S/PV.2810 Security Council
▶ This meeting at a glance
1
Speech
0
Countries
2
Resolutions
Resolutions:
611 (1998),
S/RES/611(1988)
Topics
War and military aggression
Israeli–Palestinian conflict
In accordal!ce with the decisions taken at previous
meetings on this item, I invite the Minister for Foreign Affairs of Tuniaie to take
a place at the Council table; I invite the representatives of Bahrain, Bangladesh,
Cuba, Egypt, Gabon, Greece, Jordan, Kuwait, the Lao People’s Denixratic Republic,
Lebanon, the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya, Mauritania, Morocco, ?&xzarrS,ique, Pakistan,
Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Somalia, Sudan, the Syrian Arab Republic, Turkey, the
Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Rep.iblic, the United Arab aoirates, Yemen and Zimbabwe
to take the places reserved for them at the side of the Council Chamber; and 1
invite the representative of the Palestine Liberation Organization to take a place
at the Council table.
At the invitation of the President, Mr. Mestiri (Tunisia) took a place at the
Council table; Mr. Al-Shaker (Bahrain), Mr. Siddiky (Bangladesh)#
Mr. NufleZ Mosquera (Cuba), Mr. Badawi (Egypt), Mr. Biffot (Gaban), Mr. Zepos
(Greece), Mr. Salah (Jordan), Mr. Abulhasan (Kuwait), Mr. Kittikhoun (Lao People’s
Democratic Peprblic), Mr. Fakhoury (Lebanon), Hr. Treiki (Libyan Arab Jamahiriya),
Mr. Guld Boye (Mauritania), Mr. Bennouna (Morocco), Mr. Des Santos (Mozambique) I
Mr. Shah Nawaz (Pakistan), Ir. Al-Kawar F (Qatar), Mr. Shihabi (Saudi Arabia),
Mr. Osman (Somalia), Mr. Adam (Sudan), Mr. Al-Masri (Syrian Arab Republic),
Mr. tickmen (Turkey), Mr. Cudovenko (Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Replblic),
Mr. Al-Shaali (United Arab mirates), Mr. Basendwah (Yemen) and Mr. Wnzou
(Zimbabwe) took the places reserved for them at the side of the Council Chatier;
Mr = Al-Kidwa (Palestine Li.bezation Organ ;zation) took a place at the Council table. -
The PRBSRJTs I ahould like to inform the Council that I have received
letters from the repreeentetives of the Congo and Djibouti in which they rt3gUeSt to
be invited to participate in the discussion of the item on the Councilye agenda.
In conformity with the usual practice, I prove, with the consent of the Council,
to invite those repreaentstives b participate in the discussion without the right
to vole, in accordance with the relevant provisions of the Charter and rule 37 of
the Ccuncil’s prarisional rules of procedure.
There being no abjection, it is so de&Bad.
At the invitation of the Presi&nt, nC. Wouki (Coogo) and Mr. Olhaye
(Djibouti) tcmk the placem reserved for them at the side of the Council Chather.
The PRBgXDR4Tt The Security Council will nar r&Bum ita a>nsfderatim of
the item on its agenda.
I should like to draw the attention of medmre of the Council lo document
8/19820, uhich contain8 the text of a letter dated 21 April 1988 from the charge
d’affaires ad interim of the Paremnant Mission of 2imbabbue to the United hations
addressed to the 8ecretary-Gener al.
The first speaker is the representative of the Sudan. I invite him to take a
place at the Council and to make hi&. statement-
Hr. ADAM (Sudan) (interpretation from Arabic) t We are honaJred to see
your Sir, presiding over the Council during the rxmth of April. We already know
your eminent qualities, a8 you belong tc a sister African aun”Jy whose lea&rehip
has been aharactetized by wisdou~ and determination with regard to just callsee
whether in the context of Africa or of unresolved international or regional
questions.
Through you, Sir, we pay tribute to the Permanent Representative of Yugoslavia
for the exemplary way fn which he conducted the Council’s buaineas last month.
(Mr. Adam, Sudan)
We are also honoured by the presence of Mr. Mahmmd Mestiri, Foreign Minister
of mnisia. Rnovn within thie Organisation in the reoetnt past ae a.akilful
diplonmt, he has submitted to us an ertremely serious mtter arising from the
brutal terrorist aggression against kie mace-laring aountry and its territorial
integrity early on the mcening of 16 April by a group of Israeli terrorists. They
infiltrated I\misia in order to perpetrate a heinam crime which led to the
martyrdom of one of the leaders of the Palestinian resistanas, Mr. &alil al-Wasir,
.Abu Jihcd., in a horrible manner under the very eylee of his family, inoluding a
little drild.
The tirei* Hiniatar of mnieia presented hia axmtry’s amplaint in so
aonvinoing a umnner as to leave no room for doubt or for scepticism to be built
into a false conviction in Israel’0 favour, enabling it to flout the prinnaiples of
the Charter and destroy all hum ideals and the eacred valuea and rules of the
international m-unity, vhich prohibit aggression against the ewereignty of
independent States and emphaaize the need for respect for their territorial
intmgr ity.
