavour, we
work with UNICEF and civil society organizations.
The Government has built a large boarding primary
school in Gulu to facilitate the process. It affords
demobilized children an orderly return to normal
civilian life.
It has never been the official policy of the
military to occupy schools or any other educational or
social institutions. However, in a few isolated cases,
the conflict situation has led the army to occupy some
school structures abandoned by the general population
and students. Schools were constructed near camps for
the internally displaced to service children in the
vicinity. Structures of the former Baralegi primary
school in Okwang sub-county are currently occupied
by the army, as stated in the report. However, at the
time of initial occupation, it had been abandoned and
was in a state of disrepair; now, with the return of
peace to the area, many people are moving back. There
is a population that needs to have the school. Due to
the serious damage that they underwent, it is no longer
possible to use the same structures. New structures
have been constructed and others are under
construction. Those form the new school. The
community is therefore not deprived of educational
services, as the report seems to suggest.
With regard to the agreed action plan for the
prevention of the recruitment and use of child soldiers,
which was finalized in August 2007, I would like to
inform the Council that, on 2 November 2007, the
Office of the Special Representative of the Secretary-
General for Children and Armed Conflict, as well as
the Chairman of the Security Council Working Group
on Children and Armed Conflict, were furnished with a
matrix from my Government showing its achievements
as of August 2007, together with the agreed terms of
reference for the Uganda task force for monitoring and
reporting, which is headed by UNICEF. In doing so, we
believed that we, as a Government, were exercising
maximum cooperation with the office of the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General, as well as
with all partners in the cause. We are therefore
disappointed as a Government to learn that our
dedication to the implementation of the same action
plan is being put into question.
The report alleges that there are children within
the ranks of the local defence units. Uganda wishes to
state that those units have been disbanded. Some of the
personnel have been integrated into the national army
and the police. Recruits were diligently vetted for
qualifications, which included, among other things,
successful completion of four years of secondary
school education, a minimum age of 18 years, and
medical fitness. That is not a claim, as the Secretary-
General's report states in paragraph 133; it is a
statement of fact. It therefore follows that all cases
reported about the presence of children in local defence
units are non-existent, since the institution has been
dissolved. It no longer exists. Furthermore, as a
non-existent entity, it should no longer be listed under
annex II.
Rape is a capital offence under both military and
civil Ugandan law. It is punishable by death if guilt is
proven. Moreover, reported cases of rape are always
investigated and tried accordingly. The UPDF Act
prescribes the death sentence for rape if the accused is
found guilty by an appropriate military tribunal.
Individual soldiers who have raped and been tried and
found guilty have had to face the death penalty.
Regarding rape and sexual offences committed by
people in internally displaced persons camps, we wish
to state that those are civilian cases, which should be
tried by civilian courts. In some cases, no conclusive
action has been taken for the following reasons: first,
problems regarding investigative institutional capacity
as a result of the 20 years of insurgency, which has
disrupted institutions, including the police and the
judiciary; secondly, unwillingness of witnesses to
speak out due to cultural inhibitions and fear of
retribution from fellow internally displaced persons,
given the severity of the punishment for the offender;
thirdly, failure of victims to cooperate with police
investigators due to fear of social stigma.
It is also alleged in the report that "children who
had escaped from [the Lord's Resistance Army (LRA)]
were used for gathering intelligence before being
released in February 2007" (S/2007/757, para. 133).
Uganda wishes to state that whenever children are
rescued from the LRA, the Government forces
undertake a normal debriefing exercise. The exercise is
meant first and foremost to help establish the children's
areas of origin, education levels and age. That assists
the army officers in referring the children to the
relevant locations and organizations for psycho-social
rehabilitation. In some cases, however, those children
have information of military value, including the
location of LRA arms caches. In such situations, they
can help the army recover hidden arms, thus reducing
the capacity of the LRA to wage war. They are
immediately released upon the completion of any arms
recovery exercise. It is not the policy of the
Government or the UPDF to use children to gather
intelligence. What happens in that case is the careful
extraction by the UPDF of any actionable intelligence
information that the children have at the time of
reporting or rescue. They are not used to gather
intelligence, as reported in the report of the Secretary-
General.
It is also our view that Uganda should be de-
linked from the LRA, as the LRA is no longer
operating in Uganda. The international community, and
the Security Council in particular, should exert
maximum pressure on the LRA to release all women
and children within its ranks and in captivity.
Allow me to conclude by stating the view of the
Government of Uganda that the UPDF entry should be
removed from annex II of the report, given the
circumstances under which it was put there and the
measures we have taken to ensure that underage people
are not recruited into our armed forces. We find it a
little irritating for Uganda to be called upon year after
year to explain a situation that is no longer the case, as
if we were a guilty party. If this unjustified trend
continues, we know that it will only harm our
cooperation with the Office of the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for Children
and Armed Conflict. We would not like that to happen.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I give the
floor to the representative of Sri Lanka.
Mr. Kariyawasam (Sri Lanka): Mr. President,
allow me to first congratulate you on your able
stewardship of the Security Council this month. At the
outset, allow me to convey my sincere appreciation to
you and the members of the Council for convening this
meeting, which provides an opportunity to focus our
attention on the use of children in armed conflict.
This debate takes place in tandem with the
10-year review of the Graca Machel report, which
brought this issue to the fore. It is therefore time to
take stock of action taken thus far by the international
community to address the detestable practice of the use
of children for violent purposes in conflict situations.
We recognize the role of the Secretary-General and the
contribution of the Special Representative of the
Secretary-General, Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy, to
this cause, which we believe can be more focused and
results-oriented.
As Sri Lanka celebrates the 60th anniversary of
our independence this month, we take pride in the
remarkable strides we have made in the social sector,
especially in health care and education. For the past 60
years, Sri Lanka has invested heavily in children. Free
compulsory primary education leading towards free
university education, and free health care have been the
hallmarks of our efforts. We are determined that our
children continue to reap the benefits of those
measures. We do not want our children to succumb to
the diabolical efforts of non-State actors who use our
innocent children for violent purposes.
Recognizing the need to safeguard our children
from non-State actors who recruit children as agents of
violence and terrorism, the Government has unveiled
specific measures to strengthen the existing regime of
protection of children and child welfare in its blueprint
for peace and development for the country.
We are conscious that the primary responsibility
for the protection of children and promotion of their
welfare lies with the State, and that it is imperative for
the State to ensure that children are not in danger and
to prevent them from being used as accessories for
violence. Therefore, just as we reject terrorism, we also
continue to reject the recruitment and use of children in
armed conflict as unjustifiable under all circumstances.
We seek the support of the international community to
eradicate this menace and urge stronger international
measures against those who perpetrate such crimes.
In that context, the Government of Sri Lanka
reiterates its long-held policy of zero tolerance towards
the recruitment and use of children in armed conflict.
The Government believes strongly in addressing issues
of children and armed conflict pursuant to resolution
1612 (2005). In that context, we reiterate our View that
the Security Council must consider this issue on the
basis of supporting the establishment of security and
consolidating peace in conflict-afflicted societies, to
enable States to protect their children from non-State
actors who violate children with impunity.
The report of the Secretary-General, referring to
the situation in Sri Lanka, calls upon the listed
offenders in annex II of the report to mend their
despicable behaviour and calls upon the Security
Council to consider deterrent action against repeated
violators. Specifically identifying the terrorist group
Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) as
responsible for numerous repeated grave abuses, the
Secretary-General has listed that group as a persistent
violator, repeating its listing since 2003. The Karuna
faction of the LTTE has also been listed as a violator.
We look forward to the opportunity to soon consider
the issue as it relates to Sri Lanka, in depth and in all
its aspects, in the Working Group on Children and
Armed Conflicts.
The Secretary-General suggests in paragraph 149
of his report that increased pressure is required against
persistent and recalcitrant violators of child rights such
as LTTE by further considering the need to impose
targeted measures against those parties. This
suggestion of the Secretary-General is in accordance
with his recommendation in paragraph 163 of his
report, which welcomes the Security Council's
continuing consideration of effective targeted measures
against parties to armed conflict who continue to
systematically commit grave violations against
children in armed conflict in defiance of
recommendations by the Working Group on Children
and Armed Conflict and of Council resolutions. This
clearly singles out the terrorist group LTTE as
deserving stronger targeted measures.
Almost a decade has now passed since the LTTE
gave a public undertaking to cease the recruitment and
use of children as combatants, and also to release
children within its ranks. This commitment was never
implemented by the LTTE, which continued to recruit
and use children as combatants even after the Council
adopted resolution 1612 (2005), under the terms of
which parties to armed conflict that recruit or use
children for armed hostilities must cease such practices
forthwith, release children within their ranks and enter
into action plans with UNICEF or relevant
peacekeeping missions.
Repeated violations of all undertakings given to
the international community by non-State actors, like
the LTTE, must stop. It is our collective responsibility
to find ways and means to make such non-State actors
fall in line.
The Security Council's initiative to address the
issue of children in armed conflict and subsequent
efforts by the Security Council Working Group must be
made to focus more on the real underlying core issue:
the recruitment of children. We must be cautious in
considering the expansion of the mandate without
addressing the core issue, since such an approach may
not usher a change on the ground and will not inspire
confidence in the process undertaken by the Security
Council.
We agree with the views indicated in paragraph
132 of the report concerning the responsibility of
Governments in relation to rehabilitative measures for
children who seek special protection and surrender to
Government forces. The rehabilitation of children, who
have been used as combatants by non-State actors, is as
important as preventing children from being recruited
for armed conflict. However, rehabilitation efforts to
ensure the successful reintegration of children into
society require resources and expertise. Tangible
international assistance and support for such efforts, as
opposed to mere declarations of concern, will be
invaluable not only in promoting the welfare of
children but also for consolidating peace and
peacebuilding efforts.
Collective will is required to take focused action
with respect to real issues of concern on the ground.
Therefore, first and foremost, the Security Council
needs to be more resolute in taking action to prevent
children from being used as soldiers and accessories in
all conflict situations.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now call on
the representative of El Salvador.
Mrs. Gallardo Hernandez (El Salvador) (spoke in Spanish): On behalf of my delegation, Mr. President,
may I begin by wishing you every success during your
Presidency.
My delegation welcomes this initiative to
convene an open debate on the subject of children and
armed conflict. We are dealing with, no doubt, an
extremely sensitive matter, not only for its implications
in terms of peace and security, respect for human rights
and fundamental freedoms, particularly those of
children, but also given the associated consequences in
terms of peacebuilding, reconciliation and national
reconstruction during the post-conflict period.
El Salvador recognizes, as a matter of principle,
the importance of encouraging measures at the
national, regional and international levels intended to
put an end to the recruitment and use of children in
armed conflict, which is in violation of applicable
international law, in addition to other grave violations
committed against children affected by armed conflict.
When viewed from this angle, our delegation
echoes the importance of stepping up national efforts
intended to establish an appropriate legal framework,
which will contribute to more clearly and precisely
defining those grave violations. Those include murder
and maiming of children, rape and other acts of sexual
violence, kidnapping, denial of access to humanitarian
assistance intended for children and attacks against
schools, nurseries and hospitals, which are frequently
perpetrated by the parties in an armed conflict.
As has been broadly reported by relevant United
Nations bodies, in an armed conflict children are the
target of different forms of sexual and gender violence,
including rape, which is prohibited by international
humanitarian law as a flagrant violation of their human
rights. Clearly, rape is a method of war, which is
deliberately employed to humiliate girl children and
their families, thereby forcing them to become
displaced and causing humanitarian crises.
It should be noted that this negative situation
generates a culture of violence and negative values,
which may very well be reproduced by other children
in different forms, making it difficult for them
subsequently to achieve reconciliation with society.
Our delegation exhorts the international community to
contribute to the establishment of an enabling
environment that will bring an end to impunity of those
who commit crimes against children, particularly those
who promote the recruitment and use of children in
armed conflicts.
It should also be stated that post-conflict and
peacebuilding processes require the international
community to work with countries emerging from
conflict in their endeavours to implement measures
intended to achieve national reconciliation. These
include measures to benefit of children who are the
victims of violence.
In the view of my delegation, the Peacebuilding
Commission might be more closely involved in
supporting the mechanisms that exist within the
Security Council to deal with these matters, in
particular within the context of peacebuilding
strategies. In addition, strengthening communication
and coordination between bodies within the United
Nations system and with post-conflict countries could
in turn contribute to bolstering efforts to achieve the
reintegration of children in society. In our view, the
satisfactory reintegration of children in post-conflict
societies is an important element in implementing
peacebuilding strategies, and thus should be taken into
account in the early planning stage and throughout the
implementation of peacebuilding operations.
El Salvador welcomes the dialogue of
cooperation between the United Nations system and
countries emerging from a situation of armed conflict.
Clearly, in a peacebuilding process many of the issues
that arose during the armed conflict may continue to
have an adverse effect on children, marking them and
making it difficult for them to learn a culture of peace
in the future.
Therefore, post-conflict countries' societies
should have an opportunity to reassess relevant actions
once they have achieved greater levels of political
maturity and democratic governance as a result of the
implementation of peace agreements and through open
and transparent dialogue with the international
community.
In this regard, attention should be drawn to the
importance of continuing to promote a broad-based
approach, which incorporates all aspects of political
issues, security and human rights, together with
fundamental freedoms in post-conflict countries.
