S/PV.5868Resumption1 Security Council
▶ This meeting at a glance
39
Speeches
0
Countries
0
Resolutions
Topics
Peacekeeping support and operations
African Union peace and security
Sustainable development and climate
Security Council deliberations
Peace processes and negotiations
Diplomatic expressions and remarks
Africa
The President: I wish to remind all speakers, as
indicated this morning, to limit their statements to no
more than five minutes, in order to enable the Council
to carry out its work expeditiously. Delegations with
lengthy statements are kindly requested to circulate
their texts in writing and to deliver a condensed
version when speaking in the Chamber.
I now invite His Excellency Mr. Ahmed Ouyahia,
Former Prime Minister and Personal Representative of
the President of Algeria, to take the floor.
Mr. Ouyahia (Algeria) (spoke in French):
Mr. Abdelaziz Bouteflika, President of the People's
Democratic Republic of Algeria, has asked me to
convey to the Security Council his deep regret at not
being able to be here in person to attend this important
meeting due to an especially busy national agenda. He
has also asked me to convey to the Council his best
wishes for the success of this meeting between the
African Union and the United Nations. He has also
given me the honour of reading out to the Council the
following message on this occasion.
"I wish at the outset to thank the President
of the Security Council for having taken the
initiative to organize a high-level Security
Council debate on strengthening partnership
between the Security Council and regional
organizations, particularly the African Union
through its Peace and Security Council. It has
indeed become urgent to improve the capacities
and to strengthen the action of regional
organizations, especially the African Union, in
the critical area of maintaining peace and
security.
"For the African continent, seeking and
maintaining peace and security represents a major
challenge as significant as the issue of
development. In that respect, we note with
pleasure the decrease in recent years of the
number of conflicts and crisis situations on the
continent, as well as the undeniable progress that
has been made in Sierra Leone, Liberia, Burundi,
Cote d'Ivoire and the Democratic Republic of the
Congo. That trend should strengthen and grow
thanks to Africa's collective commitment to
peace, embodied in the actions of the Peace and
Security Council of the African Union. It should
2
also be encouraged and robustly supported by the
entire international community.
"At the tenth summit of the African Union
that took place in Addis Ababa in January, the
Secretary-General stressed the importance of
tightening cooperation links between the African
Union and the United Nations. He pointed out
that it was vital to enhance that partnership in
order to overcome the obstacles to peace and
security on the continent. I welcome the high
quality of cooperation between the United
Nations and the African Union and the success
that has been achieved in that area.
"In the framework of that cooperation, a
transfer of authority took place late last year from
the African Union Mission in Sudan to the
African Union-United Nations Hybrid Operation
in Darfur. That major development was based on
a dynamic balance between imperative political
considerations and unavoidable operational and
logistical requirements. Elsewhere, the United
Nations has supported such African countries as
Burundi, Sierra Leone and Guinea-Bissau under
the programme of work of the Peacebuilding
Commission. In January 2007, two of those
countries benefited from the Peacebuilding Fund.
Unfortunately, the allocated budgetary envelope
has not been fully disbursed.
"With respect to issues of peace and
security, the situation in Africa has been
characterized by emergences from crises and the
perpetuation of conflicts that we had hoped to see
resolved, first, by the mobilization of Africans
themselves, and later by that of the international
community. That is the case with the Western
Sahara, where the United Nations Mission for the
Referendum in Western Sahara has been deployed
for more than 15 years. It is also the case with
Somalia, where the African Union Mission has
clearly been unable to provide the conditions
necessary for resolving the security, policy and
humanitarian aspects of the situation.
"The implementation of a peace and
security architecture of the African Union -
including a mechanism for the prevention,
management and settlement of conflicts, the
Peace and Security Council and a council of
elders - reflects Africa's resolve to take
08-30700
responsibility for itself and to act in favour of
political solutions that integrate the values of
conciliation and reconciliation and ensure the
sustainability of agreements reached.
"I hope that this high-level Security Council
debate will represent a decisive step towards
strengthening cooperation between the United
Nations and regional organizations, in particular
the African Union. Such cooperation, based on
the principles of the United Nations Charter,
could give rise to innovative modes of operation.
In that respect, it would be extremely useful for
us to adopt a more ambitious interpretation of
Chapter VIII of the Charter, which is the legal
basis for peacekeeping operations led by regional
organizations. Such an interpretation could take
account of local realities and favour responses
adapted to specific contexts and characteristics,
with a clear view of each party's respective
responsibilities and complementarities.
"It is indeed important that the as yet
unexploited potential for synergy, interaction and
coordination of cooperation between the Security
Council and regional and subregional
organizations be fully achieved. There is no doubt
whatsoever that a successful synthesis of regional
and subregional efforts with the activities of the
international community will allow us to mobilize
all the energy necessary to achieving goals that
serve the cause of peace.
"In that context, as soon as it is approved by
the Security Council, a peacekeeping operation
on the African continent should be treated in the
same way as operations led by the United
Nations, particularly in terms of the management
and disbursement of funding, which should be
adequate and regular. The time has come to
institutionalize funding and to move beyond the
ad hoc approach of some financing that makes it
difficult to plan and manage such missions.
"If we are to lay such uncertainties to rest
once and for all, we should consider funding
mechanisms that are more consistent and better
coordinated. In that respect, the path laid out in
January 2007 by the heads of State of the African
Union - which consists of organizing missions
that are led by the Union, agreed with the
Security Council, and funded by assessed
08-30700
contributions of United Nations Member States in
the context of Chapter VIII of the Charter -
should be endorsed and implemented as soon as
possible. Such an approach would allow us
sustainably to overcome the significant funding
constraints facing Africa. It would help to
enhance the partnership between the African
Union and the United Nations and to reassert the
authority and credibility of the Security Council
in its supervision of regional initiatives, which
would then be undertaken with clear objectives,
effectively and in the certainty that funds would
be put to best use, to the satisfaction of the
international community as a whole."
Having read out President Bouteflika's message, I
should like very briefly to add two comments on behalf
of the delegation of Algeria.
First, we support the statement made by the
President of the United Republic of Tanzania, the
current Chairman of the African Union, and endorse
the proposal he made on behalf of Africa.
Secondly, Algeria pays homage to the personal
efforts of President Mbeki to convene this meeting and
to draw up the draft resolution that has been submitted
to the Security Council. Such a commitment on his part
is a tribute to his country, South Africa. It does honour
to Africa. On behalf of President Bouteflika, we thank
him very warmly.
The President: I now call on Her Excellency
Mrs. Laure Olga Gondjout, Minister for Foreign
Affairs, Cooperation, Francophonie and Regional
Integration of Gabon.
Mrs. Gondjout (Gabon) (spoke in French): On
behalf of the President of the Gabonese Republic, His
Excellency Mr. El Hadj Omar Bongo Ondimba, whom
I have the honour to represent here, I would like to say
how pleased our delegation and I myself are to see
Mr. Mbeki presiding over this high-level meeting on
the role of regional organizations in the maintenance of
international peace and security.
As the Council knows, the President of the
Gabonese Republic is very interested in questions
related to international peace and security, particularly
in Africa. He thus fully supports the initiative that the
Council presidency has taken to organize this meeting
to examine questions related to the maintenance of
international peace and security. The Council can be
3
assured of his solidarity with the resulting
recommendations.
The report of the Secretary-General on the
relationship between the United Nations and regional
organizations, in particular the African Union, in the
maintenance of international peace and security
(8/2008/186) has proposed interesting paths for
reflection on strengthening cooperation and
coordination between the United Nations and regional
and subregional organizations.
While today we have reasons to be pleased with
developments in recent years in this area, particularly
in Africa, we must acknowledge that a great deal
remains to be done so that this cooperation can have
more solid content. With a constant and significant
contribution to United Nations peacekeeping
operations and to our own, in accordance with Chapter
VIII of the United Nations Charter, Africa has shown
its will and capacity to mobilize for the resolution of
conflicts and crises that threaten collective security.
That is the case with the African peacekeeping mission
in Burundi, African Union-United Nations Hybrid
Operation in Darfur (UNAMID) and the recent African
Union Mission in Somalia (AMISOM).
The President of the Gabonese Republic, in
consultation with his peers in the Economic
Community of Central African States (ECCAS) and the
Central African Economic and Monetary Community
(CEMAC), is contributing to the search for solutions to
the crises in the subregion. As Chair of the Ad Hoc
Committee on the Situation in the Central African
Republic, he encourages consultations and inclusive
dialogue to reach political and economic stabilization
of that country.
The President of the Gabonese Republic has also
been active in the deployment of the Multinational
Force of the Central African Economic and Monetary
Community (FOMUC). The same is true of the case of
Chad, where Gabon is working for an inclusive
dialogue between the various stakeholders.
Gabon is also in the contact group to follow up
the Dakar agreement signed on 13 March 2008
between Chad and the Sudan at the initiative of
President Abdoulaye Wade of Senegal. The group held
its the first meeting of Foreign Ministers in Libreville
on 10 April 2008. Another meeting of the contact
group, this time at the level of experts on defence,
security and intelligence, will be held in Tripoli, Libya
at the end of this month to consider and plan for the
rapid establishment, with the support of the United
Nations and the European Union, of a surveillance
force at the border between Chad and the Sudan.
Unfortunately, all of these African initiatives
come up against the insufficiency of resources, in
particular with regard to financing, human and
institutional capacity-building and peacebuilding.
Because of this, my country supports the Secretary-
General's proposal to quickly create a panel of eminent
experts for an in-depth consideration of predictable and
stable financing of peacekeeping operations initiated
by regional organizations.
Capacity-building in preventive diplomacy is
another area of concern, which was addressed in
resolution 1625 (2005) of 14 September 2005. From
that perspective, joint mediation and good offices
missions could help defuse the brewing conflicts and
crises.
On a completely different topic, Gabon would
like to launch a strong appeal to the international
community for assistance to developing countries
facing increases in food prices, which could produce
socio-economic troubles likely to degenerate into
lasting crises.
I express the wish that the resolution to be
adopted at the end of this debate will strengthen the
framework for cooperation between the United Nations
and regional organizations, the African Union in
particular, in the maintenance of international peace
and security.
The President: I now give the floor to the
Minister for Foreign Affairs of Sierra Leone, Her
Excellency Mrs. Zainab Hawa Bangura.
Mrs. Bangura (Sierra Leone): At the outset, I
would like to convey the sincere appreciation of His
Excellency Mr. Ernest Bai Koroma, President of the
Republic of Sierra Leone, for the invitation extended to
him to participate in this debate. While also
congratulating President Thabo Mbeki on conceiving
this laudable initiative, allow me to convey President
Koroma's profound regret for his inability to be
personally present to contribute to this all-important
subject, due to compelling preoccupations at home.
My gratitude also goes to the Secretary-General
for his comprehensive report to the Security Council
08-30700
on this subject (S/2008/l86) and the recommendations
therein.