The action carried out by the Israeli inetitutions of aggression and their
intelligence eefvices on 16 Apr 11, vi th the knanledge and bleeeing of the Israeli
Cabhet, a@ reported by reliable ma80 media, vaa not the firet of its kind against
Tunisia’s swereignty. In Octaber 1985 the Council adopted resolution 573 (198!0,
in the vake of the aggression perpetrtted by Israel againot Tunieia’s swereignty
and territorial Integrity. That aggresaim of October 1985 VW committed blatantly
by the Israeli air force, vhkh ocvered hundreds of wiles to fulfil its mission.
The recent aggression of 16 April against Tunisia’s sweteignty and territorial
integrity Look a different form, but the result was the same. There is RO au&
thing as a perfect crime.
(Mr. Mae, Sudan)
Hdlm farael@a politioal institutions md ite &XI mdia have this the choeen
Offidal oflmw and aetho4s we have oom ti aeeo&ate with them, no one ha0 80 far
ma& my reference to any other party or presented any hard widenue aaawing MY
Other pIWw of aooaerinating the Palestinian wrtyr, Abu Jihad.
(Mr. Adam, Sudan)
AZ1 reliable reporting organisations and mma mdia have branded Israel with
the perpetration of thie heinous crime.
By Way of exaa@e, we refer to the Israeli Premier ‘8 initiative of sending a
cmgretulattory cable to tha terroriste on the eucceee of their terrorist action.
B&e that eimply out of a&niration for a prelpeditated aot of aggression undertaken
by a group that lan&d in Tmieia from eoae celestial body in another univa~ae?
Thtarghout ite history Israel hae adopted disinformation aa a basis for its
entire politiual institution. The meet eloquent example in this regard is prrobebly
its use of methods of deosptiqn and fraud in building iter nuclear capability. It
persisted in that arrogant decmption mtil it was recently exptmed by an Israeli
expext who had worked at the Dtnona reactor. The world was suddenly alerted by
irrefutable evidence to the eeriownesa of ferael’s lmlenciee and its use of
military mi*t - even if that mi#lt lead to the outbreak of a devastating nuclear
war.
The strategic technical aD-operation &at ham gone ar for years between
’ Israeli intelligence services and their counterparts in som mjor Parer0 known for
their friendship with Israel hae enabled G e latter to play hevoc with all
international norms and laws that should be respected and Ipaintrrfned. That
ooqmration has enabled Israel to strike at will in pureuit of the Palestinians
wharf ft has displaced from their homeland. This is a singularly serious mtterr
because it hss a direct beating on the security of States, their national
sovereignty over territories and their right ti dfdefon-trbskitg. I need not cite
examples of Israel’6 past action8 against the ecw3rsignty of States other than
Tunieia; we are 8’11 aware of them.
Therefore the crime perpetrated by Ieraeli eervioee againet Tunisia and
previouf3 crimes against the territorial integrity ma political independence of
(Hr. Mam, Sudan)
other States are a flagrant breach of Article 2 (4) of the tlhited Nations Charter
end must be condemned once again, the Council must take appropriate measures to
ensure that that will not be repeated. If the State terrorism praotised by Israel
this tima is designed to enhanoa the prestige of its security and of ita military
and political institutione in the context of the continued Palestinian uprising
within Xsreel and inside the oooupied Palestinian territories, then the result has
been ample tely corn tet-produo t ive - it hee increased the resistance to occupation
in the occupied territories and more martyrs heve fallen.
Israel continues to impmda all peace initiatives in the ares ellaed essentiellY
at respecting the legitimate rights of the Palestinians, including the
establishment of their own inhpendent state end a just, permment and genuine
Peace in the Middle -St. The eforemmtionecl requites that Israel withdraw from
all the Arab territories occupied by it since 1967 and its acceptance of fixed
intetnetionel borders. Ultimately, that means abendonment of Isreel*e expansionist
dreams end aspirations of superiority vis-&via the other States in the region.
Rae the psychology end orientation of the Israeli leadership achieved that stsge?
AL1 indications and the tendencies of Xarael’s leaders indioate otherwise.
PinSlly, I must soquaint the members of this Council with the official
communique issued by the Ministry for Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Sudan in
the wake of the assassination of the martyr Abu J ihad: It stated that the
assassination of the Palestinian leedet shocked the civilized world end the entire
Arab nation; that the Sudan cannot but express its denunciation of this heinous
crime and condemn the Israeli design to deport Palestinian freedom fighters from
their homeland to Iabancn, having exhausted all mans of oppression and terrorism
in the occupied land of Palestine. The communiqu4 indicates that the Sudan haa
been follwtng with grave awcecn all the acts of terrorism and oppression taking
place in occupied Palestine , and affirms that a people of the aagrbitude awl
detertination of the Palestinian people will nevm ceve in to oppreeoion and
terrorimn.
The PRESZDBNTt I thank the representetive of the Sudan for the kind
words he addreseed to me.
The neHt speaker is the representative of Uauritani.8. I invite him to take a
place at the Council table and to nreke hi8 etateemnt.