Consideration should also be given to the need to
promote a gradual process in promoting justice,
reparation and rehabilitation of victims of conflict.
Lastly, allow me to reiterate the political will of
the Government of El Salvador to continue to promote
measures intended to strengthen the rule of law and
democratic good governance and to step up efforts at
the institutional level to guarantee the promotion and
the effective protection of the human rights of all of the
people of El Salvador, especially the children.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Guinea.
Mr. Zoumanigui (Guinea) (spoke in French):
First, I wish to congratulate you, Mr. President, on
your country's assumption of the presidency of the
Security Council for this month and to thank you for
organizing this meeting. I also wish to assure you of
our complete cooperation. This is an opportunity for
me to express our gratitude to His Excellency
Mr. Giadalla Ettalhi, Permanent Representative of the
Socialist People's Libyan Arab J amahiriya for the work
achieved in the past month. Allow me to express to
Ms. Coomaraswamy, Ms. Veneman and Ms. Becker our
appreciation for the presentation of the report and for
their statements which further enlightened us on this
matter.
The founding fathers of our Organization in
adopting its Charter stressed, inter alia, the need for the
peoples of the United Nations, "to save succeeding
generations from the scourge of war to promote
social progress and better standards of life in larger
freedom" and, to that end, "to unite [their] strength to
maintain international peace and security."
The conflicts of today, given their new
dimensions, affect civilian populations more, in
particular those who are the most vulnerable including,
inter alia, children. The actions of the international
community to find a solution to this situation are
encouraging and should be supported. In that respect,
we welcome the fact that the Security Council has been
dealing with this important matter on a permanent
basis since 1999, with particular focus on the full
implementation of relevant recommendations and the
strengthening of measures to be taken at all levels to
put a definitive end to the tragic consequences of
conflicts on children worldwide.
We appreciate the report in document
S/2007/757, which provides useful information on
compliance in ending the recruitment and use of
children in armed conflict and also includes
information on progress made in the establishment of a
monitoring and reporting mechanism and in the
development and implementation of action plans.
While welcoming the progress achieved by the
parties, my delegation shares the concerns expressed in
the report, supports the efforts under way and favours
an in-depth consideration of the recommendations
made by the Secretary-General.
My delegation notes that the success of any
action depends on cooperation. For that reason, we
encourage partnership between United Nations bodies
on the one hand and between those bodies and other
national and international actors on the other, so that
the question of children and armed conflict will have a
positive outcome. In addition, the Security Council
should carry out a comprehensive thematic evaluation
of the protection of civilians in armed conflict,
encompassing all the issues that have an impact on
children and armed conflict: women, peace and
security, small arms and light weapons and cross-
border matters.
We encourage, in particular cooperation between
the Security Council and the Peacebuilding
Commission, which in our opinion should take into
account the issue of children and armed conflict.
My delegation firmly supports a zero-tolerance
policy and welcomes the adoption of a comprehensive
strategy on assistance and support to victims of sexual
exploitation and abuse. This will help the United
Nations to help victims of sexual exploitation
responsibly and in a coordinated manner. Thus, my
delegation, which condemns rape and sexual violence
during armed conflict, considers that in no situation
should such violence serve as a weapon of war.
We appeal to Member States to attach greater
importance to the work of the 2008 Third Biennial
Meeting of States to Consider the Implementation of
the Programme of Action to Prevent, Combat and
Eradicate the Illicit Trade in Small Arms and Light
Weapons in All Its Aspects. The scope and tragic
consequences of the illicit use of those weapons show
that the fight against this scourge requires greater
capabilities than those of national entities alone. Thus,
it behoves the international community to draw up and
implement specific measures for combating the
scourge.
Clearly, the participation of my delegation in this
meeting is based on the will of my Government to be
fully involved in the efforts of the international
community to effectively combat the recruitment and
use of children in armed conflict. Even though Guinea
itself has not been the theatre of armed conflict, it
belongs to a continent, and in particular to a subregion,
which has long been scarred by conflicts that have had
a negative impact on the lives of countless children.
My Government, aware of its responsibilities, has
spared no effort to be involved in the search for a
solution to conflicts in the subregion.
Today we are encouraged by the process of peace
and stabilization in the countries of the Mano River
Union, Cote d'Ivoire and Guinea-Bissau. We invite the
international community to give further support to that
process. In the view of my delegation, the various
experiences gained at the national, subregional,
regional and international levels in combating the
recruitment and use of children in armed conflict
should be shared in order to bring into play the
comparative advantages of each organization and
country.
Lastly, my delegation expresses the hope that this
meeting will make it possible for us to plan future
actions on the basis of experience gained in order to
better discharge a common and historic duty: to
bequeath to the next generation - that is, today's
children - a world of peace, security, justice, progress
and harmony.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Iraq.
Mr. Al Bayati (Iraq): Allow me at the outset to
congratulate you on your assumption of the presidency
of the Security Council for this month. I would like
also to extend my appreciation to the delegation of the
Libyan Arab Jamahiriya for its successful presidency
of the Council last month. I wish further to welcome
the Special Representative of the Secretary-General on
Children and Armed Conflict, Ms. Coomaraswamy, and
to thank her for her constructive efforts to fulfil her
mandate in following the situation of children and
armed conflict. I also would like to thank Ms. Ann
Veneman, Executive Director of the United Nations
Children's Fund, for her briefing.
My delegation took note of the report of the
Secretary-General on children and armed conflict
(S/2007/757) and would like to make the following
comments on the situation concerning Iraq. The Iraqi
children went through tremendously difficult
circumstances during the last three decades due to the
irresponsible policies of Saddam's regime. They were
among the first victims of chemical weapons used by
the former dictator in Halabja and other areas and
cities of Iraq. They were victims of forced
displacement and mass executions committed by the
previous regime as a systematic policy to punish the
Iraqi people. The innocent children of Iraq paid a
heavy price because of international sanctions and the
embargo imposed on Iraq due to the invasion of
Kuwait by the dictatorship. The Iraqi regime used the
suffering of the Iraqi people, including children, during
13 years of sanctions to pressure the international
community and to avoid fulfilling its international
obligation.
After the fall of the dictatorship in 2003, Iraqi
children were the victims of terrorist acts and sectarian
violence in Iraq. Many of them were subjected to daily
threats to their lives because of the suicide bombings
and the roadside bombs which led to the killing and
maiming of several children. We agree with most of the
facts outlined in the report concerning the suffering of
the Iraqi children due to the terrorist acts of Al-Qaida
and other armed groups who target civilians, foremost
amongst which are children.
The most recent terrorist act, which took place on
1 February 2008, was a dual bombing in the pet market
in Baghdad. It led to casualties and loss of life for
dozens of innocent children and women. This is another
example of the ruthlessness of this terrorist enemy.
The report has noted that there are indications of
children being recruited as combatants by non-State
armed groups, Al-Qaida and Al-Qaida-affiliated
groups. In this regard, we would like to refer to what
has recently been reported by the international media
regarding documentaries prepared by Al-Qaida which
show clearly the recruitment of children at the age
around 11 to carry out suicide operations, kidnappings,
armed robberies and the planting of explosive devices.
Despite the difficult circumstances, Iraq has witnessed
in 2007 positive progress in the situation of children,
due to the decrease in the number of terrorist
operations and the implementation of the Baghdad law
enforcement plan.
The Iraqi Government has been keen to take all
possible executive and legislative measures to
minimize the suffering of children, to provide them
with a decent life and to compensate them for the years
of deprivation and suffering they have gone through.
The Government has established an inter-ministerial
committee - the National Committee for Children -
to consider means of improving the situation of
children in Iraq. The Iraqi Government has also
completed the executive and legislative steps needed to
ratify the two Optional Protocols to the Convention on
the Rights of the Child of 1994: the Optional Protocol
on the Sale of Children, Child Prostitution and Child
Pornography and the Optional Protocol on the
Involvement of Children in Armed Conflict, both of
which entered into force in 2002.
The Iraqi Government is keen to start constructive
and positive cooperation with the United Nations to
improve the situation of children in Iraq and has
extended a formal invitation to Ms. Coomaraswamy, the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict, to visit Iraq and to
examine the situation of children and the efforts of the
Iraqi Government to alleviate their suffering. The Iraqi
authorities, through the Permanent Mission of Iraq in
New York, are conducting close consultations and
coordination with the Office of Ms. Coomaraswamy on
this important visit, planned for next month.
The Iraqi authorities have started to implement
their plan to train nursery staff and to include nurseries
in nutrition programmes. They have also opened nine
new nurseries, following approval by Ministry of
Health authorities. The Ministry of Labour and Social
Affairs has started a special programme for children
with mental disabilities. They have also computerized
the centres for those with physical disabilities, in
addition to starting advanced classes at those
institutions. The ministry has also introduced intensive
training courses for the teaching staff. The Ministry of
Labour and Social Affairs is focusing on families with
children and provides them with salaries, under the
social protection network. The number of beneficiary
families has reached 93,553. The number of visually
impaired children included in this programme has
reached 20,416, and a further 24,350 paralysed
children are included in the programme.
The authorities in Iraq are keen to organize
children's festivals, theatres, art exhibitions, photo
galleries and various other types of art events for
children. They have also organized several workshops,
symposiums and conferences focusing on violence
against children and the means to combat it. The date
13 July has been set as Iraqi Child Day, which is
celebrated officially by the Iraqi Government. A
governmental committee was recently established to
draft the Iraqi Child Law to be approved by the Iraqi
Government and subsequently by the Iraqi parliament.
The Iraqi Government has been keen to operate
with United Nations agencies, among them UNICEF, to
invest donor contributions, which amounted to
$40 million in 2007, in order to deliver critical health
care, safe water and sanitation, education and other
essential services to millions of children and their
families. These funds have enabled the Iraqi health
workers to conduct house-to-house immunization
campaigns protecting over 4 million children against
polio and more than 3 million against measles and
mumps, in close partnership with the World Health
Organization and UNICEF. As a result of these
campaigns, Iraq remains polio-free, and measles cases
are dramatically down, from 9,181 in 2004 to just 156
in 2007, as of November.
It is to be recognized that 4.7 million Iraqi
primary school children have benefited from the
investment in education, including the distribution of
critical school materials, the rebuilding and restoring
of schools, the addition of extra classrooms for
displaced children and the provision of accelerated
learning opportunities. A Government-supported
assessment of school attendance rates in 2007 is now
under way.
The Prime Minister of Iraq, His Excellency
Mr. Nuri al-Maliki, has called for a national enquiry
into the conditions of children in orphanages and is
urging the Iraqi Government to make possible a rapid
assessment of all the country's orphanages and juvenile
centres as soon as possible. An open monitoring system
for the assessment of children's institutions is a top
priority, as is improving the skills of care-givers and
accelerating community-based child care alternatives.
It is also important to highlight the major role of
the partnerships that have made these achievements
possible, most notably those with the European
Commission, Japan, Italy, Canada and other friendly
countries, in addition to other United Nations agencies
and non-governmental organizations.
The Government and the people of Iraq would
like on this important occasion to express their sincere
appreciation and gratitude to all countries, international
organizations and United Nations agencies, foremost
among them UNICEF and the World Health
Organization, for their continued tremendous efforts to
help Iraqi children. We hope for their continued
support to improve the situation of Iraqi children and
to put an end to their suffering.
Finally, I would like to express my appreciation
to the Special Representative of the Secretary-General,
Ms. Coomaraswamy, for her efforts in preparing the
report. We are looking forward to her visit to Iraq, and
we affirm the commitment of the Iraqi Government to
cooperate constructively with her to help the children
of Iraq.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Switzerland.
Mr. Maurer (Switzerland) (spoke in French): I
thank the delegation of Panama for having organized
this year's important open debate on children and
armed conflict. Switzerland takes notes with
satisfaction of the report of the Secretary-General
(S/2007/757) and welcomes the efforts of the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for Children
and Armed Conflict and of UNICEF to prevent abuses
and to protect children.
Despite certain encouraging developments
described in the report, much remains to be done to
make the system for the protection of children in armed
conflict truly effective. In that context, the Secretary-
General's proposals and recommendations deserve our
full attention: we need to obtain tangible results on the
ground.
Switzerland, which fully endorses the
recommendations set out in the report, considers that
the Security Council should give particular priority to
the following areas. First, consideration should be
given to expanding the scope of the monitoring and
reporting mechanism to include the six categories of
grave violations, in particular rape and other grave
forms of sexual violence.
Secondly, a series of specific targeted measures
should be taken against parties to armed conflict that
are responsible for grave and persistent violations
against children. The Security Council should refer to
the International Criminal Court all cases on which
national courts either have not exercised their
jurisdiction or have not done so in accordance with
their obligations under international law.
Thirdly, although some progress has been made
in this regard, it is imperative to remind all parties to
armed conflict listed in the annexes to the report of the
Secretary-General that they must prepare and
implement concrete action plans.
Fourthly, child protection advisers should be
included in both peacekeeping and political missions
whenever appropriate. Furthermore, Switzerland calls
upon all the parties to armed conflict mentioned in the
annexes to the report of the Secretary-General to
continue the dialogue that the Security Council has
begun with the Governments concerned, the United
Nations agencies as well as national and international
civil society actors. Only through enhanced
coordination and cooperation among all concerned
parties will it be possible to improve the protection of
children in armed conflict.
