S/PV.5936Resumption1 Security Council
▶ This meeting at a glance
58
Speeches
0
Countries
0
Resolutions
Topics
Conflict-related sexual violence
Peacekeeping support and operations
Women, peace, and security
Sustainable development and climate
War and military aggression
Security Council deliberations
Thematic
The President: I should like to inform the
Council that I have received a letter from the
representative of South Africa, in which he requests
that the Council extend an invitation under rule 39 of
its provisional rules of procedure to Mrs. Lila Hanitra
Ratsifandrihamanana, Permanent Observer of the
African Union.
It is so decided.
I would like to remind all speakers, as I indicated
in this morning's meeting, to limit their statements to
no more than five minutes, in order to enable the
Council to carry out its work expeditiously.
Delegations with lengthy statements are kindly
requested to circulate their texts in writing and to
deliver a condensed version when speaking in this
Chamber.
I now give the floor to the representative of
Bangladesh.
Ms. Jahan (Bangladesh): I would like to thank
you, Mr. President, for organizing this open debate on
this important and topical issue.
The issue has been on the Council's agenda for
quite some time. We take note of the Secretary-
General's latest country report on children and armed
conflict and the annual report of the Working Group on
Children and Armed Conflict. It is heartening to find
that the continued engagement of the Security Council
and the efforts of its Working Group have produced
some tangible results and that many more, positive
outcomes are in the offing. In that context, we note that
certain countries and parties to conflicts have complied
with the recommendations.
While we appreciate the activities of the Working
Group, we would also like to see the discussion on its
working methods and procedural issues completed
quickly so that the Working Group can devote
itself fully to its mandated activities. The
Special Representative of the Secretary-General,
Ms. Coomaraswamy, deserves our particular praise for
her dedicated efforts in upholding the cause of children
involved in armed conflicts.
In a recent field trip to a country emerging from
conflict, I was struck by the shocking revelation of
instances of voluntary or coerced recruitment of child
soldiers in the conflict. I was struck by a story that a
2
nine-year old, who was completely deaf and dumb, was
using his toy of terror - in this instance, a loaded
machine gun - to satisfy the thrill of killing. What
prompts such actions? That is something that we need
to ponder. We need to come up with solutions.
While many child soldiers are coerced into
fighting, the induction of children into armed conflicts
is often prompted by difficult socio-economic
conditions. In that context, as also underlined in the
concept paper before us, approaching the issue from a
development perspective would be an effective way of
addressing the problem in a more sustainable manner.
While such a development approach should be a
comprehensive one, there should be a particular focus
on addressing the root causes of armed conflict from a
proper perspective.
The vulnerable situation of children in post-
conflict societies also needs special attention. For
peace to be sustained, those children must be
rehabilitated and reintegrated back into their
communities more effectively. Reintegration and
rehabilitation can be successful only if adequate
incentives are given to child combatants to return to
normal life. Reintegration would require instilling
certain societal values as well as some psychosocial
and ideological grooming of the returnees.
Rehabilitation entails child protection and welfare.
National efforts in this context should be
complemented by international assistance, including
resource mobilization. The Peacebuilding Commission
should have the issues of the rehabilitation and
reintegration of children permanently on its agenda
when taking up any country-specific configuration. The
sharing of countries' best practices would be useful in
formulating effective reintegration strategies.
The contribution of child protection advisers so
far in nine peacekeeping and political missions can be
regarded as significant progress. We would like to see
such approaches incorporated in the other ongoing
missions without delay.
The United Nations could explore the possibility
of assisting national Governments in mobilizing a
social movement in conflict-ridden and conflict-prone
countries to develop social and moral resistance to the
induction of children in armed conflict.
It is well documented that children suffer the
most under unregulated sanction regimes. The Council
08-42816
has a duty to ensure that sanctions do not affect the
innocent. The issues of children under foreign
occupation must also be appropriately addressed. There
should be special provisions for girl children, who are
particularly vulnerable to sexual exploitation and
Violence.
Despite the United Nations system-wide
response, the overall situation of children in situations
of armed conflict remains a matter of grave concern.
Ensuring compliance by non-State actors and armed
groups remains a big challenge. We must try to address
those issues in a more resolute manner.
Children are among the principal and the most
hapless Victims in all wars and civil conflicts. Armed
conflicts hold terrible consequences for children's
development and for the peace and stability of
generations to come.
Mitigating measures will have limited success
unless there is a genuine political will for conflict
prevention. We, the international community, should
join hands to work towards that end, and the Council in
particular has a responsibility in that regard.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Uganda.
Mr. Butagira (Uganda): I thank you,
Mr. President, for giving me the floor. Allow me to
congratulate you on presiding over this meeting.
Uganda has been a proponent of identifying the
causes of underage children finding their way into
armed forces, in order to find a sustainable solution to
the problem. We were quick to point out that even
though the recruitment of children into our army was
not institutionalized, we were not oblivious to the fact
that some children, owing to the breakdown in
institutional, social, economic and cultural values,
managed to circumvent the system, present false
information as to their age and be recruited. In most
cases, the abject poverty in those areas led the parents
to get their children employed in the armed forces by
overstating their ages.
That was an issue that was, in the end,
acknowledged by the Task Force on Monitoring and
Reporting and by the Secretary-General in his seventh
report to the Security Council on children and armed
conflict.
08-42816
The International Criminal Court (ICC) was
established with the determination to put an end to
impunity for perpetrators of the most serious crimes of
concern to the international community as a whole and
contribute to the prevention of such crimes. The parties
to the Rome Statute were also mindful of the millions
of children, women and men who had been Victims of
unimaginable atrocities that deeply shock the
conscience of humanity. Article 6 (e) of the Statute
recognizes that forcibly transferring children of a
national, ethnic, racial or religious group to another
group with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, the
first group constitutes genocide. Uganda holds in the
highest regard the mandate of the ICC to fight against
impunity. It is with that in mind that Uganda was the
first to make a referral.
In that same spirit of cooperation, the Ugandan
Government has been engaged in various initiatives
with the Office of the Special Representative of the
Secretary-General for Children and Armed Conflict to
put an end to the practice wherever it has been
identified and to ensure the delistment of the Uganda
People's Defence Forces (UPDF) and Local Defence
Units (LDUs) - which have now been disbanded -
from annex II of resolution 1612 (2005). In this regard,
I am happy to report that the Ugandan Government and
the Uganda Task Force on Monitoring and Reporting
have vowed to start negotiations to iron out the few
hitches inhibiting the finalization of the action plan.
This will soon be completed.
We believe that, as far as Government
cooperation goes, Uganda has exhibited an undeniable
spirit of partnership in the implementation of
resolution 1612 (2005), regardless of the circumstances
under which UPDF and LDU were included in Annex
II to the resolution.
With regard to the sanctions or punishment
regime, if it is to be believed that the motive for
punitive measures against States accused of recruiting
children into armed forces is actually to help the
children, then a different approach, in my View, may
have to be adopted. Demonizing countries and
condemning Member States, even with the objective of
ending impunity, will only delay and may derail an
otherwise noble initiative.
Uganda is of the View that the fastest and most
sustainable avenue for solving a problem is not by
placing emphasis on punishment, but by engaging the
3
parties involved in dialogue. Sanctions only punish the
most vulnerable of society and, as history will show,
only serve to harden an accused State's resolve.
In conclusion, there can be no durable solution to
a problem whose root causes have not been identified
or contextualized or are ignored when they are pointed
out. Issues like poverty, lack of vocational skills or
even the total absence of registration systems for births
in conflict areas are too serious to be pushed aside. I
would like to reiterate that Uganda remains committed
to the protection of the world's children who are
affected by armed conflict, and to ensuring respect for
international norms and standards for the protection of
children affected by armed conflict.
Mrs. Eilon Shahar (Israel): At the outset, allow
me to congratulate you, Mr. President, on your able
stewardship of the Council this month and thank you
for convening this important debate. I also wish to
thank Ms. Coomaraswamy, Mr. Mulet, Ms. Venemen
and Ms. Hunt for their informative statements and,
more importantly, for their commitment and dedication
to working on this issue before today's meeting. As
others have mentioned, we would also like to commend
the Working Group on Children and Armed Conflict,
under the able stewardship of the representative of
France, for its important work.
Children are primary Victims in many cases of
armed conflict. They are the targets of conflict and,
increasingly, its instruments. While the United Nations
has focused on the issue of children and armed conflict
since the 1996 Graca Machel report, followed by
Security Council resolution 1261 (1999) and many
others, children are still involved in armed conflict as
soldiers, with an alarming increase in cases of sexual
Violence and the culture of impunity.
In this regard, we welcome the adoption of
Security Council resolution 1820 (2008) last month,
which recognized the vulnerability of children in
armed conflict to rape and other acts of sexual
Violence. Israel, for its part, assigns great importance to
the protection of children from violence and armed
conflict, as evidenced in its signature of the
Convention on the Rights of the Child and the Optional
Protocol on armed conflict. Indeed, we maintain a
comprehensive system of laws, protecting children's
rights across the board, and pay careful attention to the
issue of children and armed conflict also through our
vast non-governmental organization and advocacy
networks.
Since the appointment of the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for Children
and Armed Conflict, we has also worked closely with
the United Nations to promote a constructive dialogue
on this issue. My delegation has followed closely the
Special Representative's recent travels around the
world and her work to raise awareness about this issue.
Despite the evident progress, lessons learned
from previous disarmament, demobilization and
reintegration (DDR) programmes for children are not
being applied to armed conflict as they should. Child
soldiers continue to be overlooked or do not have
formal access to DDR processes, and thousands of
returning soldiers do not receive demobilization
assistance. Long-term reintegration is severely under-
funded, and girls in particular are routinely neglected,
despite their involvement in the conflict as fighters or
subjection to severe sexual violence.
At the same time, there have been noticeable
achievements in protecting children, inter alia, through
Security Council resolutions that I have mentioned and
the work of the International Criminal Court. The latter
has issued arrest warrants for war crimes and crimes
against humanity that include the forced enlistment and
use of children in hostilities. Similarly, the Special
Court for Sierra Leone's decision on Brima, Kamara
and Kanu marked the first time an international
criminal tribunal has invoked the offence of
conscripting child soldiers.
The scourge of global terrorism means that
civilians today are increasingly vulnerable and
threatened, both from indiscriminate and targeted
attacks. Children have also often become the object of
terrorist interest for purposes of recruitment,
incitement to Violence and human shielding.
In our region, despite the "state of calm",
Palestinian terrorists in the Gaza Strip continue to fire
rockets indiscriminately at Israeli cities in the southern
envelope, including Sderot, placing children in
particular peril. In Sderot, up to 94 per cent of children
suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder. The
psychological effects are no less damaging than
physical wounds. Indeed, until last month, the
frequency of rocket attacks since June 2007 reached an
average of one attack every three hours.
Israeli civilians are not only the victims of
indiscriminate attacks; they are likewise targeted by
terrorists. In March 2008, a Palestinian terrorist
stormed a rabbinical seminary in Jerusalem and
murdered eight boys in cold blood. The Security
Council must unequivocally and unconditionally
condemn such terrorist attacks and call for an end to
Violence against Israeli civilians and to impunity for
those who commit acts of terrorism.
These terrorists do not even care or show concern
for their own populations. Last month, on 12 June,
Palestinian media reported that terrorists accidentally
detonated a bomb in a weapons factory housed in a
residential building in Beit Lahiya. Ten Palestinians
were killed in the explosion and several dozens were
wounded, among them many children, including the
apartment building owner's four-month-old baby
daughter. Hamas has long operated in civilian areas,
using civilians as shields, and has commandeered
schools and houses of worship for making weapons and
planning and carrying out attacks. As evidenced,
terrorism is a grave threat to all children - in our area,
both to Palestinian and to Israeli children.
As many child soldiers are found within the ranks
of armed groups, existing initiatives have limited
impact in protecting children from recruitment and use
in conflict. By their nature, armed and terrorist groups
reject pressure and persuasion to end such practices.
Hence, the international community must advocate for
context-specific and more sophisticated strategies to
address the practice of involving children in armed
conflict.
On previous occasions, my delegation has raised
the issue of indoctrination and incitement to Violence,
of youth and children in particular. Indeed, while we
tend to focus our energies primarily on the conscription
and use of children in hostilities, children need
protection from all aspects of armed conflict, including
programmatic attempts to brainwash them. In recent
months and before, Hamas's Al-Aqsa TV has
repeatedly called upon children to form human shields
and carryout attacks and violence against Israel.
Similarly, Hamas's summer camps are notorious for
their indoctrination of children with propaganda, hate
and Violence.
For the international community to truly deliver
on the issue of children and armed conflict, utilizing,
inter alia, the development approach, we must
holistically confront the conditions that condone and
promote violence in society. This must be a shared
commitment on the part of all States, parties and
people. As Nelson Mandela once said,
"No one is born hating another person because of
the color of their skin, religion or background.
Hatred and intolerance have to be learned and, if
they can be learned, so can love and tolerance,
which are more natural to the human heart. Even
in the grimmest times I have seen glimmers of
humanity, which have reassured me that man's
goodness is the flame that can never be
extinguished."
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of the Republic of Korea.
Mr. Kim (Korea): At the outset, let me express
my appreciation for the work of the Security Council
and its Working Group on Children and Armed
Conflict to end violations against children in armed
conflicts. My delegation would also like to commend
the Secretary-General's Special Representative for
Children and Armed Conflict for her dedication to the
alleviation and ultimate resolution of the plight of
children in armed conflict.
A statement by the President of the Security
Council adopted in February this year
(S/PRST/2008/6) underlined the importance of the full,
safe and unhindered access of humanitarian personnel
and goods and the delivery of humanitarian assistance
to all children affected by armed conflict. It also
expressed concern about the widespread and systematic
use of rape and other forms of sexual Violence against
children - in particular girls - during situations of
armed conflict.
The prevalence of sexual violence in armed
conflict has become horrible. The Secretary-General's
report highlighted the fact that girls, and sometimes
boys, have been targeted with various forms of sexual
and gender-based violence, including rape, during
armed conflicts. Alarmingly, close to 60 per cent of the
Victims of sexual Violence are children in various areas
of armed conflict, and sexual Violence - in particular
rape - has been deliberately used for political and
military purposes in some conflict areas.
Unless the international community -
specifically, the Security Council, which is the only
body capable of taking forceful measures - responds
with strong determination to end such Violations, the
situation cannot be improved. In that regard, the
adoption of Security Council resolution 1820 (2008) on
women and peace and security, and sexual Violence in
situations of armed conflict, is a very positive
development.
The scope of the monitoring and reporting
mechanism of resolution 1612 (2005) should be
expanded to include sexual violence as a trigger for
listing a party in the Secretary-General's annexes. That
is why many delegations welcomed the adoption of last
February's presidential statement, which demonstrated
the Security Council's readiness to review the relevant
provisions of resolution 1612 (2005). We anticipate
that a result will appear soon in the form of a new
resolution.