Mr. OUID BOY& (Mauritania) (interpretation fram Arabto)% It give8 IS
pleasure to eee a brother, the repreaentstive of &mbiar PraRiding aver tie
8eCurity Council’s deliberation8 thie amth. I extend to you, Sir, sincere
oongretulations on your assumption of the preef&ency. My delegatim feels thatr
Shar&@ Co your dipltxnatic skill and great exper iencm, the Council will be able to
fulftl its duty in the maet felicitous manner.
t take this opportunity to express our abngratulations to and appreciation of
your predecewzc, the Permanent Representative of Yugoslavia, Mr. Dragoal.av Pejic,
for the able manner in which he guided the Council’s work during Ilsrd.
I should also like to weloom a prominent Tunieian Arab official vho is Well
knoun for his vast k-ledge, wisdom, serioueneeo of purpoee and pru&nes,
wt. MeImoud mstifi, the Minister for Porelgn Affair6 of Tunisia, who cam
perecmally to address the Security Council on the TunLian amplaint - indeed, a
canplaint by us all and an indication of our repugnance at Israel’s dastardly act
of assassination of the Paleetinian freedom fighter Rhalil al-Wssir and an act of
aggreseion against Tunieie’s sovereignty and territorial 1ntagrit.y.
aggression against Tunisia’s sovereignty and territorial integrity and the
assassination of a great Palwtinlan free&m Pighter Khalil al-Warir and other
innocent pecuans.
Tmieh, whi& hail been a victim of Zraelll aggression, has wfnt8ind urd
uin~ino intim& tiw of kinship with Uauritania. Our actions amverge towards
th@ eotabliahmat of the great Arab Maghreb within the PramawoCk of Arab MitY#
which is Freu of intoleranca and aggreseion. Burtherlrore, %miuia ham a reputation
in the international coammity for its paacafulness, opennetm8 hospitality, Wi6dOa
and modaration.
(MC. Ould Boye, Mauritania)
That hae been reflected in the support we have seen in the past Pew days for
this sister country. There is no doubt that Israel’s act oP aggression against
Tunisia and its cowardly assassination of Whalil-al-Wasit have proven several
facts; first, that Israel does not want peace) secondly, that violence is inherent
in Israel’s system of life an8 that, therefore, it would be difficult for 28rael to
renounce it. Also, Israel has proved that it has lost its nervea in the face of
the Palestinian people who are in revolt inside occupied Palestine, especially as
the Palestinians have pre-empted Israel’s ability to use its essential weapons. It
has beoonm clear to the entire world that the demcracy claimed by Israel is but (L
srmkescreen thraJn up in an effort to deoeive certain nations and to lure
increasing nunWas of settlers to ferael.
pamvet, there is another established fact, namely, that the Palestinian
people, mder the leadership of the Palestine Liberation Organisation, has gained
more resolve and determination. Palestinians no larger dread the Israeli soldiers,
aho are armed to the teeth.
Our amsistsnt position has been that the Palestinian people, whose land has
been usurped unjustly and by aggression, will emerge victorious in its war against
Israel) it is supported by all forces that uphold peace and justice.
Israel is mistaken uhen it assumes that, by k ill ing a Pales tin ian freedots
fighter who has been denied his land, it will be able to stem the grawing tide of
the Palestinians’ uprising, which is aimd at regafnlng their dignity, independence
and freedom. The determination of the Palestinian people has bear. reinforced and
they no longer fear death. The Palestinians enthusiastically embrace martyrdom.
Martyrs are buried amid chants and songs of joy and pride.
(Mr. (luld Boye, Maw itania)
A Uauritanian poet who considers himself a Palestinian has stated%
“We receive our maetyrs in pride and dignity as we celebrate their
departure, and we sing the songs of death in the cause of life as being the
way to life. We sing in our wounds, for miracles reside in the masses and
oppression gives birth to freedcsn.’
As I a&rem the Security Council, I declare our solidarity with and support
fa eietec Tunisia in the face of Ierael’s vicious act of aggression against
‘hJl\misien territory and swereignty. I reiterate my country’s support for the
Pale8tine Liberation Organizatior. and the heroic Palestinian people confronted by
the Campaign of ter rot and assassination cart ied out aga inst them by Israel, both
inside and cuteida their homeland. Israel iS Once again challenging all
intWIK#tiOnal law3 and norms of behaviour by cotmaitting an act of aggression
against an independent, sarerefgn State *&et of the mite8 Nstione.
llccordingly, my delegation calls upon the Security C0uncil met strongly t0
aakdemn Israel ta its repeated acts oE apgression against the Tmisian RB@liC
and to tske proper action in order to prevent the recurrent Of such acts Of
aggress ion. We call upon the Security Council, in accordance with the spirit of
the bited Nation8 Charter and the resolutions of the @netal Assembly, also to
c4mdem a8 an abhorrent act of terrorism Istael's assassination of Rhalil-al-Wazir,
vh0 wa6 in his civilian residence and in the presetroe of his children and other
family amhers.
8u adopting such a position, which is in conformity with the principles for
which it was established, the Security Council would undoubtedly enhance 'be
WnfiC&nC@ Of peoples and States in the mitea Nations an6 in tie hiq’neai; Oiqau
entrusted with the maintenance of international peace and security, namely, the
Security Council itself.