Armed conflict leads to an increase in all forms
of violence. Among them, trafficking in small arms
increases the vulnerability of children in situations of
conflict and of post-conflict transition. Switzerland
would like the Secretary-General to formulate, in his
next report, specific recommendations on the
protection of children in armed conflicts in relation to
the use of small arms and light weapons.
As a general rule, the gender dimension needs to
be taken into consideration more systematically in the
international community's response. The Security
Council may want to consider the problem of children
and armed conflict in conjunction with resolution 1325
(2000), on women and peace and security, and
resolution 1674 (2006), on the protection of civilians in
armed conflict.
In conclusion, I would like to reaffirm
Switzerland's support for the Security Council Working
Group on Children and Armed Conflict and to
encourage it to pursue its work to achieve concrete
results so that we may combat more effectively the
recruitment and use of child soldiers and other
violations of the rights of children, as well as the
impunity enjoyed by those responsible for grave abuses
and violations against children in armed conflict.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Thailand.
Mr. Pramudwinai (Thailand): On behalf of the
Government and the people of Thailand, I wish to
warmly congratulate Panama upon its assumption of
the presidency of the Security Council for February
and to express our appreciation to you, Sir, for
organizing the open debate on this important topic.
The Thai Government, like the Governments of
most other countries, shares the commitment of the
Secretary-General, his Special Representative for
Children and Armed Conflict, UNICEF and other
relevant parties to protect and improve the well-being
of children around the world. But since this morning
we have heard, and we continue to hear, various voices
of care and concern for the plight of children in all
situations of trouble. Some may see this as a fact of
life, one that is seemingly perennial, but taking
advantage of the fragility of children is not to be
tolerated. That practice must be curtailed, and their
future ensured.
In this connection, we would like to share with
the Council our views on this crucial issue. First,
Thailand notes that the Security Council has of late
made significant strides in the specific area of children
and armed conflict within the context of its principal
mandate on the maintenance of international peace and
security. We appreciate the commitment and
contribution of the Security Council in this area.
However, we are of the view that the mechanism
established by the Security Council on this particular
subject is still in its nascent stage; there is certainly
room for improvement and consolidation. Thorough
reflection by the Council would be necessary in this
regard, and we agree with many speakers that a
thorough but incremental, step-by-step approach offers
the best way forward.
Secondly, Thailand welcomes the fact that, in
conjunction with the Security Council, there has been
greater interest within the overall United Nations
system on the issue of children. This advancement of
the children's agenda can be recognized in various
forms and forums, including the General Assembly, the
Economic and Social Council, the Human Rights
Council, the executive boards of specialized agencies,
funds and programmes and relevant human rights
treaty bodies. In our view, because the issue of children
is multidimensional and diverse, our approaches,
strategies and instruments should be so as well, bearing
in mind the uniqueness, strengths and constraints of
each of those various bodies. Against this backdrop, we
firmly believe that greater effort should be made by the
international community to address the root causes of
armed conflict through greater international
cooperation in the areas of poverty alleviation and
sustainable socio-economic development. Development
is another name for peace and security.
Thirdly, the Thai Government has always been
fully committed to doing what it can to contribute to
the realization of our collective vision of a world fit for
children. Our track record in this area, both at home
and abroad, speaks for itself and underlines our strong
determination to constantly improve the well-being of
all our children. For in so doing, we know full well that
a strong and sustainable foundation for the peace,
security and future development of the country is
firmly laid.
As concrete testimony to our commitment, the
Thai Government has already become a party to the
Convention on the Rights of the Child and its two
Optional Protocols, on the sale of children, child
prostitution and child pornography, and on the
involvement of children in armed conflict. We are
determined to ensure that we have the most effective
domestic legal framework in place for our children. A
broad range of policy initiatives has also been
implemented to promote and protect the rights of
children in Thailand, including the right to education,
through a policy of universal access to education. In
short, our commitment to the cause of children is a
strong and healthy national commitment.
Fourthly, we cannot stress enough that utmost
care should be exercised in the preparation of reports
of the Secretary-General on such issues as children and
armed conflict. It should be clear that the scope of the
report on this issue and its follow-up should be strictly
restricted to situations of armed conflict. In this
context, we would like to echo the view expressed by
several previous speakers that any reference in such a
report to any country where there is no situation of
armed conflict is not only unwarranted but also
misleading and should not be repeated in the future.
In conclusion, the Thai Government wishes to
reaffirm its commitment to the cause of children. We
will continue to work actively with our partners at
home and abroad in various areas for the children, our
future.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Afghanistan.
Mr. Tanin (Afghanistan): Allow me to begin by
joining previous speakers in congratulating you, Sir, on
your assumption of the presidency of the Security
Council. We wish you every success in steering the
work of the Council to a successful conclusion. We
extend our appreciation to Panama for convening
today's debate, which provides an opportunity to
reaffirm our collective commitment to ensuring the
protection, rights and well-being of children in armed
conflict.
We also thank Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy,
Special Representative of the Secretary General, and
Ms. Ann Veneman, Executive Director of UNICEF, for
their insightful briefings, delivered this morning.
Since the adoption of resolution 1612 (2005), a
number of important steps has been taken to ensure the
protection of children in conflict situations. These
include the creation of a monitoring and reporting
mechanism to provide accurate and timely information
on grave violations against children in war and of the
Working Group to develop concrete recommendations
on child protection in country-specific situations.
Nevertheless, it remains a grim reality that children
continue to be subject to grave violations in conflict
situations worldwide.
Today's meeting is of particular importance to
Afghanistan as a country that has suffered from
decades of armed conflict that has had a devastating
impact on the most vulnerable part of our population,
namely, children. Nevertheless, since 2001, we have
achieved considerable progress in promoting and
safeguarding the rights of our children.
We remain firm in our commitment to ensure the
security and well-being of our children at every stage
of their lives. Afghanistan is a party to the Convention
on the Rights of the Child and its Optional Protocols;
on the Involvement of Children in Armed Conflict, and
on the Sale of Children, Child Prostitution and Child
Pornography. National legislation has been enacted to
implement the Convention and its two Protocols. With
the conclusion of our nationwide child demobilization
programme, 7,444 underage soldiers recruited by
illegal armed groups have been demobilized. As a next
step, we have put in place reintegration committees and
vocational schools in many provinces to reintegrate
former soldiers into civil life. In that regard, we call on
our international partners to assist us in implementing
such programmes and to facilitate the creation of
employment opportunities for our young people.
In addition, strict measures have been adopted to
prevent the recruitment of soldiers under the age of 18
into our armed forces. Mechanisms are in place in our
security institutions to assess and monitor new soldiers
during both the recruitment and training stages to
ensure that the minimum age requirement for
recruitment is being met.
Regarding child trafficking, our Government has
established a special task force to prevent children
from being abducted and falling victim to traffickers.
Since 2002, 429 cases of child trafficking have been
reported, from which 329 children have been rescued.
Our Penal Code is one among various domestic laws
addressing the abduction and kidnapping of children.
Those measures have been complemented by President
Karzai's initiative to create an inter-ministerial
commission for the prevention of child trafficking in
November 2003, as well as by the launch of our
national action plan to combat child trafficking.
Despite our progress, terrorism remains a harsh
reality in the lives of our children. Terrorists have
increased attacks against schools, teachers,
schoolchildren and clinics. Attacks on schools and
school burnings have kept approximately 300,000
children from attending school out of fear of violence.
As indicated in the report of the Secretary-General,
between August 2006 and July 2007 alone, at least 133
incidents of school attacks were reported. Such attacks,
which have occurred mainly in the southern provinces,
have led to the closing of 384 of the 721 schools in the
provinces of Helmand, Kandahar, Uruzgan and Zabul.
Terrorists have spared no effort to harm all
segments of society as they have increased their attacks
in densely populated areas or in the vicinity of public
gatherings. Such acts have had a devastating impact on
the lives of our children. Just three months ago, a
terrorist attack against a parliamentary delegation in
Baghlan province led to the death of more than 50
children, while another 90 were severely wounded. In
that context, I express my delegation's appreciation to
the Council for its swift response in condemning the
attack on 8 November.
Afghanistan's enemies have resorted to new and
brutal tactics. In the most malicious practice
conceivable, terrorists are recruiting children and
sending them out to function as suicide bombers. As
documented in a UNICEF report entitled "Child Alert:
Afghanistan", released in October of last year, a
16-year-old Afghan boy was ordered to wear a vest full
of explosives and to detonate it in Ghazni province.
The report quotes the boy as saying, "The remote
control battery was with me, but I could not do it and
threw the battery away If I didn't do it, they said I
would go to hell". In that regard, we remain extremely
concerned about the use of religious schools in the
region where children are indoctrinated and deceived
into carrying out terrorist acts.
We are also concerned about the loss of life and
injury suffered by children during counter-terrorism
operations, mainly as a result of the Taliban's use of
the civilian population as human shields. In that regard,
we call on our international partners to exercise the
maximum caution and to enhance coordination with
Afghan security forces during counter-terrorism
operations to avoid the loss of civilian lives.
Despite considerable progress in improving the
lives of our children - as seen in the reduction in the
infant mortality rate by 85,000 per year and in the
increased access to health centres throughout the
country - the humanitarian situation of our children
remains dire, owing to the prevailing security situation.
Hundreds of thousands of Afghan children lack the
basic necessities for a decent life. These include food,
water, adequate shelter and sanitation facilities. Their
situation is further complicated by the difficulty in
gaining access to supplies and humanitarian assistance.
In that regard, we welcome UNICEF's latest appeal for
financial assistance in support of the situation of
children in Afghanistan.
Addressing the protection of children in armed
conflict requires the collective commitment of the
international community. It also necessitates a
comprehensive strategy encompassing key pillars. As
part of the effort to safeguard the rights of children, the
international community should place a special focus
on poverty alleviation, lending financial and economic
assistance to post-conflict countries so as to enable
them to achieve their development goals. By doing so,
we will meet the preconditions for the creation of an
environment conducive to sustainable human
development and the well-being of our children.
My delegation commends the work undertaken by
the relevant United Nations agencies to protect and
promote the rights of children in armed conflict,
particularly the United Nations Children's Fund
(UNICEF), the Office for the Coordination of
Humanitarian Affairs and the Department of
Peacekeeping Operations. We are particularly grateful
to UNICEF for its ongoing efforts in support of a better
and brighter future for our children.
In conclusion, I would like to underscore the
commitment of Afghanistan to ensure the protection of
children's rights in general. We remain committed to
supporting every measure, both within the Council and
within other relevant organs of the United Nations, to
protect the rights of children in armed conflict. After
all, by protecting our children, we are securing our
future.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now call on
the representative of Peru.
Ms. Tincopa (Peru) (spoke in Spanish): At the
outset, I wish to thank you, Sir, and your delegation for
having organized this important debate. We also wish
to express our gratitude for the report submitted by the
Secretary-General (S/2007/757) and for the statements
made this morning by the Special Representative of the
Secretary-General for Children and Armed Conflict,
the Executive Director of UNICEF and the
Representative of Watchlist on Children and Armed
Conflict on behalf of non-governmental organizations.
Because of the conditions of underdevelopment
and exclusion, protecting children is extremely difficult
in many of the countries covered by the Secretary-
General's report and by the Security Council's Working
Group on Children and Armed Conflict. Conflict is a
circumstance in which the situation of children requires
redoubled and concerted efforts. Therefore, Peru
supports the Secretary-General's recommendations and
requests the Security Council and the other bodies
concerned to adopt them.
States have equipped themselves with binding
instruments to protect human rights and humanitarian
law. Even in the context of conflict situations, we must
reaffirm the importance of making progress in the
universalization and effective implementation of such
law. For its part, the Security Council should continue
to employ, or expand the use of, available instruments
and measures to halt the abuse of children's rights in
conflict situations.
We wish to highlight the need for Member
States - particularly those affected by armed
conflict - to continue, within the framework of their
legal systems, to undertake or adopt measures to bring
to justice those responsible for the recruitment and use
of children and other grave crimes committed against
children. Neither amnesty nor impunity is acceptable.
We would also like to highlight the role that has
been played by the International Criminal Court in
cases such as those in the Democratic Republic of the
Congo and the importance of expanding the categories
of offences against children falling within its
jurisdiction. Support for the work of international
justice mechanisms is part of an holistic approach by
the Security Council to support peace, truth and
national reconciliation. Peru is pleased that it has been
able to contribute to the prosecution of those accused
of these and other crimes before the International
Criminal Court.
We agree with the Secretary-General's
recommendation that the Security Council attach the
same importance to all categories of grave violations,
not only the recruitment and use of child soldiers, but
also the killing and maiming of children, rape and
other grave sexual violence, abductions, attacks against
schools, hospitals and refugee centres, and denial of
access to humanitarian aid that specifically targets
children.
The task of implementing resolution 1612 (2005)
remains pending and should be approached in a
coordinated fashion, by States, the United Nations
system and civil society alike. Also pending is the
updating and strengthening of existing mechanisms to
achieve the objectives of resolution 1612 (2005) under
the new circumstances of insecurity that children
confront, particularly in countries where the Security
Council has established peacekeeping operations or
political missions.
To this end, Peru considers it important that the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict should also include in her
reports, in a disaggregated manner, information on
rapes and sexual abuse of children, particularly girls,
along with information from peacekeeping operations
and the Department of Political Affairs. It would also
be desirable to bolster the capacity of such missions
with child protection advisers.