Ending impunity is a critical element in
addressing any kind of Violations. Impunity for parties
to an armed conflict, as well as for individual
perpetrators, should be ended. In order to do so, the
Security Council must refer systematic and persistent
Violators of children to the International Criminal
Court, while paying full attention to the development
of national justice mechanisms.
Effective implementation of resolution 1612
(2005) is also part of the critical work being done by
the Working Group on Children and Armed Conflict
and of the consideration of the Security Council itself.
The role of the Working Group could be further
strengthened if it addressed concrete measures, such as
the recommendation of targeted measures to the
Security Council, in addition to monitoring their
implementation.
Important new actors are emerging in the area of
addressing the issue of children in armed conflict.
Peacekeeping operations and political missions -
particularly their child protection advisers - are
included on the list. My delegation believes that their
role is very important not only for the full
implementation of the monitoring and reporting
mechanism, but also for the effective prevention of
Violations and for more comprehensive protection of
children.
In that regard, the Security Council and the
Secretary-General should send a strong message to the
head of each mission to provide solid leadership.
Above all, each national Government should take
ultimate responsibility for protecting its own children.
In that connection, technical and financial assistance
should be provided for capacity-building, and
Governments should cooperate fully with the Security
Council in preparing and implementing action plans,
including by establishing an effective and transparent
justice mechanism.
Finally, my delegation would like to discuss the
development approach, as emphasized in the concept
paper. We fully agree that the international community
needs a broader strategy for the protection of children
from the perspective of both prevention and
development. If we are to effectively address the
complex issue of children in armed conflicts, ending
Violations, carrying out recovery and reintegration
processes and protecting children over the long term
require the full cooperation of all relevant bodies,
including the Security Council; the Office of the
Secretary-General; peacekeeping operations; political
missions; the Peacebuilding Commission; humanitarian
agencies such as UNICEF, the Office of the United
Nations High Commissioner for Refugees and non-
governmental organizations; and development actors.
That is especially true at the field level; community-
based programmes and the participation and
contributions of non-governmental organizations are
critical.
Today's open discussion on children and armed
conflict should make a substantive contribution to the
deliberations of the Security Council, as did the most
recent open debate on that subject. The Republic of
Korea looks forward to a new draft resolution that will
move that most critical process forward.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Austria.
Mr. Pfanzelter (Austria): We are very grateful to
you, Sir, and to the Vietnamese presidency for
convening today's open debate. We share with other
speakers the desire to make our views known to the
Council, because the issue of children in armed conflict
has been a priority area of our foreign policy and
especially of our commitment within the United
Nations. We understand your advice and will follow it
as we present a shortened version of the text that is
currently being circulated.
You have invited us, Sir, to express our views on
how the Security Council, the United Nations as a
whole and the international community can better
deliver on the protection of children affected by armed
conflict. Austria fully agrees that we need to look at the
root causes of conflict in order to find sustainable
solutions. Our interventions, I think we all agree, must
be comprehensive and effective.
We also agree that there is an imperative need to
improve support for and protection of children. The
effective reintegration of children associated with
armed groups is of particular concern. Therefore, the
situation of children must be systematically included in
disarmament, demobilization and reintegration
processes. The specific needs and capacities of girls
have to be given special attention. The Austrian
Government is committed to further contributing to
efforts in support of affected children and is, as
members are aware, supporting a number of projects
implemented by United Nations partners and at the
bilateral level.
The protection of children in armed conflict is not
only a humanitarian concern, but also a significant
peace and security issue. The protection of children
must therefore be systematically considered in peace
agreements and in the mandates of United Nations
peacekeeping operations and political missions. Austria
welcomes the increasing deployment of child
protection advisers over the past few years. We also
actively support ongoing efforts within the United
Nations system to further develop good practices and
guidance for their work.
Indeed, the Security Council has an important
role to play in providing effective protection to
children in conflict situations. We wish to congratulate
the Working Group, under French chairmanship, on its
outstanding work, which is documented in the annual
report now before the Council. Over the past six
months, much time and energy has been spent on
procedural issues. Therefore, we hope that the Working
Group can now return to a greater focus on effective
measures to protect children. More resources are
needed for all actors concerned.
Austria would like to encourage the Council to
ensure respect for its resolution 1612 (2005) and for all
its previous resolutions on this issue. The fact that
there is a long list of persistent violators is of
increasing concern. We raised that concern at the last
open debate on this subject, held in February, and we
feel that we must do so again today.
This situation demands further action by the
Security Council to strengthen the rule of law and to
end impunity. We support the Secretary-General's call
to make full use of the range of measures and tools
available to the Council. We also call on the Security
Council and on Member States to fully use
accountability mechanisms, including the International
Criminal Court, to bring to justice perpetrators of
Violations against children.
In this context, I would like to draw attention to
the final report of the Austrian Initiative on the
Security Council and the rule of law, which contains
17 concrete recommendations on how the Security
Council could strengthen the rule of law in its various
fields of activity. The report was recently issued as a
document of the United Nations (S/2008/270) and is
available in all official languages.
Austria also supports the Secretary-General's
recommendation that equal weight be given to all
categories of grave violations against children. As a
first step, the crime of rape and grave sexual Violence
should be introduced as an additional element to
trigger the monitoring and reporting mechanism.
Together with many other speakers, we have laid out
the reasons for that approach. Those reasons have
gained even more weight in the meantime with the
adoption of resolution 1820 (2008) on sexual violence
during and after armed conflict.
Austria believes that the Security Council should
therefore carry forward its intention to further
strengthen the framework for the protection of children
by reviewing the relevant provisions of its resolutions
and initiating work on a new resolution to increase the
efficiency of its actions.
The future of our children depends on our
response to the challenges before us today. Austria will
continue to work closely with the United Nations and
all our other partners to improve the situation of
children, especially those affected by armed conflict.
In concluding, I would like to commend the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General on
Children and Armed Conflict for her activities,
dedication, engagement and for the many endeavours
she has undertaken to improve the plight of children in
armed conflict.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Nicaragua.
Mr. Hermida Castillo (Nicaragua) (spoke in Spanish): The delegation of Nicaragua would like to
thank Viet Nam for convening this very important
meeting. The delegation of Nicaragua regards this
debate in the Security Council as one more opportunity
to call attention to the tragic evil that embroils
hundreds of thousands of children in armed conflict
around the world, depriving them of their family life,
their childhood, their education, their health and above
all, in most cases of the simple opportunity to live.
Over the past few years, there has been much
discussion on that topic and tangible progress has been
acknowledged, including the creation of the Working
Group of the Security Council on Children and Armed
Conflict, the establishment of the monitoring and
reporting mechanism and the adoption of commitments
and plans of action by countries affected by armed
conflict.
Nonetheless, many challenges remain to be faced.
Moreover, we must not ignore the importance of
sustainable reintegration into communities and family,
in which education plays a decisive role as a factor for
peace. Greater efforts must be made to ensure the right
to education in emergency situations. Education has
often been ignored in situations of armed conflict. In
order to achieve the Millennium Development Goal on
education, we must give more attention to the fact that
education is currently not part of emergency response.
At the present time, two thirds of the children of the
world who are not in school live in countries affected
by conflict.
Above and beyond all of those endeavours and
the challenges that we face, if we really wish to put an
end to the participation of children in armed conflict,
we need to tackle the problem at its root - conflict
itself. We agree with what has been said by many
delegations and by the presidency of the Security
Council in its statement issued in February, in which
the need was stressed to establish a broad-ranging
strategy of prevention aimed at attaining sustainable
development and the eradication of poverty.
What is needed is to seek urgently an alternative
to unbridled capitalism, which exacerbates conflicts to
the benefit of the economic interests of the arms
industries or those that extract natural resources, which
are ultimately the greatest beneficiaries of the suffering
and death caused by armed conflict.
Lastly, my delegation would encourage all
interested parties to continue to foster a constructive
dialogue with the parties to conflict, which would yield
tangible benefits for boys and girls affected by armed
conflict.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Liechtenstein.
Mr. Frommelt (Liechtenstein): We thank you,
Sir, for organizing this important and timely open
debate and for distributing an excellent concept paper.
We also commend the Special Representative of the
Secretary-General on Children and Armed Conflict and
her Office for their dedication in advancing the work of
the United Nations on that topic.
Liechtenstein has been actively involved in the
efforts of the United Nations to address the plight of
children affected by armed conflict since the very
beginning. As a member of the group of friends of
children affected by armed conflict, we will continue to
do so and view this open debate as a further step that
should lead to a substantive new resolution and
towards a future agreement on the use of targeted
measures against those responsible for the worst
violations.
Security Council resolution 1612 (2005)
established a monitoring and reporting mechanism for
serious violations of the rights of the child at the field
level, as well as a Working Group on Children and
Armed Conflict here in New York. While that decision
has already proven its positive effects on the ground, it
is important to maintain the political momentum and to
further develop and enhance tools aimed at improving
the safety and security of children affected by armed
conflict. As foreseen in resolution 1612 (2005), the
monitoring and reporting mechanism provides reliable
information on situations listed in annexes I and II of
the reports of the Secretary-General, including the
recruitment and use of child soldiers, the killing and
maiming of children, rape and other grave sexual
Violence against children, attacks against schools and
hospitals, the abduction of children and the denial of
humanitarian access.
However, only one of those six grave
violations - the recruitment and use of child
soldiers - currently triggers the inclusion of countries
in the annexes of the reports. We therefore reiterate our
call to treat all six types of grave Violations on an equal
basis as triggers for inclusion in the annexes of the
Secretary-General's reports. The current differentiated
treatment of those violations is, in fact, difficult to
understand in the light of the universality of human
rights and the principles of international humanitarian
law.
Any measures taken by the Working Group in
response to grave violations of the rights of the child
have to be complemented by effective enforcement.
One option worth considering in that regard is the
expansion of the Working Group's mandate to
recommend targeted measures, including arms
embargoes, bans on military assistance and the
imposition of travel restrictions on individuals.
With regard to the working methods of the
Council's Working Group on Children and Armed
Conflict, we are concerned by the slowdown in the
publication of the Working Group's conclusions. While
in 2007 conclusions were published at intervals of two
to three months, this year we have not seen any
conclusions since February. We understand that the
procedural issues that led to the delay have been solved
and expect more conclusions to be adopted during the
second half of this year.
Liechtenstein also supports the recommendation
of the Secretary-General, contained in his last report to
the Council (S/2007/757), to refer to the International
Criminal Court (ICC) for investigation and prosecution
the Violations of the rights of children that fall within
the Court's jurisdiction.
Incidentally, this open debate coincides with the
tenth anniversary of the adoption of the Rome Statute,
and anniversary activities are under way in parallel to
the discussions in the Council Chamber. It is therefore
most appropriate to recall that the Rome Statute of the
ICC, among many other significant advances in the
area of international criminal justice, also set a
milestone for the fight to end impunity for massive
Violations of the rights of children. The specific
references to sexual violence and the conscription and
enlistment of child soldiers in articles 7 and 8 of the
Rome Statute concerning crimes against humanity and
war crimes must be highlighted in that connection.
The practical work of the ICC, in particular with
respect to the situations in the Democratic Republic of
the Congo and in northern Uganda, has already had a
positive impact on the ground and is setting important
precedents. When the first trial commences, hopefully
later this year, the fight against the involvement of
children in armed conflicts will gain additional
prominence and draw even stronger international
attention.
The ICC is therefore playing a supportive role in
many areas where the Council has been actively
engaged for many years. Other examples are the
protection of civilians and the issue of sexual violence
against women and girls in armed conflict, recently
addressed specifically in resolution 1820 (2008). The
ICC's role is independent, but also complementary to
the mandate given to the Security Council and in
keeping with the purposes of the Charter of the United
Nations. We therefore hope that the Council will
continue to give political backing to the ICC in
carrying out its mandate under the Rome Statute.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Japan.
Mr. Takasu (Japan): I would like to express my
appreciation to you, Sir, for convening this open debate
on children and armed conflict. My appreciation goes
also to the valuable presentations made this morning
by Special Representative Coomaraswamy, Executive
Director Veneman, Assistant Secretary-General Mulet
and Ms. Hunt.
Since the Council first took up this issue about
10 years ago, we have been heartened by the progress
made towards protecting children who have the
misfortune to be caught in the midst of armed conflict.
For example, important precedents have been set at the
International Criminal Court and the Special Court for
Sierra Leone to put an end to impunity for crimes
against children, particularly the recruitment and use of
children by armed forces or armed groups. The
monitoring and reporting mechanism established by the
Security Council resolution 1612 (2005), the Office of
the Special Representative of the Secretary-General,
and the child protection advisers in the peacekeeping
and political missions have all contributed to achieving
concrete results. The dialogue amongst the parties
concerned led to the release of more than 3,000 child
soldiers in Cote d'Ivoire. In Chad and the Central
African Republic, this May an agreement was reached
by the parties to the conflict to release child
combatants.
Despite some of those achievements, we are
deeply concerned about the plight of an estimated
250,000 children who are still forced to serve in armed
forces and armed groups. The recent report of the
Secretary-General (S/2007/757) and the report of the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General
(A/62/228) highlighted emerging critical issues of
concern, including the lack of security in and around
camps for internally displaced persons and refugees
and the illegal detention of children for alleged
association with armed groups.
Those children affected by armed conflict, who
have been deprived of their families and of appropriate
education, should be given every opportunity to enjoy
normal civilian life. Post-conflict peacebuilding must
address the lives and livelihoods of such children and
ensure their full reintegration into communities. It is
indispensable to provide not only physical protection
but also basic human services. We should pay
particular attention to alleviating the factors at the
community level that are likely to lead to the
recurrence of conflicts, such as discrimination against
former child soldiers and the lack of productive
economic activities for them. Physical and mental
rehabilitation, vocational training and expanded
educational opportunities should be provided to
empower those Victims. In post-conflict situations,
Governments have the primary responsibility to lead
the way by formulating and implementing child rights-
based policies, while communities and civil society
play an important role in building a climate of
reconciliation and forgiveness.
The Peacebuilding Commission can support
national efforts to address the needs of children. For
example, the Strategic Framework for Peacebuilding in
Burundi has made specific commitments addressing
the needs of child soldiers and to promote their human
rights in the context of transitional justice in response
to Special Representative Coomaraswamy's briefing at
the country-specific meeting. In the case of Sierra
Leone, the Peacebuilding Cooperation Framework
recognizes that the education, employment and
empowerment of youth are critical and priority issues.
At the last open debate on children and armed
conflict here in February, the Council issued a
presidential statement in document S/PRST/2008/6,
inviting all parties concerned to enhance their
exchange of information about programmes and best
practices on the reintegration and rehabilitation of
children. The Peacebuilding Commission, with its
diverse stakeholders, is in a position to provide
valuable support to develop a coordinated and
integrated approach to achieve durable peace.