The PREsXDtSW I thank the representative of bhuritania ear hie kind
wards addressed to IDB. The next opeaker ia the representative of Djibouti. I
invite him to take a place at the Caunail table and to make his staterent.
Mr. OLIflWE (Djibouti); I wish to acknowledge at the outset the presence
Oe Ur. Blahmud Mestiri, Foreign Mini&x of %$,anisia, who haa travelled all the way
here to plead his comtry*a aomplaint to thie COMC~~, Lollwing tie sat of
aggression auatained by his awntry. Eli8 preeence here is aleat testimony of the *
gravity of the mtter for the consideration of the Council. Djibouti ha8 a Social
relation with Tunisia and hae always respected and a&ired the pragmatism,
maderation CmB aoneiatenay in international relative of that eietarly nation. We
are e&nod that it has becoa again the object of Xerael i terror ier.
Beeare proamding, 1 should like to congratulate yarr sir, an your aammption
0e the preeiidency 0e the Council for this mnth. I am aonfidbnt that your drill8
rrd proeeesianalien will judiaiouely guide the Council.
The Council ie meting to oon6ider Tunisia9 legitimate aomplaint concerning
Israel’8 blatant disregard of ite sovereignty end territorial integrity-
CUWinaing evidence incriminating Israel in thie attack, which culminatid in the
tragic death of Khalil-al-Wait l Abu Jihad. and other innocent individuals, hae
been detailed by the epakece who spoke before me and therefore I need not clue11 on
it at length. This is a eerioue trim that requirea the most intenee ocmpera tion
in the Council to arrive at far-reaching concf.usione and nteaeures which will
effectively ensure that euch disdain and arrogance ohall have no place in thie
war ld. It to dioturbing that Ierael could commit multiple atrocities
eimultamously in the occupied territozie@, in Tunisia and, only a few days ago, in
Lebmm, and still be obBeseed with eecurity end paw.
(Mr. Ofhave, Djibouti)
Indsed, it is Israelgo very denial of security, ‘peace and freedom to other8
that ie the root cause of the prublem. The trampling underfoot of the rights of
Palestinians for alsmt half a oentury and the consistent flouting of all relevant
United #ations reeolutiona aimd at achieving lasting peace in the region is a
recipe for diaaeter.
The asewsinrtion of Khalil al-Waair, Abu Jihad, has only added umte ‘fuel m
an already preoerioua situation. Duu we shall have a conflagration. During the
Onet four aontbo we have witneseed the spontaneous uprising of the Palestinians in
the ocarpied Arab territories, which has to date resulted in the death of some 2DO
PeoEle, thousands of GaMaltie8, unquantifiable loss of property and deportations.
These psople demand nothing more thah the basic elements of human decenty, the rule
Of lw and the exeroise of self-determination towards self-rule, as enshrined in . the Chwtu. ‘ire m&due and wifle the popular uprising simply through resorting to
ooeraion and the ume of form, acampanied with ureets, detentions, deportations
blookades and cwfewm, will not serve the cause of peace nor heal the wounds. On
the QHIttuy, it hae mly served to exacerbate and further aggravate the belieate
balance. In the prmess, Israel has , unnecessac ily , earned for itself tbe Math,
amlf#laation aud ignominy of the international cornunity, It is suffering from a
credibility crieie of enormous proportions , as a result of its wtal defiance and
contravention of n&emus United Nations resolutions, in particular security
Council resolutions 607 (1988) and 608 (1966). As could be expected, the
aesaseinstion of A&u Jihad has further strengthened the resolve and the will of the
Palestinian people, who mote than ever firmly reject resignation and deepair:
their reaction is rage, not submission.
Obviously, political control in Israel is in the hands of men who are
vehsmemtly oppoeeB ti the very notion of peace, let alone peace negotiations; and
My hop@, however fragile, raised by Secretary of State Shultz has now evaporated.
(Mr. fllha&, 03 ibouti)
AS the observer rightly pointed out,
%he Icraelie [settlers] live nwxe in the past than the present and attach
greater weight to the claims of history than the claim of medo
Ierael ie entitlad to its opinions and prejudices; it ie not, however, entitled to
its om oonaegtian and interpretation of hutnan rights, flreedom and international
law and practice. Israel knwe full well how far io too far and how larch ie tcm
EWCh. It must be punished severely for its conteapt of this Councils
We offer our sincereet condolences to the family of the elain leader and to
the Palestinian population, who have Buffered an irreparable loss. BgUallYr we
wish t0 state out full syrppathy and solidarity with the evermnt and the people
of Tunisia. The Council is in duty-bound to condean in the strongest possible
t.errre the repeated act of aggression against the cravereignty and territorial
integrity of a staunch and law-abiding Memhet of the United Nstions.
I thank the Council for having acceded to my rwueat to participate in this
dabate.
The pRlBIDR4T: I thank the tepreeentative of Djibouti for the kind words
he addressed to abe.
The next speaker is the representative of the Congo. fn invite him to take a
place at the Council table and to make hie ststement.
Mr. ADOIJKI (Congo) (interpretation from Prench)t I am pleased to have
this opportunity to congratulate you , sir, cn your aesuuaption 0E the presidency of
the Security council. You have my delegation’s very beat wiehee during your term
0e 0ffm thh3 month.