The remarkable talent and ability of President
Mbeki, coupled with his consummate experience,
convince us that we can exude pride and confidence
that his special talents can be brought to bear on the
proceedings of this meeting.
Partnership and cooperation provide the
opportunity to tap into the comparative advantages of
the United Nations and regional stakeholders to
respectively contribute to addressing threats to
international peace and security. Thus a concerted
effort in managing, resolving and preventing conflicts
constitutes a vital ingredient for international peace,
security and prosperity.
As a nation that has emerged from a protracted
conflict and that is still grappling with the effects of
that menace, Sierra Leone is a living testimony to the
critical importance of a regional approach to conflict
resolution and prevention. The historic decision by
Security Council in resolution 1181 (1998), in
welcoming and recognizing the important contribution
of the Economic Community of West African States
(ECOWAS) in support of Sierra Leone Government's
efforts to re-establish effective administration and the
democratic process and to embark on the task of
national reconciliation, reconstruction and
rehabilitation, is a clear demonstration of the
imperative of these partnerships.
With two thirds of the world's poorest countries,
Africa has experienced a myriad of civil conflicts that
resulted in abject poverty and socio-economic
exclusion. Efforts by the African Union (AU) and
subregional organizations such as ECOWAS in
establishing mechanisms for conflict prevention,
management and resolution - particularly the crisis
situations in Liberia, Sierra Leone, Guinea-Bissau,
Cote d'Ivoire and the Darfur region in the Sudan -
clearly demonstrate the willingness and commitment of
the continent to take on its responsibility for peace,
security and stability in the continent.
Despite positive trends and advances with regard
to obtaining durable peace in Africa, the conditions
required for sustainable development have yet to be
consolidated throughout the continent. Thus, these
efforts can yield dividends only through the
cooperation and support of the international
community, based on the principle of mutual respect
and trust. There is therefore an urgent need to intensify
and harmonize national, regional and international
efforts in order to develop African human and
institutional capacities, particularly in countries
emerging from conflict.
The need to support those countries in getting
back on their feet is more than imperative, and it
involves peacebuilding and preventive diplomacy. We
know only too well the challenges faced by post-
conflict countries after years of civil strife. Such
countries, often fragile and reeling under the weight of
poverty, are usually not equal to the Herculean task of
rebuilding what has been scarred by years of
devastation. Supporting those countries in order to heal
the wounds of conflict is, in itself, an antidote that
could stabilize them as well as prevent them from
sliding down the thorny path that leads to renewed
conflict.
It is in that light that we applaud and greatly
appreciate the efforts and engagement of the
Peacebuilding Commission regarding countries like
ours, grappling with post-conflict reconstruction. We
trust that the call for close collaboration between the
Peacebuilding Commission and the AU Standing
Multidimensional Committee could be strengthened
through regular consultation and coordination. The
abundant resources that we muster for intervention and
peacekeeping operations could be significantly reduced
if we heavily invest in preventive diplomacy, by
tackling the root causes of conflicts upstream. Thus, a
stitch in time saves nine.
In order to accomplish that goal, the United
Nations system should adapt itself to the
transformations and developments that the continent is
currently experiencing, particularly in the context of
the evolving structures and programmes of the AU. In
the spirit of Chapter VIII of the Charter of the United
Nations, the AU and subregional organizations have
devised mechanisms to strengthen their peacekeeping
capacity and to take the lead in peacekeeping
operations on the continent. Those ongoing efforts
require close collaboration and coordination between
the United Nations and the AU.
In concluding, I wish to emphasize that, in the
promotion of international peace and security, the real
challenge lies in strengthening partnership and
cooperation between the United Nations and regional
organizations, in particular the African Union. That
5
also calls for implementation of the relevant mandates
of the General Assembly and the Security Council and
highlights the need for the United Nations and the
international community to provide further support to
the AU in the following ways.
First, the AU Peace Fund should be replenished,
and flexible, predictable and sustainable financing
should be ensured for AU peacekeeping operations so
that they can expedite or step up troop deployment in
peacekeeping operations. Secondly, the initiatives of
the African Union and subregional organizations to
prevent, mediate and resolve conflicts with the
assistance of the United Nations should be encouraged
and supported. Thirdly, cooperation with the New
Partnership for Africa's Development (NEPAD) should
be strengthened by providing coherent support for its
programmes through the mobilization of internal and
external financial resources. Fourthly, the individual
and collective efforts of African countries should be
supplemented so that agricultural productivity can be
increased in a sustainable way, in order to ensure food
security in the context of NEPAD's Comprehensive
Africa Agriculture Development Programme. Finally, a
well-structured multi-stakeholder post-conflict
peacebuilding programme that has clearly defined and
coordinated roles for each partner should be
established.
The President: I now invite His Excellency
Mr. Majozi Sithole, Minister of Finance of Swaziland,
to take the floor.
Mr. Sithole (Swaziland): I wish at the outset to
join all those who have spoken before me in
congratulating South Africa on its assumption of the
presidency of the Security Council for the current
month. I also wish to commend the initiative that your
delegation has taken, Madam President, in convening
this very historic meeting. We fully support you in this
initiative.
The Swaziland delegation welcomes the report of
the Secretary-General on the relationship between the
United Nations and regional organizations, in
particular the African Union, in the maintenance of
international peace and security (S/2008/ 186).
The preparation of the report signifies the
importance of the subject matter. Over the past few
years, experience has shown that regional
organizations play a significant role in the maintenance
of international peace and security. The importance of
that role emanates from the fact that regional
organizations have a comparative advantage over the
Security Council when it comes to understanding the
nature of the conflicts obtaining in a particular region,
by reason of proximity. Even the Charter of the United
Nations recognizes the importance of regional
organizations, in its Chapter VIII.
While it is recognized that it is the primary
responsibility of the Security Council to maintain
international peace and security, the Council cannot
carry out that mandate in isolation. That highlights the
importance of the need to strengthen and deepen the
relations between the United Nations and regional
organizations in order to effectively maintain
international peace and security.
Close collaboration between the United Nations
Security Council and the African Union Peace and
Security Council can significantly improve the
handling of the conflict situations in Africa. The
challenges faced by the African Union in its efforts
aimed at conflict prevention, management and
resolution are daunting. All too often, the African
Union has had to initiate its own missions in conflict
areas because the United Nations has not been able to
deploy peacekeeping missions there. Even after
peacekeeping operations have been authorized by the
Security Council, the United Nations has been slow in
operationalizing such missions.
The frustration experienced by the African Union
emanates mainly from a lack of the resources it
requires to operationalize its initiatives. It is therefore
imperative to establish a mechanism that would
provide funding in a predictable, flexible and
sustainable manner for the long-term planning of
peacekeeping missions. In that regard, we welcome the
timely proposal contained in the report of the
Secretary-General that a high-level panel be
established to study the funding situation and to come
up with modalities for how it should be done.
Swaziland wishes to align itself with the
statement of the Chairperson of the Commission of the
African Union, which we fully support. We urge that
the exercise by the high-level panel be conducted
expeditiously. We believe that it would not be an
academic exercise, because we are talking about
human lives here. We also welcome the progress made
in the operationalization of the peace architecture of
08-30700
the African Union. We look forward to the continued
support of the international community in that regard.
The importance of strengthening relations
between the United Nations and the African Union
cannot be overemphasized. Let us look forward to its
success.
Finally, I wish to join colleagues who have
spoken before me in saying the following. Let us keep
our eyes on the problems that we are currently facing.
The food prices that continue to escalate every day
have the potential to cause problems and uprisings in
our countries.
The President: I now invite His Excellency
Mr. Dieudonne Kombo Yaya, Minister for Foreign
Affairs of the Central African Republic, to take the
floor.
Mr. Kombo Yaya (Central African Republic) (spoke in French): Permit me to convey to you, Madam
President, the regrets of His Excellency Mr. Francois
Bozize, President of the Republic and Head of State,
who, because of other commitments, could not
personally take part in this meeting on cooperation
between the United Nations Security Council and the
African Union Peace and Security Council. He remains
convinced that, under your country's presidency, the
Security Council will further strengthen its cooperation
with the African Union Peace and Security Council.
The African architecture in the area of conflict
prevention, management and resolution is the outcome
of the commitment of our heads of State or
Government, first within the former Organization of
African Unity and then within today's African Union
(AU), to ensure that peace and security - which are,
moreover, inseparable - are the top priority, because
without peace there can be no economic and social
development. The relevant provisions of the Charter of
the United Nations and of the Constitutive Act of the
African Union emphasize that point quite clearly.
We welcome the active cooperation between our
two organizations in the area of peacekeeping. There
are many examples in that regard. I need not refer to
them in detail, as most of those who have spoken
before me have eloquently cited numerous examples of
the partnership between the United Nations and the
African Union. However, I would like to emphasize in
particular the need to strengthen the capacity of
subregional organizations with conflict settlement
mechanisms, such as the Council for Peace and
Security in Central Africa. Such bodies work at the
grass-roots level, play a basic and crucial role in the
settlement of conflicts and should rely on the African
Union only as a last resort. We therefore welcome the
proposal of the Secretary-General for the establishment
of a joint United Nations-African Union group of
experts to consider in detail how to support the
peacekeeping operations of subregional organizations,
especially in terms of funding.
I should like to take this opportunity, on behalf of
my President, to commend Secretary-General Ban
Ki-moon for his support for the establishment of a
regional office for the Great Lakes region of Central
Africa.
In the light of the new situation, enhancing the
capacity of the African Union also continues to be a
priority. As you are aware, Madam President, the
Central African Republic is a post-conflict country that
is trying to emerge from two decades of ongoing crisis.
Any effort aimed at re-establishing and strengthening
peace should take into account the economic situation
in the country, because extreme poverty, hunger and
the precarious state of our people's health constitute
fertile ground for instability.
I should like to take this opportunity to welcome
the joint efforts made by the African Union through the
United Nations Peacebuilding Support Office in the
Central African Republic, including the efforts of the
Special Envoy of the Chairman of the African Union,
in order to bring about reconciliation in Central Africa,
including the work done to prepare for the inclusive
dialogue, which came to an end on 31 March and
which will open up the way for the dialogue to take
place very soon.
In conclusion, we fully support the draft
resolution put forward by your country, Madam
President, which opens up new horizons for our
continent.
The President: I now invite His Excellency
Chief Ojo Maduekwe, Minister for Foreign Affairs and
Envoy of the President of Nigeria, to take the floor.
Mr. Maduekwe (Nigeria): On behalf of President
Umaru Musa Yar'Adua, may I commend South
Africa's initiative in bringing this crucial subject
before the Security Council. By the same token, I
commend Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon for his
comprehensive report on the issue. The report is
pertinent not only in terms of its proposals for
prospective cooperation between the United Nations
and the African Union (AU), but also in proffering
targeted recommendations to improve that partnership.