Children are the most vulnerable members of
society when conflict breaks out. The concept of
human security, focusing on the safety and security of
the individual, which Japan promotes wholeheartedly,
provides a vitally important perspective for the
protection and empowerment of children affected by
armed conflict. An integrated approach based on that
concept is highly relevant to the entire process. Japan
believes that those endeavours will, in turn, contribute
to the international efforts to achieve the Millennium
Development Goals. For instance, at the recent G8
summit, leaders stressed the importance of the
enhancement of human security and the promotion of
good governance in achieving those goals.
In mainstreaming the human security approach,
Japan has been providing assistance and support to the
programmes aimed at supporting former child soldiers
and Victims of sexual exploitation and Violence in
many countries, such as the Democratic Republic of
the Congo, Burundi, Uganda and Liberia. In addition,
through the United Nations Trust Fund for Human
Security, Japan supports capacity-building in local
communities to build durable child-friendly
environments, for instance, in Kenya and in the
Democratic Republic of the Congo. The Fourth Tokyo
International Conference on African Development was
also an occasion to address the importance of ensuring
human security as a top priority.
Political leaders in Africa and in many other parts
of the world agreed the importance of approaching
seamless peacebuilding efforts from a human-centred
perspective, encompassing conflict prevention, early
warning, conflict resolution and the prevention of
relapses into conflict, all of which contribute to durable
peace. Equally crucial are a smooth transition between
one phase and the next and the creation of
interdependence between security, human rights and
development.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Norway.
Mr. Levald (Norway): I have the honour to speak
on behalf of the five Nordic countries - Denmark,
Finland, Iceland, Sweden and Norway.
Children bear the least responsibility for armed
conflicts, yet when conflicts arise, they suffer the most.
We therefore commend the Special Representative of
the Secretary-General for Children and Armed Conflict
for her valuable work. Through her tireless efforts, she
lends a voice to children who otherwise would not be
heard.
The Nordic countries reiterate their unequivocal
endorsement of the recommendations contained in the
Secretary-General's report (S/2007/757) concerning
child rights and the role of child protection in future
peacekeeping missions. Each of the six categories of
grave violations set out in resolution 1612 (2005) must
be addressed with equal resolve. We must act to put an
end to all assaults on the human dignity of children.
Women and girls constitute the largest and most
vulnerable group of victims in armed conflicts.
Therefore, both those groups deserve our constant
attention. In line with the recommendations of the
report (S/2007/757) of the Secretary-General and of the
Working Group on Children and Armed Conflict, we
ask that sexual and gender-based violence be included
on the list of Violations that trigger listing in the
annexes to the Secretary-General's reports.
We recognize the absolute importance of
resolution 1612 (2005) and the mechanisms set up in
its wake. We welcome the reports of the Special
Representative announcing the release of hundreds of
children from armed groups in the Democratic
Republic of the Congo and Chad. We also welcome the
reports of progress made in Liberia and Sierra Leone.
However, we remain deeply concerned at the high
number of Violations against children in the Sudan,
including their recruitment by armed forces and
groups, and rape and sexual Violence, especially in
Darfur.
Although promising progress has been made in
some areas, there often remains a gap between words
and deeds, between United Nations resolutions and
actions by affected Member States. The monitoring and
reporting mechanism provides the Security Council
with reliable information on grave violations of child
rights. With that knowledge comes responsibility. The
Security Council should therefore seriously consider
effective targeted measures against those who commit
grave violations against children. We call on the
Working Group to explore the full range of measures to
hold persistent perpetrators responsible, whether they
fall short of their own action plan objectives or choose
to ignore the mechanism altogether.
Increased efforts are needed in order to end
impunity for perpetrators of crimes against children.
We welcome the progress made by the International
Criminal Court (ICC) in persecuting individuals
suspected of grave violations of the rights of the child.
Nevertheless, effective national courts are also needed.
Governments should benefit from the competence and
capacity of the United Nations monitoring and
reporting mechanism. We encourage the Security
Council to refer Violations against children in armed
conflict to the ICC for investigation and prosecution
when national Governments continuously fail to
address such crimes.
The body of international humanitarian and
human rights instruments leaves us with strong moral,
political and legal obligations that must lead to action
to provide a protective environment for the
development of children, enriching their childhoods,
expanding their opportunities and inspiring hope in our
common future. The recently concluded Convention on
Cluster Munitions, which will open for signature in
December of this year, and the ongoing negotiations
within the framework of the Convention on
Conventional Weapons will, hopefully, serve as
effective tools to that end.
The Nordic countries encourage the Security
Council to ensure that it pays equal attention to all
children affected by armed conflict. Procedural
arguments concerning whether or not a specific
situation is on its agenda should not undermine the
Security Council's ability to discuss the plight of all
children affected by armed conflict and, if necessary, to
act accordingly.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Germany.
Mr. Matussek (Germany): Germany fully aligns
itself with the statement delivered this morning by the
representative of France on behalf of the European
Union.
Let me start by commending the Vietnamese
presidency of the Security Council for putting the
important item of children and armed conflict on the
agenda of the Council. I would also like to extend my
gratitude to the Secretary-General and to his Special
Representative for Children and Armed Conflict for
their dedicated engagement in taking this important
issue forward. I would also like to again thank France
in its capacity as Chair of the Security Council
Working Group.
As the Council is aware, the German Government
has always attached great importance to the promotion
and protection of the rights of children, and in
particular to the situation of children affected by armed
conflicts. In the context of conflict prevention and
post-conflict rehabilitation, Germany finances and
implements a number of projects to counter the
recruitment of child soldiers and to promote their
reintegration into civilian life, for instance in the Sudan
and Nepal. We welcome the very significant progress
made by the international community on that issue, but
at the same time we are acutely aware of the necessity
to redouble our efforts and to move the agenda
forward.
The Security Council has made impressive
progress on this issue since it was first put on its
agenda, 10 years ago. In particular, the adoption of
resolution 1612 (2005) in 2005 is rightfully regarded as
a milestone in creating an effective international
monitoring and reporting mechanism on the issue of
children and armed conflict. Progress so far shows that
the mechanism is working well. Some parties to
conflict listed in the annexes of the Secretary-General's
reports have shown increased consideration of the
issue. Some have even adopted action plans
commensurate with the United Nations
recommendations pertaining to the use of child soldiers
and illegal recruiting practices. What is more, the
monitoring and reporting mechanism also provides
Member States with ample information and evidence of
grave Violations in the six major categories of
violations against children, while focusing on the
illegal recruitment and use of children as child soldiers.
However, important challenges remain. We
believe that the Security Council should seriously start
to discuss ways to take the issue of children and armed
conflict forward. In our View, such a discussion should
take up the following three points.
First, we should address all aspects related to
grave Violations against children in armed conflict,
including the issue of sexual Violence against children.
That issue deserves our undivided attention.
Perpetrators should be included in the annexes of the
Secretary-General's reports. In that context, we
welcome the recent adoption of resolution 1820 (2008)
on sexual Violence in situations of armed conflict.
Secondly, we must speak in clear language with
parties to conflicts that keep appearing on the lists of
perpetrators and with those parties that have chosen to
ignore persistent calls to cease their illegal practices
with regard to children in armed conflict. In our View,
the Security Council should consider ways and means
of imposing targeted measures against the main
perpetrators. That should also imply the referral of
serious violations to the International Criminal Court
in cases where national systems fail to provide
adequate protection for children in armed conflict.
Thirdly and finally, more attention should be paid
by the Security Council to the mainstreaming of the
issue of children and armed conflict in United Nations
peacekeeping and political missions alike, for instance
through child protection advisers and enhanced
cooperation with the relevant United Nations actors,
such as UNICEF, the United Nations Development
Programme, the Office of the United Nations High
commissioner for Refugees and the Department of
Peacekeeping Operations.
Finally, although it is of the utmost importance
that the United Nations system as a whole continue to
address the root causes of conflict affecting children -
such as, inter alia, poverty, the lack of development
and the lack of good governance - we believe that the
Security Council should remain focused on a rights-
based approach. That means the full implementation of
the monitoring and reporting mechanism on children
and armed conflict, as set out in resolution 1612
(2005). Germany will remain engaged on the issue of
children and armed conflict within the Security
Council and with like-minded partners beyond.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Ghana.
Mr. Tachie-Menson (Ghana): I would like to
thank this month's Vietnamese presidency of the
Security Council for organizing this debate. Allow me
also to express my delegation's appreciation to the
Chairperson of the Security Council Working Group on
Children and Armed Conflict for the annual report on
the activities of the Working Group. Ghana remains
convinced that the Working Group has a key
responsibility in moving forward the children and
armed conflict agenda by proposing stronger and more
effective recommendations for the Council's
consideration. We note with satisfaction that the
sustained activity of the Council's Working Group has
resulted in definitive conclusions and
recommendations. We regret, however, the recent
inertia in the Working Group's discussions, as that
development may hinder progress. We hope that the
desire to make positive differences in the lives of
children affected by armed conflict will continue to be
the guiding principle in the Group's deliberations. We
express our support for the Chairman's
recommendation calling for increased Secretariat
support for the Working Group's effective and efficient
functioning.
While acknowledging that the engagement of the
Security Council has yielded some tangible results, the
overall situation of children affected by armed conflict
remains worrisome. The recruitment and use of
children by armed forces and groups continue to be a
cause of concern. Numerous children have been killed
and injured as a result of conflict, sexual violence
against children and attacks on schools are on the
increase in conflict situations, humanitarian access is
restricted and aid to those unfortunate Victims cannot
be assured in many conflict areas. Obviously, more
remains to be done to ensure the practical
implementation of resolution 1612 (2005). The
effective closing of the gaps in the implementation of
resolution 1612 (2005) will require concerted action by
all stakeholders, including affected States, parties to
conflict, United Nations entities, peacekeeping and
support units and the international community as a
whole.
There should be no impunity for those who target
children during armed conflict. The Secretary-
General's report in document S/2007/757 strongly
emphasizes national action to bring to justice
individuals responsible for grave violations against
children and to end impunity for such Violations. The
prime responsibility for investigating and prosecuting
the perpetrators of such acts falls upon State
authorities. Clearly, there is a need to build the
capacity of national security and legal actors, including
by increasing the provision of human and financial
resources to the concerned authorities to strengthen
their capacity to investigate and prosecute crimes
against children. However, it is apparent that, where
State authorities lack the ability to carry out those
functions, the international community should play its
role without fail.
Ghana continues to place emphasis on the
effective implementation of disarmament,
demobilization and reintegration (DDR) programmes.
In order to enhance the protection of children on a
long-term basis, resources should be mobilized for
programmes aimed at the sustainable reintegration of
child survivors of conflict into their societies. It is also
critical for DDR programmes to include primary health
care, counselling and social support to address the
special needs of girls in the context of armed conflict
and the specific problem of sexual violence. Also, a
sustained investment in development, especially in
education and skills training, will secure the successful
reintegration of children into their communities and
prevent recruitment. Such programmes should include
employment support and income-generating projects
for former combatants. There is also an urgent need for
the rehabilitation of school buildings and the provision
of school materials to support continued schooling and
the provision of life and vocational skills for children
who have left school.
In addition, increased attention must be paid to
sexual and gender-based Violence, since the sexual
exploitation of children in conflict situations has
become widespread. It is significant to recall the
Council's adoption of resolution 1820 (2008) on sexual
violence during and after armed conflict. Under that
resolution, we have an important opportunity to create
a more systematic approach to protecting women and
girls from sexual violence during conflict, as well as to
providing timely and sustainable intervention. Our
delegation's expectation is that the implementation of
the resolution will take cognizance of the relevant
thematic issues on the Council's agenda, including
children in conflict situations.
We wish to applaud the efforts of the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for Children
and Armed Conflict, Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy, The
positive nature of the contacts and discussions of the
Special Representative with respective Governments
during her country visits have had the necessary impact
by ensuring better collaboration on the protection of
children.
In conclusion, I wish to reiterate that children
affected by armed conflict, like all other children of the
world, should have the right to live and to dream of a
better future.
The President: I give the floor to the
representative of Colombia.
Ms. Blum (Colombia) (spoke in Spanish): I
would like to join previous speakers in thanking the
delegation of Viet Nam for its initiative to convene this
debate, as well as for the preparation of the document
previously circulated as a contribution to the
discussion. I would also like to congratulate the Deputy
Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs of Viet
Nam, Mr. Pham Gia Khiem, for his work leading the
morning's portion of this meeting.
I also thank Ms. Coomaraswamy, Ms. Veneman,
Ms. Hunt and Mr. Mulet for their informative
presentations
The open debate format for the briefing on the
annual report of the Chairman of the Working Group of
the Security Council on Children and Armed Conflict
is very appropriate. It provides an opportunity to
express points of view concerning the Group's work
and its contributions to the Security Council and other
organs of the United Nations system.
The protection of children and the promotion of
their rights are priorities for my country. Colombia has
ratified the international instruments aimed at putting
an end to the recruitment of minors. Moreover, our
legislation establishes obligations for protection
against the illicit recruitment of children and
adolescents. We therefore support all efforts that
contribute to that end.
The Security Council Working Group has adopted
important guidelines for its work, including the terms
of reference and the tool kit. My delegation wishes to
stress the importance of the guides and modalities
continuing to be implemented in accordance with
resolution 1612 (2005).
The Security Council established essential
principles for the implementation of that resolution.
One is the priority that it assigns to situations on the
agenda of the Security Council and the differentiated
treatment given to situations included in annex II of the
report of the Secretary-General. A second aspect is its
recognition of the primary role of national
Governments in the protection of children affected by
conflicts, as well as the duty of United Nations entities
to cooperate with Governments. The Council also
established the principles that govern the management
of information in the implementation of the resolution.
In addition to being objective, accurate and reliable,
information should be thoroughly verified in close
consultation with the Governments concerned.
My delegation has taken note with interest of the
suggestions contained in the document circulated by
the presidency. Of particular interest is the suggested
approach on the protection of children, both from a
human rights perspective and with a focus on
development issues.
My country's commitment to fully guarantee the
rights of children - and of all our citizens - is part of
a three-pillar Government agenda: security based on
democracy; investment based on social responsibility;
and social cohesion based on prosperity and freedom.
Our democratic security policy, which has made
it possible to restore security on our territory while
guaranteeing the viability of democracy and the
strengthening of the legitimacy of the rule of law, is a
fundamental basis for strengthening the programmes to
prevent the forcible recruitment of children and
adolescents and to enhance the protection of children
affected by the actions of illegal armed groups. We
have arrived at this stage by restoring the State
monopoly on the legitimate use of force in order to
confront these groups. Our citizens have placed their
trust in these policies, which has made it possible to
continue this process in a sustained manner, by
building investment and social cohesion.
The elements of the Colombian State's strategy
on children and armed conflict include the prevention
of recruitment, along with protection, rehabilitation
and reintegration. Since 1999 the Colombian Institute
for Family Welfare has provided assistance to more
than 3,600 children and adolescents who have been
taken away from illegal armed groups. The national
budget resources for this programme for the period
2002-2007 were over $14 million.