I wieh to tianic your ptedeceasoc, His excellency Ambaseedor PBjic of
Yugoslavia, for the excellent fob he did last month.
I should like once again to place on rec~d the deep respect my delegation and
I have for Bie Excellency or. Mahmoud Mestici, Minister foe Foreign Affairs of
(Hr. Mouk i, Congo)
Tunisia, who le present at this dabrto. We should havie mch preferred to greet and
welcome him warrly to t?eu York in leas dietreaoing eircuaotancee. Never theleso, we
are pleased to 986 him hero with 8180
The Palestinian people are muming their dead. Indeed, for the pet 40 years
life there haa continued t@ extraat a ghaotly daily toll. In the aurrent
Palestinian national uprising, tbe international mdia have relayed pictures of
atone-thrcwing being rt by bloody reprewion at the hands of the occupation fotces
in Mesa and the wbot Bank - two aaaupied territoriee uhoge inhabitanta, as we knar,
have opted fur e path other than rosignatlon and despair.
The Palwtinien &ad strewn crlarg tbrt peth are now legion. Not even
Palestinian leaders 8re spared the onay*r lightning terrorist strikeac they fall
murdered in their turn.
In aOtobu 198s Tuniclia witne88ed a nmlvo attack against the Palestine
Liberation Otganisatiar (MD), in flagrant violation of international law and
Tunieia*s sarereignty and territorial integrity. ?&w it has become the 8etting
for the deepicabla murd= of Hr. Khalil l l=Uasir , a Pu) leader, in Tunis on 16
April, in oircurtanae~ I shall not duo11 upon but which Tunisia’s Minieter for
Poreign Affaim,.with an saute een8e of hio lofty rospmaibilitlee, eccurately
described to the Counoil.
In tbe Minister ‘r view - rhued by international absuvere of recognised
credibility and impartiality - a Refty dcm of blindness and caaplacency would be
required to absolve those reeponrible for thie politicelly motivated murder on
Tunisian territow.
The Congo firmly aondeae the Political msaerination of the Palestinian
leader Rhaftl al-Uauit. Hy country has expreesed its condolencQo to the
Palestinian people and to the faailiee of the mniehn victims. The Congo ehareo
Tunisia’8 respect foe internc,tioRa1 law.
Olr. MoukI, Cargo)
Thb otir &t&d h TmAe a~nrthltut~ m l ttaafc against ‘Rni8fm
l UUa<y Mb territorial integrity. It cannot go unpunished. Aa previoue
l pukur hmm rightly epphesimd, thie ariaa ~~deminea the relaxation of tension
that ir naamsary in the fmrch, whidr is already arduotm, for a just and lasting
perin t?m widdle East-
Mt. Wouki, Cmqo)
All cbmber sate8 of the mited Nations are &&bound to work for peace by
doing their u&et to faoilitate the amvening of the Inteenational Peace
Conferewe on the Middle Baet*
& delegation rOiteKate0 that the Cango umdenme all attack8 fin&n-d,
SUppOrted and perpetrated by Oovernmnt8 a8 being particularly odious. W
delwtiOll i8 reminded in the849 dCCU~tMCC+S Of thQ CegtdaC ~8a88hatiOn8 Of
fteedoa fighters Qatpettated by the CaCist South African apartheid r8gime.
In keeping with itp Charter &ligation8 end its special responsibilities for
the minteMM0 Of int0tMtiOMl pee and Security, the Security Council mu8t
axpre88 the horror and the tepbiation and firm amdemation of this aat of
aggteadan Jhiah Tmiaia ia entitled to heat tram the intetnetional community and
stab8 maor8 of the Boautity CoUnuil.
Like 80 many paa-leping Btatar and peaplss, the Carncil ucmld thhus be
displaying it8 aative Sdid&tity with ‘PUlliSis, a united tbtione nttbet uho8e
generow hoepitelity md l meteignty hate once again been ~0 outraqeady flated,
The IfRBBOEPTr I thenk the representative of the Con90 tot his kind
WOrdS addrO88ed t0 m.
I shall now make a elsteant in ~sy Capacity a8 the Representative of Zambia.
When the framers of the United Nation6 Charter delibera”*ed wet it8
prwisions, they envisaged, inter alia, a provision for the prevention of
eituatiais that threaten international peace and securitv. In an effort to achieve
this end, they made it obligatory for all Metier States to refrain in their
international relation8 from the threat or use of force against the territorial
integrity or political independence of any State , or in any other manner
inconaietent with the purpcsee of the United Nations.
A8 Mslllber States of the Wited Nations, we therefore have a moral obligcrtiow
to fulfil in good faith, the provisions of the Char&x in order to pronw8 greater
intunatianal underetmding and co-peration. This, in our vie-u, is a cardinal
principle which We all should cherish and respect.
It i8 With thi8 VieV in mind and our faith in the United NatiOII8 a8 the
arbiter for resolving international dispute8 that my delegation saw the imperative
need for the &murity Council to accede to the request by the Government of Tunisia
to debate the item before US.