As borne out by the improved situation of
children in Cote d'Ivoire, in stabilized areas of the
Democratic Republic of the Congo and in Nepal, when
a country's political leaders reach a viable and
sustainable peace agreement and assume the
responsibility to protect their population, particularly
their children, conditions tend to improve.
It is for this very reason that emphasis should be
placed on the need for the Security Council and the
other United Nations organs to support the work of the
Peacebuilding Commission in order to adopt an
integral approach to managing post-conflict processes
with a view to preventing the resurgence of violence.
In conclusion, we are of the view that human
rights, peace, international security and development
are mutually interlinked. Dealing with them in an
integral manner will contribute more effectively to
successfully addressing issues concerning children,
especially those in conflict situations. Their lives and
the future of countries in conflict or emerging from
conflict depend on our efforts, as, ultimately, does the
stability of entire regions everywhere in the world.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of the United Republic of
Tanzania.
Mrs. Kafanabo (United Republic of Tanzania):
At the outset, allow me to join other speakers in
congratulating Panama on having organized this open
debate on children and armed conflict. We thank the
Special Representative of the Secretary General for
Children and Armed Conflict, the Executive Director
of UNICEF and Jo Becker from Watchlist on Children
and Armed Conflict for their comprehensive updates on
this issue.
We wish to state our satisfaction with the work of
the Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict and UNICEF in the
protection of children and the promotion of their rights
in situations of armed conflict.
We also thank the Secretary-General for his
detailed report on children and armed conflict
(S/2007/757) and welcome the recommendations
contained therein.
It is a matter of serious concern that many
children are losing their childhood and even their lives
as a result of ongoing conflicts in different parts of the
world. It is even more disturbing that, now, children
are not only caught in the crossfire of the warring
parties, but are more and more becoming deliberate
targets and unwitting victims of violence and abuse.
Children are forcibly turned into cannon fodder and
killing machines as child soldiers and are lured into
destructive covert missions.
My delegation is further concerned with the
escalating incidences of rape and sexual abuse of
children, especially girls, in times of conflict. We
strongly condemn rape and sexual violence and abuse
in all of their manifestations. The gravity of rape and
sexual violence and abuse lies not only in the physical
trauma they cause, but in the long-term psychological
trauma as well. Means to provide assistance and
support to victims of rape, sexual violence and abuse
have thus to be provided. We note the decline in cases
of sexual violence and abuse brought against
peacekeepers. We urge the Secretary-General not to
relent on the zero-tolerance policy on sexual
exploitation and abuse.
We also condemn the attacks on civilians and
public properties, especially those targeting schools
and teachers. Stern measures need to be taken against
all those who are in violation of international law
relating to the rights and protection of children in
armed conflict. We need to send a clear message that
those violating the rights of children, including those
recruiting children and using them to fight adult wars,
will be prosecuted with the full weight of international
law. We thus call upon Member States to end impunity
and to prosecute those responsible for violations of the
rights of children.
We commend the efforts of the Special Court for
Sierra Leone and the International Criminal Court in
prosecuting such persons and urge Governments to
support their work. We would further request the
Security Council to consider targeted measures for the
worst offenders, especially those who are repeatedly
mentioned in the reports of the Secretary-General.
The monitoring and reporting mechanism that has
been created through resolution 1612 (2005) has
invigorated our quest to improve the situation of
children in armed conflict. We are encouraged by the
positive results on the implementation of the
monitoring and reporting mechanism, including the
creation of awareness and dialogue on the issues
affecting children in situations of conflict. The
mechanism also provides a good example of teamwork
and collaborative efforts among Governments, United
Nations country teams and civil society organizations
on the ground.
We note also that other countries that are not on
the agenda of the Security Council have volunteered to
implement the monitoring and reporting mechanism.
That is testimony to its usefulness. We would thus call
upon the Security Council to extend the monitoring and
reporting mechanism to all situations of children in
armed conflict, not only those on the agenda of the
Council. It is therefore important that the monitoring
and reporting mechanism be supported and adequately
financed.
We commend the efforts of the Security Council
and its Working Group on Children and Armed
Conflict in following up on the reports from the
monitoring and reporting mechanism. We would,
however, encourage members of the Working Group
also to undertake field visits to see the reality on the
ground. We welcome the Working Group's adoption of
the toolkit on children and armed conflict. The Security
Council is encouraged to make greater use of the
toolkit.
While progress has been made on improving the
situation of children in armed conflict, the situation on
the ground is still unsatisfactory and is becoming more
complex.
We need also to address the root causes of
conflicts, as well as other political, economic and
social issues that can improve the situation of children
and other civilians in situations of conflict. At the same
time, we need to support the rehabilitation and the
reintegration of all children who have been associated
with armed forces. In that respect, there is an express
need for child protection mandates and child protection
advisers in all Department of Peacekeeping Operations
and Department of Political Affairs missions, as
appropriate.
In conclusion, we urge the Security Council to
continue to be seized with the issue of children and
armed conflict and make it one of its priority issues.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I call on the
representative of Egypt.
Mr. Edrees (Egypt) (spoke in Arabic): At the
outset, let me congratulate you, Sir, on assuming the
presidency of the Security Council, as well for
convening this interactive debate on children in armed
conflict. We are also grateful for the comprehensive
report of the Secretary-General, prepared by his
Special Representative for Children and Armed
Conflict, Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy. I should like to
thank the Special Representative for her
comprehensive presentation of the report and for her
dedicated efforts, together with the members of her
Office, to help eliminate all forms of violence against
children in armed conflict.
Egypt has been pleased to extend all necessary
support to the Special Representative for Children and
Armed Conflict since the adoption of resolution 1612
(2005), which established the Working Group to
monitor all violations perpetrated against children in
armed conflict. Egypt has regularly participated in all
open debates held by the Security Council on the
matter to join in evaluating efforts to protect children
in armed conflict and to step up international efforts to
that end. In so doing, I would like to reflect on some
elements presented in the report.
First, Egypt supports the Secretary-General's
approach in preparing the report before us and fully
understands the methodology used to interpret the
mandate of his Special Representative, especially in
monitoring all forms of violence against children in
armed conflict, including compliance in ending the
recruitment and use of children in armed conflict and
other grave violations. Such violations include the
killing and maiming of children, rape and other sexual
violence, abduction, denial of humanitarian access to
children, attacks on schools and hospitals by parties to
armed conflict, and forced detention in violation of
international law and international humanitarian law,
which also apply equally to children suffering under
foreign occupation.
It is therefore necessary for the mandate of the
Security Council's monitoring and reporting
mechanism to be extended to cover situations related to
children in occupied Palestine, as reflected in the
report, to an extent equal to its coverage of the
suffering of Lebanese children from Israel's extensive
and unprecedented use of cluster bombs during the July
2006 conflict in southern Lebanon, which took place
under the eyes of the Security Council. All violations
should be treated on an equal footing, and no child
should be abandoned in such conflicts or any other
without international protection.
Secondly, Egypt supports most of the
recommendations made in the report of the Secretary-
General, especially the recommendation that the
Security Council consider giving equal care and
attention to children affected by armed conflict in all
situations of concern listed in the two annexes and
equal weight to all categories of grave violations,
including not only the recruitment and use of children,
but also the killing and maiming of children, rape and
other grave sexual violence, abduction, attacks against
schools or hospitals, and denial of humanitarian access
to children. Egypt also supports the recommendations
aimed at making available adequate resources and
necessary funding by donors to national Governments,
the United Nations and partners to support the
rehabilitation and reintegration of children in armed
conflicts and to address immediately the grave
humanitarian, human rights and development
consequences of cluster munitions, particularly for
children. However, we also believe that the annexes
should have included a reference to Israel's violation of
its commitments as an occupying Power, as stipulated
in the Fourth Geneva Convention, particularly those
related to guaranteeing peace and security for children
in the occupied Arab territories in Palestine, Lebanon
and Syria.
Thirdly, Egypt expresses its appreciation for the
extensive efforts of the Security Council Working
Group on Children and Armed Conflict, pursuant to its
current mandate, without the suggested expansion to
include, as recommended, imposing targeted measures
and monitoring the implementation of such measures
by parties to armed conflict who commit grave
violations against children in all situations of concern.
The proposed expansion of the mandate of the Working
Group could affect the necessary balance in addressing
all aspects of situations of concern listed in the
annexes, whether or not they are included as items on
the Security Council's agenda, without concentrating
heavily on a certain aspect at the expense of others.
Finally, if it is to meet all its goals, the Office of
the Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict should coordinate with
the new Office of the Special Representative of the
Secretary-General on Violence against Children, which
was created under General Assembly resolution
62/ 141, particularly with respect to violations
stipulated in the Convention on the Rights of the Child
and the Convention on the worst forms of child labour,
in order to achieve the needed complementarity and to
fill any legal or practical gaps in dealing with all
situations of the use of children in armed conflict.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I call on the
representative of Nicaragua.
Mr. Castellen Duarte (Nicaragua) (spoke in Spanish): My delegation commends you, Sir, for
convening this important meeting on a subject of
particular importance to us all. I should also like to
thank the Secretary-General for his extensive and
detailed annual report on children and armed conflict,
contained in document S/2007/757, which reflects
progress and challenges and takes global stock of that
thorny problem in the light of international
instruments, including relevant resolutions of the
Security Council.
Children are humankind's greatest treasure. They
represent the continuity of our species, our future, and
the bridge to generations to come. According to the
Gospel of Saint Matthew, Jesus Christ, in a discussion
with his apostles at which they argued about which
among them was the most important, placed a child in
their midst and said "unless you turn and become like
children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven"
(The Holy Bible, Matthew 18:3-4).
My delegation shares the concerns referred to in
the Secretary-General's report about a series of acts,
undertaken in armed conflict throughout the world, that
violate children's human rights. Those include the
recruitment of children and internal displacement;
cross-border incursions by armed groups to recruit
children in refugee camps; the targeting of girls and
boys alike for sexual and gender-based violence,
including rape; the growing frequency of children
being detained for their alleged link to armed groups,
in contravention of international norms, concerning
which the Secretary-General cites instances in
countries on three continents; systematic and deliberate
attacks on students, teachers and schools, particularly
schools for girls, with the aim of preventing them from
studying; and the use of weapons with indiscriminate
effect, including cluster munitions, in areas with
civilian populations, with serious consequences,
particularly for children and long after conflicts have
ended.
In addition, in armed conflicts there is organ
trafficking, separation of families and the indirect
effects such as the loss of basic services, including
provision of drinking water, sanitation and health and
education services, and also increased poverty,
malnutrition and disease and the terrible psychological
impact of war on children.
Among the signs of progress, the report of the
Secretary-General points to major precedents for
ending impunity for those who commit crimes against
children, such as the confirmation of charges against
various suspects by the International Criminal Court
and the pronouncement of sentences by the Special
Court for Sierra Leone, including with regard to ending
the recruitment of children by the forces in conflict in
Cote d'Ivoire. It is also important that national
authorities, who are responsible for ending impunity,
prosecute those who violate the rights of children in
their territories. Particular attention should be given to
the situation of children in post-conflict situations.
We would like to support the recommendations of
the Secretary-General set out in his report, especially
those regarding equal weight to all categories of grave
violations against children, not just those related to
preventing the recruitment of children by armed forces
or groups; support for countries in implementing the
monitoring and reporting mechanism within the
framework of resolution 1612 (2005); the possibility of
targeted measures against parties that continue to
commit grave violations against children; and
immediate consideration of the grave humanitarian,
human rights and development consequences of cluster
munitions.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Qatar.
Mr. Al-Nasser (Qatar) (spoke in Arabic): The
State of Qatar attaches great importance to the issue of
children and armed conflict. I therefore thank you,
Mr. President, for giving me the opportunity to
participate in this important discussion today. I would
like also to thank Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy, the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict, for her important efforts
and for her illuminating briefing.
Despite the almost universal ratification of the
United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child,
millions of children in conflict-ridden areas are, on an
almost daily basis, still subject to killing, maiming,
abduction, recruitment and rape or other forms of
sexual violence. Children who are victims of the
circumstances in which they live in those areas are also
subject to another type of attack that makes them
permanently vulnerable to practices that violate their
right to survival and development. Here I refer to
attacks on their minds that violate their right to the
very education and knowledge that develops their
ability to face the conditions of life imposed on them.
Their schools are targeted, their textbooks are burned
and their teachers are killed. Such conditions put
children in an environment that invites them to carry
weapons and subjects them to repeated economic and
sexual exploitation.
Just over ten years, Ms. Graca Machel submitted
a report on the situation of children in armed conflict.
In her study, she identified major gaps in the provision
of education in conflict-ridden areas. She highlighted
the need to ensure continuity of the different phases of
education, from early childhood education to higher
education, during times of conflict, and to stand up to
the repeated targeting of educational facilities. She
highlighted also the need to attach greater importance
to secondary education, which has become non-existent
in conflicts.
Since the preparation of that report, there has
been a better understanding of education and its role as
a mechanism of protection and a means for the
prevention of conflicts. Monitoring and reporting
mechanisms established by the Security Council have
become highly capable of detecting serious violations
targeting children in conflict-torn areas and have made
concrete progress in ending the recruitment of children
in some areas.