We are pleased with the effort of the Secretary-General
and agree with his viewpoint that there are outstanding
questions about the nature of the partnership between
the United Nations and regional organizations,
including the AU, that need to be clarified.
African problems are truly global problems, in
ways that grim statistics render more disturbingly
challenging than the current pace of global response
would suggest, especially in the area of funding,
despite the untiring best efforts of the Secretary-
General. Nigeria therefore fully endorses this debate,
as it affords us an opportunity to redefine and realign
the major strands of the evolving strategic partnership
between the AU and the United Nations. Indeed, the
foundations of the functional relationship we seek
between the United Nations and the AU are rooted in
Chapter VIII of the Charter of the United Nations and
in the Constitutive Act of the African Union. In a
global village, one cannot afford unsafe compounds; it
is too close for comfort.
Regional organizations like the AU are uniquely
placed to tackle threats to regional peace and security.
Nigeria recognizes the efficacy of complementarities
and partnerships in that regard. That is part of the
reason that we have been steadfast in our commitment
to the United Nations, the AU and subregional
organizations such as the Economic Community of
West African States.
We believe that this debate, which comes at a
time of reduced shooting wars in Africa, serves to
energize a momentum which we should build upon. On
its part, the African Union has sufficiently
demonstrated political will for the peaceful resolution
of the continent's problems. What is now required is
for the international community to put its money where
its mouth is.
I would like to conclude by calling for very close
cooperation between the United Nations and the AU in
drafting a resolution that will not only meet the
challenges of today but address our dreams for
tomorrow, namely, that of a more peaceful world
underpinned by an ever-closer partnership between the
United Nations and regional organizations, in
particular the African Union. I am confident that we
can achieve that objective. But that will be difficult if
the United Nations continues to ignore the wisdom of
the African proverb that says that you do not shave a
man's head in his absence. If close to 60 per cent of the
Security Council's time is devoted to African issues,
and Africa is the only continent not represented on the
Security Council in the permanent category, how can
the United Nations make progress on the issue of
African ownership of its own problems and solutions
without addressing that imbalance?
The President: I now invite His Excellency
Mr. Ronnie Shikapwasha, Minister for Home Affairs
and Special Envoy of Zambia, to take the floor.
Mr. Shikapwasha (Zambia): First of all, I would
like to commend South Africa for its assumption of the
presidency of the Security Council, which comes at a
momentous period in the affairs of the African
continent.
With regard to peace and security on the
continent, Africa continues to grapple with intractable
peace and security situations in many parts of the
continent. South Africa's presidency is therefore a
further confirmation of the confidence of the
international community in the leadership and role that
South Africa continues to play in the various conflicts
and their resolution. South Africa's role has in many
ways enhanced Africa's initiatives in the resolution of
some of Africa's long-standing conflicts. In that regard,
the convening of this meeting is relevant in our attempt
to find solutions to Africa's raging conflicts. This
meeting also comes at a time when the international
community is seeking to partner with the African
Union to find solutions to Africa's flashpoints. Finally,
South Africa's presidency also comes at a time when
the world is looking to the continent to assume greater
responsibility for its own human condition arising from
conflict situations.
While we recognize the centrality of the Security
Council in the maintenance of peace and security, the
evolution of conflicts and their management has thrust
new responsibilities on the African continent, and
indeed the African Union (AU). Africa's willingness to
find solutions to some of the hard conflicts has
increased Africa's role in the finding of solutions to
those conflicts on behalf of the international
community, especially the Security Council.
Africa continues to suffer from a lack of
resources and capacity to secure lasting solutions to the
continent's conflicts. There is a need, therefore, to
develop and work on mechanisms with the United
Nations system to enhance the provision of predictable
and sustainable resources to Africa's efforts in finding
solutions to its conflicts. The United Nations efforts in
that respect should include the funding of peace
operations, especially that related to start-up financing
for equipment and logistics.
Zambia supports in that regard the amendment of
United Nations rules on peacekeeping budgets to
finance regional operations authorized by the Security
Council. As regards the deployment and management
of African Union-led peace support operations, Zambia
recommends for consideration at this meeting that such
operations be funded through United Nations assessed
contributions. Considering the importance of resources
to the success of AU missions - and indeed, to those
of the United Nations - it is proposed that an in-depth
analysis of the current financial outlays to peace
missions also be made.
While financial resources are cardinal to positive
outcomes in conflict zones, Zambia would support
cooperative mechanisms that ensure human dignity
based on the development of coherent strategies and
policies that would protect civilians in armed conflicts.
Zambia would, in that respect, support early warning
systems that anticipate human-made social, political
and economic upheavals which are the precursors of
Africa's conflicts.
The President: I now call on His Excellency
Mr. Cheikh Tidiane Gadio, Minister for Foreign Affairs
of Senegal.
Mr. Gadio (Senegal) (spoke in French): On
behalf of President Abdoulaye Wade of the Republic of
Senegal, whom it is my honour to represent, I should
like at the outset warmly to congratulate South Africa
and President Thabo Mbeki on having again this year
convened an open Security Council debate on the
relationship between the United Nations and regional
organizations, in particular the African Union, in the
maintenance of international peace and security. I
should also like to commend the leadership of
President Kikwete of Tanzania, the acting Chairman of
the African Union.
The interest that all Member States have shown in
today's debate is justified by the complex nature of
conflict situations in Africa and throughout the world.
That complexity requires synergy and dynamic
interaction between the United Nations, which has the
primary responsibility for the maintenance of
international peace and security, and regional
organizations, which are a complementary tool to the
activities of the Organization. In that respect, Chapter
VIII of the United Nations Charter clearly sets out the
modalities for cooperation between the Security
Council and regional organizations.
In that regard, we should welcome the high
quality of the partnership between the African Union
and the United Nations. That partnership is all the
more necessary given that Africa contributes almost
35 per cent of contingents and hosts almost half of all
peacekeeping operations, including the largest and
most complex. In that respect, at their 2006 summit,
the heads of State and Government of the African
Union called on the United Nations to consider, within
the framework of Chapter VII of the Charter, the
possibility of funding, through contributions by its
Member States, peacekeeping operations deployed by
the African Union or under its authority, with the
consent of the United Nations.
That invitation demonstrates the resolve of
African leaders to take responsibility for conflicts as
soon as they break out and to intervene relatively
quickly when the United Nations cannot do so. The
case of Darfur is a perfect illustration of that approach.
However, as all are aware, Africa does not always have
the necessary resources to assume such a burden, nor
does it always remain concretely engaged by
providing, quantitatively and qualitatively, the forces
necessary to the success of its interventions. The case
of Darfur also raises the issue of striking a balance
between the urgent need to act to stop atrocities and
due respect for the initiatives of such regional
organizations as the African Union.
African solutions for African problems represent
a noble and praiseworthy approach, but they should not
add to the unbearable suffering of the victims of
conflicts in Africa. In the face of the urgency that has
been recognized by the United Nations and the African
Union, action needs to be taken immediately.
The delicate issue of funding arose during the
operations in the three African missions in Burundi,
Somalia and Darfur. It should be considered in depth
so that we can find a solution. Any solution should,
however, take equal account of the start-up phase of
missions and their long-term viability.
There is a similar concern with regard to
implementing the key provision of the Dakar Accord
between Chad and the Sudan concerning the peace and
security force to monitor the long common border
between those brotherly countries. The Dakar
Accord- concluded on 13 March 2008 in the
presence of the Secretary-General of the United
Nations and the Chairman of the African Union
Commission, and with the strong support of the
Secretary General of the Organization of the Islamic
Conference and all the States of the Islamic ummah -
needs important logistic and financial resources if it is
to be successful. Senegal therefore strongly supports
the proposal contained in paragraph 76 of the
Secretary-General's report of 7 April 2008 on the
relationship between the United Nations and regional
organizations, in particular the African Union, in the
maintenance of international peace and security.
The greatest attention should be given to
strengthening African peacekeeping capacities,
particularly in terms of planning and managing training
operations for civilian, military and police personnel,
as well as logistical support. Regional organizations, in
particular the African Union, should have the ability to
be more alert to potential conflicts so as to be able to
avert them and to take all necessary measures, in close
collaboration with the United Nations, and in particular
the Security Council.
We need to make better use of preventive
diplomacy and strategic anticipation if we are to be
able to fulfil our commitments. The entire world is
listening to the African continent today, as for instance
with regard to the electoral processes in Zimbabwe
and, earlier, in Kenya. Unfortunately, we Africans have
answered only with a deafening silence that can be
heard everywhere. In establishing its council of elders,
the African Union has understood and recognized that
conflicts, be they dormant or active, can be resolved
only by political means - in other words, negotiation,
early warning and good offices.
In closing, I would insist on the need for the
international community to take urgent measures to
address the humanitarian crises sorely afflicting many
States in Africa and throughout the world, as reflected
in the brilliant plea made this morning by the leaders of
the African Union Commission.
The President: I now call on Her Excellency
Ms. Rosemary Museminali, Minister for Foreign
Affairs of Rwanda.
Ms. Museminali (Rwanda): The Rwandan
delegation applauds the initiative of President Mbeki of
South Africa to strengthen the relationship between the
United Nations and regional organizations, in
particular the African Union (AU), in the maintenance
of peace and international security. More particularly,
it could not have come at a more appropriate time than
at this moment, when people all over the world are
remembering the over 1 million Rwandans who lost
their lives 14 years ago in circumstances that could
have been prevented or halted later on. This forum thus
offers us an opportunity to review mechanisms by
which we can prevent and effectively intervene in
future conflicts in Africa and other parts of the world
with greater coherence and effectiveness.
What we need to do is direct our efforts towards
creating a mechanism that will address effective and
efficient coordination of both organizations in order to
deliver peace and security where it is needed most: in
conflict areas. AU member countries have taken up
their responsibility. They have shown goodwill and a
readiness and willingness to actively engage in
peacekeeping and security maintenance, mainly on the
African continent but also in other parts of the world.
What we expect from the Security Council, which is
mandated by the Charter to maintain international
peace and security, is the realistic, timely and
predictable provision of adequate resources to
accomplish those missions. Timely intervention has
been hampered by the inefficient provision of
resources, which in turn leads to missions being
ineffective.
AU member countries are capable of raising
sizable numbers of professional military and police
personnel for peacekeeping, but they are still largely
incapable of properly equipping them. The United
Nations therefore needs to agree to effectively maintain
its central role of sustaining peacekeeping forces in
conflict areas by equipping them effectively and by
making available the logistical support they need to
perform their duties.
In our view, this meeting offers us an opportunity
to forge a greater mutual partnership to address
regional conflicts by putting in place a joint team from
both organizations to work together to deal with
practical issues that have hampered our effectiveness in
the past. We are grateful that this has been provided for
in the draft resolution before the Council.
Greater participation by regional organizations in
conflict resolution needs to be tapped more and more,
given the fact that those regional organizations have
greater proximity to conflict areas and a better
appreciation of the political and cultural issues.