The Colombian Institute for Family Welfare
promotes concrete action at the regional level to assist
and protect children and adolescents, for inclusion
within the development plans established by the offices
of mayors and governors.
The Office of the Counsellor for Women's
Equality has integrated the gender perspective in the
public policy implemented by the Office of the High
Counsellor for Social Reintegration, aiming at
providing solutions for the impact of recruitment on
children separated from illegal groups. Through this
focus on social integration, children and adolescents
are supported in regaining self-esteem, participation,
education, income generation, restored family ties and
health.
As programmes are implemented, they generate
the need to make further efforts at coordination and
allocation of resources, especially in the field of
training and education of human resources.
International cooperation can play a significant role to
complement those efforts.
In addition, since the establishment in December
of our Intersectoral Commission for the Prevention of
the Recruitment and Use of Children, Adolescents and
Young Persons, an important diagnostic and
awareness-raising effort has been under way at the
institutional level. Several factors that fuel the problem
have been effectively neutralized. This has entailed an
enormous challenge to the country.
From that perspective, I would like to reiterate
once again the resolute will of the Government of
Colombia to continue to advance in the protection of
children affected by the actions of illegal armed
groups, to strengthen the policies of prevention in this
area and to channel international cooperation efforts to
that end.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Uruguay.
Mr. Cancela (Uruguay) (spoke in Spanish): The
delegation of Uruguay would like to underscore the
importance of today's open debate on children and
armed conflict, and that of the annual report of the
Security Council Working Group on Children and
Armed Conflict. Once again, we have an opportunity to
stress the importance of continuing to make progress in
improving the working methods of the Security
Council with a View to adopting substantive reforms of
those methods as soon as possible, within the
framework of Council reform.
Children are one of the most vulnerable sectors of
society, but at the same time they are society's present
and its future. In that regard, we are particularly
gratified at the high level of ratification of the
Convention on the Rights of the Child; we appeal to
those States that have not yet acceded to the
Convention and its Optional Protocols to do so. We
also urge full and effective implementation by States
already party to them.
Uruguay recognizes the contribution of the
International Criminal Court, which defines as war
crimes those crimes that involve sexual violence or the
recruitment or enlistment of persons under 15 years of
age or their use as active participants in the hostilities
of armed conflict, along with the contributions made
by other international tribunals that have included the
protection of children in their respective spheres of
jurisdiction.
The delegation of Uruguay appreciates the efforts
of the Security Council Working Group on Children
and Armed Conflict and recognizes the role that the
Council has played; here, there has been movement
from words to implementation. We also know that this
item is included in the agenda of the General
Assembly, a forum in which year after year Uruguay
plays an extremely active role with a view to
strengthening and increasing the involvement and
responsibility of that universal organ regarding a
matter that falls within its mandate and that is of
universal concern.
We also owe special recognition to the work of
the Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict, whose mandate Uruguay
fully supports.
The figures set out in recent reports on the impact
of armed conflict are particularly disquieting. We are
concerned at the continuing illegal recruitment of
children in conflict zones, many of whom are abducted
from refugee camps; at the various forms of sexual
Violence against children, which leave devastating
permanent scars on their victims; by the cases of
children detained in contravention of international law;
at the systematic and deliberate attacks against schools;
and at the nearly total impunity enjoyed by those who
continue to commit crimes against children.
We reaffirm the need to assess the
implementation and the format of the monitoring and
reporting mechanism established through resolution
1612 (2005). We believe that its scope should be
broadened to include all kinds of grave violations
against children, for no violation is more serious than
the others, and all must be given equal weight. We
appreciate the broad and inclusive nature of the
mechanism, which works with the involvement of all
parties to a conflict: Governments, non-governmental
armed forces, the United Nations system and civil
society.
We believe that only through concerted and
coordinated endeavours, through strengthening the
norms of international law and through enhancing the
use of available judicial mechanisms - in particular
the International Criminal Court - will it be possible
to formulate and implement plans of action against the
grave Violations that continue to assail children in
situations of armed conflict.
The delegation of Uruguay is of the view that
greater attention needs to be paid to the reintegration of
children associated with armed groups and of those
who have been victims of other grave violations of
their rights, in particular sexual abuse or exploitation.
In that regard, we agree that there is a need to
take a broad and comprehensive approach to conflict
prevention, tackling the root of the problem in order to
achieve a sustainable, long-term solution.
We applaud the work being done jointly by civil
society and the United Nations system, including
peacekeeping missions, in building lasting mechanisms
to protect children. We believe that the work of the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General on
Children and Armed Conflict in peacekeeping missions
and the inclusion by UNICEF of child protection
advisers in peacekeeping missions should be
strengthened and should be given the appropriate
support in terms of human, financial and technical
resources.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Egypt.
Ms. Gendi (Egypt) (spoke in Arabic): I would
like to start by congratulating you, Mr. President, on
the assumption by Viet Nam of the presidency of the
Security Council, and to thank you for your invitation
to this thematic debate on a very important theme, in
order to address it from all its angles, whether security,
political or humanitarian. I would also like to
congratulate the Secretary-General and thank
Ms.Coomaraswamy for her significant presentation
and her untiring efforts to protect children in armed
conflict. I would like to commend the Working Group
on Children and Armed Conflict for its continuous
efforts, which we hope will bear fruit in eliminating all
forms of violence perpetrated against our children in
armed conflict.
Egypt has studied with much interest the
Vietnamese concept paper and what it contains on the
need for the United Nations to address the growing
linkage between development and the situations of
children in armed conflicts. That important idea was
raised at a time when the United Nations was
concentrating on this matter only from the perspective
of its effect on international peace and security and on
human rights, without attempting to protect or establish
the right to development as one of those rights. There
is no doubt that development, when available in its full
range, can help to overcome the causes of conflict,
establish peace and enable a return to normal life in
situations of conflict. That would, in turn, protect
children from any threat against their lives and from
any form of violence that might be perpetrated against
them, especially during armed conflict, whether
manifested through the use of child soldiers or through
sexual or other abuse against children.
There is no doubt that the linkage between
development, peace and human rights, as endorsed by
our leaders at the 2005 World Summit, requires more
attention on our part through the implementation of
that linkage on the ground, especially in the light of the
positive effects of sustainable development and the
eradication of poverty on efforts to achieve peace,
prevent conflict and resolve any future conflict. Special
emphasis must certainly be placed on efforts to
establish that linkage in the coming period on the part
of the Working Group on Children and Armed Conflict
and the General Assembly, in cooperation with the
various entities of the United Nations, in particular the
Office of the Special Representative of the Secretary-
General for Children and Armed Conflict and UNICEF.
The report of the Working Group shows some of
the limited achievements accomplished in several
countries where children have suffered as a result of
armed conflicts, including cote d'Ivoire, Congo,
Sudan, the Philippines, Colombia and others. At the
same time, the report indicates that the situation is still
very volatile and that the phenomenon is still spreading
around the world and taking new and different violent
forms. That makes it imperative for the Working Group
to intensify the preparation of reports on the situation
of children in armed conflict in every armed conflict
and in every situation where children are under foreign
occupation in all its forms and manifestations.
While the Working Group, the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for Children
and Armed Conflict and UNICEF work to that end,
special emphasis should be placed on the reintegration
and rehabilitation of those children, their
reintroduction to normal life and the creation of the
necessary conditions for them to enjoy similar
standards of education, nutrition and health to those
enjoyed by children in advanced countries. That will
require the commitment of more financial resources
and better coordination between the Security Council,
General Assembly and Economic and Social Council.
It will also require active participation between the
private sector and civil society, with all its institutions,
and the support of international financial institutions.
In order to achieve such a goal, Egypt was among
the first countries to call for a visit by the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General to Palestine,
Lebanon and Iraq, to examine the disgraceful
humanitarian situations that children there are exposed
to under foreign occupation and to come up with
recommendations that could be feasibly transformed
into decisions of the Working Group. However, the
reports submitted by Mrs. Coomaraswamy on those
visits, which were very objective and impartial, were
only mentioned in passing in the report of the Working
Group. At the same time, apart from a brief reference
to the case of Afghanistan, the report did not mention
anything related to children who are detained or in
prison. No mention whatsoever was made of their
situation, destiny or future, or of what kind of
measures should be applied to guarantee their release
and rehabilitation and preserve their future, especially
in the case of Palestinian children detained in the
prisons of the Israeli occupation forces and Iraqi
children detained by the international coalition forces.
The Working Group must begin to look into the
situation of those children, especially in the light of the
adoption by the UNICEF Executive Board of the
UNICEF Child Protection Strategy, in a way that
guarantees an effective way of dealing with an entire
generation of children who have been detained for
vague or trivial reasons. That effort should be aimed at
dealing with the root causes that led those children to
resort to violence, at the forefront of which is
occupation itself. Such a solution must be aimed at
ending all forms of occupation and must endorse the
need for occupying forces to respect human rights and
their international obligations as an occupying
authority and fulfil their responsibility to guarantee
that all people enjoy their inalienable rights, especially
the right to self-determination.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Rwanda.
Mr. Ndabarasa (Rwanda): My delegation
welcomes this opportunity to participate in the open
debate on children and armed conflict and wishes to
express our appreciation to the delegation of Viet Nam
for organizing this debate. My delegation believes that
this open debate should mark the beginning of a
concentrated effort on the part of the Security Council
to comprehensively address the issue of children in
armed conflict, as set out in the concept paper of 7 July
2008.
Allow me to also take this opportunity to note
with appreciation the efforts of the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General on Children
and Armed Conflict and a number of United Nations
agencies - UNICEF, the Office for the Coordination
of Humanitarian Affairs, the Department of
Peacekeeping Operations, the Department of Political
Affairs and the Office of the United Nations High
Commissioner for Refugees - and many other
international and local non-governmental organizations
that work to protect children in areas of armed conflict.
The employees of those agencies endure numerous
hardships, including threats to their personal security,
and deserve to be commended.
My delegation firmly believes that tackling the
issue of children in armed conflict requires a holistic
and coherent approach. In that respect, we view
conflict prevention as the key to addressing this
scourge. Conflict and poverty act as enablers and lead
to children unwittingly getting caught up in or coerced
into armed conflict. Extreme poverty can lead to
conflict, and inevitably children and women become
the first victims. It is therefore imperative that
concerted attention be given to addressing poverty by
achieving the Millennium Development Goals and
through conflict prevention.
The Great Lakes region has experienced the
challenges posed by genocide and armed conflict and
endured the consequences first hand. Rwandan
refugees and nationals of the Democratic Republic of
the Congo are being held hostage by the members of
the former Rwandan Armed Forces and Interahamwe,
also known as the Forces democratiques de liberation
du Rwanda (FDLR), in the eastern Democratic
Republic of the Congo. The FDLR continues to use
that position to kidnap and forcefully recruit children
into its ranks for use as soldiers, workers and even
sexual slaves. In addition to this generation of young
people being denied a future, they are indoctrinated
with a genocidal ideology. Those young people are
trained to carry and use guns and taught hate instead of
arithmetic. That leaves the prospects for future peace
and stability in the region severely threatened.
The Secretary-General's report contains some
useful recommendations on the way forward. I will
focus on two of them. First, the focus on the
disarmament, demobilization and reintegration of
armed groups in conflict afflicted areas has yielded
some positive outcomes in the Great Lakes region and
in other areas. However, it needs to be accompanied by
a strengthening of the capacity of local authorities to
enable them to establish the socio-economic
infrastructure required to absorb demobilized former
armed militias and to resettle internally displaced
persons and refugees.
Secondly, my delegation believes that the
Security Council should be firm and show leadership in
dealing with the threat posed by armed groups in
conflict-affected areas. My delegation welcomes the
adoption of Security Council resolution 1804 (2008),
which seeks to comprehensively deal with the threat
posed by the FDLR in the Great Lakes region. It is that
kind of action that, if comprehensively implemented in
concert with a development approach, will help rid us
of the scourge of children in armed conflict.
The plight of children in armed conflict is not an
abstract concept or the subject of television
documentaries or films - it is anathema to us all. The
people of Rwanda, more than any in recent times, have
experienced the absence of real peace and security and
the impact it has on our children. My delegation
therefore wishes to reiterate its firm commitment to
addressing the plight of children in armed conflict and
to international peace and security through our
contributions to United Nations and African Union
peacekeeping missions.
We remain committed to actively supporting the
Security Council in its efforts to adopt both a
development and a conflict-prevention approach to
addressing the plight of children in armed conflict.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Malawi.
Mr. Matenje (Malawi): Let me begin by
commending you, Sir, for convening this open debate
on children and armed conflict and thanking you for
allowing my delegation to address the Security
Council.
At the World Summit in 2005, world leaders
reaffirmed their commitment to promoting and
protecting the rights and welfare of children in armed
conflicts. They also called upon States to take effective
measures, as appropriate, to prevent the recruitment
and use of children in armed conflict, contrary to
international law, by armed forces and groups, and to
prohibit and criminalize such practices.
Despite that noble call, children continue to be
kidnapped and forcibly conscripted or recruited into
service around the world as armed fighters, guards,
helpers or sex slaves. In the process, their rights are
violated with impunity. Many die and others are
displaced from their homes and communities, maimed
or disabled and let to suffer untold physical,
developmental, emotional, psychological, mental and
spiritual harm. Because armed conflict destroys State
structures that provide social services, children in
armed conflict suffer from the loss of access to basic
social services such as health care, education, water,
sanitation and nutritious food, thereby deepening
poverty. Those are issues of key importance to national
and international peace and security, requiring the
immediate, as well as long-term, collective attention of
the international community.
In that regard, my delegation observes that some
progress has been made at the international level in the
development of norms, standards and guidelines aimed
at combating the recruitment or use of children in
armed conflict and at securing the release of children
in armed conflict, supporting their reintegration into
society and affording them the greatest possible
protection from armed forces or groups. Those norms,
standards and guidelines are incorporated into a
number of instruments, for example the Paris
Principles and commitments to protect children from
recruitment or use by armed forces and armed groups,
the Convention on the Rights of the Child, Security
Council resolutions 1612 (2005) and 1820 (2008), the
African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the
African Child, the Cape Town Principles on child
soldiers in Africa and other international instruments.
However, more needs to be done to protect children
from the menace of armed conflicts.
In that regard, we agree with the call made by the
President of the Security Council on 12 February to
adopt a broad strategy of conflict prevention that
would address the root causes of armed conflict in a
comprehensive manner in order to enhance the
protection of children on a long-term basis, including
by promoting sustainable development, poverty
eradication, national reconciliation, good governance,
democracy, the rule of law and respect for and
protection of human rights, in particular the rights of
the child. However, that can be achieved only if the
Security Council works in full cooperation with
relevant organs of the United Nations, such as the
General Assembly and the Economic and Social
Council, that are mandated to deal with development
issues.