Despite those positive developments and the
creation of multiple legal and operational mechanisms,
education in conflict areas has reached a stage of the
utmost gravity. Statistical reports indicate that 43
million children in various regions of the world
affected by armed conflict are deprived of basic
education. Such reality puts us far behind on the road
to achieving the Millennium Development Goals,
which call on States to provide a full course of primary
education by 2015. Furthermore, the reports of the
Special Representative for Children and Armed
Conflict note repeated and deliberate targeting of
schoolchildren, especially girls, and of teachers, not to
mention attacks on schools and educational buildings.
Despite international appeals that have been
launched to meet the educational needs in conflict
areas since the International Conference on Education
for All, in Dakar in 2000, education rates remain low
and in some cases non-existent in those areas. That is
why the State of Qatar has joined States and
international organizations that call for giving special
attention to the areas of education and the elimination
of illiteracy during and after conflicts.
Her Highness Sheikha Mozah Bint Nasser
Al-Misnad, Consort of His Highness Sheikh Hamad
Bin Khalifa Al-Thani, Emir of the State of Qatar, has
had a major impact at the national, regional and
international levels in drawing attention to support for
education efforts in poor countries and in countries
affected by various conflicts, especially the education
of girls and young people and providing them with
skills needed for daily life, based on the belief that
education is the best means to contain violence and
establish peace and calm.
Her Highness has contributed to the integration of
education in programmes of humanitarian relief and
emergency responses in the State of Qatar. One of the
most important of those are the Reach Out to Asia
initiative, which sought to participate in the process of
rebuilding the educational infrastructure in many
countries, including Pakistan, Lebanon and Bangladesh.
As UNESCO's Special Envoy for Basic and
Higher Education, Her Highness has expressed her
concern in several international forums about the
consequences on education that result from tragedies
that triggers the flame of violence in areas of conflict.
This situation has prompted Her Highness to launch
many educational initiatives of international
dimensions, including the establishment of the
International Fund for Higher Education in Iraq to
confront the rapid deterioration that has afflicted the
educational infrastructure in that country. Qatar has
contributed $15 million to that Fund. At the end of
February Her Highness will sponsor the UNESCO
Regional Review Conference for the Middle East and
North Africa in Doha, through which she will seek to
mobilize regional efforts in order to reach a consensus
on the issue of the protection and promotion of
education in situations of conflicts in the region, with
special focus on the plight of refugees.
Her Highness has not hesitated to convey her
message, which aims to strengthen the global
responsibility to ensure quality education in times of
conflict and emergencies. She believes that such
responsibility needs to be extended to include the
United Nations system with all its committees and
organs, including the Security Council.
At this important meeting, Her Highness calls on
the Security Council to join the international campaign
to ensure that the utmost importance is attached to the
situation of education in areas affected by armed
conflict, within the framework of the Security
Council's agenda and to devote equal attention to
ensuring the right to education during conflicts and in
post-conflict peacebuilding situations through
rehabilitation and reintegration programmes, and calls
for the full enforcement of all legal and operational
standards.
The message of Her Highness emphasizes that
quality education has cumulative benefits, which
reduce the impact of conflict on children and help
prevent future conflicts. History has proven that.
Historically, lack of equal access to education has been
one of the root causes of conflicts such as the genocide
in Rwanda and the ethnic conflicts in Kosovo. In her
message, Her Highness stresses that the Security
Council should consider the issue of the lack of
educational opportunities for children and young
people during conflicts as one of the root causes of
existing armed conflicts, and not just as a product of
them. Such children and young people will be highly
vulnerable to becoming involved in military action and
sexual slavery if they are constantly denied quality
education. They would thus become a factor for
instability and for the continuing cycle of violence that
triggers conflicts and crises. That is precisely what we
are witnessing in today's world.
We recognize the importance of the concrete
results that have been achieved through the monitoring
mechanism established by resolution 1612 (2005) and
the important role of the Working Group on Children
and Armed Conflicts. It is therefore imperative that we
further develop workplans for existing mechanisms, in
order to ensure the right to education in times of
conflict and crisis and in post-conflict peacebuilding
situations. In that regard, we must take into account
fundamental issues, including, first, prevention, by all
means necessary, of the repeated and deliberate
targeting of schoolchildren and teachers, schools and
other educational institutions, by considering them to
be protected against any and all attacks aimed at
undermining and paralysing education; secondly,
putting an end to impunity for perpetrators of such
crimes against education and learning; thirdly,
including programmes to support the continuity of
education in emergency humanitarian responses in time
of conflict; fourthly, attaching great importance to the
education sector during the stabilization, peacebuilding
and reconstruction phases in such countries; fifthly,
providing continuous support once the emergency is
over; and finally, ensuring that those important aspects
are a strategic priority in the programme of work of the
Security Council and its various committees and other
subsidiary bodies.
We must not lose sight of the fact that children
are the most precious resource for building peaceful
communities. The Government of Qatar, with the
guidance and support of Her Highness Sheikha Mozah
bint Nasser Al-Misnad, will seek to cooperate with
international partners and international
non-governmental organizations for the purpose of
ensuring the right to education in conflict areas. The
Security Council must also renew its commitment to
international efforts for the protection and promotion
of the right of children to education, in order to
promote international peace and security.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I give the
floor to the representative of Germany.
Mr. Ney (Germany): Germany fully aligns itself
with the statement delivered this morning by the
representative of Slovenia on behalf of the European
Union.
I would like to add my voice to those who have
expressed their appreciation to the presidency for
including the important item of children and armed
conflict on the agenda of the Security Council. Our
particular thanks go to the Secretary-General for his
most recent insightful reports on this issue, to the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict for her dedicated work in
taking this agenda forward; and to France for its
ongoing commitment in dealing with this issue as
Chair of the Security Council Working Group on
Children and Armed Conflicts.
The German Government attaches great
importance to the promotion and protection of the
rights of children, in particular to the situation of
children affected by armed conflict. We welcome the
progress made on this issue. At the same time, we are
mindful of the fact that much more remains to be done.
An estimated 300,000 child soldiers continue to
exist worldwide, and tens of thousands of children are
still killed, maimed, raped or abducted from their
homes as a result of unlawful recruiting practices every
year. Our work is far from over.
The Security Council has come a long way in
dealing with this issue since it was first put on the
Council's agenda in 1998. The adoption of resolution
1612 (2005) is rightfully regarded as a milestone in
creating an effective international monitoring and
reporting mechanism for children and armed conflict.
The first signs of progress are evident. Some
parties to conflicts listed in the annexes of United
Nations reports have shown a greater consideration of
this subject matter, and some have adopted action plans
commensurate with the United Nations
recommendation to end the use of child soldiers and
illegal recruiting practices. Others have committed
themselves to a more regular dialogue with the United
Nations to create preconditions for their de-listing from
the United Nations list of perpetrators.
Under the Security Council's monitoring and
reporting mechanism, ample information and evidence
of grave violations has been collected in six major
categories of violations against children, while
focusing on the illegal recruiting and use of children as
child soldiers. We fully agree with that focus.
However, there are three points I would like to
highlight in particular.
First, to adequately address all aspects related to
violations against children in armed conflict, we must
not shy away from including new perspectives in the
scope of our dealing with these issues. Sexual violence
is one such issue that deserves our undivided attention.
Perpetrators should be included in the annexes to the
reports of the Secretary-General.
Secondly, we must also speak a clear language
with conflict parties that keep appearing on the lists of
perpetrators or with parties that have chosen to ignore
persistent calls to cease their illegal practices with
regard to children in armed conflict. In cases where
national systems fail to provide adequate protection for
children in armed conflict, the Security Council should
act and refer such violations to the International
Criminal Court for further investigation and possible
prosecution.
Thirdly, another important area for enhanced
attention by the Security Council is the mainstreaming
of the issue of children and armed conflict in United
Nations peacekeeping and political missions, for
instance through child protection advisers and
enhanced cooperation with relevant United Nations
actors such as UNICEF, the United Nations
Development Programme, the Office of the United
Nations High Commissioner for Refugees and the
Department of Peacekeeping Operations. The report of
the Secretary-General, for instance, clearly shows that
there is an interrelation between the issues of refugees,
internally displaced persons and armed conflict, and
the likelihood of children becoming involved as
soldiers in volatile situations in the aftermath of armed
conflict. Here too, the United Nations faces challenges
that are yet to be mastered.
Germany fully supports the analysis and
recommendations outlined in the report of the
Secretary-General (S/2007/757). We remain firmly
committed to joining hands with all those striving to
end the use of child soldiers and the plight of all
children affected by armed conflict. In the context of
conflict prevention and post-conflict rehabilitation, the
German Government already supports measures
countering the recruitment of child soldiers, their
reintegration into civilian life, for example in the
Sudan and Nepal, and measures addressing all aspects
related to violations against children and women in
armed conflicts. We look forward to further
consideration of these issues within the Security
Council and with like-minded partners beyond.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Myanmar.
Mr. Swe (Myanmar): I wish to commend you,
Mr. President, for the initiative in holding an open
debate on the issue of children and armed conflict, an
issue that is given high importance by my Government.
I wish also to thank you for the opportunity to speak in
the debate.
Myanmar has gone through more than four
decades of insurgency and has recently emerged from a
situation of armed conflict with the return to the legal
fold of 17 major insurgent groups. Only a few fringe
insurgent groups such as the Karen National Union
(KNU), Karenni National Progressive Party and Shan
State Army-South still continue to take up arms against
the Government and engage in terrorist activities
against the population. Except for counter-insurgency
operations against these insurgent groups, major
military campaigns are no longer conducted in my
country. The Government is able to bring about peace
and security in almost all corners of Myanmar.
The Secretary-General's report (S/2007/757)
reflected some, but not all, of the important activities
undertaken by the Government of Myanmar to prevent
the recruitment of child soldiers. In spite of the
commitment made by the Government at the highest
level that no child under 18 years will be recruited into
the military, and despite the concrete steps taken by my
Government - some of which are reflected in the
Secretary-General's reports S/2007/666 and
S/2007/757 - we are greatly disappointed that the
Myanmar national army, Tatmadaw Kyi, is still listed
in Annex 1 of the Secretary-General's latest report. I
strongly urge that Tatmadaw Kyi be taken off of the
list.
Let me again reiterate that Myanmar's military is
an all-volunteer army and that, under the defence
services act and relevant regulations, the minimum age
for recruitment is 18 years old. In order to prevent
under-age children who lie about their age from getting
into the military, and in order to institute stringent
scrutiny and educate the public, the Government in
2004 set up a high-level committee to prevent
recruitment of under-age children. The committee is
headed by the Secretary One of the State Peace and
Development Council, who is also the Adjutant-
General of the Armed Forces. The Government is
implementing stringent scrutiny at the recruitment
stage, at the training stage and even after the training
period.
As a result of strict scrutiny, between February
2007 and January 2008 some 962 under-age persons
were rejected during the recruitment stage. Between
2004 and January 2008, 172 people who had slipped
through the initial scrutiny were discharged from the
military. Between 2002 and January 2008, disciplinary
action was taken against 44 military personnel who
failed to strictly abide by the recruitment criteria.
We are also closely cooperating with the United
Nations country team in Myanmar, including UNICEF.
We have drawn up a plan of action and have regularly
provided updates to the United Nations country team
regarding the activities of the committee, including
detailed information on under-age children who were
discharged, and disciplinary action was taken against
military recruiters who contravened regulations.
As part of the cooperation with the United
Nations, since 2004 we have invited the United
Nations resident coordinator and the UNICEF
representative to visit the recruitment centres, training
facilities and military establishments. We have also
invited the Deputy Executive Director of UNICEF and,
more recently, the Special Representative of the
Secretary-General to Myanmar. During the Special
Representative's visit, we agreed to cooperate in the
establishment of a monitoring and reporting
mechanism within the framework of Security Council
resolution 1612 (2005), and we appointed the Director-
General of the Ministry of Social Welfare as the focal
point. Those developments were reflected in the
aforementioned reports of the Secretary-General. Most
recently, at the suggestion of the Special
Representative, the Director-General of International
Organizations in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs was
nominated as an additional focal point for
implementing the resolution 1612 (2005).
Education is an important element in addressing
the issue of child soldiers. The end of the conflict in
former insurgency areas has enabled the Government
to build hundreds of schools in those areas.
Additionally, in order to educate military personnel,
police personnel, staff members of relevant ministries
and the general public, the Government, actively
assisted by the UNICEF, has conducted a number of
seminars and workshops. In November and December
2007 4 workshops and seminars were held, in which
both World Vision and Save the Children took active
part. They were followed by a number of multiplier
courses in various states and divisions. Public
awareness campaigns have been intensified to educate
the general public.
We see some improvement in the report of the
Secretary-General. We noted that it now includes the
situation of children in Lebanon, Iraq and Afghanistan.
But for some inexplicable reason the groups that are
clearly mentioned in the body of the report for
recruiting child soldiers and wounding children in
those situations were not listed in the annexes. We
would strongly urge objectivity and fairness in treating
all situations that affect children in armed conflict.
The Secretary-General's report mentioned that
United Nations country teams are primary sources of
information for the report and that the information in
the report is gathered, vetted and verified for accuracy.
This certainly is not the case with regard to allegations
concerning Tatmadaw Kyi and the insurgent groups
that have returned to the legal fold. In contrast, the
remaining insurgent groups are given undue favourable
treatment.