Therefore, it is urgent to institutionalize relations
between the United Nations and regional organizations,
particularly the African Union, in the areas of conflict
resolution and peacekeeping by building the AU's
capacity to implement initiatives that are in fact
possible but that seem impossible at current resource
levels.
My delegation therefore wishes to propose, inter
alia, the following measures, some of which have
already been mentioned by other delegations. We wish
also to support all the proposals set out in the draft
resolution before the Council. These measures include
the following.
First, AU peace and security measures taken to
resolve conflicts should be considered pivotal and
should be reinforced and supported by the Security
Council.
Secondly, we feel that the United Nations should
work on more predictable ways to fund peacekeeping
operations. More reliable funding should be considered
through assessed contributions by Member States,
because we find that these resources are more
predictable and therefore facilitate better planning and
contribute to greater efficiency. Current fundraising
measures need to be reviewed.
Thirdly, as most African nations willing to
contribute to United Nations peacekeeping operations
do not have the matching resources, we feel that,
whenever regional organizations undertake peace and
security roles, the United Nations should work out
ways to immediately prepare light and heavy support
packages to ease the transition from operations by
regional organizations to United Nations operations, in
order to avoid the costly delays that have plagued some
of the missions in the region, such as those in Somalia
and Darfur. Consider how much the former African
Union Mission in Sudan (AMIS) - the current African
Union-United Nations Hybrid Operation in Darfur
(UNAMID) - would have been able to achieve with
better mobility, better logistics and well-paid, well-fed
forces provided with proper health care.
Rwanda is happy to contribute to the promotion
of international peace and security through its military
and police contributions to United Nations and African
Union peacekeeping missions in the Sudan, Liberia,
cote d'Ivoire, the Comoros and Haiti. We are
committed to continuing these contributions for as long
as they are required, and as our meagre financial
resources permit.
We are committed to this quest for a working
partnership to spread peace because, more than
anybody else, we have tasted the lack of peace and
security, and we know what the lack of peace means
for a country and a region. The failure to address the
threat posed by genocidal forces such as the members
of the former Rwandan Armed Forces and
Interahamwe, also known as the Forces de'mocratiques
de liberation du Rwanda, has perpetuated conflict in
the Great Lakes region. My delegation therefore
welcomes the recent adoption by the Security Council
of resolution 1804 (2008), which aims to address the
threat posed by those forces not only to Rwanda but
also to the entire Great Lakes region. Any delay in the
response to this threat undermines us all. It allows the
international supporters of those forces to increase
their activities of destabilization, which are manifested
in the current blatant activities and international
conferences aimed at genocide denial. Genocide denial,
as a last stage of the implementation of the genocidal
ideology, is a formidable threat to peace and security,
as it energizes perpetration.
We all need to watch out for masked political
manoeuvres aimed at undermining peace and stability.
This poses a serious threat to peace and security, and
we urge the Security Council and regional
organizations to discourage and deal with the threat.
Today in Rwanda we face a situation where, ironically,
those who stopped the 1994 genocide are being
labelled as perpetrators by those seeking to manipulate
the international system; these allegations are based on
misinformation provided by perpetrators still at large
or by their sympathizers.
Our painful experience in Rwanda taught us that
peace comes at a huge price. There can be no peace
without reconciliation and without recognition of the
rights and interests of all people, including the right of
States to exist and the right of self-determination. We
have learned that no community's rights can or should
supersede another's. We have learned the value of
sharing, the value of communities finding and
consciously forging ways to promote living side by
side in peace and mutual respect. It is these initiatives
that this joint meeting needs to recognize; it needs to
enhance mechanisms to help nurture and enhance long-
lasting peace and stability.
In conclusion, I express the hope that the
outcome of this meeting will be a firm and clear
mechanism to strengthen the mechanisms for
institutionalizing relations between the United Nations
and regional organizations, particularly the African
Union, in the crucial areas of conflict resolution and
peacekeeping. Once again, an opportunity is before us
to translate our many challenges and opportunities into
a shared destiny of peace, security and prosperity for
all.
The President: I invite the Minister for Foreign
Affairs of Angola, His Excellency Mr. Joao Bernando
de Miranda, to take the floor.
Mr. Miranda (Angola) (spoke in Portuguese; English text provided by the delegation): I would like
to start by conveying our appreciation to the President
for holding this high-level meeting on peace and
security in Africa. I am greatly honoured to participate
in this forum on behalf of the President of the Republic
of Angola, His Excellency Jose Eduardo dos Santos,
who for unavoidable reasons could not travel to New
York.
Allow me to congratulate the President, on behalf
of my Government and on my own behalf, for the wise
manner in which he has been conducting the work of
the Security Council, especially for the opportunity and
pertinence of including in its agenda an issue that is
vital to its good performance, and that is matters
related to peace and security in Africa. I would also
like to express my appreciation to the previous Council
President for the constructive manner in which he,
together with the Secretary-General, contributed to the
realization of this important high-level meeting, which
takes place at a juncture when both the United Nations
and the African Union (AU) are confronting multiple
and complex challenges linked to peace and
development in the African continent.
On the occasion of the 2007 Security Council
meeting on the same topic, under the French
presidency (5749th meeting), the Council recognized,
among other aspects, the fundamental role of regional
and subregional organizations in the prevention and
resolution of conflicts on the basis Chapter VIII of the
United Nations Charter, as well as of Council
resolutions 1625 (2005) and 1631 (2005), to which we
can add presidential statement 2005/39. The Council
reiterated the importance of the relevant paragraphs of
the Outcome Document of the 2005 Summit, General
Assembly resolution 60/1, on the need for development
aid for Africa and strengthening the African Union's
operational capacity for peacekeeping operations for a
10-year period.
Africa is aware that the principal causes for the
conflicts in the continent have a direct relationship
with circumstances resulting from the complexity of its
ethnic and linguistic phenomena. However, they are
also fundamentally linked to the underdevelopment
that is a consequence of the undeniable legacy of a
long period of colonization that dramatically marked
the course of its history. It is in that context that the
AU, along with subregional economic communities,
has been deeply engaged in the operationalization of its
peace and security structures and mechanisms, namely
the African Standby Force, the early warning system,
the Panel of the Wise and the Special Fund for peace
and security.
We understand that in order for the United
Nations and the AU to be able to adequately counter
the constraints on the efficiency of the necessary
cooperation in the domain of conflict prevention,
management and resolution, it is of the utmost
necessity to address the issues of peace and security in
an inclusive manner, not dissociating them from
development problems. The convergence of those
elements is fundamental for the success of
peacekeeping operations. That is one of the lessons we
learned while following and observing certain conflict
resolution, peace consolidation and economic
reconstruction processes as the first Chairman of the
United Nations Peacebuilding Commission, in 2006
and 2007.
As we have already mentioned, peace and social
development are correlated elements that complement
one another. Having achieved peace, the Republic of
Angola has been undertaking enormous efforts to
create subjective and material conditions for its
reconstruction, with a View to reaching sustained
development. The accomplishments of my Government
have deserved the recognition of all the Angolan
society and the international community, in light of the
tangible results already reached in the recovery of the
economic and social infrastructure destroyed during
the war and in the construction of new infrastructure.
Judging from the positive trend in our economic
growth, which is above of 19 per cent, our perspectives
are, frankly, encouraging.
It is in this perspective that the Angolan
Government conceived and is implementing the
National Strategy for Poverty Reduction in order to
reach the human development indicators set out in the
Millennium Declaration. Our experience has
demonstrated that in the African context, the
consolidation of peace results from the combination of
various factors such as the conception and
implementation of a coherent policy of national
reconciliation, the implementation of economic
reforms that favour the provision of ample space for
free initiative on the part of national and foreign
citizens, the constant reinforcement of State authority
as an imperative for the consolidation of democratic
institutions, and respect for and safeguarding of human
rights as a component of peace, democracy and
development, among others.
Indeed, under the able leadership of the President
of the Republic, Jose Eduardo dos Santos, Angola has
been removing the hurdles that hindered the smile of
its people. Today, only six years after the end of the
internal conflict that lacerated the country for several
decades, peace and national reconciliation are
consolidated, and with them democracy, whose
consecration will be strengthened with the holding, for
the second time in the history of Angola, of the
legislative and presidential elections foreseen for 2008
and 2009, respectively.
The Republic of Angola reiterates, therefore, its
firm commitment to working in a self-sacrificing and
altruistic manner in the Peace and Security Council of
the African Union, and in the subregional organizations
of which it is a member, towards helping to find
peaceful solutions for the conflicts that still persist in
certain countries of our continent. To that effect, my
Government considers the cooperation between the
African Union and the United Nations to be of extreme
importance.
I would like to state that my delegation will
support the deliberative text that will result from our
debate.
The President: I now invite the Deputy Minister
for Foreign Affairs and Special Envoy of the President
of Egypt, Mr. Ibrahim Ali Hassan, to take the floor.
Mr. Hassan (Egypt) (spoke in Arabic): Allow me
at the outset to convey the greetings of His Excellency
President Mohamed Hosni Mubarak and his wishes for
the full success of this summit. We would also like to
extend our thanks and appreciation to His Excellency
President Thabo Mbeki, President of the Republic of
South Africa, for his constructive initiative in calling
for this important meeting at this high level to discuss
one of the most important issues of concern for Africa
and the world.
I am confident we all agree on the high priority
that the issue of peace and security represents on the
international list of concerns and on the agenda for
African collective action. This matter was clearly
reflected in devising the Constitutive Act of the African
Union (AU) in 2001 and earlier in the Charter of the
Organization of African Unity, in 1963. The issue of
peace and security in the African continent also comes
at the forefront in the New Partnership for Africa's
Development (NEPAD) document, which considered it
a necessary precondition for achieving comprehensive
development in the continent, hence emphasizing the
firm correlation between the promotion of peace and
security on the one side and the efforts to eradicate
poverty and achieve the Millennium Development
Goals on the other.
In this context, the African Union has been keen
on establishing institutions and mechanisms that are
capable of dealing, both seriously and effectively, with
conflict situations in Africa. Efforts have not been
confined only to the establishment of the African
Union Peace and Security Council, which plays a
crucial role in promoting security, stability and in
dispute settlement in the continent; they also extend to
the establishment of the African Standby Force, the
Panel of the Wise, a Peace Fund and a continental early
warning system, along with a comprehensive political
framework for reconstruction and rehabilitation in
countries emerging from conflict. That rendered the
AU highly capable of taking rapid and effective actions
to contain existing conflicts and avert the emergence of
new ones. As a result, many conflicts were resolved
within the past few years, bringing the number down
from 12 at the beginning of this century to a limited
number, for which efforts are under way to find
peaceful settlements.
The NEPAD initiative was launched in tandem
with the establishment of the African Peer Review
Mechanism in order to consolidate the pillars of good
economic and political governance, in fulfilment of the
aspirations of the peoples of the continent for a
promising future based on solidarity and integration
and arising from the principle of African national
ownership, stressing that the future of Africa will be
built by the Africans themselves.