The Minister of Foreign Affairs of mnieia, Mr. Meetiri, in his lucid and
detailed pte8entstian to this body, stated hi8 COU#ltty’S indignation and outrage at
Israeli toobl disregard of mnisia’s swereignty and territorial integrity. My
aomtry, whidr hae suffered eimilrr acts of aggreeeion from the racist r6gilPe Of
South Mr:=, is in full 8yaOathy with TuniSiabe Cmplaint and suppotit.
TMiSia i8 a friendly, no*aligned and pWXtfU1 country committed to the total
eradhation Of all vestiges of colonialism, oppreaeion and foreign domination.
Thea0 are lofty aims which d88etve. the unflinching support of all free&X&-1Wing
ao~ntrie~ the war 18 over. lImisia*s amitment to these ideals is donmnsttated by
it8 teadine and willingne88 to offer 8arEtUary to oppreeeed and displaced
people. It8 8actifioe and eelflessneae are highly comendable and merit the
sympathy and support of the international comamity at large.
The 5itUation in the Pliddle East continues to deteriorate by the day as
Israeli forces continue to brutalise , maim and break bones and to kill Palestiniens
in the w-pied tecritor ies despite the resolutions of the setcutity council, ana
indeed the artcry of the international community against this reign of terror.
(The Ptes i&n t)
It is regrett86i.e Uist in this Qy and age, and given recent attempt8 at peace
initiativea which include the proposal br an international peamnfexence to
addtees ule Middle East situation, the core of which is the question of Paleatiner
I.sr: ael hes chosen to take a dangerous pati of attacking ite grab neighbour e and
&are that are not close to its borders in hot pureuit of those oppmmd to its
UlilLtary occupation. Tbla aggressive posture cannot and uill not contribute to
peace ad security in the Middle East. It will breed further tension and escalate
oonflicta, both of which conetitute a serious threat to international peace and
security.
Pbr a 1-g tim nm my country has repeatedly urged Israel to adopt a policy
of peaoetful mexistence with ita Arab neighbours. We find it ironic that a COMUY
which publicly eeeke secure bacdbre Bharld reaort to mate terror iem NIX a way of
dealing a permanent blow to thoee who dieagree with its policies. By aeekihq t0
reeolve political p&lby military xeane Israel ie engaging in an exercise of
eelf delua iox. Wa continue to believe that it is in’fecael’e ovn intereet, and
indeed in the interest of all muntrlee in the region, that a peaceful and just
eolutkn TV this vexing prablera have its twtn in an international peace
amference. Peace and aggreaeion cannot wexiet.
We in Zaxbia otrongly condemn the armed terrorist wmmando attack on T\mbia
on 16 April 1988 end call on the international ammunity to apate no effort in
cmdermlmg this attack. Assassination of Leaders is not the anewer to the problems
ot the region. In this regard, Israel should have the courage to accept the
universal call for an international peace conference on the Middle East in which
all the parties wncerned, including the Palestine Liberation Organlzation (PLO),
vi11 particiwte on an equal fwtirrg. It ia our conviction that the eituation in
(The Pre8 ident)
the Middle t3mt require8 leader6 with great courage and vision, it require8 leader8
capable of looking beyond the imediate political advantagae in order to addreae
the long-term interests of the Middle East and ita people. Only if and when this
i8 done, can Xerael hoge to live in peaceful, secure and internatitrna11~ r,mognieed
borders.
The raid on TunLia, which resulted in the brutal murder of Abu Jihad, a
pre&er of the PrD Executive Committee and other@, has indeed shodted the
inter national ommun ity . It cannot be seen a8 just an ieolated act of lawleesnese
by M unknown gang of bandits: rather, it must be viewed a8 a aarefullY
premditated aoeeaaination with intent to liquidttte the Pu) leadership. This was
indeed the ease on 1 Octcber 1985, when Ierael cmmitted a similar aot of
aggremion against mnieia, which was strongly condemned by the Ccuncil in its
resolution 573 (1985). Iefael, therefore, hao a “track reaortP in military
operations against the leaderehip of the PLO.
It mu6t be clear from etatemente originating tram Israel that, rather than
dkxganising the Pfl), the assassination of Abu Jihad hae merely rervenl to
aggravate the eituation in the Middle East. It has inspired the oppreeeed People
Of Palestine to fight to victory, and it has provided a rallying pint which will
serve to strengthen their bonds of unity6 a goal for which the late Abu Jihad
worked eo diligently during his lifetime. Iecael will never overcome the just
struggle of the Palestinian people by assaseinating itt3 authentic leaders. Indeed,
a8 the Israeli paper Radaehot, in its editorial opinion, Pointedly wondered:
‘If Pu) leaders are targets for bumping off, with uhan, actually, do we intend
In conclusion, my delegation calls on the Security Council, which ie charged
with the pritnery responsibility of maintaining international peace and security, to
(The President)
But &aisively by ‘adopting the draft ruolution before it so that this aat Of
WWe8eLon will not ba t8psabd in the Luturo by Iereel, or indaed by any otiwt
UountrY.
1 nQlp resunm ly fun&ions as President ot the security Counoil.
With the aonowrence of wmber8 of the Council, I shall nap 8uSpond the
meLine for 30 rinutea in or&r that ambin points ray be cleated up.