We are greatly disturbed that in the annex to the
report Tatmadaw Kyi is falsely described. I quote,
"This party has also been responsible for the killing
and maiming and denial of humanitarian access to
children in the reporting period." This is added despite
the admission in the report that "these reports,
however, cannot be confirmed". In view of this, I
would like to urge that this reference to Tatmadaw Kyi
be deleted.
The issue of protection of children in general and
children in armed conflict in particular is too important
to be politicized. It is in this spirit that I find
objectionable the unfounded allegations made earlier in
the morning, some of which have even found their way
into the report. These allegations have crept into the
report because of lack of cooperation with the Member
Government. To resolve the issue of children and
armed conflict, cooperation with the Government is
most crucial. In fact, resolution 1612 (2005) clearly
stipulated that the monitoring and reporting
mechanisms must operate with the participation of and
in cooperation with the national Government. It also
stipulates that any dialogue with non-State armed
groups must be conducted in the context of peace
processes where they exist and in the cooperation
framework between the United Nations and the
concerned Government.
That has not been the case with regard to
Myanmar. Cooperation needs transparency. On the
ground, we have a close working relationship with the
United Nations country team. In fact, to be transparent,
the United Nations country team has volunteered to
share its report. We are disturbed that, owing to the
objection by the Office of the Special Representative,
the United Nations country team was unable to do so.
Let me stress that it is only through cooperation and
partnership and acting transparently that we can
address the issue of children and armed conflict.
In this spirit, my delegation will continue to
cooperate with the Security Council Working Group.
Here, I wish to express our support for the View
expressed earlier that more transparency and
improvement in the Group's working methods would
certainly enhance its effectiveness.
Let me close by once again reiterating our
commitments made at the highest level that no one
under 18 years of age will be recruited into the
Myanmar armed forces. I wish also to inform the
Council that the six armed groups that have come back
to the legal fold - the Democratic Karen Buddhist
Army, Kachin Independence Army, Karenni National
People's Liberation Front, Myanmar National
Democratic Alliance Army, Karen National Union-
Karen National Liberation Army Peace Council and the
United Wa State Army - have committed themselves
and openly declared that they will not recruit child
soldiers.
The Government of Myanmar will continue its
cooperation with the Special Representative of the
Secretary-General, Ms. Coomaraswamy, whose
integrity and fairness we hold in high esteem. We will
intensify our cooperation with the United Nations
country team in general and UNICEF in particular.
Together we will work for the protection and
promotion of children.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Colombia.
Mr. Montoya (Colombia) (spoke in Spanish):
First, allow me to congratulate you, Sir, and the
delegation of Panama for the excellent work in the
presidency of the Council during the month of
February. My delegation appreciates the initiative
taken in convening this open debate. My delegation
thanks, and takes note of the informative briefings by,
the Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict and the Executive
Director of UNICEF. I would also like to thank the
Secretary-General for his seventh report to the Council
on this topic (S/2007/757).
Parallel to the adoption and implementation of
Security Council resolution 1612 (2005), in Colombia
there has been a process of strengthening institutions,
underlining the unequivocal commitment of my
country to the welfare of children. Since 1991
Colombia has been a State party to the Convention on
the Rights of the Child. In 2005, we became a State
party to the Optional Protocol to the Convention.
The legal framework in Colombia prohibits the
recruitment of children under the age of 18.
Furthermore, national legislation defines minors who
are used by illegal armed groups as victims. One of the
main lines of action of the Colombian State concerns
the prevention of recruitment by those groups.
The Colombian Institute of Family Welfare has
developed a programme to prevent recruitment, which
operates, inter alia, through investment in areas of risk,
strengthening institutional networks, care of children,
food security promotion, prevention of family violence
and through education, health, and income generation
tools.
Since 2004, the central command of the military
forces has been conducting the campaign "Better
prevention than demobilization". Through its
permanent directive of May 2005, the highest ranks in
the military were ordered to develop activities for
preventing recruitment by illegal armed groups. In
addition, the Ministry of Defence issued in March 2007
a directive in which it prohibits all members of the
armed forces to use children for intelligence purposes.
The report of the Secretary-General describes the
positive results achieved through the demobilization
process in Colombia. More than 46,000 persons who
belonged to illegal armed groups have been
demobilized. Of the 11 self-defence groups listed in
annex II to the report of the Secretary-General
submitted in February 2005 (S/2005/72), only two
appear in the seventh report, and today they are
practically dismantled. With the disappearance of the
self-defence armed structures, the danger of forced
recruitment by them has also ceased.
On 3 December 2007, the Government created
the intersectorial commission for the prevention of
recruitment and use of children, adolescents and youth
by illegal armed groups. One of the main
responsibilities of this commission will be to make
recommendations for updating the national policy
framework to reinforce the prevention of recruitment
and use of children by those groups. The composition
of the commission, which is headed by the Vice-
President of the Republic and is composed by various
State Ministers and other high-level officials,
guarantees a comprehensive perspective of the
different aspects of this issue.
The report of the Secretary-General includes, in
paragraph 116, a reference to four criminal groups
devoted to drug trafficking as new organized illegal
armed groups. It is necessary to emphasize that since
these are criminal organizations devoted to drug-
trafficking, they are being combated as such by the
competent authorities in Colombia; thus they can only
be subject to State action and the weight of the law in
order to dismantle their structures and take them before
the justice system.
On those and other topics concerning Colombia
contained in the seventh report, the Government has
submitted and will continue to submit the pertinent
clarification to the Office of the Special
Representative, as well as to other relevant actors.
Let me now refer to some general aspects of the
report. The reasons for which the Security Council
gave priority to situations that are on its agenda are
still valid. In that regard, the Council should continue
to concentrate that priority on the situations that are in
annex I of the Secretary-General's report and maintain
a different treatment for the situations included in
annex II.
Also, the Council should continue to give
different weight and higher precedence to the essential
element that gave origin to the mechanism, that is, the
problem of the recruitment and use of children. It is
equally important that, concerning targeted measures,
the Council rigorously observe Chapter VII of the
United Nations Charter.
Colombia reiterates the importance of taking into
account the central role of national Governments in the
protection of and effective assistance to children. Any
action by the United Nations should be carried out in
consultation and coordination with the respective
Governments.
Lastly, Colombia reaffirms its will to continue
working with the United Nations system in
strengthening existing national measures and
institutions for the protection and promotion of the
rights of children.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Liechtenstein.
Mr. Frommelt (Liechtenstein): We thank the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General on
Children and Armed Conflict, Ms. Coomaraswamy, and
her Office for their dedication to advancing the work of
the United Nations on this topic. The report
(S/2007/757) makes again for disturbing reading. We
are alarmed by the escalating number of systematic and
deliberate attacks on schools with weapons having
indiscriminate effects such as cluster munitions, as
well as by evidence suggesting that camps for
internally displaced persons are one of the prime
recruiting grounds for child soldiers.
Security Council resolution 1612 (2005)
established a monitoring and reporting mechanism for
serious violations of the rights of the child at the field
level, as well as a Working Group on Children and
Armed Conflict here in New York. As this decision has
proven to have a positive effect on the ground, we
believe it is important to keep the momentum to further
develop and enhance tools aimed at improving the
safety and security of children affected by armed
conflicts.
In accordance with resolution 1612 (2005), the
monitoring and reporting mechanism provides reliable
information on situations listed in annexes I and II of
the report, including the recruitment and use of child
soldiers, killing and maiming of children, rape and
other grave sexual violence against children, illicit
exploitation of natural resources, abduction of children
and the denial of humanitarian access. However, only
one out of these six grave violations - the recruitment
and use of child soldiers - currently triggers the
inclusion of countries in annex I of the report. We
believe that the role of the monitoring and reporting
mechanism could be significantly enhanced if other
violations were accorded the same effect and if all
types of violations were given equal weight.
It is, in fact, difficult to understand how
differential treatment of grave violations of children's
rights in various conflicts can be compatible with the
universality of human rights and the principles of
international humanitarian law. Political considerations
must not override the fundamental rules of protection
for the most vulnerable members of society. To further
strengthen the monitoring and reporting mechanism,
we welcome the information provided by
non-governmental organizations and call for the
inclusion of a child protection adviser in the mandate
of all future peacekeeping missions and, where
appropriate, political missions.
Any measures taken by the Working Group in
response to grave violations of the rights of the child
have to be complemented by effective enforcement. An
option in this regard is the expansion of the Working
Group's mandate to recommending targeted measures,
including arms embargos, bans on military assistance
and the imposition of travel restrictions on individuals.
Moreover, we support the recommendation in the
Secretary-General's report that the Security Council
refer violations of the rights of the child that fall within
the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court to
that Court for investigation and prosecution.
Liechtenstein has been actively involved in the
development of the United Nations mechanism to
address the plight of children affected by armed
conflict since its inception. As a member of the Group
of Friends of children affected by armed conflict, we
will continue to do so, and we hope that this open
debate will lead to the expansion of the criteria for the
inclusion of situations in annex I of the reports of the
Secretary-General, thereby improving the situation of
children in armed conflicts worldwide.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Bangladesh.
Mr. Islam (Bangladesh): I am delivering this
statement on behalf of my Ambassador, who has been
held up by a previously scheduled pressing
engagement.
The Security Council returns once more to the
important issue of children and armed conflict. The
delegation of Bangladesh welcomes this opportunity to
participate in the debate. I thank the Secretary-General
for his comprehensive and analytical report on children
and armed conflict (S/2007/757). We agree with his
action-oriented recommendations and urge their
appropriate implementation.
We commend the United Nations for its system-
wide response to the needs of war-affected children.
The Special Representative of the Secretary-General,
Ms. Coomaraswamy, deserves our particular praise for
her dedicated efforts in this regard.
We are encouraged to see that the measures taken
by the Security Council Working Group on Children
and Armed Conflict have had some positive impact in
ameliorating the condition of children affected by
armed conflict around the globe. The monitoring and
reporting mechanism of the Council is also
praiseworthy. In this context, we appreciate the
compliance by certain countries and parties to conflicts
with the recommendations of the Working Group, and
we urge others to follow suit. However, ensuring
compliance by non-State actors and armed groups
continues to be a big challenge; we must try and
address it in a more resolute manner.
We support the idea of using child protection
advisers to provide prompt advocacy and response for
the protection of children in order to mainstream child
protection in United Nations peacekeeping operations.
We call upon relevant parties to conflicts to develop
and implement concrete, time-bound action plans, in
close collaboration with United Nations peacekeeping
operations, in order to halt and prevent violations and
abuses against children and their recruitment and use in
armed conflict.
It is encouraging to note that, as indicated in the
Secretary-General's report, strengthening the United
Nations institutional framework, the strict monitoring
and enforcement mechanism and the code of conduct
have resulted in marked progress in preventing and
reducing incidents of sexual exploitation and abuse of
children by peacekeepers and other United Nations
personnel. We believe that other ongoing efforts in this
regard, such as strengthening the accountability of
uniformed contingent personnel and integrating victim
support and assistance, particularly for children, in the
relevant programmes, will further improve the
situation.
The vulnerable situation of children in post-
conflict societies needs special attention. Long after
the guns have fallen silent, children remain traumatized
and permanently scarred by the brutality of war. For
peace to be sustained, these children must be more
effectively rehabilitated and reintegrated into their
communities. The Peacebuilding Commission should
have this issue permanently on its agenda while
working in any country-specific configuration.
Since recruitment of children by armed groups is
closely linked with internal displacement and refugee
issues, there should be cross-regional initiatives and
cooperation among neighbouring States, in addition to
United Nations efforts, to address the problem in a
holistic manner. We are also concerned at the
increasing number of children in detention for their
alleged association with armed groups. We believe that
those children should be given the protections of law
admissible under juvenile justice systems.
It is well documented that children are the ones
who suffer the most under unregulated sanction
regimes. The Council has a duty to ensure that
sanctions do not affect the innocent. Issues of children
under foreign occupation also need to be appropriately
addressed.
There is no doubt that children are the most
hapless victims of conflict. Violence is often ingrained
in their psyche and often becomes the only solution
known to them in seeking redress. The root causes of
conflict should therefore be addressed in their proper
perspective. To prevent today's victims from becoming
tomorrow's perpetrators, the values of a culture of
peace must be inculcated in every child. United Nations
efforts should promote a culture of peace through peace
education programmes and other non-violent
approaches to conflict prevention and resolution.
Denied the protection of traditional institutions
like the family, stripped of the treasure and innocence
of childhood and faced with societal breakdown and
the erosion of values and of the rule of law, children
affected by armed conflict suffer lasting adverse
consequences for their development. Girl children are
particularly vulnerable to sexual exploitation and
violence. We urge the Security Council to mobilize a
more coordinated, committed and strengthened
international response to further advance the agenda in
order to better protect our children from war. As a State
party to the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the
Rights of the Child on the Involvement of Children in
Armed Conflict, Bangladesh remains committed to our
collective responsibility to ensure a better life for our
children - free from poverty, exploitation and
violence.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Benin.
Mr. Ehouzou (Benin) (spoke in French):
Mr. President, I congratulate Panama, your country,
most warmly. It has been a very long day, and it has
not yet come to an end. But it has been worthwhile
because we are dealing with the cause of children, who
are the future of our planet.
Three years ago, in February 2005, my country,
then the President of the Security Council, organized a
similar public debate (see S/PV.5129) to launch the
negotiations that resulted in the adoption of resolution
1612 (2005). For today's debate, I welcome the
important contributions of the French Minister for
Foreign Affairs, Mr. Bernard Kouchner; the Minister
for Development Cooperation of Belgium, Mr. Charles
Michel; and the Under-Secretary of State for Foreign
Affairs of Italy, Mr. Vittorio Craxi. Their presence lent
additional stature to this meeting of the Security
Council devoted to children.