With regard to the rule of law, we note with
concern that most countries affected by armed conflict
lack the capacity to bring the perpetrators of armed
conflict to justice due to a lack of resources. While
national Governments have the primary responsibility
to provide effective protection and relief to children
affected by armed conflict, they need to be assisted in
strengthening their law enforcement and legal and
judicial systems in order to be responsive to the
security needs of their people. The United Nations and,
in particular, the Security Council have an important
role to play in that regard.
In addition, States that have not done so yet
should be encouraged to sign and ratify the Convention
on the Rights of the Child and its Optional Protocol on
the Involvement of Children in Armed Conflict, and
ensure that their national legislation is aligned to the
Convention. Most importantly, the Convention and its
Optional Protocol must be fully implemented in order
to render them meaningful in the fight against the use
of children in armed conflict. That is because the
obligation to protect and assist children, both in times
of peace and in armed conflict, is a basic principle of
human rights and humanitarian law. In that regard, in
addition to engaging official State agencies, it is
critical for the international community to find
innovative ways of involving non-State armed groups
in ways that do not undermine the rule of law in
seeking lasting solutions to armed conflict around the
world.
In conclusion, Malawi appreciates the work of the
International Criminal Court, UNICEF, the Department
of Peacekeeping Operations and the Security Council
Working Group on Children and Armed Conflict to
address the use of children in armed conflict in all its
dimensions. Malawi also takes this opportunity to
encourage the Security Council to ensure that political
considerations do not override the need to protect
children from armed conflict. Malawi condemns the
use of children in armed conflict.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Cote d'Ivoire.
Mr. Djedje (Cote d'Ivoire) (spoke in French): I
wish to thank you, Mr. President, for having convened
this open debate of the Security Council devoted to
children and armed conflict. The level of the debate
and the presence of the Deputy Prime Minister
demonstrate the firm commitment of the Government
of Viet Nam to that critical issue. I also commend the
work done by Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy, Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for Children
and Armed Conflict, to draw the international
community's attention to the impact of situations of
armed conflict on children.
The subject that we are discussing today was first
presented in detail to the international community in
1996, in Mrs. Graca Machel's report on the impact of
armed conflict on children. The firm and committed
reaction to that report led to the creation of the Office
of the Special Representative of the Secretary-General
for Children and Armed Conflict and to the formulation
of a series of important Security Council resolutions
that established a process to enable the United Nations
and its Members to address this very serious problem.
We welcome the progress made by the Council,
including the monitoring and reporting mechanism and
the development of action plans to end the use of child
soldiers, and the important efforts made by the
Working Group on Children and Armed Conflict.
The Government of C6te d'Ivoire fully
appreciates the deletion of the parties to the conflict in
Cote d'Ivoire from the list annexed to the report of the
Secretary-General on children and armed conflict.
Those parties have been delisted because they have
stopped recruiting children and have taken concerted
steps to identify and release children in order to permit
their reintegration. We welcome the fact that the
Working Group established by the Security Council has
taken note of the progress in Cote d'Ivoire, where
parties previously associated with the illegal
recruitment and use of child soldiers have put an end to
those practices.
Cote d'Ivoire would like to take this opportunity
to discuss a situation - one of which we are
sometimes unaware - that occurs following the
demobilization of children. Often, the reintegration of
children into their community is not as easy as one
would hope. Recidivism, or children's inability to
behave appropriately in their family or their
community, is a problem that deeply concerns us.
My Government welcomes the considerable work
carried out by UNICEF, the Department of
Peacekeeping Operations and their partners. However,
it is not possible to protect children without involving
the Governments of countries that face conflicts or that
are trying to rebuild after a conflict.
In that regard, the United Nations and the
Security Council must focus their efforts on promoting
national measures aimed at strengthening the
protection of children, at effectively implementing
programmes for the demobilization and reintegration of
minors, at creating social, economic and legal
conditions that will prevent recruitment and at
preventing other offences committed against children.
The rehabilitation and reintegration of all
children who have been associated with armed forces
or armed groups are essential. The international
community must thus continue to provide the resources
necessary to implement and promote national
rehabilitation and reintegration programmes in order to
ensure the long-term viability and success of such
interventions. Such programmes must also take account
of the particular concerns of girl combatants and girls
associated with armed groups. We call on partners to
include support for health and education as a priority in
their emergency programmes, so that education,
sanitation and health services and children's health
care continue in camps for refugees or displaced
persons during an armed conflict.
We hope that the comprehensive efforts made at
the level of the United Nations system and in
cooperation with interested States produce concrete
results that will improve the situation of children in
armed conflict.
As the Secretary-General indicated in his 2007
annual report on this subject (S/2007/757), the heart of
the process is the formulation of action plans by States
and non-State actors to put an end to the recruitment
and use of child soldiers. Such action plans have
proved to be effective ways to guide and measure the
progress made. However, I should like to emphasize
the following three points.
First, the Security Council must intensify its
efforts to prevent conflicts and safeguard peace, in
order to protect children by preventing or reducing the
causes of armed conflicts. However, when conflicts
erupt, the Council must strive to increase the
effectiveness of peacekeeping operations and to
improve the humanitarian situations in conflict areas.
Moreover, when we look at the issue of children
in armed conflict, we must constantly respect and
support the role of Governments, as stressed several
times in resolution 1612 (2005). Governments bear the
primary responsibility for protecting their children.
Other parties must seek the cooperation of the
Governments concerned so that they can together
remedy the violations committed against children in
armed conflicts.
The Security Council and its Working Group on
Children and Armed Conflict must improve their
communication with the Governments concerned. They
must recognize and support the positive steps taken by
Governments to improve mutual trust. At the same
time, politicization of the issue of children must be
avoided. The protection of children should not be used
as a pretext for interference in a country's internal
affairs.
Finally, resolution 1612 (2005) must continue to
serve as a basis for improving and perfecting the
monitoring and reporting mechanism as well as the
Working Group's activities in general. It is paramount
that the Security Council address the issue of the scope
of the monitoring and reporting mechanism. Currently,
the mechanism is activated only in the event of
violations related to the recruitment and use of child
soldiers, and it is applied systematically only to
situations that are formally included on the Council's
agenda. In fact, the mechanism should be automatically
applied to all situations of armed conflict in which the
safety and rights of children are violated by armed
forces or armed groups.
In conclusion, I should like to urge the United
Nations not to resort systematically to sanctions when
dealing with the issue of children and armed conflict,
because situations differ from one another. As for
parties to conflicts, I urge them to fulfil their
obligations by respecting international humanitarian
law and protecting the rights of children.
Finally, with regard to development partners,
during the period of post-conflict reconstruction they
must give priority to reintegrating children into the
family, school and society and must ensure that the
resources provided are adequate and substantial.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of the United Republic of Tanzania.
Ms. Kafanabo (United Republic of Tanzania):
We thank the delegation of Viet Nam for organizing
this open debate on children and armed conflict. The
situation of children in armed conflict is a serious
concern and warrants special attention by the Security
Council. We also thank the Secretary-General, the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict, the Assistant Secretary-
General for Peacekeeping Operations, the Executive
Director of UNICEF and the representative of the
non-governmental organization for their contributions
to the debate this morning and for their efforts to
improve the situation of children affected by armed
conflict.
My delegation wishes to commend the efforts of
the Special Representative and to place on record our
support for her work. We also wish to commend the
work of the Working Group on Children and Armed
Conflict, under the leadership of France. We call for
more support for the Office of the Special
Representative and for the Working Group on Children
and Armed Conflict in the discharge of their mandates.
The Security Council has come a long way since
the adoption of resolution 1261 (1999), its first
resolution on children and armed conflict, which has
been followed by five other resolutions. Those
resolutions and the presidential statements that have
been issued on this subject matter have laid the
foundation and the framework for the protection of
children in armed conflict. We are encouraged by the
progress that has been achieved in the protection of
children in conflict situations as a result of continuous
engagement by the Security Council on the issue.
We are further encouraged by the results achieved
through the monitoring and reporting mechanism that
was established under resolution 1612 (2005).
However, we note that, despite those encouraging
results, the situation on the ground is far from
satisfactory. More concerted efforts are required to
maintain the momentum and to further improve the
lives of children affected by armed conflicts in all
situations.
In that regard, we request that the Security
Council consider monitoring the other grave violations
in addition to the recruitment and use of children in
armed conflict. We can start the addition of other
violations in phases, beginning with sexual and gender-
based violence as a trigger for action. That trigger is
suggested in view of the adoption of resolution 1820
(2008) on sexual violence in armed conflict, as well as
of the magnitude of the problem of sexual violence
perpetrated against children.
The continued violation of the rights of children,
particularly in situations of conflict, is a matter of
serious concern. My delegation is further concerned by
the escalating incidences of rape and sexual abuse of
children, especially girls, in times of conflict. We
strongly condemn all violations of the rights of
children, including rape and gender-based violence, the
use of children as instruments of war, such as human
shields, perpetrators of attacks, spies and suicide
bombers.
We also condemn attacks on civilians and public
property, especially those targeting schools, teachers
and recreational areas. We have to hold perpetrators of
those crimes accountable so as to end impunity. In that
regard, we acknowledge the work of the International
Criminal Court (ICC) in bringing the perpetrators to
justice and call upon Member States to support the
ICC. We also urge national Governments to strengthen
the rule of law in their countries and to bring the
perpetrators to justice. Furthermore, we call upon the
Security Council to consider targeted sanctions against
perpetrators.
One of our greatest challenges in protecting
children is to end conflict. We need to tackle the root
causes of war as well as to address other political,
economic and social issues that can improve the
situation of children and other civilians in situations of
conflict. It is thus imperative that programmes being
undertaken in conflict areas have a strong focus on
children. We request the Secretary-General to ensure
that trained and adequately resourced child protection
advisers be stationed in all peacekeeping missions.
Furthermore, children's concerns should be
mainstreamed in peace processes and in disarmament,
demobilization and reintegration programmes with a
focus on long-term community-based reintegration.
Adequate resources should be made available to those
child-focused programmes. We urge the Security
Council to remain seized of this issue.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Afghanistan.
Mr. Tanin (Afghanistan): Allow me to begin by
expressing my delegation's gratitude to the delegation
of Viet Nam for convening today's meeting on children
and armed conflict. This meeting provides an
opportunity to renew our strong commitment to
ensuring the protection and rights of children in armed
conflict, as well as to review progress made in that
regard.
We would also like to express our appreciation to
Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy, Special Representative
of the Secretary-General for Children and Armed
Conflict, for her visit to Afghanistan and her
comprehensive statement.
All children have the same needs and share the
same dreams. They represent the future of our societies
and mirror the State they live in. The Government of
Afghanistan is still making efforts to rebuild its
country devastated by 30 years of war that dramatically
affected the lives of our children, particularly girls. The
major victims of the war in Afghanistan are our
children. Years of conflict in our country have
destroyed the basic necessities of life, such as schools,
health care, adequate shelter, water and food, and
disrupted family relationships. They have also created
stigma and post-traumatic distress and generated a
pessimistic outlook on the future.
Afghanistan is strongly committed to reversing
the impact of war on children and fulfilling its
obligation to protect children. The improvement of the
situation of Afghan children and the comprehensive
protection of their rights is an essential precondition
for the sustainable development of our State. It will
also lay a solid foundation for our next generation to
live in peace and prosperity and enjoy its human rights.
Our vision for ensuring the protection and well-being
of our children is to develop an environment that
provides security, guarantees economic and social
opportunities and respects the rule of law.
We have achieved considerable progress in
improving the status of children since 2001.
Nevertheless, today we are facing critical security
challenges that jeopardize the gains made in the past
seven years and undermine our collective efforts to
improve the living conditions of our children and give
them a promising and bright future.
Terrorism continues to be a major threat and
drastically affects the daily lives of our people,
particularly our children. The deterioration of the
security situation in Afghanistan is the product of the
surge of terrorist activities carried out by Al-Qaida, the
Taliban and other associated armed groups in the
region. Terrorists have increased attacks in our
territory, using barbaric acts and methods including car
bombs, suicide attacks and improvised explosive
devices directed at national and international forces.
Such attacks deliberately target densely populated
areas where children are the prime victims.
The Taliban is using the most atrocious practices
conceivable to conduct its subversive operations.
Terrorists are recruiting, training and exploiting
children as combatants and sending them to operate as
suicide bombers. As Afghan and international security
forces become more astute at recognizing suicide
attackers, the use of children is increasing because
children are not generally objects of suspicion. Child
suicide bombers also constitute an effective instrument
of psychological warfare because the spectre of the
child attacker is as terrifying as it is incomprehensible.
The intensification of the Taliban intimidation
campaign through the burning of schools and clinics,
the night-time dissemination of threatening notes and
attacks against teachers and schoolchildren has created
an atmosphere of terror and traumatizes children,
which prevents them from going to school and ruins
their future. Furthermore, it undermines our efforts at
achieving development goals aimed at improving the
living conditions of our citizens, including children,
and ensures a gloomy future for our people.
The state of hopelessness resulting from years of
living in conflict and from poor socio-economic
conditions, supported by the brainwashing
indoctrination provided in madrasas across our borders
are creating favourable conditions for recruiting and
training innocent children to target a wide spectrum of
Afghan and international civilian and military
personnel. We are deeply concerned about the rising
number of children killed and injured by the Taliban
and other foreign terrorist groups.
We would also like to express our grave concern
about the loss of lives and injuries of children during
counter-terrorism operations. In that regard, we call on
our international partners to exercise maximum caution
and to enhance coordination with Afghan security
forces during operations in order to avoid the loss of
civilian life and ensure the safety and physical integrity
of children.
The protection of children in armed conflict is
one of the most daunting humanitarian and security
challenges that the international community faces
today. Addressing the socio-economic needs of
children in armed conflict and ensuring their rights
requires an integrated strategy with a special focus on
poverty alleviation, especially among the most
vulnerable segments of our society, including widows
and orphans.
The successful implementation of such a strategy
requires full cooperation and coordination among the
Government of Afghanistan, development partners and
the United Nations agencies. We would like to call on
donor countries and development agencies to assist us
in achieving sustainable development, poverty
eradication and good governance.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of New Zealand.
Ms. Banks (New Zealand): I thank you,
Mr. President, for initiating this debate on children in
armed conflict. New Zealand also thanks the Secretary-
General for his report (S/2007/757). New Zealand
agrees with the report's recommendation that the
Security Council should not limit its attention to the
recruitment and use of child soldiers, but should give
equal weight to all categories of grave violations
against children, namely, killing and maiming, attacks
against schools and hospitals, rape and other grave
sexual violence, abduction and the denial of
humanitarian access.
We were proud to sponsor recently Council
resolution 1820 (2008) and welcome the recognition
that children in armed conflict are acutely vulnerable to
sexual violence. We look forward to the Secretary-
General's next report, as requested in resolution 1820
(2008), and call for action to stop abuses against
children.
We commend the progress made by the Working
Group on Children and Armed Conflict, with France as
its Chair. We want to see it continue to publish
conclusions that lead to strong and swift action against
the perpetrators of grave violations against children.