Despite the numerous developments and the
continuing changes on the regional and international
scenes - which all reaffirm the need for further
cooperation and consultation between the United
Nations Security Council and the African Union Peace
and Security Council - we still lack the institutional
mechanism needed to consolidate such cooperation in a
specific framework that commits to the historical,
cultural and developmental particularities of the
African States. Such a framework must take into
consideration the delicate balance agreed upon in the
2005 United Nations Summit between the issues of
peace and security, economic and social development
and respect for the human rights and fundamental
freedoms of the African citizen.
At an early stage Egypt discerned the dire need to
bolster the cooperation between the United Nations and
the AU. To that end, Egypt proposed, during its
presidency of the African Union Peace and Security
Council in December 2006, its well-known initiative to
establish a Coordination and Consultation Mechanism
between the African Union Peace and Security Council
and the United Nations Security Council. We would
like to place on record our appreciation for the warm
welcome and interest with which the Egyptian
initiative was received and for the progress achieved in
its invigoration through joint sessions of the two
organs.
Furthermore, Egypt emphasizes the need to
promote cooperation and consultation between the
peace and security structures on both sides through
exchanging information and reports between the two
Councils, dispatching fact-finding missions or
conducting joint missions. In addition, there is a need
to speedily adopt the appropriate norms and to agree on
the necessary conditions by which to consider African
peacekeeping missions as United Nations missions and
to provide the necessary funding. Such coordination
should also expand to include the various African
subregional arrangements, as they play a vital role in
dispute settlement and maintaining peace and security
in the continent through their active regional
mechanisms.
Moreover, there is a much-needed constructive
cooperation between the United Nations, the League of
Arab States and the Organization of Islamic
Conference in maintaining international peace and
security. We wish to highlight in this respect the
ongoing cooperation between the AU and the
subregional economic groups and the increasing
coordination between the AU and the League of Arab
States to achieve security and stability in Africa and to
contribute jointly to the settlement of existing conflicts
in a number of African States, such as the Sudan,
Somalia and the Comoros, etc. We salute the summit
decisions on both sides, as they reveal how highly they
value the cooperation between them, and underscore
the need to carry on their efforts to reinforce peace and
security in Africa.
In the light of its responsibilities towards the AU
and the United Nations, Egypt has steadily been keen
on actively participating in peacekeeping operations,
most recently through its broad participation in the
Hybrid Operation in Darfur. Within the framework of
capacity-building in preventive diplomacy, it has
established the regional Cairo Center for Training on
Conflict Resolution and Peacekeeping in Africa, which
since 1995 has been organizing regular training courses
for African diplomatic and military cadres to enable
them to gain the necessary capabilities in the field.
Furthermore, Egypt attaches great importance to
the issue of peacebuilding and reconstruction in the
area, especially in countries emerging from conflict. In
the context of its membership in the Peacebuilding
Commission, Egypt is eager to elevate the standards of
those efforts so as to reach a situation that would
magnify the benefits derived from the international and
regional financial institutions and to serve the process
of rehabilitation and reconstruction in those States.
I would like to conclude by reaffirming that
Egypt is keen to continue to advance its role in the
African continent. It is committed to continue and
reinforce its contributions in peacekeeping operations,
settling disputes and achieving security and stability in
the continent. I reaffirm our confidence that the
resolution to be adopted by this summit will positively
contribute to consolidating the pillars of cooperation,
coordination and complementarity between the efforts
of the United Nations on one hand and the pivotal role
undertaken by the AU and other regional organizations
on the other, towards fulfilling the aspirations and
ambitions of our peoples in a safe world where we all
live in peace, freedom and prosperity.
The President: I next invite the Minister for
Foreign Affairs of Liberia, Her Excellency Madam
Olubanke King-Akerele, to take the floor.
Madam King-Akerele (Liberia): It is an honour
to address this body, representing Her Excellency the
President of Liberia, Madam Ellen J ohnson-Sirleaf.
She was unable to be here as she would have liked. On
her behalf, we want to congratulate South Africa on its
presidency of the Security Council, while commending
the Council on this initiative. We also wish to thank the
Secretary-General for his very thought-provoking
report and the proposals contained therein.
I wish to state here that Liberia is an example par
excellence of what can be accomplished through a
combination of a regional initiative - in our case, the
Economic Community of West African States
(ECOWAS), which took the high road in intervening in
the Liberian crises in the 19905 - and then the
international community, through the United Nations
Mission in Liberia (UNMIL) in the following years.
Let me begin by referring to the intervention of
the Special Representative of the United Nations
Secretary-General to Liberia, Ellen Margrethe Loj,
who addressed the Council on 14 April (5864th meeting) and to brief it on the status of developments
in Liberia. Having benefited and continuing to benefit
from an extraordinary United Nations presence through
UNMIL, which combines a range of peacekeeping
forces representative of the United Nations
membership, we remain most grateful for that role. The
peace we enjoy today is largely attributable to their
presence, as well as to the fact that ECOWAS laid the
foundations in the 1990s. Indeed, many of our
ECOWAS brothers have paid dearly for that peace.
Given the fragility of that peace - the reasons
for which were detailed by Ms. Loj - it is clear that
there is still much to be done if we are to achieve
sustainable peace and security. Hence the subtitle of
my intervention on the issue before us today: "No
sustainable security without development; no
development without sustainable security".
If we are to have an enhanced and meaningful
relationship between the United Nations Security
Council and the African Union (AU) Peace and
Security Council, that perspective must guide us. I now
want to focus on a few specifics.
The objectives of the AU Peace and Security
Council include the promotion of peace, security and
stability in Africa, the anticipation and prevention of
conflict and the promotion of peacebuilding and post-
conflict reconstruction. In the letter dated 8 April from
the Permanent Representative of South Africa
addressed to the Secretary-General transmitting the
concept paper (S/2008/229), it is indicated that today's
debate will provide an opportunity to address, at the
highest political level, the complex nature of some
current conflicts and the need to respond in a timely
manner to threats, taking into account factors such as
the capacity - and, at times, the limitations - of
regional organizations. Here, I want to underscore the
word "threats".
Liberia wishes to submit that the growing food
crisis is not only a worldwide crisis, but is also proving
to be a major security issue for the continent. It is a
serious threat to peace and security that could
undermine the gains that are being made throughout
the continent if it is not addressed urgently. A recent
Jeune Afrique article refers to it as a food crisis that is
spreading like wildfire. Thus, protests have been
sparked throughout the continent, from Morocco to
Mauritania and Senegal and from cote d'Ivoire to
Mozambique, Tunisia, Cameroon, Burkina Faso, Egypt
and Tunisia. This speaks for itself.
Surely that is sufficient warning: we can ill afford
to wait. Liberia proposes high-level attention and the
holding, on an urgent basis, of a special meeting of the
Security Council on the food crisis. We further propose
that we join forces, bringing together the expertise of
the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United
Nations, the African Union and relevant food-
producing countries in Asia and food-importing
countries in Africa and elsewhere to tackle this matter
within the shortest time possible. We believe that, on
this issue, we need the equivalent of Security Council
resolution 1325 (2000), on women and peace and
security.
In addition, this situation will undermine one of
the key Millennium Development Goals, related to
improving food security. This is a major security
matter that needs to be tackled. It is at the core of the
economics of insecurity, with which we all must be
concerned if we are to achieve sustainable security.
Next, I would like to refer to Council resolution
1325 (2000), on women and peace and security. It is an
excellent example of an important Security Council
resolution that is being considered and implemented at
the local and national levels in many African countries,
including my own. That resolution has now been
adopted in the context of an African Union declaration
of heads of State. However, we need a mechanism for
monitoring its implementation, and we urge the
Security Council to look into that. We are pleased that,
in response to the resolution, the Secretary-General has
appointed a woman as his Special Representative for
Liberia. Indeed, we believe that Liberia could be used
as a case in point in the implementation of the
resolution. Plans are under way for the Presidents of
Finland and Liberia to convene a meeting in 2009 on
women and international peace and security, within the
framework of the resolution.
I would now like to highlight the importance of
collaboration between the African Union and the
United Nations Security Council to ensure stronger
border security among African countries, in order to
implement counter-terrorism measures and to control
the trafficking of small arms and light weapons.
With regard to the series of reports on various
topics submitted by United Nations panels of experts to
the Security Council and other bodies, while Liberia
fully appreciates their importance, we would like to
emphasize that they need to include the views and
contributions of the relevant countries.
As far as the African Union and Security Council
forces in Darfur are concerned, there are clearly major
lessons which we must learn and on the basis of which
we must make corrections.
In closing, I wish to reiterate Liberia's View, in
the light of its very painful experiences over the past
15 years, that Africa's leadership must, through the
African Union, do everything possible to avert the
looming crises that pose threats to the continent and to
world peace and security. I also wish to reiterate that
there can be no sustainable security without
development and no development without sustainable
security.
The President: I now give the floor to Her
Excellency Mrs. Bernadette Simvura, representative of
Burundi.
Mrs. Simvura (Burundi) (spoke in French): First
of all, I should like to convey to you, Madam
President, the apologies of Her Excellency
Ms. Antoinette Batumubwira, Minister for Foreign
Affairs of the Republic of Burundi. For reasons beyond
her control, she was obliged to leave the Chamber in
order to catch her flight this afternoon. She requested
that I read out the following message to the Council.
"Permit me at the outset to express the
regrets of His Excellency the President of the
Republic of Burundi, who is unable to attend this
meeting. The President, Mr. Pierre Nkurunziza,
requested that I wish you, Madam President,
every success in this meeting and express
Burundi's commitment to work within the United
Nations and the African Union for regional and
international peace and security.
"Burundi's presence at this meeting, and its
commitment to strengthen the relationship
between the United Nations Security Council and
the African Union Peace and Security Council,
are based on three considerations.
"First, since 1 April 2008, Burundi has been
a member of the African Union Peace and
Security Council. Therefore, the Government of
Burundi is preparing to contribute to that
important task with every means at its disposal.
"Secondly, over the past 15 years, Burundi
has benefited from the support and assistance of
the United Nations, in particular the Security
Council, and of the African Union, in particular
its Peace and Security Council.
"In that regard, our experience as a country
that has seen the deployment of Organization of
African Union observer missions and the African
Union Mission in Burundi, followed by the
United Nations Operation in Burundi, equips us
today to make a valuable contribution to the
analyses and debates on issues relating to joint
efforts between the United Nations and the
African Union aimed at restoring and maintaining
peace. Beginning with peacekeeping efforts by
the United Nations and the African Union,
Burundi has now moved on to the peacebuilding
phase. In that connection as well, Burundi's
contribution will be enriched by our experience.