I would also like to express the Beninese
Government's great appreciation to the Secretary-
General and to his Special Representative, Under-
Secretary-General Radhika Coomaraswamy, for the
impressive annual report submitted on children and
armed conflict (S/2007/757). The report is as
exhaustive as it is informative about the scale of
violations of which children are victim, caught as they
are in a vicious spiral of armed conflict in countries
throughout the world.
We have also been able to appreciate, through the
facts and analysis set out in the report, the
praiseworthy efforts of the United Nations system, in
particular by UNICEF, represented here today by its
Executive Director, Ms. Ann Veneman, to tackle
resolutely the violations of the rights of children in
conflict situations and to increase pressure on their
perpetrators in order to force them to halt these
violations.
We welcome in particular the effective,
methodical and persevering consideration of the issue
by the Security Council Working Group set up within
the context of resolution 1612 (2005). It provides the
Security Council with determined leadership and it
confirms the relevance of the reasons that led to its
establishment.
We also welcome the mobilization of civil
society, which makes it possible to strengthen
monitoring of the activities of national armed forces
and of non-State armed groups and of their practices
towards children in conflict situations. We have also
noted the ongoing mobilization of the special task
forces on monitoring and reporting, which strive to
keep the spotlight on violations of children's rights in
countries in conflict situations.
My delegation gathers from this report that the
Security Council has not yet fully reflected in its
actions the need to pay equal attention to the issue of
children and armed conflict, regardless of whether the
countries concerned are on its agenda. That is the only
explanation that my delegation can find for the fact
that the Working Group and the Special Representative
of the Secretary-General lack sufficient resources to
follow up on situations in countries not on the
Council's agenda.
In that regard, the seriousness of the facts brought
out in the report requires not only that appropriate
budgetary measures be taken to put an end to a
situation that penalizes children in countries not on the
agenda, but also that the Security Council's Working
Group be fully mandated so that it can fully carry out
its functions related to information received from the
monitoring and reporting mechanism concerning
children and armed conflict.
Our second observation after considering this
report is that the Security Council has not
demonstrated all the firmness necessary to make
inveterate violators of children's rights in countries in
armed conflict situations comply with international
norms. In that regard, my delegation is of the view that
effective measures must be taken against parties that
do not meet their obligations under resolutions 1539
(2004) and 1612 (2005), particularly with regard to the
adoption of action plans to cease violations of
children's rights in all their aspects.
The international justice system, in particular the
International Criminal Court, must also become more
active than it has been in the past, by pursuing those
who are responsible for the recruitment and use of
children in armed conflicts or who commit
reprehensible acts against them, in contravention of
international law and international humanitarian law.
Here, I must welcome the cooperation that has made it
possible to transfer to The Hague those warlords from
the Democratic Republic of the Congo sought by the
Court. In that regard, my delegation - which, since
2005, has raised the issue of raising the level of
qualifications for the recruitment and use of child
soldiers - is pleased to note that one of the persons
transferred is also accused of crimes against humanity,
not only of war crimes. Unquestionably, the
maltreatment of child soldiers dehumanizes them,
making them war machines or simply what we might
call cheap cannon fodder. That is very sad and is
nothing less than a crime against humanity. Those
responsible must be held accountable to the
international community.
Our third observation is that the Security
Council's actions have been aimed much more at
demobilizing children involved in armed groups. The
fundamental issue of their rehabilitation and
reintegration into their communities does not seem to
have received the attention required. That situation
could be a cause of the resurgence of conflicts in the
countries concerned. The international community
must find the means to ensure appropriate supervision
of children freed by armed groups.
The international community must redouble its
efforts to put an end to the use of rape as a weapon of
war. In that regard, my delegation welcomes the
adoption of resolution 62/134, on eliminating rape and
other forms of sexual violence in all their
manifestations, including in conflict and related
situations, adopted by the General Assembly in
December 2007.
Our fourth observation is that the United Nations
must redouble its efforts to halt once and for all, at the
level of its personnel, the ignominy of the sexual
exploitation of children in the context of peacekeeping
operations. The troop-contributing countries must fully
shoulder their responsibility by taking the measures
required to ensure the prevention of sexual crimes,
which must be vigorously prosecuted. At the same
time, international and governmental forces must
ensure strict respect for their rules of engagement in
order to avoid the abuses that have claimed countless
victims among the children and civilian populations
whom they are supposed to protect.
Finally, my delegation fully associates itself with
the recommendations made by the Secretary-General in
his report and pleads for their diligent implementation
for the great benefit of children, on whom depends the
future of countries in conflict situations, which must
return as soon as possible to the path of peace.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now call on
the representative of Cote d'Ivoire.
Mr. Bailly (Cote d'Ivoire) (spoke in French): I
should like at the outset to congratulate you, Sir, on
your assumption of the presidency of the Security
Council for the month of February.
The Ivorian delegation - which I have the
honour to lead in the absence of His Excellency
Mr. Ilahiri Djedje, Permanent Representative of Cote
d'Ivoire to the United Nations, who is on mission in
the context of the implementation of the Ouagadougou
Political Agreement - is pleased to make its modest
contribution to today's open debate on children and
armed conflict.
Instability and internal conflicts lead to
uncontrolled population movements. Children, that
important sector of the vulnerable population in our
countries, must thus fend for themselves, sometimes
without parents and teachers, and thus without
education and health care. Hence, we have witnessed
the phenomenon of child soldiers, whether as a result
of their own will, for the simple reason of survival, or
as a result of recruitment. With regard to the latter
case, the report of the Secretary-General (S/2007/757)
states that the recruitment of children and internal
displacement are closely linked.
Here, I should like, on behalf of my delegation
and on my own account, to congratulate Secretary-
General Ban Ki-moon on his reading of the Ivorian
crisis. I should also like to welcome the positive
approach of the Security Council and the cooperation
that it has shown in formulating resolutions on C6te
d'Ivoire - particularly the most recent resolution,
1795 (2008), to mention just one.
It should also be noted that, in countries beset by
armed conflict, many children and young people suffer
not only from war-related violence, but also from the
devastating effects of HIV/AIDS. That is why my
delegation commends UNICEF's actions throughout
the country. Congratulations go also to United Nations
agencies, including the United Nations Operation in
Cote d'Ivoire, the United Nations Development
Programme, the World Food Programme, the Office of
the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees
and the World Health Organization for all their
activities on the ground to make their contributions in
the area of children's protection.
A country such as ours, which makes peace its
second religion, nearly toppled in the horror of an
endless war. Very fortunately, the Ivorian parties
understood the trap of armed conflict and made a firm
commitment to end that situation in order to devote
themselves to the real battle - combating poverty and
underdevelopment - by becoming involved in the
process of achieving the Millennium Development
Goals.
Faced with the deteriorating situation of the past
five years, His Excellency Mr. Laurent Gbagbo, the
Ivorian head of State, took the welcome initiative of
engaging in direct dialogue with the former rebels,
which led to the Ouagadougou Agreement, which was
endorsed by the Economic Community of West African
States, the African Union and the Security Council.
Thanks to the implementation of the Agreement and of
the recommendations of the Security Council, everyone
in Cote d'Ivoire is pleased to see that no Ivorian parties
are now listed in the annexes to the report of the
Secretary-General. No substantiated evidence of the
active recruitment or use of children by armed groups
has been found.
My Government has thus been recognized for all
its actions to protect children, and it intends, more than
ever before, to redouble its efforts in this sphere -
members of the Council may be certain of that. Here,
my delegation considers that, as the Secretary-General
suggests in his report, task forces on monitoring and
reporting should continue their work, supported by a
verification commission, in order to ensure that this
trend continues.
On Tuesday, 5 February 2008, my delegation took
note with interest of the draft conclusions adopted by
the Security Council Working Group on Children and
Armed Conflict. These clearly reflect the qualitative
developments in the political situation in Cote d'Ivoire.
We welcome the close cooperation in which we were
involved, and we encourage the Working Group to
continue its noble mission on situations around the
world that continue to be matters of concern.
My delegation is also pleased that, following the
visit to our country by the Special Representative of
the Secretary-General for Children and Armed
Conflict, Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy, C6te d'Ivoire
is no longer numbered among the countries in which
child soldiers are to be found. Ms. Coomaraswamy
deserves my delegation's praise for her appropriate and
convincing working methods.
The Ivorian Government is aware that the future
of the nation depends on the quality of its young people
and has taken a number of concrete measures, including
the following. In November 2005, the National Armed
Forces of Cote d'Ivoire formulated an action plan to put
an end to the phenomenon of the child soldiers who had
fought at their side. Today, the integration of young
people falls within the "reintegration" element of the
disarmament, demobilization and reintegration (DDR)
programme being implemented under the Ouagadougou
Agreement. The national DDR programme, which is
being supervised by the United Nations Development
Programme (UNDP) and UNICEF, provides for a
reintegration plan adapted to the needs of young
victims of our country's armed conflict. The Civic
Service envisioned in the Ouagadougou Agreement will
welcome all young people who have become familiar
with the handling of weapons in war. In August 2007,
the President of the Republic signed a decree on the
organization and functioning of the Civic Service.
For those reasons, my delegation wishes again to
request the international community to help Cote
d'Ivoire to combat impunity throughout our territory.
We are aware that the Ivorian judicial administration
has not covered the whole of our national territory
since the beginning of the crisis, on 19 September
2002. We all consider that since the courts, the police
and the gendarmerie have not been redeployed in areas
formerly occupied by the Forces Nouvelles, it would
not be appropriate to speak of impunity or law and
order. Likewise, the Ivorian Government still expects
an exemption from the United Nations regarding the
non-lethal weapons that are essential for equipping our
law enforcement agencies.
Cote d'Ivoire is eager for peace and respects
human rights in general and the rights of the child in
particular. With the on-the-ground experience we have
gained in five years of crisis management, our country
is at the disposal of the international community to
share that extraordinary experience, especially with
countries still in situations of armed conflict.
The Ivorian parties - led by His Excellency
President Laurent Gbagbo and Prime Minister
Guillaume Soro, and under the watchful eye of His
Excellency President Blaise Compaore of Burkina
Faso, to whom we express our gratitude - are striving
to bring the country out of crisis, through the
organization of credible, transparent elections. This is
in the interest not only of our country, but also of the
entire West Africa sub-region. To that end, the Ivorian
Government looks to the United Nations for greater
political, material and financial support to help it
redeploy the general administration and the judicial
administration, including the police and the
gendarmerie, in the areas formerly occupied by the
Forces Nouvelles.
In conclusion, my delegation urgently appeals to
the United Nations, and in particular to the Security
Council, to put a permanent end to the phenomenon of
child soldiers, which poses a threat to international
peace and security, either through prevention or by
effectively addressing crises that arise anywhere in the
world.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I now give the
floor to the representative of Nigeria.
Mr. Akindele (Nigeria): The delegation of
Nigeria congratulates you, Sir, on your assumption of
the presidency of the Security Council, confident that
your sterling qualities will stand you in very good stead
as you steer the Council in its onerous tasks and bring
about a fruitful outcome during the month of February.
We would like also to express our most sincere
gratitude to the Secretary-General for his very
comprehensive and detailed report on the situation of
children affected by armed conflict (S/2007/757),
including the content and the tenor of its annexes I and
II. We also applaud the work of the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for Children
and Armed Conflict and the Executive Director of
UNICEF, as well as that of all agencies involved in this
sphere of activity.
My delegation notes the key elements of the
report, relating, inter alia, to the fact that some
progress has been made in the implementation of the
monitoring and reporting mechanism; the development
and implementation of action plans; the mainstreaming
of the protection of children in United Nations
peacekeeping operations; compliance with regard to
ending the recruitment and exploitation of children;
rape and other sexual violence; abductions; denial of
humanitarian assistance and access to children; and
absence of respect for the rule of law by some parties
to armed conflict.
My delegation is indeed delighted to note that
some modicum of progress and some positive
developments have been recorded during the reporting
period, in that, in some instances, no new cases of
recruitment of children have occurred, and in that some
measures have been taken to effect the release of
children from the grip of certain armed forces for
rehabilitation. Other positive measures include
disarmament, demobilization and reintegration
programmes for children, as well as investigations into
cases of abuse of the rights of children.
Nevertheless, we observe that there is a lot of
work still to be done, as violations of the rights of
children caught up in situations of armed conflict and
violations of humanitarian law have not abated. In this
connection, my delegation is of the view that it
behoves the international community not to rest on its
oars, but rather to rededicate itself to a greater
commitment to ending impunity for those who abuse
the rights of children. Indeed, is it not high time that
the international community tackled the question of the
abuse of the rights of children from the viewpoint of
prevention, rather than tackling its effects? A well
articulated conflict prevention mechanism or
framework would not only spare the international
community the tedium of being called upon, time and
again, to attend to festering conflicts - which continue
to occur in situations of poverty, marginalization,
political and economic exclusion, impunity,
lawlessness, injustice, et cetera - but could indeed
pave the way to finding a lasting solution to conflict.
My delegation therefore believes that effective
dialogue, poverty alleviation measures, technical
assistance, political and economic inclusion and
measures to tackle the root causes of conflict should go
pari passu with the relevant recommendations
contained in the Secretary-General's report.