The Working Group is a vital component of a series of
mechanisms for ensuring that children affected by
conflict are protected.
We recognize the dedication of Special
Representative Radhika Coomaraswamy to the
commitments in her mandate and to the valuable
findings she brings back from her field visits.
We acknowledge that today is the tenth
anniversary of the creation of the International
Criminal Court (ICC) and take the opportunity to
reiterate the central importance of the ICC in bringing
to justice the perpetrators of abuse against children.
New Zealand commends all those involved, those
countries where progress has been reported and
especially the Security Council for the ongoing efforts
to better ensure the safety of children affected by
conflict. We call on the Council to continue its work to
fulfil the mandate set out in resolution 1612 (2005),
which we believe continues to provide sound
foundations for the valuable work of the Special
Representative.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Nepal.
Mr. Acharya (Nepal): Let me begin by
congratulating Viet Nam on its assumption of the
presidency of the Security Council for this month. I
would like to thank you, Sir, for organizing this open
debate on the important subject of children and armed
conflict during Viet Nam's presidency.
Nepal appreciates the remarks made on the
subject this morning by the Secretary-General; his
Special Representative, Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy;
the Executive Director of UNICEF, Ms. Ann Veneman;
and the Assistant Secretary-General for Peacekeeping
Operations, Mr. Mulet.
Armed conflicts continue to have a gruelling
impact upon children. In most conflicts, children are
often recklessly recruited by armed groups and left
without much protection. In others, they are the ones
who bear the brunt of the worst effects of war,
including displacement. Sometimes they are also
affected by sexual abuse and exploitation.
The Security Council's resolutions, including
resolution 1612 (2005), and thematic debates have
contributed immensely to addressing the plight of
children in armed conflict. Although some progress has
been recorded in the past decade to improve the
protection and well-being of children in armed
conflicts, much still remains to be done.
Ending conflicts is, without any doubt, the best
way to protect children from them. Therefore, the issue
of children in armed conflict should be taken into
account in the light of the centrality of peace processes
wherever they exist. Nepal supports the concept of
including the protection of children in peace
agreements and United Nations peacekeeping missions,
as long as they contribute to the cause of protecting
children while ending the conflict.
Where a peace process does not exist, the
protection of children should be given paramount
importance in all situations of conflict. Nobody should
be spared from accountability for their actions against
children, and no culture of impunity should be
tolerated.
The welfare and protection of children in armed
conflict should be viewed from a comprehensive
perspective. Nepal subscribes to the approach of
finding a durable solution from the standpoint of rights
and development. In that context, the international
legal instruments for the protection of rights of
children should be rigorously applied in all
circumstances. A long-term strategy aimed at solving
the root causes of the involvement of children in armed
conflicts should be the way forward. In that regard, we
welcome the proposal of the Office of the Special
Representative to conduct research on root causes.
There also needs to be some work on addressing the
development perspective of children in armed conflict.
Nepal accords high priority to protecting and
promoting the rights of children who have been victims
of armed conflict. We are working closely with the
Security Council Working Group on Children and
Armed Conflict, and the Government and the political
parties in Nepal are fully committed to implementing
various recommendations of the Group, especially in
the context of the ongoing peace process. Among other
things, we are working with United Nations agencies
on the ground to prepare a rehabilitation plan for those
minors who will be released from the cantonments
soon, as per the Comprehensive Peace Agreement
signed on 21 November 2006.
The Government of Nepal is committed to ending
impunity for crimes committed against children under
any pretext. As a party to the Convention on the Rights
of the Child and its Optional Protocol, Nepal is taking
measures to enact and implement the provisions of
those instruments.
We are confident that our efforts will result in
tangible achievements with the formation of a new
government in the near future, which is likely to be
headed by the Communist Party of Nepal (Maoist), as
the largest party in the Constituent Assembly that we
successfully elected on 10 April of this year. The
declaration of the Constituent Assembly to make Nepal
a federal democratic republic, ending the 240-year
monarchy in a peaceful manner, has heralded a new era
of political transformation. Those and other political
developments are likely to have a significant positive
impact on the protection and welfare of children
affected by the 10-year armed conflict that is coming to
an end in Nepal.
Nepal commends the initiatives taken by the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict in creating a synergy to
bridge the efforts of various agencies in addressing the
plight of children affected by armed conflict in various
parts of the world. The Government of Nepal looks
forward to her proposed visit to Nepal at a mutually
convenient time.
In conclusion, I wish to confirm that Nepal is
committed to working with the members of the Council
to create an effective framework for the protection and
promotion of the rights of children affected by armed
conflict and in finding a lasting solution to this grave
humanitarian problem.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of the Philippines.
Mr. Davide (Philippines): The Philippines
welcomes this open debate on the important issue of
children and armed conflict and congratulates and
commends you, Mr. President, and the members of the
Council for organizing it. Through it we may find
lasting solutions and establish effective and durable
measures that will prevent and eliminate the
recruitment and use of children in armed conflicts. The
full text of my statement will be circulated; I shall
deliver an abbreviated version.
Each of us was a child. If we had not been loved,
cared for and protected at that time, we would not have
been here today. No one may successfully argue
against the proposition that children are the best and
most valuable treasure of every nation of the world.
The Philippines' greatest national hero, Dr. Jose Rizal,
enthrones children as the hope of the nation. It follows
without saying that the abuse of children or denial of
their rights is the destruction of the nation's hope and
future and the dissolution of any promise for its
progress.
Thus, the Philippines places utmost importance
on children. The Constitution of the Philippines makes
the child the core of the Filipino family. It recognizes
the vital role of young people in nation-building and
directs the State to promote and protect their physical,
moral, spiritual, intellectual and social well-being and
to defend the right of children to assistance and
provide them special protection from all forms of
neglect, abuse, cruelty, exploitation and other
conditions prejudicial to their development.
The Philippines has a vast arsenal of statutes on
the rights of or concerning the protection of children,
such as the Family Code, the Child and Youth Welfare
Code and, more important, Republic Act No. 7610,
otherwise known as An Act Providing for Stronger
Deterrence and Special Protection Against Child
Abuse, Exploitation and Discrimination. Apropos the
issue at hand, that act includes provisions prohibiting
the use of children in armed combat and protecting
them from armed conflict. It establishes children as
"zones of peace" and provides for the evacuation of
children during armed conflict. In that regard, pursuant
to Executive Order No. 56, which was issued in 2001
by President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo, the Philippines
has established a comprehensive programme
framework for children involved in armed conflict,
which is implemented by 18 Government agencies with
the active participation of civil society.
The Philippines is a State party to international
agreements for the protection of the rights of children.
More relevantly, it has ratified the Convention on the
Rights of the Child and its Optional Protocol on the
Involvement of Children in Armed Conflict. At the
regional level, in 2001 the Association of Southeast
Asian Nations adopted a declaration of commitment on
children.
The adverse effects of conflict on children are
immeasurable and will affect them throughout their
lives. Often, those effects lead to the destruction of
their frail and still developing psyches, cause
unspeakable mental anguish and, in the worst cases,
bring about their untimely and undeserved deaths. The
Philippines is fully aware of the need to rectify that
situation as soon as possible, as well as to stop the
torment of child soldiers and to reintegrate and
rehabilitate the unfortunate children thus affected.
The Philippines has exerted vigorous efforts in
that regard and is continuing to take the most effective
action in cooperation with all stakeholders. Our
positive efforts have been recognized by the
international community, with the United Nations
having cited and commended the very high standard of
the legal framework in the Philippines, which
effectively protects children. The Organization has also
cited the Philippines' positive and constructive
cooperation with the United Nations on the issue of
children and armed conflict, in particular as regards the
establishment of a monitoring and reporting
mechanism.
The Philippines would once again like to
underscore its avowed policy to consider children as
zones of peace, as I mentioned earlier. Moreover, the
Government is doing all it can to prevent and eliminate
the recruitment and exploitation of Filipino children in
armed conflicts. Furthermore, many children involved
in armed conflicts because of non-State actors have
been rescued, rehabilitated and reintegrated into their
families and communities by the Department of Social
Welfare and Development.
A recent development worthy of note is the
review being conducted by the Philippine Government
to include provisions relating to children in armed
conflict in the ongoing peace negotiations with the
Communist Party of the Philippines-New People's
Army and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front. That is
consistent with moves to mainstream the issue vis-a-vis
those two non-State actors, in particular in the context
of the peace process. It must be stressed, however, that
the Philippines reserves the exclusive right to deal with
non-State actors in the Philippines.
Another development in the Philippines is the
continuing work being done by the Inter-Agency
Committee on Children Involved in Armed Conflict
pursuant to the comprehensive programme framework
to which I referred earlier. The Committee has
organized dialogue workshops with frontline service
providers. The project hinges on the three priority areas
of the Committee, namely, first, improving monitoring
and reporting of the Committee's cases; secondly,
improving institutional coordination; and, thirdly,
effectively rehabilitating and reintegrating into the
community children affected by armed conflict.
The strength of the legal protection afforded to
children in the Philippines, the comprehensive and
coordinated activities of the Government to protect,
rehabilitate and reintegrate children affected by armed
conflict and our excellent cooperation with the United
Nations, which has brought about positive changes on
the ground and resulted in increased protection and
safety for children, constitute key indicators of
progress. In the light of those measures, the Philippines
recommends that the Security Council seriously
consider ways of evaluating progress in the protection
of children affected by conflict. In doing so, the
Council would conclude that the Philippines can be
dropped from the list of countries included in annex II
of the reports of the Secretary-General on children and
armed conflict pursuant to resolution 1612 (2005). Due
process now supports such a course of action.
The removal of the Philippines from the list
would be a signal triumph vis-a-vis my country's
commitment to doing justice to the children caught up
in armed conflict, and to their loved ones. It would
equally be a victory for the United Nations and would
further encourage the Security Council to focus on
other countries in dire need of help. It does not take a
leap of the imagination to realize that there are more
children in other places who are at risk or who are
being deprived their rights, their futures and even their
lives due to more serious causes than armed conflicts.
In conclusion, the Philippines wishes to reiterate
its appreciation for the importance that the Security
Council attaches to the issue of children and armed
conflict. We assure the Council of our continuing
cooperation on this issue. The Philippines would again
like to place on the record that it looks forward to the
visit of Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy, Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for Children
and Armed Conflict, in order that she can see for
herself the relative calm and peace that prevail in my
country and can see that it is not in a dire situation of
armed conflict.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Myanmar.
Mr. Swe (Myanmar): I wish to thank you,
Mr. President, for the opportunity to participate in
today's open debate. My delegation appreciates the
decision of the Vietnamese presidency to focus on
ways and means by which the international community
as a whole can contribute to achieving a long-term and
sustained solution to the issue of children and armed
conflict.
We also believe in a broad strategy of conflict
prevention. In cases where conflicts occur, national
reconciliation must be the preferred strategy. In that
connection, we are speaking from our national
experience. As a result of our policy of national
reconciliation, 17 out of 18 insurgent groups have now
returned to the legal fold. Peace and stability prevail in
almost all quarters in Myanmar. The country is no
longer in a situation of armed conflict.
We have also been addressing successfully the
issue of under-age children in the military. In its
summary, the report of the Secretary-General on
Myanmar (S/2007/666) pointed out that "The
Government of Myanmar has made a commitment at
the highest level that no child under the age of 18 will
be recruited". In that regard, I wish to stress that
Myanmar's international obligation is not to recruit
anyone under 16 years of age. However, our domestic
rules and regulations provide for a higher standard.
Under the Myanmar Defence Services Act and the
directives of the War Office Council, the minimum age
requirement for recruitment into the military is 18
years.
The Myanmar Armed Forces, including
Tatmadaw Kyi, is an all-volunteer army; those who
join the military service do so of their own free will.
Forced conscription in any form is strictly prohibited.
A new directorate has been established to oversee strict
adherence to orders, regulations and directives in the
recruitment process. However, there are cases where
persons younger than 18 years of age have professed
themselves to be older and have been able to enter
military service. There are also cases where recruiters,
particularly in far-flung areas, are lax in enforcing the
minimum-age requirement.
In January 2004, therefore, the Government
established a high-level committee for the prevention
of the military recruitment of under-age children as
soldiers. To achieve its objectives, the committee has
adopted a plan of action to strictly ensure that children
under 18 years of age are not recruited into the armed
forces. Public awareness measures have also been put
in place. The Committee has also set up a task force
composed of the relevant ministries.
What I would like to stress here is that a
mechanism and the necessary regulations are in place
to ensure that no one under 18 is recruited into the
military. In order to raise awareness among those who
are involved in the recruitment process, officers of the
Office of the Adjutant-General conduct talks on the
protection and promotion of child rights and the
directives and regulations governing the recruitment
process. UNICEF is also invited to conduct lectures on
the protection and promotion of child rights. New
recruits found to be underage at recruitment centres or
training bases are discharged and handed over to their
parents or guardians. Punitive action is taken against
recruiters who contravene regulations.
The Government has been providing detailed
information regarding the progress made in its
awareness-raising activities, the number of and specific
particulars about under-age children discharged from
the military and other pertinent data to the Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for Children
and Armed Conflict. That information was also
provided to the resident representatives of the United
Nations Development Programme and UNICEF, who
have from time to time had occasion to visit
recruitment centres to witness the recruitment process
first-hand. We also invited Ms. Radhika
Coomaraswamy, Special Representative of the
Secretary-General, to visit Myanmar. During her visit
in June 2007, the Government of Myanmar
demonstrated its positive engagement by agreeing to
set up a monitoring and reporting mechanism.
The Government is implementing a policy of
stringent scrutiny at the recruitment stage, at the
training stage and even after the training period. As a
result of that strict scrutiny, between February 2007
and May 2008 some 1,049 underage persons were
rejected at the recruitment stage. From 2004 to May
2008, 259 people who had slipped through the initial
scrutiny were discharged from the military. From 2002
to January 2008, disciplinary action was taken against
44 military personnel who failed to strictly abide by
the recruitment criteria.
Education is an important element in addressing
the issue of child soldiers. The Government, actively
assisted by UNICEF, has conducted a number of
seminars and workshops. Between November and
December 2007, a total of four workshops and
seminars were held, in which both World Vision and
Save the Children took active part. Those were
followed by a number of multiplier courses. Between 1
February 2008 and 30 June 2008, we are able to
conduct multiplier courses all over the country,
attended by over 100,000 military personnel and their
spouses.
I also wish to inform the Council that the six
armed groups that have come back to the legal fold, as
mentioned in the Secretary-General's report, have
committed themselves and openly declared that they
will not recruit child soldiers.
Resolution 1612 (2005) contains important
elements for addressing the issue of children and
armed conflict. Here, I wish to stress in the strongest
possible terms the need for United Nations entities to
abide strictly by the stipulations of resolution 1612
(2005), in particular regarding the dialogue established
under the framework of the monitoring and reporting
mechanism by United Nations entities with non-State
armed groups. Allow me to also stress that resolution
1612 (2005) also stipulates that the mechanism must
operate with the participation of and in cooperation
with national Governments.