The rmetinq was euapendsd at 12 noon awl remlad at 1.25 p.m.
The PRBIDoBsr; It ie ny unQr8tending that ‘the Counail is ready to
prowad to the vote on the draft resolution before it. tlntenr 1 hear any
objection, I shall put it to the vote.
ThaPe being no abjection, it is so dsOi&d-
Does any member rich to make a statement bofoce the voting?
wr. omw (united states 0e Amrica)t The mited statea bplores the use
0e violanw from datevet quarter. In pntticular , we oondea acts 00 politbl
a8daesinaticn, as Aaerican Governsant epokeemm stated cleuly in Washington last
week.
Bmisia is a aloee and valued friend ot the United States. Bbt a sewn8 time
in le#a than three year6 it hae 8Uftered a violation ot ite territorial integrity
and ita satereignty. The United Rater ha8 repeawdly m@ba6irod LU mapport for
Tmiaia% territorial integrity) we reumin eaitheul to that pledge. Our
relationship with Tunisia is fknly tooted in a aomm Qdication co the dignity of
man and to the puceuit of polltical mderation and tolaatwe. T~~ieia enjcw a
eolid reputation as a peaceful wuntry. Owef the wurw oC the year6 it has
pursued its national goals in a ma~ec consistent with its wamitwnt to peaosful
rsso1ution of its problems. The psrgetration 00 political assassination un
Tmisian soil stands in stark contrast m ~unisia’e long-standing tradition of
non-violmoe.
Despite the strong vi-6 the United States holds on political assassination,
and despite out strong support for Tunisia’s national sovereignty and territorial
d----*L.. LL- .-14.-a “L-L-r Lu cG”8&A c* UIrmyA .CI, b1.e “II.c*I” “LOL5e ..-. -W.-w *-C-a- !e thunto M ,hq &aft - 1-e-s.. e.- .--
resolution todey because it dieproportionetely places all blase for this latest
round in the ricing spiral of violent in the Middle Poet on one event only vhila
failing to mention other actions that pteoeded it. ft also includes language which
is suggestive of Chapter VII sanctions.
(Mr. Okun, United States)
Ae we deliberate here today we must not lose sight of the broader goals we all
share. All involved must renew their efforta Co reach a amprehensive settlement
in the Middle East which will realise the legitimate rights of the Palestinian
people in a manner that protects Israel’s security. Palestinians and Israelis both
deserve a future of eecurity, dignity and prosperity. There must be mtual respect
for each other’s rights and a climate where fear and recrimination can be replaced
by security and trust. We believe now is the tisle to act.
The PRESIDENFfr The Council will ncy vote on the draft resolution before
it contained in cbcument S/19819.
A vota was taken by shav of handa.
In favourt Algeria, Argentina, Brazil, China, France, @rmeny, Federal
Republic of, Italy, Japan, Nepel, Senegal, Union of Soviet
Socialist Republics, United Kingdom of Great Britein and Northern
Ireland, Yugoslavia, Zahia
None Against :
Abstaining: Unitid States of America
The PREsIDEapt The result of the voting is as follcws: 14 votes in
favour,ncneagainstandlabstention. The draft resolution has been adopted as
resolution 611 (1998).
I &all new call on any member of the Council that wiehea to make a statement
follcwing the voting.
Sir Criopin TICXELL (United ikngdom): My delegation has just voted in
favour of the resolution. we did so in view of my Government’s consistent
condemnation of terrorism in all its form6, including such acts of political murder
as that of Mr. Khal il al-Waz ir .
(Sir: Criepin Tickell, United Ring&m)
Aa the sponsor8 of the draft and othere well know, we would have preferred
aertain dmngee tp the text. In particular, we would have wished it to leave more
open the implication of reeponaihility for the murder , einoe, a8 I said here on
21 @ril, we da not knaw with certiinty who was tesgonaible. we aleo regret that
Security Council resolution 573 (1985) was incorrectly quoted. Further, we find
that operative mragraph 3 ha6 little maning when aken with the rest of the
resolutifm, whiah doea not contain epecific provisions fez implementation. Our
mderetanding of ogetcrtive pmagraph 2 L that it can only refer to maewee that
we appropriate and lawful and in accordance with the prwiaione of the Charter of
tie thiwa abtione.
In spite of our Qubte m theme points, my delegation voted in favour of the
be* to mmke ulear our datetminatian to join the Comail in vigororre candemation
02 the murder, and to help bring horn lo those reaponeible the grave coneequencee
of their aat.
The PRPBPRm I call an the representative of the Palestine Liberation
Otgaizatictn , who hae aaked to speak.
Mr. AL-I(lW?A (Paleetine Liberation Organisation (AC)) ) (interpretetion
frm ArabicIt On behalf of the delegation of the Palestine Liberation
Orqanioation, I wish to thank all thoee who expreeeed their position of principle
by orndeming the criminal aeeaeeination of Abu Jihad. I should alao like to
express our gratibrde to all those who extended eympathy ta the family of the
martyr, the Palestine Liberation Organisation and the Paleetinian people. we have
ttmsmitted those sentiments to the bereaved family and leadrship of the pm. ,
There ie no doubt that the international conaenaue regarding the item before
the Cooncil has contributed in a concrete fashion tn allwiating WI a large extent
the suffering sustained a8 a result of this lose. But I should like to emphaa ize
. . (Mr. Al-Kichua, Paleetine tiberqrtion orsanisatf~)
here that our Palestinian people end its sole, legitidpate repreeentative~ the
Palestine Liberation Organisation, will be able to weroom this lose end put it
behind it.