"Thirdly, and finally, our participation in
this meeting is relevant because Burundi is taking
part in peacekeeping operations in Africa. A
Burundian national defence force battalion is now
in Somalia as part of the African Union Mission
in Somalia. A second battalion is preparing to
deploy to Somalia. Although we have been
saddened by the death of a soldier in that
operation, the Government of Burundi continues
to believe that it has a duty to contribute in this
way to peace on our continent, all the more so
because our country has enjoyed the support of
many African countries and countries from other
continents. In that regard, I wish in particular to
refer to the large South African contingent that
has already contributed a great deal in the
context, initially, of African Union and,
subsequently, of United Nations peacekeeping
efforts in Burundi. Our military and police
officers are also participating in observer
missions in Darfur and Cote d'Ivoire. Burundi
also plans to send troops to Chad.
"It is in the light of all these considerations
that the Government of Burundi is here today. We
hope that the draft resolution to be adopted at the
end of this meeting of the Security Council on
Cooperation with the African Union will enjoy
the full political and financial support necessary
for its implementation. At stake is the credibility
of our two organizations - and, more so, that of
our overriding commitment to maintain regional
and international peace and security."
The President: I now give the floor to Her
Excellency Ms. Sanya Stiglic, Permanent
Representative of Slovenia.
Ms. Stiglic (Slovenia): I have the honour to
address the Council on behalf of the European Union
(EU). The candidate countries Turkey, Croatia and the
former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, the countries
of the Stabilization and Association Process and
potential candidates Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina,
Montenegro and Serbia, and the European Free Trade
Association countries Liechtenstein and Norway,
members of the European Economic Area, as well as
Ukraine, the Republic of Moldova, Armenia and
Georgia, align themselves with this statement.
Given the time constraints, I will shorten my
statement. The full version is now being distributed
and constitutes our official statement.
The creation of the African Union (AU) and its
organs has been one of the most promising
developments in recent years. It is therefore highly
appropriate to focus this discussion on Africa. The very
presence of such distinguished guests adds particular
weight to the significance of today's debate.
I would like especially to thank the Secretary-
General for his remarks and his personal commitment
to promoting dialogue between the United Nations and
regional and subregional organizations.
The European Union is firmly committed to, and
actively supports, effective multilateralism. In that
context, the importance of regional organizations and
their potential in preventive diplomacy, peacekeeping,
peacemaking and post-conflict peacebuilding has
grown considerably over the past years. It is only to be
expected that their contribution in the foreseeable
future will continue to increase steadily.
The development of a stronger international
society, well-functioning international institutions and
a rules-based international order with the United
Nations at its core is a central objective of the
European Union, which recalls the primary
responsibility of the Security Council to maintain
international peace and security. Regional
organizations can reinforce and complement United
Nations efforts through an active role in maintaining
international peace and security, in the spirit of Chapter
VIII of the Charter, as was also stressed in resolution
1631 (2005).
The European Union seeks to strengthen
cooperation with the United Nations on, inter alia,
areas of crisis management and peacekeeping
operations, counter-terrorism, human rights,
sustainable development and climate change. In recent
years, the European Union has made significant
progress in the development of its own crisis
management structures. This has allowed the EU to
deploy numerous civilian and military operations,
many of them in support of or at the request of the
United Nations.
Under the framework of the European Security
and Defence Policy, and in addition to individual EU
member States' commitments, the European Union
continues to support peacekeeping efforts in Africa,
particularly in the Democratic Republic of the Congo,
Guinea-Bissau, Chad and the Central African Republic,
in line with substantial European Commission support.
We remain committed to further developing our
relationship with the United Nations, especially by
working closely together in implementing the joint
statement on United Nations-EU cooperation in crisis
management signed in June 2007.
The second European Union-Africa Summit, held
in Lisbon in 2007, laid down the foundations of a
strategic partnership. We have reached a new milestone
in our cooperation. In the field of peace and security,
the first priority of the partnership aims at
strengthening dialogue to reach common positions and
implement common approaches on challenges to peace
and security in Africa, in Europe and globally. The
second priority is to work together towards the full and
effective functioning of the African peace and security
architecture, in particular through the African standby
force, the Continental Early Warning System and
regional mechanisms and organizations. The third
priority is to provide predictable and sustainable
financing for Africa-led peace support operations, to
ensure that the AU and regional mechanisms will be
able to plan and conduct peace support operations.
Substantial support has been provided to capacity-
building at the regional and subregional levels, as well
as to specific African-led peace operations, including
in Darfur, Somalia and the Central African Republic.
These operations have been supported by the Peace
Facility for Africa, through which €350 million has
already been committed, and by bilateral contributions
of EU member States. Furthermore, we are working
with the Group of Eight (G-8) and other members of
the international community to contribute to the
funding of African-led peace support operations.
A culture of prevention is indeed gaining ground,
as is the understanding of the need to strengthen and
support the tools used when responding to situations
that could potentially lead to violence. In parallel,
more attention has been given to addressing the root
causes of conflict. The sooner we act to prevent
conflict, the greater the chances of success.
The EU recognizes the importance of different
conflict prevention tools, as highlighted in the report of
the Secretary-General (S/2008/ 18). The use of quiet
diplomacy and preventive mediation, such as the
Mediation Support Unit of the Department for Political
Affairs, as well as the effective use of sanctions and the
Secretary-General's good offices, are essential in de-
escalating potential violent conflicts.
The European Union believes that it is essential
to include civil society in conflict prevention, as it
promotes encouraging links between civil society and
Government, as well as local ownership. Moreover,
women should play a positive role in conflict
prevention, and they are still underrepresented in
formal stages of conflict prevention. Similarly, the
implementation of resolution 1612 (2005) on children
affected by armed conflict continues to require further
application.
The European Union considers the Peacebuilding
Commission to be an important achievement of the
United Nations reform process. We welcome the
engagement the Commission has shown in Burundi and
Sierra Leone in the first year of operation, and
welcome the placing of Guinea-Bissau on its agenda.
Through the European Development Fund and other
European Commission instruments, the EU plays a
major role in assisting those countries in meeting their
peacebuilding challenges. The recent launch of the
European Security and Defence Policy mission in
support of security sector reform in Guinea-Bissau
further reaffirms the EU's readiness to use its full
policy mix of instruments in support of the work of the
Peacebuilding Commission.
The European Union remains committed to
international justice, which is particularly relevant in
conflict areas. We firmly believe that there can be no
impunity, in particular for the most serious crimes, and
that there can be no long-standing peace without
justice.
While the primary responsibility for conflict
prevention rests with Member States, the international
community is crucial in providing much-needed
support, especially through regional and subregional
organizations. The recent support provided by the
United Nations and the EU to such organizations in
their efforts to improve relations between political
parties in Kenya, as well as ongoing international and
regional efforts in dealing with humanitarian and
security situations such as those in the Democratic
Republic of the Congo, the Sudan and Somalia, only
reaffirm the need to further cooperation with regional
organizations.
The European Union remains very concerned
about the political situation in Zimbabwe and will
continue to closely monitor the situation on the ground
and support efforts towards ensuring democracy,
stability, economic recovery and respect for human
rights. The European Union supports the call launched
at the special summit of the Southern Africa
Development Community for the expeditious release of
the presidential election results, in accordance with the
due process of law. It reiterates its concern at the
prolonged and unexplained delay in releasing the
presidential results, which is undermining the
credibility of the process.
In conclusion, I would like to thank South Africa
for its leadership in convening this debate. Let me
reaffirm that it is a priority for the European Union to
continue providing its expertise and resources to peace
and stability in Africa as a partner of both the United
Nations and the African Union.
The President: I now call on His Excellency
Mr. Vanu Gopala Menon, Permanent Representative of
Singapore.
Mr. Menon (Singapore): I am making this
statement on behalf of the 10 States members of the
Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN).
Today, we live in a more complex and
interconnected world, with many new actors on the
international stage and more variables and alignments
to consider. While the threat of global war has receded,
there has been an increase in the number of smaller
conflicts. Those are often asymmetric, low-intensity
and diffused. It has become a messier world. The
situation presents new challenges to global peace and
security. Obviously, the United Nations has a crucial
role to play, but in a globalized world regional
cooperation can also play a key role. Even the United
Nations Charter recognizes the role that regional
arrangements can play in helping the United Nations to
achieve its objectives.
ASEAN and the African Union (AU) are
examples of regional organizations that have helped to
build and protect regional peace and security. We note
that many ASEAN members have long-standing
historical ties with Africa. Since 1955, the Bandung
Asian-African Conference has promoted the Bandung
spirit of solidarity, friendship and cooperation between
Asia and Africa. That spirit was reaffirmed by
President Thabo Mbeki of South Africa on behalf of
the African Union at the eighth ASEAN summit in
Cambodia in November 2002. President Mbeki not
only recalled the historical roots of cooperation
between Asia and Africa, but he also commended
ASEAN's programmes in South-South cooperation and
its determined efforts to promote a region free of
nuclear weapons and terrorism.
In response, ASEAN leaders found much
common ground with African aspirations and
acknowledged the need for greater interaction between
ASEAN and the AU. They acknowledged the need for
greater interaction between the two regional
organizations, including a possible meeting between
the two secretariats. They also agreed to take steps to
promote stronger ties between Asia and Africa,
including convening an ASEAN-New Partnership for
Africa's Development conference.
That idea was soon followed by the Asian-
African Subregional Organizations Conference
(AASROC) process, which was initiated in Bandung,
Indonesia, in 2003. A second AASROC was held in
Durban, South Africa, in 2004. In 2005, an Asia-Africa
Summit was held in Bandung, commemorating the
golden jubilee of the Bandung spirit. At the Summit,
the leaders of the Asian and African countries adopted
a declaration on the New Asian-African Strategic
Partnership to serve as a framework for building
stronger links between Asia and Africa covering three
broad areas of partnership - political solidarity,
economic cooperation and sociocultural relations. The
Strategic Partnership would address issues of common
concern, such as armed conflicts, weapons of mass
destruction, transnational organized crime and
terrorism, which are fundamental to ensuring peace,
stability and security. In that respect, ASEAN looks
forward to the further strengthening of cooperation
with the AU.
As a regional organization, the AU serves as a
key forum for African States to interact and cooperate
with each other to promote such common objectives as
good governance, sustainable development, and peace
and stability. For example, AU peacekeepers have been
deployed to areas such as Burundi, Somalia, the
Comoros and Darfur. We note that a mutually
beneficial AU-United Nations partnership has grown
over the years and continues to serve as a good
example of how regional organizations can positively
contribute to the maintenance of international peace
and security. ASEAN supports all efforts to strengthen
the AU-United Nations partnership.
On our part, ASEAN has evolved into a
multifaceted organization with cooperation in many
fields. A shared sense of destiny and community
motivated us to conclude the ASEAN Charter last year.
The Charter reflects our common vision and
commitment to the development of an ASEAN
community as a region of lasting peace and stability,
sustained economic growth, shared prosperity and
social progress. It will remake ASEAN into a more
effective and rules-based organization in today's
rapidly changing global landscape.