I wish to conclude by stressing once again that
the Government of Myanmar has made a commitment
at the highest level that no one under the age of 18 will
be recruited into the military. We have set up a
mechanism through a high-level committee for the
prevention of military recruitment of underage
children. We have also established working groups
under the committee and have set up two focal points,
one in the Ministry of Social Welfare and the other in
the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, to cooperate with the
United Nations Country Team.
The United Nations Country Team in Myanmar
has been a good partner and is supportive of the
Government's endeavours to prevent the recruitment of
underage children into the military. We will continue
our cooperation with the United Nations Country
Team. We have high respect for and confidence in
Special Representative of the Secretary-General
Radhika Coomaraswamy and her integrity. We will
continue our cooperation with her.
Allow me to express the hope that the positive
steps taken by Myanmar to address the issue will be
accorded the recognition they deserve and that
Tatmadaw Kyi will be removed from the annex of the
forthcoming report of the Secretary-General.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Tonga.
Mr. Tupouniua (Tonga): I have the honour to
speak on behalf of the Pacific small island developing
States, comprising Fiji, the Federated States of
Micronesia, the Marshall Islands, Nauru, Palau, Papua
New Guinea, Samoa, Solomon Islands, Tuvalu,
Vanuatu and my own country, the Kingdom of Tonga.
We would like to take this opportunity to thank you,
Mr. President, for convening this open debate on
children and armed conflict. We congratulate you on
your leadership in taking the initiative to highlight the
impact of armed conflict on the security of children.
The issue of armed conflict and its impact on
children is of great importance to the world, and it is
also relevant to our region. Children and young people
make up a large percentage of our population, and the
challenge of providing a safe and secure environment
is of paramount importance to our leaders. We may not
have the problems of child soldiers, as experienced by
some United Nations Member States, but our region
has experienced internal conflicts, and those conflicts
have had a negative impact on our children and young
people. We also face the challenge of cleaning up our
environment to make sure it is free of old munitions
from previous world wars. Old munitions are
hazardous to our environment. They affect our waters
and fishing environment. They also have a negative
impact on the health of our children. Therefore, a long-
term approach would be beneficial to maintaining a
safe and secure environment for the next generation.
The work initiated by the Security Council has
made a difference in exposing the detrimental impact
of armed conflict on children. The Security Council's
initiative on children and armed conflict has yielded
positive results in extending more protection to
children in conflict situations. The Working Group of
the Security Council on Children and Armed Conflict
has systematically reviewed 18 country reports of the
Secretary-General on children and armed conflict, and
13 sets of recommendations were adopted on the basis
of the conclusions of the reviews. Nine peacekeeping
missions involve child protection advisers, and the
security of children has also been featured in peace
agreements.
It is important that the Security Council sustain
the efforts to implement the four formal action plans
listed in the annexes to the Secretary-General's annual
report in order to end the recruitment of child soldiers.
We are aware that an estimated 1,400 children have
been released as a direct result of compliance with the
action plans. There is a need, however, to also focus on
preventative measures with regard to that issue.
Protecting the physical security of children is the first
step.
We must take extra steps to ensure that children
are cared for in post-conflict development. Children
who have experienced the trauma of war, particularly
child soldiers, should receive the necessary support to
help them with reintegration into their communities.
Many reports have shown that it is particularly difficult
for child soldiers to be accepted by their families and
communities due to the atrocities they were forced to
commit during times of conflict. Efforts are needed,
therefore, to work with Member States and grassroots
organizations to make provisions for child soldiers.
Many lack access to education, basic housing and
health care. Younger children, particularly young girls,
are easy targets for violence, sexual assault and human
trafficking. The recent report of the Vienna Forum to
Fight Human Trafficking noted that the increasing
demand for forced labour and sexual exploitation
leaves children vulnerable.
It is important to sustain the health and well-
being of children by eliminating possible security
threats to their mental, physical and emotional well-
being and to create an environment that promotes
safety and healthy development for those children after
they have been rescued. It is also important to
stimulate economic development and growth in post-
conflict settings so those children and young people
will have access to education, vocational training and
employment opportunities. In particular, it is important
to provide our children and young people with
educational and vocational opportunities to promote
political and economic security within our region.
We hope that the Working Group will continue to
monitor the treatment of children and child soldiers in
conflict situations. Greater cooperative efforts between
the Working Group and relevant United Nations
agencies, including the United Nations Office on Drugs
and Crime and UNICEF, are important in making
provisions to promote community-based reintegration
for children in post-conflict development.
The preventative approach advocated to deal with
the issue of children in armed conflict situations also
applies to other threats to international peace and
security. It is important to take active measures to
address the security implications of cross-cutting
issues, as those issues are not labelled as traditional
security threats but, in reality, have serious security
implications. For instance, climate change is a cross-
cutting issue that is relevant to international peace and
security, and it is our hope that the Security Council
will adopt a proactive approach to addressing the
security implications of climate change, as it has done
with the issue of children and armed conflicts.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Benin.
Mr. Zinsou (Benin) (spoke in French): My
delegation would like to warmly congratulate you, Sir,
on your country's assumption of the presidency of the
Security Council. We express our appreciation to the
representative of the United States of America for his
masterly guidance of the work of the Security Council
in June.
Benin, which conducted the negotiations leading
to the adoption of resolution 1612 (2005), welcomes
the remarkable progress made thus far in its
implementation. We pay a well-deserved tribute to the
Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict, Ms. Coomaraswamy; to
the members of the Working Group of the Security
Council and its main leader, France, co-sponsor of the
resolution; and to all of those in the field who have
provided new impetus to the follow-up mechanism and
the communication of information on children in armed
conflict.
The performance of the mechanism is indeed
most commendable, in particular since the issuance of
the independent study that made it possible to consider
jointly the situations referred to in annex I of the
Secretary-General's report, those situations which are
on the Council's agenda, and those that are not the
Council's agenda listed in annex II, on the basis of the
mandate provided by resolution 1379 (2001). We
encourage the Working Group to continue to work in
the spirit of the universality of its mandate and the
equitable treatment of all of the violations reported to
it. We welcome the invaluable contribution of UNICEF
to that positive evolution of the mechanism.
Progress made in the protection of children
affected by conflict can be measured in the large
number of children who have been liberated or
demobilized in both categories. While we are delighted
by those developments, there remains a great deal to do
towards making a reality of our dream of a world
without child soldiers, without children who are
mutilated or killed, without schools that are bombed
and without sexual violence being perpetuated on
children; a world without war against children, who are
the future of humankind.
The Council must tirelessly pursue its actions by
maintaining pressure on parties to conflicts. Without
belittling the advantages of the dialogue that has been
advocated by the Working Group of the Security
Council, in our view it is intolerable that we still have
more than 15 parties to conflict that continue with full
impunity to violate the rights of children in various
ways, despite the ongoing efforts made by the
international community to persuade them to mend
their ways.
The International Criminal Court (ICC) has
begun to play an active part in combating impunity for
crimes committed against children in armed conflict.
The Court requires the cooperation of States to achieve
its goals. We congratulate the ICC on its tenth
anniversary.
For its part, the Security Council should no
longer tolerate challenges to its authority if it intends
to preserve the credibility of the mechanism and its
own credibility in exercising the powers entrusted to it
by the Charter. The effectiveness of the Council
depends to a large extent on its internal dynamics.
There may be differences in the interpretation of
resolution 1612 (2005) and of earlier resolutions, but at
the time that the resolution was being drafted, we could
not imagine that the Working Group would be deprived
of the capacity to impose measures targeting those
parties which violate the rights of children once
verification of criminal acts had taken place.
We find ourselves in a situation which, back in
2006, was already of interest to the United Nations
Office of Internal Oversight, which, in the first
recommendation of its report, emphasized the disparity
between, on the one hand, the objectives and intentions
ascribed to the mechanism and its original intent and,
on the other hand, the fact that, in practice, there was
heavy emphasis on documenting verified violations
and that specific action by the Council was still not
forthcoming, despite the seriousness of the violations.
That is the case despite the relevant provisions of
resolution 1612 (2005). In paragraph 8 (a), the
resolution states that the Security Council decides,
inter alia, to entrust the Working Group with the
recommendation of measures to promote the protection
of children affected by armed conflict; in paragraph 9,
reaffirms that it intends to consider imposing, through
country-specific resolutions, targeted and graduated
measures against parties to armed conflict which are on
the Council's agenda and are in violation of applicable
international law relating to the rights and protection of
children in armed conflict.
Those paragraphs provide sufficient leeway for
the Working Group to propose measures against the
parties involved and for the Security Council to find
the appropriate formula for follow-up to those
proposals. It is our hope that the Council will be able
to mobilize the necessary political will to make full use
of the potential of resolution 1612 (2005).
If the general understanding is that the
aforementioned provisions deal only with situations on
the agenda of the Council, and if we conclude
therefrom that the mechanism lacks the ability to act
against parties in situations that are not on the
Council's agenda, it is then up to the Council to bridge
that gap. The earlier that is done the better, so as not to
perpetuate the practice of double standards in its efforts
to protect children in conflict situations.
We call on the members of the Council to work
vigorously to strengthen international measures for the
protection of children in conflict situations, both in
terms of mandates and in terms of resources allocated
to the various component parts.
At the same time, my delegation would like to
draw the Council's attention to the need to become
even further involved in the rehabilitation of child
victims abuse in conflict situations and to ensure that
poor communities are not left to deal alone with the
physical and psychological trauma inflicted on those
children.
The situation of children affected by armed
conflict should enjoy all due attention in the context of
peacebuilding efforts. The international community
should further contribute to the social reintegration of
those children by ensuring that they receive the
education and support they require and to which they
have a right if they are to grow and realize their full
human potential. At stake are the future stability of
their countries, the regions in which they are located,
and international peace and security.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Ireland.
Mr. Kavanagh (Ireland): Ireland welcomes this
opportunity to address the Security Council on the
subject of children and armed conflict. We fully
associate ourselves with the statement made by the
representative of France on behalf of the European
Union.
At the outset let me thank you, Mr. President, and
the Government of Viet Nam for organizing this open
debate on so important a topic.
Since the issue of children and armed conflict
was formally placed on the agenda of the Security
Council in 1998, the progressive engagement of the
Council has yielded significant gains for children.
Ireland supports the implementation of the
monitoring and reporting mechanisms on children and
armed conflict established by resolution 1612 (2005).
In that regard, we welcome the annual reporting of the
Working Group of the Security Council on Children
and Armed Conflict. The creation of the Working
Group gives firm evidence of the international
community's commitment to addressing that issue at
the highest level.
Ireland welcomes the adoption by the Working
Group, under the chairmanship of the Permanent
Representative of France, of concrete conclusions,
which contain increasingly specific requirements and
recommendations. These remind States of their
obligations and encourage them to take measures to
strengthen child protection. We note that, in many
cases, the conclusions have already had a positive
impact, including with regard to drops in child
recruitment and enhanced dialogue between parties to
conflicts and the United Nations. Ireland calls upon all
parties to implement the conclusions of the Working
Group. We also call for the Security Council and the
Secretary-General to look into the need to give the
Working Group the means required to enable it
effectively and transparently to continue its work for
the benefit of children.
Ireland is the current Chair of the Human
Security Network, a position that we will hold until
May 2009. The harmful and widespread impact of
armed conflict on children has been one of the priority
issues for the Network since its establishment almost
10 years ago.
We continue to be a strong supporter of the
valuable work of Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy, Special
Representative of the Secretary-General for Children
and Armed Conflict. We would like to take this
opportunity to commend Ms. Coomaraswamy and her
Office for their committed efforts in raising awareness,
engaging with parties to conflict through her field
visits and keeping this issue high on the international
agenda.
Ireland also recognizes the need to promote a
broad-based approach to the problem and, in that
regard, fully supports - in addition to the work of the
Office of the Special Representative - the endeavours
of UNICEF and other United Nations agencies, funds
and programmes, along with non-governmental
organizations, regional organizations and national
authorities.
We would also like to underline the importance of
the role that the International Criminal Court can play
in the fight against the impunity of perpetrators of war
crimes and crimes against humanity carried out against
children, including perpetrators who enlist and
conscript child soldiers.
Ireland draws attention to the establishment of
the European Union's Guidelines on Children and
Armed Conflict, which could be drawn upon by other
actors, and to the integration of that issue into the
Union's development and humanitarian policies. In the
context of the European Security and Defence Policy,
the issue is also integrated into external crisis
management operations of the Union, such as the
European Union-led peacekeeping force, which is
currently in place in Chad and the Central African
Republic under a mandate conferred by the Security
Council.
Children affected by armed conflict are among
the most frequent victims of serious human rights
violations and abuses. During an armed conflict, girls
in particular are subject to widespread - and at times
systematic - gender-based human rights violations
that have far-reaching repercussions. As Chair of the
Human Security Network, we have chosen to focus on
the theme of gender-based violence. In that regard, we
note in particular that the Secretary-General's report
issued in December 2007 (S/2007/757) recommends, in
its paragraph 160,
"that the Security Council give equal weight to
all categories of grave violations, including not
only the recruitment and use of children, but also
the killing and maiming of children, rape and
other grave sexual violence, abductions, attacks
against schools or hospitals and denial of
humanitarian access to children".
Successive resolutions of the Security Council
have also recognized such grave abuses. Resolution
1325 (2000) recognizes the human rights of girls and
their right to protection, including protection from
gender-based violence, particularly rape and other
forms of sexual abuse. Resolution 1325 (2000) also
recognizes the special needs of girls in post-conflict
situations and the necessity of taking girls' rights and
needs into account in designing peace programmes,
peace agreements, camps for refugees and internally
displaced persons, and disarmament, demobilization
and reintegration programmes. Most recently, Security
Council resolution 1820 (2008) highlights the targeting
of girls through the use of sexual violence and
demands that all parties to armed conflict take
appropriate measures to protect women and girls from
sexual violence.
In closing, let me reaffirm that Ireland is
committed to working closely with the United Nations
system, as well as with other relevant international and
regional organizations, to relieve the suffering of
children in armed conflict and to bring an end to
serious violations and abuses of children's rights.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Liberia.
Mr. Barnes (Liberia): I would like to thank the
presidency of the Security Council for organizing this
meeting to discuss and debate this very important
matter. In view of the fact that my country, Liberia, is
just emerging from a tragic drama in which children
were devastatingly victimized in a brutal civil war, I
feel morally obligated to add my voice to the ardent
appeal for the international community in general, and
this body in particular, to find practical and effective
solutions to the issue of children and armed conflict.
For me personally, the problem of children and
armed conflict and the far-reaching consequences of
children being caught up in armed conflict - whether
as innocent victims or as conscripted armed fighters
trained and conditioned to perpetuate unspeakable
violence against their fellow human beings - is not an
abstract concept. As a result of our civil conflict, I am
personally acquainted with quite a few former child
soldiers whom I have observed to be physically and
emotionally damaged.