I take this occaeion tm place on reoPrd our appreciation to all metier6 that
voted in favour of the draft resolution, eepecially to the norraliwed counUiee
that aponeored it and to express -cur satisfaction chat the United Stats8 did not
exercise it23 paaer of veto. In this regard, I express the hope that paeitive
Positlone will be taken to serve the just ceuse of peace in the Middle Bset.
In cOncluaion, I once again expreee our deep gratitude to Tunietir its
Gwernwnt and people, and aleo strees bD all metiers of the Council that our
people will continue ita struggle to attain ite inalienable naticnal rights.
The PRaSIDmr I call nw QI the Minieter for Boreign Affair6 of
Tmieia, P&r. Blahmu4 Hwtiri, who has asked to apeak.
Hr. MESTIR (mnieia) (interpretation froID Pren&)s I am particularly
abliged to the w&ere of the Council for their paeitive reeponee to TuriSk’e
appeal. %a hope that the text which has juet been aQpted, even though it &me not
fully meet our expectitione, will nevertheless have the Cleterrent ef feet we hoped
to we.
We ace most grateful also to the eponeore of the draft reeolution, who, in a
spirit of fraternity and solidarity, took upon theppaelves the teak of negotiating
this text and finding solutions aazeptable to the members of the Council. We are
particularly grateful to thoee of them who had to overmum their convictions in
presenting a draft resolution which was not fully satisfactory to them. We can
(Mr. Mestiri, l%nieia)
aaaure them that we too had to make an effort - one which did not come easily to
US - to satisfy ourselvea with this decision which, when all ie said and done,
basically responds to the concerns of our people.
Finally, the aggression has been denounced and condemned and the aggressor
named. Our sincae thanks go to all those delegations which have expressed to US
their solidarity, sympathy and support on behalf of their respective countr lea. I
should have liked to name them all, because they were all generous in their words
to my country, my people and President. Our gratl tude also goes to those who,
notwithstanding the pressures brought to bear on them - eometlmas in an inelegant
fashion - nevertheless lived up to the responsibilities incusbent upon them under
the Charter.
We also unders’tand those who, unable to vote in favour of the draft
resolution, abstained, thus enabling the international community to denounce and
conderrn this aot of aggression and, hence, the aggressor.
We know beyond all doubt who the aggressor was. Almost all speakers
identified the aggressor; it is clear that even those who expressed doubts know
per feotly well who the aggressor was. We are therefore convinoed that in the light
of rlew elements the task of the Secretary-General to place the responsibility for
this act, a task set out in paragraph 4 of the resolution, will not be an unduly
dif fioult one. This will enable the Security Council, which remains seized Of the
matter, to take measures under the Charter with respect to the aggressor as
confessions and discoveries continue to emerge.
For our part, we ahall transmit to the Secretariat a file wnteining technical
information about eucb matters as the logistical support provided during the
operation by an Israeli aircraft flying in air mce near Tunisian territory. The
presence of that aircraft has been oonf irmed also in a communiqu& issued by the
Italian air-traffic controllers’ union, the text of which is available.
The Charge d*Affairs ad interim of the Permanent Mission of Malta has j-t
Provided us with a letter from his Government confirming that the aircraft bearing
the number 4X977 and Israeli insignia - the aircraft I mentioned in my introductory
statement - overflew the region. The letter contains precise data concerning its
movements, which coincide in terms of time and space with the aggreseion. This
letter too will be transmitted to the Secretariat.
Our file also contains information from the Lebanese authorities on the false
ljdSJPOct8 and aliases used and on the rental of the vehicles employed by the
terrorists.
(MC. Mestiri, Tunisia)
We hope that other States, especially rhose in the Mediterranean region, will
join Malta in m-operating in this with the Secretary-General, to whom we pay a
tribute; from the outset he has viewed the problem in its true context.
Communications from him, without straying from the m0st complete objectivity, have
stated clearly what the international community knows full .well.
In Conclusion, Mr. President, I wish to assure you of our appreciation and
admiration for the patience and wisdom with which you guided this debate. I could
not paas in silence over the position taken by Zambia, a friendly brother nation of
Africa which, in keeping with a long tradition of tireless struggle for just
causes, played a decisive role in the conclusions reached in this &bate.
The PSeSIDPNTt I thank the Minister for Foreign Affairs of Tunisia for
the kind words he addressed to me and to my country.
There ace no further speakers for this meeting. The Security Council has thus
concluded the present stage of its consideration of the item on its agenda.
The meeting rose at 1.45 p.m. -
Vote:
611 (1998)
Consensus
▶ Cite this page
UN Project. “S/PV.2810.” UN Project, https://un-project.org/meeting/S-PV-2810/. Accessed .