ASEAN has always regarded economic
cooperation as a key factor to achieving peace and
prosperity in the region. In that regard, our leaders
adopted an ASEAN economic community blueprint last
year to integrate the 10 ASEAN economies into one
single market and production base. We will also be
developing similar blueprints for our other two
pillars - political security and sociocultural
cooperation. For example, within ASEAN, we have
recently instituted the ASEAN defence ministers
meeting to further enhance mutual trust and confidence
among our defence establishments and to explore
practical and concrete cooperation. That allows us to
actively address non-traditional and transborder
security concerns among our members and with
external partners.
In conclusion, allow me to express ASEAN's
appreciation to the AU and the United Nations for the
growing collaboration over the years. As observed by
President Mbeki in 2002, the potential for ASEAN and
the AU to enhance mutual understanding and
cooperation is significant. As for ASEAN-United
Nations cooperation, that has existed since our
establishment in 1967. We are pleased that ASEAN
acquired formal observer status in the United Nations
in 2006, and concluded a memorandum of
understanding on ASEAN-United Nations cooperation
the following year. Those moves reaffirm the mutual
commitment between our regional grouping and the
United Nations. ASEAN looks forward to enhanced
cooperation with both the AU and the United Nations
in working towards preserving international peace and
security and promoting sustainable development.
The President: I now give the floor to His
Excellency Mr. Yahya Mahmassani, Permanent
Observer of the League of Arab States.
Mr. Mahmassani (League of Arab States) (spoke in Arabic): Allow me at the outset to congratulate you,
Sir, on your assumption of the presidency of the
Security Council for this month. I should also like to
commend your initiative to convene this debate to
enhance the Security Council's role in strengthening
the relationship between the United Nations and
regional organizations, in particular the African Union,
in the maintenance of international peace and security.
I take this opportunity to express our appreciation
to your predecessor, the Permanent Representative of
the Russian Federation, for his successful presidency
of the Council last month.
In view of the geographical and historical ties
between the African Union (AU) and the League of
Arab States, I want to stress the importance of
horizontal cooperation among regional organizations.
This is exemplified by the distinguished record of
cooperation between the Arab League and the AU.
Eighty per cent of Arab League citizens reside on the
African continent, and 50 per cent of the League's
member States are also members of the African Union.
Moreover, 20 per cent of African Union member States
are members of the League of Arab States. This unique
situation must be taken into account in considering the
advantages offered by horizontal cooperation between
the two organizations.
In the light of their common responsibilities and
the interrelated interests of their member States,
regional organizations possess distinct advantages that
enable them to address regional challenges and threats
to international peace and security. These include their
proximity to conflict areas and their knowledge and
well-informed views on the specifics of the conflicts.
The great challenges of the first years of the
twenty-first century have resulted in stronger
cooperation between the United Nations and regional
organizations in the implementation of the relevant
resolutions and statements of the Security Council and
of the provisions of the 2005 World Summit Outcome
(General Assembly resolution 60/1).
In the framework of the shared responsibility of
the United Nations and regional organizations in the
maintenance of international peace and security and of
the geographic and demographic interrelationship
between the Arab League and the African Union, the
two organizations have been taking positive steps in
the settlement of conflict issues. Effective cooperation
between our organizations has proven to be a viable
approach to resolving a number of crises and other
issues, along with strengthened cooperation between
the United Nations and our two organizations with a
View to safeguarding security and stability throughout
the African continent. We have witnessed this in the
Sudan peace negotiations and in the process of finding
a way to resolve the Darfur crisis, as well as in the
effort to attain security and stability in Somalia and,
more recently, in the Union of the Comoros. This
embodies the concept of tripartite cooperation among
the United Nations, the League of Arab States and the
African Union.
The Charter of the United Nations gives the
Security Council primary responsibility for the
maintenance of international peace and security. But
cooperation between the United Nations and regional
organizations has become inevitable; it is at the heart
of the interests and the policies of regional
organizations, owing to the positive and effective role
those organizations play in addressing regional issues
and in the peaceful settlement of disputes. Regional
organizations make an effective contribution to
strengthening United Nations capacities, especially in
the spheres of preventive diplomacy, peacemaking,
peacekeeping and exchanges of expertise.
The Security Council should undertake effective
cooperation with regional organizations, including the
African Union, in order to bolster its important role in
the maintenance of international peace and security and
in conflict prevention. It should define guiding
principles for the expansion of dialogue and
cooperation between the United Nations Security
Council and the African Union Peace and Security
Council in order to foster the political will needed to
maintain peace and to implement the relevant
resolutions.
In the context of strengthening the partnership
between the African Union and the Security Council in
the maintenance of international peace and security, the
Council must be more responsive and must make a
greater effort to achieve the partnership we are seeking
and to overcome the challenges it is facing. This would
be facilitated by early warning systems to address and
manage crises before they escalate, as well as by a
process by which to allocate responsibilities and by an
expansion of the scope of AU-Security Council
cooperation and consultation.
Enhancing the regional dimension of
peacemaking and strengthening the leading role of the
AU in conflict prevention and resolution in Africa are
of great importance, and the Security Council must
provide logistical and technical support to AU member
States as they work to maintain the peace in post-
conflict situations. It is also important to improve
coordination among various African initiatives, to
provide peacekeeping training and to establish regional
centres in order to prevent crises from recurring and to
enhance the financial and administrative capacity of
the AU with respect to peacekeeping operations, the
protection of civilians and the delivery of humanitarian
aid to those affected by conflict.
Issues related to international peace and security
are closely linked with those related to development
and economic growth in Africa; thus, the United
Nations must not view African issues in strictly
security or political terms. These are economic and
development issues as well, and they require greater
political will to provide further support to the AU,
enabling it to address and overcome the challenges
facing it, to make progress in the implementation of the
New Partnership for Africa's Development and to free
the continent from conflict.
In addition, cooperation between the United
Nations and regional organizations in the maintenance
of international peace and security must be enhanced in
the framework of United Nations reform. That means
reforming its institutions and improving its
performance to equip it better to confront the
challenges facing the international community.
The President: I now call on His Excellency
Mr. Yukio Takasu, Permanent Representative of Japan.
Mr. Takasu (Japan): First of all, I would like to
express my deep appreciation to you, Mr. President,
and, through you, to all the other members of the
Council for giving me the opportunity to address this
high-level meeting in my capacity as Chair of the
Peacebuilding Commission. The Peacebuilding
Commission is actively engaged in effectively
supporting post-conflict peacebuilding efforts, in the
belief that the measure of its success is real impact on
the ground.
In accordance with its mandate, the
Peacebuilding Commission is striving to marshal
support and resources for peacebuilding and recovery
in post-conflict countries and to improve coordination
within and outside the United Nations system in an
integrated manner. We have been trying our best to
enhance cooperation with partners beyond the United
Nations system, such as regional and subregional
organizations, international financial institutions,
bilateral donors and civil society.
One of the key observations from our intensive
work is that all peacebuilding efforts require
addressing the regional as well as the local dimensions.
As most conflicts have significant regional dimensions,
it is indispensable to engage regional and subregional
organizations in the process. Issues such as the illicit
trade in arms and narcotics trafficking cannot be
addressed without coordinated regional and
international efforts, including effective border control
among the countries in a given region. Youth
unemployment and a lack of economic opportunities
are widely recognized as a common challenge to post-
conflict societies. This problem also requires a regional
approach, as unemployed youth often move from one
place to another in search of employment
opportunities, including, sometimes, as soldiers. The
Peacebuilding Commission has analysed those issues
and has offered practical guidance in our country-
specific activities and in the Working Group on
Lessons Learned.
The Peacebuilding Commission truly values the
ongoing efforts of regional and subregional
organizations. These organizations play an important
role in the areas of conflict prevention and
peacebuilding. At the same time, their activities are
more effective when they are fully integrated into, and
well coordinated with, the overall work of the
Commission. Successful peacebuilding requires the
sustained engagement of multifaceted stakeholders
with diverse expertise and specialties. I recognize the
essential added value that the Peacebuilding
Commission can provide with its convening role of
mobilizing the dedicated efforts of all stakeholders.
The founding resolutions of the Peacebuilding
Commission refer directly to Chapter VIII of the
United Nations Charter and thereby provide a strong
rationale for close collaboration between the
Commission and regional and subregional
organizations. The Commission will explore practical
and flexible ways to cooperate and make a concrete
difference on the ground.
The first three countries to be considered by the
Commission, namely, Burundi, Sierra Leone and
Guinea-Bissau, are all in Africa. As a member of all
three country-specific configurations of the
Commission, the African Union has been an effective
and active contributor to the Council's deliberations,
both in New York and on the ground. We value and
appreciate the Union's effective partnership. In that
connection, I would like to suggest two ways of
promoting more enhanced collaboration between the
African Union and the Peacebuilding Commission.
First, the African Union may wish to have more
active inputs in the process of drafting and
implementing the integrated peacebuilding strategies of
the Peacebuilding Commission and to align itself more
closely with them. The strategies are articulated in such
a way as to minimize the risk of relapse into conflict,
and they thus also contribute to conflict prevention.
The integrated strategies elaborated for Burundi and
Sierra Leone serve as a good basis for cooperation
activities by the African Union.
Secondly, we see great potential in harmonizing
the policy framework on post-conflict reconstruction
and development adopted by the African Union's
Executive Council and the work of the Peacebuilding
Commission, which take similar approaches to
promoting post-conflict peacebuilding. The
Peacebuilding Support Office is engaged in active
collaboration with the AU's subcluster on the policy
framework, which is expected to produce tangible
benefits for both the Peacebuilding Commission and
the African Union Peace and Security Council. Those
efforts will also facilitate the development of linkages
between post-conflict reconstruction and development.
In conclusion, I can tell the Council that we are
making great strides in fostering close collaboration
between the Peacebuilding Commission and regional
and subregional organizations, starting with the African
Union, to promote peacebuilding and conflict
prevention in Africa. I intend to consult further with
members of the Commission on how it can best address
that need. The Commission's planned meeting
tomorrow afternoon with the Chairperson of the
African Union Peace and Security Council will provide
a useful opportunity to that end. I look forward to
fruitful discussions on that occasion.
The President: I now give the floor to His
Excellency Mr. Leslie Kojo Christian, Permanent
Representative of Ghana.
Mr. Christian (Ghana): I wish to congratulate
South Africa on presiding over the Security Council for
the month of April and on organizing this debate. I
wish to convey to the Council fraternal greetings from
His Excellency President J. A. Kufuor, who was
prevented from coming to New York by pressing
matters of State and the forthcoming twelfth session of
the United Nations Conference on Trade and
Development, to be held in Accra.