In many ways, the kids and young adults whom I
know and who are ex-combatants are just that: children
and young adults. Yet, upon closer examination, one
can see the scars of deep hurt and pain in their eyes. At
the slightest provocation, such individuals may be
prone to resort to violence because they have been
conditioned to respond to almost any situation with
brutality. Their humanity has been buried deep beneath
a tough, unfeeling exterior.
I encountered a young Liberian during a time
when there was a brief respite in the fighting. He asked
me for a job, and, although I had been warned that he
was an ex-combatant, I wanted to help. Thus, I hired
him. Most of my neighbours wanted nothing to do with
this unfortunate young man and treated him like a
pariah. Over time, we would talk and my young friend
told me how he had gotten into the killing business.
He was only about 10 years old when rebels
raided his village and killed his parents in front of him.
Orphaned, he was soon urged to join another rebel
group, as part of what was referred to as the "small
boys unit", to avenge his family and just in order to
survive. At first, his rebel commanders armed him with
a slingshot and a machete. As a novice, he would hit
his target with a stone slung from his slingshot and
then finish off the stunned victim by chopping him to
pieces with his machete. Eventually, as a sign that he
was a fully matured killer, he graduated to the prized
AK-47.
Most of my conversations with this young man
left me speechless, but once I did ask him if he had any
regrets. He said to me, "Only one. Once, an old man
begged me not to kill him, and I shot him anyway." My
young friend looked haunted. His humanity had been
taken away. While he is only one example, there are
countless other examples of children worldwide who
have been directly involved in and impacted by armed
conflict.
Our world is continually becoming a smaller
place thanks to the phenomenon we all call
globalization. I say that this globalization is a double-
edged sword. Humanity can choose to be on the cutting
edge or the bleeding edge of the globalization sword. If
we of this generation do not do right by our children -
who are the future - we can rest assured that the
bleeding edge will be the dominant force of the future
of our common humanity.
My delegation seizes this opportunity on behalf
of the children of the world to plead to the collective
conscience and morality of the United Nations -
which represents the best hope for a future that is safe,
free, just and prosperous - to take the bold and
courageous actions necessary to protect our children
and the future of our planet. We can choose to take
those bold and courageous steps now and correct this
scourge or pay the drastic price of a more violent and
uncertain future. Left to its own devices, the
phenomenon that produces children victims and killers
today will only yield adult victims and killers
tomorrow.
The President: I now give the floor to the
representative of Mexico.
Ms. Rodriguez (Mexico) (spoke in Spanish): The
Mexican delegation is grateful to Viet Nam for
convening this public debate on an issue of great
topicality on the international agenda and of great
importance to the agenda of human rights and
international humanitarian law.
Mexico notes with concern that the great majority
of victims in armed conflict continue to be civilians,
and in particular children, who have suffered from
deliberate killings and maimings as well as the
indiscriminate use of force, in violation of applicable
international law.
My country's Government commends the work of
the Special Representative of the Secretary-General for
Children and Armed Conflict, the Working Group on
this topic and UNICEF in implementing resolution
1612 (2005). Nonetheless, and despite those efforts,
Mexico regrets the fact that the situation of children in
countries in armed conflict continues to be serious.
That is why the international community must continue
to take action to eradicate the problem.
Mexico endorses the Security Council's appeal,
reiterated in the presidential statement of 12 February,
for the adoption of a broad-ranging strategy of conflict
prevention that would address in a comprehensive
fashion the underlying causes of armed conflict in
order to guarantee better protection for children in the
long term.
At the same time, my country applauds the
resolve expressed by the Council that it will continue
to include or increase the numbers of child protection
advisers in the mandates of peacekeeping operations
and political missions, and reaffirms the importance of
their also being included in demobilization,
disarmament, reintegration and rehabilitation
programmes. In that regard, Mexico attaches great
importance to the inclusion of the issue of the
protection and rehabilitation of children in peace
negotiations, to the demobilization of child soldiers
throughout any conflict, and to the application of
preventive measures to ensure that they are not
recruited again or suffer reprisals.
Mexico wishes to underscore its concern that
children continue to be the main victims of the increase
in the indiscriminate use of landmines and cluster
munitions in countries in armed conflict and their
effects in post-conflict situations. We would therefore
encourage Member States to sign the Convention on
Cluster Munitions at the conference that will take place
in Oslo in December.
Mexico believes it essential to combat the
impunity of those who violate human rights and
international humanitarian law as they continue to
recruit and use children in armed conflict and commit
other serious offences, such as the killing and maiming
of children, sexual violations, abductions, attacks on
schools and hospitals, and the denial of humanitarian
assistance to children. In that respect, my country
underscores the importance that those responsible for
such crimes be brought to justice in national courts or
international tribunals or even referred to the
International Criminal Court for investigation and trial.
We also support the idea that the Council should
continue to adopt targeted sanctions against parties to
conflicts that commit grave offences against children,
in disregard of the recommendations of the Working
Group and the relevant resolutions of the Security
Council.
I note that Mexico condemns any act of sexual
exploitation or abuse committed by United Nations
personnel in which women and children are the main
victims. In that regard, my country urges Member
States to step up their efforts to implement the strategy
of assistance and support to victims of such acts so that
children can receive the understanding and support that
they need.
Lastly, we stress our hope that the Security
Council's call on the parties to conflict indicated in the
annexes to the report of the Secretary-General
(S/2007/757) to formulate and implement tangible
plans of action to put an end to the recruitment and use
of children in armed conflict will help to strengthen the
overall framework of the Organization's action to
protect children in armed conflict.
The President: I now give the floor to Mrs. Lila
Ratsifandrihamanana, Permanent Observer of the
African Union.
Mrs. Ratsifandrihamanana (spoke in French): I
wish to echo all previous speakers who have spoken on
this essential issue since this morning in commending
the Vietnamese presidency on its initiative for
convening this meeting. I would also like to pay tribute
to the outstanding work of the Special Representative
of the Secretary-General, Ms. Radhika
Coomaraswamy, and to the valuable contributions
made to today's debate by Ms. Ann Veneman,
Ms. Kathleen Hunt and Mr. Edmond Mulet.
Much has been said since we began the
discussion this morning, and all representatives of
African countries have stressed, with particular
reference to Africa, the crucial importance of the issue
of children in armed conflict. The policy of zero
tolerance for the recruitment of child soldiers and the
abuse and atrocities that children suffer has been
advocated since the adoption of resolution 1659
(LXIV) by the Council of Ministers of the
Organization of African Unity in 1996. Moreover, the
provisions of that resolution have been taken up once
again in various other key texts of the African Union.
The commitment of the leaders of the African Union
rests, above all, on the protection of children in armed
conflicts, the appeal for assistance from the
international community, the non-recruitment of
children under 18 as soldiers, the education of and
assistance to former child soldiers, regional training
programmes for members of the armed forces and the
establishment of peace corridors during armed
conflicts for the protection of children and for
humanitarian assistance.
(spoke in English)
Africa was the first region to adopt a
comprehensive instrument on the rights of children,
namely, the African Charter on the Rights and Welfare
of the Child adopted in 1990, a year after the adoption
of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the
Child.
The member States of the African Union also
endorsed the African common position entitled Africa
Fit for Children, which articulated priorities aimed at
improving the lives of children, including the right to
protection in situations of armed conflict and foreign
occupation. In 2007, a conference was organized in
Egypt to adopt a call for accelerated action on the
implementation of the Plan of Action for Africa Fit for
Children 2008-2012. Under that document member
States agreed to protect children from all forms of
abuse, neglect, exploitation and violence. The plan of
action focuses on the legislative and policy framework,
the institutional framework, mobilizing and leveraging
resources for Africa Fit for Children, and realizing the
right to an education and to protection.
Other African Union organs and bodies, such as
the Peace and Security Council, the Pan-African
Parliament, the African Court on Human and Peoples'
Rights and the African Commission on Human and
People's Rights, as well as all regional economic
communities, are actively engaged with respect to the
question of children in armed conflict.
However, despite those efforts, pockets of
resistance to the zero-tolerance policy of the African
Union on the use and abuse of children in armed
conflict can be observed in various conflict situations
around the continent.
The question of children and armed conflict is
certainly one that receives unanimous condemnation
and entails our shared responsibility in order to
strengthen responses for its total eradication. In that
regard, I would like to make a few points.
First, in Africa and other parts of the world,
illegal armed rebel groups are solely responsible for
the use and abuse of children in armed conflict. Our
response must thus include the strengthening of
strategies towards specifically targeting them.
Secondly, the question of children in armed
conflict is linked to the vulnerability and the
weakening of families owing to poverty. It would
therefore be crucial for the Security Council to lend its
full support to the achievement of the Millennium
Development Goals and other global commitments to
the eradication of poverty.
Thirdly, the impact of the involvement and abuse
of children in armed conflict extends far beyond the
person of the victim. It would thus be crucial to
support the efforts of Governments and regional
organizations, such as the African Union, which are
first in the line of responsibility towards the
rehabilitation and reintegration of victims.
Fourthly, as provided in the Council's presidential
statement (S/PRST/2008/6), the mobilization of
necessary resources and access to them by parties
would be crucial to facilitate the implementation of all
recommendations by the Security Council and the
international community as a whole.
(spoke in French)
In conclusion, I would like to reaffirm the resolve
of the African Union to work with the whole of the
international community to ensure that the zero-
tolerance policy towards the recruitment of child
soldiers and the abuses to which they are subjected
becomes a reality in Africa and all over the world.
The President: After consultations among
members of the Security Council, I have been
authorized to make the following statement on behalf
of the Council.
"The Security Council reiterates its
commitment to address the widespread impact of
armed conflict on children and its determination
to ensure respect for and implementation of its
resolution 1612 (2005) and all its previous
resolutions on children and armed conflict, and
the Statements of its President on 24 July 2006
(S/PRST/2006/33), 28 November 2006
(S/PRST/2006/48), and 12 February 2008
(S/PRST/2008/6), which provide a
comprehensive framework for addressing the
protection of children affected by armed conflict,
as well as the provisions on children contained in
other resolutions, including resolutions 1325
(2000), 1674 (2006) and 1820 (2008).
"The Security Council reiterates its strong
and equal condemnation of the continuing
recruitment and use of children in armed conflict
in violation of applicable international law,
killing and maiming of children, rape and other
sexual violence, abductions, denial of
humanitarian access to children and attacks
against schools and hospitals by parties to armed
conflict, while acknowledging that the
implementation of its resolution 1612 (2005) has
already generated progress, resulting in the
release and reintegration of children in their
families and communities, through, inter alia, a
more systematic dialogue between the United
Nations country task forces and parties to the
armed conflict on the implementation of time-
bound action plans.
"The Security Council reaffirms the need
for States parties to comply with their obligations
under the Convention on the Rights of the Child
and the Optional Protocols thereto, for armed
groups distinct from the State to refrain from
recruiting or using children in hostilities, and
urges States that have not yet done so to consider
ratifying or acceding to those instruments.
"The Security Council welcomes the
ongoing implementation of the monitoring and
reporting mechanism on children and armed
conflict, in particular the efforts that have made
possible the implementation of the mechanism in
all situations listed in the annexes to the latest
Secretary-General's report (S/2007/757), and
invites the Secretary-General, where applicable,
to bring the mechanism to its full efficiency, in
accordance with resolution 1612 (2005).
"The Security Council welcomes the
sustained activity of its Working Group on
children and armed conflict, as outlined inter alia
in the latest report by its Chair (S/2008/455), and
as the monitoring and reporting mechanism is
being implemented in a growing number of
situations of armed conflict, requests the
Secretary-General to provide additional
administrative support in order for the Working
Group to continue to fully carry out its mandate
in an effective manner.
"The Security Council invites its Working
Group on Children and Armed Conflict to
continue adopting conclusions providing clear
guidance to the parties to armed conflict and
relevant international actors on the concrete steps
that need to be taken in order to respect their
obligations under international law, in particular
Security Council resolutions on children and
armed conflict, and proposing effective
recommendations based on timely, objective,
accurate and reliable information, to the Council
with a view to promoting the protection of
children affected by armed conflict, including
through appropriate mandates of United Nations
peacekeeping operations and political missions.
The Security Council welcomes the efforts by its
Working Group to improve its working methods
and encourages it to continue to do so with a
view to further improving its transparency and
efficiency.
"The Security Council commends the work
carried out by the Special Representative of the
Secretary-General for Children and Armed
Conflict, Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy, and
underlines the importance of her country visits in
facilitating better coordination among United
Nations partners at the field level, promoting
collaboration between the United Nations and
Governments, enhancing dialogue with parties to
conflicts in implementing applicable international
law, including their obligations under Security
Council resolution 1612 (2005), and thereby
securing concrete child protection commitments.
"The Security Council also commends the
work carried out by UNICEF, as well as other
relevant United Nations agencies, funds and
programmes, within their respective mandates,
the child protection advisers of peacekeeping
operations and political missions in cooperation
with national Governments and relevant civil
society actors, in enhancing the activities of the
United Nations Country Task Forces on
Monitoring and Reporting and promoting child
protection at the field level, including through
implementation of Security Council resolution
1612 (2005) and following up on the relevant
conclusions of the Security Council Working
Group on Children and Armed Conflict.
"The Security Council recognizes the
important role of education in armed conflict
areas as a means to achieve the goal of halting
and preventing recruitment and re-recruitment of
children and calls upon all parties concerned to
continue to ensure that all children associated
with armed forces and groups, as well as issues
related to children, are systematically included in
every disarmament, demobilization and
reintegration process, with a particular emphasis
on education.
"The Security Council reiterates the need
for stronger focus by all parties concerned,
including Governments and the donor
community, on the long-term effects of armed
conflict on children and the impediments to their
full rehabilitation and reintegration into their
families and communities, through, inter alia,
addressing the need for providing appropriate
health care, enhancing their exchange of
information about programmes and best practices,
and ensuring the availability of adequate
resources, funding and technical assistance to
support national strategies or action plans in the
area of child protection and welfare, and
community-based programmes, bearing in mind
the Paris Principles to Protect Children from
Unlawful Recruitment by Armed Forces or
Groups, with a view to ensuring the long-term
sustainability and success of their programmatic
response to the release, rehabilitation and
reintegration of all children associated with
armed forces and armed groups.
36
"The Security Council looks forward to the
next report of the Secretary-General on children
and armed conflict, and reiterates its readiness to
continue to review the relevant provisions of its
resolutions on children and armed conflict,
building on the provisions of resolution 1612
(2005), with a view to further enhancing the
comprehensive framework of the protection of
children in armed conflict."
This statement will be issued as a document of
the Security Council under the symbol
S/PRST/2008/28.
There are no further speakers inscribed on my
list. The Security Council has thus concluded the
present stage of its consideration of the item on its
agenda.
The meeting rose at 6.25 p.m.
08-42816
▶ Cite this page
UN Project. “S/PV.5936Resumption1.” UN Project, https://un-project.org/meeting/S-PV-5936Resumption1/. Accessed .