With regard to conflict management, we urge that
good attention be paid to the illicit spread of small
arms and light weapons, which tend to fuel conflicts,
especially in developing countries. The case of West
Africa is a case in point, and that is why the Economic
Community of West African States (ECOWAS) found it
expedient to sign the Convention on Small Arms and
Light Weapons on 14 June 2004, in Abuja.
My delegation wholeheartedly endorses the
recommendations of the Secretary-General on the role
of the International Criminal Court with regard to
violations of the rights of children that fall within its
purview and jurisdiction.
Nigeria considers the promotion and protection of
the rights of children as a top priority and has indeed
made remarkable progress in the domestication of the
Convention on the Rights of the Child. Indeed, as of
today, no fewer than 17 states of the Federation have
adopted the Nigerian Child Rights Act, which came
into force in 2003. Nigeria's commitment is
unshakeable with regard to the full implementation of
all the legal instruments relating to the rights of the
child. This, of course, includes the recent declaration
of the General Assembly's Commemorative High-level
Plenary Meeting Devoted to the Follow-up to the
Outcome of the Special Session on Children (General Assembly resolution 62/88).
Finally, in order to further strengthen the modest
but notable achievements made in protection of
children, particularly those in armed conflict, and to
move towards the goal of ending impunity and
bringing violators of children's rights to justice, we
urge States that are yet to do so to ratify and implement
the various conventions and protocols that guarantee
the safety, protection, promotion and continued
espousal of the rights of children in all situations,
particularly in armed conflict.
In the same vein, we urge all the relevant
agencies and stakeholders to pay the necessary
attention to rehabilitation, technical assistance,
capacity-building, reintegration programmes and other
post-conflict challenges, with the goal of ensuring
proper development of children in peace, love and
progress, away from the destructive situations of
conflict. We believe that the world will be a better
place by paying serious and committed attention to this
clarion call.
The President (spoke in Spanish): I give the
floor next to the representative of Rwanda.
Mr. Nsengimana (Rwanda) (spoke in French):
My delegation congratulates you, Mr. President, on
your country's assumption of the presidency of the
Security Council for the month of February. We thank
you for having scheduled this debate on children and
armed conflict. My delegation also welcomes the
participation of individuals who travelled to this
meeting, that is, His Excellency Mr. Samuel Lewis-
Navarro, Vice-President and Minister for Foreign
Affairs of Panama; His Excellency Mr. Bernard
Kouchner, Minister for Foreign Affairs of France; His
Excellency Mr. Charles Michel, Minister for
Development Cooperation of Belgium; and His
Excellency Mr. Vittorio Craxi, Under-Secretary of
State for Foreign Affairs of Italy.
My delegation thanks the Secretary-General for
his report (S/2007/757). We also thank Ms. Radhika
Coomaraswamy, Special Representative of the
Secretary-General for Children in Armed Conflict, for
her presentation. We thank Ms. Ann Veneman,
Executive Director of UNICEF, and Ms. Jo Becker,
Representative of Watchlist on Children and Armed
Conflict, for their respective statements, which are
very useful for a good understanding of the subject.
Rwanda is profoundly concerned with the well-
being of children - not just in Rwanda, but also in the
region of the Great Lakes and in the world in general.
Thus we welcome the progress achieved, as reflected in
the report of the Secretary-General. We are also
profoundly concerned to note the still-considerable scale
of the scourge of the use of children in armed conflicts
and of rape and other sexual violence against children
and women in conflict areas. My delegation thanks the
United Nations and other actors for the progress
achieved and welcomes the recommendations made.
When my delegation speaks of children in armed
conflict and of rape and sexual violence committed
against children and women in conflict areas, we speak
from experience, having suffered that scourge during the
1994 genocide. After the halt of the genocide, my
Government made demobilization of child soldiers and
combating rape and sexual violence major objectives of
its policy. We welcome the results achieved, which mean
that not only are there no more child soldiers in Rwanda
and that combating rape and sexual violence has greatly
reduced the scale of that scourge, but also that a
vigorous policy for the protection and advancement of
women is in force and that laws to severely punish those
who violate these rights and to promote the rights of
children and women have been adopted.
With regard to the recruitment of children by
armed forces in the eastern part of the Democratic
Republic of the Congo and the rape and sexual
violence committed there, my delegation deeply
deplores the situation and is doing everything in its
power to contribute to its resolution. However, my
delegation would like to draw the attention of the
Security Council to the fact that the real solution lies in
the resolution of the problem, which is the root of this
evil: disarmament and repatriation of the Forces
democratiques de liberation du Rwanda (FDLR) and
the ex-FAR and Interahamwe, who, after having
committed genocide in Rwanda in 1994, continued
their murderous work in the Kivus. The threatened
population found refuge in Rwanda 10 years ago, and
the genocidal forces continue to occupy the land whose
owners languish in refugee camps in Rwanda and
bordering countries. Those genocidal forces make
massive use of child soldiers and rape young
Congolese girls and women. That was clearly set out in
the report of Under-Secretary-General John Holmes.
Those forces continue to threaten Rwanda, where they
still desire to finish their dirty task of genocide.
My delegation finds that the most appropriate
way to free children and women in the eastern
Democratic Republic of the Congo from the scourges
described in the Secretary-General's report is through
the liberation of the region from the genocidal forces
who have chosen to take up residence there and who
live openly, under the nose of the Security Council and
of the broader international community. It is essential
that the United Nations Organization Mission in the
Democratic Republic of the Congo, in cooperation with
the countries concerned, make that a priority. Thus it
would serve the cause of children and respond to the
expectations of the Nairobi communique and to the
conclusions of the Goma Conference of January 2008.
The President (spoke in Spanish): Following
consultations among members of the Security Council,
I have been authorized to make the following statement
on behalf of the Council:
"The Security Council takes note with
appreciation of the seventh report of the
Secretary-General (S/2007/757) on children and
armed conflict, and the positive developments, as
well as outstanding challenges, in the
implementation of its resolution 1612 (2005)
reflected therein.
"The Security Council, reiterating its
primary responsibility for the maintenance of
international peace and security, reaffirms its
commitment to address the widespread impact of
armed conflict on children, its determination to
ensure respect for and the implementation of its
resolution 1612 (2005), and all of its previous
resolutions on children and armed conflict, as
well as respect for other international norms and
standards for the protection of children affected
by armed conflicts.
"The Security Council stresses, in this
regard, the need to adopt a broad strategy of
conflict prevention, which addresses the root
causes of armed conflict in a comprehensive
manner in order to enhance the protection of
children on a long-term basis, including by
promoting sustainable development, poverty
eradication, national reconciliation, good
governance, democracy, the rule of law and
respect for and protection of human rights.
"The Security Council reiterates the primary
responsibility of national Governments in
providing effective protection and relief to all
children affected by armed conflicts, and
encourages further cooperation and coordination
between Member States, the United Nations
system and the international community, in a
spirit of partnership.
"The Security Council reiterates the
importance of the full, safe and unhindered
access of humanitarian personnel and goods and
the delivery of humanitarian assistance to all
children affected by armed conflict, and stresses
the importance for all, within the framework of
humanitarian assistance, of upholding and
respecting the humanitarian principles of
humanity, neutrality, impartiality and
independence.
"The Security Council calls for the full
implementation of the monitoring and reporting
mechanism on children and armed conflict, as
called for in paragraph 3 of Security Council
resolution 1612 (2005), in all situations of armed
conflict listed in the annexes to the Secretary-
General's report S/2007/757.
"In this regard, the Security Council
reiterates that the mechanism should continue to
collect and provide timely, objective, accurate
and reliable information on violations and abuses
committed against children affected by armed
conflict and to operate with the participation of
and in cooperation with national Governments
and relevant United Nations and civil society
actors, including at the country level.
"The Security Council commends the work
carried out by the Special Representative of the
Secretary-General for Children and Armed
Conflict, Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy, including
her field activities in situations of armed
conflicts.
"The Security Council also commends the
work carried out by UNICEF and the child
protection advisers of peacekeeping operations
and political missions, in cooperation with other
relevant United Nations entities.
"The Security Council welcomes the
sustained activity of its Working Group on
Children and Armed Conflict, as outlined, inter
alia, in the latest report by its Chair (S/2007/428),
and invites it to continue adopting conclusions
and proposing effective recommendations for
consideration and, where appropriate,
implementation by the Council, including through
mandates of United Nations peacekeeping
operations and political missions.
"The Security Council will continue to
consider including or enhancing the presence of
child protection advisers in the mandates of all
relevant United Nations peacekeeping operations
and political missions.
"The Security Council strongly emphasizes
the need to end impunity for violations and
abuses perpetrated against children in armed
conflict, and in this regard welcomes the fact that
several individuals who are alleged to have
committed such crimes have been brought to
justice by national, international and 'mixed'
criminal courts and tribunals.
"The Security Council acknowledges that
the implementation of its resolution 1612 (2005)
has already generated progress, resulting in the
release and reintegration of children in their
families and communities, and in a more
systematic dialogue between the United Nations
country task forces and parties to the armed
conflict on the implementation of time-bound
action plans.
"Nonetheless, the Security Council strongly
condemns the continuing recruitment and use of
children in armed conflict in violation of
applicable international law, killing and maiming
of children, rape and other sexual violence,
abductions, denial of humanitarian access to
children and attacks against schools and hospitals
by parties to armed conflict.
"The Security Council is concerned with the
widespread and systematic use of rape and other
forms of sexual violence against children, in
particular girls, in situations of armed conflict,
and calls on all parties to armed conflicts to take
special measures to protect girls and boys from
sexual and gender-based violence, particularly
rape, in situations of armed conflict.
"The Security Council expresses its concern
that civilians, particularly children, continue to
account for the vast majority of victims of acts of
violence committed by parties to armed conflicts,
including killing and maiming as a result of
deliberate targeting, indiscriminate and excessive
use of force in violation of applicable
international law. The Council condemns these
acts and demands that those parties immediately
put an end to such practices.
"The Security Council is gravely concerned
by the persistent disregard of its resolutions on
children and armed conflict by parties to armed
conflict identified in the reports of the monitoring
and reporting mechanism, including parties to
whom precise, immediate and unequivocal
requests have been addressed. Recalling the
statement S/PRST/2006/48 made by its President
on 28 November 2006, the Security Council
reaffirms its intention to make use of all the tools
provided in its resolution 1612 (2005).
"The Security Council reiterates its call on
parties to armed conflict listed in the annexes of
the Secretary-General's report S/2007/757 that
have not already done so to prepare and
implement, without further delay, concrete time-
bound action plans to halt recruitment and use of
children in violation of applicable international
law, and to address all violations and abuses
against children in close cooperation with the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General,
as well as with UNICEF and the United Nations
country task forces on monitoring and reporting.
"The Security Council expresses concern
over the casualties inflicted on children in armed
conflict by the indiscriminate use of landmines
and cluster munitions, and in this regard calls
upon all parties to armed conflicts to desist from
such practice.
"In order to further strengthen the
comprehensive framework of the protection of
children in armed conflict, considering the
changing nature of armed conflicts and the issues
raised by the Secretary-General in his report, the
Security Council expresses its readiness to review
the relevant provisions of its resolutions on
children and armed conflict, building on the
provisions of resolution 1612 (2005), with a view
to further increasing the efficiency of its actions.
"The Security Council recognizes that a
stronger focus is required on the reintegration and
rehabilitation of children associated with armed
forces and armed groups, and in this regard
invites all parties concerned, including Member
States, regional organizations, the Secretariat and
other relevant United Nations entities, including
UNICEF, the United Nations Population Fund,
the United Nations Development Fund for
Women, the World Health Organization, the
United Nations Development Programme, the
Office of the United Nations High Commissioner
for Refugees, the Office of the United Nations
High Commissioner for Human Rights, the
International Labour Organization and the United
Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural
Organization, the international financial
institutions, including the World Bank, as well as
civil society, to enhance their exchange of
information about programmes and best practices,
bearing in mind the relevant provisions of
international law, Security Council resolutions on
children and armed conflict, as well as the Paris
Principles to protect children from unlawful
recruitment by armed forces or groups, and
ensure that adequate resources and funding are
available to support national strategies or action
plans in the area of child protection and welfare,
and community-based programmes, with a View
to ensuring the long-term sustainability and
success of their programmatic response to the
release, rehabilitation and reintegration of all
children associated with armed forces and armed
groups.
"The Security Council requests the
Secretary-General to submit his next report by
May 2009 on the implementation of its
resolutions on children and armed conflict."
This statement will be published as a document of
the Security Council under the symbol S/PRST/2008/6.
There are no further speakers inscribed on my
list. The Security Council has thus concluded the
current stage of its consideration of the item on its
agenda.
Before adjourning the meeting, allow me to
express my gratitude once again for the difficult and
relevant work carried out on the issue of children and
armed conflict by the Office of the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General on Children and
Armed Conflict, UNICEF and the non-governmental
organizations. I also wish to thank France for its
leadership in this area and all Member States that have
participated in this important debate. In conclusion, I
thank the support staff for this meeting for their patience
and dedication.
The meeting rose at 8.15pm.
▶ Cite this page
UN Project. “S/PV.5834Resumption1.” UN Project, https://un-project.org/meeting/S-PV-5834Resumption1/. Accessed .