Ghana appreciates the continued support of the
United Nations and the international community aimed
at the resolution of the conflicts in Africa, including
the deployment of two thirds of all United Nations
peacekeeping operations in Africa, as well as the
commendable contributions of relief agencies towards
the alleviation of the plight of persons displaced by
conflicts. While there has been significant progress in
the resolution of some conflicts in Africa, the current
situation in other parts of the continent demands our
most urgent attention.
The role of the United Nations remains crucial in
Africa's quest for a new era of peace and stability.
Chapter VIII of the United Nations Charter, which
explicitly prescribes a role for regional organizations in
the maintenance of international peace and security,
dictates the need for a close and symbiotic relationship
between the United Nations and the African Union,
given the current situation on our continent.
In that connection, it is my delegation's view that,
if we are to ensure more effective resolution of
conflicts in Africa, there should be a calculated and
conscious strategy aimed at promoting the
interdependence of the United Nations Security
Council and the African Union Peace and Security
Council. That requires, among other things, full
implementation of the 10-year capacity-building
framework for cooperation concluded between the
Secretary-General and the African Union Commission
in November 2006.
The lack of resources, coupled with other factors,
has undermined the deployment of African Union
peacekeeping operations in Africa. Therefore, we urge
the United Nations Security Council and the
international community to step up their efforts to
address the critical resource gaps.
As recent reports of the Secretary-General have
shown, the cost of prevention is far less than the cost
of resolving conflicts. Therefore, the need to pursue a
strategy of prevention, which entails tackling the
underlying causes of conflict and instability, should
receive the priority attention of the international
community. To that end, we call upon the international
community, in particular the Security Council and the
Peacebuilding Commission, to actively support the
African Post-Conflict Reconstruction Policy
Framework, adopted in 2006, which focuses on
tackling the root causes of conflict and thereby
preventing the occurrence or recurrence of crises.
In that regard, we acknowledge the important
contribution of the Peacebuilding Commission, of
which Ghana is a current Vice-Chair, to the ongoing
efforts to rebuild Burundi, Sierra Leone and Guinea-
Bissau, aimed at ensuring sustainable peace in those
countries, which remain on the agendas of both the
Security Council and the Commission.
Africa's development blueprint, the New
Partnership for Africa's Development (NEPAD),
reaffirms the commitment of African States to the
tenets of good governance and democracy, underpinned
by the promotion of economic and social justice and
scrupulous respect for human rights and the rule of
law, as prerequisites for durable peace and security.
Ghana is proud to be among the African countries
that have so far subscribed to the African Peer Review
Mechanism in the context of NEPAD - a process by
which the quality of national governance in our
country is subjected to external scrutiny. It is our firm
conviction that it is only through such constructive
processes that Africa will emerge stronger and more
resilient. We are optimistic that the goals of the African
renaissance, namely, peace, stability and prosperity,
will be attained sooner rather than later throughout the
entire continent of Africa.
The President: I now give the floor to His
Excellency Mr. Francis K. Butagira, Permanent
Representative of Uganda.
Mr. Butagira (Uganda): Let me take this
opportunity to thank the South African presidency of
the Security Council for organizing this important
debate. My delegation is also extremely pleased at the
tireless efforts of the Secretary-General, who has
devoted so much time to the cause of global peace and
security.
In June last year in Addis Ababa, the African
Union (AU) Peace and Security Council and the United
Nations Security Council issued a joint communique
by which they committed themselves to the
development of a stronger and more structured
relationship between the Security Council and the
Peace and Security Council on conflict prevention,
management and resolution, peacekeeping and
peacebuilding, including post-conflict reconstruction
and development. They further agreed to strengthen the
relationships between all the relevant structures of the
United Nations Security Council and the AU Peace and
Security Council.
We encourage close consultations between the
African Union and this important organ of the United
Nations, whose primary responsibility is the
maintenance of international peace and security.
Africa is inspired by the spirit of collective
security of the Charter of the United Nations. It was
out of that fundamental conviction and commitment
that the AU and the AU Peace and Security Council
were born to oversee Africa's regional peace and
security concerns. We firmly believe that collective
security should be applied equitably, without
discrimination.
To millions of Africans, tangible improvements
relating to development, security and the enhancement
of human security remain pivotal. That is why we are
encouraged by the report of the Secretary-General on
the relationship between the United Nations and
regional organizations, in particular the African Union,
in the maintenance of international peace and security
(S/2008/186). The operations of regional organizations
and their relations with the United Nations must be
predicated on the principle of multilateralism. Hence,
the efforts of the United Nations Security Council and
the AU Peace and Security Council are mutually
reinforcing. However, the Security Council has primary
responsibility for the maintenance of international
peace and security.
The effectiveness of the AU's Peace and Security
Council is premised on three principles: first, the
ability to enforce agreed norms among AU member
States, secondly, the will to harmonize Africa's
regional security arrangements and, thirdly, the
commitment by African Governments to provide
sustainable and predictable financing for AU peace
initiatives.
Regrettably, for this new and struggling
organization that is grappling with a multiplicity of
problems, there are deficiencies in all three areas. That
is why we have come here to make an earnest plea that
peacekeeping operations undertaken by the AU be
covered by the regular budget of the United Nations.
The Minister for Foreign Affairs of Rwanda has made
reference to that particular aspect, as did President
Kikwete of Tanzania this morning.
The international community must demonstrate
similar concern and generosity to Africa as it did with
regard to Bosnia, Kosovo, East Timor and Afghanistan.
For instance, in 2000, while $2 billion was pledged for
the reconstruction of the Balkans, barely $150 million
was pledged for Sierra Leone. Thirty thousand NATO
troops were deployed in Kosovo, as contrasted with
16,700 United Nations troops in the enormous country
of the Democratic Republic of the Congo. The AU
Mission in Darfur was grossly underfunded, and it had
a shortfall of $200 million in July 2005. The United
Nations is dragging its feet in assuming its full
responsibility to deploy in Somalia.
In order to allay fears that Africa is a breeding
ground for terrorists, concerted efforts must be made to
stem the tide of State failure. That means that the
United Nations must invest not only in governance and
capacity-building but also in enabling African States to
address basic socio-economic problems such as the
provision of education and health services. Poverty,
alienation and dehumanizing conditions can lead to
desperation and terrorism.
Another issue of special concern to my delegation
is the need for the conclusion of a memorandum of
understanding between the United Nations
Peacebuilding Commission and the AU and the New
Partnership for Africa's Development (NEPAD), to
establish a symbiotic relationship in the post-conflict
and reconstruction areas. Such a relationship should be
based on complementarity and the avoidance of
duplication. They should enter into mutual relations to
address the multiple challenges that war-affected
societies face. They should establish a network of
institutions and mechanisms to guide, plan, monitor
and evaluate post-conflict reconstruction efforts in
Africa, to make them coherent and practical on the
ground. The Commission should avoid being
politicized, lest it become irrelevant. There is a need
for a programmatic and well-funded United Nations
Peacebuilding Commission.
In conclusion, there is an overwhelming need for
the Commission to deepen its relationship with the AU,
NEPAD and other organs.
The President: I now give the floor to His
Excellency Mr. Araya Desta, Permanent Representative
of Eritrea.
Mr. Desta (Eritrea): At the outset, I wish to thank
your delegation, Madam President, for convening this
important meeting. I also wish to express my
delegation's profound appreciation for being invited to
this debate on peace and security in Africa, which has
been organized by South Africa in its capacity as
President of the Security Council. My country holds
this issue dear. President Isaias Afwerki has expressed
his regret for not being able to attend this meeting due
to other earlier commitments.
In the interest of time, I will briefly highlight the
views of my Government on certain critical issues
facing Africa. As many speakers who have spoken
before me have highlighted the importance of
improving the institutional cooperation between the
United Nations and the African Union, consistent with
General Assembly resolution 61/296 of 17 September
2007, I shall limit my statement to a few elements.
The challenge is to build on existing cooperation
in a manner that tackles crises and conflicts on the
ground by means of real tangible commitments: first,
by addressing African priorities; secondly, by having a
common political and security assessment of a given
conflict situation; thirdly, by being able to clearly
define the role of each institution; fourthly, by
initiating joint operations on clearly defined objectives;
and, fifthly, by developing a comprehensive strategy to
resolve conflicts and other pertinent issues. All of that
requires strong political and financial commitments on
the part of both institutions to resolve many of ongoing
conflicts.
As the agenda of the Security Council
demonstrates, Africa is the region that suffers most
from intra-State and inter-State conflicts. Both the
United Nations and the African Union are engaged in
addressing many of those conflicts. Most of the
conflicts continue to cause loss of life and
immeasurable suffering to the people of our continent.
The progress made in some conflict situations is
laudable and promising. Yet, in others the response has
been slow, necessitating that efforts be accelerated in
order to end the suffering and frustration of the peoples
affected.
Eritrea, which has risen from the ashes of war
itself, is making an effort to contribute to peace and
stability in the Sudan and Chad. It remains committed
to regional peace and stability. In the same spirit and
with the same objective as in southern and eastern parts
of the Sudan, Eritrea has been working unreservedly in
partnership with the United Nations, the African Union
and neighbouring countries to bring all stakeholders to
the negotiating table, with a view to reaching and
concluding a peace agreement in Darfur.
It is important to assess every conflict situation
objectively, on its own merits. Regional peace and
security are maintained not by circumventing peace
agreements when their implementation is being
prevented, but by maintaining the integrity of those
agreements and by accepting and respecting the
authority of the bodies empowered by peace accords to
carry out their mandates. When a peace treaty is
breached and international law is violated, the Security
Council, as the United Nations body empowered to
maintain international peace and security, should
exercise its moral and legal obligation to bring the
parties into compliance, in the interests of peace and
security. The African Union must also add its voice and
moral authority to ensure that the rule of law is
respected.
I would not want to conclude my statement
without concurring with the views expressed by many
that the support given to the African Union should be
predictable and sustainable and that more time and
resources should be devoted to preventing conflicts in
our region.
It is my understanding that the Council is ready
to proceed to the vote on the draft resolution before it.
Unless I hear any objection, I shall put the draft
resolution to the vote now.
There being no objection, it is so decided.
A vote was taken by show of hands.
In favour:
Belgium, Burkina Faso, China, Costa Rica,
Croatia, France, Indonesia, Italy, Libyan Arab
Jamahiriya, Panama, Russian Federation, South
Africa, United Kingdom of Great Britain and
Northern Ireland, United States of America,
Viet Nam
The President: There were 15 votes in favour.
The draft resolution has been adopted unanimously as
resolution 1809 (2008).
I wish to thank all the participants for joining
together to make this meeting possible. My thanks go
to all the heads of State and Government, ministers and
26
other representatives, as well as to the Secretary-
General.
The Security Council has thus concluded the
present stage of its consideration of the item on its
agenda.
The meeting rose at 5.35 p.m.
08-30700
▶ Cite this page
UN Project. “S/PV.5868Resumption1.” UN Project, https://un-project.org/meeting/S-PV-5868Resumption1/. Accessed .